Professional Documents
Culture Documents
USdsdasdsdsd
USdsdasdsdsd
F.G. 1
TARCH SLURRY
NaSO (15% starch db) STARCH SLU
(30-45% solids)
NaOH (1% starch db)
Propylene oxide (6-10% starch db)
HYDROxYPROPYLATION | 40°C
0
HSO/HCI
pH adjustment
!
WASH / DRY
CH,OH CH,OH CH,OH CHOH
K. K. + CH-CH-CH, pH ll K). K. O
CH-CH-CH,
OH
U.S. Patent Jun. 30, 2015 Sheet 2 of 3 US 9,068,022 B1
FG. 2
HYDROXYPROPYLATION | 40°C
"h
HCI o.
(pH adjustment)
DRY + Sodium free salts
e.g., NHCl, KC,
CHOH CH, OH CHOH CHOH
'O O O-
+ CH-CH-CH,
Y O 1.
pH > 1 O O O.
O
CH-CH-CH,
OH
U.S. Patent Jun. 30, 2015 Sheet 3 of 3 US 9,068,022 B1
(O) enteedu.e.
C O C
g
S E E o
is cy
83
is 3 S
st 5 St C C
g 93 : 3 S
Z C) -
+3+k - - S
er
m
5 5
s E
H
se
--- d
d
o Cd o d od od o O d o d
S S S S 3 g S S & Sp
US 9,068,022 B1
1. 2
PROCESS FOR MAKING AMODIFIED Such as Substitution and crosslinking. The resulting modified
STARCH PRODUCT starch product can be used in place of conventionally modi
fied Starches in a wide variety of applications, including, but
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED not limited to, food products, pharmaceutical products, nutra
APPLICATIONS ceutical products, paper products, personal care products, and
the like.
This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent
application Ser. No. 12/436,390, filed on May 6, 2009, which BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
claims the benefit of priority of U.S. Provisional Patent Appli
cation No. 61/050,711, filed May 6, 2008, and is also a con 10 FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of a conventional starch
tinuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/498, modification process.
392, filed on Jul. 7, 2009, which claims the benefit of priority FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram of one embodiment of the
of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/081,125, filed process for making a modified Starch product in accordance
Jul. 16, 2008, each of which applications is incorporated by with the present invention.
reference herein in its entirety. 15 FIG. 3 is a graph showing viscosity and pasting profiles of
a native starch, a conventionally modified Starch, and modi
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION fied Starch products made in accordance with the present
invention.
Modified starches have been used for years in many diverse
applications. There is a continuing need to improve upon DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
starch modification processes and modified Starches to meet
various demands of these applications. By using the process of the present invention, a modified
One conventional method for modifying starch, hydrox starch product that has a low or reduced sodium content, or
ypropylation, involves the addition of sodium sulfate and that is substantially free of sodium, can be made. The modi
Sodium hydroxide in addition to propylene oxide to a slurry of 25 fied starch of the present invention can be used to reduce,
native or modified starch. Sodium hydroxide raises the pH of Substantially reduce, Substantially eliminate, or eliminate the
the slurry to about 11.5, thereby facilitating the hydroxypro Sodium content of many products.
pylation reaction between the starch and the propylene oxide. The process of the present invention involves the use of
Hydroxypropylated Starch, in a high pH environment, will non-Sodium salts and non-sodium alkaline compounds to
gelatinize, so sodium Sulfate is added to the starch slurry, for 30 facilitate the hydroxypropylation reaction described above.
example, at a level of about 10% or more on a dry basis, in The hydroxypropylation reaction can take from a few hours to
order to inhibit gelatinization of the hydroxypropylated over 20 hours, depending on the reaction conditions and the
starch. After hydroxypropylation has been completed, the pH desired properties of the end product. Generally, a reaction
of the slurry is reduced by adding an acid, and the resulting time of about 18-20hours is suitable. Once the starch has been
hydroxypropylated modified starch is washed and dried for 35 hydroxypropylated using this process, the pH of the slurry is
further use. A schematic diagram of this conventional process reduced, and the modified starch is dried for further use.
is shown in FIG. 1. Because the modified starch does not contain sodium, a wash
The modified starch resulting from the conventional ing step is not necessary, but in Some instances a washing step
hydroxypropylation reaction contains sodium saltata level of may be incorporated into the process, depending on the
about 15-25% by dry weight of the modified starch before the 40 intended use of the modified starch product. A schematic
washing step. The washing step typically reduces the sodium diagram of one embodiment of the process of the present
salt to a level of about 0.5% or less on a dry basis. invention is shown in FIG. 2.
Another conventional method for modifying starch is by Similarly, the modified starch can be made using other
cross-linking the starch. This can be done by adding cross starch modification reactions, such as cross-linking the
linking agents, including, but not limited to, a mixture of 45 starch, by replacing sodium-containing compounds used in
sodium trimetaphosphate (STMP) and sodium tripolyphos Such reactions with non-sodium compounds. The modified
phate (STPP), or phosphorus oxychloride and epichlorohy starch can also be made by using a combination of starch
drin, to either a native starch slurry or starch slurry that has modification processes, such as hydroxypropylation and
previously been hydroxypropylated. About 5% sodium chlo cross-linking, to achieve the desired properties.
ride is added to the reaction in order to modulate the cross 50 The process of the present invention can be used to modify
linking process to provide uniformity and consistency in this starch from a wide variety of sources. Such as, but not limited
typically fast reaction. The resulting modified Starch contains to, corn/maize, wheat, rice, buckwheat, barley, oat, millet,
sodium salt at a level of about 5-25% by dry weight (before rye, Sorghum, potato, Sweet potato, tapioca/cassava, arrow
the washing step). root, sago, arracacha, banana, plantain, malanga, kudzu, Oca,
55 canna, taro, yams, chestnuts, edible beans, such as lentils,
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION favas, mung bean and peas. In addition to modifying a native
starch from these or other sources, the process of the present
The present invention is directed to a process for making a invention can be used to modify a previously modified Starch.
modified starch, to modified starch products resulting from The modified starch product resulting from the process of the
this process, and to related products containing the modified 60 present invention can also be further modified using other
starch as an ingredient, processing aid, or formula compo starch modification processes.
nent. The process and resulting product according to the Non-sodium salts suitable for use in the process of the
present invention reduce, Substantially reduce, or eliminate present invention include, but are not limited to, the follow
the sodium level typically associated with conventional ing:
modified Starch products. 65 The inorganic or organic salts of alkali metals (e.g.,
The process of the present invention can be used as an lithium, potassium, caesium), and alkaline earth metals
alternative to conventional starch modification processes, (e.g., beryllium, magnesium, calcium), or acid or base
US 9,068,022 B1
3 4
addition salts formed with cations such as bismuth, in 21 CFRS 101.61(b)(6), and “low sodium' means 140 mg
barium, aluminum, copper, cobalt, nickel, cadmium, sodium or less per RACC, or “reference amounts customarily
ammonium, and the like; consumed, as defined in 21 CFR S 101.61(b)(4). In one
Chloride salts such as potassium chloride, lithium chloride, embodiment of the present invention, the modified starch
caesium chloride, europium chloride, gadolinium chlo product of the present invention is used to make a reduced
ride, terbium chloride, magnesium chloride, calcium sodium food product which contains at least about 25% less
chloride, ammonium chloride, choline chloride, and the Sodium than an appropriate reference food. In another
like: embodiment of the present invention, the modified starch
Sulfate salts such as potassium Sulfate, magnesium Sulfate, product of the present invention is used to make a low sodium
calcium Sulfate, ammonium Sulfate, aluminum Sulfate, 10 food product containing about 140 mg Sodium or less per
and the like; RACC.
Phosphate salts such as mono-, di-, tri-basic potassium, Although the following Example I describes a hydroxypro
calcium, ammonium, and the like; pylation reaction, the process of the present invention can be
Potassium bisulfate, potassium carbonate or bicarbonate; applied to any starch modification reaction which conven
and 15 tionally involves a sodium salt, in order to reduce or eliminate
Cation salts formed with organic acid anions such as cit the Sodium content of the resulting modified starch, Such as,
rate, malate, lactate, gluconate, tartrate. Succinate, for but not limited to, the starch modification reactions described
mate,acetate, propionate, glucuronate, benzoate, oxalic, in 21 CFR S 172.892. Included in these starch modification
and the like. reactions are substitution and cross-linking reactions. The
Of these salts, the preferred non-sodium salts for use in the modified starch product of the present invention can be made
present invention include potassium chloride, ammonium using a combination of starch modification reactions to obtain
chloride, magnesium chloride, calcium chloride, Zinc chlo a modified Starch product having the desired functional and
ride, aluminum chloride, potassium Sulfate, magnesium Sul organoleptic properties.
fate, potassium bitartrate, and a combination thereof. The modified starch product can be mechanically blended
The advantage of the modified starch product made by the 25 with any native starches and/or modified starches described in
process of the present invention is that the modified Starch can 21 CFRS172.892 in various ratios to produce modified starch
be used in reduced sodium, low sodium or Sodium-free prod products with functionality suitable to a variety of food and
ucts, such as food products, and can provide all the textural other applications.
properties obtained by using a conventionally modified Starch It has been observed that modified starch products made
ingredient without adding a significant amount of Sodium to 30 with different salts have different effects on the gelling and
the food product or other type of product. pasting properties of the modified Starch products, and
As will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, although require different levels of non-sodium salts to complete the
the process of the present invention does not utilize Sodium modification process. By using a particular non-Sodium salt
containing reactants to make the modified Starch product, during the starch modification process, it is possible to make
some trace levels of sodium may be present in the modified 35 a low sodium modified starch with the desired gelatinization
starch made by the process of the present invention due to and other properties for a particular application. For example,
factors other than the modification process itself. if a magnesium salt is used during the starch modification
One key advantage of the modified starch of the present process instead of a sodium salt, the gel onset temperature of
invention is that the modified starch can be used as an ingre the low sodium modified starch is lower, i.e., the low sodium
dient or formula component to reduce the Sodium content in 40 modified Starch gels at a lower temperature, than if a calcium
a wide variety of products, such as food products, while salt is used. Using these properties, it is possible to select and
providing the same or similar textural and other organoleptic combine various low Sodium modified Starches, and native
or physical properties obtained by using a conventionally and conventionally modified Starches, to customize the modi
modified Starch ingredient in Such products. fied Starch characteristics, such as texture, viscosity, taste and
As used herein, the expressions “substantially free of 45 Sodium content, as needed for a particular application.
sodium.” “low sodium,” “reduced sodium', and “sodium
free” shall refer to a sodium level or levels that are less than Example I
the sodium content of comparable reference products con
taining conventionally modified Starch ingredients. In a pre To evaluate the properties of the modified starches made by
ferred embodiment, a low sodium modified starch made in 50 the process of the present invention, a variety of non-sodium
accordance with the present invention is used to prepare food salts were used in the hydroxypropylation of native starch,
products that are low sodium, reduced sodium, or Sodium and properties of the resulting modified Starch product were
free, and that have Substantially the same texture, Viscosity compared to those of a native starch and a conventionally
and taste properties of comparable Sodium-containing refer modified starch.
ence food products made using a conventionally modified 55 Waxy corn starch was obtained from a commercial source
starch. As used herein, the expression “reference food shall and modified according to the procedure by Wang and Wang
refer to a food product having Substantially the same formula (Starch/Stärke 52 (2000) 406-412) with modifications.
as a food product comprising a low sodium modified Starch, To make the modified starch products of the present inven
but without the low sodium modified starch and related for tion, a starch slurry containing dry starch at 35% solid con
mula modifications. 60 centration (dry starch basis) was prepared and salt (NHCl,
Products made using the modified starch of the present KC1, CaCl, or MgCl2 at their respective maximum concen
invention may be labeled to reflect the sodium reduction if the trations) was added. Then the pH of the starch slurry was
products meet labeling regulations or guidelines regarding adjusted to 11.5 by KOH, instead of NaOH, in order to reduce
the Sodium content of a given product or type of product. the sodium content. Propylene oxide was added at 8% on a
For example, for food products, “reduced sodium' as 65 dry weight basis to initiate the hydroxypropylation, and the
defined by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration means at reaction took place for 18 hours. Afterward, the slurry pH was
least 25% less than an appropriate reference food, as defined neutralized to 5.5-6.0 with HCl, and the modified starch prod
US 9,068,022 B1
5 6
uct of the present invention was recovered and dried at 40°C. TABLE 2
to moisture content below about 12%.
As used herein, “HP shall refer to “hydroxypropylated”. Pasting properties of native and HP-modified starches
As used herein, “HP-NHC1, “HP-KCI”, “HP CaCl,” 5 Pasting Peak Final Break- Set
and “HP-MgCl,” shall refer to a modified starch product of Temperature Viscosity Viscosity down back
the present invention made by replacing sodium chloride in (° C.) (BU-8) (BU) (BU) (BU)
the modification process with ammonium, potassium, cal
cium or magnesium chloride, respectively. Native waxy 69.9 827 468 475 115
corn starch
10
Thermal Properties Conventional 62.8 960 461 610 109
The gelatinization temperature and enthalpy of the modi HP waxy corn
fied starch products, and of a native starch and a convention HP-NHCI 76.4 223 139 101 17
HP-KC 74.7 479 288 240 48
ally modified starch, were measured with a differential scan HP-CaCl, 71.1 237 190 3 36
ning calorimeter (DSC), and the results are Summarized in 15
HP-MgCl, 69.7 366 246 174 S4
Table 1. As used herein, “HP-(salt) refers to a modified
starch product that has been hydroxypropylated using the (*BU refers to “Brabender Units)
named Salt and without a Subsequent washing step.
HP NHCl waxy corn had the highest gelatinization tem The low sodium modified starch of the present invention
perature and HP MgCl, had the lowest onset gelatinization may include the salt residue remaining after the modification
temperature and enthalpy, as shown in Table 1. The signifi reaction has taken place. In a conventional Sodium-based
cantly lower enthalpy values of the modified starch products reaction, the residual sodium salt associated with a modified
made in accordance with the present invention suggest that starch is typically washed out. The non-sodium salt residues
some of their crystalline structures were disrupted during the associated with the low sodium modified starch of the present
25
modification process. Commercial HP waxy corn starch had invention may or may not be washed out, depending on the
a significantly lower gelatinization temperature due to the desired effect of the low sodium modified starch. Table 3
added hydroxypropyl groups that weaken the crystalline Summarizes the various salt residue levels of Some embodi
Structure. ments of the low sodium modified starch.
30
TABLE 1. TABLE 3
Gelatinization properties of native and HP-rnoclified starches Salt residue in hydroxpropylated
low sodium modified starches (LSMS
Gelatinization
Onset Peak End Temp Enthalpy 35 Salt as Salt content (% total Preferred range in
Process Aid in finished LSMS) finished ISMS
Temp (C.) Temp (C.) (° C.) (J/g)
Native waxy 68.7 73.1 8O.O 14.8
NHCI O*-41S O-30
KC O-40 O-30
corn starch
Conventional 62.7 68.4 76.2 14.1
CaCl2 O-43 O-30
MgCl2 O-6S O-30
HP waxy corn 40
HP-NHCI 75.8 80.6 86.3 7.6 *0% indicates the salt residue in starch resultant was washed out,
HP-KC 75.7 79.7 85.2 9.1 SThe highest level of salts in modified starch occurs when salt was added its saturation point
HP-CaCl, 77.4 83.1 89.2 3.2 and no wash step was applied at the end of reaction process,
HP-MgCl, 74.9 80.3 86.8 7.4
45
In some embodiments, it may be desirable to retain or
Pasting Properties optimize the residual non-sodium salt levels due to the nutri
tive significance of a particular salt residue. The low sodium
The pasting properties, including pasting temperature, modified starch in these embodiments serves to provide an
peak viscosity, breakdown, and final viscosity, of the modi additional source of the nutritive salt in the finished product.
fied starches were evaluated at 6% (db) by a Micro Vis 50 The following examples present a variety of food products
coAmyloGraph(R), available from C.W. Brabender Instru made with the modified starch product of the present inven
ments, Inc., South Hackensack, N.J. The results, and the tion. Although these examples describe food products, the
results of the same analysis performed on a native starch and modified Starch product can also be used in any type of
a conventionally hydroxypropylated Starch, are summarized non-food products in which a conventionally modified starch
in Table 2. 55 is used.
HP-NHCl waxy corn had the lowest overall viscosity In the Examples below, the columns marked as 'A'
profile, whereas HP-KCl waxy corn had the highest peak and describe conventional food product formulas, and the col
final Viscosity among all the modified Starch samples, as
shown in Table 2 and FIG. 3. All of the modified starch umns marked “B” describe food product formulas made with
products made in accordance with the present invention had 60 the modified starch product of the present invention. The food
higher pasting temperatures and lower viscosities compared products are made using conventional methods, but utilize the
with the native starch and the conventionally modified HP modified Starch product of the present invention as an ingre
starch. The conventionally modified HP waxy corn starch dient in place of or in combination with conventionally modi
displayed a significantly higher viscosity than the native fied starches. The “B” formulas containing the modified
starch because the Substituted hydroxypropylated groups 65 starch product resulted in finished food products having tex
weaken the crystalline structure and improve water absorp ture, Viscosity and taste properties that were comparable to
tion. the products made using the “A” formulas, but with lower or
US 9,068,022 B1
7 8
significantly lower Sodium levels. All percentages are given -continued
as percent by weight unless otherwise indicated.
A. B
Example II Ingredients % %
5 Spice O.2-0.5 O.2-0.5
Sour Cream Sauce Dry Mix Low Sodium Modified Starch 4-31
Total 100 100
SOUP
Example VI
A. B 35
Ingredient % % Mushroom Cream Soup or Sauce
White Cheese powder SO-60 SO-60
Sweet whey 6-12 O-6
Reduced minerals whey 6-12
Fine Flour Salt 12-16 O-3 40 A. B
Maltodextrin 8-10 8-10 Ingredients % %
MSG O.2-0.6 O.2-0.6
Natural Flavorings 2-2.5 2-2.5 Patent Flour 2-3 2-3
Low sodium salt (fine) 6-12 Salt 1-1.5 O.3-0.7
Low sodium Modified Starch 4-6 Chicken Bouillon 0.6-1 0.6-1
45 Mushroom Pieces 7-9 7-9
Total 100 1OO Spray Dried Veg Fat 10-15 10-15
Water 23-26 23-26
Potassium Chloride O. 1-0.3
Spice and Seasonings O.05-0.1 O.05-0.1
Example IV Heavy Cream 35-40 35-40
Polar Gel Food Starch 2-3 O-2
50 Milk Solids 3-4 3-4
Instant Chicken Soup Base Natural Flavorings O.2-0.7 O.2-0.7
Low Sodium Modified Starch O.5-2
A. B 55
Ingredients % %
DRY MIX Example VII
Nonfat Dry Milk 25-30 25-30 Cream Mushroom Soup
Mira Thick 468 25-31 O-31
Maltodextrin 10-13 10-13 60
Shortening Powder 5-7 5-7
Chicken flavor S-8 S-8
Salt 6.5-7.5 2-4.5 A. B
Potassium Chloride 1.5-2.5 Ingredients % %
Guar Gum O.3-O.S O.3-O.S
Natural Flavorings 0.2-1 0.2-1 65 Heavy Cream 15-17 15-17
Savory Flavors O.5-12 O.5-12 Mira Thick-468 1.5-2.5 O-25
US 9,068,022 B1
10
-continued Example X
A. Extruded Ready-to-Eat Cereal
Ingredients % %