CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-

SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Summary of Evaluation of Technical Proposals

Sr. Maximum Technical Scores Financial Score
Name of Firm Total
No. points
Obtained Points Weighted Points Obtained Points Weighted Points
1 Cameos Consultant 100.000 92.025 73.620 100.000 20.000 93.620

Technical (Weighted Points = Obtained Points x Weightage / 100)

Financial (Weighted Points = Obtained Points x Weightage / 100)

1/14
The Building Consultant

Sr. Duration Rate

No. Description of Numb Man-Months Per-Months Amount
Staff er
1.        Team Leader/Architect 1 12 300,000.00 3,600,000.00
2.        Junior Architect 1 24 225,000.00 5,400,000.00
3.        Structure Engineer 1 12 225,000.00 2,700,000.00
4.        Hydrology/Drainage 1 8 225,000.00 1,800,000.00
Engineer
5.        Environment Engineer 1 6 225,000.00 1,350,000.00
6.        Geotechnical Engineer 1 2 225,000.00 450,000.00
7.        GIS Specialist 1 3 150,000.00 450,000.00
8.        Quantity Surveyor 1 12 100,000.00 1,200,000.00
9.        Junior Structure Engineer 1 8 75,000.00 600,000.00
10.    Contract specialist 1 6 100,000.00 600,000.00
11.    CAD Operator 6 36 50,000.00 1,800,000.00
12.    Computer Operator 4 24 50,000.00 1,200,000.00
13.    Office Boy 1 6 25,000.00 150,000.00
159 21,300,000.00

Sr. Duration Rate

No. Description of Numb Man-Months Per-Months Amount
Staff er
1.        Resident Engineer/Architect 1 24 375,000.00 9,000,000.00
2.        Site Supervising Engineer 1 24 150,000.00 3,600,000.00
3.        Material Engineer 1 12 100,000.00 1,200,000.00
4.        Quantity Surveyor 1 12 100,000.00 1,200,000.00
5.        Surveyor 1 6 60,000.00 360,000.00
78 15,360,000.00
Sr.No. Nomenclature Unit Quantity Unit Price Total Amount

1 Rent for Office Accommodation Per month 12 75000 900000

2 Office Utilities Costs Per month 12 15000 180000

3 Cost / rental of Furniture / Furnishings Per month 12 15000 180000

4 Cost L.S 1,000,000.00
(rentals)
i). of Computers and accessories
Office/Oth
ii). Photo copy machines
er
iii). Communication equipment
Equipment
iv). Drafting / Engineering equipment

v). Surveying instruments (rentals)

vi). Transport Vehicles (Rentals)
vii). Site visits and Meetings in
Islamabad
viii). during currency of Design and co-
ordination in supervision
ix). Traffic count

5 Communication expenses Per month 12 15000 180000

6 Rented Vehicle with Fuel Per month 12 15000 180000

7 Drafting/Reproduction of Reports L.S 12 15000 180000

8 Office/Drafting Supplies L.S 12 15000 180000

Non-Technical/Support Staff as needed for key

9 professional staff along with number, charge L.S 12 15000 180000
Others notrate and category
covered above tofor reviewwith TOR
comply
10 requirement (In accordance with your L.S 12 15000 180000
Comments on TOR).
Limited Soil Investigation along project
11 P.S. Report 500,000.00
alignment with report.
Total 3,840,000.00

Sr. No. Description Amount (Rs.)

1 Detailed Design of Construction cost. 25,140,000.00
5,028,000.00
Detailed Supervision of Construction
2 15,360,000.00
cost.
Grand Total: 40,500,000.00 101,250.00
Cameos Engineering Consultant

Sr. Duration Rate

No. Description of Number Man-Months Per-Months Amount
Staff
1.        Team Leader 1 12 500,000.00 6,000,000.00
2.        Junior Architect 1 24 350,000.00 8,400,000.00
3.        Structure Engineer 1 12 350,000.00 4,200,000.00
4.        Hydrology/Drainage 1 8 350,000.00 2,800,000.00
Engineer
5.        Environment Engineer 1 6 350,000.00 2,100,000.00
6.        Geotechnical Engineer 1 2 350,000.00 700,000.00
7.        GIS Specialist 1 3 200,000.00 600,000.00
8.        Quantity Surveyor 1 12 85,000.00 1,020,000.00
9.        Junior Structure Engineer 1 8 100,000.00 800,000.00
10.    Contract specialist 1 6 100,000.00 600,000.00
11.    CAD Operator 6 36 75,000.00 2,700,000.00
12.    Computer Operator 4 24 35,000.00 840,000.00
13.    Office Boy 1 6 20,000.00 120,000.00
159 30,880,000.00

Sr. Duration Rate

No. Description of Number Man-Months Per-Months Amount
Staff
1.        Resident Engineer 1 24 300,000.00 7,200,000.00
2.        Site Supervising Engineer 1 24 75,000.00 1,800,000.00
3.        Material Engineer 1 12 100,000.00 1,200,000.00
4.        Quantity Surveyor 1 12 95,000.00 1,140,000.00
5.        Surveyor 1 6 75,000.00 450,000.00
78 11,790,000.00
Sr.No. Nomenclature Unit Quantity Unit Price Total Amount

1 Rent for Office Accommodation Per month 6 0 0

2 Office Utilities Costs Per month 6 25000 150000

3 Cost / rental of Furniture / Furnishings Per month 6 25000 150000

4 Cost L.S 500,000.00
(rentals)
i). of Computers and accessories
Office/Oth
ii). Photo copy machines
er
iii). Communication equipment
Equipment
iv). Drafting / Engineering equipment

v). Surveying instruments (rentals)

vi). Transport Vehicles (Rentals)
vii). Site visits and Meetings in
Islamabad
viii). during currency of Design and co-
ordination in supervision
ix). Traffic count

5 Communication expenses Per month 6 25000 150000

6 Rented Vehicle with Fuel Per month 6 25000 150000

7 Drafting/Reproduction of Reports L.S 500,000.00

8 Office/Drafting Supplies L.S 200,000.00

Non-Technical/Support Staff as needed for key

9 professional staff along with number, charge L.S 500,000.00
Others notrate and category
covered above tofor reviewwith TOR
comply
10 requirement (In accordance with your L.S 200,000.00
Comments on TOR).
Limited Soil Investigation along project
11 P.S. Report 1,000,000.00
alignment with report.
Total 3,500,000.00

Sr. No. Description Amount (Rs.)

1 Detailed Design of Construction cost. 34,380,000.00

2 Detailed Supervision of Construction cost. 11,790,000.00

Grand Total: 46,170,000.00
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF
CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-
SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Summary of Financial Evaluation

Evaluation Criteria Lowest Bid Cameos Consultant

Specific experience
2,921,486.00 2,921,486.00 100.000
Score 100.000

Weightage 20.000 20.000

Lp/P x 100
Where
Lp is the lowest price from among all the proposals received.
P is the price of proposal whose price score is to be computed.

Weighted Points = Obtained Points x Weightage / 50

6/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-SANGSILA,
DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

FINANCIAL OPENING SHEET

Obtained Weightage
Name of Firm/ Consultants Remarks Name Designation Contact Number Signature
Points Points

1 Cameos Consultant 92.025 73.62 Pass

7/14
CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-SANGSILA, DISTRICT
DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Eligibility Criteria
Rakhshan Engineering Global Engineering System
S# Requirements Cameos Consultant NESPAK Consultant DMC
Consultant Peshawar

Year Response Year Response Year Response Year Response Year Response
1 Valid Registration Certificate of
Pakistan Engineering Council
a PEC % 715 Pass 1 Pass 1757 Pass 1864 Pass 884 Pass
b Valid Date 2021 Pass 2020 Pass 2020 Pass 2020 Pass 2019 Pass
2 Specialization Code i.e1203 Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass
3 Specialization Code i.e1205 Yes Pass Yes Pass No Fail No Fail Yes Pass
4 Specialization Code i.e 1226 Yes Pass Yes Pass no Fail No Fail Yes Pass
5 Affidavit in original Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass
Facilities available with the
Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass
6 Consultant Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Man-months of staff and Project
Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass
7 Duration as per TOR Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
8 NTN Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass Yes Pass
9 BRA Yes Pass Yes Pass No Fail No Fail No Fail

8/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-
SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Summary of Evaluation of Technical Proposals

Evaluation Criteria Maximum points Cameos Consultant NESPAK Consultant
Specific experience
1
a) General Experience (10)
Project of Rs 300 million completed in last 10 Years in Similar Geographical Region 10 10.000 10.000
Each Project Have 1 Marks (maximum 10 Projects)

2
b) Specific Experience of the Firm Balochistan (10)
Similar Nature Project of Rs 300 million completed in last 10 Years in Similar 10 10.000 10.000
Geographical Region
Each project Have 2 Marks (maximum 05 projects)

Sub Total 20.000 20.000 20.000

Approach and Methodology
2- A Appreciation of the Project
1 i. Evidence of Site Visit with Photographs (10 ) 10 10.000 0.000
2 ii. Clarity of Appreciation (01) 1 0.800 0.800
3 iii. Comprehensiveness of appreciation (01) 1 0.700 0.800
4 2-B Problem Statement/ Understanding Of Objectives
5 i. Identification of Problems / Objectives. (02) 2 1.400 1.600
6 ii. Components of Proposed Service (02) 2 1.200 1.600
4 2-C Methodology
5 i. Proposed Solutions for this Project (02) 2 1.400 1.600
6 i. Quality of Methodology (2) 2 1.400 1.600
ii. Comprehensiveness of appreciation. (02) 2 1.500 1.600
iii. Conciseness, clarity and completeness proposal. (02) 2 1.400 1.700
2-D Suggested changes for improvement TOR (02) 2 1.200 1.700
2-E Innovativeness/Comments on TOR (2) 2 1.600 1.700
2-F Work Program (2) 2 1.800 1.700
Sub Total 30.000 24.400 16.400
Qualification & Competence of Key Staff National Experts
a)        Team Leader / Senior Structure Engineer 10 9.700 9.550
b)        Highway Engineer 10 9.200 9.550
c)        Structure Engineer 10 9.700 9.700
d)        pavement Design Engineer 5 4.775 2.750
e)        Environment Engineer 5 4.850 4.850
f)         Geo Technical Engineer 5 4.775 4.850
g)        Survey Engineer 3 2.865 0.000
h)        Quantity Surveyor 2 1.760 1.940

Sub Total 50.000 47.625 43.190

9/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-
SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Summary of Evaluation of Technical Proposals

Evaluation Criteria Maximum points Cameos Consultant NESPAK Consultant
Specific experience

Total 100.000 92.025 79.590

10/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-SANGSILA,
DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Summary of Specific Experience

Evaluation Criteria Socre Cameos Consultant NESPAK Consultant
No of Score for No of Score for
General experience Project Each Marks Obtained Project Each Marks Obtained
a) General Experience (10)
Project of Rs 300 million completed in last 10 Years in Similar
Geographical Region
Each Project Have 1 Marks (maximum 10 Projects)
Design 10.000
10.000 1.000 10.000 10.000 1.000 10.000
Sub Total 10.000 10.000
Specific experience
b) Specific Experience of the Firm Balochistan (10)
Similar Nature Project of Rs 300 million completed in last 10 Years in
Similar Geographical Region
Each project Have 2 Marks (maximum 05 projects)
Design
10.000 5.000 2.000 10.000 5.000 2.000 10.000
Sub Total 10.000 10.000

Total 20.000 20.000 20.000

11/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA
BUGTI-SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM)

Summary of Technical Approach/ Methodology Work Plan, Organization staffing proposal

presentation

Evaluation Criteria Socre Cameos Consultant NESPAK Consultant

Marks in Marks in
Specific experience Percentage Marks Obtained Percentage Marks Obtained
2- A Appreciation of the Project
i. Evidence of Site Visit with Photographs (10 ) 10 100% 10.000 0% 0.000
ii. Clarity of Appreciation (01) 1 80% 0.800 80% 0.800
iii. Comprehensiveness of appreciation (01) 1 70% 0.700 80% 0.800
2-B Problem Statement/ Understanding Of Objectives 0.000
i. Identification of Problems / Objectives. (02) 2 70% 1.400 80% 1.600
ii. Components of Proposed Service (02) 2 60% 1.200 80% 1.600
2-C Methodology 0.000
i. Proposed Solutions for this Project (02) 2 70% 1.400 80% 1.600
i. Quality of Methodology (2) 2 70% 1.400 80% 1.600
ii. Comprehensiveness of appreciation. (02) 2 75% 1.500 80% 1.600
iii. Conciseness, clarity and completeness proposal.
(02) 2 70% 1.400 85% 1.700
2-D Suggested changes for improvement TOR (02) 2 60% 1.200 85% 1.700
2-E Innovativeness/Comments on TOR (2) 2 80% 1.600 85% 1.700
2-F Work Program (2) 2 90% 1.800 85% 1.700

Total 30.000 24.400 16.400

12/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM) (CAMEOS
Consultant)

POSITION / AREA OF OVERALL

Academic and General Qualification 30 % Project related Experience in Weight
EXPERTISE Name marks Status with the Firm 10% RATING (Sum of
of the Marks 60% Balochistan
Weighted Ratings)
(Show all experts Percentage Weighted Number of Percentage Weighted
Weightage Points Marks (A+B+C)
to be evaluated) Rating Rating (A) Project Rating Rating (C)
a)        Team Leader Asadullah Jan 10 3 90% 2.7 10 0.60 6 100% 1.00 9.70
b)        Highway Design Engineer Waseem Haider 10 3 90% 2.7 10 0.60 6 50% 0.50 9.20
c)        Structure Engineer kamran Babar 10 3 90% 2.7 10 0.60 6 100% 1.00 9.70
d)        Pavement Design Engineer Shamim Ahmed 5 1.5 85% 1.275 10 0.30 3 100% 0.50 4.78
e)        Environment Engineer Ali Ahmed Durrani 5 1.5 90% 1.35 10 0.30 3 100% 0.50 4.85
f)         Geo Technical Engineer Ali Gull Marri 5 1.5 85% 1.275 10 0.30 3 100% 0.50 4.78
g)        Survey Engineer Irfan Ali 3 0.9 85% 0.765 10 0.18 1.8 100% 0.30 2.87
h)        Quantity Surveyor Muhammad Saeed Akhat 2 0.6 60% 0.36 10 0.12 1.2 100% 0.20 1.76

Ph.D. 100% M.Sc - 90% B.Sc - 85% Diploma - 60%

Full time - 100% Part time with previous association - 50% Part time only for this assignment - 0%
Experience

·          Marking Criteria for Team Leader, Highway Engineer will project base, each project with same firm will score 10% per project in the same geographical area upto maximum 10 projects.

Marking Criteria for Quantity Engineer and Quantity surveyor will be project base, each project with same firm will score 10 per project in the same geographical area upto maximum 10 projects

13/14
 CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTION OF BLACK TOP ROAD DERA BUGTI-SANGSILA, DISTRICT DERA BUGTI LENGTH 65 KM) (NESPAK
Consultant)

POSITION / AREA OF OVERALL

Academic and General Qualification 30 % Project related Experience in Weight
EXPERTISE Name marks Status with the Firm 10% RATING (Sum of
of the Marks 60% Balochistan
Weighted Ratings)
(Show all experts Percentage Weighted Number of Percentage Weighted
Weightage Points Marks (A+B+C)
to be evaluated) Rating Rating (A) Project Rating Rating (C)
a)        Team Leader Azhar Masood 10 3 85% 2.55 10 0.60 6 100% 1.00 9.55
b)        Highway Design Engineer Basit Ejaz 10 3 85% 2.55 10 0.60 6 100% 1.00 9.55
c)        Structure Engineer Shoukat Qadeer 10 3 90% 2.7 10 0.60 6 100% 1.00 9.70
d)        Pavement Design Engineer Nadeem Ahmed 5 1.5 90% 1.35 3 0.30 0.9 100% 0.50 2.75
e)        Environment Engineer Kashif Bashir 5 1.5 90% 1.35 10 0.30 3 100% 0.50 4.85
f)         Geo Technical Engineer Sohail Kabria 5 1.5 90% 1.35 10 0.30 3 100% 0.50 4.85
g)        Survey Engineer 3 0 85% 0 0 0.18 0 0% 0.00 0.00
h)        Quantity Surveyor Muhammad Jawad Ghani 2 0.6 90% 0.54 10 0.12 1.2 100% 0.20 1.94

Ph.D. 100% M.Sc - 90% B.Sc - 85% Diploma - 60%

Full time - 100% Part time with previous association - 50% Part time only for this assignment - 0%
Experience

·          Marking Criteria for Team Leader, Highway Engineer will project base, each project with same firm will score 10% per project in the same geographical area upto maximum 10 projects.

Marking Criteria for Quantity Engineer and Quantity surveyor will be project base, each project with same firm will score 10 per project in the same geographical area upto maximum 10 projects

14/14