Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7 Spur Gears
7 Spur Gears
Fn
b
A Parabola
Ft
Tangent to base circle
B C Tooth profile
t
A
t
b
C
h
a
Data:
P=9KW, N1=2000 rpm, N2=500 rpm.
Speed ratio i=(N1/N2)=(2000/500)=4
141/2o , z1=20,
Hence z2=iz1=4x20=80 teeth
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Design Procedure :
Step 1 : To identify the weaker member :
From Table 12.7, Page 234, for Cast steel 0.2% (untreated)
pinion, allowable static stress d1 138.3Mpa( N / mm 2 )
For High grade CI (heat treated) gear, d2 78.5Mpa
o
1
From Eq 12.5c P 204, Lewis form factor ' y' for 14 system
2
0.684 0.684
y1 0.124 0.124 0.0898 (for pinion)
z1 20
0.684 0.684
y2 0.124 0.124 0.1154 (for gear)
z2 80
y
d1 1 138.3 0.0898 12.42, d2 y2 78.5 0.1154 9.0598
As d2 y2 y , the gear is weaker.
d1 1
B
A
e=0.0386
a
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Data:
P=12KW, N1=1000 rpm,
Speed ratio i=(N1/N2)=2.5
Hence N2=1000/2.5= 400rpm.
Assume full depth involute, z1=20.
(From Table 12.4(b), Page 230)
Hence z2=iz1=2.5x20=50 teeth
For compact design, size of gears should be
as minimum as possible. Hence select
strongest material for both the pinion & gear.
Hence select chrome vanadium steel,
0.45%C heat treated, static stress =516.8
Mpa (Table 12.7, page 234)
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Design Procedure :
Step 1 : To identify the weaker member :
From Table 12.7, Page 234,
for chrome vanadium steel (heat treated) material
allowable static stress d1 d2 516.8Mpa
Here as both pinion & gear are assumed
to be of same material, the pinion is weaker.
Design must be based on the pinion.
Lewis form factor for 200 FDI tooth system,
0.912
for pinion y1 0.154 0.1084
20
0.912
for gear y 2 0.154 0.1358 (Eq 12.5(d) P204)
50Bangalore
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Step 2 : Tangential tooth load Ft
(a) Using Power transmitted & rpm,
1000 P C s
Ft Eq 12.7a Page 205
v
where P Power transmitted in KW 12 KW
Cs Service factor (from Table 12.8, Page 235)
Assuming medium shock loads, 8 - 10 hrs service/day, Cs 1.5
d 1 N1 mz1 N1
v Peripheral velocity
60000 60000
m 20 1000
v (1.047m ) m / sec
60000
Substituti ng the above in equation of Ft , we get
1000 12 1.5 17191.97
Ft (1)
1.047m m
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Tangential tooth load
(b) Using Lewis equation of beam strength
Ft d C v byp Eq 12.5(a), Page 204
where Cv velocity factor, d d1 516.8Mpa
b 10m (Equation 12.5(d), p 205), y y1 0.1084, p πm
Substituti ng, we get Ft 516.8 C v 10m 0.1084 πm
Ft 1759.955m 2Cv (2)
17191.97
Equating(1) & (2), 1759.95m 2Cv
m
m 3C v 9.768 (3)
3
Find module ' m' by trial & error.Assume m 2 RHS
3
i.e. m 2 9.768 2.69 mm
From Table 12.2, page 229 the preferred values are
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
m 2.5 mm & m 3 mmBangalore
Trial 1 :
Let m 2.5mm, Then pitch line velocity v 1.047m
v 1.047 2.5 2.6175 m/sec
3.05
For v upto 8m/sec, C v
3.05 v
3.05
Cv 0.538
3.05 2.6175
m 3Cv 2.53 0.538 8.408 9.768 ( RHS ).
Hence module of 2.5 is not suitable.
Trial 2 :
Let m 3 mm, Then pitch line velocity v 1.047m
v 1.047 3 3.141 m/sec
3.05
Cv 0.493
3.05 3.141
m 3Cv 33 0.493 13.3 9.768( RHS ).
Select m 3 mm as it yields m 3C v value greater than the required value.
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Step 3 : Dimensions of the gear & pinion
(a) Pitch diameter of pinion d 1 mz 1 3 20 60mm
Pitch diameter of gear d 2 mz 2 3 50 150mm
d1 d2 60 150
(b) Center distance between shafts a 105mm
2 2
(c) Face width b 10m 10 3 30 mm
(d) Circular pitch p πm 3 9.425 mm
17191.97 17191.97
(e) Tangential tooth load Ft 5730.6 N
m 3
(f) For 20 o FDI system, from T12.4, Page 230, addendum h a 1m 1 3 3mm
dedendum h f 1.157m 1.25 3 3.75 mm (where m module 3 mm)
Addendum diameter of pinion d a1 d1 2ha 60 (2 3) 66mm
Addendum diameter of gear d a2 d2 2ha 150 (2 3) 156mm
Dedendum diameter of pinion d f1 d 1 2h f 60 (2 3.75) 52.5mm
Dedendum diameter of gear d f2 d2 2h f 150 (2 3.75) 142.5mm
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Step 4 : Check for dynamic & wear load :
K 3v(Cb Ft )
(a) Dynamic load Fd Ft Eq12.12 Page 207
K 3v Cb Ft
where C Dynamic load factor from T12.12 Page 236
Here v 3.141m/sec 3m/sec, From Table 12.14 Page 237,
tooth error e 0.0785mm
From T 12.12, page 236, for Steel & Steel combination, 200 FDI system
for e 0.01, C 114.4 N/mm
114.4
for e 0.0785, C 0.0785 892.3N / mm (Linear variation)
0.01
K3 20.67 (Always for SI system of units), Page 207
20.67 3.141 (892.3 30) 5730.6)
Dynamic load Fd 5730.6
(20.67 3.141) (892.3 30) 5730.6
2.11 10 6
Fd 5730.6 14336N
245.2
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
(b)Wear load Fw d1bQK Eq12.15 (a ) Page 208
K load stress factor from T12.16, Page 239
Q Ratio factor from Eq 12.15c, Page 208
2 z2 2 50
Q 1.428, b 30mm, d1 60 mm
z1 z 2 20 50
Fw 60 30 1.428 K 2571.43K
For safe design, Fw Fd 2571.43K 14336
or K 5.575, For K 5.913( 5.575), & 200 tooth system,
From Table 12.16, page 239,
BHN for pinion 600
BHN for gear 600
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Problem 3
(Type II: where velocity/center distance/diameters are known)
A pair of carefully cut spur gears transmit 20
KW at 230 rpm of the gear. Reduction ratio is
5:1. The pinion is made of cast steel (heat
treated) with allowable stress of 197 MN/m2.
Gear is made of Cast iron with allowable stress
of 56 MN/m2.
Determine the module, face width and number
of teeth on pinion & gear. Also suggest suitable
surface hardness for the gear pair. Pitch line
velocity of the pinion is not to exceed 7.5
m/sec. P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Gear
Pinion
N2
N1
d2
d1
1 2 z2
z1
a
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Data: P=20KW, N2=230 rpm,
Speed ratio i=(N1/N2)=5
Hence N1=230x5= 1150rpm.
Pitch line velocity v=7.5m/sec
Assume pressure angle FDI
d1=197 Mpa, d2=56
Mpa,
πd1 N1
As pitch line velocity of pinion m/sec,
60000
Given that the value is not to exceed 7.5 m/sec,
π d1 1150
7.5 d1 124.5mm.
60000
Select pitch circle diameter of pinion d1 120mm
Pitch circle dia of gear d 2 id1 5 120 600mm.
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Design Procedure :
Step 1 : To identify the weaker member :
Here the number of teeth are to be found out (not assumed).
But to decide the weaker member assume tentatively,
z1 20 teeth z2 iz1 5 20 100 teeth (Not the final value)
0.912
Lewis form factor for pinion y1 0.154 0.1084
20
0.912
for gear y 2 0.154 0.145 (Eq 12.5(d) P163)
100
For pinion, d1 y1 197 0.1084 21.35
For gear, d2 y2 56 0.145 8.11 y
d1 1
B
A
e=0.05
AB AC
From similar triangles ABC & CDE,
DE CD
(8 - 6) (0.059 - 0.05)
i.e. x 0.0055
(7.23 - 6) x
For v 7.23 m/sec, tooth error e (0.059 - 0.0055) 0.0535
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
(b)Wear load Fw d1bQK Eq12.15a Page 208
K load stress factor from T12.16, Page 239
Q Ratio factor from Eq 12.15c, Page 208
2 z2 2 75
Q 1.667, b 80mm, d1 120 mm
z1 z 2 15 75
Fw 120 80 1.667 K 16000K
For safe design, Fw Fd 16000K 20575
or K 1.286
For K 1.344( 1.286), & 200 tooth system,
From Table 12.16, page 239,
BHN for pinion 350
BHN for gear 250
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Problem 4
(Type II: where velocity/center distance/diameters are known)
A compressor running at 400 rpm is driven by a
25 KW, 1200 rpm motor through a pair of
141/2o involute spur gear. The centre distance is
around 400 mm. The pinion is made of forged
steel of static allowable 190 MN/m2 and 350
BHN. Gear is to be made of cast steel of
allowable stress 180 MN/m2 and 300 BHN.
Design the gear for safe continuous operation.
Check the gear for endurance, wear & dynamic
strength.
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Data: P=25KW, N1=1200 rpm,
N2=400 rpm,
Speed ratio i=(N1/N2)=(1200/400)=3
Center distance a=400 mm
pressure angle
d1=190 Mpa, d2=180 Mpa,
BHN (pinion)=350, BHN(gear)=300
N1 d2 d2
As velocity ratio i 3
N2 d1 d1
d1 d 2 d1 3d1
d 2 3d1 Also center distance ' a' 400
2 2
Pitch diameter of pinion d1 200mm
Pitch diameter of gear d 2 3 200 600mm
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Gear
Pinion
N2
N1
d2
d1
1 2 z2
z1
a
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Design Procedure :
Step 1 : To identify the weaker member :
Here the number of teeth are to be found out (not assumed).
But to decide the weaker member assume tentatively,
z1 20 teeth z 2 iz1 3 20 60 teeth (Not the final value)
0.684
Lewis form factor for pinion y1 0.124 0.0898
20
0.684
for gear y 2 0.124 0.1126 (Eq 12.5(c) P204)
60
For pinion, d1 y1 190 0.0898 17.06
For gear, d2 y2 180 0.1126 20.27
y
d1 1 d2 y2
Pinion is weaker,hence design must be based on pinion.
(Note : The above values of Bangalore
y should
P R Venkatesh not be used for design)
Mech Dept RVCE
Step 2 : Tangential tooth load Ft
(a) Using Power transmitted & rpm,
1000 P C s
Ft Eq 12.7(a) Page 164
v
where P Power transmitted in KW 25 KW
Cs Service factor (from Table 12.8, Page 235)
Assuming medium shock loads, continuous service, Cs 1 .8
d 1 N1 200 1200
v Peripheral velocity 12.57m / sec
60000 60000
Substituti ng the above in equation of Ft , we get
1000 25 1.8
Ft 3581N (1)
12.57
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
Tangential tooth load
(b) Using Lewis equation of beam strength
Ft d C v byp Eq 12.5(a) Page 204
6.1 6.1
where Cv velocity factor 0.327
6.1 v 6.1 12.57
(Assume accurately cut & ground gears, eq 12.6(c),page 205, for 6 v 20m/sec)
d d1 190 Mpa
b 10m (Equation 12.5(f), p 205), p πm
0.684 0.684m
y y1 0.124 0.124 (0.124-3.42 10-3 m)
d1 200
m
Substituting, we get Ft 190 0.327 10 m (0.124-3.42 10-3 m) πm
Ft (242.03m 2 6.675m3 ) (2)
Equating (1) & (2), 3581 (242.03m 2 6.675m3 )
Solving, module m 4.25 mm.
From table 12.2, page 229, the preferred values are 4 & 5mm.
m 4 mm gives Ft 3445 N required value of 3581 N.
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Select m 5mm. Bangalore
Step 3 : Dimensions of the gear & pinion
(a) Pitch diameter of pinion d 1 mz 1 200 5 z1 z1 40
Number of teeth on pinion 40 teeth
Pitch diameter of gear d 2 mz 2 600 5 z 2 z2 120
Number of teeth on gear 120 teeth
d1 d2 200 600
(b) Center distance between shafts a 400mm
2 2
(c) Face width b 10m 10 5 50 mm
(d) Circular pitch p πm 5 15.71 mm
(e) Tangential tooth load Ft 3581N
o
(f) For 14 1 tooth system, from T12.4, Page 230, addendum h a 1m 1 5 5mm
2
dedendum h f 1.157m 1.157 5 5.785 mm (where m module 5 mm)
Addendum diameter of pinion d a1 d1 2ha 200 (2 5) 210mm
Addendum diameter of gear d a2 d2 2ha 600 (2 5) 610mm
Dedendum diameter of pinion d f1 d 1 2h f 200 (2 5.785) 188.43mm
Dedendum diameter of gear dP f2R Venkatesh
d 2 2h 600
Mech Dept
f
RVCE ( 2 5.785) 588.43mm
Bangalore
Step 4 : Check for dynamic load :
K 3v(Cb Ft )
(a) Dynamic load Fd Ft Eq12.12 Page 207
K 3v Cb Ft
where C Dynamic load factor from T12.12 Page 236
Here v 12.57m/sec.From Table 12.14 Page 237,
for v 12m/sec, tooth error e 0.033mm
for v 15m/sec, tooth error e 0.023mm
By interpolation, for v 12.57 m/sec, e 0.0311
From T 12.12, page 236, for Steel & Steel combination, 14.50 involute system
for e 0.01, C 110.3 N/mm
110.3
for e 0.0311, C 0.0311 343.3 N / mm (Linear variation)
0.01
K3 20.67 (Always for SI system of units), Page 207
20.67 12.57 (343.3 50) 3581)
Dynamic load Fd 3581
(20.67 12.57) (343.3 50) 3581)
5390.26 10 3
Fd 3581 16928 N
403.86
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
C
e=0.033
E
x
D
B
A
e=0.023
AB AC
From similar triangles ABC & CDE,
DE CD
(15 - 12) (0.033- 0.023)
i.e. x 0.0019
(12.57 - 12) x
For v 7.23 m/sec, tooth error e (0.033- 0.0019) 0.0311
P R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore
(b) Check for wear load :
Fw d1bQK Eq12.15a Page 208
where d1 Pitch circle diameter of the gear 200 mm
2z 2 2 120
Q Ratio factor 1.512.15c Page 208
z 2 z1 120 40
2
sin 1 1
Also K es
12.15b Page 208
1.4 E1 E2
where es surface endurance strength of gear pair
and es 2.75( BHN ) 7012.15 d page 208
350 300
where BHN avearge value for pinion & gear 325
2
es 2.75(325) 70 823.75Mpa, Pressure angle 14.50
b Face width of gear 50 mm, E1 E2 207Gpa 207 103 N / mm 2
823.752 sin(14.5) 1 1
Load stress factor K 3
1.173
1.4 10 207 207
Wear load Fw d 1bQK 200 50 1.5 1.173 17588N
As Fw Fd , the designP is safe.
R Venkatesh Mech Dept RVCE
Bangalore