Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nature and Scope of Auditing
Nature and Scope of Auditing
P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
It should be appreciated that audit ‘is a logical process. It involves’ the conduct of logical
procedures, designed to obtain audit evidence (information and expatiations), which provide
a basis for drawing conclusions on which the auditors bases his opinion on the financial
information.
management).
ii. The matters to be addressed in the auditor’s report are dictated by the terms of the
auditors’ appointment and any relevant statutory and professional matters that the
FEATURES OF AN AUDIT
i. Understanding the nature of the business of the client, its operating environment, its
organizational structure, its method of operation, and its accounting policies and
Agreement etc.
1
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
* Visiting the clients operating premises, and reviewing relevant technical manuals in
* Obtaining and reviewing the organizational chart and the administrative manual of
* Ascertaining the addresses of registered offices, other offices and factories, as well as
which affect the enterprise. * Obtaining and reviewing copies of important agreements,
service contracts, loan agreements, technical service agreement, lease agreements etc.
ii. Determining that audit strategy, including the nature, timing and extent of the audit
work by:
2
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
* Observing procedures.
* Organisational charts.
OBJECTIVES OF AUDITING
1. Primary Objective: This is for the auditor to form and express an opinion to the truth
and fairness of the financial statement for any person reading them to have belief in
them.
a. To ensure that the financial statement before him comply with any relevant
statutory requirement
3
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
ADVANTAGES OF AUDIT
3. Prevention of fraud
DISADVANTAGES OF AUDIT
1. Audit fees: For every audit work, an auditor is entitled to some amount of money
known as audit fees. This might be according to professional scale of fees; the client
is requested to pay a huge amount as audit fee which he might develop the fair to pay
such amount.
2. Time Consuming: Audit work consumes considerably too much time as it is a logical
process, and it involve the conduct of logical procedures, base on the specialized view
4
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
he audits the company’s account, in other words nothing is hidden to him as the
financial status of the organization will be known to you, and hence there is no
4. Identification of faults
TYPES OF AUDIT
1. Private Audit: This is a type of audit that is carried out on the request of the
interested party. It is not compulsory for sole trader and partnership business to audit
their account, but if they wanted to, they will make an arrangement with the auditor,
2. Statutory Audit: A statutory audit arises under the Companies and Allied Matters
Act (CAMA) 1990, as a result of which it has become statutory obligation for the
3. Interim Audit: At this audit, the workdone is mainly internal control evaluation which is
related to system audit work by recording the system of accounting, evaluating strengths and
4. Final or Completed Audit: The auditor conducts the final audit after the end of the
financial year by completing the compliance testing, verification of all assets and liabilities,
5
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
5. Continuous Audit: Are those audit works carried out on continuous basis – monthly,
quarterly or bi-annually. Any audit work not carried out yearly could be related to continous
audit
6. Procedural Audit
7. Management Audit
Access To Books
The auditor of a company has a right of access, at all items to the books and accounts
and voucher of the company, whether kept at the head office of the right of access to
books etc is an absolute right and is not subject to any restriction exception or
qualification. This means that the auditor can examine the books vouchers etc at any
Right of Inspection
It is a right of the auditor that he can inspect the record of the company at any time. He
can visit without any notice and verify the cash or any document.
Right of Information
The auditor has the right to obtain any information and explanation from the officers or
directors of the company as he may think necessary for the performance of his duties as
necessary for the performance of his duties as auditor. He may report to the members
accordingly.
6
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Access to Branches
The auditor has a right to visit the branch office of the company if any, if a duly qualified
auditor has not audited the accounts of company branch and if he deems it necessary to
Receiving Notices
A company auditor has a right to receive all notices and other communications relating
to any general meeting of the company, which any member of the company is either to
The auditor has a right to attend any general meeting and to be heard there at any part of
the business, which concerns him as auditor, however, the right to attend a general
Report to Member
The auditor has a right to make a report to the members on the account examined by him
and to state whether the said account give the information required by the companies act
The auditor has a right to sign the auditor's report or authenticate any other document of
the company.
The auditor has a right to seek opinions of experts in different fields whenever he feels it
7
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Receive Remuneration
The auditor has a right to receive remuneration for auditing the accounts of the company
after he has completed the work of audit even if he is dismissed in the middle he has a
Speak
The auditor has a right that he can speak in the annual general meeting for the
explanation of some matters, which are related, with the accounts of business.
Present in Meeting
For the safeguard of his right, the auditor has a right to remain present in the meetings of
the company. Sometimes the business accounts may not be presented before the
shareholders for the approval. In this time the auditor can protect himself.
Opinion
The auditor has also a right to consult the experts for some matters. In order to clear the
doubt, he may get the help of the technical services. So the auditor has also a right to
Correction
The auditor has also a right of correction. He can make correction in the written or
spoken matters. Even that he can make a revised statement if he founds any written
mistake in it.
Representation
The auditor has also a right to defend himself if he is asked to leave the office in the
8
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Important Note
It is clear that the right of an auditor cannot be limited either by the articles of
9
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
1. Professionally Competent
knowledge of the accountancy. To understand the accounting details, he can apply his
2. Honest
This is the personal quality of an auditor. He should have the high moral standard. It
is his duty to report on the fact basis. The auditor must be honest and sincere with his
profession. He is not responsible to sign any paper which is no correct under his
observation.
3. Up to Date Knowledge
1979, sales tax and excise act and wealth tax etc this is helpful in checking the correct
10
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
6. Intelligent
in reasoning
7. Qualification
auditor.
8. Tactful
comment and criticize the policies of management. In case of missing, can collect it
9. Maintain Secrecy
keen competition and if the auditor does not care of the secrecy of the business, then
the client of the auditor has to face a lot of difficulties. So, the auditor must maintain
10. Patience
It is also the personal quality of auditor when any document is received by him he
cannot make hurry to sign it or express or implied promise to provide the proof later
on. In spite of it, he personality check the records to know the true views.
The attitude of an auditor must be positive. By this quality he can get the desirable
11
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Auditor should be bold and courageous person. Any authority should not influence
him. He should possess the courage to face the differences in opinion between him
13. Courteous
It is an important quality, which the auditor should possess. His attitude towards the
staff of client should be very humble and polite. He should also stress on his own
The auditor has a quality of preparing the budget. According to the facts and figures
of the Previous year, the estimates are established for the next year. The auditor can
check that these budgets are according to their facts and corrects.
Personal Qualities
15. Independence
management interference.
16. Vigilance
This is also the quality of an auditor. By this quality the auditor can discover the
errors and frauds. The auditor can also watch and check that if accounting staff has
12
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
made any fraud or error. Because he has to be alert minded so that he cannot avoid
17. Judgement
depreciation, provision for bad debts, inventory valuation. The auditor can apply
prescribed areas.
An auditor must have common sense. He can make difference between essential and
non-essential information. An item, which can influence the decision of other people,
19. Prudence
and techniques. There is a need to use prudence for guiding the businessman when he
is asked to do so.
20. Practical
An auditor must have practical training. He can seek training in the field of finance,
An auditor must have qualities of self-control. The balance work shows regular
13
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
progress on the part of audit. There is no over work or less work every day. A
discipline is created in every work. The quality of audit work is improved due to
discipline.
22. Initiative
An auditor must have the quality of initiative. He can start and complete an audit
work without any help. The auditor must have experience, qualification and courage
to complete the auditor work. He has courage to deal with audit work even in difficult
situations.
23. Leadership
An auditor must have leadership. He is the working under his leadership. He must
have communication ability. He can motivate and control the audit staff. As a team
political conditions. He is also aware of the latest knowledge, which affects the
business concern.
The auditor should also aware of the use of computer in the business for getting the
information. He is must also trained in handling the data through the computers
requirements. These requirements define the context within which auditors conduct their
14
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
The companies and Allied Matters Decree, 1990 is the principal source of statutory matters
Nigeria (ICAN).
APPOINTMENT OF AUDITOR
Whenever any person starts his business, he wants to keep an account whether he is
of sole trader or partnership, it may not be necessary to audit their accounts because of their
less sales or whatever the case may be but Audit of Annual Accounts of a company is
Every company shall at each annual general meeting appoint an auditor or auditors to
audit the financial statements of the company, and to hold office from the conclusion of that,
until the conclusion of the next, next annual general meeting. S.357 (1). CAMA 1990. Since
15
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
the auditors are appointed by the shareholders at the AGM, they are therefore independent of
Why Audit of Companies is Necessary: Those who carry on business with the other
accountancy demands specialized skill. Shareholders are generally laymen. Thus there arises
a need of an agency to stand in between the shareholders and management. The agency, viz.,
statutory auditors, should be technically qualified for the job and should be independent, and
able to withstand the pressure of management. It is because of this law demands for skillful
and independent auditor, who is appointed by the shareholders of the company so that they
REAPPOINTMENT OF AUDITORS
2. He has given the company notice, in writing, of his unwillingness to continue as auditor;
3. A resolution has been passed at an annual general meeting appointing somebody or stating
certificate has to be obtained from the person concerned stating that the appointment or
16
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
RESIGNATION OF AUDITOR
An auditor may resign before his term of office expires by depositing a notice in
writing to that effect at the company's registered office. His resignation becomes effective on
the date he lodges such notice or on such later date as may be specified in the notice.
The Board of Directors of the Company has no power to remove an auditor appointed
by the company in general meeting, i.e., the auditors can be removed only by the company in
general meeting and prior approval from the Central Government is also necessary for such
removal of the auditors. He also has a right to make written representation on the matter to
REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS
The Board fixes the remuneration of the First Auditors. Where the auditor is
appointed or re-appointed by the general meeting, the remuneration is fixed by the general
Central Government is approached for appointing the auditor, the Government fixes the
Director)The remuneration fixed for an auditor is inclusive of all expenses allowed to him so
that he cannot claim any amount additional to the remuneration fixed either as expenses or
otherwise.
Statutorily and ethically, only individual possessing the requisite knowledge and skill
can be appointed as auditor of the company. The auditor should be independent in carrying
17
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
out his work so that he is able to give an unbiased opinion based on an objective assessment
of facts. Thus, he should have no interest, financial or otherwise and whether directly or
indirectly, in the company and/or its management. A person, who is Chartered Accountant
within the meaning of Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 and holds a certificate of practice, or
a partnership firm where of all the partners are Chartered Accountants holding certificates of
practice, may be appointed as auditor of a company. S. 358(1). However, in the latter case,
the appointment as an auditor may be made in the firm name and any of its partners may act
in the name of the firm. The following persons cannot be appointed as auditor of a Company
according S. 358(2)
the company;
3. Any person who is indebted to a company for a sum exceeding Rs. 1,000/- or who have
guaranteed to the company on behalf of another person for a sum exceeding Rs. 1,000/-.
4. A person who is holding any security of that company, after a period of one year from the
18
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
AUDIT PLANNING
Although all audits will have precisely the same objective, ‘lamely, to report to the
interested parties on the result of audit undertaken within the content of an engagement it is
nevertheless true that the detailed manner in which the audit is conducted will largely
For the audit objective to be achieved a systematic approach to the task is essential and,
although all aspects of audit work are closely interrelated, it is convenient to distinguish the
essential phases through which the audit develops. In summary an audit plan is a statement
setting out the audit objectives and the strategies to be adopted in achieving the objectives.
Planning ensures that there are no gaps or duplications in the audit work, every member of
staff understands what is required of him and the key control areas identified so that attention
The auditor’s operational standards require the auditor to adequately plan the audit. The
Planning enables the auditor to determine the audit objective and strategy of
Planning focuses attention on high risk and critical areas of the audit.
Enables the auditor to determine his staffing requirement and other resources to be
19
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Planning facilitate audit review by managers and partners. Planning is all evidence of
PLANNING PROCEDURE
The planning procedure to adopt for an audit is a function of whether it is a first audit
or an existing audit. If it is a first audit and being taken over from an existing professional
colleague, the auditors must ensure compliance with ethical guide on change of professional
engagement. This requires that the incoming auditor should seek necessary professional
The approach for planning an old audit is essentially a review and an update of information
To ensure that the audit is planned, efficiently and effectively, the auditor must, from the
The operating environment, with due attention to the legal, political, economic and
Recent events in tile economy and within the enterprise that have implication for the
The organisational structure of the enterprise and the existence of any related parties.
The nature of the accounting system, accounting records and internal control in
Matters noted in the prior period audits which have relevance to the current year’s
audit.
20
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
out the information obtained and the decisions taken as a result of the audit planning effort.
The APM is used to communicate information about the audit engagement and the audit plan
to members of the audit team. It also serves as a record of the audit plan for future reference.
- Information relating to the accounting system, records and the internal controls of
the enterprise
- The analyses of the audit risk and the audit approach. This may be either a
21
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
- Timing of the audit visits including interim, final and attendance at stock take.
iv Audit programmes- This will include both compliance and substantive audit
programme for all aspects of the financial statements including share capital, reserves
and long term liabilities, purchase and creditors, sales as debtors, cash and bank
AUDIT BUDGET
audit assignment. This will enable the auditor to determine the profitability of the audit
- The audit cost budget - The cost arrived at under the time rate analysis
22
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
- It provides a basis for measuring performance. The analysis of variance can assist in
The audit budget may not be met because of the following reasons:
- Attitude of the member of the audit team may be responsible for adverse valiance in
audit budget.
Basis for charging fees: Audit fees are to be charged based on the effective changed based
on tile graduated rate on turnover of the company, whichever is agreeable to by the company.
The likely problems that; could be encountered in implement lug audit plans include the
following:
- The shortage of qualified staff. This may be done to unanticipated high turnover of staff
in the film.
23
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
systems etc.
- Changes in government policies and professional guidelines that affect the business of the
enterprise.
Steps that may be taken to minimize the above problems include:
- Constant liaison with the management of the enterprises to ascertain development and
- The auditor should keep the management informed of pending audit visits.
- The auditor should monitor the environment to anticipate governments legislation and
accountancy pronouncement.
- The auditor should consider the rate of turnover of staff and the firms requirement
24
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
The Auditors Operating Standard states that the auditor should adequately plan
control and record his work. The principles of quality control apply to all organisations
carrying out independent audits whether in the private or the public sector.
The principles of audit control are applicable not only to auditing but to the entire
range of professional services provided by a firm. Quality control is the means by which a
firm obtains reasonable assurance that its expression of audit opinions always reflects
observance of approved auditing standards, any statutory or contractual requirement and any
professional standards set by the firm itself. Quality control should also promote observance
The objectives of quality control procedures are the same for all firms. It is important for
all firms to put in place a functional quality control process. For each firm, the exact nature
and extent of the procedures needed will depend on its size and the nature of its practice, the
number of its officers and its organization. The main features of the procedures include:
communicate them to all partners and relevant staff and to other professionals
employed by the firm in the course of its audit practice. This should normally involve
considered in given to the firm’s independence and its ability to provide an adequate
service to the client. The firm should determine what information is needed to
25
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
committee.
3. Professional Ethics: There should be procedures within the firm to ensure that all
integrity and confidentiality, set out in the ethical statements issued by the institute.
These procedures include providing guidance particularly to those staff who are not
members of the Institute, resolving questions on the above principles and monitoring
compliance with them. For smaller firms in particular, it may be appropriate that the
task of guiding staff ill these areas should be allotted to a particular partner. If for
Skills and competence - The firm’s partners and staff should have attained the skills and
competence required to fulfill their responsibilities. This involves Procedures relating to:
a. Recruitment
Staff should be informed of the firm’s procedures for example by means of manuals and
updated.
necessary expertise in specialized areas and industries, involves both planning for staffing
needs and determining criteria for recruitment based on such needs. Such criteria should be
26
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
designed to ensure that cost considerations do not deter the firm from recruitment of audit
Technical Training and Updating: All partners and staff should be required to keep
themselves technically up-to-date on matters that are relevant to their work. The firm should
relevant legislation.
The methods of implementing the above procedure may vary according to the size of the
firm, for example, a smaller can ensure that it has copies of essential reference books
smaller firm I Hit ran be acquired from various professional bodies and commercial
sources: and Co operative arrangements with other firms can help meet training needs.
should be the opportunity for on-the-job training and professional development. This should
provide staff with exposure to difference types of audit anti with the opportunity to work
with more experienced members of the team who should be main responsible for the
supervision and review of the work of junior staff. It is important that the performance of
27
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
staff on audits is evaluated and that the results of these assessments are communicated to the
staff concerned, given the opportunity for staff to respond to comments made for any action
to be agreed.
guidelines on controlling are effective for every audit; reference of technical problems
to designated specialists within the firm, and procedures for resolving matters of
judgement. For smaller firms, and particularly for sole practitioners, Consultation with
other practitioner or with any relevant professional advisory service may be a suitable
5. Monitoring the firm’s Procedures: The firm should monitor the effectiveness of its
application of the quality control procedures outlined above. This monitoring process
standards of the firm are being properly and effectively carried out.
This process should include periodic review of a sample of the firm’s audit files by
a. Have procedures for select ion of particulars audits for review and for the frequency,
b. Set the levels of competence for the partners and staff who are to participate in review
activities.
28
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
c. Establish procedures to resolve disagreements, which may arise between the reviewers
It should be borne in mind that the purpose of this independent review is to provide an
assessment of the overall standards of the firm, and is to provide quite separate from the
purposes of the earlier review procedures referred to in consultation which are carried out by
member of the audit team to provide control over the individual audit.
Where in the smaller firm, impendent review within the firm is not possible, identifying
potential problem area. Alternatively, an independent and objective ways for monitoring the
AUDIT EVIDENCE
Audit evidence refers to all the information obtained by the auditor by the conduct of
compliance and substantive procedures from which he draws conclusions on which he bases
his opinion on the financial statements. The auditor’s operational standard requires the
The quantum of audit evidence needed to achieve the required level of assurance necessary to
form; in opinion is a question for the auditor to determine by exercising his judgement in the
light of tile opinion called for under the terms of his engagement. Generally, the judgement
29
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Accordingly, audit evidence is considered relevant where it enables the auditor to draw
In relation to compliance procedure relevant audit evidence are those, which enable the
a. Controls exist;
In relation to substantive procedures relevant audit evidence are those, which enable the
auditor to decide:
- Whether a transaction or an event which pertains to the enterprise took place during
the period.
- Whether an asset or a liability or a transaction has been omitted from the records.
30
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
The reliability of audit evidence is influenced by its source-internal and external and by its
nature - visual, documentary or oral. While being dependent on the circumstances under
which it is obtained, the following generalizations are used in assessing the reliability of
audit evidence;
- External evidence, for example confirmation received from a third party, is more
- Evidence obtained by the auditor himself is more reliable than that obtained from the
enterprise.
- Evidence in the form of document and written representation is more reliable than
oral representation.
The distinction between compliance and substantive tests derive from their objectives.
Compliance tests are those tests, which seek to provide audit evidence as to whether
controls are being applied as prescribed. Substantive tests on the other hand, are those audit
tests, including analytical review procedures, which seek to provide audit evidence regarding
t lie completeness, accuracy and time validity of transactions and balances included in the
degrees of reliability depending upon their nature and source. The inspection of
tangible assets provides the auditor with reliable audit evidence as to the existence of
31
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
provides the auditor with reliable audit evidence as to tile manner of the performance
of the process or procedure at the time of observation but not at any other time.
The degree of reliability that the auditor attaches to evidence obtained in this manner
- Analytical review procedures- These include the study of significance radios, trends
and other statistic and investigating any unusual or unexpected variations. The auditor
obtained from within the enterprise, will provide tile audit with a reasonable basis for
drawing conclusions.
It is important for the auditor to obtain third pa.rty evidence in addition to that obtained,
entirely from within the enterprise because such audit evidence tend to be more objective
32
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
than that which is obtained solely from within the company alone. In certain circumstances,
third party audit evidence may be more authoritative than evidence obtained from within the
actuaries.
The reliability of the valuation of assets carried out by specialist valuers is dependent oil the
skills and experience of the valuers, their independence and objectivity as well as their
integrity. The reliability will also be influenced by the objective of the valuation and the
The auditor will also consider the assumptions made by the valuer for consistency with other
He should also check the computation carried out by the valuer in arriving that his valuation
- The physical verification of the land and buildings to ascertain their ‘existence.
- The examination of title deeds and certificate of occupancy to ascertain the ownership
- The auditor on should review depreciation policies on the building to ensure that the
- The auditor should ascertain whether the land and buildings are free of third party
lien.
33
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
the debtors and tile amount owing the company by the debtor, and necessarily the
collectibles of the debts. The auditor must ensure that the replies are not intercepted by
The additional audit work needs to be performed in order to verify the amount of trade
- Agreeing the opening balances of trade debtors to prior year audit working papers and
- Agreeing closing balances included in debtors schedule prepared by the’ client staff
to the debtors control account and the individual debtors ledger balances.
ensure authenticity.
- Vouching discounts and amounts written off during the year to ensure that they were
- Vouching return inwards to stock records to ensure that they are authentic.
- Reviewing the aged analysis of debtors to determine the collectability of the amounts,
- Comparing the current year trade debtors balances with those for prior years and in
- Ensuring that trade debtors are properly presented and relevant information disclosed
34
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
further investigation.
The two audit objectives normally associated with tests executed on a sample of transactions
management throughout the period during which the transactions occurred. This type
ii. To determine whether transactions and balances included in the accounts and the
financial statements are complete, accurate and valid. This type of audit test is known
as substantive test.
An example of audit test which not only assist the auditor in determining the reliability of
controls, but also the completeness accuracy of transactions and balances is the test counting
of stock items when the auditor attends the client’s stock take. Such test count will enable the
auditor:
- To determine the extent to which the stock take procedures can generate reliable
- To ascertain the accuracy of the counted stock items. By tracing a single transaction
of each type through all stages of the accounting system, the auditor is able to confirm the
35
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
correctness if his understanding of the accounting and internal control systems which exist in
the client’s enterprise. This type of test is referred to as walk-through test or walk-through
Internal control system can be defined as the own system of control which may be
business of assuring that an organization has a reliable financial reporting system and
functions effectively in compliance with applicable laws and regulations. Internal control
seeks to provide that there is proper maintenance of environment that frowns at corruption
and deter any fraudulent activities by management and employees. Internal controls are
When conducting an independent audit for a large company who has an internal audit
staff, external auditors needs to evaluate the internal auditors' functions. These functions
consist of the internal auditors' competence, objectivity, and work performance. The
principles of internal control are: Maintaining adequate records, divide responsibilities for
related transaction, apply technological controls, perform regular and independent reviews,
insure asset and bond key employees, separate record keeping from custody of assets. The
the internal and external auditors in order that these internal audit functions can be
adequately evaluated by the external auditors. Because of the external auditors' reliance on
these internal audit functions and because of the scope of the audit, sometimes tension enters
36
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Control Environment: This to a large extent influences the control consciousness of its
Risk Assessment: One of the components of internal control is the identification and analysis
of relevant risks to the achievement of objectives which forms a basis for how the risk should
be managed.
identification, capture and exchange of information of information in a form and time frame
Control Activities: These are the activities and procedural policies that help to ensure that
Monitoring: This is also one of the components of internal control as it is a process used in
This behavioral aspect is extremely important because of the working team relationship that
must exist. If it does not exist, it is likely that this behavioral aspect can significantly
influence many audit decisions made the external auditors. Thus, because of the nature of this
relationship, communication problems can affect the outcome of an effective and efficient
independent audit.
In any working relationship, one has to be totally cognizant of the human relations
component that can arise, and the internal and external audit relationship is no exception. It is
possible for external auditors to have a negative attitude toward internal auditors that can
affect the relationship. Oftentimes, this situation is compounded by the internal auditors'
negative perception of the external auditors' status within the independent audit. Although
37
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
not all external and internal auditors experience this behavior, it nevertheless is still an
important element to be evaluated because of the potential behavioral problems that can
Some internal auditors see their interactions with external auditors as not one of their
favorite parts of their job because of the external auditors’ limited use of the work performed
by internal auditors. The internal auditors perform various operations that could be used by
the external auditors, but some external auditors do not rely on the work. As a result, this
situation can cause tension and conflict, and it often stems from poor communication.
Therefore, one way to improve communications between internal and external auditors is to
determine what may be the specific communication problems or barriers affecting this
relationship. Once the barriers have been identified, then appropriate training and /or
counseling to deal with the communication barriers can be developed and administered.
The following communication barriers are common types of barriers that may arise in
this relationship.
Given the nature of the internal and external auditor relationship, an element of pride
may enter into the situation. Each group perceives the work performed as critically important
auditor seeks information from an internal auditor, or vice versa, there is a tendency not to be
as open and detailed regarding the information sought. This barrier can be dealt with by
providing an environment that encourages open lines of communication and reinforces the
38
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
Lack of Credibility
From the standpoint of the external auditor, if the external auditor perceives the
internal auditors as lacking credibility, then the reliance on the work performed by the
internal auditors will be reduced dramatically. The internal auditors need to establish a basis
of competence and convey this appropriately to the external auditors. When internal auditors
can provide the necessary credentials illustrating an understanding and application of the
proper audit procedures through appropriate training and prior work performance, external
auditors can begin to accept the work as reliable and improve the relationship.
Although both types of auditors have had similar coursework in their undergraduate
accounting programs, sometimes because of the nature and type of business, specific types of
One of the first things external auditors need to do is to become familiar with the appropriate
common business practices of the company. They need to seek information from the internal
auditors to help them understand the various requirements necessary for the audit. By
providing an atmosphere of cooperation, the auditors can work together in a productive and
efficient manner by sharing the appropriate information needed for the audit.
Probably one of the most common communication barriers that can arise in this
relationship is through ineffective listening. If internal and external auditors do not make a
point to listen effectively to each other, obvious problems can surface to affect the
39
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
independent audit. Each group needs to establish a basis of trying to gain proper information
from each other by keeping an open mind and not developing any preconceived notions.
If these auditors realize that they can benefit from each other and stop from developing a
negative attitude toward each other, then this would be the first step to improve this
relationship. And, the best way to achieve this goal is through effective listening. These
auditors need to listen not only with empathy for the speaker but also with feeling and
acceptance. They have to remember that often emotions can filter the benefit that can occur if
Resistance to Change
Another common barrier that can surface in this relationship is the external auditors'
resistance to change to new ideas and procedures developed by the internal auditors to
improve the independent audit. When the change is perceived as threatening to the norm of
handling a particular issue, this change can affect the communication exchange. Internal
auditors always strive to improve the procedures and policies within the accounting
environment, and when external auditors discount the value of these new ideas, internal
ideas in that each group should give enough time to each other to show the value that can be
40
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
The first step to improve the communication between internal and external auditors is
to attempt to recognize the barriers that may cause problems. These barriers can have a direct
impact on the success of the audit. Working together as a team rather than two independent
groups can only improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the independent audit. If the
auditors can begin to recognize potential behavioral communication problems that can affect
this relationship, as noted in this article, this would be an important step to reduce and/or
eliminate the problems. Once the problems have been identified, various training and
educational efforts can be offered to help the auditors deal with these communication
concerns.
AUDITORS REPORT
It must be recognized that there are two fundamental aspect of audit. One is to
establish the facts and the other is to report material facts fearlessly to members, it was held
long ago, in the case of RE: LONDON GENERAL BANK – 1985, that an auditor failed in
his duty where he did not convey information clearly in his report. The discussion below is
based on the provisions of law, which give guidance on the report of auditors on financial
statements.
IAG 13 requires the audit’ report to include the following basic elements:
- Title
- A reference to the status under which the audit was carried out.
41
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
REPORT.
In compliance with Schedule CAMD 1990 and generally acceptable audit practice,
the auditor should refer expressly in his report to the following matters.
Whether the auditor has obtained all the information and explanations necessary for the
- Whether, in his opinion, proper books of accounts have been kept by the company,
and proper returns adequate for the purpose of the audit obtained from branches not
visited.
- Whether the financial statements are in agreement with the books of accounts and
returns.
- Whether in the auditor’s opinion the financial statements give a true and fair view of
the state of affairs, profit or loss and, where applicable, cash flow statements.
- Whether the financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the
provisions of the Companies and Allied Matters Decree 1990 and any other statute.
The auditor should also refer in his report the particular convention used in preparing the
An example of audit report containing the basic elements and setting out those matters
42
Auditing Handbook by Akinyele A.P (Esq)
Institute of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies,
OAU, Ile Ife.
NECESSARY.
IN OUR OPINION, THE COMPANY HAS KEPT PROPER BOOKS AND THE
DEGREE, 1990, AND GIVE A TRUE AND FAIR VIEW OF THE COMPANIES
11 MARCH, 2010
SOLAR & Co
CHARTERED ACCOUNTS
43