Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Study On The Nature of Chinese Poetry
A Study On The Nature of Chinese Poetry
!V
'>K8>K
AFPPBOQ>QFLKPR?JFQQBAFKM>OQF>ICRICFIIJBKQLC
QEBOBNRFOBJBKQPCLOQEBABDOBBLC
W
IE
#L@QLOLC/EFILPLMEV
"EFKBPB
EV
>QQEB
4-(5$12(38.%6(2".-2(-
, #(2.-
PR
#>QBLCCFK>ILO>IBU>JFK>QFLK
3EBAFPPBOQ>QFLKFP>MMOLSBA?VQEBCLIILTFKDJBJ?BOPLCQEB%FK>I.O>I"LJJFQQBB
9E>KD'LKDJFKD/OLCBPPLO PF>K+>KDR>DBP>KA"RIQROBP
'RKQFKDQLK1>KF>/OLCBPPLO PF>K+>KDR>DBP>KA"RIQROBP
9ER6BFER> PPL@F>QB/OLCBPPLO PF>K+>KDR>DBP>KA"RIQROBP
+F8>CBF/OLCBPPLO+>KDR>DB2@FBK@BP
W
IE
EV
PR
^"LMVOFDEQ?V'>K8>K
II1FDEQP1BPBOSBA
F
W
IE
EV
PR
FF
(QFP>DBKRFKBMIB>PROBQLDFSBJVABBMQE>KHP>KADO>QFQRABQLJ>KVMBLMIBTFQELRQTELJ
QEFPAFPPBOQ>QFLKTLRIAKLQE>SB?BBKMLPPF?IB
%FOPQ >KA CLOBJLPQ ( TLRIA IFHB QL BUMOBPP JV ABBM >KA PFK@BOB DO>QFQRAB QL JV >ASFPLO
/OLCBPPLO'LKDJFKD9E>KDCLODFSFKDJB@LKPQ>KQPRMMLOQ>KAMOLSFAFKDFKS>IR>?IBDRFA>K@BFK
ALFKDQEFPOBPB>O@E>KAQEOLRDELRQJVDO>AR>QBPQRAFBP(QT>P>DOB>QMOFSFIBDB>KAELKLOQLPQRAV
W
JB(TLRIA>IPLIFHBQLQE>KHEFJCLOIB>AFKDJBQLQEBCFBIALC"EFKBPBIFKDRFPQF@PFKTEF@EEB
E>P Q>RDEQ JB ELT QL >MMIV QEB >MMOLMOF>QB JBQELALILDV QL J>HFKD >ODRJBKQP >KA QEFKHFKD
IE
@OFQF@>IIV ,LOBLSBO /OLCBPPLO 9E>KD FP >IPL > JBKQLO FK JV BUMBOFBK@B LC "EFKBPB I>KDR>DB
QB>@EFKDFKTEF@EEBE>PLCCBOBAJBS>OFLRP>KADOB>QLMMLOQRKFQFBPCLOMOLCBPPFLK>IQO>FKFKD>KA
EV
MO>@QF@B(>JBUQOBJBIVDO>QBCRICLOEFPEBIM>KADRFA>K@BFKBSBOVPQ>DBLCJVDO>AR>QBPQRAFBP
>KAAFPPBOQ>QFLKTOFQFKD(QT>PEFPBUMBOQFPBPRMMLOQ>KABK@LRO>DBJBKQQE>QJ>ABJVQFJB>QQEB
PR
4KFSBOPFQVLC6FP@LKPFK ,>AFPLKBKGLV>?IB
(>IPLTLRIAIFHBQLPELTJVPFK@BOB>MMOB@F>QFLKQLJV@LJJFQQBBJBJ?BOP/OLCBPPLO1>KF>
>PQEBFKPFDEQCRI@LJJBKQPLKJVAFPPBOQ>QFLK,VPFK@BOBDO>QFQRABDLBPQL/OLCBPPLO'RKQFKDQLK
CLOEBOEBIM>KABK@LRO>DBJBKQAROFKDQEBPBVB>OP3EBBUMBOFBK@BLCPE>OFKD>KAIFPQBKFKDQL>
PQLOVLCJ>OSBILRPKBPPFKEBOPBJFK>OT>P>IT>VPFJMOBPPFSB>KABKGLV>?IB(>JSBOVDO>QBCRIQL
/OLCBPPLO 9ER CLO EBO @IB>O FKPQOR@QFLKP S>IR>?IB BUMBOQFPB >KA ABSLQBA BKQERPF>PJ FK "EFKBPB
I>KDR>DBQB>@EFKD>KAFQT>PJVELKLOQLTLOH>PEBOQB>@EFKD>PPFPQ>KQ(TLRIA>IPLIFHBQLDFSB
QE>KHPQL/OLCBPPLO+FCLODFSFKDJBQEBLMMLOQRKFQVQLPFQFKLKEFP@I>PPLC2VKQ>@QF@3EBLOFBPFK
FFF
JVCFOPQPQ>DBPLCTOFQFKDQEFPAFPPBOQ>QFLK
(K >AAFQFLK ( TLRIA IFHB QL BUMOBPP DO>QFQRAB >KA QE>KHP QL QEB C>@RIQV JBJ?BOP FK QEB
CLOJBOABM>OQJBKQ>AJFKFPQO>QLO>KAQEBSBOVCFOPQC>@RIQVJBJ?BOQE>Q(Q>IHBAQLLKJVCFOPQA>V
LCDO>AR>QBP@ELLICLOEBOHFKA>PPFPQ>K@B>KA@LKPQ>KQPRMMLOQ(>JSBOVQE>KHCRIQL,P'>FV>K
>IB@QROBO>PTBII>PQB>@EFKD>PPFPQ>KQ(>IPLT>KQQLDFSBQE>KHPQL,P1>@EBI6BFPPQEBDO>AR>QB
DO>AR>QBPQRAFBPTLRIAE>SBKLQPJLLQEIVJLSBALK
W
,>KVQE>KHPDLQLJVCOFBKAP>KA@I>PPJ>QBPTELE>SBLCCBOBAJB@LKQFKRBAEBIM@>OB>KA
IE
PRMMLOQ(TLRIAIFHBQLQE>KH'LKD8>K%>KD8>K8>KTBK6R>KA6BKQFKD)FJVCBIILT3 P
FK AFCCBOBKQ PBJBPQBOP LC "EFKBPB I>KDR>DB QB>@EFKD CLO QEBFO >PPFPQ>K@B >KA @LKQOF?RQFLK ,V
EV
EB>OQCBIQ>MMOB@F>QFLKDLBPQL!OBKA>K#LTIFKDTELE>PEBIMBAMOLLCOB>A>KABAFQJVAFPPBOQ>QFLK
( T>KQ QL QE>KH 7F>KD +] CLO >KPTBOFKD NRBPQFLKP OBD>OAFKD JV CFK>I LO>I ABCBKPB LC QEFP
(TLRIA>IPLIFHBQLDFSBJVPMB@F>IQE>KHPQL/OLCBPPLO'LKDJFKD9E>KDiPTFCB,OP,FKER>
+F ,V QFJB >Q QEB 4KFSBOPFQV LC 6FP@LKPFK ,>AFPLK TLRIA KLQ E>SB ?BBK PL ABIFDEQCRI >KA
JBJLO>?IBTFQELRQEBO@LKPQ>KQPRMMLOQHFKAEBIM>KAT>OJBK@LRO>DBJBKQ
+>PQIVLOO>QEBOCFOPQIV (>JDOB>QIVFKAB?QBAQLJVC>JFIV3EFPAFPPBOQ>QFLKTLRIAKLQE>SB
?BBK@LJMIBQBATFQELRQQEBFOPRMMLOQRKABOPQ>KAFKD>KAILSB(TLRIAIFHBQLBUMOBPPJVPFK@BOB
DO>QFQRABQLJVM>OBKQPTELE>SB?BBKLCCBOFKDJBBKAIBPPPRMMLOQ>KARK@LKAFQFLK>IILSBCOLJ
FS
QEBJLJBKQ(AB@FABAQLIB>SBELJB>KAPQ>OQ>IFCBQELRP>KAPLCJFIBP>T>VCOLJQEBJ(>IPL
T>KQQLDFSBPMB@F>IQE>KHPQLJVFK I>TPCLOQEBFORKABOPQ>KAFKD>KAPRMMLOQAROFKDQEBVB>OP
TEBKJLPQLCJVQFJBT>PABSLQBAQLPQRAVFKD%FK>IIV(TLRIAIFHBQLBUMOBPPJVABBMBPQQE>KHP
QE>QTBE>AQLQ>HB@>OBLCBSBOVQEFKDLKLROLTK8FKDR>KDPELRIABOBA>IIQEBOBPMLKPF?FIFQFBP
TEBK(T>PPQORDDIFKDTFQE?LQEQEBMLPQM>OQRJ>KUFBQV>KAQEBMOBPPROBCOLJAFPPBOQ>QFLKTOFQFKD
(KQEBI>PQPQ>DBLCJVAFPPBOQ>QFLKTOFQFKDJVA>RDEQBOE>AQLPQ>VTFQEJB>QELJBARBQLQEB
QE>KBUMB@QBATEBK(E>AQLTLOHLKJVAFPPBOQ>QFLK>KAIBQEBOMI>V>ILKB(Q>HBQEFPLMMLOQRKFQV
W
QL>@HKLTIBADBQEBDOB>QAB?QLCDO>QFQRAB(LTBQLJVERP?>KA>KAJVA>RDEQBO(TLRIAIFHBQL
ABAF@>QBQEFPAFPPBOQ>QFLKQLQEBJ
IE
EV
PR
S
0/4.,=4984
.589@6020708=<44
&,-609198=08=<?
-<=;,.=4A
W
3,:=0;8=;9/>.=498
3EBMROMLPBLCQEFPPQRAV
!>@HDOLRKALCQEBLOBQF@>ICO>JBTLOH
IE
4KABOPQ>KAFKDQEBMLBQF@BIBJBKQP>KAEFBO>O@EV
/OBSFLRPPQRAFBPLKMLBQF@OBDRI>OFW>QFLKFK"EFKBPBMLBQOV
EV
3EBPQOBPP
LOFBKQBAJLABIP
3EBJBQOF@>IDOFA
.QEBOQEBLOBQF@>IFPPRBP
PR
3O>AFQFLK>ISFBTPLC"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBASBOPB
3LKBOB>IFW>QFLKFK"EFKBPBSBOPB
.OD>KFW>QFLKLCQEFPPQRAV
3,:=0;"90=4. 0.3,84<7,8/";9<9/4.0,=>;0<-0B98/ ><4.
./0/4-iPCLOJ>QFLK>KA@>QBDLOFW>QFLK
3EBJRPF@>I>PMB@QLC./0/4-
3EBJRPF@PBQQFKD
3EBJRPF@>ICLOJP
3EBQO>KPFQFLKLCQEBJRPF@>IP@LOBPLC./0/4-
,LABPQLKBP>KAQEBFOOBI>QFLKFK./0/4-
"EFKBPBMBKQ>QLKF@P@>IB>KAFQPJLABP
SF
"EFKBPBEBMQ>QLKF@P@>IB>KAFQPJLABP
#>Q>@LIIB@QFLK
3LKBPJLABP>KAOBI>QFLKP$SFABK@BCOLJ./0/4--;6;
(KQOLAR@QFLKQLQEB>KKLQ>QFLKP
#>Q>>K>IVPFP
-LQB
QLKBOBI>QFLK>KAJLABC>@QP
(KQBOFJPRJJ>OV>KACROQEBOAFP@RPPFLKP
3,:=0;"08=,<B66,-4."907<,8/&98,6$02>6,;4C,=49848,87-;B984.%=,20
3EBLOFDFKPLC"EFKBPBMBKQ>PVII>?F@MLBJP
KFKQOLAR@QFLKQLQEBPLKDPLCQEB,RPF@!ROB>R
W
'VMLQEBPFPLKQEBPRMBOFLOFQVLCMBKQ>PVII>?F@MLBJPFKOBDRI>OFW>QFLK
+9./>KA8LKDJFKDPQVIBMLBJP
IE
%LROQLKBP>KAQEBMBKQ>QLKF@P@>IB
$FDEQABCB@QP>KANROBDRI>QFLKP
1EVQEJFKJBQOF@>IM>QQBOK>KAIVOF@PQOR@QROB
EV
4K>KPTBOBANRBPQFLKPOBD>OAFKDQEBMLBQF@OEVQEJ
0RBPQFLKFKDQEBB@ELBP?BQTBBKIVOF@PQOR@QROBP>KAJBQOF@>IM>QQBOKPFKSBOPB
,LOBBSFABK@BCOLJ"EFKBPBJLABOKPLKDP
PR
KFKQBOFJPRJJ>OV?>PBALKQEBMOBSFLRPQTL@>PBPQRAFBP
1RIBPFKMLBQF@MO>@QF@BLKQEBPLKDPLCQEB,RPF@!ROB>R
/OBM>O>QFLKCLOQEBQBPQ
3EBABPFDKBAQBPQFKMO>@QF@B
KLSBO>IIA>Q>>K>IVPFP?>PBALKQEBQBPQOBPRIQP
PQ>QFPQF@>IPFDKFCF@>K@BQBPQQ
QBPQ ?>PBALKQEBLSBO>IIA>Q>@LIIB@QFLK
"LK@IRPFLKP
3,:=0;'$02>6,=0/%=B60'0;<0%=,8/,;/4C,=49848,%.307,=4C0/!0@ 9/06
(KQOLAR@QFLK
3EBLOBQF@>ICO>JBTLOH
?OFBCFKQOLAR@QFLKQLOBDRI>QBA
PQVIBSBOPB
SFF
3EBSBOFCF@>QFLKLCIBSBIQLKB>KAL?IFNRBQLKBFKMLBQF@MOLPLAV
$@ELBP?BQTBBK?B>QPFKJRPF@>KAOEVQEJFKOBDRI>QBASBOPB
EVMLQEBPFPLCARO>QFLK>I>@@BKQP>P>CLRKA>QFLK
.KQEB>PPRJMQFLKLCf?>KVLRAFKDM>FgpmKc
3EBARO>QFLK>I?LRKA>OVJ>OHBOFK"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBASBOPB
#>Q>>K>IVPFP
#>Q>FKQOLAR@QFLK>KAABJLKPQO>QFLKABPFDK
2>JMIBA>Q>>K>IVPFP
2Q>QFPQF@>I>K>IVPFPTFQE/B>OPLK"LOOBI>QFLK"LBCCF@FBKQ>KAEVMLQEBPFPQBPQ
#FP@RPPFLK
$UMIF@>QFLKP>KAEVMLQEBPFP
W
%LOCRQROBAFP@RPPFLK
3,:=0;'%B8=,.=4.98<4<=08.B,8/%B8=,A 0=;4.< 4<7,=.348'0;<0
IE
(KQOLAR@QFLK
2VKQ>@QF@@LKPFPQBK@VCOLJLIAMLBJPQLOBDRI>QBASBOPB
EV
1BSFPFQFKDOBDRI>QBA
PQVIBSBOPB
.OFDFKP>KA?>PF@ORIBPLC"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBA
PQVIBSBOPB
?OFBCOBSFBTLCQEBMLBQF@MOLPLAVLCOBDRI>QBA
PQVIBSBOPB
"LIIB@QFLKPLCQEB3>KDMLBQOV>KAQEBQO>KPI>QBASBOPFLKP
!>PF@ABCFKFQFLKP>KA@OFQBOF>LCMLBQOVFK$KDIFPE
*BVQBOJPLCPLRKAM>QQBOKP
/LBQF@PQ>KW>>KAPQ>KW>F@CLOJP
2QOBPPFK$KDIFPEMLBQOV
3EBJBQOF@>ICLLQ>KAALJFK>KQMLBQF@JBQBOP
/LBQF@PVKQ>U>S>OF>QFLKLCQEBPVKQ>UFKKLOJ>IPMBB@E
@>PBPQRAVLCQEBPVKQ>@QF@CB>QROBP>KAQEBJBQOF@>IP@EBJBP
2BIB@QFLKLCA>Q>
SFFF
,B>KP>KAMOL@BPP
3EB>K>IVPFPLCQTLOBDRI>QBA
PQVIBSBOPBP
"LK@IRPFLKP
3,:=0;'98.6>/482$07,;5<
$010;08.0<
::08/4A
::08/4A
W
::08/4A
::08/4A
IE
::08/4A
EV
PR
FU
3EFPPQRAVPBQPLRQQLPBBHCLOQEBK>QROBLC"EFKBPBMLBQOVLSBO>TFABO>KDBLCQFJBPM>K
QEOLRDE PVKQ>@QF@ >K>IVPFP MOLPLAF@ >MMOL>@E >KA JRPF@>I BUMILO>QFLK &FSBK QEB BUFPQBK@B LC
J>KV AFSBOPB DBKOBP >KA QBJMI>QBP LC "EFKBPB MLBQOV TEF@E E>P AO>TK QEB >QQBKQFLK LC
FKQBOAFP@FMIFK>OVPQRAFBPQEFPPQRAVILLHPQLQEBABSBILMJBKQLC"EFKBPBMLBQOV>KAQOFBPQLMOLSFAB
PLIFABUMI>K>QFLKPCLOQEBMLBQF@OBDRI>OFQFBPCOLJAFCCBOBKQ>KDIBP"E>MQBO(FKQOLAR@BPQEB?>PF@
BIBJBKQPPQOR@QROB>KAHBVQBOJPLCMLBQOVFKDBKBO>ITFQEPLJBPFJFI>O@LK@BMQPFKMLBQF@MOLPLAV
W
MOLPLAF@ MELKLILDV >KA JBQOF@>I MELKLILDV @LJM>OBA 3EB TFABIV >@@BMQBA QEBLOBQF@>I
CO>JBTLOHP LK "EFKBPB OBDRI>QBA
PQVIB SBOPB FK MOBSFLRP PQRAFBP FK@IRAFKD QEB PQOBPP
LOFBKQBA
IE
JLABIPQEBJBQOF@>IDOFA>KALQEBOQO>AFQFLK>IMBOPMB@QFSBP>OBFKQOLAR@BA>KAAFP@RPPBA2Q>OQFKD
TFQEQEBFKQOLAR@QFLKLC./0/4-iPLOFDFKP>KA@I>PPFCF@>QFLK@BOQ>FKLABP>OBPBIB@QBAQLAFP@RPPQEB
EV
MLBQF@JB@E>KFPJ>KAQEBMOLPLAF@CB>QROBPOBCIB@QBAFKQEBJRPF@ OBI>QBAC>@QPFK"E>MQBO((3EB
JRPF@>IJLQFS>QFLK>KACB>QROBPLC./0/4->OBBUMILOBA>PTBII3EB@ILPBOBI>QFLKPEFM?BQTBBK
PR
MLBQF@CB>QROBPLC./0/4->KAQEB"EFKBPB@I>PPF@>IJRPF@M>SBPQEBT>VCLOOBSB>IFKDQEBQOFDDBO
FKQEBOBDRI>OFW>QFLKLC"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBA PQVIBSBOPB"E>MQBO(((MOL?BPFKQLQEBJBQOF@>IP@EBJBP
LCPBIB@QBAMBKQ>PVII>?F@PLKDPLCQEB,RPF@!ROB>R>KAFKSBPQFD>QBPQEBCB>PF?FIFQFBPLCQEBPQOBPP
LOFBKQBAJLABIP3EBOBPRIQPLCQEBQBPQP@E>IIBKDBQEB>MMIF@>QFLKLCQEBJBQOF@>IQEBLOVLC$KDIFPE
SBOPBQL"EFKBPBSBOPBFKAFP@OFJFK>QBIV(K"E>MQBO(5>P@EBJ>QFWBAKBTJLABIQLPQ>KA>OAFWB
QEB MLBQF@ MOLPLAV LK JBQOF@>I M>QQBOKP LC BDRI>QBA PQVIB SBOPB FP BPQ>?IFPEBA 3EB QEBLOV LC
))+4:+* ;8':/54'2 5;4*'8? #! ABSBILMP > KBT T>V LC >K>IVWFKD QEB OBDRI>OFW>QFLK LC
"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBA PQVIBSBOPB"E>MQBO5@BKQBOP>OLRKAQEBOLIBQE>QMLBQF@PVKQ>UMI>VPFKQEB
U
?BQTBBKQEBPVKQ>@QF@CB>QROBP>KAQEBJBQOF@>IP@EBJBPOBCIB@QBA?V"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBA PQVIBSBOPB
>KA QEB @LOOBPMLKAFKD QO>KPI>QBA $KDIFPE SBOPB FK AFCCBOBKQ SBOPFLKP >OB BU>JFKBA 3EB PQRAV
@LKAR@QBAFKQEFP@E>MQBOFP>KBUQBKPFLKLCQEBJLAFCFBAJLABIPLCQEBMLBQF@MOLPLAVPMB@RI>QBA
FK QEB MOBSFLRP @E>MQBOP >KA FQ >IPL OBPMLKAP QL QEB @E>IIBKDB LC PFJMIV >KA RK@LKAFQFLK>IIV
>MMIVFKDQEBJBQOF@>IPVPQBJLCPQOBPP QFJBAI>KDR>DBPQL"EFKBPBSBOPB
W
IE
EV
PR
3,:=0;8=;9/>.=498
3EBMROMLPBLCQEFPPQRAV
AFPPBOQ>QFLK>FJP>QRKABOPQ>KAFKDQEBK>QROBLC"EFKBPBMLBQOVFKAFCCBOBKQCLOJP>KAPE>MBPLSBO
>TFABO>KDBLCQFJBPM>KQEOLRDEPVKQ>@QF@>K>IVPFPMOLPLAF@>MMOL>@E>KAJRPF@>IBUMILO>QFLK
#BPMFQBQE>QQEBOB>OBPQRAFBPLKQEBMLBQF@CB>QROBPLCAFCCBOBKQQVMBPLC"EFKBPBSBOPBJLPQLC
QEBJBFQEBOCL@RPBALKTLOHPCOLJ>IFJFQBAKRJ?BOLCMLBQPLOJ>AB@LJ?FKBAPRJJ>OFBP?V
W
FKEBOFQFKDMOBSFLRPIV>ALMQBAQEBLOBQF@>ICO>JBTLOHP(KQEFPAFPPBOQ>QFLK>@LJMOBEBKPFSBPQRAV
LK@BOQ>FKQLMF@POBI>QBAQLAFSBOPBCLOJPLC"EFKBPBMLBQOVFKAFCCBOBKQBO>PFP@LKAR@QBA2R@E>K
IE
>K>IVPFPFPALKBFKLOABOQLMOL?BFKQLQEBK>QROBLC"EFKBPBMLBQOVLKQEB?>PFPLCQEBFKQBOC>@B
>JLKD IFKDRFPQF@P JRPF@ >KA MLBQOV >KA QL @LKPQOR@Q MLPPF?IB BUMI>K>QFLKP CLO QEB MLBQF@
EV
OBDRI>OFQFBPFK>?OL>ABOPBKPB
!>@HDOLRKALCQEBLOBQF@>ICO>JBTLOH
PR
ILKD TFQE QEB ABSBILMJBKQ LC "EFKBPB MLBQOV >QQBJMQP QL P@EBJ>QFWB >KA RKFCV QEB
CLOJ>QFLK LC QEB MLBQOViP JBQOF@>I PQOR@QROB KBSBO PQLM %LO JLPQ PQRAFBP OBDRI>QBA SBOPB FP
@LKQFKR>IIV AB?>QBA >KA RPR>IIV QEB OBPB>O@E >OB> FP PQOBQ@EBA QL QEB IFQBO>QROB FK LQEBO BO>
RKPQLMM>?IV"EBK8FM%>??%>??'>IIB#R>KJR>KALQEBOP
,LPQJLABIP@OB>QBAFKQEBPBPQRAFBPPELTBA>OBI>QFLKLCPR@@BPPFLK>KAQLLHQEBBUFPQBK@BLC
PQOBPPM>QQBOKPFKQEB"EFKBPBSBOPB>P>MOBPRMMLPFQFLK.QEBOJLABIP?LOOLTBAQEBQEBLOBQF@>I
CO>JBTLOHPCOLJ$KDIFPEMLBQOV>KAJ>ABPLJBOBSFPFLKP?BCLOB>MMIVFKDFQQLQEB"EFKBPBSBOPB
3EFP PQRAV >PPRJBP QE>Q QEB OBDRI>OFW>QFLK LC OBDRI>QBA PQVIB SBOPB FP PE>MBA DO>AR>IIV FK QEB
ABSBILMJBKQ LC QEB MLBQF@ CLOJP COLJ QEB QBQO>PVII>?F@ SBOPB FK QEB 551 5, *+9 QL QEB
MBKQ>PVII>?F@SBOPB3EBOBDRI>OFW>QFLKFP>IPLPE>MBAFKQEBPLKDPLCQEB,RPF@!ROB>RTEF@E>OB
FJMLOQ>KQIV MLBQF@ CB>QROBP (AB>IIV PMB>HFKD > P@EBJ>QFWBA KBT JLABI BPQ>?IFPEBA LK QEB
ABSBILMJBKQLCMLBQOVTFII?B>?IBQLBUMI>FKQEBMLBQF@OBDRI>OFW>QFLK
4KABOPQ>KAFKDMLBQF@BIBJBKQP>KAEFBO>O@EV
3EBOB>OBJ>KVBIBJBKQPLOD>KFWBAFKLKBT>VLO>KLQEBOQLCLOJ>MBOCB@QMLBJPR@E>PQEB
MLBQF@ PQOR@QROB PLRKA FJ>DBOV CFDRO>QFSB I>KDR>DB MLBQF@ CLOJP >KA PL LK P CRKA>JBKQ>I
W
C>@QLOP QEB MLBQF@ PQOR@QROBP PLRKAP >KA FK TE>Q CLOJP QEB MLBJP >OB MOBPBKQBA >OB QEB J>FK
IE
L?GB@QFSBPQEFPPQRAVFKSBPQFD>QBP3EFPFPALKBFKLOABOQLCROQEBOPRJJ>OFWB>JLABIQLBUMI>FK
QEBOBDRI>OFW>QFLKLCQEB"EFKBPBMLBQOV2MB@FCF@>IIVQEBMLBQF@PQOR@QROBFP@LJMLPBACOLJQEB
EV
PJ>IIBPQ RKFQ TEF@E FP f?B>Qg QL QEB I>ODBPQ RKFQ TEF@E FP fMLBJg >KA QEB EFBO>O@EV @>K ?B
ABJLKPQO>QBAFK>QOBBPQOR@QROB>PCLIILTP
PR
'FBO>O@EF@>IMLBQF@PQOR@QROB
/LBJ
0R>QO>FK0R>QO>FK %LRO
IFKBPQ>KW>
"LRMIBQ"LRMIBQ3TL
IFKBPQ>KW>
/LBQF@IFKB/LBQF@IFKB
'BJFPQF@E'BJFPQF@E
%LLQ%LLQ
!B>Q!B>Q
2Q>KW>FP@LJMLPBALC>PBQLCIFKBPQE>QCLOJ>?>PF@OB@ROOFKDJBQOF@>IP@EBJBLO>OBDRI>O
OEVJBTFQEKBFQEBOPQOF@QIVOBNRFOBACLO>PQ>KW>3EBOB>OBJ>KVAFCCBOBKQPQ>KW>F@CLOJPTEF@E
S>OV COLJ > QTL IFKB PQ>KW> @LRMIBQ QL >K BFDEQ IFKB PQ>KW> LQQ>S> OFJ> TFQE PLJB RKFNRB
PQ>KW>F@ CLOJP HKLTK ?B@>RPB LC QEBFO FKSBKQLOP LO C>JLRP MO>@QFQFLKBOP 3EB JLPQ FJMLOQ>KQ
@LJMLKBKQFKPLRKAFPJBQBO,BQBOPMB@FCF@>IIVOBCBOPQL>M>QQBOKLCLOD>KFW>QFLKLCQEBCLLQFK>
MLBQF@IFKB(Q@LRIA?B>OBMBQFQFLKLC>?>PF@PQOBPPM>QQBOKIFHBF>J?F@LOQOL@E>F@LOFQ@LRIA?B
JLOB@LJMIF@>QBATFQE>@LJ?FK>QFLKLCPBSBO>IHFKAPLC?>PF@PQOBPPM>QQBOKP'>IIB*BVPBO
QOBBPQOR@QROBFK
W
9E>KD PQ>QBAQE>QCLLQFP>RKFQQE>QCRK@QFLKPAFCCBOBKQIVFKMOLPLAF@MELKLILDVJBQOF@>I
IE
MELKLILDV>KAMLBQF@MELKLILDV(KMOLPLAF@MELKLILDVCLLQFPLKBLCQEBMOLPLAF@RKFQPQE>Q
?RFIARMQEBEFBO>O@EF@>IMOLPLAF@PQOR@QROBP(QFPIL@>QBA?BILTQEBMOLPLAF@TLOA>KA>?LSBQEB
EV
PVII>?IB>PPELTKFK
'FBO>O@EF@>IMOLPLAF@PQOR@QROBP2BIHFOH'>VBP-BPMLO5LDBI9B@
9E>KD
PR
$?=:?6C676C6?469EEADHHH3C:E2??:424@>2CEDE2?K2
W
(K JBQOF@>I MELKLILDV ELTBSBO CLLQ FP QEB J>FK RKFQ QL @LKPQOR@Q QEB JBQOF@>I DOFAP TEF@E
IE
BUMI>FKQEBQEBLOBQF@>ICO>JBTLOHLCPQOBPPLOIFKDRFPQF@MOLJFKBK@B(KMLBQF@MOLPLAVCLLQFPQEB
?>PF@RKFQQE>QCLOJP>OB@ROOFKDJBQOF@>IP@EBJB>KAQEBM>QQBOK>KALOD>KFW>QFLKLCQEBCLLQFK>
EV
MLBJIFKBTFIIABQBOJFKBQEBJBQBOLC>MLBJ(KLQEBOTLOAP>MLBJIFKB@>K?B?OLHBKFKQL
AFCCBOBKQ KRJ?BO LC CBBQ 3EB JLPQ @LJJLK CBBQ FK $KDIFPE MLBQOV >OB QTL
PVII>?IB >KA QEOBB
PR
PVII>?IBFKIBKDQE#FCCBOBKQ @LJ?FK>QFLKPLCPQOBPPBA>KARKPQOBPPBAPVII>?IBPCLOJAFCCBOBKQQVMBP
LCJBQOF@>ICBBQ3EBOB@ROOBK@BLC>QVMBLCJBQOF@>ICBBQQEBKCLOJP >PMB@FCF@MLBQF@JBQBO9E>KD
LCCLLQ>OBAFCCBOBKQTFQECLLQFK$KDIFPEMLBQOV3EFPFPARBQLQEBC>@QQE>QQEB?FK>OV@LKQO>PQFK
"EFKBPBMLBQOVFPOB>IFWBA?VQEBBSBKQLKB>KAQEBL?IFNRBQLKBLOD>KFWBAFKCLROPVII>?IBP FKPQB>A
LCQTLPVII>?IBP3EBAFCCBOBKQT>VLCOB>IFWFKDQEB?FK>OV@LKQO>PQFK"EFKBPBMLBQOVFP?>PBALK
QEBC>@QQE>QQEBOBFPKLQBKLRDEBSFABK@BQLMOLSBQE>QCLLQ>P>MOLPLAF@RKFQCRK@QFLKP FKQEB
>MOLPLAF@RKFQQLCRK@QFLKFK>I>KDR>DB&BKBO>IIVPMB>HFKDTEBQEBOLOKLQ>I>KDR>DBE>PCLLQ
>P>MOLPLAF@RKFQABMBKAPLKFCQEBOB>OB?FK>OV@LKQO>PQPPVPQBJ>QF@>IIVOBCIB@QFKDQEBMOLJFKBKQ
>KA PQOLKD SBOPRP TB>H !B@>RPB QEBOB >OB KL ?FK>OV @LKQO>PQP PVPQBJ>QF@>IIV OBCIB@QFKD QEB
MOLJFKBKQJBQOF@>ICB>QROBP>QQEBTLOAIBSBIFK"EFKBPBI>KDR>DBQEBPQ>QBJBKQQE>QCLLQ>P>
MOLPLAF@RKFQMI>VP>M>OQFK"EFKBPBPELRIA?BNRBPQFLKBA3EFPOBJ>OH>?IBCB>QROBJ>HBPQEB
OBDRI>OFW>QFLK LC "EFKBPB MLBQOV AFPQFKDRFPE>?IB COLJ TE>Q $KDIFPE MLBQOV E>P FK @LKPQOR@QFKD
@BOQ>FKQVMBPLCJBQOF@>ICBBQ>KAMLBQF@JBQBOP
!>PBALKTE>QE>P?BBKAFP@RPPBA>?LSBFQFP@IB>OQE>Q"EFKBPBMLBQOVE>PJ>KVRKFNRB>KA
BU@IRPFSB @E>O>@QBOFPQF@P OBD>OAFKD MLBQF@ MOLPLAV @LJM>OBA TFQE PQOBPP QFJBA I>KDR>DBP IFHB
W
$KDIFPE 3EB J>FK AFCCBOBK@B IFBP FK QEB CLRKA>QFLKP ?>PBA LK TEF@E QEB MLBQF@ JBQBOP >OB
IE
@LKPQOR@QBA3LMRQFQAFCCBOBKQIVQEBAFP@OBM>K@V?BQTBBK"EFKBPBMLBQOV>KA$KDIFPEMLBQOVFK
QBOJPLCT>VPLC?RFIAFKDRMQEBJBQOF@>IP@EBJBFP@LKPMF@RLRP3EFPPQRAVPBQPLRQQLFKSBPQFD>QB
EV
QEB MLBQF@ CB>QROBP LC "EFKBPB MLBQOV QEOLRDE AFCCBOBKQ BO>P >KA QEB @LKPB@RQFSB OBI>QFLKPEFMP
>JLKDAFSBOPBCLOJPLCMLBQOV3VMF@>IJLABIPTFII?BBPQ>?IFPEBAQLBUMI>FKQEBOBDRI>OFW>QFLKLC
"EFKBPBMLBQOVFKQEBMLBQF@ABSBILMJBKQTEF@ECROQEBOEFDEIFDEQPQEBMB@RIF>OT>VPFKTEF@EQEB
PR
JBQOF@>IP@EBJBFPOB>IFWBA
/OBSFLRPPQRAFBPLKMLBQF@OBDRI>OFW>QFLKFK"EFKBPBMLBQOV
3EBPQOBPP LOFBKQBAJLABIP
"EBK
(K"EBKiPQEBLOVFQT>PMLPBAQE>Q"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBASBOPBL?IFDBP>JBQOF@>IPQOR@QROBQE>QFP
RKABOIVFKDORIBPLC?LQEQEBQLK>IM>QQBOKP>KAQEBJBQOF@>IM>QQBOKPLC"EFKBPBOBDRI>QBASBOPB
QEOLRDE >K >AS>K@BA EFBO>O@EF@>I QOBB PQOR@QROB 3EFP EFBO>O@EF@>I QOBB PQOR@QROB FP >K BUQBKABA
>OBPVJ?LIFWBA>PfSg>KAf gOBPMB@QFSBIV3EB>AABAQOBBPQOR@QROBFPQLMOLSFABQEBRKABOIVFKD
ORIBP>@@LOAFKDQLQEBQLK>IM>QQBOKPLKQEBPROC>@BIBSBI>KA@LK@IRABJ>KVS>OF>QFLKPABOFSBA
COLJQEBQLK>IM>QQBOKP
W
IE
EV
PR
As shown in the tree structure (4), a heptasyllabic line is divided into three metrical units as
12/34/567 (Jakobson 1970). On the basis of (4), Chen then reconsidered the division . As can be
seen in tree structures (5a) and (5b), there is a caesura between the second foot and the third foot
(F). According to Chen, such a caesura is observed in traditional verse recitation. Usually, there is
a major potential pause existing between the fourth and the fifth syllable, whereas only minor
pauses are accepted after the second, and either the fifth or sixth syllable. As a result of these
pauses, the last three syllables are presented as either 5/67 or 56/7. Eventually, a metrical line is
divided into two hemistiches (H) firstly, and later on each hemistich splits up into two metrical
feet (F) respectively. Since there might be two instances of pauses in the last three syllables, the
1979:380).
W
(5) Revised seven-syllable line hierarchical structure (Chen 1979:380)
IE
EV
PR
It is clear that the presupposition of creating such hierarchical tree structures is to admit that in
Chinese regulated-style verse every two syllables naturally form a metrical foot. As mentioned
above, foot as a prosodic unit is constructed by two units with binary contrast systematically
reflecting prominent metrical features at the word level. In poetic prosody, a metrical foot also
needs to be realized by prominence features in a binary contrast, such as a stressed syllable versus
an unstressed syllable in a stress-timed language. When it comes to Chinese regulated verse, the
only evident binary contrast emerges in the contrast between the even tones and the oblique tones,
which is presented every four syllables2. If that is the case, the tree structures in (5) will need to be
reconstructed.
The following are the steps proposed by Chen (1979) regarding the formation of the
heptasyllabic lines’ metrical pattern and tone assignment based on the principles shown in (6).
W
metrical foot.
tones of the second hemistich undergo alpha-switching (i.e., E to O, and vice versa).
First, the hierarchical structure is created according to (6a). The hierarchical structure in (7a)
is an example of a line in Heptasyllabic A in (3) with a right-branching subtree. After that, opposite
tones are assigned to sister constituents down to the level of the metrical foot as shown in (7b). As
needs to be opposite to
stated in (6c) and (6d), T might be either even tone or oblique tone and
T. Even tones and oblique tones are assigned to specific nodes in the last step, as shown in the tree
structure in (7c).
C@>E96=64EFC6?@E6D@7E96D6>:?2C@?9:?6D6(J?E2I2?5"@CA9@=@8J:?DECF4E653J%C@76DD@C@?8>:?8-92?8
:?(AC:?8
6A2CE>6?E@7D:2?!2?8F286D2?5F=EFC6D*?:G6CD:EJ@7,:D4@?D:?"25:D@?
(7) A heptasyllabic line in hierarchical structure with tone assignment (Chen 1979:383-384)
W
Using this procedure, Chen believed that all the canonical lines of Heptasyllabic 1 to 4 are
IE
predictable. Moreover, it is also stated that with the same principles inferred for the heptasyllabic
verse, it is easily to generate the desired prosodic patterns according to the hierarchical tree
EV
(8) A pentasyllabic line in hierarchical structure with tone assignment (Chen 1979:388)
PR
After building up the standard hierarchical tree structure of both heptasyllabic and
pentasyllabic lines along with tone assignment, some situations not ruled by the proposed
principles were fixed. Chen posed the Extracanonical Lines to try to explain the reasons why some
existing poem lines have tone arrangement that violate the desired principles. Based on the data
PFQR>QFLKPTFQERKBUMB@QBAQLKB>PPFDKJBKQPELRIAE>SBQEBFOLTKOBDRI>QFLKP%FSBMLQBKQF>IORIBP
>OBQERP@LJMLPBAQLLCCBOBUMI>K>QFLKPQLQEBBU@BMQFLK>I@>PBP>PABJLKPQO>QBAFK
$UQO>@>KLKF@>I+FKBP"EBK
W
IE
EV
PR
For each poem line, two free slots are permitted with the first slot always being free. Under the
condition that the fifth position is filled by an oblique tone and followed by an oblique tone at the
same time, the fifth position is free. The third position is usually free unless the fifth position is
free. The even-numbered and the final positions are fixed. As seen from (9), the circled positions
The question lies in that the data base used by Chen was limited, making it difficult to create
rules on the basis of data that is not thorough enough. Moreover, the detailed statistical procedure
was not revealed, so whether the results had statistical significance is unknown. Under this
condition, the validity of the “five potential rules” for some certain patterns because of the lack of
the specific ratio of each type of the extracanonical lines are questionable. Aside from this, if the
desired hierarchical tree structures developed earlier are not able to conjecture all situations of tone
assignment and additional rules have to consider variations and exceptional cases, the theoretical
With many questions not answered yet, Chen further advanced the tree structures in (5) and
proposed two new hierarchical tree structures as shown in (10). To revisit the principles of tone
W
IE
EV
PR
(11)
According to the principles of building up a hierarchical tree structure and assigning the tones
proposed by Chen, opposite tones should be assigned to sister constituents down to the level of the
metrical foot. As demonstrated in (10a), it is obvious that the 1 and 2 positions form a metrical
foot, the 3 and 4 positions form another metrical foot, the 5 position is one metrical foot and
the last two positions form a metrical foot. If the Tonotactic Condition is consistently applied to
all layers of the tree, tone assignment within one metrical foot should be completely different. Now
that in the advanced hierarchical tree structures, the layer of metrical foot is extended to the bottom
line with every two syllables forming a metrical foot, the tones of every two syllables that form a
metrical foot should be opposite. However, in (11), it seems that the 1 and 2 syllable are both
W
assigned the oblique tone, the 3and 4syllable are both assigned the even tone, and the last two
IE
syllables are both assigned the oblique tone. If the advanced tree structures are solid, then the tone
assignment in (11) violates the “binary contrast” nature of metrical feet. As for the advanced
EV
hierarchical tree structures shown in (10), there are two problems. First, since the two syllables
within a metrical foot are already assigned the same tone, as shown in (11), the reason why
PR
different S/W labeling are realized as two syllables with the same tone is unknown. Second, one
syllable can be one metrical foot under the condition that the syllable is a stressed syllable. In (10),
however, the 5 syllable is weak, but it was considered as one metrical foot by Chen. 3
Inspired by Kiparsky’s study on the Finish poetry and influenced by Metrical Phonology, Chen
(1979) from a new perspective, established a hierarchical structure and tried to explain the
underlying metrical patterns of Chinese regulated verse. The metrical foot is a perfect device to
analyze English poetry because English is a stress-timed language, while whether foot as a
prosodic unit in the Chinese language is still questionable. On this account, using metrical foot as
C@>E96=64EFC6?@E6D@7E96
??F2=,@C<D9@A96=53J%C@76DD@C@?8>:?8-92?8
Reproduced with permission of copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.