Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reading Strategies For All Content Areas
Reading Strategies For All Content Areas
TABLE of CONTENTS
Reading is ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 2
Research Helps Shift the Concept of Reading ………………………………........ 2
Changing the Face of Reading Comprehension Instruction ………………… 3
Prior Knowledge ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 3
Vygotsky’s Learning Theory ………………………………………………………………………. 4
Strategic Teachers …………………………………………………………………………………….. 4
Metacomprehension ……………………………………………………………………………………. 5
Teacher Decision-Making ………………………………………………………………………….. 5
Eight Questions to ask about Instructional Activities ………………………. 6
Teacher as Mediator ………………………………………………………………………………….. 7
Textbooks ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… 7
Contrasting Good and Poor Readers ………………………………………………………… 8
Cooperative Learning ………………………………………………………………………………….. 10
Reciprocal Teaching ……………………………………………………………………………………. 11
Effective Explicit Instruction …………………………………………………………………. 12
Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA)………………………………………….. 13
Guidelines for Asking Questions ……………………………………………………………… 14
Question/Answer/Relationship (QAR) …………………………………………………… 15
Instructional Activities That Lead Students to a Gradual Shift in
the Responsibility for Self-Directed Learning …………………………………….. 16
Frayer Model ……………………………………………………………………………………………….. 17
Modeling Reading: Think Alouds ………………………………………………………………. 18
Teaching Inference ……………………………………………………………………………………. 19
Ten Major Inference Types ……………………………………………………………………… 20
Summarizing …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 20
The Strategic Reader ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 22
The Twelve Systems of Strategic Actions used by Readers ……………. 23
Strategies Good Readers Use …………………………………………………………………... 23
Fix-Up Strategies ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 24
Informed Strategies for Learning (ISL) ………………………………………………. 25
Graphic Organizers …………………………………………………………………………………….. 26
Semantic or Chapter Mapping ………………………………………………………………….. 27
1
Reading is …
Analytic
Interactive
Constructive
Strategic
There has been a conceptual shift in the way many researchers and teachers
think about reading, which gives students a much more active role in the learning
and reading comprehension process.” This shift is reflected in changes from
packaged reading programs to experience with books and from concentration on
isolated skills to practical reading and writing activities.
2
Changing the Face of Reading Comprehension Instruction
Accept comprehension for what it is. (Recognize the shift in the
concept of reading)
Change the way we ask questions.
Change the attitude and practices of teaching vocabulary.
Change the way we teach comprehension.
Develop curriculum that treats comprehension and composition as
similar processes.
Change the teacher’s role in the classroom. *Pearson)
The most logical place for instruction in most reading and thinking strategies
is in social studies and science rather than in separate lessons about reading. The
reason is that the strategies are useful mainly when the student is grappling with
important but unfamiliar content. (Becoming a Nation of Readers)
Prior Knowledge
One of the most universal findings to emerge from recent research is the
marked degree in which a learner’s prior knowledge of a topic facilitates future
comprehension. This prior knowledge or pathway to understanding new ideas, when
related to content area assignments, is crucial. Content teachers must take steps
to determine students’ prior knowledge and background experience of a topic
before deciding the students can cope with a specific unit of study. (Readence,
Bean, & Baldwin)
Strategies
3
Vygotsky’s Learning Theory
Learning is response. When a person hears or reads something he’s never
heard before, it doesn’t imprint upon his brain the way print remains on paper.
People are not blank, absorbent tablets. Instead, a person responds by hunting
through his mind for knowledge and understanding he already has to see how he
can make the old meaning connect to the new.
At this point he will need a mediator who can answer questions like these:
“You mean it’s like …?” and, “Well, if it’s like that, does it mean that it works the
same way?” Of course, as no two people have identical temperaments, perceptions
and life experiences, the way one sees, hears, touches, smells, and tastes his world
will lead him to a unique point of view and interpretation of the world.
If the above is true, then what one reads gets taken into all levels of the
mind and is almost instantly processed according to what the reader believes and
knows. The text becomes the readers’, and what one person reads will not have the
same meaning for another person. If you begin to think this way, it becomes
difficult to assess rightness and wrongness to individual interpretations.
4
Metacomprehension
Metacomprehension instruction stems from Brown’s descriptors of
metacognition – 1) awareness of one’s own activities when reading, solving problems,
and studying, and 2) use of self-regulatory mechanisms by active learners.
Instruction in the classroom should make clear how a text is read (strategy),
why it is important to employ the strategy, and when the strategy would be used.
Strategic teachers employ the following activities:
Prereading
Guided Reading
Post Reading
Coaching and feedback
Teacher Decision-Making
Components Teacher
-Process (how-to-read-this-kind-of-text-knowledge
5
Monitor Constructs activities that make vivid the text/reading
interaction
Provides feedback
-Move on!
-Reteach?
-More practice?
-Forget it!
6
Teacher as Mediator
Current research on effective teaching redefines the role of the teacher
during instruction. Based on Vygotsky’s theory, teachers are described as
“mediator,” or helpers, who take a much more active and interactive role in
instruction
What this means to students’ learning strategies is that what they initially
can accomplish only with assistance they are eventually able to do by themselves
(Gavelek). Through this support or “scaffolding” system, the teacher gradually
releases the responsibility of learning to the students, enabling them to become
independent learners.
Textbooks
Text Considerateness
7
Whether the text is appropriate for the students and the purpose
Whether the information is accurate and consistent
Readability
The ease with which a person can read printed materials, called readability, is
related to many factors. These factors are not measured by conventional
readability formulas that are based on length of sentences and the number of long
or multisyllable words.
Readability includes:
Before Reading
8
Focus their complete attention on reading.
During Reading
After Reading
Poor Readers
Before Reading
During Reading
After Reading
A dramatic improvement for poor readers results when they are taught to apply
intervention strategies to content text. (Orange County Public Schools)
9
Cooperative Learning
Group work can increase students’ achievement and encourage positive
feelings about learning and success. It improves student motivation,
participation/involvement, and critical thinking skills (Alvermann, Moore, & Conley).
Cooperative learning groups mix students of low, average, and high achievement
levels in groups of 4 or 5 to work on a common academic task. Through positive
social interaction, shared responsibility for each other’s learning, peer tutoring,
and coaching, students become active learners.
Teacher Responsibilities
Form groups with low, average, and high achievers in each group.
Give clear directions about the assignment or task.
Set and call attention to time limits.
Teach group skills; establish guidelines.
Interact with groups to explain, clarify, motivate, or keep on task.
Foster a pleasant and friendly work atmosphere. (Johnson, Johnson,
Holubec, & Roy)
Student Responsibilities
10
Reciprocal Teaching
This strategy is conducted in cooperative groups where students work together
with informational texts in order to learn the material better. There are five
strategies used in this method.
1. Reading. The assigned text is first broken down into short sections for
the students to read. Typically, the leader of the group reads the section
aloud to the group.
5. Predicting. The students now make predictions about what the next
section may contain.
6. Continue using steps 1–5 until assigned text or chapter has been
completed. (Palinscar & Brown)
Initially the teacher models each of the segments, gradually turning over the
reins to the students while providing feedback and encouragement. The teacher
dialogue is the key to the successful implementation of the Reciprocal Teaching
Strategy. (Palincsar)
11
1. Demonstration
Demonstrating is the process of teaching through examples, experiments or
modeling. Demonstrations help to raise student interest and reinforce
memory retention because they provide connections between facts and real-
world applications of those facts.
2. Guided Practice
Guided practice is showing and releasing the students to do the task or
standard at hand. An important part of this step is “checking for
understanding”.
3. Collaboration
Collaboration allows students to actively participate in the learning process
by talking with each other and listening to other points of view. Collaboration
establishes a personal connection between students and the topic of study
and it helps students think in a less personally biased way. Group projects
and discussions are examples of this teaching method. Teachers may employ
collaboration to assess student's abilities to work as a team, leadership
skills, or presentation abilities.
4. Independent Practice
Independent Practice is the part of the lesson cycle where students are
given the opportunity to practice the concept presented during the lesson
and is a time for students to work towards mastery of the knowledge/skills
presented in the lesson before an assessment is given. It is usually an
activity that the students accomplish individually, with a partner, or in small
groups while the teacher monitors the work. Activities during this part of
the lesson cycle can take many forms but are always aligned with the
learning goal and continue to push students towards mastery of the content.
12
http://www.readingrockets.org/strategies/drta
Stauffer reports the DRTA is effective for science and social studies
lessons as it is for reading narratives. The teacher sets the climate for DRTA and
directs the process by breaking the material into appropriate parts, but it is the
students who take the dominant role.
Next, students read and confirm or reject predictions, then refine the
hypotheses as new information is gathered. In essence, Moore, Readence, &
Rickelman set forth a process where the reader:
Poses questions
Tests these questions on reading the text
Generates new questions as reading progresses
13
Guidelines for Asking Questions
Questioning can effectively guide and extend comprehension Teachers can
provide practice in critical thinking by asking carefully prepared questions on high
levels. At the same time they should avoid too many low level, single answer
questions. Providing questions before reading helps students focus on major ideas
and concepts.
*** Try waiting 3-5 seconds after asking a question, allowing students to process
the question and formulate a response. (Conley)
Question/Answer/Relationship (QAR)
14
http://www.readingrockets.org/strategies/question_answer_relationship
Explain to students that there are four types of questions they will
encounter. Define each type of question and give an example.
Procedure
15
(Raphael)
Modeling
Guiding
Observing
Correcting
16
Frayer Model
The Frayer Model is a vocabulary development tool. The model helps to
develop a better understanding of complex concepts by having students identify
not just what something is, but what something is not. The center of the diagram
shows the concept being defined, while the quadrants around the concept are used
for providing the details.
For example:
17
Modeling Reading: Think Alouds
To move the cloak of mystery surrounding the comprehension process teachers can
verbalize their own thoughts while reading orally. This detailed process of making
thinking public is called “think alouds.”
After several modeling experiences, students can work with partners to practice
“think alouds,” taking turns reading orally and sharing thoughts. Carefully
developed materials should be used initially (short with obvious problems). Finally,
encourage readers to practice “think aloud” strategies as they complete silent
reading assignments independently. (Davey)
18
Teaching Inference
Students need to be taught HOW to make inferences. They need to realize
that inferences are everywhere and that during the reading process an inference
can be (and often must be) modified.
1. TEACH. The teacher reads a passage and specifies the type of inference to
be made. The teacher models/demonstrates, talks, exemplifies after reading
the passage. The teacher identifies and list Word Clues in a “think aloud”
discussion explaining just what the Word Clues clarify to help make the
inference accurate.
2. PRACTICE. Students read a passage, individually or in groups. As they read
they are to scrutinize/analyze the text to identify Word Clues that provide
evidence to justify the inference category specified. List the students’
Word Clues on the board. Encourage full and rich discussions as they talk
about why each Word Clue made a contribution to the inference.
3. APPLY. Identify the types of inference being applied. The students see
(read) a passage, one line at a time, and jot down their inferences. After
each line is exposed students reject/revise their inferences. At the
conclusion students identify and list the Word Clues that allowed them to
make the inferences. List the Word Clues is important until students take
ownership for this step in the task of inferencing.
4. EXTEND. Move into students’ textbooks. Practice expository passages. Ask
questions such as: “What kind of inference category is needed?” What are
the key words or Word Clues that lead to it?” “What is the inference we can
make?” Extension takes students to the real world of their own textbooks.
5. ASSESS. Find out if students can do the inference procedure. “If Word
Clues + Experiences = Inference, what do you do if students don’t have the
prior knowledge or experiences?” The Mapping procedure helps call prior
knowledge to the surface, builds bridges necessary to make inferences.
(Johnson & Johnson)
19
Ten Major Inference Types
1. LOCATION: “While we roared down the tracks, we could feel the bounce
and sway.”
2. AGENT (Occupation or Pastime): “With clippers in one hand and scissors in
the other, Chris was ready to begin the task.”
3. TIME: “When the porch light burned out, the darkness was total.”
4. ACTION: “Megan dribbled down the court and then passed the ball to
Cheryl.”
5. INSTRUMENT (Tool or Device): “With a steady hand, she put the buzzing
device on the tooth.”
6. CAUSE-EFFECT: “In the morning, we noticed that the trees were uprooted
and homes were missing their rooftops.”
7. OBJECT: “The broad wings swept back in a “v,” and each held two powerful
engines.”
8. CATEGORY: “The Toyota and Nissan were in the garage, and the Mercedes
was out front.”
9. PROBLEM-SOLUTION: “The side of his face was swollen, and his tooth
ached.”
10. FEELING-ATTITUDE: “While I marched past in the junior high band, my
Dad cheered and his eyes filled with tears.” (Johnson & Johnson)
Summarizing
Taylor points out that summarizing is an effective postreading technique that
research shows fosters increased understanding and remembering. She explains
and describes hierarchical summarizing, cooperative summarizing and mapping.
Some other ways to help students learn summarizing include teaching them to
recognize good summaries and providing practice in writing summaries and in rating
their own or others’ summaries.
Stanfill and Santa help students with summarizing by having them state the thing
being summarized, telling what it begins with, what’s in the middle, and what it
ends with. They call this procedure the “One-Sentence Summary.”
20
Marshall describes another technique to help students develop summaries by
teaching these steps:
1. Create a map.
Brown, Compione, and Day have developed rules for condensing major ideas in a
text. Using the rules, students check their own learning during reading and their
preparedness for later tests.
Middle grade students should learn the first two rules; high school and college
students can be taught to use them all, the invention rule being the most difficult.
(Stewart & Tei)
21
The Strategic Reader
Understands how different reading goals and various kinds of texts require
particular strategies (analyzes)
Identifies tasks and sets purpose (discriminates between reading to study
for a test and reading for pleasure)
Chooses appropriate strategies for the reading situation (plans)
o Check for understanding
o Back up and reread
o Use prior knowledge to connect with text
o Make and adjust predictions; use text to confirm
o Infer and support with evidence
o Make a picture or mental image
o Monitor and fix-up
o Ask questions throughout the reading process
o Use text features (titles, headings, captions, graphic features)
o Summarize text; include sequence of main events
o Use main idea and supporting details to determine importance
o Determine and analyze author’s purpose and support with text
o Recognize literary elements (genre, plot, character, setting,
problem/resolution, theme)
o Recognize and explain cause-and-effect relationships
o Compare and contrast within and between text
o Skimming
o Paraphrasing
o Look for relationships
o Read ahead for clarification
Monitors comprehension, which involves
o Knowing that comprehension is occurring
o Knowing what is being comprehended
o Knowing how to repair/fix-up comprehension
Develops a positive attitude toward reading
(Adapted from Paris, Lipson, & Wixson; Cook, & The 2 Sisters,
TheDailyCafe.com)
22
The Twelve Systems of Strategic Actions used by Readers
1. Solving the words using a flexible range of strategies.
2. Self-monitoring their reading for accuracy and understanding and self-
correcting.
3. Searching for and using information.
4. Remembering information in summary form.
5. Sustaining fluent, phrased reading.
6. Adjusting reading in order to process a variety of text.
7. Making predictions.
8. Making connections.
9. Synthesizing new information.
10. Reading “between the lines” to infer what is not explicitly stated in the text.
11. Thinking analytically about a text to notice how it is constructed or how the
author has crafted language.
12. Thinking critically about a text. (Pinnell & Fountas)
23
Fix-Up Strategies
Reread – It is OK to reread text that you’ve already read. Maybe you
misread a word or left out a word that holds the meaning to the text.
Read ahead – You might want to continue reading for a couple of sentences if
you are confused. If the confusion does not clear after a couple of
sentences, try another strategy.
Figure out the unknown words – You may use context clues, identify roots
and affixes, or use a dictionary to determine the meaning. Do not just skip
the word altogether.
Make a mental image – Take time to make a movie in your head. As you read
the descriptions of characters or settings, paint a picture. This strategy
will help you visualize and comprehend better.
Define your purpose for reading – Ask yourself why you are reading. Reading
to learn or pass a test requires more concentration than reading for
enjoyment.
Ask questions – If you ask questions as you read, you will be more actively
engaged with the text. You will be looking for answers to your questions, and
will remember what you read.
Make predictions – As you read, think about what might happen next. You
will be making inferences and drawing conclusions about the characters and
plot.
Stop to think – Every so often as you read, you should stop and think about
what you have read. If you don’t remember anything you have read, why
continue? Pause and summarize in your head.
Make connections to what you already know – As you read you should be
thinking about how the information fits with what you know about yourself,
what you’ve read in other texts, and how things operate in the real world.
This will help you remember what you read.
24
Look at the pictures, illustrations, charts, and graphs – These are used by
the author to help you understand what you are reading. Pictures and
illustrations help you visualize what you are reading. Charts and graphs are
used to present the information in a more visual manner. By closely
examining these, you can deepen your level of understanding.
Read the author’s note – Sometimes the author will present background
information as an author’s note. By reading this section, you will be
preparing your brain to take in new information and connect it to what you
have already learned.
Ask for help – When you are not understanding what you are reading, and
you do not know which fix-up strategy to use, ask someone. You might ask a
friend or you might need help from a teacher or parent.
Stress to the students that they should not continue to read if they are not
able to summarize what they have read so far. If they do, they are just
wasting time “saying words” and they won’t be learning or understanding
anything from the text. (Esperanza Rising)
PROCEDURE
25
5. Encourage students’ discovery of what, how, and when strategies work by
helping generate analogies using metaphors.
6. Persuade students why the strategies promote reading and learning and why
they are worth the extra effort and time.
7. Model the effective use of the strategy with demonstration and some
examples.
8. Allow students to practice new strategies on relevant material.
9. Give corrective feedback and praise to students during discussions and after
practices so that they use the strategies properly.
10. Fade support so that students must take increasing initiative to recruit,
apply, and correct their own strategies.
11. Bridge the strategy to all parts of the curriculum, especially to content area
reading assignments. (Cook; Orange County Public schools)
ISL
Graphic Organizers
Moore, Readence & Richardson depict graphic organizers as providing a
verbal and visual structure for new vocabulary, identifying and classifying major
relationships of concepts and vocabulary in a unit of study. Visual graphic examples
are time lines, diagrams, cartoons, pictures, flow charts, structured overviews,
pyramid designs, outlines, feature analysis charts, semantic or chapter mapping
charts.
26
It also can be used effectively as a visual reference for full and rich discussion for
the whole class as concepts are studied and specific examples are related to them.
1. The teacher introduces a graphic organizer to the class. It can have several
different appearances. It can be shown as circles, squares, or ovals with
connecting lines.
3. Through class discussion, the teacher writes the main idea of the text in the
middle of the top circle.
4. The students share the supporting details of the main idea and place them in
circles that are connected to the main idea by lines.
27
New Directions in Reading Instruction by the International Reading Association
Gertrude Whipple Professional Development Project
28