Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

Phys. Chem. Earth (A), Vol.26, No. 4-5, pp.

343-354, 2001
Pergamon © 2001 ElsevierScienceLtd.
All rightsreserved
1464-1895/01/$ - see frontmatter
PII: S 1464-1895(01)00064-3

Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains and Plate


Kinematics: Example of the Cretaceous Mt. Stuart Batholith

K. Benn I, S. R. Paterson 2, S. P. Lund 2 , G. S. Pignotta' and S. Kruse 3

~Ottawa-Carleton Geoscience Centre and Department of Earth Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON K1N6N5,
Canada
2Department of Earth Sciences, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089-0740, U.S.A.
3Department of Earth Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON K1N6N5, Canada

Received 8 June 2000; accepted 28 November 2000

Abstract. The Cretaceous Mt. Stuart batholith was


syntectonically emplaced within amphibolite grade
metasedimentary rocks of the Cascades Crystalline Core, 1. Introduction
Washington State. The northern part of the batholith defines
a NW-SE trending antiformal fold. We present fabric data Magnetic anisotopy techniques, especially the anisotropy of
from that part of the batholith, collected during field mapping low-field magnetic susceptibility (AMS), are commonly used
and anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) to measure the preferred orientations of Fe-rich minerals in
measurements. The significance of the data is discussed in granitoids. The magnetic anisotropy methods are particularly
terms of regional tectonic deformation and plate kinematics. useful where the mineral fabrics are difficult to determine in
The data were collected from rocks with well preserved the field, due to poor outcrop conditions or because the shapes
igneous textures and the fabrics therefore formed during of the fabric-defming crystals are only weakly anisotropic.
rnagmatie deformation. The AMS provides measurements of Lineation measurements may be hard to make in the field
the preferred orientations of Fe-rich minerals (biotite 4- because, unless they are strongly deformed, granitoids do not
hornblende 4- traces of pyrrhotite and magnetite) which are develop a fissile schistosity within which the linear fabrics
consistent with field measurements of the mesoscopic fabrics could be viewed. The advantage of using magnetic techniques
defined by plagioclase, biotite and hornblende crystals. The in fabric studies of plutons lies in the fact that precise and
magnetic fabrics are also consistent with the orientations of reproducible foliation and lineation measurements can be
folds, mineral fabrics and boudinage struetures that record obtained for virtually any outcrop in a pluton (Bouchez, 1997).
high-temperature subsolidus deformation in the margin of the Magnetic fabrics yield a maximum of information when they
pluton and in its host rocks. The lineations are parallel to the can be compared with mesoscopic structures within plutons
stretching direction associated with small increments of strain (foliation, banding, schlieren, folds) and with mesoscopic and
that occurred during deformation of the magrnatic arc, as the map-scale structures in the country rocks.
batholith was crystallizing and deforming in the tectonic stress One of the earliest studies to compare the AMS fabrics of
field, ca. 93 Ma. The fabrics in the Mr. Stuart batholith are a granitoid pluton with the structural data from its country
used to infer emplacement in a magmatic arc during either 1) rocks was of the Riesenfemer tonalitic massif in the Italian and
plate displacement perpendicular to a NW-SE trending plate Swiss Alps. The results showed that the K 1principal direction
margin, or 2) wrench dominated transpression. In the second of the magnetic susceptibility (the magnetic lineation) is
case the analysis suggests a nearly N-S plate vector along the parallel to the Alpine fold axes and fabrics in the host terrane,
western North American margin during plutonism. The results leading to the interpretation that the magnetic fabric records a
demonstrate the potential usefulness of magmatic fabrics in N-S Alpine contractional tectonic event that affected the
syntectonic plutons for plate tectonic analyses of orogenic pluton (Henry, 1975). Several subsequent studies in other
belts. © 2001 ElsevierScienceLtd.All rightsreserved tectonic terranes have also shown that the magnetic fabrics in
weakly deformed or undeformed plutons record synmagmatic,
Correspondence to: Keith Benn tectonically induced strains (Archanjo et al., 1994; Bouchez
344 K. Bennet al.: MagmaticFabricsin Batholithsas Markersof RegionalStrains
and Gleizes, 1995; Benn et al., 1997; Gleizes et al., 1997; Benn
et al., 1999; Pignotta and Benn, 1999). In the French Pyrenees,
several studies have proposed that the fabrics in syntectonic
plutons emplaced during Hercynian contraction can be used to
interpret a bulk regional dextral transpression, based on the
oblique orientations of the pluton fabrics with respect to the
orogenic belt and on dextral deflections of the fabrics near the
pluton margins (Leblanc et al., 1996; Gleizes et al., 1997;
Gleizes et al., 1998).
Another example of the application of pluton fabrics to
studying synemplacement tectonics comes from the southern
Slave Province, Canada. There, Berm et al. (1998) suggested )ia
that the pervasive magnetic lineation mapped in the Late
Archean Sparrow pluton indicates the orientations of regional .A.
shortening and stretching directions during a contractional,
possibly transpressive tectonic event. The fabric information
was especially useful since the strain field information could
not be obtained directly from the metamorphic country rocks BS
of the southern Slave Province, which have undergone several
phases of deformation resulting in fold interference patterns m

Fig. 1. Locationmapofthe MountSmartbatholith(MSB)withinthe


and a complicated finite strain picture. CascadesCore,whichis the southernextensionofthe CoastPlutonic
The documentation of tectonic signatures in the magmatic Complex.The CascadesCoreis offsetalongthe TertiaryFraserFault
fabrics of some syntectonically emplaced plutons raises the (FF) - Straight Creek Fault (SCF). IS: Insular Superterrane, IM:
following two important questions. First, can the magmatic IntermontaneSuperterrane.
fabrics in plutons and batholiths, which are often mapped using
magnetic anisotropy techniques, be widely applicable as batholith, which was deformed into an apparent fold during
indicators of regional, synmagmatic deformations? Second, if magma crystallization. Comparisons of the pluton fabrics with
pluton fabrics are related to regional deformations, might they the structures in the country rocks are used to demonstrate
also be used to interpret the kinematics of tectonic plate that the igneous fabrics in the batholith record tectonic
interactions at plate margins, during the period when the deformation of the Mt. Smart magmas as they were emplaced
plutons were emplaced and the magmatic fabrics were frozen and crystallized, and that the magnetic lineation indicates a
in as the plutons solidified? Pluton emplacement and stretching direction parallel to regional fold axes. The results
solidification likely occurs in about about 105 years, and of this study confirm the tectonic significance of the internal
isotopic dating methods allow the crystallization ages of fabrics of the Mt. Smart batholith, and point towards the
plutons to be determined precisely. Therefore, pluton fabrics general usefulness of the magmatic fabrics in plutons for
have the potential to provide a "snapshot" of strain, and terrane analyses. The fabric and structural data from the
possibly of plate kinematics, during a relatively short period batholith and its wall rocks are used to propose constraints on
of orogenic evolution. the kinematics of the plate displacements along the North
To further investigate the tectonic significance of pluton American margin during plutonism, c a . 93 Ma.
fabrics, this contribution presents two fabric data sets (field
and AMS measurements) from the Cretaceous Mt. Stuart
batholith, situated within the Cascades Crystalline Core, 2. Tectonic setting and geology
Washington State. The Cascades Crystalline Core is
considered to be the southern extension of the Coast Plutonic The Mt. Stuart batholith is the largest of the mid-Cretaceous
Complex (Fig. 1), the largest magmatic arc terrane in the plutons within the Cascades Crystalline Core, in Washington
North American Cordillera. The geology of the country rocks State (Fig. 1). The Cascades Crystalline Core is considered to
and of the batholith are well documented providing a be the southern extension of the Coast Plutonic Complex,
framework within which the pluton fabrics may be analyzed. British Columbia (Fig. 1). It is made up of deformed and
Maps of the mesocopic and magnetic foliations and variably metamorphosed Upper Paleozoic to Mesozoic rocks,
lineations are presented for the northern part of the Nit. Stuart including sedimentary and volcanic rocks and ophiolitic slices
K. Benn et al.: Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains 345

[ ' 1 Cenozoic sedimentary


rocks
Mt. Stuart batholith
Tonalite and granodiorite
['7"I Granodiorite
Diorite and gabbro
D Metagabbro and metadiorite
(Big Jim complex)
Country rocks
Chiwaukum schist
Ingalls ophiolite

..t_ Foliation
~ . _ Leavenworth Fault
A Windy PassThrust
~ I Axial surface trace
Fig. 2. Geology of the Mount Smart batholith and its host rocks.

that were accreted to the western North American margin metapelitic and metapsammitic Chiwaukum Schist, and the
during mid-Cretaceous to Paleogene orogenesis (Brown, Ingalls ophiolite complex which overlies the Chiwaukum
1987; Miller et al., 1993). Accretion may have resulted from Schist on a thrust contact (Windy Pass Thrust, Fig. 2). The
the collision of the Insular and Intermontane superterranes, regional metamorphic grade of the country rocks ranges from
resulting in the regional shortening accommodated by the greenschist in the rocks enclosing the mushroom region, to
Northwest Cascades Thrust System and in burial upper amphibolite in the Chiwaukum Schist that hosts the
metamorphism (MeGroder, 1991). Alternative models suggest hook and sill regions (Miller et al., 1993). Aluminum-in-
the Cascades Crystalline Core represents the exhumed roots of hornblende geobarometry on the rocks of the Mr. Smart
a mid-Cretaceous magmatie are built upon previously batholith suggests the depth of emplacement was between 6
amalgamated terranes (Brown and Talbot, 1989; Kriens and and 12 km (Ague and Brandon, 1992; Anderson, 1997).
Wernicke, 1990; Walker and Brown, 1991). The Cretaceous The main phases of the Mt. Stuart batholith consist of
tectonics are recorded in the metamorphic rocks of the biotite (+ hornblende) tonalite and granodiorite with
Cascades Crystalline Core by thrust faults, by upright to metaluminous and marginally peraluminous compositions.
overturned NW-SE trending gently plunging folds and by Trace element signatures suggest an origin within a calc-
pervasive NW-SE trending extension lineations (Brown and alkaline volcanic arc setting (Anderson, 1992; Paterson et al.,
Talbot, 1989; Miller and Paterson, 1992; Miller and Paterson, 1994). The tonalite locally grades into diorite and gabbro in
1994). the southern part of the batholith (Fig. 2). A slightly older
The Mt. Stuart batholith (93 Ma) crops out as two closely (95.5 Ma) mafic unit called the Big Jim complex (Fig. 2) is not
spaced massifs (Fig. 2). The western portion is an elliptical volumetrically significant relative to the main phases of the Mt.
body composed oftonalite and granodiorite. The main body of Stuart batholith.
the Nit. Stuart batholith lies to the east, and has been Previous structural studies of the Mt. Stuart batholith
informally subdivided into the northern "hook", the central documented a foliation and a mineral lineation that are most
narrow NW-SE striking portion referred to as "the sill", and strongly developed near the NE margin of the pluton, where
the southernmost part which is referred to as "the mushroom" they record magmatic deformation and a locally developed
because of its shape in map view. The hook region has been high-temperature subsolidus overprint (Miller and Paterson,
interpreted to be an antiformal fold plunging gently to the 1992; 1994). The magmatic and high-temperature subsolidus
northwest (Paterson et al., 1994; Paterson and Miller, 1998a). fabrics are parallel, and, based on numerous field and
The host rocks of the Mt. Smart batholith consist of the microstructural observations, they are interpreted to record a
346 K. Bennet al.: MagmaticFabricsin Batholithsas Markersof RegionalStrains
continuum in magmatic to subsolidus deformation that
occurred as the batholith crystallized and began to cool from
the solidus. In the hook and the sill, the mesoscopic foliation
generally strikes NW-SE, and at different localities it dips
moderately to steeply either to the NE or to the SW. The
lineation has a shallow plunge, and it is generally parallel to the
axes of magmatic to subsolidus folds documented in the NE
margin of the batholith (Miller and Paterson, 1994). The
foliation, the lineation and the folds within the batholith margin
have orientations similar to tectonic folds and fabrics in the
metamorphic host rocks of the Chiwaukum Schist. The
lineations are also parallel to the direction of the maximum
principal stretch indicated by boudinaged dykes of Mt. Stuart
magmas within the Chiwaukum schist (Miller and Paterson,
1994), and to the NW-SE instantaneous stretching direction
indicated by the preferred orientation of magma-sealed joints
within the batholith (Fig. 18 in Paterson et al., 1994). In the
interior of the hook and sill regions, the foliation and lineation
are of magmatic origin, and they are less intensely expressed
than near the pluton margin.
The magmatic fabrics in the mushroom region of the
batholith define a different pattern from the one observed in Fig. 3. Photomicrographsof (A) the typicaligneoustexturein the
the hook and the sill. We interpret the difference in fabric sampledrocks,and (B) kinkedtwinsin a feldsparcrystal
pattern to be due to the fact that the mushroom region is demonstratingveryminorcrystal-plasticstrain.The long
dimensionof eachphotomicrographis 6 mm.
hosted by greenschist grade ophiolitic peridotites and gabbros
that responded in a less ductile fashion to regional
deformations than the amphibolite grade metasedimentary 1989; Bouchez et al., 1990). They include the preservation of
rocks that host the hook and the sill. Hence in the mushroom well developed crystal faces on early crystallizing minerals
region the magmatic foliations show a concentric pattern such as feldspar, micas and amphiboles, and the lack of
parallel to the pluton margin, suggesting they may record extensive dynamic recrystallization of the minerals. Similar
internal flow of the magmas within an already constructed microstructural criteria are used to identify the presence of
magma chamber (Paterson et al., 1994); the fabrics may have crystallized melt within the leucosomes ofmigmatites (Vernon
been isolated from tectonic stresses by the rigid host rocks. In and Collins, 1988).
this study, we concentrate on the fabrics in the hook and sill Igneous textures are well preserved throughout much of the
regions, which were emplaced within highly ductile country Mr. Stuart batholith (and in all of the studied samples), with
rocks. In those parts of the batholith, the magmatic fabrics only a very weak and locally developed suprasolidus to
have a predominantly tectonic signature, probably due to a subsolidus overprint. Some plagioclase crystals exhibit
small difference in viscosity between the batholith and its concentric igneous zonation, and most have euhedral to
ductile host at the time of fabric formation, which allowed the subhedral crystal habits (Fig. 3A), indicating that the rocks we
magmas to deform with the country rocks. sampled for this study have not been affected by significant
high-temperature subsolidus strain and reerystallization. Some
plagioclase-plagioclase grain boundaries are lobate and
3. Microstructures cnspate suggesting minor plagioclase grain boundary migration
occurred, either during or immediately following the latest
We have studied the magrnatic fabrics that are preserved stages of crystallization. Minor intracrystalline plastic
within rocks with pristine igneous textures, indicating that the deformation is also manifested in a small fraction of the
mineral orientations were frozen into the rocks when they plagioclase crystals by the presence of kinked deformation
solidified and were not subsequently reworked by solid state twins (Fig. 3B). However, since euhedral to subhedral
deformations. The criteria for identifying igneous textures are plagioclase crystal shapes and igneous compositional zonation
well known and have been described in detail (Paterson et al., are well preserved, we interpret that the studied rocks did not
K. Benn et aL: Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains 347

undergo extensive subsolidus strain and recrystallization. principal igneous Fe-rich opaque phase in the Mt. Stuart
batholith is pyrrhotite (Anderson and Paterson, 1991).
Recently acquired data on the remanenee-bearing magnetic
4. AMS method mineralogy in the batholith (S.P.L. and colleagues, work in
progress) suggest that igneous pyrrhotite is the principal
Oriented blocks (and a few oriented drill cores) were collected carrier of the NRM that was acquired during emplacement of
at seventy-five stations in the study area. Oriented drill cores the Mt. Stuart batholith. The data show that the primary NRM
were extracted from the blocks using a specially outfitted drill is carried by pyrrhotite, and that a slightly later NRM is
press at the Geological Survey of Canada, in Ottawa. At least recorded by pyrrhotite and secondary magnetite. Thermal
three drill cores of approximately 7 cm length were obtained demagnetization curves that reveal blocking temperatures of
for each sampling station, and two or more cylindrical 400°C and less, and alternating-field demagnetization spectra
specimens of 10.8 em3 were cut from each core, providing a confirm the presence of pyrrhotite. The ongoing study of
sample of at least 64.8 cm3 for each station. The AMS magnetic mineralogy in the Mt. Smart batholith suggests that
measurements were performed using a Kappabridge KLY-2 magnetite is limited to relatively restricted regions, which
instrument (AGICO, Czech Republic) at the University of might correspond to regions where high oxygen fugacity
Ottawa. The KLY-2 is an a.c. bridge operating at 920 Hz with magmas crystallized, to zones of deuteric alteration that
an internal field intensity of 300 A/m (r.m.s. value). The occurred shortly after emplacement, or in some eases to
magnetic susceptibility is measured along the axis of the pick- anomalously high paleo-pressures resulting from loading of the
up coil with the specimen being placed in fifteen predetermined crust above parts of the batholith shortly following its
orientations. The resulting data allow calculation of the emplacement (Brown and Walker, 1993; Paterson et al.,
orientation of the anisotropy ellipsoid and the values of the 1994).
principal susceptibilities along each of the principal axes (K1> Based on these data, we conclude that the AMS fabrics in
K2> K3). The average AMS ellipsoid was calculated for each the studied sample suite are most likely controlled by a
sampling site using a tensor averaging method (Jelinek, 1978). combined contribution of biotite + hornblende + pyrrhotite at
most of the sampling sites. The orientations of those igneous
minerals should record the strain that affected the batholith as
5. Magnetic mineralogy it crystallized, and locally a very minor component of strain
acquired as the rocks cooled from the solidus (see previous
Determination of the magnetic mineralogy is of critical section on microstructure). Fine-grained secondary magnetite
importance in magnetic fabric studies, since the presence of may also contribute to the AMS signal at some of the sites.
certain minerals may lead to anomalous AMS fabrics that
cannot be related to the petrofabrics of interest in a simple and
straightforward way. Anomalous AMS may occur because the 6. Fabric results
formation of magnetic minerals post-dates (and, therefore,
their orientations may not record) the fabric forming event The mescopic mineral foliation and lineation, and the AMS,
(e.g. magnetite of metamorphic or hydrothermal origin; Benn were mapped throughout the hook and sill regions of the Mt.
et al., 1993), or because the intrinsic anisotropies of some Stuart batholith, which represent a large-scale, shallowly
minerals are anomalous, leading to AMS orientations that do plunging antiformal fold that has also been mapped out in the
not correspond to the shape preferred orientations of the country rocks (Fig. 2). The orientations of the mesoeopic and
igneous minerals (Rochette et al., 1992; Rochette et al., 1994; magnetic fabric elements are compiled on the maps and the
Borradaile and Henry, 1997). It is, of course, critical to be accompanying lower-hemisphere equal-area projections in Fig.
aware of the presence of such minerals in the sample suite 4.
since, in many cases, the AMS is used to measure fabric The poles to the mesoscopic and magnetic foliations define
orientations that could not be routinely verified by other NE-SW point distributions, tending to partial girdles in the
means. equal-area projections (Fig. 4A,C). The average foliation
Petrographic inspection of thin sections reveals that two orientations are parallel to the axial surface traces of the
paramagnetic Fe-bearing silicate phases are present in the NW-SE trending regional folds that have affected the host
studied rocks. Biotite is present in all of the samples and rocks and that gave rise to the outcrop pattern of the hook
hornblende is locally present. Opaque minerals were also region of the Mt. Stuart batholith. Hence the igneous foliation
observed in some samples. Petrological data suggest the within the batholith is consistent with the NW-SE shortening
348 K. Bean et al.: Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains

C:eoelalton:

Fig. 4. Compiled data for the orientations of the magnetic (A,B) and field (C,D) measurements for the hook and sill regions of the Mr. Stuart batholith.

event that is recorded in its host rocks, and it is in essence an similar degree of scatter of the mesoscopic foliation poles (Fig.
axial-planar fabric. 4C), measured in the field, suggests the orientations of the
The magnetic lineations in the batholith trend NW-SE and, magnetic and mesoscopic foliations may be more complicated
on average, the plunge is subhorizontal (Fig. 4B). This at a local scale than is suggested by the compiled
orientation is parallel to the shallowly plunging axes of the measurements for the study area. For instance, small-scale
regional folds, and to the axes of the small-scale folds folding of the magmatic foliation, which is difficult to observe
documented in the margins of the batholith (Miller and in most outcrops, has previously been documented in the
Paterson, 1994). The average orientations of the mesoscopic- Mount Stuart batholith and in other plutons of similar ages in
scale lineations and magnetic lineations are very similar to the the Cascades Core (Paterson et al., 1998). Also, somewhat
pole to the best-fit plane calculated for the magnetic foliation complicated foliation patterns in parts of the Mt. Stuart
poles (compare equal-area projections in Fig. 4A,B). batholith, close to remnants of host rocks that overlie the
Some of the scatter in the orientation distribution of the pluton and in the vicinity of large stoped blocks (Paterson and
magnetic foliation poles might be explained as the effect of Miller, 1998b), may have escaped reworking by tectonic
magnetic mineralogy. For instance, the presence of small deformation of the crystallizing intrusion. It may be that some
amounts of secondary magnetite could result in the of the magnetic and field measurements presented here were
misorientation of the magnetic foliation with respect to the gathered from regions of magmatic folding, or near to
foliation defined by mineral shapes (Benn et al., 1997; Berm et unexposed stoped blocks, or in regions where early-formed
al., 1998; Pignotta and Benn, 1999). On the other hand, a fabrics due to internal convection of the magmas or to
K. Benn et al.: Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains 349

emplacement flow were not entirely overprinted by acquired during the syn-crystaUization deformation that
syncrystallization deformation. The scatter in the magnetic resulted in the present outcrop pattern of the book and sill
lineation orientations may also be in part a mineralogical effect, regions, which are suggestive of an antiformal fold, and in a
but a similar orientation distribution exists for the field pervasive stretching of the crystallizing magmas parallel to the
measurements of the mesoseopic lineation, defined by fold axis. According to the results of Miller and Paterson
plagioclase and hornblende crystals (Fig. 4D). Therefore we (1992) and Miller and Paterson (1994), the deformation of the
cannot rule out the presence of an early-formed igneous batholith was concentrated along its margins once it had fully
mineral lineation, that has not been entirely overprinted by crystallized and begun to cool below the solidus.
subsequent deformation of the crystallizing magmas. Having demonstrated the signature of syn-crystaUization
In summary, a predominant NW-SE striking foliation and regional deformation preserved by the igneous mineral fabrics
a subhorizontal NW-SE trending lineation in the study area are in the Mt. Stuart batholith, we now discuss the usefulness of
well defined in the equal-area projections. They indicate that the data for establishing interpretations of the regional tectonic
a steeply dipping, NW-SE striking foliation and a shallowly picture, c a . 93 Ma. First, it is argued that the predominant
plunging NW-SE trending mineral lineation are prevalent fabrics within the hook and sill regions can be used to infer
throughout the hook and sill regions of the Mr. Stuart shortening and stretching directions over a short period in the
batholith. Those predominant fabric orientations most likely crystallization history of the batholith, such that the data earl
record synerystaUization tectonic deformation of the batholith. be used to approximate the principal axes of a small increment
ofsyn-crystallization strain. Then, we speculate that the fabric
data can be used to infer pluton emplacement in an arc that
7. Discussion was characterized by either 1) plate convergence that was
perpendicular to a NW-SE trending plate boundary, or 2)
The results of this fabric study are consistent with previous wrench dominated transpression due to highly oblique plate
structural and rnicrostructural analyses of the Mt. Stuart convergence. These two proposals are developed by placing
batholith (Miller and Paterson, 1992; 1994). Based on the the fabrics from the Mt. Stuart batholith within the context of
parallelism of magmatic and high-temperature subsolidus previously published structural and plate tectonic studies of the
fabrics within and adjacent to the NE margin of the batholith, region.
those authors suggested a continuum in the deformation of the
granitoids and their host rocks during emplacement. They
showed that, within the high-temperature deformed NE margin 7.1. Igneous fabrics and strains
of the batholith, the mineral and extension lineations are
parallel to 1) the axes of small-scale folds of the igneous fabric The average magnetic lineation trend in Fig. 4B (296 °) is
within the granitoids, 2) the axes of the folded metamorphic perpendicular to the average orientation of numerous
fabrics in the host rocks and 3) a NW-SE stretching direction extensional fractures within the batholith that are sealed by
indicated by boudinaged granitoid dikes within the country late-stage leucogranitic and pegrnatitic dykes. The average
rocks. They also showed the lineations are perpendicular to the pole to the late dykes is 300 ° (from Fig. 18 in Paterson et al.,
average orientation of magma-sealed joints within the 1994). This indicates that the magnetic lineations are parallel
batholith, suggesting the lineations are also parallel to the late to the maximum principal incremental stretching that caused
increments of stretching during solidification of the batholith. the extensional fractures to form during the final stages of
The present study provides an extensive mapping of the solidification of the batholith. The same parallel relationship
igneous fabrics throughout the hook and sill regions of the Mt. between the incremental maximum principal stretching
Stuart batholith. Application of the AMS technique provided direction and magnetic lineations was documented in the
lineation measurements throughout the hook region, where syntectonic South Mountain batholith, Nova Scotia (Benn et
outcrop conditions are generally poor, and confirmed the al., 1997), and it is therefore possible that the relationship
numerous field measurements of the mineral lineation in the sill occurs in other granitoids emplaced within contractional
region where the outcrop conditions are more condusive to orogens.
field mapping. The results in Figs. 4B,D show that the hook The interpretation that the magnetic lineation records an
and sill regions of the Mt. Stuart batholith have an average incremental stretching direction implies either that 1) it formed
magmatic lineation that is parallel to the magmatic and during a progressive pure shear deformation of the
subsolidus fabrics documented within its deformed NE margin. crystallizing magma body, such that the lineation remained
It is interpreted that the fabric patterns shown in Fig. 4 were parallel to the instantaneous stretching axis throughout a finite
350 K Bennet al.: MagmaticFabricsm Batholithsas Markersof RegionalStrains
magmatic strain history (of undetermined duration and North America (Chardon et al., 1999, and references therein).
intensity), or that 2) it records a relatively small increment of The onset of the proposed earlier sinistral transpression is
non-coaxial strain in the magma, such that the lineation was poorly constrained but it would have terminated c a . 106 Ma,
not rotated to any significant degree from the instantaneous whereas the proposed dextral transpressive event would have
stretching axis. Both interpretations are consistent with begun between 106 Ma and 93 Ma ago (Chardon et al., 1999).
detailed studies of the igneous foliation in close proximity to The switch from sinistral to dextral transpression could be
stoped blocks in the Mt. Stuart batholith, that suggest the linked to an anticlockwise rotation (from E to N) of the
magrnatic foliation formed late in the crystallization history relative displacement vector of the Farallon plate between 125
(Paterson and Miller, 1998b). and 75 Ma, or to the formation of the Kula plate during this
The data do not allow us to distinguish whether the period, which had a nearly N-S oriented displacement vector
lineations in the Mt. Smart batholith formed during a with respect to North America (Engebretson et al., 1985). We
progressive pure shear or in response to a small increment of can use the data from the Mt. Stuart batholith to propose some
non-coaxial strain, nor can we determine the magnitude of the further constraints on possible plate kinematics along the part
finite strain recorded by the fabrics. However, the parallelism of the western margin of North America corresponding to the
between the lineations and the average pole to late dykes Cascades Crystalline Core c a . 93 Ma, during the emplacement
allows us to use the average lineation orientation to of the batholith.
approximate the instantaneous stretching axis during the late Kinematic considerations suggest that in large-scale
stages of crystallization of the batholith. In the following orogenic belts such as the Mesozoic to Tertiary western North
section, the fabrics are considered within a plate tectonic American margin, predictable relationships should exist
context, and we speculate they can be used to suggest between relative plate motions, finite strain axes and
emplacement within an arc that was characterized either by 1) instantaneous strain axes (Tikoffand Teyssier, 1994; Teyssier
orthogonal convergence at a NW-SE trending plate boundary, et al., 1995). The theoretical predictions of those authors'
or 2) by highly oblique plate convergence and associated kinematic modelling have been favorably compared to several
wrench-dominated transpression. natural examples of transpressive plate boundary
environments, including Sumatra (Tikoffand Teyssier, 1994),
the San Andreas fault system and the South Island of New
7.2. Plate kinematics Zealand (Teyssier et al., 1995; Yeyssier and Tikoff, 1998) and
the Coast Plutonic Complex in British Columbia (Fossen and
In mid- to late-Cretaceous time, the western margin of the arc Tikoff, 1998).
represented by the Coast Plutonic Complex (Fig. 1) was part In a zone of homogeneous transpression (i.e. diffuse
of a west-verging fold and thrust belt extending from deformation over a broad area without strain partitioning into
Washington State (the Northwest Cascades Thrust System) to transurrent shear zones) a distinction is made between, on the
southern Alaska (Rubin et al., 1990). A kinematically linked one hand, wrench dominated transpression where the
system of east-verging folds and thrusts representing a back- instantaneous stretching axis ( s1 ) makes an angle greater than
thrust system exists along the eastern side of the Coast
35 ° with the zone boundary, and pure shear dominated
Plutonic Complex in southern British Columbia (Rusmore and
transpression where Sl makes an angle less than 35 ° to the
Woodsworth, 1991). A predominant WSW-ENE trend of
extension lineations in the bounding thrusts led to zone boundary (Tikoff and Teyssier, 1994). In wrench
interpretations that the accretionary event involved mainly arc- dominated transpression, g 1, and the maximum finite stretch,
perpedicular crustal shortening (Rubin et al., 1990; Rusmore S l , are both horizontal at low strains, and s 1 becomes
and Woodsworth, 1991).
vertical at higher strains. In pure shear dominated
On the other hand, a compilation of structural patterns and
transpression, both s1 and s1 are predicted to be vertical
geochronology has shown that, within the Coast Plutonic
Complex in British Columbia, orogen parallel displacements throughout the strain history. In the special case oforthogonal
may have been strongly partitioned into a system of steeply convergence at a plate boundary, a pure shear deformation is
dipping shear zones, suggesting a possible transpressive expected with both Sl and s 1 vertical, and the instantaneous
tectonic environment (Chardon et al., 1999). Those authors and finite flattening planes (and, presumably, regional foliation
propose the arc system may have undergone first sinistral, then strikes) parallel to the plate boundary.
dextral transpressional deformations due to oblique Based on these considerations and on our data, we can
convergence of the Farallon and/or Kula plates with respect to construct two plate kinematic models. In the first model, the
K. Benn etal.:MagmaticFabricsin Batholithsas Markersof RegionalStrains 351
bulk homogeneous pure shear, steeply plunging lineations are
A
| expected to develop. The fabrics within the Mt. Smart
batholith and structures, such as boudinaged dykes, in its wall
rocks suggest that S l , and s 1 , were both horizontal at least
during the small increments of strain that they record. The
horizontal lineations preserved in the Mt. Stuart batholith
might be reconciled with the plate kinematic model in Fig. 5A
if vertical crustal thickening resulting from are-perpendicular
shortening in the Cascades Crystalline Core were
accommodated by thrusts in the metamorphic country rocks,
such as the Northwest Cascades Thrust System (McGroder,
Kulaplate p ~ ; ~ i
1991), where NE-S W trending stretching lineations have been
vector " "i
documented. Then, the lineatious in the batholith might
indicate lateral, arc-parallel flow of the crystallizing magmas
induced by the regional shortening.
A second kinematic model calls for emplacement and
crystallization within a ductile crust undergoing wrench
dominated transpression. Fig. 5B presents the schematic
model, assuming a homogeneous transpression. It is
constrained by values of 0, the angle between the maximum
instantaneous stretching axis and the plate boundary, and by (x,
the angle between the relative plate displacement vector and
the plate margin (Tikoff and Teyssier, 1994). For wrench
dominated transpression, 0 should have a value between 35 °
and 45 °, and cx should have a value of 20 ° or less (Tikoff and
Teyssier, 1994). In Fig. 5B, we take Sl to be approximated
by the average trend of the magnetic lineation (296°). To
Fig. 5. Two possibleplatekinematicmodelsfor the NorthAmerican demonstrate the proposed model, a value of 0 = 35 ° (the
marginin the regionof the CascadesCrystallineCore,for the period c a . lowest predicted value for wrench dominated transpression) is
93 Ma. (A) Orthogonalconvergenceof the Farallonor Kulaplate with arbitrarily chosen in Fig. 5B, which suggests a paleo-plate
respectto NorthAmerica.(B) Highlyobliqueconvergenceof the boundary trending 331 ° , similar to the trend of the Coast
Farallon or Kulaplatewithrespectto NorthAmerica,resultingin
Plutonic Complex and of several major regional shear zones
wrenchdominatedtranspression.
within it (Chardon et al., 1999). In Fig. 5B, the maximum
possible angle of 20 ° is chosen for (x, and a plate displacement
Mt. Stuart batholith was emplaced within the mid-crustal parts vector of 351 ° is derived. Note that if a value of 45 ° was
of an arc undergoing NE-SW arc-perpendicular shortening (as chosen for 0, the determined plate boundary trend would be
previously proposed by Paterson and Miller, 1998a). This 341 o, and then the interpreted plate displacement vector would
model, shown schematically in Fig. 5A, would require the plate be oriented 001 °.
margin to be parallel to the predominant fabrics in the Plate reconstructions suggest that between 100 Ma and 75
batholith, that record NE-SW syn-emplacement tectonic Ma, the displacement vector of the Farallon plate with respect
shortening perpendicular to the predominant foliation and to North America underwent a clockwise rotation from about
lineation in the batholith. It would also suggest that the 035 ° to about 028 ° (Engebretson et al., 1985; Kelley and
Cascades Crystalline Core, and the Mt. Stuart batholith, would Engebretson, 1994). During the same period, the Kula plate
have undergone a bulk pure shear deformation. One advantage may have been formed and would have undergone a relative
of this model is that the interpreted plate displacement vector displacement trending about 005 ° (Engebretson et al., 1985).
(Fig. 5A) is similar to the one proposed for the Farallon plate If the plate kinematic analysis in the previous paragraph is
with respect to North America, between 100 and 75 Ma, based correct, it would suggest that at 93 Ma, the relative
on plate reconstructions (Engebretson et al., 1985). A displacement vector for the plate lying outboard of that part of
disadvantage is that kinematic models predict that during a the North American margin corresponding to the Cascades
352 K. Benn et aL" Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains

Crystalline Core would have been trending between 351 o and previous structural and fabric analyses within and adjacent to
001 o. Comparing to the interpretations of Engebretson et al. the Mt. Smart batholith suggests that the magnetic fabrics may
(1985): 1) if the Farallon plate was outboard of the study area record a small increment of finite strain, and that the fabric
during emplacement of the Mt. Stuart batholith, then our orientations can be interpreted to approximate the orientation
analysis would suggest the plate displacement vector may have of the instantaneous strain during the final stages of
undergone a greater rotation than proposed by the plate crystallization. The fabric and structural data have been used
reconstructions, 2) if the Kula plate was outboard of the study to fit the Mt. Stuart batholith, and the Cascades Crystalline
area at that time, then our interpretations suggest a similar Core, into the plate tectonic history along the North American
plate displacement vector to the one indicated by the plate margin, c a . 93 Ma. The results may indicate that the Mt. Stuart
reconstructions, which is 005 ° . Hence our analysis of the batholith was emplaced within part of an arc subjected to NE-
wrench dominated kinematic model, summarized above and in SW shortening, orthogonal to a NW-SE trending plate
Fig. 5B, would be most compatible with a northward boundary. Alternatively, based on considerations of the
displacement of the Kula plate with respect to the southern kinematics of transpressional deformations, the fabrics may
extension of the Coast Plutonic Complex at 93 Ma. indicate a boundary between either the Farallon or Kula plate
The above plate kinematic analyses and the derivations of and North America that had a NNW-SSE trend, and a NNW
possible plate displacement vectors are based mainly on the to N relative displacement vector for the outboard plate at the
fabric and structural analysis of the Mr. Stuart batholith, and time of crystallization of the batholith.
they assume either a homogenous bulk regional pure shear, or The results demonstrate the potential usefulness of igneous
a homogeneous transpression, c a . 93 Ma within the Cascades fabrics and other magrnatic structures in syntectonic plutons
Crystalline Core. Furthermore, the second kinematic model for analyses of regional deformations in orogenic belts, and
(Fig. 5B) excludes partitioning of the transpression into possibly for determinations of plate kinematics associated with
transurrent shear zones (Teyssier et al., 1995). If one or more orogens. An extension of this type of tectonic analysis could
of the major transcurrent shear zones, such as the Coast shear involve mapping the magmatic fabrics in plutons of different
zone, that may have accommodated plate boundary-parallel ages within an orogenic belt, in order to investigate the strain
displacements in the Coast Plutonic Complex in Cretaceous history during succesive short periods corresponding to the
time (Hollister and Andronicos, 1997; Chardon et al., 1999) emplacement and crystallization of the magma bodies. Such
extended as far south as the Cascades Crystalline Core, then future studies may provide information on the incremental
plate boundary-parallel displacements could have been strain histories of orogens.
partitioned into the shear zones during possible Cretaceous
transpression. As a result, the plate boundary would be
constrained to be oriented more closely to the maximum Acknowledgements

instantaneous strain axis ( s 1 ) (Teyssier et al., 1995), i.e. it


The field and laboratory work was funded by Research Grant 105990 awarded
would be rotated clockwise with respect to the plate boundary to K.B. by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada.
indicated in Fig. 5B. However, to our knowledge, no large- K.B. thanks the Geological Survey of Canada - Ottawa for access to the drill
scale transcurrent shear zones of Cretaceous (or earlier) age press in the paleomagnetics laboratory. Comments by two anonymous
reviewers helped improve the paper. Special thanks to the Guest Editors for
have been mapped as far south as the present study area.
their efforts putting this issue together.
Therefore, if a wrench dominated transpression model is
applicable to the Cascades Crystalline Core, then we interpret
Fig. 5B to be a reasonable approximation of plate kinematics References
at the time of emplacement of the Mr. Stuart batholith, based
on the present data set. Ague, J.J. and Brandon, M.T., Tilt and northward offset of Cordilleran
batholiths resolved using igneous barometry, Nature, 360, 146-149, 1992.
Anderson, J.L., Compositional variation within the high-Mg, tonalitic Mount
Stuart batholith, northern Cascades, Washington, Geol. Soc. AmericaAnn.
8. Conclusions
Meeting Abs. 24, A3, 1992.
Anderson, J.L., Regional tilt of the Mount Stuart batholith, Washington,
Magnetic and field measurements of the pervasive magmatic determined using aluminum-in-hornblende barometry - implications for
foliation and lineation in the Cretaceous Mt. Stuart batholith northward translation of Baja British Columbia - Discussion, Geol. Soc.
suggest it underwent a NE-SW shortening and NW-SE America Bull., 109, 1223-1225, 1997.
Anderson, J.L. and Paterson, S.R., Emplacement of the Cretaceous Mt. Stuart
stretching, parallel to regional folds, during emplacement and
batholith, central Cascades, Washington, Geol. Soc America Ann.
solidification c a . 93 Ma. Comparison of the results with
K. Benn et al.: Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains 353

Meeting Abs., 23, A387, 1991. massif tonalitique des Riesenfemer - Vedratte di Ries (Fronti,~'e Italo-
Arehanjo, C.J., Bouchez, J.-L., Corsini, M., and Vauchez, A., The Pombal Autrichienne), Tectonophysies, 27, 155-165, 1975.
granite plnton: magnetic fabric, emplacement and relationships with the Hollister, L.S. and Andronicos, C.L.., A candidate for the Baja British
Brasiliano strike-slip setting ofNE Brasil (Paraiba State),d Struct. Geol., Columbia fault system in the Coast Plutonic Complex, GSA Today, 7, 1-7,
16, 323-335, 1994. 1997.
Benn, K., Ham, N.M., Pignotta, G.S., and Bleeker, W., Emplacement and Jelinek, V., Statistical processing of anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility
deformation of granites during transpression - magnetic fabrics of the measured on groups of specimens, Stud. Geophyz. Geodet., 22, 50-62,
Archean Sparrow pluton, Slave Province, Canada, J. Struct Geol., 20, 1978.
1247-1259, 1998. Kelley, K.P. and Engebretson, D.C., Updated relative motions and terrane
Berm, K., Home, R.J., Kontak, D.J., Pignotta, G., and Evans, N.G., Syn- trajectories for North America and oceanic plates: Cretaceous to present,
Acadian emplacement model for the South Mountain Batholilh, Meguma Geol. So(:. America Ann. Meeting Abs., 26, A-459, 1994.Kriens, B. and
Terrane, Nova Scotia: magnetic fabric and structural analyses. Geol. Soc. Wemicke, B., Characteristics of a continental margin magmatic ate as a
America Bull., 109, 1279-1293, 1997. function of depth: the Skagit-Methow crustal section, in: M.H. Salisbury
Berm, K., Roehette, P., Bouchez, J.L., and Hattori, K., Magnetic and D.M. Fountain (cds), Exposed cross-sections of the continental crust,
susceptibility, magnetic mineralogy and magnetic fabrics in a late Arehean Kluwer Academic Publishers, 159-173, 1990.
granitoid-gneiss belt, Precam. Res.. 63, 59-81, 1993. Leblenc, D., Gleizcs, G., Roux, L., and Bouchez, J.L., Variscan dextral
Berm, K., Roest, W.R., Rochette, P., Evans, N.G., and Pignotta, G.S., transpression in the French Pyrenees: new data from the Pic des Trois-
Geophysical and structural signatures of syntectonic batholith Seigneurs granodiorite and its country rocks, Tectonophysics, 261, 331-
construction: the South Mountain batholith, Megnma Terrane, Nova 345, 1996.
Scotia, Geophys. d. Int., 136, 144-158, 1999. McGroder, M.F., Reconciliation of two-sided thrusting, burial metamorphism,
Borradalle, G.J. and Henry, B., Tectonic applications of magnetic and diachronous uplift in the Cascades of Washington and British
susceptibility and its anisotropy, Earth-Sci. Rev,, 42, 49-93, 1997. Columbia, Geol. Soc. America Bull.. 103, 189-209, 1991.
Bouchez, J.L., Granite is never isotropic: an introduction to AMS studies of Miller, R.B., Brown, E.H., McShane, D.P., and Whitney, D.L., Intra-arc
granitic rocks, in: J.L. Bouchez, D.H.W. Hut'ton,and W.E. Stephens (eds.), loading and its tectonic implications, North Cascades crystalline core,
Granite: from segregation of melt to emplacement fabrics, Kluwer Washington and British Columbia, Geology, 21, 255-258, 1993.
Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 95-112, 1997, Miller, R.B. and Paterson, S.R., Tectonic implications of syn- and post-
Bouehez, J.L. and Gleizes, G., Two-stage deformation of the Mont- emplacement deformation of the Mount Smart batholith for mid-
Louis--Andorra granite pluton (Variscan Pyrenees) inferred from magnetic Cretaceous orogenesis in the North Cascades, Can. J Earth Sci., 29, 479-
susceptibility anisotropy, J. Geol. Soc., London, 152, 669-679, 1995. 485, 1992.
Bouchez, J.L., Gleizes, G., Djouedi, T., and Rochette, P., Microstrueture and Miller, R.B. and Paterson, S.R., The mmsition from magmatic to high-
magnetic susceptibility applied to emplacement kinematics of granites: the temperature solid-state deformation: implications from the Mount Stuart
example of the Foix pluton (French Pyrenees), Tectonophysics, 184, 157- batholith, Washington, J. Struct. Geol., 16, 853-865, 1994.
171, 1990. Paterson, S.R., Fowler, T.K.Jr., Sehmidt, K.L., Yoshinobu, A.S., Yuan, E.S.,
Brown, E.H., Structural geology and accretionary history of the Northwest and Miller, R.B., Interpreting magmatic fabric patterns in plutons, Lithos,
Cascades system, Washington and British Columbia, Geol. Soc America 44, 53-82, 1998.
Bull., 99, 201-214, 1987. Paterson, S.R. and Miller, R.B., Magma emplacement during arc-
Brown, E.H. and Talbot, J.L., Orogen-parallel extension in the North perpendicular shortening - an example from the Cascades Crystalline Core,
Cascades crystalline core, Tectonics, 8, 1105-1114, 1989. Washington, Tectonics, 17, 571-586, 1998a.
Brown, E.H. and Walker, N.W., A magma loading model for Barrovian Paterson, S.R. and Miller, R.B., Stoped blocks in plntons - paleo-plumb bobs,
metamorphism in the southeast Coast Plutonic Complex, British Columbia viscemeters, or chronometers, J. Struct. Geol., 20, 1261-1272, 1998b.
and Washington, Geol. Soc. America Bull., 105, 479-500, 1993. Paterson, S.R., Miller, R.B., Anderson, J.L., Lurid, S., Bendixen, J., Taylor,
Chardon, D., Andronices, C.L., and Hollister, L.S., Large-scale transpressive N., and Fink, T., Emplacement and evolution of the Mount Smart
shear zone patterns and displacements within magmatic ares: the Coast batholith, in: D.A. Swanson and R.A. Hangerud (eds), Geologicfield trips
Plutonic Complex, British Columbia, Tectonics, 18, 278-292, 1999. in the Pacific Northwest, Geol. Soc. America, Boulder, 2F1-2F47, 1994.
Engebretson, D.C., Cox, A., and Gordon, R.G., Relative motions between Paterson, S.R., Vernon, R.H., and Tobisch, O.T., A review of criteria for the
oceanic and continental plates in the Pacific basin, Geol. Soc. America Sp. identification ofmagmatic and tectonic foliations in granitoids, J. Struct.
Paper 206, Boulder, 1985. Geol, 11. 349-363, 1989.
Fossen, H. and Tikoff, B., Extended models oftranspression and transtension, Pignotta, G.S. and Benn, K., Magnetic fabric of the Barrington Passage
and application to tectonic settings, in: R.E. Holdsworth, R.A. Strachan, plnton, Meguma Terrane, Nova Scotia: a two-stage fabric history of
and J.F. Dewey (eds), Continental transpressional and transtensional syntectonic emplacement, Tectonophysics, 307, 75-92, 1999.
tectonics, Geol. Soc. Sp. Pub. 135, Geol. Soc., London, 1998. Rochette, P., Jackson, M., and Aubourg, C., Rock magnetism and the
Gleizes, G., Leblanc, D., and Bouchez, J.L., Variscan granites of the Pyrenees interpretation ofanisotropy of magnetic susceptibility, Rev. Geophys., 30,
revisited: their role as syntectonic markers of the orogen, Terra Nova, 9, 209-226, 1992.
38-41, 1997. Rochatte, P., Scalllet, B., Guillot, S., Le Fort, P., and P~her, A., Magnetic
Gleizes, G., Leblanc, D., Santana, V., Olivier, P., an~l Bouchez, J.L., properties of the High Himalayan ieucogranites: structural implications.
Sigmoidal structures featuring dextral shear during emplacement of the Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 126, 217-234, 1994.
Hercynian granite complex of Canterets-Panticosa (Pyrenees), J. Struct. Rubin, C.M., Saleeby, J.B., Cowan, D.S., Brandon, M.T., and McGroder,
Geol., 20, 1229-1245, 1998. M.F., Regionally extensive mid-Cretaceous west-vergent thrust system in
Henry, B., Microtectonique et anisotropie de susceptibilit~ magn~'tique du the northwestern Cordillera: implications for continent-margin tectonicsm,
354 K Benn et al. : Magmatic Fabrics in Batholiths as Markers of Regional Strains

Geology. 18, 276-280, 1990. continental tectonics, Geology, 23, 447-450, 1995.
Rusmore, M.E. and Woodsworth, G.J., Coast plutonic complex: a mid- Tikoff, B. and Teyssier, C., Strain modeling of displacement-field partitioning
Cretaceous contractional orogen, Geology, 19, 941-944, 1991. in transpressional orogens, ,/. Struct GeoL, 16, 1575-1588, 1994.
Teyssier, C. and Tikoff, B., Strike-slip partitioned transpression of the San Vernon, R.H. and Collins, W.J., Igneous microstructures in migmatites,
Andreas fault system: a lithospheric-scale approach, in: R.E. Holdsworth, Geology, 16, 1126-1129, 1988.
R.A. Strachan, and J.F. Dewey (eds), Continental transpressional and Walker, N.L. and Brown, E.H., Is the Coast Plutonic Complex the result of
transtensional tectonics, Geol. Soc. Sp. Pub. 135, Geol. Sot., London, accretion of the Insular terrane: evidence from geochronometry in
143-158, 1998. Washington Cascades, Geology, 19, 714-717, 1991.
Teyssier, C., Tikoff, B., and Markley, M., Oblique plate motion and

You might also like