Professional Documents
Culture Documents
H2 Refuling Assement of Composite Storage Tank For Fuel Cell Vehicle
H2 Refuling Assement of Composite Storage Tank For Fuel Cell Vehicle
ScienceDirect
Shitanshu Sapre a, Kapil Pareek a,*, Rupesh Rohan b, Pawan Kumar Singh c
a
Centre for Energy and Environment, Malaviya National Institute of Technology, Jaipur, Rajasthan, 302017, India
b
Indian Rubber Manufacturers Research Association, Thane, Maharashtra, 400604, India
c
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Dhanbad, Jharkhand 826004, India
highlights
Article history: Hydrogen as compressed gas is a promising option for zero-emission fuel cell vehicle. The
Received 4 April 2019 fast and efficient refueling of high pressure hydrogen can provide a convenient platform
Received in revised form for fuel cell vehicles to compete with conventional gasoline vehicles. This paper reports the
12 June 2019 finding of adiabatic simulation of the refueling process for Type IV tank at nominal working
Accepted 8 July 2019 pressure of 70 MPa with considering the station refueling conditions. The overall heat
Available online 7 August 2019 transfer involved in refueling process was investigated by heat capacity model based on
MC method defined by SAE J2601. The simulation results are validated against experi-
Keywords: mental data of European Commission’s Gas Tank Testing Facility at Joint Research Centre
Hydrogen storage (GasTef JRC), Netherlands. The results confirmed that end temperature and state of charge
Hydrogen refueling significantly depends on refueling parameters mainly supply hydrogen temperature and
Type IV tank filling rate.
Fuel cell vehicle © 2019 Hydrogen Energy Publications LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
* Correponding author.
E-mail address: kapil.cee@mnit.ac.in (K. Pareek).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2019.07.044
0360-3199/© 2019 Hydrogen Energy Publications LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
23700 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 4 ( 2 0 1 9 ) 2 3 6 9 9 e2 3 7 0 7
walls. The effect of buoyancy was considered negligible during The required parameter for the development of heat ca-
the filling. The H2 supply temperature from the station pacity model and estimation of final temperature from station
reservoir to vehicle tank is based on the SAE J2601 protocol and vehicle are tabulated in Table 2. Based on the station and
[23]. The simulation was conducted for transient filling con- vehicle refueling parameter, total heat transfers, internal en-
ditions using density based solver of commercially available ergy and amount of hydrogen transported from the refueling
CFD package, ANSYS Fluent 16.0 [24]. station to vehicle tank were calculated.
In this study, we have taken an initial pressure of tank
Heat capacity model (HCM) 2 MPa, and the initial temperature of tank 20 C which is
similar to ambient temperature. We assumed that the vehicle
For prediction of end temperature of the compressed gas in- is in a hot soak condition where the environment is hotter
side the tank, various studies on the behavior of gas have been than ambient. The hot soak margin of safety to overheat has
conducted [25e27]. By considering actual thermodynamics taken to be þ7.5 C [27]. So the initial temperature (Tinitial ) is the
conditions at the station and vehicle tank, accurate tank filling sum of ambient (Tambient ) and hot soak temperature ðDThot Þ as
results can be achieved. For this, Honda R&D Inc. has devel- given by Equation (1).
oped the new refueling method applicable to both communi-
cation and non-communication filling stations called MC Tinitial ¼ Tambient þ DThot (1)
method. Where MC stands for mathematical construct or total Before delivering the hydrogen, the station needs initial
heat capacity of the system which includes combined specific information about the vehicle tank based on initial tempera-
heat and mass capacity of the tank [27,28]. Fig. 2 represents a ture and pressure. The initial mass (minitial Þ, density ðrinitial Þ and
schematic of a H2 tank with terminology involves in the internal energy (uinital Þ of tank is given by the Equations (2)e(5).
development of the total heat capacity model. The heat ca-
pacity of the tank is a function of energy delivered to the tank minitial ¼ Vvt rinitial ðTinitial ; PSinitial Þ (2)
in the form of heat and heat transfer from the tank walls. The
heat capacity will be the deciding factor for the storage density mCV ¼ Vvt rtarget (3)
of compressed H2 tank. Therefore, heat capacity is defined in
terms of initial temperature, pressure, and volume of station madd ¼ mcv minital (4)
and vehicle tank [29].
Fig. 2 e Schematic representation of the H2 tank during refueling (a) energy transferred in control volume (b) temperature
distribution on a section of wall.
23702 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 4 ( 2 0 1 9 ) 2 3 6 9 9 e2 3 7 0 7
2 3
PstationFinal PstationInit
h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ
16 4 7
h¼ 6 7þ
44 2 5
2 3
PstationFinal PstationInit PstationFinal PstationInit
h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ þ h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ 2
6 4 4 7
6 7þ
4 2 5
2 3 (6)
PstationFinal PstationInit PstationFinal PstationInit
h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ þ h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ 3
6 4 4 7
6 7þ
4 2 5
2 3
PstationFinal PstationInit PstationFinal PstationInit
h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ 3 þ h Tprecooling ; PStationInit þ 4
6 4 4 7
6 7
4 2 5
Based on average enthalpy delivered (h) to tank, adiabatic perature rise before 50 s followed by a knee point were
internal energy (Uadaibatic Þ , and adiabatic temperature (Tadiabatic Þ observed in all four H2 supply temperature. The sharp tem-
can be obtained for the adiabatic filling condition where no perature rise occurs mainly due to the real behavior of com-
heat is transferred from the system. The combined mass and pressed H2 as it suddenly expands from the injector, in
specific heat capacity of characteristic volume (kJ/K) are addition to negative Joule Thomason Coefficient of H2. Beyond
calculated using the Equation (7) which represents the total the knee point, the temperature rise is moderate. The tem-
heat absorbed by the wall. perature of gas is inversely proportional to mass content in-
side the tank. Therefore, in the later stage of filling, the
Uadaibatic j
MC ¼ C þ A þ g 1 ekDt (7) compressed mass of gas increases and temperature rise rate
Uinitial
decreases, which is similar to the observation reported by
The empirical coefficients (C, A, g, e, k, j) used in Equa- Melideo et al. [16].
tion (7) for calculation of MC are obtained from the confir- It is also observed that the temperature rise is directly
mation test performed on Type IV tank for fill time longer proportional to the filing rates. The slow filling rates result less
3 min [31]. Finally, the end temperature (Tend ) of the gas is irreversibility and low entropy generation than higher filling
determined using tank parameters initial temperature, rates. Hence, at higher filling rates temperature attained at the
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 4 ( 2 0 1 9 ) 2 3 6 9 9 e2 3 7 0 7 23703
Fig. 3 e Temperature evolution inside the tank at different H2 supply temperatures of a) ¡40 C, b) ¡20 C, c) 0 C and d)
15 C.
rðP; TÞ
SOC ¼ (9)
rð70MPa; 15 CÞ
Fig. 5 e End temperature using heat capacity model (MC) at different supply temperature and filling rate (a) ¡40 C (b) ¡20 C
(c) 0 C and (d) 15 C.
Heat capacity model results heat during refueling. The experimental studies by Liu et al.
have also observed the fact that the heat transfer takes more
The energy transfers to vehicle tank from refueling station are time than the heat generation at higher filling rates [30].
in the form of average enthalpy supplied to the vehicle tank. Similarly, at low supply temperature less amount of heat is
Fig. 5 represents the end temperature as a function of different transferred to the vehicle tank which restricts the end tem-
H2 supply temperature and filling rates. The higher end tem- perature to prescribe limit of 85 C.
perature is obtained with higher filling rates due to the fact Around 1.3e2.4 C decrease in temperature is observed at
that compressed gas has lesser time to transfer the generated different filling rates and supply temperature compared to
Fig. 6 e SOC achieved using heat capacity model of Type IV Fig. 7 e Maximum temperature inside the tank at filling
tank at different H2 supply temperature and filling rates. rate of 10 g/s and different supply temperature.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 4 ( 2 0 1 9 ) 2 3 6 9 9 e2 3 7 0 7 23705
Fig. 8 e Comparison of state of charge obtained by simulation, heat capacity model and experimental (JRC) at different H2
supply temperature of (a) 0 C (b)15 C (c) ¡20 C and (d) ¡40 C.
adiabatic simulation. However, at higher filling rates and system. For a shorter filling time, fast filling rates accumulate
ambient H2 supply temperature, end temperature still a large amount of heat inside the tank. In both circumstances,
exceeding the limiting value of 85 C. the end temperature of refueling increases and eventually
Fig. 6 represents the influence of filling rates and supply lowers the SOC.
temperature on the SOC using the heat capacity model. The The HCM considered overall heat transfer through the
heat transfer from the characteristic volume of tank lowers walls of tanks or heat absorbed by the tank walls, which lead
the end temperature inside the tank which improves the state to higher SOC of the tank than SOC obtained from simulation
of charge. data. On the other hand, in JRC experimental studies, due to
transient heat transfer during filling, the estimated SOC is the
Comparison with experimental results highest. As per SAE J2601, SOC of 90% and above are in
acceptable range. The simulation results for H2 supply tem-
The end temperature reached its peak value at filling rate of perature of 40 C and 20 C are in the desired range of
10 g/s. Fig. 7 shows the comparison of maximum temperature more than 90% SOC (Fig. 8c and d). While the SOC drops to
attained at the end of refueling for simulation, HCM and JRC less than 90% for most of the times for H2 supply temperature
experimental data for different supply temperature. It can be of 15 C and very close to the desired range for 0 C at higher
noted that the end temperatures of JRC experimental data are flow rates.
the lowest for all four H2 supply temperatures. Due to overall In order to, better evaluate the accuracy of simulation and
heat transfer consideration in HCM, the end temperatures are heat capacity model standard error and root mean square
falls in the middle of JRC and simulation data. The simulation error (RMSE) are computed. The smaller the standard error is
data due to adiabatic filling are the highest for all for H2 supply better the model performs. The standard error (x, y) in terms
temperature. of percentage is presented in Fig. 8 which shows that
Fig. 8 shows SOC of the tank and calculated errors in SOC maximum error lies between 1 and 2% in simulation and it is
estimation. The SOC has shown a strong dependency on end reduced to less than 1% in heat capacity model which can
temperature of filling, supply temperature and filling rates. generally satisfy the precision requirement in engineering
The major contributor in lowering of SOC in the simulation are calculations [31]. The initial and boundary conditions applied
adiabatic conditions and target of short filling time. The in numerical computation are also partially responsible for
adiabatic conditions do not permit any heat transfer from the such a small deviation in results.
23706 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 4 ( 2 0 1 9 ) 2 3 6 9 9 e2 3 7 0 7
For more sensible comparisons among the results, RMSE is Jaipur for providing the facilities for execution of simulation
calculated. The RMSE of simulation found to be in range of studies.
0.857e1.3153 for different supply temperature which is
further reduced to less than 1% by implementing heat capcity
model for all supply temperature. However, critical thermo- Appendix A. Supplementary data
dynamics behavior of H2 during filling is responsible for the
low state of charge. The heat capacity model improves the Supplementary data to this article can be found online at
level of estimation of the state of charge and provides good https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2019.07.044.
agreement with the experimental results.
references
Conclusions
[1] Staffell I, Scamman D, Abad AV, Balcombe P, Dodds PE,
A Type IV tank of 29L at operating pressure of 70 MPa and
Ekins P, Shah N, Ward KR. The role of hydrogen and fuel cells
filling time of 200 s has been investigated for adiabatic filling at
in the global energy system. Energy Environ Sci
different flow rates. Furthermore, heat capacity model based 2019;12:463e91.
on MC method of SAE J2601 is utilized. The results of simu- [2] Pareek K, Rohan R, Chen Z, Zhao D, Cheng H. Ambient
lation and analytical heat capacity model are compared with temperature hydrogen storage in porous materials with
the experimental results of GasTef at JRC. exposed metal sites. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2017;42:6801e9.
Results obtained by refueling simulations show that the [3] Pareek K, Zheng Q, Rohan R, Xu G, Cheng H. Room
temperature hydrogen physisorption on exposed metals in A
temperature inside the tank gets affected by the boundary
highly cross-linked organo-iron complex. Adv Mater Interfac
conditions such as filling rates and supply temperature. The 2014;1. 14000107.
maximum temperature in adiabatic simulation experienced [4] Sacramento EM, Carvalho PCM, de Lima LC, Veziroglu TN.
in H2 supply temperature of 15 C at all filling rates which Feasibility study for the transition towards a hydrogen
exceeds the limit of safety of 85 C. Although, the end tem- economy: a case study in Brazil. Energy Policy 2013;62:3e9.
perature of filling significantly lowers by precooled supply [5] Schur DV, Savenko AF, Bogolepov VA, Zginaicheko AY,
temperature. The higher end temperature also affects the Matysina ZA, Magrez A, Baibarac M, Veziroglu TN. Hydrogen
accumulators for various purposes: NATO science for peace
storage density attained at end filling. From this, it may also be
and security series C: environmental security. Dordrecht:
concluded that Type IV tank needs precooled H2 supply for Springer; 2013.
higher storage density for automotive applications. [6] Hua TQ, Ahuwalia R, Peng JK, Kromer M, Lasher S,
The thermodynamic involved in the refueling process was McKenney Law K, Sinha J. Technical assessment of
investigated by heat capacity model based on the MC method. compressed hydrogen storage tank systems for automotive
The results obtained after considering the in and outflow of applications. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2011;36:3037e49.
[7] Preek K, Zhang Q, Rohan R, Yunfenga Z, Cheng Z. Hydrogen
heat through the tank leads to lower the final temperature by
physisorption in ionic solid compounds with exposed metal
1.3e2.4 C at different filling rates. By this maximum tem-
cations at room temperature. The Royal Society of Chemistry
perature stay within limits defined by international standards 2014;04:33905e10.
and SOC has also improved. The outcomes have been [8] Singh A, Prakash MM, Murthy SS. Performance of a solid
compared to experimental results of GasTef at JRC which state hydrogen storage device with finned tube heat
shows satisfactory agreement. The difference in simulation exchanger. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2017;42:26855e71.
and experimental results may be due to the selection of [9] Hydrogen staorage technologies road map. In: DOE, editor.
U.S. DRIVE (driving research and innovation for vehicle
boundary conditions, physical models and real behavior of H2.
efficiency and energy sustainability); 2017.
Finally, the simulation approach proved to be suitable for [10] Heitsch M, Baraldi D, Moretto P. Numerical investigations on
predicting the refueling parameters of compressed H2 system. the fast filling of hydrogen tanks. Int J Hydrogen Energy
The deviation in results can be overcome by transient heat 2011;36:2606e12.
transfer during the refueling process which provides good [11] Miguel N de, Acosta B, Baraldi D, Cebolla OR, Moretto P. The
insight of heat losses during the refueling. The transient filling role of initial tank temperature on refuelling of on-board
based vehicle tank parameters during refueling will provide hydrogen tanks. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2016;41:8606e15.
[12] Yang JC. A thermodynamic analysis of refueling of a
better understanding of end temperature of refueling as well
hydrogen tank. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2009;34:6712e21.
as exact estimation of storage density of storage system. [13] Hosseini M, Dincer I, Naterer GF, Rosen MA. Thermodynamic
analysis of filling compressed gaseous hydrogen storage
tanks. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012;37:5063e71.
[14] Ortiz Cebolla R, Acosta B, Moretto P, Frischauf N,
Acknowledgment Harskamp F, Bonato C, Baraldi D. Hydrogen tank first filling
experiments at the JRC-IET GasTeF facility. Int J Hydrogen
The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of Early Energy 2014;39:6261e7.
Carrier Research grant (ECR/2016/1001039) form SERB, [15] Ortiz Cebolla R, Acosta B, de Miguel N, Moretto P. Effect of
Department of Science and Technology, Government of India precooled inlet gas temperature and mass flow rate on final
The authors also acknowledge the Centre for Energy and state of charge during hydrogen vehicle refueling. Int J
Hydrogen Energy 2015;40:4698e706.
Environment, Malaviya National Institute of Technology,
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 4 ( 2 0 1 9 ) 2 3 6 9 9 e2 3 7 0 7 23707
[16] Melideo D, Baraldi D, Iboraa AB, Cebolla OR, Moretto P. CFD [24] ANSYS fluent user guide 16.0; 2016. AI.
simulations of filling and emptying of hydrogen tanks. Int J [25] Bourgeois T, Ammouri F, Weber M, Knapik C. Evaluating the
Hydrogen Energy 2017;42:7304e13. temperature inside a tank during a filling with highly-
[17] Galassi MC, Papanikolaou E, Hietsch M, Baraldi D, Iborra AB, pressurized gas. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2015;40:11748e55.
Moretto P. Assessment of CFD models for hydrogen fast nard P, Chahine R. Estimation of final hydrogen
[26] Xiao J, Be
filling simulations. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2014;39:6252e60. temperature from refueling parameters. Int J Hydrogen
[18] Melideo D, Baraldi D, Galassi MC, Ortiz Cebolla R, Acosta Energy 2017;42:7521e8.
Iborra B, Moretto P. CFD model performance benchmark of [27] Harty R, Mathison S, Gupta N. Improving the hydrogen tank
fast filling simulations of hydrogen tanks with pre-cooling. refueling perfomance through the use of an advance fueling
Int J Hydrogen Energy 2014;39:4389e95. algorithims-The MC method naional hydrogen association
[19] Acosta B, Moretto P, de Miguel N, Ortiz R, Harskamp F, conference long beach, California. 2010. p. 1e34.
Bonato C. JRC reference data from experiments of on-board [28] Handa K, Mathison S. Developement of new hydrogen
hydrogen tanks fast filling. Int J Hydrogen Energy refueling method for FCV to reduce refueling time honda
2014;39:20531e7. R&D technical review. Honda R&D Inc.; 2015. p. 43e9.
[20] Bai-gang S, Dong-sheng Z, Fu-shui L. A new equation of state [29] Mathison S, Handa K, McGuire T, Brown T, Goldstein T,
for hydrogen gas. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012;37:932e5. Johnston M. Field validation of the MC default fill hydrogen
[21] Suryan A, Kim HD, Setoguchi T. Comparative study of fueling protocol. SAE International Journal 2015;01:131e44.
turbulence models performance for refueling of compressed [30] Liu YL, Zhao YZ, Zhao L, Li X, Chen HG, Zhang L-F, et al.
hydrogen tanks. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2013;38:9562e9. Experimental studies on temperature rise within a hydrogen
[22] Zhao Y, Liu G, Liu Y, Zheng J, Chen Y, Zhao L, et al. Numerical cylinder during refueling. Int J Hydrogen Energy
study on fast filling of 70 MPa type III cylinder for hydrogen 2010;35:2627e32.
vehicle. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012;37:17517e22. [31] Zhang IL, Peng H, Ning Z, Zhongqiang Mu Z, Sun C.
[23] Reddi K, Elgowainy A, rustagi N, Gupta R. Impact of hydrogen Comparative research on RC equivalent circuit models for
SAE J2601 fueling methods on fueling time of light-duty fuel lithium-ion batteries of electric vehicles. Appl Sci
cell electric vehicles. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2017;7:1e16.
2017;42:16675e85.