PRESENTATION GRADING FORM

(ME 158P-2)

Date: October 01, 2022

Evaluated By: Engr. Rofuat L. Lu

(Name of Panelist)

Proposal Defense
Final Defense
OVERALL GROUP GRADE
Group #: 5

TITLE: Design of CO2 Recovery System for Beer Manufacturing Plant with a Capacity of 1M packaged
Beer annually

Maintenance of Group

Knowledge of Subject

Engineering Standards
Personal Appearance

Time Management
Relevance to the
Voice Projection

Value & Quality

Overall Impact
Seat Numbers /

Compliance to
Presentation

Presentation

Overall Grade
Clarity of

Materials

Interest
Names

Matter
Topic

(According to the
SN’s & indicate the
Leader in the name)
√ X √ X √ X √ X √ X √ X √ X √ X √ X √ X √ X
SN #38 – MANAOIS, EDEL
QUEEN MONIQUE B.
(Leader)
-
-
SN #34 – ESTRADA,
ROUBENJ S.
-
-
SN #33 – EBCAS, ALFRED
CHRISTIAN C.
-
-
SN #35 – GARCERA, MIGUEL
ENRIQUE NEO L.
-
-
SN #36 – LAYSA, CHRISTIAN
JOHN A.

SN #37 – LLOVIT, KENT

IVAN G.

SN #39 – NG, CURT PATRICK

C.
-
-

i
Overall Grades: Legends: √ - GOOD X – NOT GOOD
EXCEL-LENT (91-100) - x
VERY GOOD (81-90) - xx
GOOD (71-80) - xxx
FAIR (60-70) - xxxx
POOR (59 & below) - xxxxx

TOPICS TO BE ASSIGNED (Topics & Subtopics should be subdivided equally for the no. of members in the
group)

TOPIC 1 –INTRODUCTION
SUBTOPIC:
 Statement of the design problem
 Objective of the design
 Review of related literature
 Scope and limitation
TOPIC 2 – Operating Parameters and Specifications
SUBTOPIC:
 Plant capacity
 Process flow diagram of beer manufacturing plant
 Process flow diagram of CO2 recovery system
TOPIC 3 – Equipment calculations
SUBTOPIC:
 CO2 recovery system capacity calculation
TOPIC 4 - Pipe sizing
SUBTOPIC:
 Capacity and Dimensions for Beer Manufacturing Equipment
 Capacity and Dimensions for CO2 Recovery System
TOPIC 5 - System Layout
SUBTOPIC:
TOPIC 6 – Plan site and layout
SUBTOPIC:
 Plant Layout
 Site determination
 Site Survey
 Application for construction
TOPIC 7 - Economics
SUBTOPIC:
 Budget Estimate of Investment Cost
 Operating Cost
 Manufacturing cost
 Viability/economic
TOPIC 8 - Standards
SUBTOPIC:
 OSHA standards and codes
 ANSI standards and codes
 NFPA standards and codes
TOPIC 9 - Conclusion
SUBTOPIC:
 Recommendation

ii
iii