Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Oil Well Perforation Technology Status and Prospects
Oil Well Perforation Technology Status and Prospects
Cite this article as: PETROL. EXPLOR. DEVELOP., 2014, 41(6): 798–804. RESEARCH PAPER
Abstract: Perforation is a key link in well completion. To meet the development requirements of different types of oil and gas fields,
after over ten years of research and development, a series of perforation methods and matching processes have been established, such as
deep penetration shaped perforation, composite perforation, directional perforation etc, which on the one hand improve the result and ef-
ficiency of perforation completion and stimulation, on the other hand prolong the service life of reservoir by protecting the reservoir.
Meanwhile, the optimization of perforation design and the improvement of perforation check method further enhance the safety and suc-
cess rate of perforation, and make the perforation test process and field application more standardized. For unconventional tight oil and
gas reservoirs, deep−ultra-deep reservoirs, thin and poor reservoirs, reservoirs with edge or bottom water, staged fracturing of horizontal
wells, and re-perforating of old wells, perforation techniques such as 3D perforation, ultra-deep penetration perforation, and high tem-
perature high pressure perforation, and supplement perforation etc should be studied according to the features of the specific oil and gas
reservoir and well.
Key words: perforation technology; perforation process; status; development prospect; face direction perforation; 3D perforation
Table 1 Average penetration depth of some perforators from several plants in China and abroad[11−14]
Gun diameter/ Perforation density/ Penetration
Supplier Bullet type Charge load/g
mm (Perforation·m−1) depth/mm
GEO Dynamics, USA 114.3 4039 RaZor HMX 39 16 1 597
Owen, USA 114.3 SDP-4500-411NT3 39 16 1 376
Sichuan Perforating Charge Plant, China 114.3 SDP48HMX39-1 39 16 1 538
Daqing Perforating Charge Plant, China 114.3 SDP45HMX-1 39 16 1 356
scope or rotate the perforation string, in order to make the addition, for horizontal wells with serious sand production,
perforation direction toward the principle direction, which can oriented perforation can be implemented along the direction
make fluid break rock easier, and reduce reservoir fracture with minimum stress difference, in order to reduce pressure
pressure in future stimulation, so the difficulty of fracturing drop, change fluid flow characteristic and form more uniform
can be reduced, and perforation effectiveness improved; stress distribution, thus reduce sand production.
meanwhile, the effective drainage area in reservoir and well
2.1.4 Underbalanced perforation and dynamic
production capacity can be increased[18].
underbalanced perforation
Currently, there are two probationary types of gyroscope
oriented perforation, i.e. tubing conveyed and cable conveyed, Underbalanced perforation and dynamic underbalanced
according to the way of transporting gyroscope downhole. perforation are both designed to work at underbalanced pres-
The tubing conveyed process is more mature, but the control- sure in wellbore. When perforating, the pressure difference
ling perforation direction through rotating tubing is still not between wellbore and reservoir can help generate fast shock
accurate enough. The cable conveyed perforation can be ap- backflow, which will flush the plugs and explosion remnant in
plied in wells less than 30° in deviation, much higher in op- and near perforation tunnels and clean the oil flow paths,
eration accuracy and efficiency than the tubing conveyed one, making the seepage characteristics near wellbore area closer
the cable conveyed type is developing quickly. to original reservoir. This technique originated in the US, and
The oriented perforation on horizontal wells usually utilizes has made advancement in China during the past several
an integrated counterweight system as its orienting device, as years[3]. At present, mature underbalanced perforation tech-
shown in Fig. 3. In the perforation process on horizontal well nique in China employs internal packers to separate each per-
with long horizontal interval, in order to ensure operation forated interval, and generate underbalanced pressure in tub-
security, the corresponding unidirectional or bidirectional ing according to operation requirements, then connection be-
delayed detonator is used. Through detonating segment by tween tubing and casing annulus under the packer can be
segment, perforation at one time can be achieved on ultra-long made by dropping bar or pressure detonating, generating un-
horizontal intervals. derbalanced pressure in perforating interval. The perforation
Besides, there could be some problem in the process of gun will subsequently be detonated to shot the hole, as shown
horizontal well drilling, such as reservoir damage while drill- in Fig. 4. In this operation, pressure gauge and other relative
ing and wellbore deviation from target reservoir. To solve devices can be incorporated into the perforation string, to
these problems, oriented multi-stage composite perforation on monitor temperature and pressure downhole during the whole
horizontal wells has been developed, and now become the operation process, and provide formation skin factor, original
first choice when designing single well stimulation plan in reservoir pressure, permeability, formation factor, and pre-
many oil fields in China[19]. In 2013, this technique was suc- dicted production, etc.
cessfully applied in Well TZ16-16H of Tarim Oilfield, in In dynamic underbalanced perforation, an unbalanced
which the multi-stage composite fracturing perforator con- pressure compartment is installed to the perforating gun. The
sisting of FS96-13DP29 perforating gun, YS95 fracturing gun exploding energy generated from perforation will instantly
and SDP39HMX29-2 perforating charge was used to perforate open the compartment, and the fluid in the annulus of perfo-
at the depth of 4 190−4 293 m. Through double stage powder rated interval will flow into the compartment, and thus gener-
charge and repeatedly working, the pressure effective time in ating underbalance pressure in the casing annulus. This kind
wellbore was extended to more than 800 ms, and the total of technique makes it easier to generate underbalanced pres-
penetration depth of perforation tunnel and fracture was more sure and the field operation more convenient. And besides, it
than 5 000 mm. The operation resulted in significant produc- can be used with dynamic underbalanced perforation optimi-
tion increase. zation software.
Furthermore, oriented perforation can also prevent the
downhole completion devices from damage by perforating, fix
up the cement channelling outside casing, and build up con-
nection with the rescue well in pressure control operation. In
− 800 −
LIU He et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2014, 41(6): 798–804
2.1.5 Full bore perforation each fracturing interval, the bridge plugging and multiple
perforation can be done at one time, and the bridge plug can
In full bore perforation, a special full bore perforator con-
be drilled out quickly after fracturing, which together simpli-
nected with corresponding downhole tools by tubing is run
fies the operation process, saves operation time and cost sub-
down together, and then located by deep correction pup joint,
stantially. Pumping perforation is a kind of mainstream perfo-
as shown in Fig. 5. When all the above devices are conveyed
to target interval, the exploder will ignite and the perforating ration technique in producing shale gas, coal bed methane and
charge will explode. The explosive residue will automatically tight oil and gas abroad. In North America, nearly 85% of
fall down to the bottom hole or into the pocket gun. In the tight oil and gas reservoirs and shale gas reservoirs are pro-
perforating string, a path equivalent to oil tubing in diameter duced by this technique. Over the past few years, this tech-
will be formed, so that the future logging, acidizing, fracturing nique has also been used widely in the perforation and frac-
or reservoir testing can be easily implemented without pulling turing of unconventional reservoirs in China. The main de-
out the string or dropping perforation gun to bottom hole. This vices of the technique include cable perforating operation
way, the effect of repeated operation on downhole parameters vehicle, blowout prevention wellhead, pumping perforating
can be avoided, making the testing results better reflect origi- gun, switch block used to choose firing holes, sealing tools,
nal reservoir property, and formation evaluation more accurate. drillable composite bridge plugs and drilling & milling shoes
Besides, the operation string enables to do several jobs in one used to drill bridge plugs.
trip, so that the operation cost can be reduced substantially 2.1.7 Face direction perforation technique
and the operation cycle shortened. The full bore perforation
technique has an obvious edge when applied in deep or ul- Currently, conventional perforators at home and abroad are
tra-deep wells with complex tripping operation, low pressure mostly with firing hole distributing spirally at 60° phase angle.
gas wells with difficult well control and areas with harsh en- The spiral distribution of perforation holes can not effectively
vironment and operation difficulties, over other perforation guide the fracture propagation direction, so fractures would
techniques. only extend along the direction of minimum principal stress,
and the fracture strike is uncontrollable. As a result, in
2.1.6 Integrated pumping perforation and bridge plugging
multi-stage fracturing, it is very likely to cause connections
For horizontal well fracturing, limited by wellbore, geo- between fractures of different fractured intervals, which may
logical conditions and fracturing devices, staged perforating affect the fracturing effectiveness. The best fracture network
or fracturing must be taken to achieve maximum reservoir is that with the fracture strike vertical to wellbore axis and all
recovery efficiency. Traditional horizontal well perforation fractures extending along the wellbore radial direction. So in
technique uses tubing to convey perforation devices, which 2013, a new perforation technique emerged, which was called
faces great challenges in multi-staged perforation and fractur- face direction perforation.
ing, besides, it has poor operation security, long operation The face direction perforation changes conventional spiral
cycle and high operation cost. The integrated pumping perfo- distribution of firing holes, and uses specially made oversized
ration and bridge plugging takes cable conveying mode. For perforating charge and special charge distribution mode. The
firing holes are distributed in clusters, and 3 perforation
charges are loaded for each cluster. The perforation direction
forms a fan shaped plane. After perforating, multiple perfora-
tion holes will generate on the casing inner wall in one cross
section vertical to casing axis. The circular distribution of
these holes can form a stress concentration plane along the
wellbore radial direction, which makes it easier to break up
rocks underground, reducing the difficulty in fracturing,
compared with the stress concentration point generated in
conventional perforation. When fracturing, the fractures will
extend toward wellbore radial direction along the stress con-
centration plane, thus the fracture strike near wellbore can be
controlled, preventing the intersecting or connecting of frac-
tures in different fractured intervals, and improving the per-
fection degree of fracture network. The oversized perforation
charge adopted in this process helps to increase the area of
perforated holes, enhance the capacity of connectivity be-
Fig. 5 Integrated full bore perforation, acidizing & fracturing tween wellbore and reservoir, reduce hole friction effectively
string and improve well production capacity.
− 801 −
LIU He et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2014, 41(6): 798–804
remaining oil of water flooded layers, perforation not only foration combined with drillable bridge plugs”, the other
plays the role of opening up wellbore and reservoir simply, “coiled tubing dragging perforation by cluster combined with
but also closely stresses on the close combination with geo- bridge”. How to make stages and clusters according to spe-
logic & reservoir engineering and completion, especially with cific wellbore and reservoir conditions, and the later evalua-
completion tools[22−27]. tion methods are both important research titles in the future.
For unconventional reservoirs such as shale gas, coal bed Some research institutions have started relevant work in re-
methane, ultra-low permeability-tight ones, hydraulic fractur- cent years, but still have not established a complete theory
ing is needed to make wells reach economic production. For system yet, and need further research and development.
deviated wells, including highly-deviated wells, cluster wells, For stimulation of old wells, currently old wells in many
horizontal wells and other types of wells special in structure, fields have witnessed production decline, including wells
effective control of fracture strike and perfecting fracture completed with casing perforation, screen pipe and open hole.
network is the key of single well productivity. Perforation on The reasons causing production drop of old wells are complex,
these types of wells should focus on solving the following including imperfect perforation, insufficient formation energy,
problems: (1) obtain larger drainage area on well wall; (2) and plugging in near wellbore area due to accumulation of
reduce reservoir fracture pressure significantly and lower the high molecule polymer and solid particles during long term
difficulty of hydraulic fracturing; (3) guide fracture propaga- production, so how to recover productivity of old wells
tion direction, induce the connection of hydraulic fractures through re-perforation or explosion fracturing is also an im-
and natural fractures, forming completed fracture network and portant research direction in the future.
improve well productivity. On the basis of face direction per-
4 Conclusions
foration, angle fixable perforation and oriented perforation,
the combination of them could give birth to the “3D” perfora- As more and more different kinds of reservoirs are devel-
tion technique and its matching process, which will provide a oped in China and abroad, the development of oil fields or gas
new approach for perforation of unconventional reservoirs fields becomes more and more difficult. Strict requirements
and wells with special structures. In addition, the testing are set on the matching techniques, and perforation has turned
method and optimization system for the “3D” perforation from a simple completion method into an important link in
method need to be built up, in order to make a proper perfora- reservoir development and is playing an more and more im-
tion plan for different types of wells, wells with different con- portant role in protecting reservoir, enhancing well productiv-
ditions and wells in different reservoirs, to improve well pro- ity, promoting operation efficiency, improving development
ductivity. effectiveness for unconventional reservoirs, recovering old
To meet the needs of new and old wells with poor and thin well productivity, extending oilfield lifetime, producing re-
layers, oil zones with edge water or bottom water, and re- maining oil potential and enhancing ultimate oil recovery.
maining oil area in water flooded areas where hydraulic frac- With the expansion of petroleum development domains in the
turing can not be conducted, ultra-deep penetration perfora- future, perforation will face more and more complicated
tion with accurate orientation and its combination with orien- problems, and its development road also will become broad.
tation tools, new composite perforation technique with con-
Acknowledgment
trollable energy taking geological condition into consideration,
and optimization design methods aiming at different forma- Xi’an Tongyuan Oil Tools Co. Ltd. is hereby acknowledged
tion conditions must be developed in the future. for providing current perforation status and field testing data.
For deep and ultra-deep reservoirs, because of the high
temperature and high pressure downhole, the perforation References
string working condition is very complex, and conventional
perforator and perforation technique can not meet the re- [1] Li Dongchuan, Zhu Guibao, Yu Haiying. Analysis of penetra-
quirements on safety and efficient operation in deep wells. tion performance for shaped perforator in concrete target.
Therefore, deep penetration perforation charge with tempera- Technology Supervision in Petroleum Industry, 2008, 24(6):
ture resistance, high pressure perforator, perforation tools with 8–11.
sulfur resistance and anti-explosion function, and perforation [2] Wang Changshuan, Feng Guofu, Wang Baoxing, et al. Com-
operation process in deep wells need to be developed[28]. The bustion mechanism and experimental analysis of multistage
pressure and temperature resistance level are at least 175 MPa, powder charging technology in super positive pressure com-
210°C/170h, respectively. And all the devices should normally posite perforation. Well Logging & Perforation, 2006, 9(4):
function at 6 000 m depth underground at least. 74–77.
For multi-stage fracturing in horizontal wells, perforation [3] Liu Fangyu, Liu Qiao, Cai Shan. Dynamic under-balanced
by clusters has strong effect on fracturing. Currently, there are pressure perforating technology and its application. Well Log-
two types of widely used process of perforating by clus- ging Technology, 2010, 34(2): 193–195.
ter-multi-stage fracturing: one “cable conveyed pumping per- [4] Bakker E, Veeken K, Behrmann L, et al. Technology of dy-
− 803 −
LIU He et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2014, 41(6): 798–804
namic negative pressure perforation. World Well Logging 2000, 29(2): 31–33.
Technology, 2004, 19(5): 48–60. [18] Jiang Hu, Chen Mian, Zhang Guangqing, et al. Impact of ori-
[5] He Hongmin, Lu Lijun, Mu Guanghua, et al. On dynamic ro- ented perforation on hydraulic fracture initiation and propaga-
tary oriented perforation technology. Well Logging Technol- tion. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,
ogy, 2013, 37(4): 451–454. 2009, 28(7): 1321–1326.
[6] Zhang Shaocheng, Zhang Feng, Zhou Zhao, et al. On set shoot [19] Wang Lei, Zhang Leyu, Li Jingjing, et al. Research of perfora-
angle compass perforating technology. Well Logging Tech- tion parameters and initiation pressure for horizontal perfo-
nology, 2012, 36(1): 68–72. rated wells. Journal of Chongqing University of Science and
[7] Tang Kai, Luo Miaozhuang, Chen Feng, et al. Application of Technology: Natural Science Edition, 2013, 15(5): 57–60.
full-bore perforation technology. Well Logging Technology, [20] Zou Liangzhi. Analysis of compound perforation technology
2010, 34(5): 496–500. in oil and gas wells. World Well Logging Technology,
[8] Yang Xinfeng, Kong Fanpeng, Li Senmao. Study on spacer 2013(1): 63–66, 62.
system of full bore perforating. Well Logging Technology, [21] National Energy Administration. SY/T 6824-2011 Combined
2009, 33(6): 597–600. perforator general technical specification and detection
[9] Zhu Haiyan, Deng Jin’gen, Liu Shujie, et al. A prediction method for oil and gas wells. Beijing: Petroleum Industry
model for the hydraulic fracture initiation pressure in oriented Press, 2011.
perforation. Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2013, 34(3): 556–562. [22] Wang Yanjie. Study of clean perforation pulse deflagration
[10] Qin Fadong. Research on the application of accumulated en- fracturing technology. Silicon Valley, 2013(12): 95–96.
ergy effect of high energy gas fracturing. Journal of Xi’an Pe- [23] Liang Zhuang, Ge Yong, Li Jie, et al. Application of water-
troleum Institute, 1992, 7(3): 17–22. power injector radial horizontal well technology in CBM ex-
[11] Sun Yan. The application and quality requirements of deep ploration. Journal of Liaoning Technical University: Natural
penetrating perforating guns and matching tools. China Science Edition, 2011, 30(3): 349–352.
Chemical Trade, 2013, 5(7): 125–126. [24] Zhang Yi, Li Gensheng, Xiong Wei, et al. Stimulation mecha-
[12] Xu Peng. Technology of hydraulic deep penetrating drilling in nism of oil well using high-pressure water jet deep-penetrating
the application of ultra-short radius horizontal well perfora- perforation technique. Journal of the University of Petroleum,
tion. China Science and Technology Review, 2013(11): 155. China, 2004, 28(2): 38–41.
[13] Hornby B E, Yu Jiahua. VSP: beyond time-to-depth. The [25] Wang Lijun, He Fengyun, Wu Chunyu, et al. Capacity calcu-
Leading Edge, 2006, 25(4): 446–452. lation and influencing factors of deep penetration hydraulic jet
[14] Grechka V, Mateva A. Inversion of P-wave VSP data for local perforation. Journal of Daqing Petroleum Institute, 2001,
anisotropy: Theory and a case study. Geophysics, 2007, 72(4): 25(2): 22–24.
D69–D79. [26] Wen H L. Oil well perforator design using 2D Eulerian code.
[15] Wang Shushen, Zheng Changjian, Zhao Chunhui, et al. Ap- International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2002, 27(5):
plication of combined perforating technology in Zhao 53- Ping 535–559.
37 horizontal well. Well Logging Technology, 2005, 29(Supp.): [27] Souli M, Ouahsine A, Lewin L. ALE formulation for
49–51. fluid-structure interaction problems. Computer Methods in
[16] Yang Baojun, Guo Wei. Development and application of com- Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 2000, 190(5/6/7):
bined perforation technology. Oil Drilling & Production 659–675.
Technology, 1997, 19(6): 58–62. [28] Pei Jingxiu, Chen Huabin. The big break in the application of
[17] Wu Jinjun, Ma Ronghua. Study and application of the com- “Three Super” perforation technology in Chuanqing Oilfield.
bined perforation fracturing technique. Oil Field Equipment, China Petrochem, 2013(7): 74.
− 804 −