Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Using Pomelo (Citrus Maxima) Skin As Alternative Material To Manufacturing Commercial Packing Peanuts
Using Pomelo (Citrus Maxima) Skin As Alternative Material To Manufacturing Commercial Packing Peanuts
July 2021
Mindanao State University
College of Education Training Department
JP Laurel St., General Santos City
APPROVAL SHEET
The Research entitled “Use of Pomelo (Citrus maxima) Peels as an Alternative Material for
Loose-Fill Packaging” prepared and submitted by IAN JOHN C. AROBO, MALIK NOR H.
BUBONGA, and SHAN ANDRIE T. BISNAR in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the
subject, Research 10, has been examined and is recommended for acceptance and approval.
Examination Committee.
_ July 1, 2021__
Date of Submission
Ms. ESMAIDA H. ANDANG, MAED
Directress
ii
Abstract
since a lot of people use packing peanuts to prevent damages on products. This study
focused on the creation and comparison of the commercially sold Polystyrene Packaging
against the Pomelo (Citrus Maxima) Packaging. The pomelo was boiled to soften and mixed
with pure glycerin and additional mixtures and then left to dry. The experimentation had four
tests: flammability, cushion tests 1 & 2, and water solubility. Independent t-test was used to
compare the means. To conclude, we found out that S2 surpassed S1 in terms of flammability
significant difference in the means of the two samples in terms of cushion test 2. To further
improve the study, we recommend conducting the research at a proper facility with proper
equipment and possibly use pomelo with glycerin to create biodegradable materials.
iii
Acknowledgement
First and foremost, we would like to give our praises and thanks to our God Almighty
for the blessings He has given and showered us which guided us to proceed further through our
We want to give our deepest thanks to our research supervisor, Mrs. Ammabel Oclarit
Alza, MA, for giving us tips and examples and for providing guidance throughout the research.
Also, we would also like to thank Kenneth Ian B. Galagaran and our other schoolmates for
We are extremely grateful for our parents for buying the materials for our research and
for the sacrifices and support they gave amidst this pandemic throughout the school year. Thank
you for being with us for sending your supports and prayers to be able to complete this research.
iv
Table of Contents
Approval Sheet ii
Abstract iii
Acknowledgement iv
Table of Contents v
List of Tables ix
List of Graphs x
CHAPTER 1
1. Introduction 1
1.2 Hypothesis 4
1.5Definition of Terms 6
CHAPTER 2
2.1 Pomelo 7
2.5 Starch 10
v
2.6 Wheat 11
2.10 Sulfur 15
2.13 Biodegradability 17
CHAPTER 3
3. Methodology 19
3.4 Samples 19
3.6 Flowchart 21
3.7 Tests 21
CHAPTER 4
4.1 Introduction 23
vi
CHAPTER 5
5.2 Conclusions 33
5.3 Recommendations 34
REFERENCES 35
APPENDICES 38
APPENDIX A 39
Rind Preparation 39
APPENDIX B 40
Mixture Preparation 40
APPENDIX C 42
APPENDIX D 44
vii
List of Figures
Page Number
viii
List of Tables
Page Number
ix
List of Graphs
Page Number
x
Chapter 1
Introduction
The pomelo or pummelo (citrus maxima) is the largest citrus fruit from the Rutacae
family and the principal ancestor of the grapefruit. It is recognized by its thick rind with dense,
spongy pith beneath. Pomelo rinds are usually high in moisture content (75-80%) and water
activity (0.90-0.98). People usually discard peels because of its bitter taste. Because of this, we
came up with an idea to make pomelo peels useful instead of being trash as well as dealing
with excessive use of plastic. By making pomelo rind as an alternative to loose-fill packaging,
we can minimize the use of plastic. When buying appliances, plastic is used to cover the
appliances to prevent it from being getting damaged. Most people discard the plastic by burning
or throwing it anywhere which is harmful to the environment. Since pomelo rind is dense and
thick, it can be used as a substitute to plastic loose-fill packaging and it is eco-friendly so you
The Pomelo has thick, rigid, and firm peel. Pomelo peel possesses excellent damping
behaviour preventing its fruit pulp from damage when the fruit is dropping from its tree with a
typical height of 3-5 meters. The thick skin of the ripe fruit should be dull and pale green to
yellow in colour. Vitamin C is present in pomelo peel which stimulates collagen production,
and thus maintains and improves skin elasticity, and lessens hyperpigmentation or darkening
Eating dried pomelo peels provide health benefits including preventing urinary tract
infection, strengthening gums, effective in treating diarrhea, helps fight off free radicals,
produces collagen that ensures firm, bright and younger skin, helps treat cough and cold, helps
slow down aging process and helps keep the body energized. The peel can be used by decoction
or extracting the essence of pomelo peels by boiling. It is used for treating chorea, epilepsy, as
well as convulsive coughing. The boiled pomelo peel also cures frost bites and gas pains.
Pomelo peels also works effectively as sedative in nervous affection, vomiting, griping
soothing and toning. Despite all the above there are some precautions that must be observed.
Pomelo is rich in potassium and Vitamin C which is harmful for the patients with kidney and
liver problems. The hypotension patients should avoid it because pomelos reduce the blood
pressure considerably. Limit the intake of pomelos because excessive consumption could result
to various health problems. People allergic to citrus fruits should avoid it. Consult the health
practitioner for using it to treat health problems. If consumed excessively it results constipation
and formation of kidney stones. Pomelo peels were usually thrown to bins as wastes after the
pomelo fruits are peeled and eaten. We aim to use pomelo peel to maximize the use of it by
making pomelo peel as an alternative loose-fill packaging. Which results to less use of plastic
to make plastic loose-fill packaging to protect newly bought appliances. (Susin Lim, 2020)
The reason why we see so much trash lying around is because too much material is
being thrown away – either food or wasted objects. People buy packaged furniture and that
After it has been thrown, the contents of the trash are thrown into sea or any body of
water near a wasteland and there isn’t just one person buying a single object or more, there are
millions per day. Millions of tons of garbage will probably fall into water or buried in land and
One helping solution for earth to stop accumulating waste is to make use of the wastes
we throw away. On average, about 2, 175 tons of food scraps end up in the trash everyday just
in Manila. 1/3 of the food produced globally never reaches our tables. If we put our mind into
2
this, what could end up in the trash could be useful just like our research the pomelo peel.
It is unknown how long it will take for polystyrene, an ingredient of packing peanuts,
to biodegrade. Some experts estimate its decomposition to take around 500 years or more.
Styrofoam is one of the most environmentally unfriendly and unforgiving types of waste that
is being made today. We know that plastics are made in order to replace and reduce the use of
wood on other materials but it is being made too much. Animals roaming in the wild run around
and eat what they can find, and there are just not a little but so many groups of them. It could
Styrofoam is a light-weight material, about 95% air with good insulation properties.
Because of the amount of air in its structure, Styrofoam is considered to be not being able to
sink and float in water, and capable of maintaining its form. If it is burned in a normal fire, it
releases pollutants such as carbon black and carbon monoxide which is a very harmful poison
This study aimed to make use of pomelo rind as an alternative loose-fill packaging in
order to replace and compete with the current commercial plastic loose-fill packaging. It aimed
to avoid plastics and their byproducts in littering our cities, oceans, and waterways. This study
1) What is the maximum weight capacity it can hold while providing cushion?
2) Is the loose-fill packaging soluble enough to be thrown into the water without
problem?
3
3) Is there any difference in the flammability of the pomelo packing peanut from the
4) How effective will the pomelo packing peanut be compared to the commercial
packing peanut if they are placed to cushion an egg from a fall from a certain
height?
Hypothesis
There are no significant differences between the pomelo packing peanut and the
a) Cushion
b) Water Solubility
c) Flammability
Students. This can serve as a reference and guide for the students conducting similar
fruit studies.
Professors. This study will help them reference and add idea to their lessons and
tests. It will be easier for them to tackle and bring up related topics about this research,
especially in Botany.
Farmers & Market. This study will help them have more information about the
Businesses. This will help companies that make commercial packaging have an idea
of another packaging that is biodegradable. They may produce more of this since it would be
4
Buyers. The product will provide safety and assurance of the item to the client.
Future Researchers. This research will be useful especially for researchers who plan
The study was only limited to the peeling of the pomelo rinds as an alternative loose
fill packaging and not any other fruit peels. The limitations were working by hand and without
The appropriate time to find ripe pomelos is between April to June, which is the
pomelo’s season where they mostly bloom and have low price. It would take another big
amount of time to conserve the bought pomelos to ensure they work best for our project. It also
would just take a short amount of time to peel the pomelos but a long time for conducting the
The tools needed for this project were source of flame/heat (oven, microwave, stove).
The other materials included were pure glycerin and baking powder. Other sources would be
Procedures involve performing the correct method in order for the laboratory
apparatuses to work according to their use and common techniques like grinding, transferring,
measuring, etc.
5
Definition of Terms
Rind - Rinds occur naturally, growing to cover and protect a fruit or a plant. You can
also call the thick, waxy covering on a wheel of cheese a rind, or the inedible skin on a sausage
or another food. The Old English root rinde originally meant "bark or crust," and later also
Moisture Content - The quantity of water contained in a material, such as soil (called
soil moisture), rock, ceramics, crops, or wood. Water content is used in a wide range of
scientific and technical areas, and is expressed as a ratio, which can range from 0 (completely
dry) to the value of the materials' porosity at saturation. It can be given on a volumetric or
Water Activity - The partial vapor pressure of water in a substance divided by the
standard state partial vapor pressure of water. In the field of food science, the standard state is
most often defined as the partial vapor pressure of pure water at the same temperature.
term most commonly refers to products that contribute to green living or practices that help
conserve resources like water and energy. Eco-friendly products also prevent contributions to
Loose-fill packaging - Loose fill materials are used to fill empty spaces in packages
6
Chapter 2
This chapter introduces and provides the review of related literature convenient and
associated with this study in order to find a solution to the problems and issues that will soon
rise up in the study. This chapter also discusses the different variables which are related and
used in the study. It introduces the framework for the study that consists of the major focus of
Pomelo
Pomelo (Citrus maxima or Citrus grandis) is a large citrus fruit. It is considered as the
most substantial fruit of the Rutacea family and the progenitor of grapefruit. Pomelo has milder,
The origin of the word “pomelo” was taken from the Dutch word pompelmoes, which
is rendered pampelmuse in German, and pamplemousse in French. Its scientific name, Citrus
maxima, means "biggest citrus". In English, the word "pomelo" (also written as pumelo,
The C. maxima tree, which is very sensitive to cold temperature, has a rounded crown
and grows up to 16 to 50 ft tall. The tree has oblong to elliptic leaves that measures10.5 to 20
cm (4 to 8 in) long, with winged petioles (leaf stems). The fruits, which differ from round to
pear-shaped and ripen to red, yellow, and orange and weighing up to 9 kg (20 lbs).
The flesh of the fruit, which varies from yellow, pink, to red. It is often juicy, and
divided into 11 to 18 segments. Like other citrus fruits, pomelos are high in vitamin C. Pomelos
Pomelos have long been popular in Asia, especially China, Indonesia, and Thailand,
Japan, Fiji, but are increasingly found in specialty markets in the United States as well. The
juice of pomelo is also used in various types of beverages (both alcoholic and non), and the
peel may be candied. Traditional medicinal uses of the fruit include treatment of coughs, fevers,
The fragrant flowers are collected and processed into perfume in Vietnam, and the
wood, which is hefty and hard-grained, is used for making tool handles. (Bailey et al. 1976,
Citrus fruit arises through the growth and development of an ovary and consists of 8–
16 carpels clustered around and joined to the fl oral axis, which forms the core of the fruit. The
carpels form locules, or segments, in which seeds and juice sacs (vesicles) grow. The pericarp
(rind or peel) is divided into exocarp, or fl avedo, and mesocarp, or albedo. The fl avedo
consists of the outermost tissue layers, which have cuticle-covered epidermis and parenchyma
cells. The fl avedo is the outer, colored part and the albedo is the inner, colorless (white) or
sometimes tinted part (as in red grapefruit or blood oranges). The fl avedo consists of the
epicarp proper, the hypodermis, the outer mesocarp, and oil glands. Above the epicarp is a
multilayered protective skin or cuticle that is quite complex in origin, structure, and
7
development. The cuticle consists of an inner layer of cutin, which is a heterogeneous polymer
of fatty acids and cellulose, and an outer layer consisting of cutin (Baker et al., 1975).
All surfaces eventually crack and are uplifted to form large, fl at, irregular plates. This
outer surface can be rubbed gently to give shining polish. By restricting water loss through
evaporation, the cuticle plays an essential role in maintaining high water content within tissue
that is necessary for normal metabolism. One estimate claims that cuticle reduces the rate of
evaporation from living plant cells from about 3.6 to 0.14 mg/cm2 /Pa/h.
Water loss varies with the type of fruit or commodity, its anatomy, and surrounding
conditions. This coeffi cient of transpiration (the rate of water loss) is 42 for apple and 7400
for lettuce (Wills et al., 1998). Numerous stomata are scattered over the surface of the
epidermal cell layer over the parenchymatous tissues between the oil glands (Turrell and Klotz,
1940).
The rind of most citrus fruits is generally inedible, largely because of the oil. However,
the rind of kumquats is sweet and can be eaten along with the pulp. Albedo consists of inner
mesocarp, which consists of parenchymatous cells with large air spaces (Scott and Baker,
1947). This is an extremely effective cushioning material against pressure and impact to fruits.
The albedo is 1–2 mm thick in limes and tangerines, 2–5 mm thick in sweet oranges, and up to
20 mm thick in pummelos. Albedo is attached to fl avedo on the outer side and connected with
segment membrane from the inner side. The exocarp, or fl avedo, and white spongy mesocarp,
or albedo, are blended together. The endocarp is the inner side of the pericarp and a portion of
the locular membrane. When the peel/rind is stripped, the entire exocarp and all but the inner
portion of the mesocarp are removed. The segments surrounding the central axis form the
edible pulp of a mature citrus fruit. Each segment is surrounded by a continuous endocarp
membrane.
8
Starch Based Packing Peanuts
environment-friendly alternative. The starch in the peanuts comes from crop-based sources
rather than petroleum-based polystyrene, and is non-toxic. One of the first brands of
biodegradable peanuts, Biofoam, is made from the grain sorghum; other brands are made from
corn starch. Biodegradable foam peanuts have no electrostatic charge, another benefit over
polystyrene. Being biodegradable and nontoxic, they are also safe for humans and pets if
ingested accidentally. However, they are not produced in food-safe conditions, and are not
recommended for eating. Also, during the manufacturing process, the nutritional value is
removed from starch-based packing peanuts. This removes edible components, such as sugars,
that would otherwise attract rodents and bugs. Their main drawbacks compared with
polystyrene are lower resilience, higher weight (6.5 to 13 g per litre/0.4 to 0.8 lb per cubic
foot), dust creation, potential attraction of rodents, and higher price. Starch-based peanuts are
soluble in water, and polystyrene peanuts are soluble in acetone, but not vice versa. Starch
based products can be disposed with down the sink, dissolving on contact with the water.
Polystyrene Peanuts
Foam peanuts, also known as foam popcorn, packing peanuts or packing noodles, are a
common loose-fill packaging and cushioning material used to prevent damage to fragile objects
during shipping. They are shaped to interlock when compressed and free flow when not
compressed. They are roughly the size and shape of an unshelled peanut and commonly made
of expanded polystyrene foam. 50–75 millimetres (2-3 in) of peanuts are typically used for
cushioning and void filling packaging applications. The original patent was filed for by Robert
9
Polystyrene-based packing peanuts were developed and patented by Tektronix Inc. They were
made commercially available circa 1965 by Dow Chemical. Originally made from 100% virgin
polystyrene resin, peanuts made from 100% recycled polystyrene have been commercially
available since the mid-90s. The color and shape sometimes indicate what it is made of and
who made it. Often green is 70% or possibly more recycled polystyrene, white is 70% or more
virgin resin and pink means an antistatic agent has been applied; although there are some
variations. The most common shapes are similar to a "S", "figure 8" or "W". Foam peanuts are
very light (usually around 3 grams per litre/0.17 to 0.2 lb per cu ft) and easy to use.
Polystyrene peanuts may be used and reused many times with little or no loss in protection for
the product shipped. They may be reused and recycled at many packing and shipping stores.
Because of their build-up, polystyrene peanuts may also be used for various methods of home
insulation, although it is not recommended because they are not flame retardant.
Starch
joined together by glycosidic bonds. This polysaccharide is manufactured by most green plants
as energy storage. It is the most common carbohydrate in human diets and is accommodated in
large amounts in staple foods like rice, maize (corn), potatoes, cassava and wheat.
In industry, starch is transformed into sugars, for example by malting, fermenting to make
ethanol in the manufacture of beer, biofuel and whisky. It is processed to put together many of
the sugars used in processed foods. When mixing most starches in warm water, it produces
pastes such as wheatpaste, which can be used as stiffening, thickening or gluing agent.
10
The word "starch" came from its Germanic root with the meaning, " stiff, strong,
strengthen, stiffen". Modern German Stärke (strength) is associated and referring for centuries
main application, the use in textile: sizing yarn for weaving and starching linen. The Greek
term for starch, "amylon" (ἄμυλον), which means "not milled", is also associated.
in Ngalue, Mozambique dating up to 100,000 years ago. Pure drawn out wheat starch paste
was used in Ancient Egypt to glue into papyrus. The Romans utilized it in cosmetic creams, to
powder the hair and to make sauces thicker. The Persians and Indians used starch to make
Most green plants stockpile energy as starch, which is filled up into semicrystalline
granules. The left over glucose is altered into starch which is more complex than glucose (by
plants). Young plants live on this stored energy in their roots, seeds, and fruits until it can
discover suitable soil in which to sprout. Starch is a carbohydrate that contains a great amount
of glucose units, combined through glycosidic links. (M.K. Marichelvam, M. Jawaid, M. Asim
2019).
Wheat
Wheat (Triticum aestivum) is a grass widely grown for its seed, a cereal grain which is a
worldwide staple food. Wheat is grown more on land areas than any other food crop. The
planted wheat in 2014 was estimated to be 220.4 million hectares. The world trade in wheat is
In 2017,the production of wheat was 772 million tonnes from all over the world, with a
forecast of 2019 produced wheat at 766 million tonnes, making the wheat the second most-
produced cereal after corn or maize. Since 1960, production of wheat and other grain crops all
11
over the world has tripled and is expected to develop further through the middle of the 21st
century. Global demand for wheat is increasing due to the unique viscoelastic and adhesive
properties of gluten proteins, which is needed for the production of processed foods.
protein in human food worldwide. When the grain is consumed as a whole, it becomes a source
If consumed too much, gluten activates an immune response that harms the lining of the
small intestine to people with coeliac disease. This can interfere with the absorption of nutrients
from food, cause a host of symptoms, and lead to other problems like osteoporosis, infertility,
nerve damage, and seizures. A related illness called gluten sensitivity or non-celiac gluten
sensitivity can generate symptoms alike to celiac disease but excluding the intestinal damage.
Wheat gluten is used largely as an animal feed, but is a very useful raw material. Not only
is it widely available and relatively inexpensive, bioplastics made from gluten boasts
petrochemicals. Plant proteins from wheat show an advantage for use as films and plastics
because of their plentiful resources, low cost, good biodegradability and satisfactory properties
like rheological properties, water sensitivity, sound absorption and thermal behavior. (N. Patni,
Food Waste
An estimated 43 billion pounds of food were wasted in US retail stores in 2010. 33 This
is particularly disconcerting given that in 2016, 12.3 percent of American households were
food insecure. Most of the loss in retail operations is in perishables, including baked goods,
produce, meat, seafood and prepared meals. The USDA estimates that supermarkets lose $15
12
billion annually in unsold fruit and vegetables alone. Unfortunately, wasteful practices
in the retail industry are often viewed as good business strategies. Some of the main drivers for
food loss at retail stores include: overstocked product displays, expectation of cosmetic
perfection of fruits, vegetables and other foods, oversized packages, the availability of prepared
food until closing, expired “sell by” dates, damaged goods, outdated seasonal items, over
Currently, only 10 percent of edible wasted food is recovered each year, in the US. 38
Barriers to recovering food are liability concerns, distribution and storage logistics and funds
needed for gleaning, collecting, packaging and distribution. The Good Samaritan Food
Donation Act, signed into law in 1996, provides legal liability protection for food donors and
recipients and tax benefits for participating businesses. However, awareness about this law and
Water Activity
Water activity is the limited vapor pressure of water in a substance divided by the standard
state partial vapor pressure of water. The standard state is most often defined as the partial
vapor pressure of pure water at the same temperature in the field of Food Science. Using this
specific definition, pure distilled water has a water activity of precisely one. As temperature
rises, water activity normally increases, except in some products with sugar or crystalline salt.
moisture sorption isotherm curve. The isotherms are substance- and temperature-specific.
Which can be utilized to help predict the product stability over time in various storage
conditions.
13
Food designers use water activity to prepare shelf-stable food. If a product is stored below
a specific water activity, then mold growth is inhibited, which results in a longer shelf life.
Water activity can also aid to limit moisture migration within a food product made with various
ingredients. Food formulators make use of water activity to predict how much moisture
Water activity is used in various cases as a critical control point for Hazard Analysis and
Critical Control Points (HACCP) programs. The samples of the food product are taken from
the production area from time to time and tested to make sure water activity values are within
a specified range for food quality and safety. Measurements can be prepared in as little as five
minutes, and are made frequent in most major food production facilities.
Organic Oil
Organic oils are produced in remarkable diversity by plants, animals, and other
organisms through natural metabolic processes. Lipid is the scientific term for the fatty acids,
steroids and similar chemicals often found in the oils produced by living things, while oil refers
to an overall mixture of chemicals. Organic oils may also contain chemicals other than lipids,
including proteins, waxes (class of compounds with oil-like properties that are solid at common
Lipids can be classified by the way that they are made by an organism, their chemical structure
and their limited solubility in water compared to oils. They have a high carbon and hydrogen
content and are considerably lacking in oxygen compared to other organic compounds and
minerals; they tend to be relatively nonpolar molecules, but may include both polar and
14
Sulfur
Sulfur is an abundant chemical element and can be found as a mineral deposit almost
everywhere across the world. It is a waste product from the filtering of crude oil and gas in the
petrochemicals industry, which gives rise to huge stockpiles of sulfur outside refineries.
In the past few years, there’s an increasing number of sulfur due to the increase in the
refining of crude oil. Scientists have become interested in using it as an alternative to oil from
which to manufacture plastics to promote environmental friendly plastics. Sulfur also has the
Being extremely available in native form, sulfur was known in ancient times and is
mentioned to in the Torah (Genesis). English translations of the Bible frequently referred to
the Ebers Papyrus, a sulfur ointment was used in ancient Egypt to nurse people with granular
eyelids.
Sulfur is obtained from the Latin word sulpur, which was Hellenized to sulphur in the
mistaken belief that the Latin word came from Greek. This spelling was later changed as
representing an /f/ sound and developed in the spelling sulfur, which appears in Latin toward
natural, nontoxic sources of cornstarch or wheat. Even though they are nontoxic or safe if
accidently eaten, the nutritional value has been removed from the starch in these items. They
are not made food-safe conditions nor they are recommended for eating.
15
Loose fill packaging peanuts are often thought of as a useless product and a nuisance.
They make a mess once packages are opened and clinging to clothes long after. Packing peanuts
are an example of both a renewable and nonrenewable resource depending on how they’re
made. Biodegradable packing peanuts can be made from different agricultural products, such
as corn or wheat, and are renewable, biodegradable and safe if accidentally ingested. (Beth
Despite not being as omnipresent in consumer products, packing peanuts are still
commonly used in industrial places, and by some consumer electronics and lifestyle
manufacturers. One of the major reasons for environmental concerns. Packing peanuts are also
very versatile, and can easily be used for packages of every size without other changes to the
packing materials. Despite their utility, foam packing peanuts have become a thorn in the side
of consumers and environmentalists around the world, helping to initiate a decline in their
popularity.
Biodegradable packing peanuts are made from natural and organic derived starches like wheat
and cornstarch. Entirely plant-based, biodegradable packing peanuts will dissolve in water,
making it impossible for them to end up polluting oceans, lakes, rivers, canals, or waterways.
Unlike foam packing peanuts, which can take centuries to decompose, biodegradable packing
peanuts can be dissolved in just a few minutes when exposed to moisture and heat. (Pela, 2020)
Polystyrene Foam
biodegradable, and like other wastes, it can take hundreds of years to begin to degrade in a
landfill environment. Though some polystyrene peanuts can be recycled and reused, many are
never properly disposed of or simply littered or dumped. When consumed, polystyrene packing
16
peanuts can wreak havoc on the digestive systems of animals especially humans, often creating
Polystyrene is one of the most widely used plastics, the scale of its production being
several million tons per year. Polystyrene can be naturally transparent, but can be colored with
colorants. It is a poor barrier to oxygen and water vapor and has a relatively low melting point.
Dow Chemical Company invented a process to make their trademarked and popular
outdoor waste and trash (particularly in the form of foam floating in waterways and the ocean).
(Rogers, 2015)
sometimes (not always) a homopolymer meaning that it is composed only of the monomer
styrene in combination with itself. Its average melting point ranges from 210 – 249 °C.
The International Agency for Research on Cancer had established styrene as a possible
Biodegradability
by the action of micro-organisms such as bacteria or fungi biological (with or without oxygen)
while getting assimilated into the natural environment. In recent years, the recycling of
packaging materials has increased but the recycling rates for most plastic packaging remain
Biodegradable plastics often comprise polymer blends that contain partly biogenic
(renewable) carbon derived from biomass and partly petrochemical carbon. We can determine
17
if a plastic is biodegradable or not if the plastic can be disintegrated by any biological process.
(Narayan 2006)
In this test, the researchers will determine if the product would be biodegradable or not.
Package Cushioning
Package cushioning is used to protect items during shipment. Vibration and impact
shock during shipment and loading/unloading are controlled by cushioning to reduce the
designed to absorb shock by crushing and deforming, and to dampen vibration, rather than
transmitting the shock and vibration to the protected item. Depending on the specific situation,
package cushioning is often between 50 and 75 millimeters (two to three inches) thick.
Internal packaging materials are also used for functions other than cushioning, such as
to immobilize the products in the box and lock them in place, or to fill a void.
In this test, the researches will test how effective the peanut packagings will be in
18
Chapter 3
Methodology
Research Design
biodegradable loose-fill packaging using cornstarch and pomelo peels. There were two
The study “Using Pomelo Skin as an Alternative to make Loose-Fill Packaging” was
conducted at General Santos City. The durability, cushioning and efficiency tests were
Samples
The researchers gathered samples of Pomelo peels along with 60mL of pure glycerin
The pomelo peel was rinsed under running water to make it clean, and boiled for 10
minutes. The white part of the peels were cut, sliced into small pieces, and then mashed. In one
container, 1/3 tablespoon of glycerin and 50 grams of the peel were combined and then mixed
properly with a spoon. The mixture was then added with 1 tablespoon of cornstarch and 1/4
Once the mixture is done with stirring, it is put in a stove/oven/microwave and heated
for 1 minute. After the 1 minute is done it was left to cool off outside for 24-48 hours in order
to solidify.
20
Preparation of the peels
Repeat until
successful.
Adding additional mixtures
Tests
Water Solubility
The sample was placed into a body of water to see if it will dissolve or not by stirring
the samples carefully until it dissolves. The Water Solubility was ranked from 1-4 depending
Cushion
The ability to provide cushion of the product was be tested by two tests: (1) putting
weights on a group of the products ranging from light to the heaviest it can contain until the
product was straight flat. The maximum amount of weight it can take was recorded. (2) Placing
21
of the packing peanuts inside a box with an egg inside of a plastic ziplock or cellophane in
order to prevent spilling in case it breaks. The test will be done by dropping the box from
certain height ranges until the egg will break. The maximum height that the packing peanuts
Flammability
Each sample will be directly be in contact with 3 fires from 3 candles simultaneously
until it burns or melts. The time from when the sample began contact with fire until it burns
will be recorded.
Statistical Analysis
To obtain and compare the efficiency of each sample, the researchers used a t-test to
analyze the values the experiments have given. The test was used to determine if there is a
22
Chapter 4
INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses the results and the answer to the questions:
1) What is the maximum weight capacity it can hold while providing cushion?
2) Is the loose-fill packaging soluble enough to be thrown into the water without
problem?
3) Is there any difference in the flammability of the pomelo packing peanut from the
4) How effective will the pomelo packing peanut be compared to the commercial
packing peanut if they are placed to cushion an egg from a fall from a certain height?
The purpose of this study is to determine if the loose-fill packaging made from the peels
polystyrene packaging.
This study was made to produce packaging peanuts made from the peels of pomelo.
Also, this study has resulted in some significant differences where the samples went
a) Cushion Test
c) Flammability Test
Our null hypothesis in which will be used to reject or prove will be:
There are no significant differences between the pomelo packing peanut and the
d) Cushion
e) Water Solubility
f) Flammability
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
D1 D2 D3
From the graph shown above, it can be seen that all 3 samples of the Pomelo Packing
Peanut catch fire much later than all of the 3 samples of the Commercial Packing Peanut. Two
separate tests were run, 1 each for the Pomelo Packing Peanut and the Commercial Packing
Peanut.
24
Three samples were tested at the same time simultaneously under 3 different candles.
The three candles were lit and we let it set for 45 seconds. After 45 seconds came the three
samples which were put directly on top of the candle and timed with a smartphone’s stopwatch.
25
Graph 1.2 Water Solubility Test Results
4.5
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
In the shown table, the samples were ranked from 1-4 depending on the the clarity or
the state of the water after stirring the samples. The table shows that the Pomelo Packing Peanut
ranked 2, meaning the sample has made the water cloudy. Meanwhile, the Commercial Packing
Peanut ranked 3.5 which means that it was not able to dissolve but still left particles of it
All 3 samples of the Pomelo Packing Peanut were able to dissolve in the water after
stirring the samples in the water, while the 3 samples of the Pomelo Packing Peanut would not
be able to dissolve unless you manually tear it apart – and then stir. Two separate tests were
run, 1 each for the Pomelo Packing Peanut and the Commercial Packing Peanut. The results
state that the Pomelo Packing Peanuts can be dissolved while the Commercial Packing Peanut
cannot.
26
Three large pitchers were prepared and filled with tap water for about 3/5 of the pitcher. Each
sample was then put into each pitcher respectively, and stirred carefully until the samples mix
in to the water.
From the graph shown above, it can be seen that the 3 samples of the Commercial
Packing Peanut can significantly sustain much heavier weight than all of the 3 samples of the
Pomelo Packing Peanut. Almost all 3 samples of the Commercial Packing Peanut were able to
hold itself until it fell flat to an object of 700 grams, while the Pomelo Packing Peanut was only
able to hold for about 600 grams which is due to it being softer than the Commercial Packing
Peanut.
The test was done by putting each sample under an object that weighed a certain amount
until the sample becomes flattened. Each sample was placed under a water bottle indicating 1
Liter which is equivalent to 1000 mL. The water bottle was filled little by little with a smaller
27
water bottle that indicates 0.2 L which is equal to 200 mL and a smaller bottle of the used Pure
Glycerin container which says 30 mL. We used the unit conversion which is 1 mL = 1 gram.
We used the indications on water bottles for this due to the lack of accurate measuring
materials.
Height State of the egg after dropping State of the egg after dropping
50 cm Completely fine Completely fine
100 cm Completely fine Completely fine
150 cm Completely fine Completely fine
200 cm Completely fine Completely fine
250 cm Completely fine Completely fine
300 cm Visible cracks start to form Visible cracks start to form
350 cm Egg breaks Egg breaks
From the table shown, the both only kept the egg safe for up to 350 cm. Both the Pomelo
Packing Peanut and Commercial Packing Peanut were able to provide similar results in being
able to cushion a fragile material inside a box. The egg inside was observed after every attempt
and was completely fine for the first 5 attempts and yielded different results in the end.
In this test, we put an egg inside a ziplocked plastic in order to prevent it from making
a mess in case it breaks. The egg was then placed inside a box along with the 3 samples of each
of the respective packing peanuts. The test was done 3 times for each type of packing peanut.
28
Graph 1.5 Cushion Test 2 Results
As stated from the previous table, both the Commercial Packing Peanut and Pomelo
Packing Peanut were only able to keep the egg from breaking from falling from a height of 350
The test was done by marking lines on the wall measured with a measuring tape that
indicated centimeters from 0 cm to 150 cm. The box was then set to let go without any extra
29
Statistical Analysis
SUMMARY
Groups Count Mean Variance Standard t value df crit
Error of value
Difference
Pomelo Packing 3 27.89 33.39387
Peanut 3.8885 3.64065 4 2.132
Commercial 3 13.73333 11.96758
Packing Peanut
According to the table above, the two samples (S2 and S1) resulted in a t value which is 3.64065
According to the table above, the two samples (S1 and S2) resulted in a t value which is
3.64065 much greater than the crit value which is 2.132 at 4 degrees of freedom and at 0.05
significance. The Pomelo Packing Peanut produced greater values than the Commercial
Packing Peanut, in which the Pomelo Packing Peanut caught fire much later.
SUMMARY
Groups Count Mean Variance Standard t value df crit
Error of value
Difference
Pomelo Packing 3 605 50
Peanut 24.83277 - 4 2.132
7.44983
Commercial 3 790 1800
Packing Peanut
Based on the table, the two samples produced a t value of -7.44983 which is much less
than the crit value which is 2.132 at 4 degrees of freedom and 0.05 significance, which means
that we fail to reject our null hypothesis and the Pomelo Packing Peanut was not able to keep
30
Table 1.8 Mean of the samples in Cushion Test 2
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Mean Variance
Pomelo Packing Peanut 3 1050 350 0
Both the Pomelo Packing Peanut and the Commercial Packing Peanut all yielded
equivalent results when it comes to the cushioning an egg inside a box from a fall, in which
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Mean Variance
Pomelo Packing Peanut 3 6 2 0
Commercial Packing 3 12 4 0
Peanut
Each sample has produced differing results, but same results in their duplicates. This
31
Chapter 5
This chapter presents the summary and conclusions obtained from the results of the
study which is to test the use of pomelo peels as an alternative for loose-fill packaging. The
peels of pomelo were used to turn it into a packaging product rather than a waste product. The
Pomelo Packing Peanut (S2) and the Commercial Packing Peanut (S1) have yielded results from
the independent t-test. The findings, conclusions, and recommendations we have obtained
Summary of Findings
The findings of the study were summarized according to the statement of the problems
stated in Chapter 1.
1. What is the maximum weight capacity it can hold while providing cushion?
The maximum weight the Pomelo Packing Peanut can sustain at most is approximately
615g. The Pomelo Packing Peanut has a mean of 605 while the Commercial Packing Peanut
The data reveals that the t value is less than the crit value which means that there is not
enough evidence that exists to suggest that there is a significant difference between the Pomelo
2. Is the loose-fill packaging soluble enough to be thrown into the water without problem?
The results stated from the table suggest that the Pomelo Packing Peanuts can dissolve
into a body of water, if assisted by stirring. The Pomelo Packing Peanut samples were ranked
2 which means it dissolved into the water but turning the water it had been stirred in to become
The pomelo packing peanut caught fire a lot later than the commercial packing peanut.
The data obtained from the analysis state that there is a significant difference between the
flammability of the two products, for the t-value which is 3.64065 greater than the crit value
4. How effective will the pomelo packing peanut be compared to the commercial packing
peanut if they are placed to cushion an egg from a fall from a certain height?
The results from the experiment show that the Pomelo Packing Peanuts and
Commercial Packing Peanuts yielded same results which is 350cm above the ground. The data
results also state that both of the samples have the same variance which is 0. There is not
enough evidence to prove that the pomelo packing peanut will be more effective than the
Conclusions
1. There is a significant difference between the Pomelo Packing Peanut and the
Commercial Packing Peanut in terms of flammability, in which case the pomelo caught fire
faster. We failed to reject the null hypothesis in terms of the a) Cushion Test 1 and b) Cushion
2. The Pomelo Packing Peanut was able to keep up and dissolve, while the Commercial
Packing Peanut did not. All pomelo peanut samples were much more water soluble than
commercial peanut samples. The cushion test, on the other hand, reveals that both samples
33
Recommendations
The study revealed the use of Pomelo Peels as an alternative for loose-fill packaging
and factors of the study that need further analysis, or better handling of the experiment. Thus,
1. The main problem we encountered while doing the study was maintaining the right
temperature using a toaster. So we suggest you to perform the heating process with an
oven and microwave. It is easy to manage the temperature needed by the peanut without
it fluctuating.
2. Use a blender to slice the pomelo peel instead of just using knife and mortar and
pestle to make sure that the pomelo peel is as thin as possible to get the best possible
3. Utilize other materials that would make the packing peanut more sturdy, which in our case
was soft.
4. After attempting to break down the commercial packaging peanut, make sure to
discard it so that it does not harm the water sources near your home.
34
References
Berk, Z. (2016). Citrus Fruit Processing, London, United Kingdom : Academic Press
plastics.
from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2873018/
from https://www.heritagepaper.net/pros-and-cons-of-biodegradable-packing-
peanuts/
fromhttps://greenliving.lovetoknow.com/How_Styrofoam_is_Bad_for_the_En
vironment
from https://pelacase.com/blogs/news/biodegradable-packing-peanuts
AND REUSE.
fromhttps://www.colliercountyfl.gov/your-government/divisions-s-z/solid-
hazardous-%20%20waste-management/keeping-green-helpful-information-page/the-
facts-on-styrofoam-reduce-and-
35
reuse#:~:text=Styrofoam%20Statistics&text=Styrene%20is%20classified%20as%20a
,respiratory%20tract%20and%20gastrointestinal%20problems.
from http://fnbreport.ph/features/how-to-avoid-food-waste-in-the-restaurant-
industry-maitadj-
20190703/#:~:text=The%20numbers%20are%20devastating%E2%80%94an,year%20
never%20reaches%20our%20plates.
from https://getawaytips.azcentral.com/how-to-make-packing-peanuts-
12133405.html
GrrlScientist. (2017). Five Ways That Plastics Harm The Environment (And One Way
from https://www.forbes.com/sites/grrlscientist/2018/04/23/five-ways-that-
plastics-harm-the-environment-and-one-way-they-may-help/?sh=295ff95e67a0
Remover. from
https://www.academia.edu/35424324/_Effectiveness_of_Pomelo_Citrus_maxima_ext
ract_as_an_alternative_rust_Fe_2_O_3_Remover_Researchers_Background_of_the_
Study
from https://www.healthbenefitstimes.com/pomelos/
36
Grant, A. (N.D.). Pomelo Tree Care – Pummelo Tree Growing Information.
from https://www.gardeningknowhow.com/edible/fruits/pomelos/pomelo-tree-
care.html
from https://eol.org/pages/488254/articles
Sen, R. (March 2017). Synthesis and Testing of Corn Starch Based Biodegradable
fromhttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/330845696_Synthesis_and_Tes
ting_of_Corn_Starch_Based_Biodegradable_Plastic_and_Composite
37
APPENDICES
38
APPENDIX A
Rind Preparation
39
APPENDIX B
40
Plate 5: Mixture
41
APPENDIX C
42
Plate 8: Drying of the sample for days
43
APPENDIX D
44
Plate 10: Water Solubility
45
Plate 11: Flammability
46