Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contract Seatwork Continuation
Contract Seatwork Continuation
Duroja BSCE 4B
August 22, 2022
13. Is a contract characterized by the employment of serious and irresistible force valid?
Why?
- No, Violence is an external act characterized by the employment of serious and
irresistible force by one party or a third party for his account in order to secure the consent of the
other party to the contract. Employment of violence by a party or by a third person for his
account renders the contract voidable.
17.Give another example of dolo causante and dolo incidente fraud contracts. Note: On
your hand-outs has example. Do not copy.
a. dolo causante
Example:
PTB sold to DM a parcel of land representing that land was “ absolutely free from liens
and encumbrances” DM gave his consent on the faith of PTB’s representation. Then when the
sale was registered, it was found that a lis pendens notice was annotated.
b. dolo incidente
Example:
Gono enter into a contract to deliver 500 cavans of rice to Rhea with a price per cavan of
1,300 pesos, Gono delivered 300 cavans but withheld the delivery of the remaining, stating that
the price went up and priced the rice to 1,600 per cavan. The fraud here is dolo incidental
because it is committed to the existing contract.
18.Give at least two (2) example of instances not constituting fraud. Select and specify
from the four instances. Do not copy the given example.
a. “Gay sold her land with an area of sixty hectares, by misrepresentation he lead
Azzaraga to believe that the said land contained 98 hectares and thus made it in the deed of sale
and induced the vendee to pay the price of forty seven thousand (47,000) pesos. But before the
contract was p-erfected, Azarraga visited and examine the area by himself and Gay does nothing
to prevent such investigation. Latter on Azzaraga file a suit for recovery of the excess payment
for the said land because he was defrauded by Maria Gay.Supreme Court held no. One who
contracts for the purchase of real estate in reliance on the representations and statements of the
vendor as to its character or value but after he has visited and examined it for himself and hr has
the means and opportunity of verifying such statements, cannot avoid the contract on the ground
that such statements were false or exaggerated.” – Example of Usual exaggeration in trade.
b. “Romeo, on buying a watch, was assured by the seller that it was a good watch, and
could run without rewinding for one week, in the opinion of the seller. This is a mere expression
of opinion that is not fraudulent. But if the seller was a watch expert, and the only reason why
Arlene bought the watch was the opinion of the seller, the contract is voidable on the ground of
fraud.” – Example of Expression of a favourable opinion.
c. “Ginang Alahera sold Gino a diamond ring which she believed to be a true diamond
ring. It turned out that it was not. Ginang Alahera cannot be held liable for fraud but will be
required to return Gino’s payment.” - Example of Misrepresentation made in good faith.
d. “Don Emilio is the owner of a parcel of land in Laguna. Cardo is interested in buying a
land in Laguna on which to build a factory. Juaquin tells Don Emilio and Cardo that the place
where the land of Don Emilio is situated is an industrial zone. If on the strength of the
representation made by Juaquin, the land is bought by Cardo, and it turns out that place is
residential zone, the contract of sale maybe annulled because of substantial mistake on the part of
the seller and the buyer.” – Example of Misrepresentation by a third person.
19. Is the contract put in place if there is a failure of either party to disclose facts? Why?
- Failure of either party to disclose facts when there is a duty to reveal them as when the
parties are bound by confidential relations, constitute fraud (Art. 1339).
When there is a duty to disclose facts as when they are bound by confidential relations
like that of lawyer and client or principal and agent, failure of the knowledgeable party to reveal
such information amounts to fraud, hence the contract is rendered voidable. Situations like this
may occur in employment or insurance contracts where to get the employer or insurer’s assent
the prospective employee or insurance applicant who had suffered a grave ailment conceals this
fact or substitute an X’ray of a healthy person for him.
21. Is a municipal council sell or lease a public property like a plaza? Why?
- No, a municipal council cannot sell or lease public property, such as plazas, streets,
common land, rivers, bridges, etc. because they are outside the commerce of man; and if it has
been done so by leasing part of the plaza the lease is null and void, for it is contrary to law, and
the thing leased cannot be the object of a contract.
23. Give another example of different cause of contracts. There are three. Do not copy
the example in the hand-outs.
Onerous contracts:
Example:
A contractor might agree to build a home at a set price, only to have a spike in raw
materials pricing drive the cost of construction past the expected earnings from the project.
Remunatory contracts
Example:
Karl gave Dane 1 live Carabao, in consideration of the latters act in saving the former’s
cows in times of typhoon .
Gratuitous contracts
Example:
Karl promises to sell a parcel of land to Dane for the sum of P10,000 by virtue of the
promise on the part of Dane to pay the said amount for the land.