1 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

nk[ky fnukad % 28@11@2011

uksan.kh fnukad % 28@11@2011
fudky fnukad % 1@12@2014
dkyko/kh % o”kZ efguk fnol
03 00 03

ckjkerh ;s F khy iz F keoxZ U;k;na M kf/kdkjh];ka p s U;k;ky;kr

¼fiBklu vf/kdkjh% Jherh-,l-ds- nqxkaodj ½

js - QkS - [k-dz - 393@2011 fu'kk.kh dz-

egkjk”Vz ljdkj] ½
rQsZ ckjkerh 'kgj iksyhl LVs'ku ½ vf;ksxi{k
rk- ckjkerh] ftYgk- iq.ks- ½
½
fo:)

1 vfHkeku daBk mQZ pand z kar yks<a s ½

o;23%] /kank % etwjh ½
jk- vkejkbZ ckjkerh ft-iq.ks ½
2 fot; ek:rh dlcs ½
o;& 25 /kank etwjh ½
jk- vkejkbZ ckjkerh ft-iq.ks ½ vkjksih
3 lkS-jk/kk fot; dlcs ½
o; 26 /kank etwjh ½
jk- vkejkbZ ckjkerh ft-iq.ks ½
4 lkS- jatuk vfHkeku yks<a s ½
o; 22 /kank etwjh ½
jk- vkejkbZ ckjkerh ft-iq.ks ½
5 daBk mQZ pand z kar xqykc yks<s ½
o; 44 /kank etwjh ½
jk- vkejkbZ] ckjkerh- ft-iq.ks- ½

ljdkj rQsZ ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk Jh- ,l-;q- ukbZdoMs -

vkjksihrQsZ odhy Jh- ,-,e-dkGs odhy-
 2 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

U;k;fu.kZ ;
¼ fudky fn- 1 fMlascj]2014½

1- vkjksihfo:) Hkkjrh; naMfo/kku ps dye 143] 147]

148]326]323]504 vkf.k 506 lg 149 izek.ks f'k{ksl ik=
vijk/kkdjhrk nks”kkjksi Bso.;kr vkysys vkgsr-

2- vfHk;ksxi{kkph [kVY;kph FkksMD;kr gdhdr v'kh vkgs

dh] fQ;kZnh ukes nknk yks<a s gs fn- 18-4-2010 jksth ldkGh 9-30
P;k lqekjkl R;kaP;k jkgrs ?kjkrwu vkuanuxj fl/nkFkZuxj jksMus
ik;h ,dVsp xgw vk.k.;kl pkyys gksrs- R;kapk eqyxk xksdG
q gk
eksjksiar 'kkGstoG jLR;koj irax mMohr gksrk Eg.kwu R;kl Eg.kkys
dh] ßek;?kY;k vH;kl dj] ?kjh tkÞ] vls Eg.krkp jLR;koj
vlysyh ckbZ ukes fueZyk daBk yksa<s fgus xSjlet d#u ?ksryk- fryk
okVys dh] fQ;kZnh frykp f'kohxkG djhr vkgsr- frus vkjMkvksjMk
dsyk o f'kohxkG d# ykxyh- R;keqGs ?kjkckgsj lnj ckbZpk eqyxk o
tkobZ gs vkys- R;kauh i.k fQ;kZnhl f'kohxkG dsyh- R;kuarj fL=;kauh
fQ;kZnhl gkrkus ekjgk.k dj.;kl lq#okr dsyh- R;kosGh vkjksih ukes
vfHkeku daBk gkrkr ryokj ?ksowu vkyk- R;kus ryokjhus fQ;kZnhP;k
gkrkP;k iatkoj o xqM?;kP;k [kkyh] MkO;k ik;kl o Nkrhoj
ryokjhus ekjgk.k dsyh- fQ;kZnh vksjMr vlrkuk fQ;kZnhl L=h;kauh
idMwu iGw fnys ukgh- R;kosGh fotw dlcs gk gkrkr LVEi ?ksowu
vkyk- R;kusgh MksD;kP;k ekxhy cktwl LVWEius ekjys- R;keqGs
MksD;krwu o t[kekrwu jDr ;sr gksr-s fQ;kZnhl thos ek#u Vkdk] vls
 3 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

fueZykckbZ tksjkr vksjMr gksrh- R;kosGh fQ;kZnh okpok okpok vls

vksjMr vlrkuk fQ;kZnhl okpo.kslkBh fgjkckbZ ukjk;.k xk;dokM o
t;kckbZ xtkuu o fodh xk;dokM ;kauh ;sowu fQ;kZnhl lksMfoys-
R;kosGh fQ;kZnhl ekj.kkjs rsFkwu iGwu xsy-s fQ;kZnhl pDdj vkyh o
yksdkauh flYOgj T;qfcyh gkWLihVy ckjkerh ;sFks nk[ky dsy-s lcc
fQ;kZnhus ckjkerh 'kgj iksyhl LVs'ku ;sFks vkjksihafo#/n rdzkj fnyh-

3- ojhy izek.ks fnysY;k rdzkjho:u iksyhl Bk.ks ckjkerh ;sFks

vkjksihfo:/n Hkk-n-fo-dye 326]143]147]148]149]323]504 o
506 dyekUo;s f'k{kslik= xqUg;kdjhrk vijk/k dz-81@10 nk[ky
dj.;kr vkyk- xqUg;kpk rikl rikfld vaeynkjkdMs lksifo.;kr
vkyk- rikfld vaeynkjkus riklknjE;ku ?kVukLFkG iapukek o tIrh
iapukek dsyk] lk{khnkjkaps tckc uksanfoys- rikl iq.kZ d:u vkjksihaP;k
fojks/kkr iqjkok vk<Gwu vkY;kus vkjksihfo:n/k U;k;ky;ke/;s
nks”kkjksii= nk[ky dsy-s

4- vkjksihfo:) fu-20 izek.ks Hkk- n- fo- dye 143]

147]148]326]323]504]506 lg dye 149 vUo;s f'k{kslik=
vijk/kkdjhrk nks”kkjksi Bsoys- rs nks”kkjksi R;kauk R;kps Hkk”ksr okpqu
letkoqu lkafxrys- R;koj R;kauh xqUgk ukdcqy d:u laijh{ksph ekx.kh
dsyh- laifj{ksnjE;ku vfHk;ksx i{kkus dsoG fQ;kZnh gk ,d lk{khnkj
riklyk-

5- vkjksihfo:) dks.krkgh xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok u vkY;kus

 4 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

vkjksihps QkS-iz-la-dye 313 izek.ksps tckc uksanfoys ukgh-

6- vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ ljdkjh odhy Jh- ,l-;w-ukbZdokMs o

vkjksihaps odhy Jh-,-,e-dkGs ;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sdyk- vfHk;ksxi{kkph
gfddr fopkjkr ?ksrk iw<hy eqn~ns ek>s fopkjkf/ku vkys- miyC/k iqjkok
y{kkr ?ksrk eh R;koj ek>s fu”d”kZ R;k[kkyh fnysY;k dkj.kfeekall
s g
uksanfoys vkgsr--

eq n ns fu”d”kZ

1 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk; dh]fn-

18-1-10 jksth ldkGh 9-30 oktrkvkuanuxj
rs fl/nkFkZuxj jLR;koj vkejkbZ ckjkerh ;sFks ukgh-
vkjksih dz-1 rs 5 gs csdk;nk tekokps lnL;
gksaras T;kapk ,df=r mn~n's k fQ;kZnh nknk yksa<s
o lk{khnkjkauk ekjgk.k]f'kohxkG o nenkVh
dj.ks gk gksark \
2 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk;
dh]vkjksihauh csdk;nk teko teowu ukgh-
vukf/kdkjkus R;kaP;k ,df=r mn~n's kkP;k
iwrhZlkBh lnj fBdk.kh fQ;kZnh nknk
yksa<as ;kapos j cGkpk okij d:u naxk dsyk \
3 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk;
dh]vkjksiha csdk;nk tekokps lnL; gksrs o ukgh-
R;kposGh rs ryokjhlkj[;k ?kkrd
'kL=kus ;qDr gksrs] ts xqUg;kps gR;kj Eg.kwu
okijY;kl e`R;ql dkj.khHkwr gksow 'kdrs \
4 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk;
dh]vkjksihauh csdk;nk teko teowu ukgh-
 5 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

R;kaP;k ,df=r mn~n's kkP;k iwrhZlkBh fQ;kZnh

nknk yksa<S ;kauk ryokj o LVEius ekjgk.k
d#u xaHkhj nq[kkir dsyh \
5 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk; dh]
vkjksihauh csdk;nk teko teowu ukgh
R;kaP;k ,df=r mn~n's kkP;k iwrhZlkBh fQ;kZnh
nknk yksa<s ;kauk ykFkkcqDD;kauh ekjgk.k d:u
nq[kkir dsyh \
6 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk;
dh]R;kaP;k ,df=r mn~n's kkP;k iwrhZlkBh
vkjksihauh csdk;nk teko teowu fQ;kZnh nknk ukgh-
yksa<s ;kauk f'kohxkG d:u iz{kksfHkr dsys
T;k;ksxs vls iz{kksHku R;kl lkoZtfud
'kkarrspk Hkax dj.;kl fdaok brj dks.krkgh
xqUgk dj.;kl izo`Rr djsy \
7 vfHk;ksx i{k vls 'kkchr djrks dk;
dh]R;kaP;k ,df=d mn~n's kkP;k iwrhZlkBh
vkjksihauh csdk;nk teko teowu fQ;kZnh nknk ukgh-
yksa<s ;kauk thos ekj.;kph /kedh nsowu
QkStnkjh /kkdniV'kk dsyk \
8 Dk; vkns'k \ vkjksihaph funksZ”k
eqDrrk dj.;kr
;sr vkgs-

dkj.kfeeka l k

7- vkjksihfo:) nks”kkjksi fl) dj.;kdjhrk vfHk;ksx i{kkus

izdj.kke/;s QDr ,dp lk{khnkj riklyk vkgs- lk{khnkj dz-1 nknk
mRre yksa<s gs fQ;kZnh vlwu R;kauk fu- dz 30 oj rikl.;kr vkys
vkgs-
 6 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

eq n ~ n s dz - 1 rs 7 djhrk %

8- mijksDr loZ eqn~ns gs ijLij laca/khr vlysus rlsp

R;kojhy iqjkok ns[khy ,dlkj[kkp vlysus iqujko`Rrh VkG.;kdjhrk
eh rs ,d= ppsZdjhrk /ksrys vkgs-

fQ;kZnhus R;kaP;k iqjkO;k njE;ku ?kVuk pkj rs ikp o”kkZio

q hZ
?kMY;kps lkafxrys- fQ;kZnh iq<s tkowu dFku djrks dh rks xkMho:u
iMyk gksrk- R;kapk o vkjksihapk okn vlY;kus xSjletqrhrwu fQ;kZn
nk[ky fQ;kZnhus dsY;kps dFku dsys vkgs- R;kauh lnj fQ;kZnhojhy
QDr vaxB;kP;k B'kkO;frfjDr dks.krkgh etdqj dFku dsyy
s k ukgh-
fQ;knh fQ;kZnhrhy etdqjkckcr ekfgrh ulysps lkaxrkr-

9- fQ;kZnhus vfHk;ksx i{kkl lgdk;Z u dsY;kus ljdkjh

ofdykauh R;kapk myVrikl ?ksryk- vfHk;ksx i{kkps myVriklke/;s
fQ;kZnhus fQ;kZnoj vaxBk dsY;kps ekU; dsys vkgs- ijarq] vkjksihauh
ryokjhus]LVEius rlsp ykFkkcqDD;kauh ekjgk.k dsY;kps rlsp
f'kohxkG dsY;kps rs ekU; djhr ukghr- ljdkjh odhykauh vkjksihauh
csdk;nk teko d#u fQ;kZnhl ekjgk.k]f'kohxkG o thos
ekj.;kph /kedh fnyh vlY;kps fQ;kZnhl lwpfoys vlrk R;kauh
lnjph lwpd fo/kkus Li”Vi.ks ukdkjysyh vkgsr- ijarw R;kph vkjksiha'kh
rMtksM >kY;kps rks ekU; djrks-
 7 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

10- fQ;kZnh o vkjksihae/;s rMtksM >kyh vlwu R;kizek.ks

R;kauh fu- 32 oj rMtksM iqjf'kl nk[ky dsyh vkgs- lnjph ckc
fQ;kZnhP;k vfHk;ksxi{kkP;k myVriklkr ns[khy Li”V vkgs- fQ;kZnhpk
iqjkok R;kaph vkjksihaP;k fojks/kkr dlyhgh rdzkj ukgh vls n'kZforks--

11- cpkoi{kkus izdj.kkrhy ?kVukLFkG iapukek fu-dz-34] tIrh

iapukek fu-dz-35 oj ekU; dsys vkgsr- lk{khnkjakph oS|dh; izek.ki=
fu-36 oj ekU; dsyh vkgsr- vkjksihaP;k rkC;krwu ,d ryokj o LVEi
vls tIr >kY;kps ;ko:u fnlrs- rlsp oS|dh; izek.ki=gh fQ;kZnhl
t[kek >kY;kps fl) djrkr- ijarq tsFks fQ;kZnh vkjksihauh ekjgk.k
dsyh ulY;kps lkaxrkr rsFks vkjksihaP;k rkC;krqu gR;kjkaph tIrh gh
xqUgk fl) dj.l;kl iqj's kh ukghr-

12- fQ;kZnh o vkjksih ;kauh fu-32 oj R;k vuq”kaxkus rMtksM

iqjf'kl ns[khy nk[ky dsyh vkgs- ;ko:u fQ;kZnh o vkjksihe/;s
rMtksM >kyh vlY;kus fQ;kZnh vkjksihfojks/kkr iqjkok ns.;kl bPNqd
ukgh vls fnlrs- miyC/k iqjkO;kpk fopkj djrk fn- 18-1-10 jksth
ldkGh 9-30 oktrk vkuanuxj rs fl/nkFkZuxj jLR;koj vkejkbZ
ckjkerh ;sFks vkjksiha gs csdk;nk tekokps lnL; gksars o a
T;kapk ,df=r mn~n's k fQ;kZnh nknk yksa<s o lk{khnkjkauk
ekjgk.k]f'kohxkG o nenkVh d#u /kedh fnY;kckcr dkghgh fu”iUu
gksr ukgh- fQ;kZnh ;kauk loZ vkjksihauh ryokj] LVEius rlsp
ykFkkcqDD;kus ekjgk.k d:u nq[kkir dsyh] f'kohxkG d:u iz{kksfHkr
dsys fdaok thos ekj.;kph /kedh fnyh gs ns[khy fl) dj.;kl
 8 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

vfHkys[kkojhy iqjkok iqjal

s k ukgh- ;kdkeh fQ;kZZnh o vkjksihe/;s
rMtksM >kY;kus vfHk;ksxi{kkus brj lk{khnkj riklysy
s s ukghr- rlsp
iap lk{khnkjkaph lk{k uksanfo.;kr vkysyh ukgh- vkjksihauh fQ;kZnhl
ekjgk.k d:u t[keh dsys rlsp fQ;kZnhl f'kohxkG dsyh o nenkVh
d:u thos ekj.;kph /kedh fnyh gs vkjksi vfHk;ksx i{k 'kkchr d:
'kdys ukghr- R;keqGs vkjksihfo:) dks.krkgh iqjkok vfHkys[kkoj ukgh
djhrk eqn~nk dz 1 rs 7 ojhy fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ uksanfor vkgs-

eq n ~ n k dz - 8 djhrk %

13- vfHk;ksx i{k vkjksihfo:) xqUgk fl) dj.;kl vi;'kh

Bjyk vkgs- lcc eqn~nk dz- 1 rs 7 ps fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ uksanfoY;keqGs
vkjksih gs funksZ”k eqDrrk gks.;kl ik= vkgsr- lcc eqn~nk dz- 8 pk
fu”d”kZ uksanfo.;klkBh eh iq<hy vkns'k ikfjr djhr vkgs-

vkns ' k
1- loZ vkjksihaph Hkkjrh; naM fo/kku lafgrkps dye 143]147]
148]326]323]504 o 506 lg 149 izek.ks f'k{ksl ik=
vijk/kkrqu QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk dye 248 ¼1½ vUo;s
funksZ”k eqDrrk dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-

2- vkjksihaps QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk dye 437&v vUo;s ?ks.;kr

vkysY;k ca/ki=kaO;frfjDr brj tkehuca/ki=s jn~n dj.;kr ;sr
vkgsr-
 9 js-QkS-[k-Dz- 393@2011

3- eqnnseky ryokjh gs 'kL= vlY;kus mifoHkkxh;

naMkf/kdkjh ;kapd
s Ms vfiykps dkyko/khuarj fu;ekuqlkj foYgsokV
yko.;kdjhrk ikBfo.;kr ;koh o tIr LVEi ;kaph fdaer'kwU;
vlY;kus vfiykps eqnrhuarj fu;ekizek.ks foYgsokV
yko.;kr ;koh-

U;k;fu.kZ; [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr ?kksf”kr dj.;kr vkyk-

fn- 01@12@2014 ¼ ,l-ds nqxkaodj ½

ckjkerh izFkeoxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
¼dksVZ dz-5½] ckjkerh

I affirms that the contents of this  P.D.F  file judgment are 

same word for word as per original judgment.
Name of Steno      :M.G.Attar 
Court name         :Hon'ble Smt. S.K.Dugaonkar 
          J.M.F.C.Baramati
Date:              :01 .12.2014
Judgment signed by 
presiding officer on :01 .12.2014 
Judgment uploaded on  :04.12.2014