Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SCGYM 9 2 2017 Journal
SCGYM 9 2 2017 Journal
Gymnastics
Journal
vol. 9, num. 2, year 2017
Science of Gymnastics Journal is supported by Foundation for financing sport organisations in Slovenia,
Slovenian Research Agency and International Gymnastics Federation.
SCIENCE OF GYMNASTICS JOURNAL Vol. 9 Issue 2: 2017
CONTENTS
T. Heinen
A. Brinker THE ROLE OF POSITIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL
M. Mack CUES IN MOVEMENT REGULATION OF
L. Henning YURCHENKO VAULTS IN GYMNASTICS 113
M. Kritikou
O. Donti
G.C. Bogdanis
A. Donti CORRELATES OF ARTISTRY PERFORMANCE SCORES
K. Theodorakou IN PREADOLESCENT RHYTHMIC GYMNASTS 165
M-R.G. Silva
R. Santos-Rocha
P. Barata GENDER INEQUALITIES IN PORTUGUESE GYMNASTS
F. Saavedra BETWEEN 2012 AND 2016 191
K. Šibanc
M. Kalichova
P. Hedbavny COMPARISON OF MORPHOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS
I.Čuk OF TOP LEVEL MALE GYMNASTS BETWEEN
M. Bučar Pajek THE YEARS OF 2000 AND 2015 201
109
SCIENCE OF GYMNASTICS JOURNAL Vol. 9 Issue 2: 2017
Dear colleagues, academics, researchers, coaches, gymnasts, judges, students, and all
those involved with gymnastics, we are pleased to invite you to participate in the International
Seminar on Competitive Artistic and Rhythmic Gymnastics (SIGARC) 2017, which thanks to
previous experiences, with support of universities and partner institutions, is in its 5th Edition.
This event aims, through conferences, round tables, workshops, and exhibition of
scientific works in poster format, to propose an environment for reflections and sharing of
knowledge, innovation, technology, and experiences that enable the continuity process of
competitive Gymnastics development in Brazil.
The SIGARC 2017 will be held at the Centre for Physical Education and Sports (CEFD)
at the Federal University of Espírito Santo (UFES), in the city of Vitoria. This beautiful city in
southeast of Brazil is homeland of gymnasts such Natalia Gaudio, Franciely Machado, and
Emmanuele Lima that represented Brazil in rhythmic gymnastics at the 2016 Olympic Games.
The city is also homeland of Monika Queiroz who coached Brazil in two Olympics editions
(2008 and 2016).
The Mission of SIGARC is to create approaches among students, judges, coaches,
gymnasts, researchers, and other professionals who work with gymnastics, creating an
atmosphere where is possible to share experiences and knowledge benefiting each other. This is
one of the paths to the growth and development of our gymnastics, in order to benefit everyone.
110
SCIENCE OF GYMNASTICS JOURNAL Vol. 9 Issue 2 2017
EDITORIAL
Dear friends,
Competitions under FIG and Continental Unions flag this spring have already brought about
new heights of development. Especially in artistic gymnastics we have been surprised by
presentations of the triple salto backward tucked on floor and the triple salto backward piked
from rings (which MTC FIG recognises as a new element with H difficulty and goes by the
name of Donnel Whittenburg). We are proud that Whittenburg performed it in Slovenia, during
the World Challenge Cup in Koper.
Not only gymnasts and coaches are searching for new content but also researchers world-wide.
The first article in this issue comes from a group of researchers from Germany lead by Thomas
Heinen. They looked at how the gymnast’s motor control regulates Yurchenko vaults. The
article includes some very important information for coaches in the sense of motor learning.
The second article is a review by Slovene authors Boštjan and Barbara Jakše (the latter used to
be a gymnast who competed at World Championships under her maiden name Turšič) in which
they discuss the importance of omega-3 fatty acids for gymnastics. A lot of condensed
information again with high value not only for coaches but also gymnasts and their parents.
The third article is by one author only from Croatia. Sunčica Delaš Kalinski explored the main
reasons why female artistic gymnasts rarely participate in more than one Olympic Games.
Another article for coaches to think about their gymnasts’ careers.
The fourth article is from a team from Greece lead by Maria Kritikou. It looks at the correlations
between artistry performance scores and morphologic characteristics and motor abilities. The
article provides lots of interesting information for coaches, judges and gymnasts in the area
where artistry influences the final scores.
The fifth article comes from Portugal. An analysis of rhythmic routines by Amanda Batista, Rui
Garganta and Lurde Avila Carvalho concludes that the more difficult elements result in lower
scores as judges influence the evaluation of whether difficulty is recognised or not.
The sixth article is also from Portugal. Researchers around Maria-Raquel G. Silva analysed
gender inequalities in the Portuguese gymnastics between 2012 and 2016. Perhaps the new FIG
discipline, parkour, will help make gymnastics in Portugal more popular among males.
The last article comes from a mixed group researchers from the Czech Republic and Slovenia.
The group, led by Karmen Šibanc, compared morphological characteristics of top level
gymnasts between years 2000 and 2015. Two different philosophies of the Code of Points have
also had a minor impact on the changing morphologic structure of gymnasts.
Anton Gajdoš prepared a new contribution on gymnastics history, refreshing our memory of
German team at OG 1896, Walther Lehman and Yukio Endo.
Just to remind you, if you quote the Journal: its abbreviation on the Web of Knowledge is SCI
GYMN J. I wish you pleasant reading and a lot of inspiration for new research projects and
articles,
Ivan Čuk
Editor-in-Chief
111
.de
The mobile force sensor for
smartphones allows long-term
load monitoring in orthopedics,
biomechanics, and rehabilitation.
www.loadsol.de
Adjustable biofeedback
All systems from novel operate with high quality, calibrated sensors and provide reliable and reproducible results.
novel gmbh • Ismaninger Str. 51 • 81675 Munich, Germany • tel +49 (89) 417767-0 • email: novel@novel.de
novel UK • tel/fax: +44 (115) 9 622 622 • email: noveluk@novel.de
loadsol® and the coloured foot are registered trademarks of novel gmbh ©1992-2017
Heinen T., Brineker A., Mack M., Hennig L: THE ROLE OF POSITIONAL ENVIRON… Vol. 9 Issue 2: 113 - 126
Original article
Abstract
Numerous gymnastics skills demand a precise interaction between the gymnast and the
environment. It remains unclear, how different environmental cues act and interact in the
regulation of complex skills, such as Yurchenko-type vaults, where the gymnast performs a
round-off before contacting the springboard. The aim of this study was to assess the roles of
both, the position of the round-off mat and the position of the springboard, in the regulation
of a Yurchenko timer. Kinematic parameters of eight female expert gymnasts’ Yurchenko
timers were examined in a baseline condition and two experimental conditions with different
manipulations of the positions of the round-off mat and the springboard. Results revealed that
visually controlled regulation of the run-up occurred in average two steps prior to the hurdle.
Hand positioning on the round-off mat preceded a constant round-off flight phase. Gymnasts
placed their feet on average on the same spot on the springboard, regardless of whether the
springboard position was manipulated. Finally, hand positioning on the vault block mainly
varied as a function of the position of the springboard and the distance of the flight phase to
support. This study provides evidence that the position of the springboard regulates
Yurchenko-type vaults. Knowledge about relationships between informational sources in the
environment and the resulting motor behaviour in gymnasts may help coaches to develop
training programs aiming to enhance gymnasts’ ability to utilize this information in skill
performance under changing environmental conditions in training and competition.
INTRODUCTION
mat and/or the springboard on positions of pushes off the vault block and rotates to
the hands during support on the vaulting landing on her back on a soft mat. A
block and we sought to explore this effect. certified springboard (1.20 meters long,
Finally, distances of flight phases should 0.60 meters wide) with a safety mat and a
vary as a result of changes in hand and/or certified round-off mat were used (1.25
feet placement and we also sought to meters long, 1.00 meters wide). The height
explore this effect. of the vault block was 0.80 meters with a
width of 2.00 meters and a length of 1.00
METHODS meters. It was decided to use a vault block
with a standard height of 0.80 meters,
Eight female gymnasts participated in because it is typically used in methodical
this study (age = 13.9 ± 2.6 years; [mean ± progressions in gymnastics, and therefore
standard deviation]). The gymnasts in this additionally supports gymnasts’ safety
study could be characterized as experts when performing the Yurchenko timers in
because they reported to take part in the experimental conditions.
National Championships with an average Movement Analysis System. The
weekly training extent of 20.8 ± 3.3 hours kinematic parameters of the Yurchenko
and an average training experience in timers were analyzed by means of an
artistic gymnastics of 9.1 ± 2.5 years (Chi, optical movement analysis system. All
2006). The gymnasts were able to perform performances were videotaped by using
the experimental task of this study two full-HD video cameras with a spatial
(Yurchenko timer; see Motor task resolution of 1920 x 1280 pixels, and a
paragraph) under changing environmental temporal resolution of 50 Hz. The temporal
conditions (Davids et al., 2008). measurement error was ± 0.02 seconds,
Motor task. The motor task was a so- and the spatial measurement error was ±
called Yurchenko timer (Arkaev & 0.004 meters. The video cameras were
Suchilin, 2004; George, 2010; see Figure 1 placed orthogonal to the movement plane
for an illustration). Timers (as drills) are of the gymnasts. The first camera
usually used in gymnastics training in videotaped the run-up phase, and the
order to develop the ‘feel’ of a complex second camera videotaped the hurdle
skill without the need to complete the skill movement and the Yurchenko timer. The
(Elliott & Mitchell, 1991; Turoff, 1991). field of view of both cameras overlapped
The Yurchenko timer was used as by approximately two meters. Both
experimental task in order to ensure cameras were placed 20 meters away from
gymnasts’ safety, especially in the movement plane of the gymnasts. The
experimental conditions where the position of the toes at the beginning of the
positions of the round-off mat and the run-up, during each step of the run-up, and
springboard were manipulated. during the hurdle, as well as the position of
After a short run-up, the gymnast the hands on the round-off mat, the
performs a hurdle jump followed by a position of the feet on the springboard
round-off. In the round-off, the hands are during the reactive leap, and the position of
placed on a round-off mat. The gymnast the hands during support on the vault block
pushes herself off the round-off mat and were recorded using the software utilius®
places her feet on the springboard. The easyinspect (CCC-Software, 2008).
gymnast reactively leaps off the Measures. In order to assess
springboard with a backward rotation movement regulation during the run-up,
about her somersault axis performing a the hurdle, and the Yurchenko timer, the
half back somersault. She engages a following six variables were calculated
support position by placing her hands on a (see also Figure 1): (1) standard deviation
vault block. From this support position, she in footfall position during each step of the
run-up, and during the hurdle (Bradshaw, the hands to the leading edge of the vault
2004; Lee, Lishman, & Thomson, 1982), block during the support phase of the
(2) averaged distance of both hands to the Yurchenko timer (shands), (5) distance of
leading edge of the round-off mat during the flight phase of the round-off (sflight.1),
the support phase of the round-off (average and (6) distance of flight phase to support
of s1st and s2nd), (3) distance of the toes to on vault block (sflight.2). Kinematic
the leading edge of the springboard during parameters were averaged over all six trials
take-off from the springboard in the for each gymnast in each study condition.
Yurchenko timer (sfeet), and (4) distance of
Note: s1st and s2nd denote distance of first and second hand to leading edge of round-off mat.
sfeet is the distance of the toes to the leading edge of the springboard. shands indicates the
distance of the hands to the leading edge of the vault block. sRM and sSB are the distance of the
round-off mat and the distance of the springboard towards the leading edge of the vault block.
sflight.1 and sflight.2 are the distances of the two flight phases.
Figure 2. Standard deviations (SD) in footfall positions during the steps of the run-up, and
during the hurdle movement (means ± standard deviations).
Note: The bars show aggregated values for all study conditions. The peak in standard
deviation (#) occurred during the second last step prior to the hurdle movement, indicating the
onset of visual regulation (Bradshaw, 2004).
Figure 3. Illustration of the study conditions along with the means and standard deviations of
(1) the averaged distance of both hands to leading edge of round-off mat during the support
phase of the round-off, (2) the distance of the feet to the leading edge of springboard during
the take-off phase of the Yurchenko timer, and (3) the distance of the hands to the leading
edge of the vault block during the support phase of the Yurchenko timer.
Note: The baseline condition comprised gymnasts’ individual distances of round-off mat and
springboard to the vault block (BL = baseline, RM = round-off mat, SB = springboard).
in the second last step prior to the hurdle in position (SB+10 cm / RM±0 cm
the baseline condition as well as in the condition), the following pattern of results
experimental conditions. Comparing the emerged: Gymnasts placed their hands 12
baseline condition with experimental centimetres closer to the back edge of the
conditions, revealed neither statistically round-off mat (Z = 2.52, p = .01). They
significant differences in standard placed their feet on average on the same
deviations in footfall positions in the run- spot on the springboard (Z = 0.14, p = .89).
up, nor in the hurdle (all p > .05). Figure 2 However, distance of the hands during
thus illustrates the aggregated values for support on the vault block was in average
the experimental conditions and for the 0.24 metres longer compared to the
baseline condition.
baseline condition (Z = 2.52, p = .01).
In the baseline condition, gymnasts Distance of round-off flight phase was the
placed their hands 0.60 ± 0.19 metres from same as in the baseline condition (Z =
the leading edge of the round-off mat 1.40, p = .16), and distance of flight phase
during the support phase of the round-off. to support on the vault block was 0.14
The toes were placed 0.65 ± 0.13 metres metres longer compared to the baseline
from the leading edge of the springboard condition (Z = 2.24, p = .03).
during the reactive leap, and the hands
were placed 0.36 ± 0.12 metres from the DISCUSSION
leading edge of the vault block during
support on the vault block. The distance of Results revealed that when performing
the round-off flight phase was 1.35 ± 0.09 Yurchenko timers, the onset of visual
metres, and the distance of the flight phase control occurred in the run-up, two steps
from reactive leap to support on the vault prior to the hurdle. Hand positioning on the
block was 1.31 ± 0.11 metres (see Table 1 round-off mat preceded a rather constant
for details). round-off flight phase. Gymnasts placed
When both, the springboard and the their feet on average on the same spot on
round-off mat were placed 10 centimetres the springboard, regardless of whether the
closer to the vault block (SB+10 cm / springboard position was manipulated.
RM+10 cm condition), the following Hand positioning on the vault block mainly
pattern of results emerged: Gymnasts varied as a function of the springboard
placed their hands in average on the same position and the distance of the flight
spot on the round-off mat (Z = 0.56, p = phase to support. If we summarize the
.57). They also placed their feet on average results of the study, it becomes apparent
on the same spot on the springboard (Z = that female expert gymnasts predominantly
0.14, p = .89). However, distance of the use the springboard as informational
hands during support on the vault block source to regulate Yurchenko timers on
was in average 0.23 metres longer vault. Onset of visual control inferred from
compared to the baseline condition (Z = standard deviation in footfall position
2.52, p = .01). The distance of the round- occurred in average two steps prior to the
off flight phase was not significantly hurdle in all study conditions, thus
different from the baseline condition (Z = indicating that the perception of
.28, p = .78), whereas the distance of the environmental cues is likely to take place
flight phase to support on the vault block in the last part of the run-up, prior to the
was 0.13 metres longer compared to the hurdle. This result supports the notion of
baseline condition (Z = 2.52, p = .01, see an anticipatory control strategy to time and
Figure 3 for an illustration). regulate current action (i.e., run-up) to
When the springboard was placed ten future events and event-related effects (i.e.,
centimetres closer to the vault block, and placement of feet on springboard; Bardy &
the round-off mat was placed at baseline Laurent, 1998; Hoffmann et al., 2004;
Turvey, 1992). Gymnasts seem to The round-off mat does not seem to
anticipate the reactive leap from the be a strong cue on movement regulation in
springboard already prior to the round-off, the performance of the Yurchenko timers.
and they regulate the run-up accordingly. For instance, gymnasts have to place their
This result is in line with findings of feet on a particular area on the springboard
Bradshaw (2004) and Meeuwsen and in order to achieve optimum recoil during
Magill (1987). However, comparing the take-off, given the elastic properties of the
results of the current study with the results springboard (Čuk & Karacsony, 2004).
of other studies (e.g., Heinen, Artmann, The elasticity of the round-off mat,
Brinker, & Nicolaus, 2015), one could however, is rather equally distributed, and
argue that onset of visual regulation might there is in general no necessity to place the
be (to some degree) task-dependent (see hands on a particular spot on the round-off
also Bradshaw, 2004). Theories of visual mat (as long as there is enough space left;
and attentional expertise suggest that it is George, 2010). This argumentation
not only important which informational receives support from a comparison of
cues are used in movement regulation but gymnasts’ motor behaviour in the
also when these cues are used experimental conditions, and in the
(Gegenfurtner et al., 2011; Land, 2006). It baseline condition. One may speculate that
seems that skilled gymnasts possess performing a rather constant round-off
specific memory representations so that flight phase could be one important
they know at which distance they need to strategy in the performance of Yurchenko
pick up which information in order to timers, as long as there is enough space left
regulate the run-up with the aim of a on the round-off mat to place one’s hands
precise interaction with the vaulting during the round-off.
apparatus during complex skills, such as a
Yurchenko timer.
Table 1
Gymnasts’ kinematic parameters (means ± standard deviations) of the Yurchenko timers on
vault in the two experimental conditions, and in the baseline condition.
Conditions
Baseline SB+10 cm / SB+10 cm /
Variables (ind. SB and RM) RM+10 cm RM±0 cm
s1st2nd [m] 0.60 ± 0.19 0.61 ± 0.21 0.72 ± 0.21*
sfeet [m] 0.65 ± 0.13 0.65 ± 0.12 0.65 ± 0.14
shands [m] 0.36 ± 0.12 0.59 ± 0.10* 0.60 ± 0.10*
sflight.1 [m] 1.35 ± 0.09 1.34 ± 0.12 1.33 ± 0.09
sflight.2 [m] 1.31 ± 0.11 1.44 ± 0.11* 1.45 ± 0.12*
Note: * denotes statistical significant difference (p < .05) between the particular experimental
condition, and the baseline condition (RM = round-off mat, SB = springboard).
Onset of visual control inferred from an anticipatory control strategy to time and
standard deviation in footfall position regulate current action (i.e., run-up) to
occurred in average two steps prior to the future events and event-related effects (i.e.,
hurdle in all study conditions, thus placement of feet on springboard; Bardy &
indicating that the perception of Laurent, 1998; Hoffmann et al., 2004;
environmental cues is likely to take place Turvey, 1992). Gymnasts seem to
in the last part of the run-up, prior to the anticipate the reactive leap from the
hurdle. This result supports the notion of springboard already prior to the round-off,
and they regulate the run-up accordingly. compared to the round-off mat. Gymnasts
This result is in line with findings of placed their feet on average on the same
Bradshaw (2004) and Meeuwsen and spot on the springboard, regardless of
Magill (1987). However, comparing the whether the springboard position was
results of the current study with the results manipulated. This result is consistent with
of other studies (e.g., Heinen, Artmann, findings of Heinen et al. (2011, 2013),
Brinker, & Nicolaus, 2015), one could thereby supporting the notion that the
argue that onset of visual regulation might position of the springboard operates as
be (to some degree) task-dependent (see informational source to regulate
also Bradshaw, 2004). Theories of visual Yurchenko timers on vault. Even if
and attentional expertise suggest that it is gymnasts are unable to “see” the
not only important which informational springboard position during the second
cues are used in movement regulation but part of the round-off (when their back is
also when these cues are used facing the springboard, and thus their line
(Gegenfurtner et al., 2011; Land, 2006). It of sight is directed away from the
seems that skilled gymnasts possess springboard) it seems plausible that they
specific memory representations so that perceive the position of the springboard
they know at which distance they need to during the (last part of the) run-up, thereby
pick up which information in order to again supporting the idea of an anticipatory
regulate the run-up with the aim of a control, thus enabling the gymnasts to
precise interaction with the vaulting precisely hit the springboard at the end of
apparatus during complex skills, such as a the round-off. One could argue that
Yurchenko timer. gymnasts compare the position of the
The round-off mat does not seem to springboard with their long-term memory
be a strong cue on movement regulation in representation of the movement, and the
the performance of the Yurchenko timers. appropriate places of the springboard. In
For instance, gymnasts have to place their addition, in both of the experimental
feet on a particular area on the springboard conditions the springboard was placed
in order to achieve optimum recoil during closer to the vault block, thus affording a
take-off, given the elastic properties of the slightly longer run-up, which may have
springboard (Čuk & Karacsony, 2004). resulted in a slightly more dynamic round-
The elasticity of the round-off mat, off, which in turn resulted in a longer flight
however, is rather equally distributed, and phase to support on the vault block.
there is in general no necessity to place the There are several limitations of the
hands on a particular spot on the round-off study which should be highlighted. First,
mat (as long as there is enough space left; the position of the springboard and the
George, 2010). This argumentation round-off mat were manipulated in steps of
receives support from a comparison of ten centimetres. One could argue that a
gymnasts’ motor behaviour in the stronger manipulation could lead to
experimental conditions, and in the different effects on movement regulation
baseline condition. One may speculate that of the Yurchenko timer. It could for
performing a rather constant round-off instance be of interest to assess the
flight phase could be one important relationship between the strength of
strategy in the performance of Yurchenko manipulating positional environmental
timers, as long as there is enough space left cues and gymnasts’ regulation capacity
on the round-off mat to place one’s hands when dealing with these manipulations.
during the round-off. Second, gymnasts were informed
At the same time, however, the about the manipulation of both, the
springboard seems to be a more important position of the springboard, and the
cue when performing Yurchenko timers position of the round-off mat mainly for
Progress in Retinal and Eye Research, 25, between thought and action (pp. 49-59).
296-324. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
doi:10.1016/j.preteyeres.2006.01.002 Renshaw, I., Davids, K., Chow, J-Y.,
Latash, M. L. (1993). Control of & Shuttleworth, R. (2009). Insights from
human movement. Champaign, IL: Human ecological psychology and dynamical
Kinetics. systems theory can underpin a philosophy
Latash, M. L. (2008). of coaching. International Journal of Sport
Neurophysiological basis of movement Psychology, 40, 580-602.
(2nd ed.). Champaign, IL: Human Rosenbaum, D. A., Cohen, R. G., Jax,
Kinetics. S. A., Van der Wel, R., & Weiss, D. J.
Lee, D. N., Lishman, J. R., & (2007). The problem of serial order in
Thomson, J. A. (1982). Regulation of gait behavior: Lashley’s legacy. Human
in long jumping. Journal of Experimental Movement Science, 26, 525-554.
Psychology: Human Perception and doi:10.1016/j.humov.2007.04.001
Performance, 8, 448-458. Sands, B., Caine, D. J., & Borms, J.
doi:10.1037/0096-1523.8.3.448 (Eds.) (2003). Scientific aspects of
Lee, D. N., Young, D. S., & Rewt, D. women's gymnastics. Medicine and Sport
(1992). How do somersaulters land on Science (Vol. 45). Basel: Karger.
their feet? Journal of Experimental Schack, T. (2003). The relationship
Psychology: Human Perception and between motor representation and
Performance, 18(4), 1195-1202. biomechanical parameters in complex
doi:10.1037/0096-1523.18.4.1195 movements: towards an integrative
Meeuwsen, H., & Magill, R. A. perspective of movement science.
(1987). The role of vision in gait control European Journal of Sport Science, 3(2),
during gymnastic vaulting. In T. B. 1-13. doi:10.1080/17461390300073201
Hoshizaki, J. H. Salmela, & B. Petiot Schack, T., Essig, K., Frank, C., &
(Eds.), Diagnostics, treatment and analysis Koester, D. (2014). Mental representation
of gymnastic talent (pp. 137-155). and motor imagery training. Frontiers in
Montreal: Congres Scientifique de Human Neuroscience, 8.
Gymnastique de Montreal, Inc. doi:10.3389/fnhum.2014.00328
Montagne, G., Cornus, S., Glize, D., Schack, T., & Ritter, H. (2009). The
Quaine, F., & Laurent, M. (2000). A cognitive nature of action-functional links
perception-action coupling type of control between cognitive psychology, movement
in long jumping. Journal of Motor science, and robotics. In M. Raab, J. G.
Behavior, 32(1), 37-43. Johnson, & H. Heekeren (Eds.), Progress
doi:10.1080/00222890009601358 in Brain Research: vol. 174. Mind and
O’Regan, J. K., & Noë, A. (2001). A motion: the bidirectional link between
sensorimotor account of vision and visual thought and action (pp. 231-250).
consciousness. Behavioral and Brain Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Sciences, 24, 939-1031. Schöllhorn, W. I., Hegen, P., &
Prinz, W. (1997). Perception and Davids, K. (2012). The nonlinear nature of
action planning. European Journal of learning. A differential learning approach.
Cognitive Psychology, 9(2), 129-154. The Open Sports Sciences Journal,
doi:10.1080/713752551 5(Suppl 1-M11), 100-112.
Raab, M., de Oliveira, R. F., & doi:10.2174/1875399X01205010100
Heinen, T. (2009). How do people Schmidt, R. A., Young, D. E.,
perceive and generate options? In M. Raab, Swinnen, S., & Shapiro, D. C. (1989).
J. G. Johnson, & H. Heekeren (Eds.), Summary knowledge of results for skill
Progress in Brain Research: vol. 174. acquisition: support for the guidance
Mind and motion: the bidirectional link hypothesis. Journal of Experimental
Corresponding author:
Thomas Heinen
Leipzig University
Faculty of Sport Science
Jahnallee 59
04199 Leipzig, Germany
phone: +49 (0) 341 / 97 – 31821
e-mail: thomas.heinen@uni-leipzig.de
For an efficient daily training of gymnasts and, at the end, for an efficient performance, it is
important to have an energy- and nutrient-sufficient diet, which enables a proper balance
between maintaining appropriate body composition, excellent physical preparation, and
general health. The combination of an intake of negative-calorie food and an increased
amount of training, which enables the control of body weight, can have negative
consequences when it comes to nutritional inadequacy, which can lead not only to a
weakened immune system but also to an insufficient recovery after daily trainings. Today,
athletes as well as gymnasts consume various dietary supplements to improve physical and
cognitive abilities, for a more efficient recovery, a stronger immune system, and an easier
control of appropriate body weight. A sufficient intake of omega-3 fatty acids – as is also true
of vitamin B12 and D – is usually a part of a special assessment of dietary habits and needs of
gymnasts, which they can fulfil with ordinary diet or dietary supplements. The purpose of this
article is to relatively clearly evaluate the scientific evidence about the potential benefits of
consuming omega-3 fatty acids (ALA, EPA, and DHA) for a variety of objectives for gymnasts
and, at the end, to critically sum them up in a sensible recommendation, while being aware of
limitations of the evidence. Furthermore, this article is intended to encourage researchers to
study the direct influence of nutrition and potentially beneficial and permitted dietary
supplements for a variety of objectives for gymnasts.
INTRODUCTION
and “half essential” derivatives of omega-3 essential omega-3 fatty acids, given the
fatty acids (EPA, i.e. eicosapentaenoic acid fact that it does not synthesize the omega-3
and DHA, i.e. docosahexaenoic acid) (EPA fatty acids by itself, especially in addition
and DHA are not technically “essential” to the total food intake that already
because they can be produced contains a lot of saturated fat and the fact
endogenously, but the process is slow and that a fish may be potentially quite
inefficient and is affected by genetics, sex, contaminated with industrial chemicals.
age, and dietary composition (Saunder, They also wonder if we really need EPA
Davis & Garg, 2013)), there exists a and DHA in addition to ALA, which are
concern from the side of the gymnasts known as essential fats, and what the risks
about the potential inadequacy of the are of regular consumption of fish or EPA
intake of omega-3 fatty acids due to and DHA dietary supplements, extracted
different qualities of nutrition, which from fish oil or seaweed. Contradictory
controls the energy intake. There is also evidence, which is usually the result of
the need to evaluate the studies that have different study designs, erroneous
proven the potential benefits of consuming interpretations, conflicts of interest of
omega-3 fatty acids in the form of dietary researchers, and consequently
supplements on the improvement of body contradictory information, which appears
composition, physical and cognitive in various sports media, does not always
abilities, and recovery. Gymnasts also wish offer credible information to the gymnasts
to know whether the fish that contain also and, consequently, affects making the right
non-essential fatty acids (e.g. saturated fat) decisions.
(Fats are usually divided into two
categories (Haver, 2016): essential (EFAs) Characteristics of competitive artistic
and non-essential fatty acids (non-EFAs). gymnastics
EFAs belong to the group of A successful performance on the
polyunsaturated fats – PUFA (i.e. α- floor, the pommel horse, the rings, the
linolenic acid or ALA, omega-3 fatty acid vault, the parallel bars, and the horizontal
and linoleic acid or LA, omega-6 fatty bar requires a number of motor skills, such
acid) and since the body cannot synthesize as speed, strength, endurance, agility,
them, it must obtain them from food. Plants flexibility, and balance, while the level of
are generally the original source of both gymnast's skills is tightly connected with
types of PUFA in the food chain (found in the absence of injury (Sleeper, Kenyon,
seeds and their respective oils, soybean, Elliot & Cheng, 2012). Appropriate body
microalgae, fish, and marine oils). Non- weight, excellently developed motor skills,
EFAs, which the body does not need to get and a high level of various perceptual
from food, belong to the group of abilities enable the gymnasts to control
monounsaturated fats – MUFA (found in their posture while executing demanding
olives, avocados, certain nuts and seeds elements, despite the fact that they cannot
and their respective oils; considered completely rely on their eyesight. Because
neutral or potentially beneficial) and competitive gymnastics (Marina &
saturated fats – SFA (found in animal Rodríguez, 2014) demands a combination
products, vegetable oils, and tropical fats of explosive and submaximal muscle
such as palm and coconut; can promote contractions when executing numerous
CVD). Trans fatty acids – TFA are also demanding elements, there is also a
non-EFAs but are laboratory-made via relatively high heart rate (from 170–190
hydrogenation and are found in processed, beats/min with women and from 150–180
fried, and fast food and are not considered beats/min with men). Due to repetitive
safe) are even a healthy and a gymnastics elements with short breaks
representative food for the intake of (lasting up to 90 seconds), competitive
Dyerberg as proof that the Eskimo have a recommended to consume – especially for
lower incidence of cardiovascular disease the health of a pregnant woman, a nursing
when this is scientifically not entirely mother, and the proper development of the
correct. Therefore, those types of claims fetus – at least 250 mg of EPA and DHA
are either a result of misinterpretation or a from the source of sea fish or marine
case of study’s bias. Despite the fact that microalgae (Flock, Harris & Kris-Etherton,
there is a need for more well-designed 2013). Meanwhile, Simopoulos (2007)
studies that would strengthen the position states, based on the available scientific
of omega-3 fatty acids in the science of evidence, that it is recommended for most
nutrition and nutrients, there is quite a high athletes to consume omega-3 fatty acids in
amount of scientific evidence connected quantities of 1–2 g of EPA and DHA daily
with the potential benefits and protective in the ratio 2:1. If we think about the
effects of omega-3 fatty acids. benefits and potential risks, we can see that
fish is not the most appropriate source of
Sources of omega-3 fatty acids EPA and DHA, because it is contaminated
Omega-3 fatty acids consist of short with polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB),
chains (ALA) and long chains (EPA and dioxin, mercury, and other heavy metals
DHA) of omega-3 fatty acids. ALA can be (Jacobs, Ruzzin & Lee, 2014). The
found in flaxseeds, hemp seeds, and chia Slovenian Jožef Stefan Institute measured
seeds, in walnuts, soya, and, in smaller the content of mercury in 52 fresh fish and
amounts, also in dark green vegetables, 56 canned fish on the Slovenian market
e.g. Brussels sprouts, spinach, and sea and discovered that with a typical portion
vegetables, while EPA and DHA are (100 g) of fresh fish we consume from
present in marine microalgae and plankton 58% to 1940% of mercury, while with a
and also in fish that feed on marine typical portion of canned fish we consume
microalgae (the fish get EPA and DHA from 3% to 1556% of the permitted daily
from a primary source, i.e. by consuming intake of mercury (Zajc, 2006). A recent
seaweed. The amount of EPA and DHA study, conducted in five EU countries
fatty acids in certain types of fish depends (Belgium, Ireland, Italy, Portugal, and
on their environment and the type of the Spain), which assessed the risks of the
consumed seaweed) e.g. salmon, sardines, contamination of fish with different
tuna, mackerel, and others. The World chemicals from the environment, showed a
Health Organization (WHO), the Food and typical contamination with mercury in
Agriculture Organization of the United tuna, hake, cod, bream, sea bass, and
Nations (FAO), and the European Food octopus. The authors state that these results
Safety Authority (EFSA) specify the and the examination of the results from
recommended daily intake for adults other authors indicate a justified need to
(RDI), which is 0.5% (up to 2 grams) of inform people about the benefits of
ALA calories (FAO, 2010). According to consuming certain fish as well as the
the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics potential health risks (Jacobs et al., 2016).
(AND), a person may already consume the Most of the fish is not only contaminated
RDI of ALA with one spoon of flaxseeds with mercury (Nielsen, Kit, Aoki &
and chia seeds, and partly by eating dark Ogden, 2014) and PCBs, but also party
green vegetables and various berries contaminated with dioxin and chlorinated
(Vannice & Rasmussen, 2014). Even pesticides, which have harmful effects on
though our body can synthesize EPA and the nervous, immune, and cardiovascular
DHA from ALA, clinical studies have system (Bushkin-Bedient & Carpenter,
shown a potential inadequate or inefficient 2010). On the other hand, the most widely
conversion, which results in the current used dietary supplements with omega-3
consensus of WHO and EFSA that it is fatty acids on the market are produced
exactly from fish oil. Numerous companies fatty acids (EPA and DHA) in the form of
usually clean the various industrial dietary supplements. Their arguments are,
chemicals found in fish oil, but these firstly, that the body cannot efficiently
processes of removal are not always convert the essential omega-3 fatty acids
effective with fat-soluble toxins, such as (ALA) into EPA and DHA and, secondly,
dioxin and PCB (Fernandes, Rose, White, that certain individuals do not consume
Mortimer & Gem, 2006). In addition, in (enough) fish, which are a rich source of
many cases there exists a well-founded EPA and DHA. Under the term “omega-3
concern about the potential oxidation of fatty acids” we usually think of the
fish oils due to the potential presence of essentially short chain of omega-3 fatty
heavy metals, inappropriate composition of acids (ALA), which the body converts into
fatty acids, exposure to oxygen, light, and SDA (i.e. stearidonic acid), EPA, and
temperature, the content of antioxidants, DHA omega-3 fatty acids. SDA can be
and the presence of water (Cameron- directly consumed with blackcurrant, hemp
Smith, Albert & Cutfield, 2015). We seeds, or fish, and EPA and DHA with fish
should devote special attention to fish or eggs, sea vegetables (EPA), and marine
when an individual is allergic or sensitive microalgae (EPA and DHA). The
to it or to fish oils or when an individual is conversion from ALA into EPA and DHA
taking certain pills (e.g. for thinning the is slow and inefficient and generally
blood or lowering blood sugar). However, depends on heredity, gender, age, and
fish oils are in general considered as a dietary patterns (under the dietary factors
dietary nutrient without negative side we consider a large enough intake of ALA,
effects (NIH, 2015), given that we control consuming food that helps with the
the factors that may influence their conversion of ALA into EPA and DHA
adulteration. In addition to the already (e.g. fruit and vegetables), an inadequate
mentioned potential problems, there intake of protein and fasting, consuming
remains the concern of increased food that inhibits the process (e.g.
environmental pressure (the increasing saturated and trans fats, too much omega-
number of population, global warming) on 6 fatty acids, dietary cholesterol, alcohol),
the fish population, which poses a direct intake of DHA from the source of
legitimate question about the adequacy of sea fish or marine microalgae, while under
consuming fish or fish oils (Kang, 2011). the non-dietary factors we count age (when
On the other hand, the market offers more we get older the conversion decreases),
and more EPA and DHA dietary gender (women have better synthesis),
supplements that are produced from chronic diseases (diabetes, high blood
laboratory cultured seaweed and are, from pressure, high cholesterol), smoking, and
the standpoint of clinical efficiency, hereditary differences Saunder, Davis &
comparable with fish oil, without any Garg, 2013). Scientists assess that the
traces of industrial chemicals (Doughman, body can convert approximately 0.3 to
Krupanidhi & Sanjeevi, 2007). There are 21% of ALA into EPA and 0–9% into
also no signs of digestive problems DHA, while women, compared to men,
(diarrhea) or any consequences of the taste have a significantly higher percentage of
of fish after consumption (burping) or converting ALA into EPA (Burdge, Jones
belching (Neff et al., 2011). & Wootton, 2002; Burdge & Wootton,
2002), but not ALA into DHA (Childs et
Potential inadequacy of EPA and DHA al., 2014). If the intake of omega-6 fatty
omega-3 fatty acids acids (e.g. consuming various types of
Numerous professionals for vegetables oils) is too high, it may slow
maintaining optimal health advocate the down the process of conversion for up to
consumption of either fish or omega-3 40–54% (Emken, Adolf & Gulley, 1994;
Gerster, 1998), while a low-fat diet and Omega-3 fatty acids and diets without fish
calorie restriction improve the level of or vegan diets
conversion of ALA into EPA and DHA Our body is able, with the right
(Das, 2006). A randomized controlled amount and ratio between omega-6 (LA)
cross-over study measured the effect of a and omega-3 fatty acids (ALA), to
low-fat (20% of fat) and high-fat diet (45% synthesize DHA and EPA from the
of fat) lasting for 12 weeks, where the two essential ALA, but it often raises the
diets had the same amount of calories and question of sufficiency, which is why
a similar ratio between omega-6 and today there is a scientific consensus that
omega-3 fatty acids. The researchers DHA are most likely essential fats. Rosell
discovered that the low-fat diet enabled a et al. (2005) discovered that the
higher percentage of conversion of ALA concentration of ALA in the blood plasma
into EPA and DHA compared with the is similar with vegetarians and non-
high-fat diet (Raatz, Bibus, Thomas & vegetarians, while the concentration of
Kriss-Etherton, 2001). On the other hand, a EPA and DHA is lower with vegetarians
direct intake of DHA, e.g. by eating fish, (28% and 31%) and even lower with
eggs, or dietary supplements, slows down vegans (53% and 59%), but that it is stable.
the process of conversion of ALA into (Welch et al. (2010) discovered that people
EPA and DHA from 72% to 88%, which who do not eat fish (vegans, vegetarians
means that we can potentially increase the who do not eat fish, “carnivores” who do
percentage of conversion of ALA into not eat fish) consume from 57% to 80%
DHA by not eating the direct source of less omega-3 fatty acids in comparison
DHA (e.g. fish) (Emken, Adolf, Duval & with people who eat fish, although the
Nelson, 1999; Welch, Shakya-Shrestha, differences in the index of omega-3 fatty
Lentjes, Wareham & Khaw, 2010). acids in the blood plasma are then smaller,
Smoking during pregnancy also results in most likely due to the already discovered
worsening the conversion of ALA into better conversion of ALA into EPA and
EPA and DHA in the breast milk DHA with people who do not eat fish). .In
(Marangoni et al., 2004). Scientifically one study (Sarter, Kelsey, Schwartz &
speaking, it is undisputable that humans do Harris, 2015) the researchers wanted to
not need to consume fish at any stage of define the index of omega-3 fatty acids in
their life in order to achieve optimal health, 165 long-term vegans and the differences
but they do need ALA. Clinical between different age groups and gender
interventions in people with a previous and compare this measured index with
lack of consuming DHA from a direct people who have an omnivorous diet. The
source show that DHA is most likely a researchers also wanted to determine the
half-essential fatty acid. Health authorities extent to which this index of omega-3 fatty
for adult males and non-pregnant/non- acids (a biomarker that is expressed as the
lactating adult females recommend daily percentage (%) of EPA and DHA content
intakes of EPA and DHA ranging from in red blood cells based on the entire
250 to 550 mg/day (FAO, 2010; Harris et amount of fat in red blood cells) can
al., 2009). People can consume it from improve by prescribing 46 participants
more representative and less unhealthy with the initial index lower than 4%
sources than directly eating different types (authors assume that anything lower than
of fish rich in EPA and DHA, which can 4% is undesirable) a daily dietary
also be applied to gymnasts. supplement of 254 mg of EPA and DHA
from seaweed for four months. They
discovered that two thirds of the assessed
vegans have an index of omega-3 fatty
acids that is lower than 4% (even though
they consume enough ALA), but this is in showed that this type of intervention is not
general similar to people who have justifiable for the needs of primary or
omnivorous diet (the control group) and secondary prevention against
who also do not consume fish on a regular cardiovascular diseases (Greene, Ashburn,
basis (3.5%). Even though it is not exactly Razzouk & Smith, 2013; Kowey, Reiffel,
clear whether a lower index of omega-3 Ellenbogen, Kromhout, Giltay &
fatty acids has negative consequences on Geleijnse, 2010; Kwak, Myung, Lee &
health, the authors conclude that vegans Seo, 2012). Even a decade ago, a
from this study improved their index above systematic overview of 48 randomized
4% after the four-month supplementation. controlled studies and 41 cohort studies did
To conclude, the results of epidemiological not show any positive effect of consuming
research consistently suggest that a long- fish or fish oil on health or, in other words,
term deficiency of DHA in vegans presents a lower incidence of cardiovascular disease
a potential risk for impaired cognitive and cancer or a lower mortality rate
functioning in a later period of life. But, on (Hooper et al., 2006). Cundiff, Lanou, and
the other hand, there is no direct evidence Nigg (2007) emphasize that a credible
that the rise in the index of omega-3 fatty research that would confirm the inverse
acids has an additional positive effect on relationship between consuming fish and
their health, which is already protected by omega-3 fatty acids from the source of
a vegan diet. dietary supplements and the incidence of
cardiovascular disease does not exist. A
Consuming fish or omega-3 dietary lower incidence is most likely a
supplements and health throughout life consequence of dietary factors (in general
Omega-3 fatty acids are a healthier eating pattern) and a lifestyle
polyunsaturated fatty acids, which are that is a result of people who are more
present in certain types of food. They are a aware and also eat fish. It is generally
part of the essential nutrients, which means accepted that decreasing the amount of
we are supposed to consume them daily saturated fats and dietary cholesterol in
with our food. They represent vital food (meat and meat products, milk and
components of various cell structures of dairy products, eggs, fish, oils), not
the brain, the nervous system, the cell smoking, and regular physical exercise
membranes, and chemical processes, and reduces the risk of cardiovascular disease.
they are also responsible for the transfer Based on examining the results of 20
and oxidation of cholesterol. In various randomized controlled studies of adults,
studies (discussed below) EPA and DHA which measured the effect of consuming
were connected with an improved general omega-3 fatty acids on the primary and
and cardiovascular health (the main cause secondary prevention of cardiovascular
of death in Western societies), improved disease, Rizos, Ntzani, Bika, Kostapanos,
cognitive and physical abilities, control of and Elisaf (2012) discovered that the
body weight, fetal development during supplementation with omega-3 fatty acids
pregnancy, and various diseases, which is is not connected with a lower risk of
the reason why many scientists mortality from any reasons. In the past,
recommend a regular consumption of fish some studies showed the benefits of
or omega-3 dietary supplements. An consuming fish and fish oil in the form of
overview of randomized controlled studies dietary supplements on cardiovascular
conducted on a number of people and of health, while recent studies do not confirm
double-blind placebo-controlled studies, this, most likely due to a lower quality of
which examined the influence of modern nutrition, which cannot be
consuming fish or fish oils (EPA and improved by simply consuming
DHA) in the form of dietary supplements, contaminated and inadequately prepared
fish, which also contain a high level of reductionist approach to the study, which
saturated fat and dietary cholesterol, or by wishes to measure the difference by
consuming a few pills of dietary increasing or decreasing one nutrient or a
supplements. An in-depth overview of a certain type of food, rarely brings the
few studies that showed the potential expected health outcomes. At the same
benefits of consuming fish and fish oil, in time, this type of study bares no greater
comparison with those studies that did not utility value, since it is a dietary pattern
show that, revealed that there is basically that makes a difference in the end.
no controversy, since the main problem of Competitive gymnastics is, among
intervention studies (in addition to the other things, a sport discipline “for life”
potentially rancid fish oil) is the surplus of and gymnasts are first and foremost people
the prescribed 3 g of fish oil. Studies and that is why it is ethical that their sports
indicate a problematic negative influence goals are not achieved at the expense of
of the amount of EPA and DHA higher their health. Gymnastics is also a sport
than 1 g or, in other words, we get a U- discipline with a majority of female
shaped curve of the influence of population (e.g. data for Portugal for the
consuming omega-3 fatty acids on health, year 2012 shows that from the sample of
where an intake that is too small or too 14742 gymnasts from all gymnastic
large presents a health risk, especially for disciplines 81.2% are female and only
atrial fibrillation, which is the most 16.7% are male (Silva & Barata, 2016). In
common disorder of heart rate in adults the USA (USAGym, 2016) there are over 5
(Metcalf et al., 2014) that significantly million registered gymnasts over the age of
increases the risk of a stroke. An 6 and the majority of them are female
appropriate, but not exceeded, intake of (76%)) so it is probably worth stressing the
EPA and DHA can have a positive importance of consuming omega-3 fatty
influence on cardiovascular health. Most acids as an essential nutrient that a person
likely one of the best studies in recent does not consume naturally from a
years assessed the benefits and risks of an representative source in the event they are
adequate level of EPA and DHA in 2692 not properly informed or do not have a
participants without any cardiovascular properly planned diet. Gymnasts often end
diseases and with an average age of 75 their career in the late teenage years or
years. Here, the researchers relied on the early 20s and many take on various roles in
measurements of blood and discovered that the world of gymnastics, so it seems
an intake of 250–400 mg of EPA and DHA reasonable that female gymnasts acquire
results in a lower mortality rate due to information about the importance of
cardiovascular diseases (Mozaffarian et al., omega-3 fatty acids in connection with
2013). Observational and interventional motherhood and breastfeeding, which is
studies that examine the influence of a what usually follows after the period of
certain type (monounsaturated and performing in competitions. There is also a
polyunsaturated, saturated, and trans fat) or justified concern that many female
the amount of fat on the factors and the gymnasts, especially in the time of
incidence of cardiovascular disease clearly puberty, develop an eating disorder
state that a higher intake of trans fat and (energy deficiency and nutritional
saturated fat leads to a higher incidence of insufficiency), which is usually connected
cardiovascular disease, while a higher with dissatisfaction with appearance and
intake of omega-3 fatty acids leads to a the attempt to improve their performance
lower incidence of cardiovascular disease. (Nordin, Harris & Cumming, 2003). Eating
These findings do not support the disorders (eating disorder in athletes is
interventional study in a consistent or characterized by a wide spectrum of
statistically significant manner. A maladaptive eating and weight control
behaviors and attitudes. These include the potential positive effect of DHA in the
concerns about body weight and shape; majority of fish (Zeilmaker et al., 2013).
poor nutrition or inadequate caloric Eating habits throughout the person’s
intake, or both; binge eating; use of entire life are equally important, since
laxatives, diuretics, and diet pills; and exposure to heavy metals, PCBs, and other
extreme weight control methods, such as industrial chemicals in the period of
fasting, vomiting, and excessive exercise breastfeeding, childhood, and adolescence
(Bonci et al., 2008)), which are proven to (breastmilk, eating fish) has a long-term
be connected with hormonal imbalance negative effect for decades to come,
(reproductive disorders), are more frequent including the period of pregnancy (Glynn
with female athletes in aesthetic sports et al., 2007). Consuming DHA dietary
than in endurance and team sports supplements during pregnancy has proved
(Torstveit & Sundgot-Borgen, 2014). to be unjustified in some cognitive tests
Estimates of incidence of eating disorders, with properly fed and healthy children,
which can have negative, sometimes even which some studies that were included in
fatal, consequences on health as well as on previous scientific reviews did not include,
physical performance, reach up to 62% e.g. the test of attention, working memory,
with female athletes and 33% with male or the precision of looking for the hidden
athletes (Bonci et al., 2008). There are toy (Gould, Makrides, Colombo &
concerns over the negative energy balance Smithers, 2014). One of the last studies
among gymnasts in the period between 6 (Shulkin et al., 2016), which examined the
and 15 years of age, since there is a high influence of supplementation with omega-
risk of pathological eating disorder 3 fatty acids during pregnancy and
(Malina et al., 2013) that can manifest into breastfeeding, was based on 15 studies
a mental disorder even later in life, after which included 2525 children and it
the finished period of competing, due to concluded that EPA and DHA
different pressures of the environment and supplementation during pregnancy or in
expected behavior. Besides the the period of breastfeeding improves the
recommendations on the appropriate child’s development of the nervous system.
energy and micro nutrient sufficiency and Asthma is a chronic inflammation of the
a regular exposure to sunlight for the respiratory tract that is also present among
required vitamin D, the information on the athletes and the nutrition of the Western
needs of the essential omega-3 fatty acids world, which is based on a high content of
are also important in order to avoid fat, might be one of the most important
potential reproductive disorders in female risk factors (Wood, Garg & Gibson, 2011).
gymnasts. The recommended daily intake A systematic overview of 7 observational
of DHA during pregnancy is therefore at studies, which examined the connection of
least 200 mg daily, but that does not mean asthma and consuming fish or EPA and
that pregnant women are encouraged to eat DHA from fish oils during the time of
fish, since most of them are contaminated, pregnancy, revealed that consuming fish or
among other substances with mercury, EPA and DHA is inversely related with the
which is a neurotoxin that especially development of asthma in childhood. This
damages the fetus (Koletzko, Cetin & analysis only adds evidence to the existing
Brenna, 2007). A quantitative assessment literature of randomized controlled studies
of the risk of contamination with mercury about the importance of consuming
when consuming fish and the benefits due omega-3 fatty acids for general health, the
to the content of DHA that was done by health of pregnant women, and babies
the Dutch scientists showed that the (Yang, Xun & He, 2013) as well as for
negative effect of mercury on the reducing the incidence of asthma and
intelligence quotient (IQ) is greater than respiratory infections in childhood
(Bisgaard et al., 2016). Breastmilk contains 6 months and was conducted on 176
variable amounts of DHA, which depend healthy non-smokers, aged between 18 and
on the diet of the nursing mother, raising 45, who rarely consumed fish before the
the question whether consuming omega-3 study (an intake of less than 200 mg of
fatty acids in the form of dietary EPA and DHA per week), demonstrated
supplements might only be beneficial in positive effects of consuming EPA and
the event when the pregnant woman does DHA dietary supplements on certain
not eat fish on a regular basis. Nursing aspects of the cognitive functioning of the
mothers who had a vegan diet in one of the brain and also showed differences in
studies had a lower amount of DHA in gender. In the intervention, the total intake
their milk when compared with vegetarians was 170 mg of EPA and 1160 mg of DHA,
and nursing mothers who had an which is comparable with the existing
omnivorous diet, but researches did not guidelines of a healthy diet that
find any consequences of these differences recommend eating fish rich in omega-3
in the growth or the neurological and fatty acids two to three times per week.
intellectual development of the children, as The authors of the research state possible
long as their nutrition contained an reasons for the different results of other
appropriate intake of vitamin B12 (Sanders randomized controlled studies in
& Reddy, 1992). According to recent examining the influence of consuming
studies, the general belief is that a lower omega-3 fatty acids on brain health,
content of DHA in the breastmilk in not including the short duration of the studies
necessarily connected with a defective in which they could not measure the
development of the fetus (Mulder, King & significant effect, distinguishing the effects
Innis, 2014). However, in several examples between gender, the diversity of effects
in which they could suffer a fatal lack of that can be expected (memory, the reaction
DHA needed for a comprehensive and time of memory, attention, speed of
long-term cognitive development, there is processing), different amounts of
a consensus that pregnant women and intervention of EPA and DHA fats,
nursing mothers should consume 200 mg different initial states of the participants
of DHA (Koletzko, Cetin & Brenna, according to the consumption of omega-3
2007), probably best in the form of a fatty acids, etc., which could lead to
dietary supplement from a non-toxic inaccurate conclusions. Yurko-Mauro et al.
source. (2010) conducted a randomized double-
blind study of 485 healthy adults older
Consuming fish or omega-3 dietary than 55 years, which lasted for 2 years and
supplements and cognitive abilities in which they measured the influence of a
Researchers conducted a randomized daily supplementation of 900 mg of DHA
double-blind study of almost 3000 omega-3 fatty acids. The intervention
cardiovascular patients, aged between 60 group, compared with the placebo-
and 80, in the period of 40 months, where controlled group, showed an improvement
one group received 400 -mg of EPA and in learning and functioning of the memory
DHA in the form of a dietary supplement and other cognitive abilities connected
from fish oils, the second group 2 g of with ageing. Meanwhile, Chew et al.
ALA from plants, and the third and fourth (2015) conducted a randomized double-
group placebo, and they did not observe blind study of 4203 people with some sort
any positive effect on the cognitive of risk, e.g. developing age-related macular
functioning of the brain (Geleijnse, Giltay degeneration, where the experimental
& Kromhout, 2012). On the other hand, a group consumed 1 g of omega-3 dietary
randomized double-blind study supplement daily for 5 years (350 mg of
(Stonehouse et al., 2013) which lasted for EPA and 650 mg of DHA), and they did
not demonstrate any significant effects on daily on the functioning of the nervous and
cognitive health. The authors indicated that motor system of 34 professional female
the possible reasons for the inefficient football players. The test instrument was a
supplementation on cognitive health of the part of the ASDE driver test and consisted
participants could be attributed to their of a series of psychological tests to assess
good nutritional status and high education, psychomotor and perceptual-motor skills.
the short period of intervention, and a The test examined the response to visual
possible late start of the intervention, since and auditory stimuli and registered
the average age of the participants was responses. The researchers discovered that
72.7 years at the beginning of the study. the experimental group had better results
Another study examined the brains with when it came to complex reaction time,
MRI twice in the period of 5 years and accuracy, and efficiency (a more
revealed that 3660 people older than 65 appropriate selection of technical and
years, who in general consumed more food tactical solutions). The authors conclude
with omega-3 fatty acids, especially DHA, that the reliability of the study is connected
had healthier brains (Virtanen et al., 2013). with the homogeneity of the sample and
A study that examined the connection the control of the intake of macronutrients
between the intake of EPA and DHA and between the two groups, but there are
the volume of the brain, which is justified concerns about the potentially
connected with a lower risk for dementia, inadequate nutrition of the female football
included 1575 participants and showed, players, since their 3050 calories per day
using MRI and various cognitive tests, that consisted of 16% of protein, 44% of fat,
a lower amount of DHA fats in the blood is and only 40% of carbohydrates. Numerous
associated with a smaller volume of the researchers examined the potential
brain and an impairment of cognitive correlation between the consumption of
functioning of the brain, even in people dietary supplements EPA and DHA and
without clinical dementia (Tan et al., the effect on cognitive abilities and mood,
2012). With a randomized double-blind which is the basis for consistently
study they confirmed for the first time the successful trainings and performances in
conclusions of the predecessors and, in a various sport disciplines. With some
research that lasted for 26 weeks, with an studies (Fontani, Lodi, Migliorini &
intervention of 2.2 mg of omega-3 fatty Corradeschi, 2009), but not all (Jackson,
acids from the source of fish oils, showed Reay, Scholey & Kennedy, 2012),
that consuming DHA and EPA is researchers have reported on the
connected with a better cognitive improvement of the learning curve or, in
functioning and a microstructural integrity other words, visual attention and speed of
of the brain of healthy older adults (Witte information processing. Fontani et al.
et al,. 2014). (2009) took a sample of martial arts
The hypothesis of the effect of omega- athletes to measure the influence of
3 fatty acids (more precisely DHA) on consuming 2.25 g of omega-3 fatty acids
cognitive abilities is based on a double on maintaining alertness and attentiveness
effect on the improved complex of reaction and they discovered an improvement in the
efficiency, namely slower fatigue, which experimental group when it came to
enables a constant efficiency of motor reaction time and mood. In one double-
sensations, and improving the processes of blind cross-over study that included 13
motoric sensations, leading to shorter young adults, Bauer et al. (2014) compared
reaction times and higher accuracy. A the influence of DHA (417 mg of DHA
double-blind study (Guzmán et al., 2011) and 159 mg of EPA daily) with the
examined the influence of a 4-week influence of EPA (590 mg of EPA and 137
intervention of consuming 3.5 g of DHA mg of DHA daily) on the functioning of
the nervous system while executing Vassos & Asherson, 2015) that examined
cognitive tasks (STROOP, SWM, and the effect of supplementation of omega-3
SUCCAB tests) and discovered a higher fatty acids on cognitive abilities or ADHD,
efficiency of EPA in visual neural recovery failed to prove the eligibility of the
and the choice of reaction times. intervention, despite some individual
Some gymnasts face the most frequent studies with formulations with more EPA
neurobehavioral disorder from early (perhaps because of lower concentrations
childhood on; the attention deficit of omega-3 fatty acids in plasma and red
hyperactivity disorder or ADHD, but only blood cells in children and adolescents
a few ever speak of it. (the fourfold with ADHD). This was most likely due to
American Olympic champion Simone Biles the incompatibility of various components
(Turner, 2016) and the twofold British of cognitive abilities and the tests that were
Olympic silver medalist in competitive used. The authors therefore warn that in
gymnastics Louis Smith (BBC, 2016) also practice there is a serious problem, due to
suffer from ADHD). Healthcare professions the unwarranted advertising of the positive
usually solve the problem of restlessness, influence of consuming omega-3 fatty
problems with attention and monitoring acids on cognitive abilities, since the
heart rate, and in some cases hyperactivity, claims about the potential benefits on
which results in problems with learning, cognitive abilities should be limited only to
discipline, anxiety, and depression, by certain conditions.
prescribing pills that have a number of
perceived side effects. Inappropriate Consuming fish or omega-3 dietary
nutrition, in connection with hereditary and supplements and systemic inflammations,
environmental factors, presents an DOMS, and mood
important risk factor in preventing or Muldoon et al. (2015) conducted a
controlling ADHD (Curatolo, D'Agati & randomized controlled study with 261
Moavero, 2010). Authors Howard et al. healthy adults, aged 30 to 54, examining
(2011) connect ADHD with the nutrition the influence of 1400 mg of EPA and DHA
of the Western world, which is (1000 mg of EPA and 400 mg of DHA)
characterized by micronutrient from fish oils in the form of a dietary
insufficiency and an excess of energy supplement on the potential reduction of
density and is full of highly processed food systemic inflammations. In a period of 18
containing saturated fats, salt, and sugar. weeks, the researchers compared the
On the other hand, an overview of intervention group and the placebo-
scientific effects of omega-3 fatty acids on controlled group and found no reduction of
ADHD showed that the supplementation systemic inflammation, which was
with EPA and DHA in the period of 3 to 4 measured by general markers of
months significantly improved ADHD inflammation (CRP, IL-6, IL-1β, IL-8, and
symptoms, especially in connection with TNF-α), even though supplementation
GLA omega-6 fatty acids (Transler, brought a 64% increase in EPA and DHA
Eilander, Mitchell & van de Meer, 2010). in the red blood cells. Consuming EPA and
An analysis of 10 randomized, placebo- DHA in the form of a dietary supplement
controlled studies, which included 699 did result in a better “condition” of the
children, showed “only” a moderate blood, but it did not reduce systemic
efficiency in comparison with the currently inflammation, most likely because the
used pills, but the authors do emphasize a participants in the study were healthy. The
relatively innocuous side effect profile of CRP of 75% of the participants was under
omega-3 fatty acids (Bloch & Qawasmi, 2 ng/mL before the beginning of the study,
2011). Another analysis of 24 randomized but additional analysis of the group with
controlled studies (Cooper, Tye, Kuntsi, the initial CRP above 2 ng/mL or IL-6
above the reference values also showed no lasted for 28 days before the beginning of a
change in the markers of systemic training period that lasted for 17 days and
inflammation. In the modern world, two- was tested on 41 untrained men, which
thirds of adults are overweight and that is included an eccentric exercise for the
why they usually have abnormal markers strength of flexors in the elbow, while the
pointing to systemic inflammations. Eating researchers examined the progress of
animal source foods, such as dairy isometric strength and flexibility as well as
products, meat, eggs, and vegetable oils, DOMS after 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 12, and 17 days.
increases inflammations in the body. Even The research showed encouraging results
a single high-fat meal may increase of consuming DHA on the reduction of
inflammations in the body within a couple certain markers of muscle damage
of hours, which can mostly be seen in throughout the 17 days of executing the
arteries that are more stiff and narrowed eccentric exercise for building strength.
(Bui et al., 2010; Vogel, Corretti & Gray, Chappell, Jenkinson, Thies, and
Plotnick, 2000), and can contribute to Gray (2014) came to the same conclusions,
chronic inflammatory diseases of the namely that some (not all) markers of
respiratory system (Rosenkranz, oxidative stress did improve in the
Townsend, Steffens & Harms, 2010). randomized, double-blind, placebo-
The next potential benefit of controlled study that lasted for 6 weeks
consuming omega-3 fatty acids for and included a single exercise (extension
gymnasts is the influence on the reduction of the knee) in eccentric conditions. A
of inflammatory processes in the body due similar assessment was also given by
to an individual exercise or exercise researchers (Corder, Newsham, McDaniel,
program, which can further reduce delayed Ezekiel & Weiss, 2016) who conducted a
onset muscle soreness (DOMS). One of the randomized, placebo-controlled study,
randomized, double-blind, placebo- which included 14 women (the placebo
controlled studies that was conducted on group consisted of 13 women) and
45 healthy men, who were not included in measured the influence on the
any exercise program prior to the study, inflammatory processes and DOMS with
examined the influence of consuming 1.8 g an intervention of 3 g of DHA from
of omega-3 fatty acids in the form of a seaweed 7 days before and 2 days after an
dietary supplement on the inflammatory eccentric exercise for strength. DOMS in
processes during an eccentric exercise the experimental group was reduced by
(numerous gymnastic elements include 23%, while numerous participants of the
rotations around the horizontal or linear placebo group could not extend their elbow
axis and are executed with eccentric even 48 hours after the eccentric exercise.
muscle contractions of the legs and arms) Authors conclude that intervention with a
which was tested before the exercise, DHA dietary supplement ensures a better
immediately after it, 24 hours later, and 48 preservation of the amplitude around the
hours later. The research team found that joint in days of strenuous eccentric
the 4-week intervention with omega-3 fatty trainings and can be efficient in reducing
acids, in connection with the eccentric DOMS and muscles stiffness and when
exercise, was efficient in reducing the introducing a new training program for the
inflammatory markers (Tartibian, Maleki athlete, which can have a positive
& Abbasi, 2011). It is important for influence on the process of adapting to the
gymnasts that the potential reduction of training. One of the most representative
inflammatory processes is also connected studies was a randomized, double-blind,
with reducing DOMS. DiLorenzo, Drager, placebo-controlled study which was done
and Rankin (2016) examined the effect of by Atashak et al. (2013). They examined
a prior consumption of 2 g of DHA that 20 young athletes and measured the effect
of consuming 900 mg of EPA and DHA One of the main arguments for
daily on the level of oxidative stress, recommending a regular consumption of
muscle damage, and inflammatory markers fish or omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and
in a single high-intensity training for DHA) in the form of a dietary supplement
building strength (a scientifically already is that EPA and DHA are vital for the
used protocol, i.e. circuit training with 3 functioning of the brain and proper mood
exercises for strength, 4 series of 7 to 10 state. An overview of 13 randomized,
repetitions until failure, and 3-minute placebo-controlled studies that were
breaks) and measured the improvement in conducted on 731 participants and
biomarkers of inflammations and muscle examined the impact of the efficiency of
damages, with which they have proven a EPA and DHA omega-3 fatty acids on the
potential effectiveness of consuming level of depression did not show any
omega-3 fatty acids in minimizing significant benefits of prescribing omega-3
oxidative injuries and systemic fatty acids for treating depression (Bloch
inflammation due to a single high-intensity and Hannestad, 2012). On the other hand,
training for building strength, which the cross-over and intervention studies
included an eccentric function. On the have shown that a vegan diet, or even
other hand, another study (Bloomer et al., avoiding meat and fish for 14 days, has a
2009) failed to show a positive influence significantly positive effect on the mood
of consuming omega-3 fatty acids on the state, stress, and depression, even though
reduction of inflammatory processes or vegans had a lower level of EPA and DHA
DOMS, but this does not lessen the value in the blood. This is most likely due to
of previous results, since the study was avoiding high-protein (less arachidonic
conducted on an unrepresentative training acid, which is the precursor of
protocol that did not cause an eccentric inflammatory hormones, and more
contraction, e.g. a 60-minute walk uphill polyunsaturated fats) and high-fat animal
on the treadmill with additional burden. source foods and due to a higher intake of
One of the scientific overviews that antioxidants, which significantly
examined the influence of various contributes to a lower oxidative stress
nutritional interventions on DOMS, among (Beezhold, Radnitz, Rinne & DiMatteo,
other also with omega-3 fatty acids, 2015).
showed that consuming omega-3 fatty
acids in eccentric contractions is related Consuming fish or omega-3 dietary
more to the oxidative stress for reducing supplements and physical performance
DOMS (Kim and Lee, 2014). In sports Some researchers have connected the
literature, omega-3 fatty acids have shown consumption of EPA and DHA fatty acids
efficiency in reducing processes of in the form of a dietary supplement from
inflammation and muscle damage and in fish oil with a reduction in markers of
deformation of red blood cells and systemic inflammations as a consequence
metabolism during exercise, but the results of an immune response to exercise
of the studies of the intervention with (Andrade, Ribeiro, Bozza, Costa Rosa &
omega-3 fatty acids in meta-analyses are Tavares do Carmo, 2007), while many
often inconsistent due to inadequate study researchers failed to show the influence of
design. Jeromson, Gallagher, Galloway, consuming omega-3 fatty acids on the
and Lee Hamilton (2015) believe that the performance or a quicker recovery in
inappropriate ratio of omega n-6/n-3 in the healthy adults or well-trained athletes of
dietary pattern is one of the main variables team sports (Bortolotti, Tappy & Scheiter,
that can reduce the effect of intervention 2007; Buckley, Burgess, Murphy & Howe,
with omega-3 fatty acids. 2009; Raastad, Høstmark & Strømme,
1997). One research (Rodacki et al., 2012)
randomly divided 45 healthy women (65 ability and they concluded that a
years old) into 3 groups (exercise for generalization of scientific evidence about
strength; exercise for strength and EPA the potential synergistic benefits is
and DHA; EPA and DHA). The problematic due to the limitations of the
supplemented groups consumed 400 mg of study designs. Mickleborough (2013) was
EPA and 300 mg of DHA daily, 60 days faced with inconsistent results in the field
before the beginning of the training (90 of intervention with omega-3 fatty acids
days altogether), which included exercises and physical performance when he was
for strength three times a week in a period trying to determine the optimal intake of
of 12 weeks. The research showed better omega-3 fatty acids that would maximize
results in muscle strength and functional the ratio between benefits and risks and he
capacity in the group that exercised and, in came to the conclusion that the reasons for
addition, consumed omega-3 fatty acids. such diverse results, which make it
Body weight remained unchanged in both impossible to determine the final
groups after 12 weeks, which suggests the recommendations, are connected with the
influence of omega-3 fatty acids on heterogeneity of the participants, the
additional improvement of muscle intensity and duration of the examined
activation and, consequently, on muscle exercise or training, different types,
strength. Walser, Giordano, and Stebbins amounts, and duration of the intervention
(2006) conducted a study of 7 healthy with EPA and DHA dietary supplements,
people who were consuming 2 g of DHA and the interval of duration of measuring
and 3 g of EPA for 6 weeks and they the selected biomarkers of the studies. One
measured an increase in brachial artery of the last overviews of literature (Da Boit,
blood flow and conductance during a 90- Hunter & Gray, 2017) that examined the
second submaximal rhythmic squeezing of potential implication of consuming omega-
the fist (30% of maximal strength of the 3 fatty acids on physical ability showed
squeeze), while the placebo group did not that the majority of research focuses on
show this effect. Clark, Monahan, and measuring the increase in metabolic
Drew (2016) conducted a study of 14 capacity, the reduction of delayed muscle
healthy young people (25 years old) and 15 pain and fatigue, the improvement in
older people (64 years old) and measured hypertrophy, recovery, and the immune
the impact of consuming 3.6 g of EPA and system, and the reduction of oxidative
DHA for 12 weeks with a 15-second stress. Based on the inconsistency of the
squeeze of the fist at 10%, 30%, 50%, and majority of research, the authors conclude
70% of maximum conscious contraction that the supplementation with omega-3
and discovered that both teams of young fatty acids for the needs of physical ability
and old participants who enjoyed the is potentially justified for athletes with
omega-3 fatty acids in the form of dietary asthma and in sport disciplines in which
supplements had a lower diastolic and the primary motor ability that determines
mean arterial blood pressure. Omega-3 effectiveness is connected with strength,
fatty acids additionally improve the blood which can therefore also be applied to
flow during exercise, reducing the gymnasts. Even though today the
deformation of red blood cells, which mechanism of action is relatively well
theoretically increases the flow of oxygen explained, the reliable implication of
and nutrients into the trained muscle. consuming 1–4 g of omega-3 fatty acids in
Tiryaki-Sönmez, Schoenfeld, and the form of a dietary supplement for the
Vatansever-Ozen (2011) reviewed the needs of gymnasts requires research in
studies that examined the influence of a various situations during trainings and
combined consumption of omega-3 fatty competitions.
acids on body composition and physical
different plant-based diets (vegan, 20% of protein, and 12% of fat) for
vegetarian, pesco-vegetarian, half- achieving momentary loss of excess fat
vegetarian diet) with an omnivorous diet was, according to the authors, energy-
and discovered that plant-based diets, efficient, did not include dairy products
especially the vegan diet, are most (35%–70% of calories came from fat), but
affective in losing excess body weight. did include vitamin and mineral dietary
Katz and Meller (2015) carried out an supplements. The gymnast lost 356 g of fat
overview of scientific studies of the most from the total of 840 g of weight loss,
common diets and concluded that the while the rest of the weight loss was due to
majority of scientific evidence strongly the loss of muscle mass, which in the end
connects a well-planned vegan diet with fortunately did not have a negative impact
health, a successful control of body weight, on the performance. The short-term
and prevention against systemic influence of the intervention in this case
inflammations and chronic diseases. On study, especially because the article does
the basis of the index of healthy nutrition not mention BMI (or the height through
and the assessment of a Mediterranean diet which it would be measured) or body
conducted on 1475 people (104 vegans, composition, cannot be generally applied
573 vegetarians, 498 half-vegetarians, 145 to the long-term needs of other gymnasts
pesco-vegetarians, 155 people with an who are faced with permanent control of
omnivorous diet), Clarys et al. (2014) optimal body weight, especially because
assessed that the vegan diet is the the authors did not measure the numerous
healthiest (related to body weight and micronutrients, among others also the
nutritional adequacy), while the intake of omega-3 fatty acids, or potential
omnivorous diet received the lowest consequences of a possible deficiency.
assessment of the two indicators of a However, this could present a basis for
quality nutrition. Not long ago, the research in future studies that would
Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics include a larger number of gymnasts.
(AND) reiterated its position from the year
2009 about the adequacy of vegetarian CONCLUSIONS
diets for different groups of people and
stated that a well-planned vegetarian diet, Studies about the benefits of
including the vegan diet, is healthy and consuming omega-3 fatty acids (ALA,
nutritionally adequate and appropriate no EPA, and DHA) on general human health
matter the period of a person’s life, even as well as the potential risk of excessive
during pregnancy and breastfeeding, intake (when EPA and DHA exceed 1 g
during childhood and adolescence and also daily) show that the ratio forms a U-shaped
for athletes (Melina, Craig & Levin, 2016). curve. Here we must emphasize that there
On the other hand, Chen et al. (2009) exists no scientific evidence that would
write that, when talking about gymnasts confirm that consuming EPA and DHA
and the reduction of unnecessary fat or the can compensate for an unhealthy diet or
control of body composition while significantly improve our health.
simultaneously maintaining or even Numerous analyses of studies of
improving the optimal level of physical adults, which measured the effect of
abilities, this is a long-term process, since omega-3 fatty acids on the primary and
the latter must also include control over the secondary prevention of cardiovascular
amount of trainings. The case study of an disease, showed that the supplementation
Olympic gold medalist was based on the with EPA and DHA is not connected with
moto “less eating, more training” and a lower mortality rate due to any reason. A
turned out to be successful. A short-term lower incidence of cardiovascular disease
diet (1600 calories, 68% of carbohydrates, is most likely the result of other dietary
factors (in general a healthier eating On the other hand, researchers for
pattern) and a lifestyle that is a result of vegetarian diets have proven that they are
people who are more aware and also eat nutritionally adequate even with calorie
fish. Throughout their gymnastic restrictions and can be undoubtedly
development, gymnasts require more recommended to gymnasts for a successful
education by qualified professionals about control of body weight. Furthermore, AND
a well-planned and healthy diet and about reiterated that a well-planned and
monitoring the implementation of concrete supervised vegetarian diet, including the
guidelines through the strenuous rhythm of vegan diet, is healthy and nutritionally
trainings, the yearly calendar with adequate and appropriate no matter the
competitions, and the competitive career in period of a person’s life, even during
general. pregnancy, breastfeeding, during
It is difficult to uncritically imply childhood and adolescence and also for
the influence of consuming omega-3 fatty athletes.
acids on cognitive abilities, which include Gymnasts who are vegetarians and
a very broad and complex field of do not consume fish or dietary
numerous neurological processes, for the supplements from various reasons (a type
needs of gymnasts, since there is currently of vegetarianism, allergies to a specific
a lack of research carried out with source of omega-3 fatty acids) are
representative tests. Some studies have recommended to either double their intake
shown a greater direct applicability of the of ALA or to consume at least 200–400 mg
intervention with EPA and DHA in a of EPA and DHA in the form of a dietary
potentially more frequent occurrence supplement in order to avoid potential
among gymnasts, i.e. ADHD, especially in inadequate ability to convert ALA into
combination with a healthy diet, which EPA and DHA or in the case of greater
could be relevant since most of the needs.
medication that is used for ADHD carries Based on the majority of credible
numerous side effects (Gelperin, 2006). scientific evidence we can firmly conclude
The evidence about the effects of that a successful control of body weight,
consuming omega-3 fatty acids, especially efficient trainings and recovery, and
EPA and DHA, on systemic and local successful performances of gymnasts that
inflammations and DOMS in eccentric have no long-term negative effects on
contractions (exercise or training) is much health are based on a healthy diet, which is
more consistent in comparison with other based on a well-structured diet that
muscle contractions. EPA and DHA from a consists mainly (but not necessarily solely)
verified manufacturer might present one of of plants (e.g. starch and non-starch
the permitted and safe dietary strategies if vegetables, fruits, nuts and seeds) and
a gymnast uses all other known and which, in its unrefined form, is also low in
permitted ways for an efficient recovery fat. When it comes to the optimal healthy
during their training rhythm and workout diet of gymnasts we must also add to this
program, but only as part of a special 1–2 spoons of a representative intake of
assessment of needs by the coaching team, ALA (e.g. from flaxseeds) and, to be on
especially by a qualified professional from safe side, also 200–400 mg of EPA and
the field of ordinary diet and sports DHA in the form of a dietary supplement
nutrition. (fish oil or marine microalgae). It is of
An overview of studies that vital importance that the dietary
examined the influence of EPA and DHA supplement is strictly an addition to the
on overweight and obese people showed ordinary diet and that is does not include
that the current evidence does not support any contaminants. This satisfies the two
a weight-loss role of omega-3 fatty acids. principles, i.e. the nutritional adequacy of
EPA and DHA for the needs of various Analysis. Molecular Psychiatry, 17(12),
body systems and their functions and the 1272–1282.
minimal exposure to industrial Bloch, M.H., & Qawasmi, A. (2011).
contamination, which could nullify the Omega-3 Fatty Acid Supplementation for
benefits of the intake of omega-3 fatty the Treatment of Children with Attention-
acids. Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder
Symptomatology: Systematic Review and
REFERENCES Meta-Analysis. Journal of the American
Academy of Child and Adolescent
Andrade, P.M., Ribeiro, B.G., Bozza, Psychiatry, 50(10), 991–1000.
M.T., Costa Rosa, L., & Tavares do Bloomer, R.J., Larson, D.E., Fisher-
Carmo, M.G. (2007). Effects of the fish-oil Wellman, K.H., Galpin, A.J., & Schilling,
supplementation on the immune and B.K. (2009). Effect of eicosapentaenoic
inflammatory responses in elite swimmers. and docosahexaenoic acid on resting and
Prostaglandins Leukot Essent Fatty Acids, exercise-induced inflammatory and
77(3-4), 139–45. oxidative stress biomarkers: a randomized,
Atashak, S., Hossein, S., Azarbayjani, placebo controlled, cross-over study.
M.A., Stannard, S.R., Goli, M.A., & Lipids in Health and Disease, 8, 36.
Haghighi, M.M. (2013). Effect of omega-3 Bonci, C.M., Bonci, L.J., Granger,
supplementation on the blood levels of L.R., Johnson, C.L., Malina, R.M., Milne,
oxidative stress, muscle damage and L.W. et al. (2008). National Athletic
inflammation markers after acute Trainers’ Association Position Statement:
resistance exercise in young athletes. Preventing, Detecting, and Managing
Kinesiology 45(1), 22–29. Disordered Eating in Athletes. Journal of
Bauer, I., Hughes, M., Rowsell, R., Athletic Training, 43(1), 80–108.
Cockerell, R., Pipingas, A., Crewther, S., Bortolotti, M., Tappy, L., & Scheiter,
& Crewther, D. (2014). Omega-3 P. (2007). Fish oil supplementation does
supplementation improves cognition and not alter energy efficiency in healthy
modifies brain activation in young adults. males. Clinical Nutrition, 26(2), 225–30.
Human Psychopharmacology, 29(2), 133– Buckley, J.D., Burgess, S., Murphy,
44. K.J., & Howe, P.R. (2009). DHA-rich fish
BBC (2016). Louis Smith: Team GB oil lowers heart rate during submaximal
gymnast receives death threats 'every day'. exercise in elite Australian Rules
Retrived 29.12.2016, from footballers. Journal of Science and
http://www.bbc.com/sport/gymnastics/376 Medicine in Sport, 12(4), 503–7.
44035. Bui, C., Petrofsky, J., Berk, L.,
Beezhold, B., Radnitz, C., Rinne, A., Shavlik, D., Remigio, W., & Montgomery,
& DiMatteo, J. (2015). Vegans report less S. (2010). Acute effect of a single high-fat
stress and anxiety than omnivores. Nutre meal on forearm blood flow, blood
Neuroscience, 18(7), 289–96. pressure and heart rate in healthy male
Bisgaard, H., Stokholm, J., Chawes, Asians and Caucasians: a pilot study. The
B.L., Vissing, N.H., Bjarnadóttir, E., Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical
Schoos, A.M., et al. (2016). Fish Oil- Medicine and Public Health, 41(2), 490–
Derived Fatty Acids in Pregnancy and 500.
Wheeze and Asthma in Offspring. New Burdge, G.C., & Wootton, S.A.
England Journal of Medicine, 375(26), (2002). Conversion of alpha-linolenic acid
2530–9. to eicosapentaenoic, docosapentaenoic and
Bloch, M.H., & Hannestad, J. (2012). docosahexaenoic acids in young women.
Omega-3 Fatty Acids for the Treatment of British Journal of Nutrition, 88(4), 411–
Depression: Systematic Review and Meta- 20.
Controlled Trials. PLoS ONE, 10(11), of the American College of Nutrition, 28,
e0142652. 473S–481S.
Emken, A.A., Adolf, R.O., & Gulley, Geleijnse, J.M., Giltay, E.J., &
R.M. (1994). Dietary linoleic acid Kromhout, D. (2012). Effects of n-3 fatty
influences desaturation and acylation of acids on cognitive decline: a randomized,
deuterium-labeled linoleic and linolenic double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in
acids in young adult males. Biochim stable myocardial infarction patients.
Biophys Acta, 1213(3), 277–88. Alzheimers Dement, 8(4), 278–87.
Emken, E.A., Adolf, R.O., Duval, Gelperin, K. (2006). Psychiatric
S.M., & Nelson, G.J. (1999). Effect of Adverse Events Associated with Drug
dietary docosahexaenoic acid on Treatment of ADHD: Review of
desaturation and uptake in vivo of isotope- Postmarketing Safety Data. FDA Center
labeled oleic, linoleic, and linolenic acids for Drug Evaluation and Research.
by male subjects. Lipids, 34(8), 785–91. Retrieved 15.4.2017, from
FAO (2010). Fats and fatty acids in https://www.fda.gov/ohrms/dockets/ac/06/
human nutrition. Report of an expert briefing/2006-
consultation. FAO Food and Nutrition 4210b_11_01_AdverseEvents.pdf.
Paper, 91, 1–166. Gerster, H. (1998). Can adults
Farmer, B., Larson, B.T., Fulgoni, adequately convert alpha-linolenic acid
V.L., Rainville, A.J., & Liepa, G.U. (18:3n-3) to eicosapentaenoic acid (20:5n-
(2011). A vegetarian dietary pattern as a 3) and docosahexaenoic acid (22:6n-3)?
nutrient-dense approach to weight International Journal of Vitamin and
management: an analysis of the national Nutrition Research, 68(3), 159–73.
health and nutrition examination survey Glynn, A., Aune, M., Darnerud, P.O.,
1999-2004. Journal of American Dietetic Cnattingius, S., Bjerselius, R., Becker, W.,
Association, 111(6), 819–27. et al. (2007). Determinants of serum
Fernandes, A.R., Rose, M., White, S., concentrations of organochlorine
Mortimer, D.N., & Gem, M. (2006). compounds in Swedish pregnant women: a
Dioxins and polychlorinated biphenyls cross-sectional study. Environmental
(PCBs) in fish oil dietary supplements: Health, 6, 2.
occurrence and human exposure in the UK. Gould, J.F., Makrides, M., Colombo,
Food Addit Contam, 23(9), 939–47. J., & Smithers, L.G. (2014). Randomized
FIG (2016). Disciplines. Retrieved controlled trial of maternal omega-3 long-
29.12.2016, from http://www.fig- chain PUFA supplementation during
gymnastics.com/site/#. pregnancy and early childhood
Flock, M.R., Harris, W.S., & Kris- development of attention, working
Etherton, P.M. (2013). Long-chain omega- memory, and inhibitory control. American
3 fatty acids: time to establish a dietary Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 99(4), 851–
reference intake. Nutrition Reviews, 859.
71(10), 692–707. Gould, J.F., Smithers, L.G., &
Fodor, G.J., Helis, E., Yazdekhasti, Makrides, M. (2013). The effect of
N., & Vohnout, B. (2014). “Fishing” for maternal omega-3 (n-3) LCPUFA
the origins of the “Eskimos and heart supplementation during pregnancy on early
disease” story. Facts or wishful thinking? childhood cognitive and visual
A review. Canadian Journal of development: a systematic review and
Cardiology, 30(8), 864–868. meta-analysis of randomized controlled
Fontani, G., Lodi, L., Migliorini, S., & trials. American Journal of Clinical
Corradeschi, F. (2009). Effect of omega-3 Nutrition, 97(3), 531–44.
and policosanol supplementation on Gray, P., Chappell, A., Jenkinson,
attention and reactivity in athletes. Journal A.M., Thies, F., & Gray, S.R. (2014). Fish
oil supplementation reduces markers of Jacobs, S., Sioen, I., Jacxsens, L.,
oxidative stress but not muscle soreness Domingo, J.L., Sloth, J.J., Marques, A.,
after eccentric exercise. International &Verbeke, W. (2016). Risk assessment of
Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise methylmercury in five European countries
Metabolism, 24(2), 206–14. considering the national seafood
Greene, J., Ashburn, S.M., Razzouk, consumption patterns. Food and Chemical
L., & Smith, D.A. (2013). Fish oils, Toxicology. Available online 27 October
coronary heart disease, and the 2016, doi.org/10.1016/j.fct.2016.10.026.
environment. American Journal of Public Jeromson, S., Gallagher, I.J.,
Health, 103(9), 1568–76. Galloway, S.D.R., & Hamilton, D.L.
Guzmán, J.F., Esteve, H., Pablos, C., (2015). Omega-3 Fatty Acids and Skeletal
Pablos, A., Blasco, C., & Villegas, J.A. Muscle Health. Marine Drugs, 13(11),
(2011). DHA-Rich Fish Oil Improves 6977–7004.
Complex Reaction Time in Female Elite Kang, J.X. (2011). Omega-3: A Link
Soccer Players. Journal of Sports Science between Global Climate Change and
& Medicine, 10(2), 301–305. Human Health. Biotechnology Advances,
Harris, W.S., Mozaffarian, D., 29(4), 388–390.
Lefevre, M., Toner, C.D., Colombo, J., Katz, D.L., & Meller, S. (2014). Can
Cunnane, S.C. idr. (2009). Towards we say what diet is best for health? Annu
establishing dietary reference intakes for Reviews of Public Health, 35, 83–103.
eicosapentaenoic and docosahexaenoic Kim, J., & Lee, J. (2014). A review of
acids. Journal of Nutrition, 139(4), 804S– nutritional intervention on delayed onset
19S. muscle soreness. Part I. Journal of
Haver, J. (2016). Plant-Based Diets: A Exercise Rehabilitation, 10(6), 349–356.
Physician’s Guide. Perm J, 20(3), 15–082. Koletzko, B., Cetin, I., & Brenna, J.T.
Hooper, L., Thompson, R.L., (2007). Dietary fat intakes for pregnant
Harrison, R.A., Summerbell, C.D., Ness, and lactating women. British Journal of
A.R., Moore, H.J., et al. (2006). Risks and Nutrition, 98(5), 873–7.
benefits of omega 3 fats for mortality, Kowey, P.R., Reiffel, J.A.,
cardiovascular disease, and cancer: Ellenbogen, K.A., Naccarelli, G.V., &
systematic review. BMJ, 332(7544), 752– Pratt, C.M. (2010). Efficacy and safety of
60. prescription omega-3 fatty acids for the
Howard, A.L., Robinson, M., Smith, prevention of recurrent symptomatic atrial
G.J., Ambrosini, G.L., Piek, J.P., & Oddy, fibrillation: a randomized controlled trial.
W.H. (2011). ADHD is associated with a JAMA Internal Medicine, 304(21), 2363–
"Western" dietary pattern in adolescents. 72.
Journal of Attention Disorder, 15(5), 403– Kwak, S.M., Myung, S.K., Lee, Y.L.,
11. & Seo, H.G. (2012). Efficacy of omega-3
Jackson, P.A., Reay, J.L., Scholey, fatty acid supplements (eicosapentaenoic
A.B., & Kennedy, D.O. (2012). DHA-rich acid and docosahexaenoic acid) in the
oil modulates the cerebral haemodynamic secondary prevention of cardiovascular
response to cognitive tasks in healthy disease: a meta-analysis of randomized,
young adults: a near IR spectroscopy pilot double-blind, placebo-controlled trials.
study. British Journal of Nutrition, 107(8), Archives of Internal Medicine Journal,
1093–8. 172(9), 686–94.
Jacobs, D.R. Jr., Ruzzin, J., & Lee, Malina, R.M., Baxter-Jones, A.D.G.,
D.H. (2014). Environmental pollutants: Armstrong, N., Beunen, G.P., Caine, D.,
downgrading the fish food stock affects Daly, R. M., et al. (2013). Role of
chronic disease risk. Journal of Internal Intensive Training in the Growth and
Medicine, 276(3), 240–2. Maturation of Artistic Gymnasts. Sports
Relatively small number of gymnasts participate at the Olympic Games and even smaller
number participates at Olympic Games consecutively, due to numerous different reasons.
Therefore, this paper aims are: 1) to determine the number of female gymnasts who
participated in the C-I competition at Olympic Games held in 2012 and at Olympic Games
held in 2016; 2) to determine characteristics and differences in results of consecutive
participants at these two Olympic Games; 3) to determine differences between consecutive
participants and other competitors at the afore defined competitions. It was found that 25
female gymnasts participated at two consecutive Olympic Games. From one to another
Olympic Games, consecutive participants have numerically increase all scores; significantly
increased Execution and Final Scores on the uneven bars; significantly decrease Execution
and Final Score on the balance beam. Compared to other gymnasts from the 2012 and 2016
Olympic Games, consecutive participants had numerically higher values in all variables, but
only some of them have been determined as significantly different. Consecutive participants
confirmed the possibility of continuous quality of skills development in mid 20s.
INTRODUCTION
21.04±4.93 years old, while at OG2016 Pajek, Čuk, Pajek, Kovač, & Leskošek,
they were 25.07±4.93 years old. Female 2013).
gymnasts who participated only at Data analysis included calculations of
OG2012 (N=72) were 20.23±3.80 years Mean±Standard deviations. One Way
old, while ones that participated only at repeated measures ANOVA was used to
OG2016 (N=73) were 19.45±3.13 years determine differences between the
old. performances of FG2×OG. One Way
Average age of FG2×OG without ANOVA for independent samples was
Oksana Chusovitina (who was vault used to analyze differences between
finalist at OG2012 and OG2016, and FG1×OG and FG2×OG (from the OG2012
whose age make her an outlier not only in and from the OG2016). Data was
artistic gymnastics but in most elite sports considered significant if p<.05. All
(her participation at the Summer OG in calculations were performed using
Rio made her the oldest female gymnast in software package Statistica 12.0. (StatSoft,
Olympic history) was 20.45±3.83 years Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA).
old, while at OG2016 they were
24.22±3.73 years old. RESULTS
The variable sample is represented by
a set of Vault Difficulty Scores (VTDS), Competitive tactics of FG2×OG, at
Vault Execution Scores (VTES), Vault both Olympic Games, is shown in Figure
Final Scores (VTFS), Uneven Bars 1.
Difficulty Scores (UBDS), Uneven Bars Although it is a multi-structural sport
Execution Scores (UBES), Uneven Bars and there is a complex system of
Final Scores (UBFS), Balance Beam qualification for the OG, the largest
Difficulty Scores (BBDS), Balance Beam number of FG2×OG (on both OG)
Execution Scores (BBES), Balance Beam competed at all four apparatuses. At
Final Scores (BBFS), Floor Difficulty OG2012, 16 of 25 FG2×OG were All-
Scores (FXDS), Floor Execution Scores Around competitors and 9 were Apparatus
(FXES) and Floor Final Scores (FXFS) competitors. At OG2016, 14 of 25
obtained at the Qualification Competition FG2×OG were All-Around competitors
(C-I) at OG2012 and at OG2016 by the and 11 were Apparatus competitors. The
apparatus competitors, and All-Around change in the tactics for FG2×OG can be
Score (AA) obtained at the same observed in the number of those who have
competitions by the All-around competed on only one apparatus. At
competitors. OG2012, the total number of FG2×OG
The values of the mentioned scores who competed at only one apparatus was
have been retrieved from the specialized 1, while at OG2016 were 11 FG2×OG who
web site for gymnastics results competed at only one apparatus (43% of
(www.gymnasticsresults.com, accessed on all FG2×OG).
the 18th of October 2016.). Exercising characteristics and
Previous studies presented detailed differences for FG2×OG are shown in
descriptive parameters of analyzed Table 1.
variables for the same competitions The analysis determined that a total
(Massida & Calo, 2012; Leskošek, Čuk, & number of 25 female gymnasts had the
Bučar, 2013; Atiković et al., 2014; Erceg, experience of previous OG. Most of the
Delaš Kalinski, & Milić, 2014) as well as consecutive Apparatus Competitors on the
generally satisfactory metric characteristics OG2012 competed floor, while the lowest
of those scores (Bučar, Čuk, Pajek, frequency of consecutive Apparatus
Karácsony, & Leskošek, 2012; Bučar Competitors has been determined at the
uneven bars. At OG2016 the highest
Table 1
Differences of FG2×OG performance at the OG2012 and at the OG2016.
Table 2
Differences between the FG2×OG and FG1×OG performances.
2012
FG1×OG FG2×OG
N1 M±SD N2 M±SD F p η2
VTDS 12 5.63±0.74 6 6.08±0.45 1.92 0.18 0.11
VTES 8.39±0.71 8.51±0.60 0.12 0.73 <0.01
VTFS 47 13.97±0.88 18 14.42±0.91 4.11 0.05 0.06
UBDS 5.62±0.74 5.87±0.62 2.00 0.16 0.03
UBES 59 7.70±0.89 17 8.14±0.36 4.10 0.05 0.05
UBFS 13.32±1.37 14.01±0.92 4.23 0.04 0.05
BBDS 5.47±0.61 5.78±0.44 5.23 0.02 0.06
BBES 62 7.45±1.00 19 8.11±0.62 8.29 0.01 0.09
BBFS 12.92±1.31 13.89±0.97 10.52 <0.01 0.11
FXDS 5.36±0.44 5.50±0.49 1.46 0.23 0.02
FXES 59 8.07±0.45 20 8.11±0.66 0.09 0.76 0.00
FXFS 13.37±0.84 13.56±1.04 0.68 0.41 0.01
AA 43 52.91±3.51 16 56.02±2.76 10.18 <0.01 0.15
2016
N1 M±SD N2 M±SD F P η2
VTDS 5.42±0.56 5.47±1.32 4.56 0.04 0.07
VTES 49 8.78±0.48 15 8.79±0.88 2.65 0.11 0.04
VTFS 14.18±0.79 14.39±1.63 6.41 0.01 0.09
UBDS 5.74±0.64 6.60±2.21 2.88 0.09 0.04
UBES 58 8.03±0.66 15 8.53±0.39 8.08 0.01 0.10
UBFS 13.76±1.17 14.59±0.81 6.56 0.01 0.08
BBDS 5.62±0.57 5.75±0.44 1.03 0.31 0.01
BBES 54 7.75±0.81 16 7.86±0.55 0.22 0.64 0.00
BBFS 13.36±1.26 13.61±0.83 0.61 0.44 0.01
FXDS 5.34±0.76 5.63±0.59 1.75 0.19 0.03
FXES 49 7.89±0.47 12 8.21±0.49 4.55 0.04 0.07
FXFS 13.18±1.02 13.82±1.01 4.12 0.05 0.06
AA 44 54.17±3.11 14 56.48±2.50 6.07 0.02 0.10
quality of performance and this results in a Jessica Brizeida Lopez Arocha, Aliya
significant decrease of final score on the Mustafina, Alexandra Raisman, Elisabeth
balance beam, compared to the results Seitz, Giulia Steingruber and Teramoto
from the OG2012; 4) they increase Asuka) and seven entered the apparatus
numerical values of difficulty and the final competitions (vault finals: Giulia
quality of the performance on the floor, Steingruber; uneven bars finals: Aliya
compared to the results achieved in the Mustafina, Elizabeth Seitz, Jessica
OG2012. Brizeida Lopez Arocha, Gabrielle Douglas,
Determined reductions in some scores floor finals: Alexandra Raisman, Vanessa
(VTDS, BBES, and BBFS) is not proper to Ferrari, Giulia Steingruber).
attribute only to lower gymnasts Four FG2×OG out of eleven, who
competition quality, but also to the have competed only one apparatus at
changes that have occurred in the CoP OG2016, entered the final competitions
2013-2016 (FIG, 2009) in relation to the (Catalina Ponor on the balance beam,
CoP 2009-2012 (FIG, 2013). Namely, Maria Paseka and Oksana Chousovitina on
compared to the CoP 2009-2012, in the the vault, and Erica Fasana on the floor).
CoP 2013-2016 some most frequently Based on the aforementioned results
performed vaults (often the vaults of the of FG2×OG, the quality of all FG2×OG at
highest Difficulty Values, performed on all OG2016 is unquestionable. The
levels of the major competitions) went assumption is that those consecutive
through the reduction of the Difficulty participants used the period of time
Value (Delaš Kalinski, Atiković, Jelaska, between the two OG to stabilize and
& Milić, 2016). upgrade previously acquired skills. Longer
According to the analyzed CoPs, period of complex motor skills learning
lower ES on the balance beam can not be (primarily skills of elite artistic
associated with some significant changes gymnastics) is needed if we want to
in the rules on this apparatus. However, acquire the highest stage of motor skills
based on higher values of the BBDS it is (Schmidt, & Wrisberg, 2008).
possible to assume that the performance of At both OG FG2×OG, compared to
more complex and difficult elements was FG1×OG, had numerically higher values
not that stabile and correct, what led to of all scores but significant differences
lower scores of the BBES at OG2016 in between FG2×OG and FG1×OG have been
relation to the OG2012. found only in 50% of the variables (in
However, the following question VTFS, UBES, UBFS, BBDS, BBES and
arises: did the increase of most scores at BBFS variables at OG2012, and in VTDS,
OG2016 enable FG2×OG to qualify for the VTFS, UBES, UBFS, FXES and FXFS
finals? variables at OG2016; Table 2). Besides the
Referring to the original results, we quality difference among these two groups
notice the following: if compared to the of competitors, we also assume the impact
OG2012, 14 of 25 FG2×OG All-Around of age, i.e., longer sports carrier and longer
competitors, at OG2016, remained; 10 of period of deliberate practice.
25 FG2×OG have reduced the number of At OG2012, compared to FG1×OG,
competed apparatuses; one of 25 FG2×OG FG2×OG had numerically higher values of
have increased the number of competed VTDS and VTES, and significantly higher
apparatuses and have became All-Around values of VTFS. Furthermore, at OG2016,
competitor; one of them competed the compared to FG1×OG, FG2×OG had
same (one) apparatus at both OG. From 14 numerically higher values of VTES and
All-Around FG2×OG at OG2016, nine significantly higher values of VTDS and
entered All-Around Finals (Elisabeth VTFS. Referring to the original results it
Black, Carlotta Ferlito, Vanessa Ferrari, has been revealed that 5 FG2×OG (of the
total number of 18 Vault Qualifiers) old and FG1xOG was 19.45 old), and
participated at the Vault Qualifications at probably a longer sports carrier than other
OG2012, out of which four FG2×OG female Olympic Games gymnasts, the
competed Vault Finals at OG2012 (Maria obtained result can be justified. However,
Paseka, Oksana Chusovitina, Brittany due to the lack of information on the
Rogers, and Elsabeth Black). At OG2016, training process of the previously
five of 19 Vault Qualifiers were FG2×OG, mentioned female gymnasts, and the fact
out of which even three FG2×OG that training workloads as well as
competed in Vault Finals at OG2016 sequencing of training sessions are highly
(Maria Paseka, Giulia Steingruber and variable among individuals/gymnasts
Oksana Chusovitina). Taking into account (Malina et al, 2013), the influence of
the facts of having analysed scores from C- longer sports carrier and longer time of
I competition, and the scores of the 1st deliberate practice on superior levels of
vault of Vault Qualifiers count for Team performance of uneven bars by FG2×OG
Result and Individual All-Around Result remains unknown.
(FIG, 2009, 2013), it is not surprising that At OG2012, all scores achieved on the
for the 1st vault Vault Qualifiers chose balance beam by FG2×OG were
vaults with numerically higher DVs (and significantly higher from the scores
sometimes significantly higher) from those achieved by FG1×OG at the same
performed by All-Around Competitors apparatus. Accordingly, it is possible to
(Delaš Kalinski, Atiković, Jelaska, & assert that on this apparatus, FG2×OG
Milić, 2016). Whereas the FG2×OG at group significantly differs from other
both OG formed 1/4th of the group of Vault gymnasts in their technical and aesthetical
Qualifiers, and that five (OG2012) or three quality of performance. During the original
(OG2016) competed in Vault Finals, their data introspection, it was found that
higher scores on vault, compared to FG2×OG group included 3 gymnasts
FG1×OG, were only logically-achieved (Alexandra Raisman, Catalina Ponor and
results. Gabrielle Douglas) who entered balance
Higher values of VTFS of FG2×OG, beam finals at OG2012. From other 19
despite the reduction of the Difficulty FG2×OG who at OG2012 competed on the
Values of the most frequently performed balance beam in the qualification
vaults (CoP, 2013), confirm their competition, 11 of them were ranked
progression in the quality and complexity among first 31 places and the remaining 8
of the performed vaults and support a among 57 places. In accordance with those
conclusion that female gymnasts can have results, the balance beam competing
prolonged development of skills after the quality can be clearly visible and the
age of 20 (Zurc, 2017). obtained results are logical. At OG2016,
Significantly higher values for despite the certain numerical dominance of
FG2×OG in the UBES variable, at FG2xOG in all balance beam variables
OG2012 and at OG2016, confirmed the (compared to FG1xOG), significant
results of the previous studies. Namely, differences have not been determined.
Ferreirinha et al. (2011) determined that At both analysed OG, FG2xOG had
the uneven bars are apparatus which needs numerically higher values of all floor
more time to train in order to achieve variables, than FG1xOG, but the
higher technical and aesthetic level of significant difference has been determined
performance. Since for the FG2×OG only at OG2016 in FXES and (probably)
higher average values of age have been consequently in the FXFS. The reason for
determined at both OGs (at OG2012 significantly higher quality of FG2xOG,
FG2×OG was 21.04 old and FG1xOG was compared to FG1xOG, probably stems
20.23 old; at OG2016 FG2×OG was 25.07 from the fact that even 4 competitors from
the group FG2xOG, at OG2016, competed compositions generally have been above-
in floor finals (Alexandra Raisman, average with regards to the difficulty
Vanessa Ferrari, Erika Fasana and Giulia values. Apart from the mentioned, they
Steingruber), and that a member of the have been performed more correctly in the
FG2xOG group at OG2016 also was Aliya technical and aesthetical sense.
Mustafina, who won the third place in Accordingly, such exercising is definitely
floor finals at OG2012. The difference one of the key factors responsible for their
between FG2xOG and other gymnasts in repeated participation at the Olympic
FXES, support the conclusion how the Games.
chronologically older gymnasts have Pursuant to the obtained results,
potentially higher forms of capital, several conclusions can be made and they
compared to a chronologically younger are as follows: 1) FG2×OG are probably a
gymnast, is their ability to express subject of adequately planned programs
themselves artistically (Kerr et al., 2015). that enable their technical and execution
The importance of artistry in women’s evolution; 2) continuous progress of
artistic gymnastics has been a concern of FG2×OG group could be interpreted as
the International Gymnastics Federation resulting from will power, high working
and was incorporated in its execution score capacity and love for hard work which
since 2009. continuously keeps and encourages them
Nine out of 14 FG2xOG All-Around to continue to improve their performances;
competitors at OG2016 competed in All- 3) (presumably) higher chronological age
Around Finals, six competed in one of female gymnasts (since FG2×OG are at
Apparatus Finals while four competed in least 20-year-old), which is characterized
two Apparatus Finals. Apart from the fact by the stability of the motor programs,
that participation in any final competition probably plays a role in competing of
at OG is a major proof of gymnasts FG2×OG.
quality, due to the fact that nine FG2xOG However, a factor which can be
competitors who competed in All-Around considered as the most important in
Finals (from OG2012 and from OG2016) reaching, retaining and improving that
make 37% of overall competitors of All- quality, from one Olympic Games to
Around Finals, the significant difference another (individual characteristics of
between FG2xOG and FG1xOG in AA gymnasts, early experiences, preferences,
variable, at both OG, is rather logical. opportunities, habits, training or practice),
remains to be determined in other studies.
CONCLUSION
“The pathway from genes to talent to
The results of this study determined greatness is often very nuanced and
that the number of FG2×OG (from complex“ (Kaufman, 2013)
OG2012 to OG2016) was 25 (almost ¼ of
all competitors) which, according to the REFERENCES
authors, should not be considered low. At
Olympic Games from OG2012 to OG2016, Arkaiev, L.I., & Suchilin, N.G.
FG2×OG numerically increased most of (2009). Gymnastics: How to create
their scores, placed high at most final champions. UK: Meyer & Meyer sport
competitions, and confirmed the possibility Ltd. 2nd edition.
of continuous quality of skills development Atiković, A., Delaš Kalinski, S.,
in mid 20s. Kremnicky, J. Tabaković, M., &
Higher values of FG2×OG in relation Samardžija Pavletič, M. (2014).
to FG1×OG, at both analyzed Olympic Characteristics and trend of judging scores
Games, suggest that FG2×OG competitive in the European, World Championships
and Olympic games in the female's artistic Erceg, T., Delaš Kalinski S., & Milić,
gymnastics from 2006 to 2010 year. In M. M. (2014). The score differences between
Bučar Pajek, N. Jarc & M. Samardžić elite European junior and senior female
Pavletič (Eds.). Book of abstracts and gymnasts. Kinesiology, 46(Suppl 1), 88-94.
proceedings of 1st International Scientific Ericsson, K. A., Charness, N.,
Congress Organized by the Slovenian Feltovich, P. J., & Hoffman, R. R. (2006).
Gymnastics Federation, Portorož (pp. 65- The Cambridge handbook of expertise and
73). Ljubljana: Slovenian Gymnastics expert performance. New York, NY:
Federation. Cambridge University Press.
Bloom, B. S. (1985). Developing Fédération Internationale de
Talent in Young People. New York: Gymnastique (2011). Qualification System
Ballantine Books. – Games Of The XXX Olympiad. Available
Bučar Pajek, M., Čuk, I., Pajek, J., at:
Kovač, M., & Leskošek, B. (2013). Is the http://corporate.olympics.com.au/files/dmf
quality of judging in women artistic ile/FIG_Gymnastics_April2011.pdf
gymnastics equivalent at major (Accessed 3 September 2016).
competitions of different levels? Journal Fédération Internationale de
of Human Kinetics, 37(1), 173-181. Gymnastique (2016). Technical
Bučar Pajek, M., Forbes, W., Pajek, regulations. Version 2016. Available at:
J., Leskošek, B., & Čuk, I. (2011). http://www.fig-
Reliability of Real Time Judging System gymnastics.com/publicdir/rules/files/main/
(RTJS). Science of Gymnastics Journal, 20160905%20TR%202017-e.pdf
3(2), 47–54. Ferreirinha, J., Carvalho, J., Corte-
Bučar, M., Čuk, I., Pajek, J., Real, C., & Silva, A. (2011). The evolution
Karácsony, I., & Leskošek, B. (2012). of real difficulty value of uneven bars
Reliability and validity of judging in routines from elite gymnasts in last five
women’s artistic gymnastics at the Olympic cycles. Science of Gymnastics
University Games 2009. European Journal Journal, 3(1), 15-24.
of Sport Science, 12(3), 207-215. Gibbons, T., Hill, R., McConnell, A.,
Čuk, I., & Atiković, A. (2009), Are Forster, T., & Moore, J. (2002). The path
Disciplines in All-around Men’s Artistic to excellence: A comprehensive view of
Gymnastics Equal? Sport Scientific & development of U.S. Olympians who
Practical Aspects, 6(1&2), 8-13. competed from 1984-1998. United States
Čuk, I., & Forbes, W. (2010), How Olympic Committee. (Report can be
apparatus difficulty scores affect all around accessed here:
results in men’s artistic gymnastics. http://assets.usoc.org/assets/documents/atta
Science of Gymnastics Journal, 2(3), 57- ched_file/filename/4604/Olympian_Report
63. .pdf)
Delaš Kalinski, S., Atiković, A., Gladwell, M. (2008). Outliers- The
Jelaska, I., & Milić, M. (2016). Story of Success. New York: Little, Brown
Performance analysis of female gymnasts’ and Company.
vault in elite competitions from 2008- Gymnastics results. Retrived from:
2015. Science of Gymnastics Journal, 8(2), http://www.gymnasticsresults.com
109-123. (Accessed 10 October 2016).
Donti, O.; Donti, A.; & Theodorakou, Haag, H. & Haag, G. (Eds.). (2003).
K. (2014). A review on the changes of the Dictionary Sport, Sport Education, Sport
evaluation system affecting artistic Science. Kiel:ISS
gymnasts' basic preparation: the aspect of Howe, M.J.A., Davidson, J.W., &
choreography preparation. Science of Sloboda, J.A. (1998). Innate talent: reality
Gymnastics Journal, 6(2), 63-72.
Original article
Abstract
Keywords: expression, physical abilities, range of motion, somatotype, high intensity shuttle
run
INTRODUCTION
the data collection procedures. The study and a stadiometer (Seca 710, and Seca
was approved by the University’s 208, Hamburg, Germany). Body
Institutional Review Board and all composition was estimated by measuring
procedures were in accordance with the the skinfold thickness on two sites of the
Code of Ethics of the World Medical body (subscapular and triceps) using a
Association (Helsinki declaration of 1964, Harpenden skinfold caliper (British
as revised in 2013). Indicator, UK), and the equation of
The current study required the Slaughter et al. (1988) for girls aged less
participants to complete 3 testing sessions than 18 years. Somatotype was determined
at their training facilities, performed 5-7 according to the methodology of Carter
days apart, within-2-3 weeks following the (2002) using the following anthropometric
national championships. The first testing variables: stature, body mass, 4 skinfolds
session included anthropometry (stature, (triceps, subscapular, supraspinal, medial
body mass, 4 skinfolds thickness, 2 bone- calf), 2 bone breadths (biepicondylar
breaths, 2 limp-girths, and arm length) and humerus and femur) and 2 limb girths
familiarization with the physical abilities (arm flexed and calf). All measurements
tests. During the second testing session were taken on the right side of the
one International Gymnastics Federation gymnasts. The mean value of two
(F.I.G) judge (with 30 years of judging consecutive measurements was registered
experience and serving as a Reference for further analysis. A single researcher,
Judge in official competitions), evaluated experienced in kinanthropometry,
gymnasts’ artistry in a compulsory routine performed all measures in accordance with
without apparatus. A compulsory routine the International Society for Advancement
without apparatus is a pre-requisite for of Kinanthropometry, guidelines.
qualification by the National Gymnastics Static balance was assessed by a
Federation. This routine includes specific rhythmic gymnastics specific test
body elements and is performed following (Kioumourtzoglou, Derri, Mertzanidou, &
a selected music, common for all the Tzetzis, 1997). Gymnasts remained on the
gymnasts of each age category. ball of their foot with their arms held
Furthermore, a routine without apparatus above their head and the free foot at a low
where only body movements are evaluated “passé” for as long as possible.
is indicating aesthetic proficiency of the Performance was recorded in seconds.
gymnast and consists the ‘basis’ of further Athletes completed 3 trials and the best
development. The routine was evaluated was used for further analysis. Thirty
by the following criteria according to the seconds of rest were provided between
Rhythmic Gymnastics Code of Points trials. The intra-class correlation
(2012-16): the unity of composition, the coefficient (ICC) for the balance test was
relation of music and movement and the 0.85 (p<0.01).
gymnasts’ expression. Because the Shoulder flexion was measured
compulsory routine had a predetermined according to the procedures described by
use of space there was no deduction for Sleeper, Kenyon, and Casey (2012). From
this criterion. Errors or failures according a prone position, with the shoulders flexed
to the above criteria resulted in at 180°, gymnasts gripped a wooden stick
deductions. In the third testing session, and raised both arms. Shoulder flexion
gymnasts underwent a series of physical was determined by dividing the height
abilities tests (balance, flexibility, attained by the stick with the length of the
muscular power and endurance, and high athlete’s arm and then taking the arcsine
intensity shuttle run performance). of this ratio. Arm length was measured
Body mass and standing height were from the tip of the acromion to the tip of
measured with a calibrated digital scale the metacarpal bone of the middle finger.
Figure 1. Somatotype distribution of the rhythmic gymnasts. Filled circles are individual data,
while open diamond represents the average somatotype of this group of athletes.
Table 1
Correlations between artistry and its sub-components’ scores (in deduction points) and
participants’ anthropometric characteristics.
Mean±SD Artistry Unity Music Expression
&
movement
Artistry score (in deduction points) 0.96±0.26
Unity score 0.32±0.09 .810**
Music & movement score 0.33±0.09 .907** .861**
Expression score 0.32±0.14 .813** .343* .550**
Participants’ characteristics
Age (years) 9.9±1.3 -.341* -.245 -.371* -.250
Training experience (years) 2.4±1.3 -.374* -.199 -.346* -.379**
Anthropometric characteristics
Height (cm) 137.9±7.7 -.376** -.300* -.372* -.267
Weight (kg) 29.2±3.9 -.304* -.316* -.338* -.133
Body fat (%) 15.5±1.7 .357* .465** .438** .130
Body fat (kg) 4.5±0.7 .052 .044 .104 .052
Lean body mass (kg) 24.7±3.4 -.353* -.365** -.403** .160
Arm length (cm) 60.1±3.7 -.253 -.177 -.288 -.165
Supraspinal skinfold (mm) 5.8±1.4 .441** .356* .460** .331*
Subscapular skinfold (mm) 7.2±1.2 466** .325* .485** .407**
Triceps skinfold (mm) 8.7±1.5 .280 .388** .388** .055
Medial calf skinfold (mm) 8.5±1.9 .323* .410** .367* .145
Humerus biepicond.breadth (cm) 4.8±0.3 -.242 -.058 -.204 -.277
Femur biepicond. breadth (cm) 7.1±0.4 -.123 -.032 -.084 -.131
Relaxed arm girth (cm) 19.2±1.2 -.312* -.280 -.347* -.151
Flexed arm girth (cm) 20.9±1.3 -.387** -.353* -.443** -.194
Calf girth (cm) 27.9±1.8 -.286 -.249 -.336* -.152
Endomorphy 2.71±0.55 .511** .455** .560** .339*
Mesomorphy 2.99±0.70 .133 .143 .109 .098
Ectomorphy 4.22±0.88 -.277 .-108 -.215 -.323*
*: p<0.05 and **: p<0.01
Table 2
Correlations between artistry score and its sub-components’ scores (in deduction points) and
physical fitness parameters.
Mean±SD Artistry Unity Music Expression
& movement
Physical fitness parameters
Shoulder flexion (ο) 30.4±7.3 -.150 -.302* -.187 -.034
Shoulder hyperextension(ο) 37.5±4.8 -.074 -.108 -.027 -.053
Sit and reach (cm) 16.6±5.1 -.246 -.130 -.202 -.196
Straight leg raise (ο) 165.1±13.0 -.477** -.439** -.103 -.277
Sideways leg extension (ο) 154.6±15.8 -.589** -.586** -.566** -.343*
Spinal flexibility ratio (%) 85.7±7.5 -.070 -.105 -.634** -.011
Push ups (repetitions) 16±9 -.154 -.218 -.270 -.001
Abdominal muscular endurance 31±8 -.339* -.251 -.451** -.216
(repetitions)
Back extension endurance 24±4 -.401** -.240 -.293* -.436**
(repetitions)
CMJ with 2 legs (cm) 21.1±2.4 -.035 -.066 -.011 -.129
Drop jump from 40cm (cm) 22.0±3.1 -.085 -.081 -.157 -.000
High intensity shuttle run 19.54±1.50 .465** .513** .524** .225
performance (s)
Balance on the ball of the foot 13.90±13.22 -.349* -.199 -.364* -.317*
(s)
*: p<0.05 and **: p<0.01
Table 3
Results of the multiple regression analyses using the physical abilities and anthropometric
characteristics as predictors of the scores of artistry, unity, music and movement and
expression (in deduction points).
ARTISTRY Unstandardized SEB Standardized Adjusted R2
coefficient beta coefficient
B
Physical abilities 0.437**
Constant 1.088 .545
Sideways leg extension -.008 .002 -.509**
High intensity shuttle run .061 .020 .348**
performance
UNITY Unstandardized SEB Standardized Adjusted R2
coefficient beta coefficient
B
Physical abilities 0.471**
Constant .286 .176
Sideways leg extension -.003 .001 -.494**
High intensity shuttle run .023 .007 .400**
performance
MUSIC AND Unstandardized SEB Standardized Adjusted R2
MOVEMENT coefficient beta coefficient
B
Physical abilities 0.532**
Constant .337 .166
Sideways leg extension -.003 .001 -.542**
High intensity shuttle run .023 .006 .400**
performance
DISCUSSION
The aim of this study was to examine the gymnasts to move their limb sideways
the association between artistry score, using their hands into its range of motion
physical abilities and anthropometric limit. The execution of sideways leg
characteristics in preadolescent, national extension implies a firm postural control,
level, competitive rhythmic gymnasts. The body alignment and balance in order to
results demonstrated that hip flexibility properly stand while lifting and holding the
(sideways leg extension) and high leg sideways; hence it is a pre-requisite for
intensity shuttle run performance, turning, leaping and landing. Importantly,
accounted for a large part of the variance this test demonstrated the higher
of the artistry score as well as to its contribution to the variance of the artistry
separate sub-components, unity and music score compared to other commonly used
and movement. Results from the lower limb flexibility tests, such as straight
regression analysis revealed that muscular leg raise and sit and reach. However, when
endurance of the back extensors and designing a testing battery for athletes, and
subscapular skinfold significantly especially for well-trained athletes, it is
contributed to the expression score. important that the testing battery provides
Furthermore, this study provides a valid insight into sport-specific
information on values of anthropometric performance (McGuigan, 2014). General
characteristics and physical abilities of tests, do not always correlate well with
preadolescent, competitive rhythmic athletes’ competitive performance
gymnasts, associated with artistry score, (McGuigan, 2014). For example, in the
thus helping coaches monitoring training present study, sit and reach -which is a
and selection processes. valid and reliable test assessing hamstrings
Sideways leg extension was the and lower back flexibility for physically
variable that demonstrated the higher active individuals- demonstrated no
contribution to the variance of the artistry association with artistry and its sub-
score and its sub-components unity and components (Table 2). This, may be
music and movement (Table 3). Sideways explained by the fact that rhythmic
leg extension includes the combined gymnasts at this age, have already acquired
actions of hip flexion, abduction and a high level of hamstrings and lower back
external rotation (Angioi et al., 2009) and flexibility and sit and reach test is not
is suggested as a specific hip flexibility test “sensitive” to detect changes in hip
for dancers (Wyon et al., 2007). flexibility associated with complex types
Furthermore, it is recently suggested as a of movement.
lower limb flexibility test in rhythmic One interesting finding of the present
gymnastics (Santos, Lemos, Lebre, & study was that high intensity shuttle run
Ávila-Carvalho, 2015). Assessment of performance explained a significant part of
passive hip flexibility in this test requires the variance of the scores for artistry, as
well as of the scores for unity and music hyperextend the trunk in balances, leaps
and movement (Table 3). Performance and acrobatic elements, and regain a firm
time during this high intensity shuttle run standing position throughout a competitive
test depends on sprint speed, speed routine. The contribution of the
endurance (Nimphius, 2014) as well as subscapular skinfold to the variance of the
eccentric and concentric power and whole expression score may possibly be due to
body coordination required for the change the fact that in a lean body, movements are
of direction (Hader, Palazzi, & Buchheit, better defined. However, a large
2015). The ability to decelerate, change proportion of the variance in expression
direction and reaccelerate is an essential score remains unaccounted for by the
component of youth sports, influenced by physical abilities and anthropometric
training age, growth and maturation characteristics measured in the present
(Nimphius, 2014). However, despite its study. It is plausible that expression, as an
importance, this physical ability has not act of communicating emotions through
been examined in gymnastics sports. movement, is also related to different
According to the rhythmic gymnastics skills and personality traits and/or is
Code of Points (2012-2016), unity refers to developed at a later age. Furthermore,
developing a unified image with transitions although the music theme in the routine
from one movement to another, including was common for all the gymnasts that
contrasts in the speed, direction and participated in this study, a different music
intensity, without stops and/or hesitation. accompaniment may have led to different
Music and movement is defined as the movement accuracy, expression and
gymnasts’ ability to express the character interpretation, as also suggested by recent
of the music in accordance with tempo and research (Ahmed, 2016; Gantcheva,
rhythm, through continuous bodywork. 2016).
Both criteria imply the physical attribute of Several authors have pointed out
changing of direction speed while fine- anthropometric characteristics as
tuning body positioning, throughout a contributing factors to rhythmic
gymnastics routine. Furthermore, the gymnastics performance (Ávila-Carvalho,
duration of the high intensity shuttle run Klentrou, Luz-Palomero, & Lebre, 2012;
performance test in the present study was Di Cagno, et al., 2008; Douda, Toubekis,
~20 s and this time may represent the total Avloniti, & Tokmakidis, 2008).
high intensity part of the 75-90 s routine Nevertheless, the preadolescent, gymnasts
during competition. The association of this study demonstrated a balanced
between high intensity shuttle run ectomorph somatotype, thus confirming
performance with artistry scores warrants previous evidence on the importance of
further investigation, as the present study ectomorphy as a selection criterion
revealed its important contribution to the (Purenovic-Ivanovic & Popovic, 2014;
artistry score. Vernetta, Fernández, López-Bedoya,
The fact that muscular endurance of Gómez-Landero, & Oña, 2011) (Figure 1).
the back extensors and subscapular A balanced ectomorph somatotype implies
skinfold accounted for a 29.2% of that the ectomorphic component is the
expression may be explained by the dominant one and the remaining two
description of this criterion (Table 3). (endomorphy, mesomorphy) have equal
Gymnasts should create “shapes” in space prevalence and moderate values
through participation of all body segments (Purenovic-Ivanovic & Popovic, 2014). In
(head, shoulders, trunk, arms, legs) in the present study it was also found a
order to express the idea of the positive correlation of endomorphy with
choreography. Therefore, the endurance of the artistry score -in deductions- (Table 1).
the back extensors is important in order to This finding, in addition to the significant
(2008). Leaping ability and body Activities in Physical Education and Sport,
composition in rhythmic gymnasts for 6(1), 54-58.
talent identification. Journal of Sports Hader, K., Palazzi, D., & Buchheit,
Medicine & Physical Fitness, 48(3), 341- M. (2015). Change of direction speed in
346. soccer: how much braking is enough?
Di Cagno, A., Baldari, C., Battaglia, Kinesiology, 47(1), 67-74.
C., Monteiro, M.D., Pappalardo, A., Heyward, V.H. (2005). Advanced
Piazza, M., & Guidetti, L. (2009). Factors Fitness Assessment and Exercise
th
influencing performance of competitive Prescription. 4 Edition (pp.230-240),
and amateur rhythmic gymnastics-Gender Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL, USA.
differences. Journal of Science and Hume, P.A., Hopkins, W.G.,
Medicine in Sport, 12(3), 411-416. Robinson, D., Robinson, S., Hollings, S.
doi:10.1016/j.jsams.2008.01.006 (1993). Predictors of attainment in
Donti, O., Donti, A., & Theodorakou, rhythmic sportive gymnastics. Journal of
K. (2014). A review on the changes of the Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness, 33,
evaluation system affecting artistic 367-377.
gymnasts’ basic preparation: the aspect of Hopkins, W.G., Marshall, S.W.,
choreography preparation. Science of Batterham, A.M., & Hanin, J. (2009).
Gymnastics, 6(2), 63-73. Progressive statistics for studies in sports
Douda, H., Avloniti, A., Kasabalis, medicine and exercise science. Medicine
A., & Tokmakidis, S. P. (2007). and Science in Sports and Exerise, 41(1),
Adaptations on physical performance 3-13.
characteristics after a 6-month specific Karpenko, L.A., Viner, I.A., Bistrova,
training in rhythmic gymnasts. Medical I.A., Naklonov, G.I., Rumba, O.G.,
Problems of Performing Artists, 22(1), 10- Civitskii, B.A., Stepanova, I.A., &
17. Terechina, R.N. (2003). Xydojestvennaia
Douda, H.T., Toubekis, A.G., Gimnastika. [Rhythmic Gymnastics. In
Avloniti, A.A., & Tokmakidis, S.P. Russian.] Saint Petersburg: Russian
(2008). Physiological and anthropometric Gymnastics Federation, Department of
determinants of rhythmic gymnastics Physical Education, P.F. Lesgaft.
performance. International Journal of Kioumourtzoglou, E., Derri, V.,
Sports Physiology and Performance, 3(1), Mertzanidou, O., & Tzetzis, G. (1997).
41-54. Experience with perceptual and motor
Faigenbaum, A.D., Kraemer, W.J., skills in rhythmic gymnastics. Perceptual
Blimkie, J.R., Jeffreys, I., Micheli, L.J., and Motor Skills, 84(3), 1363-1372.
Nitka, M., & Rowland, T.W. (2009). doi: 10.2466/pms.1997.84.3c.1363
Youth resistance training: Updated Klentrou, P., & Pyley, M. (2003).
position statement paper from the national Onset of puberty, menstrual frequency,
strength and conditioning association. and body fat in elite rhythmic gymnast
Journal of Strength and Conditioning compared with normal controls. British
Research, 23(5), 60-76. Journal of Sports Medicine, 37(6), 490-
Fernandez-Villarino, M.A., Sierra- 494. doi:10.1136/bjsm.37.6.490
Palmeiro, E., Bobo-Arce, M., & Lago- Kosmidou, E., Proios, M.,
Peñas, C. (2015). Analysis of the training Giannitsopoulou, E., Siatras, T., Doganis,
load during the competitive period in G., Proios, M., Douda, H., Fachantidou-
individual rhythmic gymnastics. Tsiligiroglou, A. (2015). Effect of an
International Journal of Performance intervention program on body esteem,
Analysis in Sport, 15(2), 660-667. eating attitudes and pressure to be thin in
Gantcheva, G. (2016). Musical-motor rhythmic gymnastics athletes. Science of
training of junior rhythmic gymnasts. Gymnastics, 7(3), 23-36.
Original article
Abstract
Analyze of individual elite routines allows to gain more knowledge about the performance of
the RG structure. Therefore, the aim of this study is to know the difficulty elements diversity
(dance steps, masteries and dynamic elements with rotation and throw) in individual routines
of elite gymnasts who competed at the 2013 and 2014 Lisbon RG World Cup and to compare
these characteristics across different ranking groups. 288 official difficulty forms of 4
routines were analyzed. The gymnasts’ routines were clustered into three groups according to
their ranking position. Non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney tests were used.
Pearson Correlation was used to analyze the association degree of the difficulty elements in
the gymnasts’ final score. The best gymnasts presented routines with some different
characteristics, however, we verified a high similarity in the difficulties elements analyzed in
the compositions that can compromise the originality and variety of this sport. We observed
that the higher gymnasts’ final score, have also higher departure difficulty score; lower
number of combinations of base and criteria in masteries; higher number of non-fundamental
and lower number of fundamental group elements in masteries. On the other hand, higher
number of masteries and number of additional criteria of body rotations in dynamic elements
with rotation and throw, lower the gymnasts’ final score. However, we believe that the real
differences in the ranking groups is mostly justified by evaluation of the judges of the
difficulty elements presented in the official Difficulty forms and in the execution quality of the
gymnasts.
INTRODUCTION
2012). The RG-CoP changes increase the masteries; dynamic elements with rotation
difficulty and the demand of the and throw (DER) (FIG, 2012).
competition routines requirements The aim of this study are to analyze
(Lisitskaya, 1995; Oliveira et al., 2004), the difficulty elements diversity and
according to the actual practice of the variety (dance steps, masteries and DER)
sport. However, the Code also determines of the individual routines of elite gymnasts
the direction in which RG will evolve who competed at the 2013 and 2014
(Trifunov & Slobodanka, 2013). Lisbon RG World Cup and to compare
The knowledge of the content of the these characteristics across different
high level gymnasts’ competition routines ranking groups. Furthermore, to identify
including the details concerning the the difficulty elements included in the
specificity of their components, can routines that contribute the most to the
contribute to characterize the requirements success in competition. The hypothesis of
allowing improvements in a gymnasts’ the study is that the finalists gymnasts (top
preparation for competitions (Ferreirinha et 8 ranking gymnasts) have routines with
al., 2011). Therefore, to identify trends in higher scores and more complex elements
the performance structure, to understand (in quantity and difficulty) than the other
how the RG-CoP is interpreted and to meet lower-ranked gymnasts.
the compositional strategies used by
reference coaches (Ávila-Carvalho et al., METHODS
2012) can be also useful information to
coaches and gymnasts as feedback to A total of 288 individual routines
determine the training models in order to from different countries performed in 2013
improve performance (Fernandez-Villarino and 2014 Lisbon RG World Cups
et al., 2013). However, the small number (Portugal) were analyzed according to
of studies about competition routines in 2013-2016 RG-CoP rules (FIG, 2012).
RG (Agopyan, 2014) can be justified by This study was approved by the World
the constant evolution of RG-CoP Cup Organization.
requirements. Thus, according to Lebre Each participant performed 4 routines
(1993), it becomes difficult to compare the (hoop, ball, clubs and ribbon) and the
results. analysis was carried out based on the
The content of the competition Difficulty forms submitted prior to the
routines is represented by music, competition by the coaches and not
composition design and chose/combination evaluated by the judges.
of body and apparatus elements The gymnasts were clustered into
(Hökelmann et al., 2013), therefore, it is three groups according to their ranking
influenced by several qualitative and routine in each apparatus: 1st Group
quantitative factors. The qualitative factors (Finalists) – 1st to 8th place in the ranking;
are highly dependent on subjective 2nd Group – 9th to 22nd place in the ranking;
perceptions and in the other hand, the 3rd Group – 23rd to 36th place in the
quantitative factors are more objective and, ranking.
therefore, more suitable for performance The analysis was conducted by two
analysis (Breitkreutz & Hökelmann, 2012; international RG judges. The high
Hökelmann & Blaser, 2006; Hökelmann et intraclass correlation coefficient values in
al., 2012). The quantitative factors in the relative reliability analysis: intra-
individual routines in the 2013-2016 examiner (0.98) and inter-examiner (0.97),
Olympic cycle include the difficulty demonstrated high objectivity in the
elements: body difficulties; dance steps; evaluations.
Table 1
Summary of fundamental and non-fundamental apparatus group elements of the RG-CoP
(2013-2016).
Passing through the Hoop with the whole or part of Passing over the Hoop with the whole or part of the
the body body
Roll of the Hoop over minimum 2 body segments Small throw and catch
Hoop
Roll of the Hoop on the floor Throws or catches: Medium or Large throw
Rotations of the Hoop around its axis: One free Apparatus handling: Figure 8 with ample body
rotation between the fingers or on the part of the body movement; Large circles; Transmission of the
/ Series of rotations on the floor apparatus around any part of the body or under the
leg(s)
Series of rotations around the hand / One free rotation Unstable balance on the part of the body
around a part of the body
Roll of the Ball on the floor: Large (min. 1 meter) or “Flip-over” movement of the Ball; Rotations of the
series of small rolls hand(s) around the Ball; Series of assisted small roll;
Roll of the body over the Ball on the floor;
“Trust”/push of the Ball from different parts of the
body
Ball Roll of the Ball over minimum 2 large body segments Throws or catches: Medium or Large throw
Catch of the Ball with one hand Small throw and catch
Series of small bounces or one high bounce; Visible Apparatus handling: Large circles; Transmission of the
rebound from a part of the body apparatus around any part of the body or under the
leg(s)
Figures eight of the ball with circle movements of the Unstable balance on the part of the body
arms and ample movement of the trunk
Mills: at least 4 small circles of the Clubs with time For 1 or 2 clubs: Free rotations on the part of the body
delay and by alternating crossed and uncrossed or on the floor; Rolls on the part of the body or on the
wrists/ hands each time floor; Rebound from the body; “Sliding”; Tapping (min
1); “Trust”/push of the Club from different parts of the
body
Asymmetric movements of 2 Clubs Small throw and catch of 1 Club
Clubs Small throws and catches with rotation of 2 Clubs Throws or catches: Medium or Large throw
together simultaneously or alternating
Throws or catches of 2 Clubs, simultaneous or
asymmetric
“Cascade” throws (double or triple)
Spirals (4-5 waves); Spirals on the floor “Boomerang” (in the air or on the floor)
Snakes (4-5 waves); Snakes on the floor Rotational movement of the stick around the hand; Roll
of the stick on the part of the body; Rebound of the
stick from the part of the body; Wrapping; Movement
of the Ribbon around a part of the body created when
the stick is held by different parts of the body
Ribbon Passing through or over the pattern of the Ribbon Small throw and catch
“Echappé” Throws or catches: Medium or Large throw
Apparatus handling: Figure 8 with ample body
movement; Large circles; Transmission of the
apparatus around any part of the body or under the
leg(s)
Unstable balance on the part of the body
Table 2
Summary Table of Additional Criteria of throw, body rotation and catch of apparatus in
DER.
For statistical analyses of the data we (NFGE): Table 1 presents the FGE and
used the Statistical Package for Social NFGE in hoop, ball, clubs and ribbon
Sciences – version 20.0. The level of routines. These apparatus elements are
significance was set at α = 0.05. performed in the dance steps, masteries
Descriptive statistics were calculated using and body difficulties, and they should be
the mean, standard deviation (SD) and included in the official Difficulty forms.
range values. The Kruskal-Wallis and - Masteries: The mastery consists of,
Mann-Whitney non-parametric tests were at least, 1 base (1B) – FGE and/or NFGE,
used to compare the ranking groups. plus a minimum 2 criteria (2C). Or 2 bases
Pearson Correlation was performed to (2B) plus minimum 1 criteria (1C).
analyze the association degree of the - DER: Table 2 shows the additional
difficulty elements in the gymnasts’ final criteria of throw, body rotation (during the
score. fly of the apparatus) and catch of the
apparatus performed in the DER.
RG-CoP rules (FIG, 2012):
- Fundamental (FGE) and non-
fundamental apparatus group elements
Table 3
Number of masteries elements with fundamental and non-fundamental group elements in
Rhythmic Gymnastics routines clustered according to their ranking position.
Figure 1. Dance steps data presented in the Rhythmic Gymnastics routines clustered
according to their ranking position.
Table 4
Number of rotations and additional criteria performed in the DER per apparatus in the
Rhythmic Gymnastics routines clustered according to their ranking position.
Ranking groups Nº Rotations Total nº add Nº add criteria Nº add criteria Nº add criteria
Apparatus (x±sd) criteria (x±sd) Throw (x±sd) BD (x±sd) Catch (x±sd)
Hoop Finalists (n=16) 3.12±0.49 4.25±1.05 1.02±0.55 1.38±0.74 1.85±0.49
2nd Group (n=28) 3.24±0.39 4.42±0.84 1.27±0.1 1.66±0.61 1.49±0.65
3rd Group (n=28) 3.10±0.43 4.25±0.73 1.04±0.50 1.67±0.57 1.55±0.60
Ball Finalists (n=16) 3.04±0.34 3.19±0.70 0.33±0.32 1.54±0.74 1.31±0.65
2nd Group (n=28) 3.16±0.33 2.91±0.61 0.29±0.31 1.51±0.52 1.11±0.51
3rd Group (n=28) 3.07±0.52 3.29±0.81 0.37±0.29 1.74±0.76 1,18±0.58
Clubs Finalists (n=16) 3.19±0.32 4.21±0.47 1.67±0.52 1.73±0.56 0.81±0.50
2nd Group (n=28) 3.35±0.39 3.85±0.93 1.33±0.59 1.81±0.64 0.70±0.58
3rd Group (n=28) 3.27±0.37 3.92±0.90 1.30±0.51 1.89±0.55 0.73±0.51
Ribbon Finalists (n=16) 3.69±0.31 3.02±0.71 0.73±0.39 1.81±0.61 0.48±0.60
2nd Group (n=28) 3.54±0.38 3.19±0.66 0.73±0.34 2.02±0.51 0.44±0.43
3rd Group (n=28) 3.39±0.54 3.00±0.93 0.75±0.47 1.92±0.66 0.33±0.41
Figure 3. Masteries performed during a body difficulty elements in the Rhythmic Gymnastics
routines clustered according to their ranking position.
Table 5
Pearson correlations – dependent and independents variables.
Dependent Variable Independent Variables Proof value Pearson Correlation
Nº Masteries with NFGE p=0.002* 0.184
Final Score in the competition Nº add criteria of body rotation p=0.002* -0.190
(DER)
Departure difficulty score p≤0.001* 0.540
Difficulty Score in competition p≤0.001* 0.962
Legend: NFGE – non-fundamental groups apparatus elements; DER – dynamic elements with
rotation and throw; * p ≤0.05: Significant differences
Original article
Abstract
Gender participation rates are different and the potential reasons are namely sports
availability and stereotypes. In spite of gymnastics being recently considered as an “early
specialization” sport, characterized by a higher number of female participants than male
ones, it has been highlighted that there are much less published studies in female athletes
than in males. The aim of this study was to analyze the gender participation among
Portuguese gymnasts according to gymnastics’ disciplines. An individual authorized database
of all national gymnasts involved in the National School of Gymnastics of the Gymnastics
Federation of Portugal among four athletic seasons, namely 2012/2013,2013/2014,
2014/2015 and 2015/2016 was used. From a sample of 14,742 gymnasts, 81.3% were female
and only 18.7% were male(P<0.01) during the athletic season of 2012/2013. Similar results
were found in the next three seasons as follows: 83.3% females and 16.7% males in
2013/2014, 84.9% females and 15.1% males in 2014/2015 and 85.3% females and 14.7%
males in 2015/2016. Significantly gymnasts-gender differences(P<0.01) were observed for all
disciplines. No differences between genders were observed in Rhythmic Gymnastics, Women's
Artistic Gymnastics and Men's Artistic Gymnastics due to the exclusive sport participation of
female and male gymnasts, respectively. Gymnastics should improve participation and
combat gender inequalities.
INTRODUCTION
mastery (Calavalle et al., 2008; Silva & described with proportions for categorical
Paiva, 2015a). variables. Spearman correlation coefficient
Therefore, this study aims to be an was used to determine associations
extension of the published study by Silva between categorical and continuous
and Barata (2016) by analyzing the gender variables; due to the number of subjects
participation among Portuguese gymnasts evaluated the significance level used was
according to gymnastics’ disciplines. 5% (p0.05). Data was analyzed using
SPSS statistical software version 22.0 for
METHODS Windows (New York, USA).
Figure 1. Number of gymnasts participating in the several disciplines of the FGP during the
seasons of 2012/2013, 2013/2014, 2014/2015 and 2015/2016 (GfA: Gymnastics for All. TRA:
Trampoline Gymnastics. ACRO: Acrobatic Gymnastics. RG: Rhythmic Gymnastics. WAG:
Women's Artistic Gymnastics. TG: Teamgym. AER: Aerobic Gymnastics. MAG: Men’s
Artistic Gymnastics. HH: Hip Hop).
Figure 2. Gender participation in the most practiced disciplines of the FGP during four
athletic seasons: 2012/2013, 2013/2014, 2014/2015 and 2015/2016 (GfA: Gymnastics for All.
ACRO: Acrobatic Gymnastics. TRA: Trampoline Gymnastics. WAG: Women's Artistic
Gymnastics).
Figure 3. Gender participation in the less practiced disciplines of the FGP during four athletic
seasons: 2012/2013, 2013/2014, 2014/2015 and 2015/2016 (AER: Aerobic Gymnastics. TG:
Teamgym. HH: Hip Hop).
Portuguese gymnasts’ participation during done in the next sport seasons in order to
the last four athletic seasons have been clarify this evolution.
demonstrated, including the recent sport After GfA, TRA and ACRO were the
season of 2015/2016. most practiced disciplines in Portugal, but
Several studies have been conducted a recent change was observed in
in athletes regarding physiology, 2015/2016 with ACRO’s participants
biomechanics, psychology, but most of overstepping TRA’s participants. In fact,
them are reported to males. Therefore, and ACRO has a growing number of
from our best knowledge, this is one of the participants worldwide (Grapton, Lion,
very few studies evaluating gender Gauchard, Barrault, & Perrin, 2013) and
participation in gymnastics. Portuguese acrobatic gymnasts seem to be
The former president of the included in this general trend. On the other
International Olympic Committee (IOC), hand, HH had no participants, being
Jacques Rogge (2012) highlighted at the female or male, so this should be weighed
Games Opening Ceremony that “For the by Portuguese local associations and the
first time in Olympic history, all the FGP.
participating teams will have had female Although the Olympic Movement
athletes, and this is a major boost for (International Olympic Committee, 2011)
gender equality”. In fact, Donnelly and states the need to achieve equality between
Donnelly (2013) reported that 4,835 men and women in sport at all levels and
female athletes participated in the 2012 in all structures, a new challenge stands up
London Olympic Games, no countries for the sport worldwide, which is that there
excluded female athletes and women is a clear inequality of gender participation
competed in every sport. Contrarily, in gymnastics, reflected in our results,
Boykoff and Yasuoka (2013) concluded since Portuguese female gymnasts showed
that in the London 2012 Olympics, there a high and significant presence in the
were 39 men-only events, including the Portuguese Gymnastics (P<0.05). This
pommel horse and rings in gymnastics, and should be interpreted as part of a solution
only two women-only events, such as RG for the so-called “gender inequality in
and synchronized swimming. sport”, according to recent literature
In our study, significantly gender (Baker et al., 2014; Claringbould,
differences (P<0.01) were observed for all Knoppers & Jacobs, 2015; Di Cagno et al.,
disciplines with a female participation’s 2009; Godoy-Pressland & Griggs, 2014;
rate much higher than the male one. Mackintosh, Darko, Rutherford, &
As expected, no differences between Wilkins, 2014). A plausible explanation
genders were observed for RG, WAG and might be related to the dominant gender in
MAG due to the exclusive sport the social system around gymnastics, i.e.,
participation of female or male gymnasts, female sport produces a different
respectively. environment governed by distinct social
Although the still most practiced and developmental factors than those
discipline in Portugal is GfA, where important in male sport (Barker et al.,
gender selection is not a prerequisite for 2014).
sport’s participation, its prevalence On the other hand, political and social
decreased in the last season of 2015/2016, time may be an important constraint to
contrarily to Barker, Barker-Ruchti, Wals gymnastics’ practice in Portugal, because
and Tinning (2014), and Silva and Paiva athletic seasons of 2012/2013 and
(2016), who concluded that most athletes 2014/2015 demonstrated the lowest
choose to persist with competitive sport numbers of female participation in all
voluntarily. Thus, more research has to be disciplines, with exception for GfA, AER
and HH; and, in turn, the athletic season of
2014/2015 was the worst of all athletic participation in geographical areas with
seasons with regard to male participation, fewer participants.
showing a decrease in all disciplines, with The limitations of this study should be
exception for MAG. Therefore, may be the taken into account when interpreting these
social and economic situation of results. First, age was not a studied
Portuguese families in those periods of variable. Although its relative effects have
time was not favorable for sport practice been studied (Schorer, Cobley, Büsch,
(Schubring & Thiel, 2014). Portugal was, Bräutigam, & Baker, 2009), we assumed
and still is, in a terrible socio-economic that gymnastics’ disciplines would be of
crisis, which might influence gymnasts greater interest for this publication.
sport practice. Longitudinal studies are being
Moreover, Weir and colleagues (2010) implemented in the FGP in order to study
in a study about the age of sport the possible relation between the
participation concluded that the number of prevalence of a specific gymnastics’
sport participants might vary due to the discipline according to the geographic area
cultural importance of different sports with and gymnasts’ results in national and
the most capable athletes, the relatively international competitions. They would
older ones going to sports with the greatest also be interesting and necessary in
cultural relevance. In addition to physical evaluating gymnastics’ evolution in
and cognitive demands, gymnasts should relation to gender, relative age effects and
also integrate a high degree of technical sport participation.
(Barker et al., 2014) and artistic skills into This study adds additional light on the
their dynamic and aesthetic exercises (Di social, economic and cultural influence of
Cagno et al., 2009). the global economic crisis for sport
On the other hand, gymnastics is participation of Portuguese gymnasts, and
known to be the oldest sport ever practiced provides a new insight to reinforce the
and is often sought to be the better sport to practice of gymnastics worldwide, in
develop physical and mentally the “raw accordance with significant differences
material” at very young ages (Baker et al., between female and male’s participation.
2014; Silva & Paiva, 2015a). Gymnastics should be studied and used as
Although not significantly, Portuguese a sport capable of improving participation
female gymnasts’ participation only and combat gender inequalities.
increased in GfA and AER in the last
athletic season, and the same was ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
demonstrated by male participants in
MAG. This work is financed by National
Considering that when gymnasts are Founds from FCT – Foundation for
relatively older, they transfer to other Science and Technology regarding the
sports (Barker et al, 2014) and that a reference’s project: PEst-
combination of factors might be OE/SADG/UI0283/2015.
responsible for that (Omiya et al., 2014), a
problem stands up for the FGP. As REFERENCES
mentioned before, age was not available
for this study, but it might have a major Baker, J., Janning, C., Wong, H.,
influence in sport participation (Silva & Cobley, S., & Schorer, J. (2014).
Barata, 2016). Variations in relative age effects in
Education sessions to increase future individual sports: skiing, figure skating and
gymnasts’ participation should be gymnastics. European Journal of Sport
implemented as a new perspective of Science, 14(S1), 183-190.
increasing both female and male doi:10.1080/17461391.2012.671369.
deficiencies during periods of intense Silva, M.-R. G., & Barata, P. (2016).
training. Pediatric Exercise Science, 23(4), Athletes and coaches’ gender inequality:
560-572. the case of the Gymnastics Federation of
Omiya, K., Sekizuka, H., Kida, K., Portugal. Science of Gymnastics, 8(2), 187-
Suzuki K., Akashi, Y.J., Ohba, H., et al. 196.
(2014). Influence of gender and types of Slater, A., & Tiggemann, M. (2011).
sports training on QT variables in young Gender differences in adolescent sport
elite athletes. European Journal of Sport participation, teasing, self-objectification
Science, 14, S32-S38. and body image concerns. Journal of
Rogge, J. (2012). Opening Ceremony Adolescence, 34(3), 455-463.
– London 2012 Olympic Games. Retrieved doi:10.1016/j.adolescence.2010.06.007.
February 05, 2014, from Weir, P. L., Smith, K. L., Paterson, C.,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v¼fdGpa & Horton, S. (2010). Canadian women’s
WZMMPE. ice hockey - evidence of a relative age
Schorer, J., Cobley, S., Büsch, D., effect. Talent Development and
Bräutigam, H., & Baker, J. (2009). Excellence, 2, 209-217.
Influences of competition level, gender,
player nationality, career stage and playing
position on relative age effects.
Scandinavian Journal of Medicine &
Science in Sports, 19(5), 720-730.
doi:10.1111/j.1600-0838.2008.00838.x.
Schubring, A., & Thiel, A. (2014). Corresponding author:
Growth problems in youth elite sports.
Social conditions, athletes’ experiences Maria-Raquel G. Silva
and sustainability consequences. Reflective Faculty of Health Sciences
Practice: International and University Fernando Pessoa
Multidisciplinary Perspectives, 15(1), 78- Rua Carlos da Maia,196
91. Oporto 4200-150, Portugal
Silva, M.-R.G., & Paiva, T. (2015a). e-mail: raquel@ufp.edu.pt
Low energy availability and low body fat
of female gymnasts before an international
competition. European Journal of Sport
Science, 15, 591-599.
doi:10.1080/17461391.2014.969323.
Silva, M.-R.G., & Paiva, T. (2015b).
Sleep and circadian rhythm in athletes. In:
Sleep, nutrition, circadian rhythm, jet lag
and athletic performance [in Portuguese].
Lisbon: Gymnastics Federation of
Portugal/ Portuguese Institute of Sport and
Youth I.P., p.50-69.
Silva, M.-R.G., & Paiva, T. (2016).
Poor precompetitive sleep habits, nutrients'
deficiencies, inappropriate body
composition and athletic performance in
elite gymnasts. European Journal of Sport
Science, 27, 1-10.
doi:10.1080/17461391.2015.1103316.
Original article
Abstract
Over the years gymnastics is changing, difficulty of the routines is improving, the technology
and the equipment are developing, Code of Points (COP) is getting new aspects. In 15 years,
from the year of 2000 to 2015 COP changed a lot. Two measurements of morphological
characteristics of top level male gymnasts were taken and compared, one from the year of
2000 and one from 2015, both from a World Cup Competition in Ljubljana. Our study showed
some significant differences in abdomen circumferences and percentage of muscle mass of
gymnasts in 15 years. Despite there were no significant differences, the tendency is the
increase in body height, with less percentage of body fat and percentage of muscle mass (with
the exception of gymnasts competing on floor). With lower percentage of body fat, lower
percentage of muscle mass and almost unchanged body weight we can presume bone mass
probably increased and with tendency of taller gymnasts also other inner organs, increased
weight.
INTRODUCTION
Gymnastics as a sport has quite a long Gymnastics consists only of free program
history (the first World Championship was on various apparatus, which are the same
organized in 1903 in Antwerpen, as back then (FIG, 2016).
Netherlands), and as years are passing, the The competition program is similar,
competition program is changing. In the but rules in Men’s Artistic Gymnastics
mid-30s of the previous century, the male changed a lot in the last 15 years. Some
gymnastics program was already quite parts of the COP 1997-2000 and COP
similar to what we have today. Gymnasts 2013-2016 are even hard to compare. The
competed in Free Program ('floor’ today), most visible change is the calculation of
Pommel Horse, Rings, Vault, Parallel Bars the Final Score. In the year of 2000 the
and High Bar, both in the compulsory and maximal score was 10.00 points (that
optional program (Štukelj, 1989). These changed in the 2006 COP (FIG, 2006)).
days, a program in Men’s Artistic The Score was calculated from the “B”
Score – score of execution, which was Values of elements are different (from A to
maximum 5.00 points and the “A” Score, H the value is increasing per 0.1 point,
which consisted of difficulty value, special which is 0.1 point for A value and 0.8
requirements on each apparatus and bonus point for H value). In their routines
points (for executing difficult elements and gymnasts have to include elements from
connections of them), also maximum 5.00 five different groups and for including
points. From the year of 2006 on, the final each element group there is a 0.5 points
score is calculated from “D” Score for bonus. For short exercises, where there is
Difficulty and “E” Score for Execution. not 10 elements shown, the D-Panel jury
“E” Score, starts from 10.00 points and is takes an appropriate neutral deduction
evaluated by deductions (the exercise (FIG, 2016).
presentation related to compositional Regarding dismount elements, there
requirements, technique and body position) was a deduction in 2000 for a dismount
applied in tenths of a point. In general difficulty not being corresponding to the
deductions are much more defined in 2015 difficulty of the exercise. The deduction
than they were in 2000; the level of precise was 0.1 point for B value dismount, 0.2
errors (for deviations from the expected points for A value dismount and 0.4 points
perfect performance) remains mostly the for no dismount (FIG; 1997). In 2015 the
same though. Small, medium, large errors dismount element is part of the Group
and falls are deducted differently in the 15 element requirement. The gymnast
years difference (the small deduction achieves a full requirement value of 0.5
remains the same, the medium error points for D or higher value of a dismount,
changes from 0.2 to 0.3 point, the large for C value dismount he receives 0.3 points
error from 0.4 to 0.5 points, the deduction as achieving partial requirement value. For
for a fall raised up from 0.5 to 1.00 point lower difficulty values than C values, the
deduction (FIG, 1997; FIG, 2016)). gymnast does not fulfil the requirement
In the year of 2000 values of difficulty (FIG, 2016).
elements ranged from A to Super E. The As stated in Čuk et. al (2007)
difficulty value (on each apparatus except gymnastics saw a major change in its rules
for vault) for elements was up to 2.40 in 1997. FIG (1997) abolished compulsory
points and was calculated from 4 A (4 x exercises on apparatus. This reduced the
0.1 point), 3 B (3 x 0.2 points), 2 C (2 x need for a large number of hours in
0.4 points) and 1 D (1 x 0.6 points). There training. The same year FIG also
were 3 special requirements on each introduced World Cup on individual
apparatus (0.4 points each). The gymnasts apparatus which enabled gymnasts to
were awarded with bonus points for further adjust their training to their
execution of difficulty elements and personal needs and abilities in order to be
connections of elements with a D, E or successful on individual apparatus. Top
Super E values (0.1 or 0.2 points for each level gymnasts start with their gymnastics
connection, depends on the values of the career as very young, usually at preschool
elements). The level of difficulty increased age. Today experts believe that the hours
in 15 years, especially in acrobatic of training are about 5-6 hour training
elements. In2015 values reach up to H (for sessions. Gymnasts train 1500 hours per
example Kovacs with 2/1 twists on high year in 300-310 days (Arkaev & Suchilin,
bar, which did not yet exist in 2000 COP) 2003), 26-28 hours per week
and will include a difficulty value of 10 (Georgopoulos et. al, 2011).
elements (8 for juniors), the best 9 (7 for The consequences of COP changes for
juniors), but maximum 4 elements for the competitors and their preparation can be
same Element Group inside the best summarised as follows:
counting, plus the value of the dismount.
The deduction for fall has increased, Netherlands; Bach concluded that shorter
compared to previous COP; therefore persons probably stand a better chance of
competitors do not need to risk including succeeding in gymnastics while taller
an insufficiently mastered element into persons are more likely to succeed in track
routine, which was possible in previous and field (Škerlj, 1934). Čuk & Novak
code of rules. This leads to a bigger drill (1985) defined successful gymnast as the
based on a higher number of repetitions of one who is short (the ratio between the
learned movement structures. However, it length of trunk and the length of legs
has to be noted that this measure leads to should be such that the muscles can
higher exercise safety. Contrary to the quickly move these levers), light and has a
rules valid until 2000 when a gymnast had strong chest with a relatively high and
to perform three special requirements in good quality muscular mass and has a very
individual disciplines (except for vault), little subcutaneous fat. According to
the newer version of the routine must Arkaev & Suchilin (2003) typical of both
include elements from five groups. men and women modern gymnasts, is
Competitors are therefore forced to ectomorph and ecto-mesomorph type of
perform a wider range of different body composition, moderately wide
movement structures within the routine, shoulders, narrow hips, long arms,
which means that they must be technically relatively long legs and short trunk. As
and functionally better prepared for stated in Čuk et al. (2007) from the year
individual disciplines. 1933 up to 2000 gymnast’s body height
The change in rules forces and weight was not changed, but there
competitors to improve technique as well were changes in shoulders and hips width,
as condition preparation in order to where gymnasts in the beginning of the
perform the dismount with a full value new millennium had wider shoulder and
bonification, C value element for juniors narrower hips, this being a consequence of
and D value element for seniors. more complex movements with more
The above mentioned facts imply that rotations around longitudinal and sagittal
a perfectly acquired technique of complex axis.
temporo-spatial structures is an essential Gymnasts that were competing in
factor of gymnastic sport performance. As 2015 had been born in the first years of the
stated in Prassas et al. (2006), a 1990’s and most likely started to compete
prerequisite of correctly mastered around year 2000. At that time rules were
gymnastic abilities are ability to gain different, and their trainings were adjusted
height, ability to rotate, generating twist, to the rules that were in use then. In year
transferring angular momentum from one 2006 when the open ended COP was
body part to another, increasing or introduced, they had to adopt their training
decreasing rotation by altering body within new COP. Therefore, they already
configuration, ability to swing and ability had almost 9 years of adaptation time
to land. These partial abilities are based on towards COP.
understanding and use of various The main purpose of the study is to
biomechanical principles and patterns verify, if with the significant change of
which affect the given movement rules in the COP between the years,
structures at individual equipment. consequently structural change of routines,
Kinematic data, while explicitly different deduction procedure and
dependent on technique, is at the same increasing number of specialists on
time implicitly dependent on the strength, different apparatus have any effect on
flexibility, and somatotype of the particular changing male artistic gymnasts
athlete (Kob et al., 2003). It was already at morphological characteristics, specifically
the Olympic Games 1928 in Amsterdam, body height and weight, the
Table 1
Descriptive statistics of morphological differences of the gymnasts, between the years of 2000
and 2015.
No significant difference (p(t-test) > general increase of the human height in the
0.05) is in height according to the averages last decades (0.99 cm per a decade note by
for each apparatus and altogether. There Johnston & Padez (2009)). Nevertheless
was also Čuk et. al (2007) who discovered the gymnasts tend to be taller in 2015 than
no difference in gymnasts body height in 2000; however the variability is also
between 1933 and 2000, despite the higher in 2015 than in 2000 and therefore
significant meaning, where additional body body fat, lower percentage of muscle mass
mass does not necessarily represents and almost unchanged body weight, we
higher absolute power. The highest assume the difference comes from higher
difference is in percentage of muscle mass percentage of bone mass and higher mass
of gymnasts competing on floor, and it is of inner organs. Comparing the floor
the only difference that shows gymnasts routines from different years on videos,
had more percentage of muscle mass in gymnasts in 2000 mostly had 3 diagonals,
2015 than in 2000. On the other three each with mostly one basic difficult
apparatus – pommel horse, parallel and acrobatic element within a diagonal, but
high bar, the significant difference shows gymnasts nowadays mostly have 4
the gymnasts had had more percentage of diagonals of difficult acrobatic elements,
muscle mass in 2000 than they had in also with two difficulties within a
2015. diagonal. A quantitative increase of body
There is three times that F-test was loan in take offs and landings of difficult
significant (F > p(F-test)). In BMI on acrobatic elements might also lead to an
parallel bars, percentage of body fat mass increase of percentage of bone mass. So
on pommel horse and percentage of muscle further research is necessary to compare
mass on floor. Among those, the bone density, there might also be
significant difference between the years interesting to verify some potential
(p(t-test) < 0.05) is only in percentage of changes in insertion according to the
muscle mass on floor, the other compared execution of higher difficulty level
variables are not significantly different, but nowadays.
there is a big difference in variance
between these variables in 15 years. And in EXPERIMENT LIMITATIONS
almost 80% of all compared variables for
the apparatus, the level of variance in Differences in measurement
variables in 2015 was much bigger than it techniques limited the comparable
had been in 2000. Even if there are no morphological characteristics. Due to that
significant difference in measured (or we could not compare chest circumference,
calculated) values, there is a tendency for thigh circumference and skeletal lean
bigger differences between the lowest and mass. We don’t know how the InBody720
the highest value of different variables, calculating procedure for percentage of
which means the change of rules, structural muscle mass and percentage of fat mass,
change of routines, different deduction but they were still compared to see the
procedure and increasing number of difference. Gymnasts competing on vault
specialists on different apparatus did have were not compared because of the lack of
some affect to morphological data.
characteristics of gymnasts. For further analysis the same
We don’t have data for bone density, measurement techniques have to be used
but it would be interesting to compare and compared to get more reliable results.
values of it between the years. According FIG, or UEG and other continental
to the changing of bone mass density and federations might consider integrating and
skeletal status with trainings in artistic connecting the researchers from different
gymnastics (as stated in Nichols- countries and organizations, to get the data
Richardson, et. al, 2000; Dowthwaite & and variables from all the World Cup
Scerpella, 2009; Nichols et al. 1994; competitions in different locations, to
Pullock, et. al, 2006; and many others), conduct researches and update of database
values of bone density might also change for further analysis. InBody720 is
with years. As our results show, gymnasts inexpensive and fast method for
in 2015 tend to have lower percentage of determination of morphological
Standing from left: Gustav Felix Flatow, Fritz Hofmann, Gustav Schuft, sitting on fence:
Richard Rostel, Conrad Bocker, Hermann Weingärten, Alfred Flatow, Richard Gadebusch,
sitting on floor: Fritz Mantenffel, Carl Schuhmann.
Science of Gymnastics Journal 213 Science of Gymnastics Journal
GAJDOŠ A. SHORT HISTORICAL NOTES VIII Vol. 9 Issue 2: 213
Team Olympic Champions on parallel bars and horizontal bar and individual Olympic
Champions: Wingärtner Hermann on horizontal bar, Alfred Flatow on parallel bars, Carl
Schuhmann on vault.
Science of Gymnastics Journal 214 Science of Gymnastics Journal
GAJDOŠ A. SHORT HISTORICAL NOTES VIII Vol. 9 Issue 2: 213
After retirement from being gymnast, he was coach (national coach at OG 1972, where Japan
won), professor at Nihon University, director of Japanese Olympic Committee and vice
president of Japanese Gymnastics Federation (two mandates).
Science of Gymnastics Journal 215 Science of Gymnastics Journal
SLOVENSKI IZVLEČKI / SLOVENE ABSTRACTS Vol. 9 Issue 2: 216 - 219
Številne prvine pri telovadbi zahtevajo natančno vzajemno delovanje med telovadcem in
okoljem. Nejasno ostaja, kako različne točke v okolju učinkujejo in delujejo pri nadzoru
zapletenih prvin, kot so Jurčenko preskoki, kjer telovadec opravi premet vstran z obratom nazaj
kot naskok na odrivno desko. Namen te študije je bil oceniti vloge obeh objektov, položaj
blazine pred odrivno desko in položaja odskočne deske, pri nadzoru časovnih spremenljivk pri
Jurčenku. Kinematični parametri osmih telovadk so bili izmerjeni pri običajni izvedbi in dveh
poskusnih pogojih z različnimi oddaljenostmi blazine pred odrivno desko in odrivne deske.
Rezultati so pokazali, da je bil vidni nadzor nad blazino pri zaletu v povprečju dva koraka pred
blazino. Postavitvi dlani na blazino je sledil časovno konstanten let na odrivno desko.
Telovadke so v povprečju postavile svoje noge na isto mesto na odrivni deski, ne glede na to, ali
je bil položaj odrivne deske spremenjen. Postavitev dlani na kup blazin (namesto mize za
preskok) se je spreminjalo v odvisnosti od položaja odrivne deske in dolžine leta do opore na
rokah. Ta študija dokazuje, da položaj odrivne deske določa Jurčenka. Znanje o odnosih med
informacijskimi viri v okolju in posledično gibalno obnašanje pri telovadbi lahko vaditeljem
pomagajo pri razvijanju programov usposabljanja, katerih namen je povečati sposobnosti
telovadcev, da te informacije uporabijo pri prvinah in v spreminjajočih se okoljskih razmerah pri
vadbi in tekmovanju.
Ključne besede: vidno zaznavanje, zahteve naloge, zaznavanje časa pri Jurčenku, kinematična
analiza.
SLOVENSKI IZVLEČKI / SLOVENE ABSTRACTS Vol. 9 Issue 2: 216 - 219
Relativno majhno število telovadk sodeluje na olimpijskih igrah in še manjšo število sodeluje na
olimpijskih igrah zaporedoma zaradi številnih različnih razlogov. Zato je namen te raziskave: 1)
določiti število telovadk, ki so sodelovali na tekmovanju C-I na olimpijskih igrah v letu 2012 in
na olimpijskih igrah, ki so potekale leta 2016; 2) določiti značilnosti in razlike v rezultatih
zaporednih udeleženk na teh dveh olimpijskih igrah; 3) določiti razlike med zaporednimi
udeleženkami in drugimi tekmovalkami na prej določenih tekmovanjih. Ugotovljeno je bilo, da
je le 25 telovadk sodelovalo na dveh zaporednih olimpijskih igrah. Od enih do drugih
olimpijskih iger so telovadke številčno povečali vse rezultate; znatno povečala rezultat izvedbe
in končnih rezultatov na dvovišinski bradlji; znatno znižale rezultat izvedbo in končni rezultat
na gredi. V primerjavi z drugimi telovadkami z olimpijskih iger 2012 in 2016 so zaporedne
udeleženke imele številčno višje vrednosti v vseh spremenljivkah, vendar so le nekateri izmed
njih opredeljeni kot bistveno drugačni. Zaporedne udeleženke so potrdili možnost neprestanega
kakovostnega razvoja spretnosti sredi 20-ih let starosti.
Ključne besede: zaporedne udeleženke, tekmovanje C-I, olimpijske igre 2012-2016, ANOVA
Maria Kritikou, Olyvia Donti, Gregory C. Bogdanis, Anastasia Donti, Kalliopi Theodorakou
POVEZANOSTI MED OCENAMI ZA UMETNIŠKI VTIS PRI
Ključne besede: izraz, gibalne sposobnosti, obseg gibanja, somatotip, hitrost teka.
SLOVENSKI IZVLEČKI / SLOVENE ABSTRACTS Vol. 9 Issue 2: 216 - 219
Analiza posameznih sestav vrhunskih ritmičark omogoča vpogled v strukturo sestav. Cilj
raziskave je bil ugotoviti razširjenost težavnosti (plesni koraki, mojstrstva in dinamične prvine z
obrati in meti) pri vrhunskih ritmičarkah, ki so tekmovale v letu 2013 in 2014 na Svetovnem
pokalu v ritmiki v Lizboni, v treh katgorijah uspešnosti. Na osnovi 288 obrazcev težavnosti 4
orodij je bila narejena analiza. Sestave so bile razvrščene v tri skupine glede na rang na
tekmovanju. Neparametrična testa Kruskal-Walis in Mann-Whitney sta bila uporabljena za ocen
razlik med skupinami. Pearsonov korelacijski koeficient je bil uporabljen za ugatavljanje
povezanosti med stopnjo težavnosti in končno oceno. Najboljše ritmičarke so prikazale sestave z
nekaterimi drugačnimi značilnostmi, čeprav smo zaznali visoko podobnost v težavnosti v
sestavah, ki lahko spreminjajo originalnost in raznolikost tega športa. Višja končna ocena ima
višjo težavnost, manjše število povezav in mojsterstev, višje število prvin neosonovnih in nižje
število prvin osnovnih skupin prvin in mojsterstev. Na drugi strani, višje število mojsterstev in
višje število prvin z obrati in dinamičnih prvin z obrati in meti pomeni nižjo končno oceno.
Verjamemo, da je so prave razlike v kategorijah uspešnosti opravičene z ocenjevanjem sodnikov
težavnosti v obrazcu težavnosti in izvedbi.
Maria-Raquel G. Silva, Rita Santos-Rocha, Paulo Barata in Francisco Saavedra
RAZLIKE V SPOLU MED ČLANSTVOM PORTUGLASKE TELOVADNE ZVEZE MED
LETI 2012 IN 2016
SLOVENSKI IZVLEČKI / SLOVENE ABSTRACTS Vol. 9 Issue 2: 216 - 219
Karmen Šibanc, Miriam Kalichová, Petr Hedbávný, Ivan Čuk, Maja Bučar Pajek
PRIMERJAVA TELESNIH ZNAČILNOSTI VRHUNSKIH TELOVADCEV MED LOTOMA
2000 IN 2015