Professional Documents
Culture Documents
So You Want To Learn Physics... - Susan Fowler
So You Want To Learn Physics... - Susan Fowler
Introduction
Over the past few years, ever since writing "If Susan Can Learn Physics, So
Can You", I've been contacted by people from all backgrounds who are
inspired and want to learn physics, but don't know where to start, what to
learn, what to read, and how to structure their studies. I've spoken with
single mothers who want to go back to school and study physics, tenured
philosophy professors who want to learn physics so that they can make
significant and informed contributions to philosophy of physics, high
school students who want to know what they should read to prepare for
an undergraduate education in physics, and people in dozens of various
careers who want to really, really learn and understand physics simply for
the joy of it.
This post is a condensed version of what I've sent to people who have
contacted me over the years, outlining what everyone needs to learn in
order to really understand physics.
If you work through the all of the textbooks in the Undergraduate Physics list
of this post, and master each of the topics, you'll have gained the
knowledge equivalent of a Bachelor's Degree in Physics (and will be able to
score well on the Physics GRE). If you work through the graduate core of
the Graduate Physics textbooks, you'll have the equivalent knowledge of
obtaining a Master's Degree in Physics. A PhD in Physics requires the
graduate coursework as well as several years of research and a thesis, and
the experience involved in a PhD isn't something that can be gained
independently of a PhD program.
Remember that anyone can learn physics. It's no different from learning
programming, from learning a musical instrument, from reading great
literature. Whether you turn it into a hobby or a career, the pure joy of
understanding the universe around us is one of the most beautiful
experiences you can ever have in life.
Please comment with your experiences and with any suggestions you have
for improving this list!
One big problem is that a lot of the popular books written about physics
(especially those by famous physicists) are incredibly speculative and tend
to present an unrealistic view of what the study of physics is all about.
When you're learning physics, it's good to avoid these types of speculative
books, and stick to the good ones that talk about the real physics we know
exists.
Mathematical Preliminaries
Before you begin studying physics and working through the topics in the
sections below, you have to be familiar with some basic mathematics. A
high school education usually provides you with enough mathematical
background to begin, and there's no need to be familiar with calculus
before starting (though you'll need to learn when you begin).
How to Study
Everyone learns very differently, and knowing your learning style is
important: do you learn by reading, by taking notes, by talking, by
watching, by doing, or by a combination of some or all of these? Think
about this before you begin so that you'll know how to structure your
studies.
Regardless of your learning style, you'll still need to solve the physics
problems in each textbook. Solving problems is the only way to really
understand how the laws of physics work. There's no way around it. Even
though it can feel tedious at times, there's nothing more rewarding than
figuring out a really difficult physics problem and realizing that you figured
it all out yourself!
Undergraduate Physics
Overview
The undergraduate physics curriculum in every undergraduate physics
program covers the following subjects (along with some electives in
advanced topics), and usually in the following order :
1. Introductory Mechanics
2. Electrostatics
3. Waves and Vibrations
4. Modern Physics
5. Classical Mechanics
6. Electrodynamics
7. Quantum Mechanics
8. Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics
9. Advanced Electives in Physics
I'm going to cover the details of each of these fields below, including the
best textbooks to use and any additional reading you may find helpful in
your journey. I'm also going to give some details about the mathematics
you'll need to learn alongside each topic.
1. Introduction to Mechanics
This is where you'll learn about the physics of electricity and magnetism
(electromagnetism) in static situations (situations where no motion is
involved). Topics covered are: electric charges and electric
fields, magnetism and magnetic fields, Gauss's Law, capacitance, resistance
and conductance, inductance, current, and how circuits work.
Keep working through the calculus textbooks (Thomas and Stewart) while
you work through the basics of electrostatics, but you should finish them
by the time you finish the electromagnetism chapters in University
Physics. You absolutely must understand the basics of calculus before you
move on to the other topics in physics.
By this point, you should have finished the introductory calculus books
and are ready to move on to more advanced mathematics. You should start
working through Zill's Advanced Engineering Mathematics, which is an
amazing introduction to more advanced topics in mathematics (linear
algebra, complex analysis, real analysis, partial differential equations, and
ordinary differential equations). The new edition is pretty great, but the
older edition is just as good (and a lot cheaper!). The topics in this book are
essential for understanding all of the rest of the topics in Undergraduate
Physics - once you master them, you'll know all the math you need to
know to understand undergraduate physics.
4. Modern Physics
The fourth physics class that most undergraduates take is usually called
"Modern Physics", and it's an introduction to topics in physics that will be
taught in greater detail later in the undergraduate physics curriculum. If
you plan to study the advanced topics on their own, it's possible to skip
this area, but covering these topics now in your independent studies will
allow you to grasp the advanced topics that you hear so much about and
that probably got you into physics in the first place! This is where you'll
learn the basics of thermodynamics, relativity, quantum mechanics, atomic
physics, nuclear physics, particle physics, and cosmology.
5. Classical Mechanics
This is where you learn the real heart of classical mechanics, which you
were introduced to in the very first topic (Introduction to Mechanics).
You'll learn the topics in much greater depth, and learn how to use
different mathematical formalisms of classical mechanics (the Lagrangian
formalism and the Hamiltonian formalism) to solve problems in
mechanics.
If you haven't finished working through Zill by now, you should master the
topics in it by the time you finish studying classical mechanics.
6. Electrodynamics
7. Quantum Mechanics
By this point, you're ready to really dive into the fundamentals of quantum
mechanics and its applications - one of the most beautiful, interesting, and
thought-provoking topics in all of physics. You'll learn to see the world at a
completely new level - the quantum level. You'll learn about the wave
function, the Schrodinger equation, perturbation theory, the variational
principle, the WKB Approximation, the adiabatic approximation, and
scattering.
The Best Textbooks to Use
By the time you've finished this topic, you'll have mastered all of the
fundamentals of undergraduate physics!
You can pick and choose what you'd like to learn about based on your
interests. This is the most exciting part: you understand all of the
fundamentals of undergraduate physics, and you can pick up advanced
books in other topics of physics and will be able to understand them! You'll
also be able to read (and understand) some papers on the arXiv, which is
the place that almost all physics research papers are published.
Graduate Physics
Overview
Graduate-level study in physics requires mastery of every topic within the
Undergraduate Physics curriculum as covered above, and can be split into two
categories: (i) the core courses and (ii) specialized coursework. Graduate
students typically take the core courses first, which cover the areas learned
in undergraduate courses but in much greater depth and with far more
mathematical rigor, and then choose more specialized courses depending
on their area of research in physics.
I'll cover each of these in the sections below. (Note: many students are
required to take a course in classical mechanics as part of the graduate core,
but if you've mastered the material in undergraduate classical mechanics
there is no need for this).
2. Graduate Electrodynamics
What It's All About
Now that you have a more solid mathematical background and understand
all of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics, it's time to approach
graduate-level statistical mechanics. You'll revisit the Laws of
Thermodynamics, and then pick up from where you left off in
undergraduate statistical mechanics.
5. General Relativity
← Twenty Books That Shaped My … Kicking off my new site and blog →
Preview P O S T C O M M E N T…
What do you recommend for physics after the standard model? I.e.
Supersymmetry,string theory, GUT's,Quatum Gravity and general
frontier level physics that would get you to the level of
understanding the latest theories and reading the latest papers on
the Arxiv?
Sally 9 months ago · 0 Likes
Dear Susan,
Thank you so very much for taking the considerable time involved
in writing this unique article. A long time ago, I was forced to drop
out of a physics degree course after one year due to mental illness,
which I am glad to say I have now overcome. Although I was never
to become a college graduate, I have retained a life-long love of
physics and have often made many attempts to continue my
learning through self study. These have all been unsuccessful as I
could never find books to bridge the gap from the simplified
freshman texts (which I fully understood) and the more advanced
undergraduate textbooks I was buying. I found the math in these to
be completely inaccessible, so I constantly hit an invisible ceiling as
a result.
Your article is the only one I have ever found that addresses this
phenomenon and I must say that your clear and empathetic writing
style has really inspired me to try again with gusto! Only, this time,
with the right books.
Thank you so much.
Sally
Devon, England
Thank u so much for this!, i just have one question, can you tell me
onw of your bwst mathematical textbooks you know for
undergraduate students ?.
Im about to start my undergraduate career in agust and im very
excited.
Thank u from Mexico :D
Keegs 10 months ago · 0 Likes
Likes
Hi Susan,
I was just wondering if you have a list of homework problems to
work through for each of these books. I don't think I'll have the
time to do all of the problems in the books but if you have for
instance your assigned hw problems for each book that would be
really helpful. Thanks!
Kristen Fowler A year ago · 0 Likes
Thank you for writing such a clear and concise list. I'm hoping to go
back to school and major in Physics, so I'm beginning to brush up on
my math skills by taking courses at a community college before I go
back to a four year program. It's been some time since I was in
school, and since then I've developed a love of the subject. At times,
though I'm excited by the idea of maybe one day working in this
field, it can seem very overwhelming; so I'm grateful for this clear
layout and general advice you've given out. Running into things like
this helps keep me inspired. I was also pleased to find some things
I'm already familiar with, at least in the popular reading list. The
Feynman Lectures absolutely live up to the high regard in which
they're held, in my opinion. What I found fascinating about those is
that when you read about what happened sort of behind the scenes
when he was giving those lectures, it seems he was so worried the
whole time that he wasn't doing a good job. Anyway, thanks again!
You lead off with your first book at Feynman? Magnificent. I spotted
those on my first professors bookshelf, and read them all at least
three times in 4 years. Its their approach. ( Yes. I spent at least 70
hours a week in the Library for more than 8 years ). I have since
read every book about Feynman.
After two weeks in class, I noticed that the questions I asked at the
end of class, the professor would snicker a bit... ( He later admitted
to seeing someone who went from a slacker to very hard working
student ). I was also using a prodigious amount of paper, amost two
reams a semister. I noticed someone who was only doing 1/2 the
problems doing as well as I was. "How do you do it?" His answer: "I
have aready taken this class twice before, I just need to refresh my
memory ..."
From failing, I went to being the absolute speed king. I could spot
mistakes made by the professor. I studied at a normal speed, and
worked the problems and worked the problems, and worked the
problems. I switched colleges to take even a harder math program. (
it was a bit more work a week ), but I was able to excel rather
quickly.
I got a 'B' on my second test, and for the next two years, I got A
after A after A. I could finish most tests in under 20 mins. ( well, I
had done problems similar, in the book, very many times. ). I made
minor mistakes, and learned from every one.
I took every Math and Physics class my college offered. Only a few
fellow students were bold enough to ask: "How is it that you are so
very fast?" and my answer was always the same: "I have two simple
ways: practice, and reworking my tests. I do every single problem in
the book, every single problem."
There are lots of facts that can be learned in physics, but if the basics
aren't understood you end up with the insane situation where 100s
of smart physicists have wasted their time doing String Theory
PhDs, despite the fact no connection has ever been made between
String Theory and reality. All desperate to find the TOE, but
forgetting to check in with reality every now and then.
"tenured philosophy professors who want to learn physics so that
they can make significant and informed contributions to philosophy
of physics"
Where a "philosopher of physics" is someone who doesn't understand
enough physics to be a physicist. If, for example, an accepted
interpretation of quantum mechanics is found, it will be found by a
physicist not a "philosopher of physics". Someone who only has 1/10
of the information is unlikely to do better than someone with all
the information. It is the ultimate irony that "philosopher" means
lover of wisdom.
"but be aware that mastery of QFT will take a very, very long time" -
-- according to you.
A question for you, How do you manage to read 52 book a year? And
How do you keep yourself updated with technological advancements
and learn those technologies along with your extra reading,
bloggings.
Thank you very much for this thorough list of courses in Physics. I
can very well see what the next four years of my life look like on
this blog.
Likes
2. One thing I find a little missing from the text list and
discussion is comments about what books have answers. I find
that any study, but especially self study requires large amounts
of drill. Having the answer to check is useful pyschologically
(video game reward of right answer). Also, it helps push for
care (catch math mistakes). And sometimes, can be helpful in
finding where you went wrong. [Think perhaps the list should
be more slanted to texts with solutions.]
Fantastic advice! Thank you for the detailed list. This is just great.
I've used both Young and Freedman and Resnick and found
Young and Freedman infinitely easier to understand. Resnick
sometimes skips steps that seem "obvious" but can trip you up
if you don't have a teacher to point them out. I've had a
teacher describe Young and Freedman as "the book you use to
learn at home, in spite of your teacher". Resnick has some
really good problems, though, so I would recommend getting
the theory from Young and working on the problems from
Resnick. If you can solve all the problems in Resnick you have
a solid grasp on the subject.
Susan Fowler 2 years ago · 0 Likes
Dear Susan,
Thanks for this, Susan. You and your readers might also be
interested in a student-focused text on General Relativity, which has
a second edition now freely available for download. Exploring Black
Holes is a highly accessible but rigorous text that describes the
physics of non-spinning and spinning black holes in plain language
and lots of support. Written by Oersted Medal winner Edwin Taylor
and foremost relativist John Archibald Wheeler, with second-edition
updates from Taylor and Edmund Bertschinger. Check it out:
http://www.exploringblackholes.com/
Thanks
Susan Fowler 2 years ago · 0 Likes
Fuck you. Whiny bitch. Omg someone wants to have sex with me.
Likes
Found it?
Fred 2 years ago · 0 Likes
Hallo Susan thank you very much for these informations . I have
one question you are talking here from bachelor to master if I
understood right.but my question is what and where should I start
before because I want to start physic at the university but I'm sure
that I will not understand anything knowing that my bachelor was
in literature and humain science and my bachelor is on political
science.i need a structure of the study before I'm very interested in
physic string quantum theory and very interested in physic thanks
Hallo Susan thank you very much for these informations . I have
one question you are talking here from bachelor to master if I
understood right.but my question is what and where should I start
before because I want to start physic at the university but I'm sure
that I will not understand anything knowing that my bachelor was
in literature and humain science and my bachelor is on political
science.i need a structure of the study before I'm very interested in
physic string quantum theory and very interested in physic thanks.
Thank you very much for this list ma'am. I have Schroeder's
Thermal Physics (req. for class), but don't really care for it at all so I
went searching for something else. I have most of what's on this list
at the undergraduate level (and have heard great things about all of
your grad recommendations) so I had a good feeling about your
thermo/stat mech recommendation, but nobody else on forums or
Quora was talking about that book. Today I looked at about 6 or 7
stat mech/ thermo books around the campus and Bowley/Sanchez is
what I'll be going with. I almost went with Blundell, but I really
wanted a book with answers. Thanks again.
Al leong 3 years ago · 0 Likes
Subscribe
SIGN UP TO RECEIVE PERIODICAL UPDATES FROM SUSAN
FOWLER