Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PIIS0002939422001714
PIIS0002939422001714
MEGHAN K. BERKENSTOCK, KAYLA LONG, JOHN B. MILLER, BRYN B. BURKHOLDER, JOHN N. AUCOTT,
AND DOUGLAS A. JABS
• PURPOSE: To estimate the incidence of scleritis in Lyme • CONCLUSIONS: Lyme disease is an uncommon cause
disease and report clinical features. of scleritis in endemic areas. (Am J Ophthalmol
• DESIGN: Incidence rate estimate and case series. 2022;241: 139–144. © 2022 Elsevier Inc. All rights re-
• METHODS: Data were collected from an electronic med- served.)
ical record on patients with scleritis presenting to the
Wilmer Eye Institute between January 1, 2012 and De-
N
cember 31, 2020. A diagnosis of Lyme disease was made orth American Lyme disease is a multisystem
using the Infectious Diseases Society of America, Ameri- infectious disease caused by the bacterium Borrelia
can Academy of Neurology, and the American College of burgdorferi.1 Skin disease starts at the site of an in-
Rheumatology 2020 joint criteria plus a response to an- fected tick bite, and the Lyme spirochete can disseminate in
tibiotic therapy. After identifying all new-onset cases of the first weeks of infection to the joints, heart, and the ner-
scleritis in the database, the proportion of new-onset scle- vous system. Ocular involvement in Lyme disease has been
ritis with Lyme disease was calculated. The proportion reported at any stage of the disease and involve almost all
of Lyme disease cases with scleritis was estimated using ocular and adnexal structures, as well as the cranial nerves
the number of cases with Lyme disease from the Balti- involved in oculomotor function.1
more metropolitan area reported to the Centers for Dis- Lyme disease rarely has been reported as a cause of scle-
ease Control and Prevention. After querying other major ritis in several case reports or as isolated cases included as
eye centers in the area for any cases of Lyme disease scle- part of a larger series of scleritis, mostly from endemic areas
ritis, none were identified, and the incidence of Lyme dis- of the United States or Europe.1-6 We report a case series
ease scleritis was estimated using published U.S. Census of Lyme disease scleritis collected over a 9-year period in a
data for the greater Baltimore metropolitan area. Lyme disease endemic region and estimate the incidence of
• RESULTS: Six cases of Lyme disease scleritis were iden- Lyme scleritis.
tified in the 8-year time frame; 1 additional case was
identified in the following year. Lyme disease scleritis ac-
counted for 0.6% of all cases of scleritis, and 0.052% of
patients with Lyme disease had scleritis. The estimated
incidence of Lyme scleritis was 0.2 per 1,000,000 popu- PATIENTS AND METHODS
lation per year (95% confidence interval 0-0.4), whereas
the estimated incidence of Lyme disease in the area was Cases of newly diagnosed scleritis seen at the Wilmer
3 per 10,000 population per year (95% confidence inter- Eye Institute from January 1, 2012 through December 31,
val 2.9-3.1). All scleritis cases were anterior, unilateral, 2020 were identified using the SlicerDicer application in
without necrosis, and resolved with antibiotic use with- the EPIC electronic medical record system (EPIC Systems
out relapse in a median of 39.5 days (range 29-57 days). Corp, Verona, WI). Lyme disease scleritis cases were defined
Other features of Lyme disease were present in 4 of 7 pa- based on the Infectious Diseases Society of America, Amer-
tients, including a history of erythema migrans in 2 of 7 ican Academy of Neurology, and the American College of
patients. Rheumatology 2020 joint guidelines for the diagnosis of
Lyme disease.7 In brief, the diagnosis of Lyme disease re-
quired either erythema migrans (EM) or a positive serologic
Accepted for publication April 24, 2022. test for Lyme disease. Serologic diagnosis required a positive
From the Wilmer Eye Institute (M.K.B., B.B.B., D.A.J.), Department enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay test followed by con-
of Ophthalmology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Bal-
timore, Maryland; University of North Texas Health Science Center firmatory Western blot test (2 immunoglobulin M [IgM] or
Texas College of Osteopathic Medicine (K.L.), Fort Worth, Texas; De- 5 immunoglobulin G [IgG] positive bands) concurrent with
partment of Medicine (J.B.M., J.N.A.), Johns Hopkins University School or after the diagnosis of scleritis. To determine if there was
of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland; Johns Hopkins Lyme Disease Clinical
Research Center (J.N.A.), Lutherville, Maryland; Center for Clinical Tri- active Lyme disease in a patient with a positive IgM test re-
als and Evidence Synthesis (D.A.J.), Department of Epidemiology, Johns sult alone, a repeat Western blot with 5 positive IgG bands
Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland was required. If EM rash was present, a documented clinical
Inquiries to Meghan Berkenstock, Division of Ocular Immunology,
Wilmer Eye Institute, 600 North Wolfe Street, Baltimore, MD 21287.; response to antibiotic therapy was required in patients with-
e-mail: mberken2@jhmi.edu out a Western blot result. In addition to screening for Lyme
Characteristic Value
Patients, N 7
Demographics
Median age, y (range) 43 (24-81)
Male, n (%) 4 (57)
Race, n (%)
White, non-Hispanic 5 (72)
Black, non-Hispanic 1 (14)
Hispanic 1 (14)
Reside in Baltimore metropolitan area, n (%) 6 (86)
Known tick bite, n (%) 3 (43)
Presence of other ophthalmic manifestations, n (%) 0 (0)
Characteristics of scleritis, n (%)
Unilateral eye disease 7 (100)
Scleritis type
Sectoral anterior scleritis 3 (43)
Nodular anterior scleritis 3 (43)
Necrotizing scleritis 0 (0)
Posterior scleritis 0 (0)
Sclerokeratitis 1 (14)
Characteristics of Lyme disease, n (%)
Erythema migrans 2 (28)
Cardiovascular diseasea 1 (14)
Arthritis 1 (14)
Laboratory data,b n (%)
Positive immunoglobulin M antibody 1 (14)
Positive immunoglobulin G antibody 5 (72)
Antibiotic treatment regimen, n (%)
Intravenous ceftriaxone 0 (0)
Oral doxycycline 7 (100)
Oral cefuroximec 1 (14)
Mean days until resolution (range) 41 (29-57)
Postantibiotic treatment recurrence, n (%) 0 (0)
Antiinflammatory treatment regimen, n (%)
Oral indomethacin 2 (28)
Oral ibuprofen 1 (14)
Oral flurbiprofen 1 (14)
a
Bundle branch block.
b
Two patients were diagnosed based on clinical grounds within 30 days of onset.
c
Cefuroxime prescribed to finish treatment course because of intolerance of doxycycline side effects.
Outcome Value
CI = confidence interval.
a
Average population of the 8-year interval.
b
Only 3 cases of Lyme scleritis diagnosed between January 1, 2012 and December 31, 2019 were used to calculate the estimated inci-
dences. Lyme disease data released by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was only available through the end of 2019. The
remaining 4 cases of Lyme scleritis were diagnosed after January 1, 2020.
cella zoster virus scleritis. Specifically, spirochetes are he- volvement of disseminated disease, where 85% meet CDC
lical, Gram-negative bacteria, and several members of the criteria by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and IgG
phylum—including B. burgdorferi, Treponema pallidum, and Western blot, but 100% meet criteria by enzyme-linked im-
Leptospira—can cause inflammatory eye disease.14-16 Ocular munosorbent assay and IgM or IgG Western blot criteria.17
manifestations of Lyme disease can cause cranial neuropa- Tick and rash recall were relatively low, and this is similar to
thy, optic neuritis, uveitis, and less frequently scleritis.2 previous studies describing disseminated and late manifes-
In our small cohort, 83% (5/6 tested) had a positive tations of untreated Lyme disease. It is estimated that only
Western blot based on reactive IgG criteria. This is simi- 5% to 25% of patients with disseminated or late manifesta-
lar to what is seen with acute neurologic and cardiac in- tions of Lyme disease ever recall tick exposure or rash.18 , 19