Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage.

8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022, Serial #30

Global Journal of Environmental Science and Management


(GJESM)

Homepage: https://www.gjesm.net/

ORIGINAL RESEARCH PAPER


Hydro-mechanical behavior of two clayey soils in presence of household waste leachates
H.F. Yonli1,2,*, B. François3, D.Y.K. Toguyeni1,4, A. Pantet5
1
Laboratoire de Physique et de Chimie de l’Environnement, Université Joseph KI-Zerbo, BP 7021 Ouagadougou 03, Burkina Faso
2
Ecole Supérieure d’Ingénierie, Université de Fada N’Gourma, BP 46 Fada N’Gourma, Burkina Faso
3
Building Architecture and Town Planning Department, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Avenue F.D. Roosevelt 50, CP 194/2, 1050
Bruxelles, Belgique
4
Ecole Polytechnique de Ouagadougou, 08 BP 143 Ouagadougou 08, Burkina Faso
5
UMR 6294 CNRS, Laboratoire Ondes et Milieux Complexes, Normandie Université, Unihavre, 53 rue Prony, 76600 Le Havre,
France

ARTICLE INFO A B ST R AC T
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: In landfills, containment is provided by natural or artificial clayey
Article History: materials known for their low permeability and for their pollutant retention capacity. However, the
Received 08 June 2021 properties of these media are modified by leachates, whose migration they are supposed to limit. This
Revised 29 July 2021 study aims to reconsider the criteria for choosing suitable materials to make a bottom liner through both
their long term hydraulic and mechanical performances.
Accepted 06 September 2021
METHODS: Two fine materials sampled in Burkina Faso (West Africa) have been characterized in order to
compare their hydro-mechanical behavior in the presence of household waste leachates. The first material
Keywords: is classified as an inorganic clay of low to medium plasticity according to Casagrande plasticity diagram, it is
mainly kaolinitic with some traces amounts of smectites. The second one is classified clayey sand of low to
Bottom liner
medium plasticity, the predominant mineral clay being kaolinite. Hydro-mechanical tests were performed
Compressibility on both sampled materials to judge the sealing properties of these materials, as well as the characteristics
Hydraulic conductivity of deformation and rupture which have an important effect to ensure the durability of a bottom liner. All
Leachate these tests were performed first with distilled water then with leachates as interstitial fluids in order to
understand the modification of the hydro-mechanical properties of the clayey soils.
Shear
FINDINGS: Leachate contamination always alters hydraulic properties of the materials. However, between
the two soils, the most clayey and the most impervious (soils from Nouna) undergo the deeper weathering.
Indeed, hydraulic conductivity of these soils in contact with a synthetic leachate increases from 1.71x10-10
to 1.51x10-9 m/s. In contrast to soils from Boudry, these soils also undergo very significant settlements over
the long term with compressibility indexes varying from 0.164 to 0.225. For both soils, the shear strength
increases showing that, from this point view, the leachate work in the sense of of the bottom liner stability.
For soils from Nouna, the effective cohesion increases from 3 to 21 kPa with a slight decrease of friction
angle; for soils from Boudry a slight increase of cohesion is noticed while friction angle increases from 34
to 37°.
CONCLUSION: This comparative study is of practical use to environmental geotechnics professionals
because it shows that the choice in designing a bottom liner must be a compromise between long term
hydraulic and mechanical behaviors of soils. It is also important to know the nature of the flows to contain
in order to ensure the durability of the structure.

DOI: 10.22034/gjesm.2022.02.02

NUMBER OF REFERENCES NUMBER OF FIGURES NUMBER OF TABLES

40 7 7
*Corresponding Author:
Email: fabienyonli@yahoo.fr
Phone: +226 7140 9576
ORCID: 0000-0002-4981-4705
Note: Discussion period for this manuscript open until July 1, 2022 on GJESM website at the “Show Article.
H.F. Yonli et al.

INTRODUCTION slopes is determined so as to ensure a sufficient


Due to the evolution of its demography as well coefficient of stability (Abramson et al., 2002).
as its consumption, Burkina Faso (West Africa) is Vertical deformations of the liner, called settlements,
experiencing a situation of high waste production will occur during the exploitation of the landfill.
currently estimated at 500 000 tons per year for Settlements are linked to compressibility, which
its capital Ouagadougou. As in many developing similar to the hydraulic conductivity, is one of the most
countries, waste storage has migrated from important properties of the liner material (Mishra et
uncontrolled dumping to landfills of several ha. al., 2010). The assessment of the settlements caused
The construction of a landfill requires phases of by the overloads represented by the weight of the
earthworks to define a main excavation which will waste accumulated over several meters vertical
be divided in several cells. These cells will be filled deformations must be verified (Dutta and Mishra,
with waste and covered with a clayey cap liner when 2016) as well as the risk of failure of the landfill
full in order to isolate waste. Before the installation that may occur during the phases of construction,
of this cover, the rainwater percolates through operation and closure of the landfill (Townsend et
the waste and is temporarily loaded to produce al., 2015). All this requires the determination of the
leachate. Leachate quality is the result of the waste appropriate geotechnical parameters of the bottom
composition, water budget, biological, chemical, and liners. As stated above, hydraulic conductivity is the
physical conditions in the landfill body (Erhig and parameter used to judge of the sealing potential of
Stegmann, 2018), its composition varies significantly the bottom liner. In soil mechanics, stability analyzes
among landfills depending on waste composition, are based on the determination of cohesion and
waste age and landfilling technology (Christensen et angle of friction (parameters relating to shear
al, 2001). Familiarly called “garbage juice” (Jambeck, strength). Recompression and compression indexes
2007), leachate of household and similar waste has are used to predict settlements. Hydro-mechanical
a potentiel impact on land, soils and groundwater tests are carried out to measure such parameters in
(Wdowczyk and Szymańska-Pulikowska, 2021; Ullah order to judge the use of these local clayey materials
et al., 2018; Azizi et al., 2016). These leachates must as perennial impervious barriers. However some
be drained by a granular material and a network major concerns are not sufficiently addressed. For
of flexible pipelines before being pumped out for instance there is no regulatory specification about
treatment. Despite the presence of this Leachate how to measure hydraulic conductivity (Ait Saadi,
Collection and Removal System (LCRS), soil and 2003) of a bottom liner. Yet, many authors such as
groundwater protection must also be ensured by a Benson et al. (2018) have well established that this
geological barrier known as bottom liner which covers parameter often increase when soils suitable for
the slope and the bottom of the excavation. The liners experience leachate leakage. Also note that
bottom liners must limit the infiltration of pollutants according to established normative procedures tests
and various authors such as Widomski et al. (2018) are often conducted with distilled water whereas
agree that it ensures the long-term safety of the site. some authors have noticed changes on the long term
Very often, adequate geological conditions are not mechanical behavior due to the leachate impact
satisfied and techniques of strengthening and soil (Cuisinier et al., 2014). Sometimes the behavior can
treatment are implemented. The design of landfills be quite unpredictable and leachate can improve
is mainly based on a criteria related to hydraulic or alter mechanical properties of the liner. Indeed
flow of leachate through the sealing barriers. The Dutta and Mishra (2016) noticed a decrease in
most stringent national and international regulations compressibility index of bentonites in presence
define a threshold value of 10-9 m/s for hydraulic of salt solutions. Naeini et al. (2016) showed that
conductivity (also called permeability) over a interaction of inorganic clay with bentonite increased
thickness of at least 1 m on the bottom and 0.5 m shear strength of the liner. Otherwise Gratchev and
on the slopes (Wagner, 2013). In addition, mechanical Towhata (2016) noticed an increase of compressibility
properties such as shear strength, low compressibility, indexes of Kansai clay with acidic solutions, meaning
low shrinkage-swelling are required for the design an increase in settlements. Another concern is the
(Abdellah et al., 2020). Indeed, the geometry of the fact that most impervious clays do not always have

170
Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022

the best mechanical properties. Few works have modification of the behavior of the bottom liner during
highlighted the considerations described above the operation of a landfill, including leachate leakage,
through a comparison between two clayey materials deformation and risks of failure of the bottom liner. The
solicited by the same leachate. This approach makes it discussion which follows will focus on the modification
easier to understand the criteria for choosing suitable of properties according to the mineralogical nature
clayey material to make a bottom liner. The study of the liner and according to the type of leachate. It
highlights the importance of a compromise between is oriented towards the selection criteria to consider
hydraulic and mechanical performances. It also in the choice of suitable clayey soils to make bottom
highliths the importance of the representativeness liners. Fig. 1 presents the overall methodology of the
of the type of fluid used for the determination of characterization of the studied clayey soils.
the geotechnical parameters. In summary, the study
offers to environmental geotechnics professionals a Choice and identification of soils
reflection on how to judge the performance of clay In this study, two soils were collected in Burkina
barriers on the long term. In this study, the hydro- Faso. The first one is natural and comes from
mechanical performances of two clayey materials, Nouna located 284 km northwest of the capital
sampled in Burkina Faso (West Africa) and their Ouagadougou. In this zone, the geological conditions
evolution when they are in presence of household indicate a cover of aeolian sands, clays and alluvium
waste leachates are examined. The study was constituting young sediments on old lands. The
conducted in Burkina Faso between 2018 and 2020. sampling area is located in a vast plain flooded in
places and covered with weeds in the winter season.
MATERIALS AND METHODS When sampled, the soil is in the form of hardened
The methodological approach consists first of all, in blocks. Soils from Nouna are gray and hard when dry.
selecting two soils which have different mineralogical They are moistened when black, they are soft and
properties, both potentially suitable as bottom liners, they smell as organic matter in decomposition. The
and testing their hydro-mechanical properties in a sampling area is X = 406,327 and Y = 1,405,498 (UTM
defined reference condition. This reference condition, ZONE 30P). The second one comes from Boudry
simulated by saturation with distilled water, aims to located 100.5 km east of Ouagadougou (X = 749,953
describe the behavior of a landfill when it is not yet and Y = 1,353,945 UTM ZONE 30P). These soils from
solicited by the chemical action of the leachates. The Boudry are generally shallow and not very fertile, of
hydro-mechanical properties are then assessed with the ferruginous tropical type, vulnerable to the action
two types of leachates in order to understand the of erosion and runoff. The sampling area is located

Fig. 1: Methodology of characterization of the hydro-mechanical behavior of the two clayey soils
Fig. 1: Methodology of characterization of the hydro-mechanical behavior of the two clayey soils

171
Hydro-mechanical behavior of clayey soils

Table1:1:Geotechnical
Table Geotechnicalidentification
identificationparameters
parametersofofthe
thestudied
studiedsoils
soils

Fine Clay Organic Optimum Maximum dry


Liquidity Plasticity Plasticity
Soils fraction (≤ fraction (≤ matter water content unit weight
limit wl [%] limit wp[%] index PI[%]
80 µm) [%] 2 µm) [%] content [%] wOPM [%] γdmax [kN/m3]

Nouna 95 74 44 22 22 10.8 16.30 16.53


Boudry 47.6 22.5 42 20 22 3.9 9.20 19.91

Fig. 2: Mineralogical composition of the fine fraction of the studied soils


Fig. 2: Mineralogical composition of the fine fraction of the studied soils

on a large, sparsely treed plain. The reddish surface composition of the powders, which can be obtained
of the soil is sandy-silty. When sampled, the soil is by XRD analysis, is shown in Fig. 2. This mineralogical
in the form of hardened blocks. The walls remain analysis were carried out on air-dried and glycol
vertical. The soil is completely dry, light brown to saturated preparations from the fine fraction of the
yellow with gravel or nodules. Soils were collected soils. The diffractograms analysis was carried out
by hand digging of 75 cm deep hole. These samples according to Rietveld method.
were brought to the laboratory after a first on-site The geotechnical identification tests essentially
quartering operation. These samples of about 100 kg indicate clayey materials; the results of the
of soil were air-dried in the laboratory and broken up mineralogy confirm that the fine fraction is mainly
by hand. By a second quartering operation, several clayey respectively 76% for soils from Nouna
homogeneous batches were made, which will serve and 41% for soils from Boudry. XRD results from
as test samples as well as for the production of test oriented preparations and glycol-saturated oriented
specimens. Identification tests (mineralogy by X-Ray preparations reveals that the predominant mineral
diffraction over the infra 80 μm, particle size analysis is kaolinite (74% of kaolinite and 2% of smectites
using sieve analysis and sedimentometry, Atterberg for soils from Nouna, 41% of kaolinite for soils from
limits, and determination of organic matter by Boudry). The results also report a significant amount
calcination according to NF standards (AFNOR, 1992; of organic matter. In the Casagrande diagram, these
1996; 1998; 2002) and modified Proctor tests were materials are described as medium inorganic clays
carried out on these soils in order to determine their (CL), however the soil from Boudry are rather clayey
nature parameters of and compaction characteristics. sand (SC-CL). Their PI values ​​are relatively high and
The results of the geotechnical identification are thus make them promising from the point of view of
shown in Table 1. The semi-quantitative mineralogical their sealing potential.

172
Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022

Table 2: Composition
Table 2: Composition by
by category
category of
of waste
waste for
for Ouagadougou
Ouagadougou landfill
landfill (Haro
(Haroet
etal.,
al.,2018)
2018)

Percentage composition of waste fraction


Category of waste
Rainy season Dry season
Fermentable waste 23.86 19.94
Paper 1.65 2.37
Cardboard 4.49 5.19
Composites 1.53 2.28
Textiles 5.41 4.32
Sanitary textiles 1.69 1.94
Plastics 11.13 12.1
Non-classified combustibles 3.46 2.81
Glass 1.14 3
Metals 2.89 1.71
Non-classified incombustibles 4.27 5.12
Special wastes 0.22 1.14
Fine materials 38.27 38.08

Table3:3:Chemical
Table Chemicalcomposition
composition(major
(majorions)
ions)of
ofthe
thesynthetic
syntheticleachate
leachate

Ionic species Ca2+ Cl- Cu2+ K+ Mg2+ Na+ NH4+ SO42-


Concentrations (mol/L) 0,014 0,07 7.10-4 0,017 0,002 0,035 0,003 0,009
Concentrations (mg/L) 570,2 2475,8 5 673,5 50 793,2 50 834,9

Choice of leachates Thus, there are two leachates, the synthetic


Two types of leachates have been used in this one is potentially more aggressive. The formulation
study. The first one is natural and has been collected of synthetic leachates is a practice used in several
from the leachate storage and treatment ponds studies. It has the advantage of guaranteeing control
from the drainage system of Ouagadougou landfill. of the chemical composition and of discussing the
The values of BOD5/COD highlight a large amount modifications induced by the chemical species present
of organic matter. The pH value of the leachate is by varying their concentration or by considering their
representative of a basic leachate with a pH of 7.68. actions in isolation.
The low electrical conductivity value of 1182 µs/cm​​
shows that the salinity and at the same time the ionic Assessment of hydraulic conductivity by means of
strength of this leachate are not important. More filtration tests on the two materials
details about its composition figured in Vianney et The hydraulic behavior of the soils was assessed
al. (2017). The composition by category of waste of by means of API (American Petroleum Institute) type
Ouagadougou landfills are given in Table 2. filtration tests. The method is well documented and
The second leachate is synthetic and has been consists of subjecting a suspension of soil and solvent
formulated to be as close as possible of a young to a pressure of 690 kPa (Sherwood, 1997; Benna-
leachate from a household landfill in an acidogenesis Zayani et al., 2001; Pantet and Monnet, 2007 ; Rosin-
phase. The formulation of this leachate has been Paumier et al., 2011). The applied pressure forces
described by Yonli et al. (2017). It has a relatively high the liquid to flow while the solid part called cake is
biodegradable organic load consisting mainly of VFAs retained on a filter paper. The kinetics of filtration
(Volatile Fatty Acids) and it is also loaded with heavy are related to the hydraulic properties of the cake
metals. Concentrations of chemical species (Table 3) as well as the chemical composition of the filtered
are selected to stay within the usual ranges found in liquid. Although Darcy’s law was developed for grainy
landfills and described by Christensen et al. (2001). soils (sands and gravels), to this day, it is still used,
The pH of the synthetic leachate is acidic with the for cohesive soils (clays and silts). Application to fine
value of 5.07 and an electrical conductivity of 12,560 soils assumes a sufficiently high hydraulic gradient so
µs/cm highlighting a high value of ionic strength. as not to observe deviations from Darcy’s law. This

173
H.F. Yonli et al.

condition is fulfilled within the framework of this To ensure a low permeability, the samples have
study, given the high pressure value applied to the clay been remoulded by compaction with the energy of
suspensions. From Darcy’s law, it is established that Modified Proctor on wet side of the Proctor curve (at
the cumulative volume of filtrate V(m3) is expressed wOPM+3%).
as a linear relation as a function of the square root of
time t(s) using Eq. 1. Assessment of compressibility
The deformation properties of the soils were
V²=2.K.S².P.t/(μ.b)  (1) assessed by means of oedometric tests, applying a
loading stage every 24 hours. In this approach, the
Where, K is the desired intrinsic permeability (m²) consolidation phenomenon involded, implies a strong
of the material, S the surface of the sample (m²), P coupling between the mechanical compressibility of
the pressure (Pa), μ the viscosity of the water (Pa.s- the soil skeleton and the drainage of the interstitial fluid
1
) and b = cS/Vf the specific volume of the cake and supposes a saturation of the soil. The samples of
deposited per unit volume, c the cake thickness (m), soils tested in this study were allowed to swell almost
Vf is the final volume at the end of filtration (m3). The freely during a saturation phase, the sample is only
coefficient of permeability or hydraulic conductivity subjected to a vertical stress corresponding to the
k(m/s) is thereafter obtained by Eq. 2. weight of the piston (3 kPa). Then, the loads applied
to the sample were increased, step by step, up to 483
k = ρ.g.K/μ  (2) kPa, with three loading/unloading cycles. The value
of 483 kPa corresponds to the order of magnitude of
Where, ρ is the bulk density of water (kg/m), g is the stresses caused by the weight of the waste in the
the acceleration due to gravity (m²/s) landfills in Burkina Faso. The deformation parameters
The suspensions dosed at 100 g/L are prepared were calculated from the compressibility curve e-logσ’v
with distilled water (which serves as a reference where e is the soil void ratio and σ’v is the corresponding
situation) then in the presence of the leachates applied effective vertical stress. The compression and
(natural leachate and synthetic leachate) at the same recompression indexes Cc and C r are important
dosage. The void ratio of the cake is calculated after because they allow to calculate the settlement (vertical
determining its dry density ρd using Eq. 3. deformation of the bottom liner). In the case of excessive
settlements and especially differential settlements, the
e = ρs/ρd-1  (3) clayey bottom liner may be damaged.

Where, ρs is the density of the solid particles Assessment of shear strength


assumed equal to 2.65 g/cm3. The shear strength is measured by means of direct
The advantage of the filtration tests method lies shear test, using a shear test appartus equipped with
in its rapidity since it makes it possible to avoid the an automated acquisition device. It is assumed that,
saturation period required before permeability falling in landfills, the application of loads related to the
head tests. Although the void index is not the same weight of waste leads to the consolidation of the
in both tests, filtration tests and permeability falling soil through the dissipation of interstitial pressures.
head tests lead to the same orders of magnitude of This is why, tests conducted with different loads
the hydraulic conductivity. were carried out under saturated conditions with a
sufficiently slow speed (of 0.02 mm/mn), in order
Assessment of mechanical behavior of soils from to measure the effective characteristics. The shear
Nouna stress at the rupture obeys Coulomb’s law, using Eq.
The various mechanical parameters were 4.
determined by conducting tests on compacted
samples of soils from Nouna and Boudry under τ= C ′ + σ v′ .tanφ '  (4)
drained conditions with water as saturating fluid and
then with leachates. Conditions of compaction and Where, C' is the effective cohesion and φ' the
conditions of drainage are identical in both cases. effective angle of internal friction.

174
Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022

Table 4: Hydraulic
Table 4: Hydraulic conductivities of studied
conductivities of studied soils
soils obtained
obtained with
with distilled
distilled water
water

Soils Nouna Boudry


Hydraulic conductivity k(m/s) 1.71x10-10 1.01x10-9
Void ratio e 1.11 0.90

Table 5:
Table 5: Influence
Influence of
of the
the leachate
leachate on
on hydraulic
hydraulicconductivities
conductivitiesof
ofstudied
studiedsoils
soils

Hydraulic conductivities k(m/s)


Test fluids
Nouna Boudry
Distilled water 1.71x10-10 1.01x10-9
Natural leachate 3.51x10-10 2.70x10-9
Synthetic leachate 1.18x10-9 7.72x10-9

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION tests on bentonites and also noticed an increase


Filtration tests with water and leachate in the hydraulic conductivity. The phenomenon
The results of filtration tests carried out on of degradation of the sealing potential deserves
suspensions dosed at 100 g/L with soils from Nouna further investigation, because many parameters are
and Boudry are presented below. Table 4 also presents involved such as the composition of the leachate and
the characteristic values of the cake obtained. its concentration. The natural leachate has a very
These results show that the soil from Nouna has a slight impact on the permeability of the materials.
hydraulic conductivity at saturation less than 10-9 m/s, This result is in agreement with the nature of the
confirming the possibility of being used as a bottom leachate: the synthetic leachate formulated has a
liner. The soil from Boudry however has a value of very high ionic strength compared to that of the
hydraulic conductivity of 1.01x10-9 m/s. This value of natural leachate. This indicates that the mineral
hydraulic conductivity is at the limit of the acceptable pollutant load of the landfill leachate is not so high.
threshold. It appears otherwise that even with trace Setz et al. (2017) noticed that solutions having high
amounts, smectites are very necessary to obtain ionic strength or predominantly divalent cations lead
an optimal sealing. Indeed, the permeability of clay to larger pores and higher hydraulic conductivity.
materials is highly dependent on the mineralogical
composition of the clay compounds, the texture, its Influence of leachates on compressibility
water content and its state of consolidation (Marcoën Compressibility of soils from Nouna
et al., 2000). The results of the filtration tests with The results of œdometric tests conducted on
the synthetic leachate (Table 5) showed an important soils from Nouna are given in Table 6. They show that
increase in the hydraulic conductivity k of the soils although compacted (with an initial void ratio e of
from of Nouna, which varies from 1.71x10-10 m/s to 0.65 and an initial density (saturated density) gsat of
1.18x10-9 m/s, i.e. k almost multiplied by 10; it results 18.92 kN/m3 compared to the value e of 1.11 and gsat
in the decrease in their sealing potential. Concerning of 13.42 kN/m3 obtained by filtration), the soils from
the soils from Boudry, the increase with this leachate Nouna have values of compression and recompression
is slightly less significant. The less impervious material indexes which characterize compressible soils.
appears to undergo the deeper alteration. The Despite the low percentage of smectites of 2%,
degradation of the sealing potential with leachates the swelling of the soils from Nouna (part “AB” of
is a phenomenon highlighted by many authors. For the curve) appears to be very important. Indeed,
example Badv and Omidi (2007) who studied the according to Tabani (1999) and Xu et al. (2003), the
effect of a synthetic leachate rich in calcium (4000 amount of swelling clay is one of the first factors
mg/l concentration) on the hydraulic conductivity which condition the swelling of clayey soils. Tabini
of a clayey sand found an increase in the hydraulic (1999) found a swelling rate of 6.3% for a soil having
conductivity of 20%. Wang et al. (2019) used a a percentage of bentonite of 10% under a pressure of
natural leachate (stabilized inorganic hazardous 5 kPa. Nouna clay, for its part, has a swelling rate of
waste leachate) to conduct hydraulic conductivity 12.05% under a pressure of 3 kPa. Nevertheless, many

175
Hydro-mechanical behavior of clayey soils

Table 6: Influence of leachate on the parameters of the mechanical behavior of the soil from Nouna
Table 6: Influence of leachate on the parameters of the mechanical behavior of the soil from Nouna

Deformabilty properties
Initial specific weight Preconsolidation pressure
Test fluids Recompression index Compression index
𝜸𝜸sat (kN/m3) 𝝈𝝈′ 𝒑𝒑 (𝒌𝒌𝒌𝒌𝒌𝒌)
Cr Cc
Distilled water 18.92 0.049 0.164 55
Natural leachate 18.83 0.054 0.148 55
Synthetic leachate 19.37 0.095 0.225 50

Fig. 3: Compressibility curves obtained for soils from Nouna (A. Distilled water; B. Natural leachate; C. Synthetic leachate)
Fig. 3: Compressibility curves obtained for soils from Nouna
(A. Distilled water; B. Natural leachate; C. Synthetic leachate)
authors agree that the initial state of the soil (water with acidic fluids increased because of the dissolution
content and dry density) and other structural effects, of ferric oxide between the clay aggregates.
seasonal influence and even test conditions may have In order to know the contribution of each group
an influence on the swelling rate (Chrétien, 2010). All of chemical species contained in the synthetic
else being equal, the mechanical behavior of Nouna leachate (VFA, major mineral ions, heavy metals)
clay is also modified under the influence of leachates. in the increase of the compressibility, œdometric
Results are summarized in Table 6 and on Fig. 3. The tests were also performed with each one of them.
compressibility curves e-logσ’v seem quite similar The results shown in Fig. 4 reveal that while major
for distilled water (Fig. 3A) and natural leachate (Fig. mineral ions and heavy metals cause a decrease in
3B). Thus, it appears that the natural leachate having compressibility (decrease in Cc), for acetic acid, the
a weak ionic strength has few interactions with the opposite occurs. It is therefore the reaction of VFA
soil. On the other hand, the impact of the synthetic with some compounds of the soils from Nouna which
leachate is very noticeable (Fig. 3C). This raises the contributes to such an increase in the settlements.
question of the representability of leachate as a test
fluid. Let’s remember that the synthetic leachate is Compressibility of soils from Boudry
formulated to be as close as possible to a leachate The results obtained for the soils from Boudry
of household landfill in its early stages of maturation. (Table 7 and Fig. 5) well illustrate the role of mineralogy
The swelling of Nouna is partially inhibited. Indeed, on the modification of the mechanical properties of
the cations contained in this solution diffuse through soils. Swelling is not affected by both leachates. Unlike
the layer space of the clay resulting in a reduction of soils from Nouna, the compressibility of soils from
repulsive forces between the clay particles (Yonli et al., Boudry decreases because the settlements become
2017). The compression index undergoes a significant less important. Thus, if permeability is altered by
increase from 0.164 to 0.225 and it is necessary to leachates regardless of the type of clay, it is not the
consider in the design of the bottom liner as it will same way for compressibility. This observation leads
lead to higher settlements. Gratchev and Towhata us to reflect on the criteria for choosing suitable clayey
(2009) made this same observation. The authors soils to make bottom liners. Shouldn’t it be the result
noted that the compressibility of Ariake clay leached of a compromise between hydraulic and mechanical

176
Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022

Fig. 4: Influence of the


Fig.type of pollutants
4: Influence contained
of the type in thecontained
of pollutants syntheticinleachate on the
the synthetic compressibility
leachate of Nouna clay,
on the compressibility comparison
of Nouna clay, with distilled
comparisonwater
with distilled water

Table 7: Influence of leachate on the parameters


Table 7: Influence ofon
of leachate thethe
mechanical behavior
parameters of the soils from
of the mechanical Boudry
behavior of the soils from Boudry

Deformabilty properties Preconsolidation


Initial specific weight
Test fluids Recompression index pressure
𝜸𝜸sat (kN/m3) Compression index Cc
Cr 𝝈𝝈′ 𝒑𝒑 (𝒌𝒌𝒌𝒌𝒌𝒌)

Distilled water 20.21 0.007 0.109 50


Synthetic leachate 20.10 0.007 0.075 50
Real leachate 20.25 0.001 0.067 50

Fig. 5: Compressibility curves obtained for soils from Boudry (A. Distilled water; B. Real leachate; C. Synthetic leachate)
Fig. 5: Compressibility curves obtained for soils from Boudry
(A. Distilled water; B. Real leachate; C. Synthetic leachate)

performance which takes into account the composition Influence of leachates on shear strength
of the leachate? The answer to this question would Shear strength of soils from Nouna
obviously involves the choice of the representability of The effective cohesion C’ and the effective angle of
the test fluid as leachate. According to some authors internal friction Ф’ (measured at a state of compacity
such as Dutta and Mishra (2016), the decrease of identical to the case of the oedometric tests) and
compression index may be the result of the orientation determined from the Mohr relation, are respectively
of clay particles becoming more flocculated and 3 kPa and 28° for tests with distilled water. The low
resisting to settlements. Litterature also suggests that value of cohesion and the relatively high value of
the effect of diffuse double layer on the compressibility the angle of friction are consistent with the state of
of soils is less pronounced for kaolinitic soils compared saturation of the clay. Since the real leachate did not
to soils containing smectites (Mitchell and Soga, 2005). significantly alter the compressibility of Nouna, only
This statement is in agreement with the results of this synthetic leachate (compared with distilled water)
study. was used to conduct shear tests. The results of shear

177
H.F. Yonli et al.

tests with the synthetic leachate as a saturating fluid cohesion of the soil as well as to its internal friction
reveal that the soil experiences an increase in shear angle (Fig. 7). However, the increase in cohesion is less
strength (Fig. 6). The shear strength is modified with significant than that of the soils from Nouna: it goes
only an increase in the soil cohesion at 21 kPa. The from 19 kPa to 23 kPa, i.e. an increase of 21%. This
value of the angle of internal friction is not affected. finding is in agreement with œdometric tests which
The observation of this phenomenon could find an have shown that the influence of the leachate on the
explanation in the theory of the diffuse double layer. swelling and therefore on the diffuse double layer is
Leachate highly concentrated in electrolytes would negligible because of the mineralogy of the soils from
cause a change in the organization of particles. From Boudry, whose clay fraction mainly contains kaolinite.
a morphological point of view, the leachate favors an The slight increase in the internal friction angle, which
increase in the number of sheets per aggregate and goes from 34 ° to 37 °, may be due to the action of the
consequently a decrease in the number of aggregates synthetic leachate on the geometry of the grains of
with equal dry matter quantity. All this shows that sand contained in soils from Boudry.
the soil migrates towards a more cohesive state. Some authors have also found similar results,
Some authors have pointed out that it is precisely they notice an increase in shear strength of clayey
aggregates which generate the shear resistance soils in contact with leachate. Indeed Naieni et al.
(Derriche et al., 1997). (2017) studied the effect of leachate’s components
on undrained shear strength of clay-bentonite liners.
Shear strength of soils from Boudry They noticed that by addition of soluble salts of
The intrinsic curves of soils from Boudry, on the single-valence cations and leachate provided from
other hand, show that the increase in shear strength them up to 2%, the undrained shear strength of
induced by the synthetic leachate is due both to the clay-bentonite liners increased. However, they also

Fig. 6: Influence of synthetic leachate


Fig. 6:on the shear
Influence ofstrength
syntheticofleachate
soils fromonNouna (A. Stress
the shear strengthstrain curvefrom
of soils σ’v =Nouna
50 kPa ; B. Stress strain curve σ’v
= 100strain
(A. Stress kPa ;curve
C. Stress
σ’ = strain
50 kPacurve σ’v =strain
; B. Stress 200 kPa ; D.
curve σ’ Stress strain
= 100 kPa ; C. curve
Stress σ’ = 400
strain
v
kPa
curve σ’ E. Failure
= 200 kPa ;envelope)
D. Stress strain curve
v v v
σ’v = 400 kPa E. Failure envelope)

178
Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022

Fig. 7: Influence of synthetic leachate on the shear strength of soils from Boudr (A. Stress strain curve σ’v = 50 kPa ; B. Stress strain curve σ’v
Fig. 7:strain
= 100 kPa ; C. Stress Influence
curveofσ’synthetic leachate
= 200 kPa on the
; D. Stress shear
strain strength
curve of soils
σ’v = 400 kPa from Boudry
E. Failure envelope)
v*
(A. Stress strain curve σ’v = 50 kPa ; B. Stress strain curve σ’v = 100 kPa ; C. Stress strain curve σ’v* = 200 kPa ; D.
Stress strain curve σ’v = 400 kPa E. Failure envelope)
pointed out, shear strength decrease with further Contamination by leachate always alters the hydraulic
increase in contaminants. Sunil et al. (2009) noticed properties of soils. However, between the two soils
that even in lateritic soils used as landfill foundation, studied, the most clayey and the most impermeable
the contamination by municipal solid waste leachate (soils from Nouna) undergo the deeper alteration.
lead to changes in the shear strength characteristics. Furthermore, whatever the soils considered, the
The effective cohesion increases while the effective leachate with the greatest ionic strength is also the
friction angle decreases. most aggressive in terms of degradation of the sealing
The results of all the hydro-mechanical tests properties. The study emphasizes that the choice of
in this study show that while leachates are always the clayey soils as bottom liners should results from
detrimental to the sealing of a bottom liner, it is a compromise between long term hydraulic and
not necessarily the case for its mechanical behavior. mechanical performance. Indeed, soils from Boudry
This should draw attention to the fact that designing (mainly containing quartz and kaolinite), which are
a bottom liner is a complex process that requires the less impermeable of both materials, experience
extensive investigations. an improvement of their deformation properties
meaning that settlements decrease. On the contrary
CONCLUSION a bottom liner made from soils from Nouna, would
This study consisted to assess the modification experience very significant settlements over the long
of the long-term hydro-mechanical behavior of two term because of the influence of volatile fatty acids
clayey soils in presence of household waste leachate. contained in the synthetic leachate. The influence
It allowed to reconsider the criteria of choice of of the synthetic leachate on the shear strength
suitable clayey soils for a use as bottom liners. characteristics shows that it always improves the

179
H.F. Yonli et al.

stability of the bottom liner. In this case, a short-term Attribution 4.0 International License, which
design of the liner, is better from a safety point of view. permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and
This result requires further investigation by carrying reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you
out the same tests with other clayey soils and other give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and
leachates as research perspectives. The question of the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons
the representativeness of the leachate for carrying out license, and indicate if changes were made. The
a long-term characterization is also raised. The natural images or other third party material in this article are
leachate of lower ionic strength has less impact on included in the article’s Creative Commons license,
the hydro-mechanical behavior of the studied soils unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the
as evidenced by the values ​​of hydraulic conductivities material. If material is not included in the article’s
and those of the compression and recompression Creative Commons license and your intended use is
indexes. The conclusions of this comparative study not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the
of the hydro-mechanical properties of two clayey permitted use, you will need to obtain permission
soils are of practical use to professionals in the field directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of
of environmental geotechnics. The importance of the this license, visit:
surface properties with respect to leachate is well http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
demonstrated. On the long term, leachate production,
linked to the decomposition of waste, can lead to a loss PUBLISHER’S NOTE
of hydraulic performance and a modification of the GJESM Publisher remains neutral with regard
mechanical characteristics of the bottom liners. to jurisdictional claims in published maps and
institutional afflictions.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
H.F. Yonli performed the literature review, ABBREVIATIONS
compiled and interpreted the data, prepared and API American Petroleum Institute
edited the manuscript. B. François interpreted the b Specific volume of the cake
data and prepared the manuscript. D.Y.K. Toguyeni BOD5 Biologic Oxygen Demand
and A. Pantet performed the elaboration of the c Cake thickness
research problem.
C’ Effective cohesion
Cc Compression index
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to thank the national Ca2+ Calcium ion
laboratory for building and public works in Burkina CL Inorganic clay of low to medium plasticity
Faso, where a lot of geotechnical tests were carried Cl- Chloride ion
out in the framework of this study. Special thanks go COD Chemical Oxygen Demand
to the members of the technical management team Cu2+ Copper ion
on the date on which this work was carried out, in Cr Recompression index
particular the technical director Mr. Kalsibiri Kaboré. cm Centimeter
cm3 Cubic centimeter
CONFLICT OF INTEREST e Void ratio
The authors declare no potential conflict of g Gram
interest regarding the publication of this work. In
i.e. That is to say
addition, the ethical issues including plagiarism,
informed consent, misconduct, data fabrication and, k Hydraulic conductivity
or falsification, double publication and, or submission, K Intrinsic permeability
and redundancy have been completely witnessed by K +
Potassium ion
the authors. kg Kilogram
km Kilometer
OPEN ACCESS kN Kilonewton
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons kPa Kilopascal

180
K Intrinsic permeability
K+ Potassium ion
kg Kilogram
km Kilometer
kN Kilonewton
Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182, Spring 2022
kPa Kilopascal
g Acceleration due to gravity REFERENCES
g Acceleration due to gravity
L Liter Abdellah, D.; Gueddouda M.K.; Goual, I.; Souli, H.; Ghembaza,
L Liter
LCRS Leachate Collection and RemovalM.S., (2020). Effect of landfill leachate on the hydromechanical
System
LCRS Leachate Collection and Removal System behavior of bentonite-geomaterials mixture. Constr. Build. Mater.,
m
m Meter
Meter 234: 1-15 (15 pages).

m²3 Square meter
Square meter Abramson, L.W.; Lee, T.S.; Sharma, S.; Boyce, G.M., (2002). Slope
stability and stabilization methods. Wiley, New York (736 pages).
m
m3 Cubic meter
Cubic meter
AFNOR, (1992). NF P94-057: Soils recognition and testing-particle
mg
mg 2+ Milligram
Milligram size analysis—sedimentation method. Association Française de
Mg
Mg2+ Magnesium ion
Magnesium ion Normalisation, Paris, France (17 pages).
AFNOR, (1996). NF P94-056: Soils recognition and testing-particle
mn
mn Minute
Minute size analysis—dry sieving method after washing. Ocia. Association
mol
mol Mole Mole Française de Normalisation, Paris, France (15 pages).

PP Pressure AFNOR, (1998). XP P94-047: Soils recognition and testing -


Pressure Determination of matter organic content of a material. Association
Pa
Pa Pascal Pascal Française de Normalisation, Paris, France (6 pages).
Na++
Na Sodium ion Sodium ion AFNOR, (2002). NF P94-051: Soils recognition and testing-
NH4++
NH Ammonium ion Ammonium ion determination of atterberg limits-liquidity limit at the cup-plastic
4 limit rolling. Association Française de Normalisation, Paris, France
PI
PI Plasticity indexPlasticity index (15 pages).
pH
pH Potential hydrogen
Potential hydrogen Ait Saadi, L., (2003) Methodology to control the homogeneity and

ss Second permeability of clayey liners. PhD Thesis, National Institute of


Second Applied Sciences of Lyon (294 pages).
SS Surface of theSurface
sample of the sample Azizi, A.; Malakmohamadi, B.; Jafari, H.R., (2016). Land use and
SC-CL
SC-CL Clayey sand ofClayey
low tosand
medium of low to medium plasticity
plasticity land cover spatiotemporal dynamic pattern and predicting
SO42-2-
SO Sulfate ion Sulfate ion changes using integrated CA-Markov model. Global J. Environ. Sci.
4 Manage., 2(3): 223-234 (12 pages).
tt Time Time Badv, K.; Omidi, A., (2007). Effect of synthetic leachate on the
UTM
UTM Universal
Universal Mercator Mercator Transverse hydraulic conductivity of clayey soil in Urmia city landfill site. Iran.
Transverse
VV Cumulative
Cumulative volume volume of filtrate J. Sci. Technol. Trans. Civ. Eng., 31(5): 535-545 (11 pages).
of filtrate Benna-Zayani, M.; Kbir-Ariguib, N.; Clinard, C.; Bergaya, F., (2001).
VVf Final volume at Final
thevolume at the end of filtration
end of filtration Static filtration of purified sodium bentonite clay suspensions,
f
VFA
VFA Volatile Fatty Volatile
Acids Fatty Acids effect of clay content. Appl. Clay Sci., 19: 103–120 (18 pages).

XX X coordinate Benson, C.H.; Chen, J.N.; Edil T.B., Likos, W.J., (2018). Hydraulic
X coordinate conductivity of compacted soil liners permeated with coal
XRD
XRD X Rays Diffraction
X Rays Diffraction combustion product leachates. J. Geotech. Geoenviron. Eng., 144
YY Y coordinate Y coordinate (4): 3-15 (13 pages).
wl
wl Liquidity limit Liquidity limit Chrétien, M., (2010). Understanding of shrinkage-swelling
mechanisms clay soils: experimental site approach and disaster
wwOPM Optimum water Optimum
content water content analysis on individual constructions. Ph.D. thesis, The University
OPM
wwp Plasticity limitPlasticity limit of Grenoble, France (372 pages).
p
ρρ Bulk density of water Christensen, T.; Kjeldsen, P.; Bjerg, P., (2001). Biogeochemistry of
Bulk density of water landfill leachate plumes. Appl. Geochem., 16 : 659–718 (60
ρρdd Dry density Dry density pages).
ρρss Density of theDensity of the solid particles Cuisinier, O.; Deneele, D.; Masrouri, F.; Abdallah. A.; Conil, N., (2014).
solid particles
Ф’
Ф’ Effective
Effective angle of internal angle of internal frictionImpact of high-pH fluid circulation on long term hydromechanical
friction behaviour and microstructure of compacted clay from the
μμ Viscosity of water
Viscosity of water laboratory of Meuse-Haute Marne (France). Appl. Clay Sci., 88–
μm
μm Micrometer Micrometer 89: 1–9 (9 pages).
Derriche, Z.; Bouzid, F. ; Tas, M.; (1997). Analysis of the shear strength
μS
μS Microsiemens Microsiemens
of a swelling clay. XIVth Conf. Int. Mech. Ground Humburg. 271-
γγdmax
dmax
Maximum dryMaximum
unit weightdry unit weight 274 (4 pages).
sat Saturated density
Saturated density Dutta, J.; Mishra, A.K., (2016). Consolidation behaviour of bentonites
in the presence of salt solutions. Appl. Clay Sci., 120 : 61-69 (9
σ’v
σ’ Effective
Effective vertical stress vertical stress pages).
v
σ’p
σ’ PreconsolidationPreconsolidation
pressure pressure Ehrig, H.-J.; Steigmann, R., (2018). Leachate quality. Solid waste
p
%% Per cent Per cent landfilling : 511-539 (29 pages).
Gratchev, I.; Towhata, I., (2009). Effects of acidic contamination
°° Degree Degree on the geotechnical properties of marine soils in Japan. In

14
181
H.F. Yonli et al.

proceedings of the International Offshore and Polar Engineering and chemical characteristics of leachate-contaminated lateritic
Conference. 151-155 (5 pages). soil. Eng. Geol., 106: 20-25 (6 pages).
Haro, K.; Ouarma, I.; Nana, B.; Bere, A.; Koulidiati, J., (2018). Tabani, P., (1999). Water transfer in deformable soils. PhD thesis,
Characterization and potential recovery of household solid waste National Polytechnic Institute of Lorraine, France (173 pages).
in the city of Ouagadougou (Burkina Faso). J. Environ. Prot. Ecol., Townsend, T.G.; Powell, J.; Jain, P.; Xu, Q.; Tolaymat, T.; Thimothy,
9: 309-324 (16 pages). G., (2015). Sustainable practices for landfill design and operation.
Jambeck, J.-R.; Andino, J.M., (2007). Garbage Juice: Waste New York: Springer Science + Business Media (483 pages).
Management and Leachate Generation. J. Chem. Educ., Ullah, K.A.; Jiang, J.; Wang, P., (2018). Land use impacts on surface
240A-240B (2 pages). water quality by statistical approaches. Global J. Environ. Sci.
Marcoën, J.; Thorez, J.; Monjoie, A.; Tessier, D.; Schroëder, C., Manage., 4(2): 231-250 (20 pages).
(2000). Handbook on natural materials for engineered clay liners Vianney, J.; Martine, K.; Ouattara, Y.; Guinko, S.; Sawadogo, S.,
for landfills and rehabilitation of waste disposals in the walloon (2017). Evaluation of the quality of household waste leachate
region. Office wallon des déchets. treated by settling ponds at the Ouagadougou waste treatment
Mishra, A.K.; Ohtsubo, M.; Li, L.Y.; Higashi, T., (2010). Influence of the and valorization center. J. Environ. Prot., 8: 1567-1582 (16 pages).
bentonite on the consolidation Wagner, J.F., (2013). Clay liners and waste disposal. In Handbook of
behaviour of soil–bentonite mixtures. Carbonates Evaporites. 25: Clay Science. Develop. Clay Sci., 5: 663–676 (14 pages).
43–49 (7 pages). Wdowczyk, A.; Szymańska-Pulikowska A., (2021). Analysis of the
Mitchell, J.; Soga, K., (2005). Fundamentals of soil behavior. John possibility of conducting a comprehensive assessment of landfill
Wiley and Sons (592 pages). leachate contamination using physicochemical indicators and
Naeini, S.A.; Gholampoor, N.; Jahanfar, M.A., (2017). Effect of toxicity test. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf., 221:1-12 (12 pages).
leachate’s components on undrained shear strength of clay- Wang, B.; Xu J.; Chen, B.; Dong, X.; Dou, T., (2019). Hydraulic
bentonite liners, Eur. J. Environ. Civ. Eng.: 395-408 (14 pages). conductivity of geosynthetic clay liners to inorganic waste
Pantet, A.; Monnet, P., (2007). Liquid–solid transition of kaolinite leachate. Appl. Clay Sci., 168: 224-248 (25 pages).
suspensions. Mech. Mater., 39(9): 819-833 (15 pages). Widomski, M.K.; Stępniewski, W.; Musz-Pomorska, A., (2018). Clays
Rosin-Paumier, S.; Touze, N.; Pantet, A., (2011). Impact of a synthetic of different plasticity as materials for landfill liners in rural systems
leachate on permittivity of GCLs measured by filter press and of sustainable waste management. Sustainability. 10: 2489: 1-15
oedopermeameter tests. Geotext. Geomembr., 29: 211-221 (11 (15 pages).
pages). Xu, Y.F.; Matsuoka, H.; Sun, D.A., (2003). Swelling characteristics of
Setz, M.C.; Tian, K.; Benson, C.H.; Bradshaw, S.L., (2017). Effect of fractal-textured bentonite and its mixtures. Appl. Clay Sci., 22:
ammonium on the hydraulic conductivity of geosynthetic clay 197-209 (13 pages).
liners. Geotext. Geomembr. 45(6): 665-673 (9 pages). Yonli, H.F.; Toguyeni, D.Y.K.; Sougoti, M., (2017). Study of the
Sherwood, J.D., (1997). Initial and final stages of compressible influence of a young synthetic leachate on the hydromechanical
filtercake compaction. AlChE J., 43: 1488-1493 (6 pages). properties of a swelling clay. J. Environ. Sci. Eng., B 6: 569-581 (13
Sunil, B.M.; Shrihari, S.; Nayak S., (2009). Shear strength characteristics pages).

AUTHOR (S) BIOSKETCHES


Yonli, H.F., Ph.D., Assistant Professor, 1Laboratoire de Physique et de Chimie de l’Environnement, Université Joseph KI-Zerbo, BP 7021
Ouagadougou 03, Burkina Faso. 2Ecole Supérieure d’Ingénierie, Université de Fada N’Gourma, BP 46 Fada N’Gourma, Burkina Faso.
Email: fabienyonli@yahoo.fr
ORCID: 0000-0002-4981-4705
François, B., Ph.D., Professor, Building Architecture and Town Planning Department, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Avenue F.D. Roos-
evelt 50, CP 194/2, 1050 Bruxelles, Belgique.
Email: bertrand.francois@ulb.be
ORCID: 0000-0001-5075-1222
Toguyeni, D.Y.K., Ph.D., Professor, 1Laboratoire de Physique et de Chimie de l’Environnement, Université Joseph KI-Zerbo, BP 7021
Ouagadougou 03, Burkina Faso. 2Ecole Polytechnique de Ouagadougou, 08 BP 143 Ouagadougou 08, Burkina Faso.
Email: togyen@gmail.com
ORCID: 0000-0001-5306-6095
Pantet, A., Ph.D., Professor, UMR 6294 CNRS, Laboratoire Ondes et Milieux Complexes (LOMC), Normandie Université, UNIHAVRE, 53
rue Prony, 76600 Le Havre, France.
Email: anne.pantet@univ-lehavre.fr
ORCID: 0000-0002-8776-5182

HOW TO CITE THIS ARTICLE


Yonli, H.F.; François, B.; Toguyeni, D.Y.K.; Pantet, A., (2022). Hydro-mechanical behavior of two clayey soils in
presence of household waste leachates. Global J. Environ. Sci. Manage., 8(2): 169-182.
DOI: 10.22034/gjesm.2022.02.02
url: https://www.gjesm.net/article_246026.html

182

You might also like