STAR 110x110x8

Please furnish framing arrangement at this

level and all the beam shall be shown in
STAR 110x110x8 section also.

Does not match with your reply in compliance sheet

 Bottom chord of truss

100x100x6
Section shall be complete with truss at top

100x100x6

110 x 110 x 8

Does not match your reply in compliance sheet.

100x100x6

100x100x6

100x100x6 100x100x6
 50 thk

200 225

225 225
TYP.

50 thk

225 225
200 225
25
 COMPLIANCE SHEET 
COMPLIANCE SHEET OF COMMENTS OF PERMANENT STORE (HEAVY & LIGHT FOR DRAWING NO.
PE-DG-412-608-C004, C006 & C012 & DOCUMENT NO. PE-DC-412-608-C001, C002, C003 ON REVISION-
1 AS PER Lr.No.SE/C/TP/E3/AEE/Ennore SEZTPP/F.Store building/D. 947 /17, dt. 29 .08.2017

Comments on the document PE-DC-412-608-C001, PE-DC-412-608-C002 & PE-DC-412-

608-C003 :

1. Crane load shall be considered along with wind load. Modify load combination accordingly.
BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated. Full lifting load of crane considered along with wind
load in load combinations.

2. Refer comment marked on the document.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

Comments on the document PE-DG-412-608-C004:

1. Crane load shall be considered along with wind load. Modify load combination accordingly.
BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated. Full lifting load of crane considered along with wind
load in load combinations.

2. Load from secondary beam not considered while designing PB2. Please check. Furnish
deflection check.
BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

Comments on the document PE-DG-412-608-C006:

1. 65X65X6 TYP. shall be replaced with 75X75X8 TYP.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.90x90x8 provided as per STAAD analysis.

2. ALL BOTTOM CHORD CROSS BRACING SHALL BE DOUBLE ANGLE 100X100X6 TYP.

BHEL REPLY: BOTTOM CHORD CROSS BRACING provided is 75x75x6 with one angle
up & one angle down which is safe in design. Bottom chord bracing member is not
fouling with gusset plate and also sufficient clearance is with DSL of crane
(i.e. more than100mm below EL 8.5m(Bottom of Roof Truss). Also confirmation of the
same is taken from mechanical deptt (as attached). Also the same issue discussed with
DESEIN in ERM dated 30/31.08.17.

3. FURNISH SEPERATE PLAN FOR BASE PLATE.(BP-1)

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

 PROJECT: 2X660MW ENNORE SEZ                                                     
 
PE‐DC‐412‐608‐C002‐PERMANENT STORE‐FOUNDATION DESIGN 

4. UPTO STIFFNER HEIGHT PROVIDE COMMON PLATE

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

5. PLAN & SECTION DOESNOT MATCHING, PLEASE CHECK.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

6. Furnish plan at EL (+) 3.865 m

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

7. REPLACE 90X90X6 double angle with 100100X100X6 double angle

BHEL REPLY: Noted. 90X90X6 double angle is safe with sufficient margin.

8. SHOW CONNECTION OF MONORAIL WITH COLUMN.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

9. PLEASE REVIEW.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & corrected.

Comments on the document PE-DG-412-608-C012:

10. Provide double angle 90X90X6

BHEL REPLY: Top CHORD CROSS BRACING provided with one angle up & one angle
down which is safe in design.

2
 PROJECT: 2X660MW ENNORE SEZ                                                     
 
PE‐DC‐412‐608‐C002‐PERMANENT STORE‐FOUNDATION DESIGN 

11. BRACING MEMBER S HALL BE DESIGNED F OR AXIAL LOAD & M OMENT DUE TO SELF
WEIGHT. REMOVE TRUSS COMMAND.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

12. KZ PARAMETER GIVEN IN STAAD FILE NOT IN ORDER.

BHEL REPLY: Top CHORD CROSS BRACING provided with one angle up & one angle
down. So KZ parameter is OK.

13. DRAW ON SCALE,

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated.

14. DETAIL NOT ORDER.

BHEL REPLY: Noted & incorporated. Detail corrected.

3
10/30/2017 Zimbra: Inbox (7)

Search AKSHAY KAPOOR - PEM  

 
 

Mail Contacts Calendar Tasks Briefcase Preferences FW: 2x660 MW En FW: 2x660 MW En ENNORE SE
Close Reply Reply to All Forward Archive Delete Spam Actions   View

ENNORE SEZ; PERMANENT STORE

From: BHAVNA SHARMA, PEM

To: AKSHAY KAPOOR - PEM

Cc: PANKAJ KAPSIMAY, PEM SOMNATH MISHRA, PEM ANAND NARAYAN, PEM

PE-DG-412-608-C…URE_DETAIL . 7.pdf (131.3 KB) Download | Briefcase | Remove PE-DG-412-608-C…URE_DETAIL . 8.pdf (117.8 KB) Download | Briefcase | Remove
Download all attachments
Remove all attachments

Dear Sir

As discussed, min 125mm clear gap shall be provided from top of DSL support bracket to bo om of roof truss for SG crane in store for subject project.

Thanks & Regards

BHAVNA SHARMA
SR ENGINEER, MAUX DEPTT.
PS-PEM, BHEL
Direct Ph No: 0120-4368567
Mobile No: +91-9810741096

My mail address has been changed to bhavnasharma@bhel.in

Show quoted text  -  Reply  -  Reply to All  -  Forward  -  More Actions

From: AKSHAY KAPOOR - PEM

To: BHAVNA SHARMA, PEM

Cc: PANKAJ KAPSIMAY, PEM SOMNATH MISHRA, PEM ANAND NARAYAN, PEM

  PE-DG-412-608-C…URE_DETAIL . 7.pdf (131.3 KB) Download | Briefcase | Remove PE-DG-412-608-C…URE_DETAIL . 8.pdf (117.8 KB) Download | Briefcase | Remove
Download all attachments
Remove all attachments

Dear Sir
Please ensure the minimum clearance between DSL line & bottom of Roof truss EL 8.5m as depicted in attached files (CCD of light &
Regards
Akshay Kapoor

https://mail.bhel.in/#8 1/1
 1 2 3 4 5 6

A A

B B

C C

D D

1 2 3 4 5 6
 1 2 3 4 5 6

A A

B B

C C

D D

1 2 3 4 5 6