Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chigusa 2021
Chigusa 2021
To cite this article: Yoshitsugu Chigusa, Haruta Mogami, Sachiko Minamiguchi, Aki Kido, Ayami
Ishida, Yasuhisa Kurata, Eriko Yasuda, Kaoru Kawasaki, Akihito Horie, Ken Yamaguchi, Masaki
Mandai & Eiji Kondoh (2021): Chronic abruption-oligohydramnios sequence (CAOS) revisited:
possible implication of premature rupture of membranes, The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal
Medicine, DOI: 10.1080/14767058.2021.1929159
Article views: 48
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Introduction and indeed, in the last two decades, there has been
no significant progress in research on or understand-
In 1998, Elliott et al. published the concept of chronic
ing of this disease. One of the reasons for this might
abruption-oligohydramnios sequence (CAOS) for the
be the ambiguous and cryptic diagnostic criteria: vagi-
first time [1]. This disease concept canonically consists
nal bleeding without a source and amniotic fluid
of the following triad: (1) clinically significant vaginal
decreases in the absence of rupture of membranes.
bleeding in the absence of an identifiable source of
Moreover, there are no objective standards for diagno-
bleeding; (2) amniotic fluid volume initially docu- sis on imaging inspection or using pathological evi-
mented as normal; and (3) oligohydramnios eventually dence. The aim of this study, therefore, is to
developing without concurrent evidence of ruptured reconsider and clarify the true pathology of CAOS by
membranes [1]. Since then, the existence of this integrating clinical, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
sequence has been clinically realized, and the concept and histopathological findings.
has been widely accepted. Moreover, accumulating
evidence has revealed very poor pregnancy and fetal
outcomes in patients with CAOS [1–3].
Materials and methods
Despite being the pressing issue, the nature and We retrospectively reviewed patients with CAOS man-
pathophysiology of CAOS have remained enigmatic, aged at Kyoto University Hospital from January 2010
CONTACT Yoshitsugu Chigusa chigusa@kuhp.kyoto-u.ac.jp Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Kyoto University, 54 Shogoin Kawahara-cho,
Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-8507, Japan
ß 2021 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
2 Y. CHIGUSA ET AL.
GA: gestational age, SCH: subchorionic hematoma, DCH: diffuse chorioamniotic hemosiderosis, CAM: chorioamnionitis, BW: birth weight, P: primipara, M: multipara, R: ritodrine, Mg: magnesium sulfate 17 P:17-
a-hydroxyprogesterone caproate, Nif: nifedipine, CS: cesarean section, VD: vaginal delivery, PDA: patent ductus arteriosus, IVH: intraventricular hemorrhage, CLD: chronic lung disease, PPHN: persistent pulmonary
to March 2020. The diagnosis was in principle based
Neonatal outcomes
reviewed, and clinical data were extracted, including
Retinopathy of prematurity
IVH, death at one day old
and at delivery, mode of delivery, and ultrasound,
Normal development
Normal development
Normal development
Normal development
MRI, and placental pathological findings. Generally,
placental hematoma consists of marginal hematoma,
subchorionic thrombus, subamniotic hematoma,
CLD, IVH
hematoma extending outside of the placenta, and
Death
retroplacental hematoma. In assessing the intrauter-
CLD
CLD
CLD
ine hematoma by ultrasound, we did not distinguish
Apgar
them except retroplacental hematoma but defined
5
4
7
7
6
4
5
5
6
1
0
7
5
6
4
8
7
7
2,
1,
6,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
2,
1,
0,
6,
3,
5,
1,
6,
2,
5,
them collectively as a subchorionic hematoma. For
MRI findings, two board-certified radiologists (AK and
578
562
948
1140
839
721
684
716
1788
672
365
626
643
809
667
1178
1891
706
BW
YK) evaluated the following MRI findings independ-
ently: hemorrhagic amniotic fluid; marginal hema-
Amniotic necrosis
toma; subchorionic thrombus or subamniotic
hematoma; hematoma extending outside the pla-
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
–
centa; hematoma in the cervix; and retroplacental
hematoma. If the evaluation differed between the
readers, then they discussed the findings and reached
CAM
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
–
–
–
–
–
–
a consensus. For pathological findings, two patholo-
gists (SM and AI) and one obstetrician (EY) independ-
DCH
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
ently reviewed and evaluated macroscopic pictures of
placenta and membranes, hematoxylin and eosin
SCH
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
þ
slides, and Berlin blue staining slides. If the evaluation
differed between them, then they discussed the find-
Mode of delivery
VD
VD
VD
VD
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
CS
Apgar scores, morbidity and mortality.
This study was approved by the ethics committee
of Kyoto University (Registration number: R2276).
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg, 17 P, Nif
Mg,17 P, Nif
Treatment
Mg, 17 P
Mg, 17 P
Mg, 17 P
Mg, 17 P
Mg, 17 P
Mg, 17 P
Mg, 17 P
Mg, Nif
Results
Mg
Mg
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
M
M
M
M
P
P
P
P
gestational age at the diagnosis of CAOS was 22 retroplacental hematoma was not detected, although
(19–26) weeks of gestation (median and range). All a marginal hematoma was delivered in some cases
patients presented with uterine contraction, and toco- (Figure 2(a,b)). Both placenta and membranes were
lytic agents such as ritodrine, magnesium sulfate and stained brown, and membranes were extremely fragile
nifedipine, and 17-a-hydroxyprogesterone caproate and ragged in all cases (Figure 2(a,c)). Representative
were required. Nevertheless, 17 (94%) cases resulted in histological findings of fetal membranes are also
preterm birth: the gestational age at delivery was 25 shown Table 2 (e and f represent case 6, g and h rep-
(22–37) weeks of gestation (median and range). resent case 4, i represents case 7, and j represents
Although there was no definite evidence of rupture of case 15). Shedding and necrosis of the amniotic epi-
membranes on admission, oligohydramnios eventually thelium was a very characteristic finding, which was
developed in all cases. In terms of neonatal outcomes, confirmed in 17 of 18 cases (94%) (Figure 2(e,i,j),
3 neonates (17%) died within two years, and 10 neo- arrowheads). Macrophages containing brown pigment
nates (56%) developed chronic lung disease (CLD). were observed on the chorioamniotic plate (Figure
Other diseases due to prematurity, such as sepsis or 2(g)). Prominent blue staining in macrophages on
retinopathy, were also detected. Berlin blue staining was observed at the chorioamni-
Next, we analyzed the MRI findings in these cases. otic plate, indicating hemosiderin deposition (Figure
Among the 18 cases, MRI was performed in 13 cases. 2(f,h), arrows). These findings indicate diffuse chorionic
Figure 1 shows three representative cases: A and B hemosiderosis (DCH), and in all our cases, DCH was
represent case 8 at 21 weeks and 6 days of gestation, detected. Pathological chorioamnionitis was detected
C and D represent case 16 at 27 weeks and 1 day of in 9 (50%) cases.
gestation, and E and F represent case 18 at 23 weeks
and 4 days of gestation, respectively. Oligohydramnios
Discussion
was apparent on sagittal T2-weighted imaging (T2WI)
(Figure 1(a,c,e)). The signal intensity of the amniotic To the best of our knowledge, this is the second larg-
fluid on sagittal fat-saturated T1WI was relatively high est retrospective case series of patients with CAOS
compared with that of urine in the bladder, indicating meeting classical Elliott’s triad. Our data remind us of
hemorrhagic amniotic fluid (Figure 1(b,d,e), asterisks). the adverse perinatal outcome of CAOS, despite the
The portions of low signal intensity on the margins of development of perinatal care. Elliott et al. retrospect-
the placenta on T2WI (Figure 1(a), circle) showed high ively reviewed 14 cases of CAOS and reported that the
signal intensity on fat-saturated T1WI, suggesting mar- mean gestational age at delivery was 26.1 weeks, with
ginal hematomas (Figure 1(b), circle). Similar areas of neonatal mortality occurring in 6 (43%) cases [1]. In
low signal intensity on T2WI that showed high signal another case series including 15 patients with CAOS,
intensity on fat-saturated T1WI were detected on the the mean gestational age at delivery was 25.7 weeks,
surface of the placenta (Figure 1(c,d), arrowheads). with neonatal mortality occurring in 4 (26.7%) cases
These were subamniotic hematomas. The hematomas and CLD occurring in 11 (73.3%) cases [2]. In the cur-
were very widespread in some cases, even extending rent study, the rate of neonatal mortality (17%) and
outside of the placenta (Figure 1(e), dotted lines). The the incidence of CLD (56%) slightly improved, but the
area of high signal intensity lining the muscle layer of gestational age at delivery was almost the same as
the uterus suggested that bleeding extended outside that in previous studies. Thus, the neonatal morbidity
of the fetal membranes (Figure 1(d,f), arrows). The rate due to prematurity is very high. In addition, in
area of high signal intensity in the uterine cervix preterm infants delivered from mothers with CAOS,
showed that blood from the subchorionic hematoma neonatal lung injury due to the aspiration of hemor-
was about to be expelled from the uterus (Figure rhagic amniotic fluid might contribute to a severe
1(d)). Table 2 lists the specific MRI findings in these 13 prognosis. Indeed, intrapulmonary blood induced a
cases. Intrauterine hematoma was observed in all macrophage-dominated inflammatory response in an
cases; however, retroplacental hematoma was not animal model [4]. Previously, we reported that the
detected on MRI in our cases. concentrations of iron lactose dehydrogenase (LDH)
Finally, pathological findings of the placenta and and 8-hydroxy-20 -deoxyguanosine (8-OHdG), a marker
membranes were reviewed in all cases. Representative of oxidative DNA damage, in the uterine cavity in
macroscopic images of placenta and fetal membranes CAOS were high, and repeated amnioinfusion signifi-
are shown in Figure 2 (a and b represent case 7, and cantly diluted them and contributed to a favorable
c and d represent case 14). In all cases, a
neonatal prognosis [5].
4 Y. CHIGUSA ET AL.
Figure 1. Pelvic magnetic resonance imaging of three representative cases. The left panels are the results of sagittal T2-weighed
imaging (T2WI), and the right panels are the results of sagittal fat-saturated T1-weighted imaging (T1WI). (a,b) Case 8. The areas
of low signal intensity on the margins of the placenta on T2WI show high signal intensity on fat-saturated T1WI, suggesting mar-
ginal hematomas (circle). (c,d) Case 16. An area of low signal intensity on T2WI, which shows high signal intensity on fat-saturated
T1WI, is detected on the surface of the placenta (arrowheads). These are subamniotic hematomas. (e,f) Case 18. Hematoma
extends outside of the placenta (dotted lines). This hematoma is likely derived from a marginal hematoma. The area of high signal
intensity lining the muscle layer of the uterus suggests that bleeding extends outside of the fetal membranes (arrows). The signal
intensity of the amniotic fluid on sagittal fat-saturated T1WI is relatively high compared with that of urine in the bladder, indicat-
ing hemorrhagic amniotic fluid (b, d and e, asterisks). The high signal intensity in the uterine cervix shows that blood from the
subchorionic hematoma is about to be expelled from the uterus (d).
Our study revealed that MRI findings of the pla- cases other than our previous report of three cases
centa and intrauterine cavity are very useful for the [6]. Elliott et al. described “vaginal bleeding in the
objective understanding of the pathology of CAOS. To absence of placenta previa or other identifiable source
date, no studies have examined MRI findings in CAOS of bleeding” [1]. However, in all of our cases,
THE JOURNAL OF MATERNAL-FETAL & NEONATAL MEDICINE 5
Table 2. MRI findings of 13 cases. might lead to the disruption of the balance of the
n (%) amniotic fluid volume [9]. Importantly, both DCH and
Hemorrhagic amniotic fluid 12 (92) amniotic necrosis are not diseases but pathological
Marginal hematoma 13 (100)
Subchorionic thrombus or subamniotic hematoma 10 (77) features, and we believe that these features are patho-
Hematoma extending outside the placenta 13 (100) logical evidence for an objective diagnosis of CAOS.
Hematoma in the cervix 12 (92)
Retroplacental hematoma 0 (0) Our clinical data and pathological analysis strongly
MRI: Magnetic resonance imaging. indicate that CAOS is a special form of preterm PROM.
Previously, we elucidated the precise mechanism by
subchorionic hematomas were observed using ultra- which intrauterine bleeding during pregnancy causes
sound or MRI. In particular, the area of high signal PROM and preterm labor [10–12]. According to our
intensity of the placental marginal hematoma separat- basic medical research, thrombin generated by blood
ing the peripheral placenta with extensive spreading clotting releases fetal fibronectin, a clinical marker of
along the uterine wall on fat-saturated T1WI strongly preterm labor, from amniotic epithelial cells. Fetal
suggested that the hemorrhage was derived not from fibronectin is a potent ligand of Toll-like receptor 4
an unidentifiable source but from a subchorionic (TLR4) and activates TLR4 on amnion mesenchymal
hematoma. Furthermore, the relatively high signal cells. TLR4 activation results in the induction of cyclo-
intensity of the decreased amniotic fluid on T1WI oxygenase 2, prostaglandin E2, inflammatory cytokines
could help to distinguish the hemorrhagic amniotic and matrix metalloproteinases, leading to cervical rip-
fluid of CAOS from oligohydramnios due to other ening, uterine contraction, and collagen degradation.
causes. Consequently, MRI findings reliably reflect the Furthermore, thrombin directly degrades collagen.
clinicopathological findings of CAOS, such as subchor- Finally, PROM and preterm labor are caused. In all of
ionic hematoma and hemorrhagic amniotic fluid, and our cases, the fetal membranes were fragile and rag-
are valuable for the objective diagnosis of CAOS.
ged. When this information is combined with our
Our present study provides histopathological sup-
basic findings, it is quite reasonable to assume that
port for CAOS: DCH and amniotic necrosis. First, DCH
minor rupture of membranes occurred, thereby even-
is diffuse iron-stain-positive pigment deposition in the
tually causing oligohydramnios in CAOS.
chorioamniotic layers of fetal membranes, and this
This study was limited due to its retrospective
histological feature was reported by Redline et al. [7]
nature and the small number of patients. Although we
the year after Elliott et al. announced CAOS.
shed light on one part of the pathogenic mechanism
Appropriately, Redline et al. described DCH as the
of CAOS and objective diagnostic findings, the funda-
pathological correlate of CAOS [7]. Ohyama et al. ana-
mental cause of intrauterine bleeding in the 1st trimes-
lyzed the neonatal morbidity and mortality rates
ter has yet to be elucidated. Moreover, effective
among 46 cases of DCH and reported that the mean
management and treatment strategies for CAOS
gestational age was 27 weeks, with neonatal mortality
and CLD occurring in 6 (15%) and 18 (51%) patients, remain unclear.
respectively [3]. These outcomes are very similar to
those of CAOS, and in fact, 26 cases of CAOS were Conclusion
included in their study. Second, amniotic necrosis is a
prominent feature of CAOS, and it might have close Our clinical observations, imaging findings, and patho-
relevance to DCH. Ohyama reported amniotic necrosis logical evidence call for a drastic change in our under-
in 29 cases (63%) among 46 cases of DCH [3], and standing of the pathology of CAOS. The fundamental
another study showed a similar incidence: 10 cases cause of this disease is intrauterine hemorrhage and
(63%) among 16 cases of DCH [8]. In the present subsequent subchorionic hematoma, which induces
study, amniotic necrosis was observed in 17 of 18 hemorrhagic amniotic fluid. These lesions show high
cases (94%), and in the remaining 1 case, thinning of signal intensity on T1WI and cause the diffusion of
the amniotic membrane was confirmed. These findings chorioamniotic hemosiderosis. Consequently, these
are strongly associated with weakening of the fetal factors that start with H result in the necrosis and
membrane and PROM. Recently, Iizuka et al. revealed weakening of the amnion. Oligohydramnios is the
that the severity of DCH correlated with amniotic ultimate phenotype and not a diagnostic criterion.
necrosis and that amniotic epithelial cells were posi- Therefore, the true pathology of CAOS is PROM rather
tive for 8-OHdG in cases of DCH [9]. Based on these than chronic abruption, and we propose a new desig-
observations, they speculated that amniotic necrosis nation “H-induced RROM: Hi RPOM”.
6 Y. CHIGUSA ET AL.
Figure 2. Macroscopic and microscopic findings of placentas and fetal membranes. (a,b) Case 7. (c,d) Case 14. Both the placenta
and membranes were stained brown, and the membranes were extremely fragile and ragged. A marginal hematoma was deliv-
ered (a and b). (e) Case 6. Shedding and necrosis of the amniotic epithelium were observed (arrowheads). Hematoxylin and eosin
(H&E) staining, x400. (f) Case 6. Blue staining in macrophages is observed at the chorioamniotic plate, indicating hemosiderin
deposition (arrows). Berlin blue staining, 400. (g) Case 4. Macrophages containing brown pigment are observed at the cho-
rioamniotic plate. H&E staining, x200. (h) Case 4. The same portion shows prominent blue staining (arrows). Berlin blue staining,
x200. (i) Case 7. Amniotic epithelial cells are shedding or necrotic (arrowheads). H&E staining, x400 (x100 in the box). (j) Case 15.
Amniotic necrosis is prominent. H&E staining, x400.
THE JOURNAL OF MATERNAL-FETAL & NEONATAL MEDICINE 7