Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Meiboudi 2017
Meiboudi 2017
Meiboudi 2017
Research article
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Environmental responsibility in school has led to the emergence of a variety of criteria to administer
Received 8 August 2016 green schools' contributions to sustainability. Sustainability criteria of administrative green schools need
Received in revised form validity, reliability and norms. The aim of the current study was to develop and validate assessment
16 March 2017
criteria for green schools in Iran based on the role of academia. A national survey was conducted to
Accepted 14 April 2017
obtain data on sustainability criteria initiatives for green schools and the Iranian profile was defined. An
initial pool of 71 items was generated and after its first edition, 63 items were selected to comprise the
sustainability criteria. Engineering-architectural and behavioral aspects of this sustainability criteria
Keywords:
Sustainability criteria
were evaluated through a sample of 1218 graduate students with environmental degrees from Iran's
Green schools universities. Exploratory factor analysis using principal components and promax rotation method
Exploratory factor analysis showed that these 9 criteria have simple structures and are consistent with the theoretical framework.
Iran The reliability coefficients of subscales ranged between 0.62 (participation) and 0.84 (building location
and position). The study's survey of correlation coefficients between items and subscales illustrated that
those coefficients varied between 0.24 and 0.68.
© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.04.045
0301-4797/© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
606 H. Meiboudi et al. / Journal of Environmental Management 197 (2017) 605e609
(BREG, 2008). Green Star Education v1 in Australia addresses 9 2.1. Survey questionnaire
criteria: Management, Indoor Environmental Quality, Energy,
Transport, Water, Material, Land Use and Ecology, Emissions and The questionnaire consisted of three main sections; the first
Innovation (GBCA, 2015). CSUS (China Society for Urban Studies) in section covered respondent and personal data such as name,
China addresses 6 criteria: Planning and Sustainable Site, Energy, gender, age and university. Section two is investigated 9 criteria
Material and Water, Indoor Environmental Quality, Management, with related items. The respondents were asked to rate the
Education (CSUS, 2011). appropriateness of the items on a five-point priority scale ranging
Countries considering their own socioeconomic and cultural from 1 (completely inappropriate) to 5 (completely appropriate).
characteristics must be able to adapt these criteria from generalities The third section included the whole list of pooled and grouped
and into their own particular circumstances (Datnow, 2005; Durlak items. Again, the respondents were asked to identify the appro-
and DuPre, 2008). For example, climatic conditions in the Middle priateness score for each item, using the same five-point priority
East, where the temperature difference between day and night is scale previously introduced. At the end of each group of criteria, the
significantly wider, thus requiring a great deal of energy con- respondents were given the chance to add and rate any additional
sumption to make conditions livable, together with the sharp in- items.
crease in the utilization of fossil fuels that greatly contributes to air We administered questionnaire to a group of 1218 graduate
pollution and raises the air temperature, have compelled local students with environmental degrees from Iranian universities. Of
people to find a solution to this grave problem (Mahdavinejad et al., 32 universities in Iran with programs in environmental studies,
2014). Therefore, it is necessary to establish sustainability criteria of graduate students from 27 universities completed the question-
administrative green schools based on socioeconomic and cultural naire and submitted their responses within the time allotted. This
background. population size was chosen for the adequacy and appropriateness
The need for comprehensive sustainability criteria becomes of the item analysis and exploratory factor analysis.
evident when important public policy-making is decentralized to
communities. The aggregation of data from lower levels could lead
to a loss of accuracy and robustness in the analysis of particular 2.2. Data acquisition
situations. As reported by Meiboudi et al. (2016), on a national
scale, the problems may be different, requiring tailored tools. Researchers have reported several criteria for the adminis-
Additionally, with more focus on sustainability criteria across the trative of green schools, which, despite their multiplicity,
world, standardized criteria are one of the fundamental charac- convincingly converge in engineering-architectural and behav-
teristics of these features, and include validity, reliability and ioral aspects (Meiboudi et al., 2016). In this research, sustain-
norms. Thus, any rating based on any non-standard methods ability criteria of administrative green schools in Iran was
lacking accuracy and efficiency would not contribute to advancing developed based on 9 criteria, including building location and
the green school concept. position, indoor air criterion, green space, management, energy,
Developing sustainability criteria cannot be a purely scientific or waste management, transportation, education and participation,
technical process; rather, it should be an open communication and adopted from 5 different sustainability criteria for green schools
policy process (Ramos, 2009). Public participation, especially from and their accordance with Iran's conditions. The selected green
universities, is one of the principal components for designing and school criteria are known and represent existing criteria well. In
implementing sustainability criteria sets, as stressed by several this regard, the criteria provided by FEE (FEE, 2016), LEED
authors (e.g. Ioris et al., 2008; Ramos, 2009; Ridsdale and Noble, (USGBC, 2009), BREEAM Education 2008 (BREG, 2008), Green
2016) The importance of participatory design becomes more Star Education v1 (GBCA, 2015) and CSUS (CSUS, 2011) were
obvious on a national and regional scale, where the distances be- used.
tween experts, specialists and decision-makers overall are smaller An initial pool of items was generated and 71 items were
and the interaction can be comprehensive and more effective. selected with each item linked to one of the 9 above-mentioned
Academia has the expertise necessary to develop the intellectual criteria. At first, with the aid of 9 professionals in the green
and conceptual framework to achieve a sustainable development school scope via unstructured interviews, the initial refining took
goal. Universities must play a significant role in the education, place among the items selected. A professional is usually defined as
research, policy formulation, information exchange and commu- someone who has experience or skill in a particular job or activity
nity outreach required to create sustainability criteria on a national in administrative green schools. The outcome of this process led to
scale. removing 8 items in the questionnaire and reaching a total of 63
As discussed, this study focuses on developing sustainability items. From these items, the preliminary version of the sustain-
criteria for the green school in Iran from 2 perspectives: (i) devel- ability criteria on a national scale was built.
oping sustainability criteria for administrative green schools in Iran After the questionnaire was developed, the pilot study needed
based on role of academia; and (ii) assessing the adequacy of the to be conducted before the main survey. The aim of the pilot
items for assessing and achieving the exploratory factor structure study was to find out whether these questions were clear, how
embedded in the criteria. long it took for the participants to finish, whether they answered
in a proper way, etc. It helped to identify some problems and
2. Research methodology polish the final questionnaire. The pilot study to assess the ad-
equacy and suitability of the criteria's items were assigned to 50
The present study's goal is research and development, in both graduate students with environmental degrees, who were asked
technique and data gathering for a descriptive survey. The research their opinions about the articulacy and directness of the
methodology was premised on the multitude of items that a green expression of these items among the criteria. During this stage,
school must accomplish to help participants meet the criteria the statement of changes saw several items added and syntax
(Dautremont-Smith, 2012). With this understanding, question- stabilized. After this stage, it was necessary to implement the
naires were formulated, pilot tested, and administered. The criteria in large population groups to enable analysis and to
framework of methodology is organized into 4 sections as dis- evaluate the engineering-architectural and behavioral aspects of
cussed below. this sustainability criteria.
H. Meiboudi et al. / Journal of Environmental Management 197 (2017) 605e609 607
2.3. Data import of whether all parts of the questions had received responses. If it
appeared that random response patterns had been used, the
The data collected from the questionnaires was entered into v. transpose method was employed. Subsequently, the data of 31 re-
18 of the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) (SPSS Inc, spondents were excluded and sample size was reduced to 1187
2009). It should be noted that in the process of creating and people.
analyzing the data, a matrix of polychoric data were used in v. 8.5
Linear Structural Relations (LISREL) (Jo€ reskog, 1997). Step 6: Frequency analysis provided answers to questions.
Table 1
Components and total square of the loading obtained from the components analysis for green schools' sustainability criteria.
Factor Equity Variance explanation (%) Cumulative variance explanation (%) Eigenvalue
Table 2
Descriptive findings items and coefficients internal consistency subscales criteria for administrative green schools.
Criteria Number Mean Standard Factor Alpha coefficient Correlation of items Alpha coefficient
of item deviation loading after removing with the score subscale
the survey kept the squared multiple correlation coefficients of the 7503 degrees of freedom. Therefore, at the level of 0.0001, our re-
items. Additionally, because all coefficients were lower than 0.80, sults were statistically significant. Consequently, in total, after as-
this showed that there was no problem in multicollinearity and sumptions of factor analysis were identified, this analysis was
singularity in the data, either. successfully performed on the data.
Furthermore, the index of the Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin measure of Performing exploratory factor analysis on the correlation matrix
sampling adequacy (Kaiser, 1974) was equal to 0.91; the index of polychoric outcome of the data from the sample group while using
Bartlett's Test of Sphericity (Kaiser, 1974) equaled 37620.72 with possible factor finding method, various spins, various restrictions
H. Meiboudi et al. / Journal of Environmental Management 197 (2017) 605e609 609
on the number of factors and the amount of variable loading, sustainability, utilizing 63 items, including building location and
showed that the principal component factor finding method, pro- position, indoor air criterion, green space, management, energy,
max iterations with Kaiser normalization, determined the number waste management, transportation, education and participation.
of factors to be 9 and the minimum amount of loading in each item The significance of Bartlett's sphericity test demonstrated that the
on the factors to be 0.30. This analysis extracted factors with the matrix items located in the system are strong ties and suitable,
highest concordance with theoretical structure of the green which can lead to the extraction of components of the data matrix.
schools' sustainability criteria.
The results of factor analysis showed that the structure of the 9 Appendix A. Supplementary data
criteria, with equity of greater than one in totality explained 31% of
the variance scale total, and is the most appropriate and the Supplementary data related to this article can be found at http://
simplest structure for these data. Table 1 provides the resulting dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.04.045.
equity, variance explanation, cumulative variance explanation and
eigenvalues for factors. Note that this pattern was obtained after 16
References
rotations. To finalize a number of factors, we used a scree plot
(Cattell, 1978), and the amount of equity next extracted factors British Research Establishment Global (BREG), 2008. BRE Environmental and Sus-
available in this analysis. tainability Standard: BREEAM Education 2008 Assessors Manual. BREEAM, UK,
The survey questionnaire component analysis for the adminis- London.
Cattell, R.B., 1978. The Scientific Use of Factor Analysis. Plenum Press, New York.
trative green schools showed 9 criteria related to the use Chan, T.C., Mense, E.G., Lane, K.E., Richardson, M.D., 2015. Marketing the Green
engineering-architectural aspects: building location and position (7 School: Form, Function, and the Future. IGI Global, Hershey, PA. http://
items), indoor air criterion (2 items), green space (4 items) and dx.doi.org/10.4018/978-1-4666-6312-1.
Cincera, J., Krajhanzl, J., 2013. Eco-Schools: what factors influence pupils' action
behavioral aspects: management (10 items), energy (8 items), competence for pro-environmental behavior? J. Clean. Prod. 61, 117e121. http://
waste management (5 items), transportation (7 items), education dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.06.030.
(18 items) and participation (2 items). The items related to each China Society for Urban Studies (CSUS), 2011. In: Green Building. China Architecture
and Building Press, Beijing.
criterion are presented in the appendix at the end of this article.
Datnow, A., 2005. The sustainability of comprehensive school reform models in
Table 2 shows that all subscales meet the appropriate co- changing district and state contexts. Educ. Adm. Quart. 41, 121e153. http://
efficients' internal consistency and range between 0.62 (participa- dx.doi.org/10.1177/0013161X04269578.
tion) and 0.84 (building location and position). In addition, the Dautremont-Smith, J., 2012. School Sustainability Rating Systems: Strengths, Lim-
itations, and Future Prospects. University of Michigan. M.S. dissertation. http://
survey of correlation analysis between items and the subscales hdl.handle.net/2027.42/90923 (Accessed 18 December 2015).
show that the coefficients are valued between 0.24 (item 41) and Durlak, J.A., DuPre, E., 2008. Implementation matters: a review of research on the
0.68 (item 28). On the other hand, the alpha coefficient has been influence of implementation on program outcomes and the factors affecting
implementation. Am. J. Commun. Psychol. 41, 327e350. http://dx.doi.org/
removed for any item compared to other items in the subscales 10.1007/s10464-008-9165-0.
which do not show a significant difference. Foundation for Environmental Education (FEE), 2016. International Eco-schools
Programme. http://www.eco-schools.org/page.php?id¼52 (Accessed 18
December 2015).
4. Conclusions Green Building Council of Australia (GBCA), 2015. Green Schools. http://www.gbca.
org.au/uploads/Green%20Schools_Lowres.pdf (Accessed 18 December 2015).
Sustainability criteria of administrative green schools need Henderson, K., Tilbury, D., 2004. Whole-school Approaches to Sustainability: an
International Review of Whole-school Sustainability Programs. Australian
validity, reliability and norms; on the other hand, much criticism Government, Canberra.
has been levied against standardized criteria and their re- Howell, D.C., 2007. Statistical Methods for Psychology, sixth ed. Duxbury Press,
quirements for not addressing national issues and goals. To achieve Belmont, California.
Ioris, A.A., Hunter, C., Walker, S., 2008. The development and application of water
this objective, reasonable and fair comprehensive sustainability
management sustainability indicators in Brazil and Scotland. J. Environ. Manag.
criteria of administrative green schools should be established. The 88, 1190e1201. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2007.06.007.
sustainability criteria would be selected based on their utility for €reskog, K.G., 1997. LISREL 8: User's Reference Guide. SSI. Software International,
Jo
enabling meaningful benchmarking between schools. Chicago.
Kaiser, H.F., 1974. An index of factorial simplicity. Psychometrika 39, 31e36. http://
The graduate students who participated in our study are dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02291575.
beginning to realize that in many sustainable initiatives, it can play Mahdavinejad, M., Zia, A., Larki, A.N., Ghanavati, S., Elmi, N., 2014. Dilemma of green
an important role, giving credibility and scientific and technical and pseudo green architecture based on LEED norms in case of developing
countries. Int. J. Sustain. Built Environ. 3, 235e246. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
support. It can also contribute to increasing public participation, j.ijsbe.2014.06.003.
helping to generate consensus and commitment from the sus- Meiboudi, H., Lahijanian, A., Shobeiri, S.M., Jozi, S.A., Azizinezhad, R., 2016. Creating
tainability involved. an integrative assessment system for green schools in Iran. J. Clean. Prod. 119,
236e246. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.02.004.
Development and validation of sustainability criteria for green Mogensen, F.R., Mayer, M. (Eds.), 2005. ECO-schools: Trends and Divergences: a
school may help remedy their weaknesses by increasing capacity Comparative Study on ECO-school Development Processes in 13 Countries.
for managing effective criteria, improving brand recognition, Austrian Federal Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Vienna.
Ramos, T.B., 2009. Development of regional sustainability indicators and the role of
facilitating benchmarking, and reducing duplication of effort
academia in this process: the Portuguese practice. J. Clean. Prod. 17, 1101e1115.
within the green school community. This article develops and http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2009.02.024.
validates sustainability criteria of administrative green schools in Ridsdale, D.R., Noble, B.F., 2016. Assessing sustainable remediation frameworks
using sustainability principles. J. Environ. Manag. 184, 36e44. http://dx.doi.org/
Iran based on role of academia, which will lead the whole society to
10.1016/j.jenvman.2016.09.015.
a deeper understanding of green schools, and will promote the SPSS Inc, 2009. SPSS Statistical Algorithms. SPSS Inc., Chicago.
development and construction of green schools on a wider scale. Tabachnick, B.G., Fidell, L.S., 2007. Using Multivariate Statistics, sixth ed. Pearson
This sustainability criteria, adapted in Iran, encourages an in- PLC, London.
U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC), 2009. LEED 2009 for Schools New Construc-
tegrated design approach, with a national survey for engineering- tion and Major Renovations Rating System. Washington, DC. http://www.usgbc.
architectural aspects and behavioral aspects deemed to improve org/Docs/Archive/General/Docs5547.pdf (Accessed 18 December 2015).