Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Analysis of Costa Coffee Business Case
The Analysis of Costa Coffee Business Case
The Analysis of Costa Coffee Business Case
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Introduction.
Costa Coffee is a world-famous chain of English coffee houses with a 40-year history. Here
you can try unique coffee based on the author's Mocha Italia blend, handmade desserts,
French pastries, and order a delicious breakfast or hearty lunch.
The history of Costa Coffee began in the centre of London in 1971. Then two brothers -
Bruno and Sergio Costa - founded a coffee roasting factory in the Lambeth area. All local
coffee houses adored this unique taste! And 7 years later, the brothers decided to open their
first own espresso bar - Costa Coffee. Today, about 3,500 coffee houses operate under this
brand in more than 30 countries around the world. Here, the original technology of slow and
even roasting of coffee beans is strictly adhered to, and guests are offered coffee exclusively
on the unique Mocha Italia blend (a mixture of Arabica and Robusta in a certain proportion).
“Costa Coffee is the perfect place to meet friends in a cosy atmosphere. At the heart of our
philosophy is the skill of the barista, who will prepare any drink to your taste and put you in
the mood for the whole day! No wonder 7 out of 10 residents of the British capital recognize
our coffee as the best in taste. Here you will find not only your favourite classics, but also
branded drinks. It remains to choose your favourite flavour for this day!” - noted in Costa
Coffee.
By 1995, Costa had 40 coffee shops. Sergio Costa sold them for 20 million pounds and left
for Monte Carlo. The new owner - Whitbread - has increased the number of coffee shops 100
times, made the chain the second in the world after Starbucks and now sells it to Coca-Cola
for more than $ 5 billion.From the London coffee house of the brothers Sergio and Bruno
Costa, the network has grown over 40 years to 4 thousand coffee houses in three dozen
countries in Europe, Asia and Africa.
More than half - in the UK, where among the network coffee shops Costa Coffee has no
equal.
The purpose of this report is to show the deep analysis through 25 steps(from UN
Sustainable Goals to Forecasted Returns) of the Costa Coffee simulator providing valuable
1
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
recommendations and potential strategic steps for Costa Coffee in order to enter a completely
new market in NYC.
Goal 1: No Poverty
Despite the fact that the global poverty rate has doubled since 2000, 783 million
people—nearly one out of every ten people on the planet—still live in poverty (on less than
$1.90 a day). South Asia (12.4 percent of the region's population) and South Sub-Saharan
Africa (41 percent of the region's population) are home to the majority of them.
In impoverished communities, there are 122 women for every 100 men between the ages of
25 and 34. Economic growth must be inclusive, according to the UN, in order to create steady
employment and promote equality. To effectively combat poverty, broad measures are
required, including the expansion of social protection systems and the reduction of risks for
countries prone to natural disasters (they are usually among the poorest countries).
2
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
are required to feed today's hungry as well as future generations. 500 million smallholder
farmers supply up to 80% of the food consumed in most developing countries. Investing in
these types of production is an important strategy to expand food supply for local and global
markets while also improving the food security of the poorest people.
In many regions, energy poverty is the principal impediment to reducing hunger (and
growing enough food to fulfill future demand).
The shortage of trained teachers and access to adequate educational institutions are the two
main factors impeding the provision of education. Investments in providing scholarships for
rural pupils, upgrading teacher qualifications, creating contemporary educational facilities,
boosting water supplies, and electrifying schools are all needed to improve the situation.
3
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
4
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Roads, information and communications technology, sanitation, electricity, and water supply
are all lacking in most poor countries. In particular, just 16% of the world's population has
access to mobile broadband. In many African countries, a lack of infrastructure affects
corporate productivity by an average of 40%.
The manufacturing industry is the primary generator of economic growth, employment, and
social stability. The volume of conditional net production in this area in terms of per capita in
Europe and North America is $4.5 thousand, while it is only $100 in the least developed
countries.
In most jurisdictions, the whole gain in national income is allocated to the top 1% of the
population. The lowest 40% of a country's population accounts for 40% of the population, yet
they receive less than 25% of national revenue.
5
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
people), Sub-Saharan Africa (over 200 million people), and South Asia (over 190 million
people). It will cost $929 billion to provide adequate homes for all of them.
6
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Children's rights are violated in many countries around the world, and kids are subjected to
aggression and sexual violence. Impunity and a lack of statistics on offences are frequently to
blame.
The implementation of birth registration systems and the establishment of more autonomous
national human rights authorities around the world are two of the first steps toward protecting
individual rights.
Having considered the main definitions of global problems and ways to solve them, I would
like to go directly to the attitude of Cola and PepsiCo to these SDGs. For easier
understanding, below is a table.
7
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Coca-Cola PepsiCo
Goal 17: Global Water Challenge Climate: reduce general emissions and
greenhouse effect (goals 7;13;15;17)
1
https://www.pepsico.com/sustainability-report/goals-and-progress#
2
https://www.coca-cola.eu/news/supporting-co
8
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
able to do this, Kapferer’s framework is going to be used and then applied and compared to
the both brands. To be more specific, we start from their mission statements and vision. If we
have a look at Coca-Cola’s mission statement: “Refresh the World. Make a difference” and its
Vision: “to craft the brands and choice of drinks that people love, to refresh them in body &
spirit. And done in ways that create a more sustainable business and better shared future that
makes a difference in people’s lives, communities and our planet”. Obviously, Coca-Cola
became not just a simple drink, it became a part of people’s lives existing for more than 100
years. So, what is the secret of coke to be on top for a long time?
Firstly, it has a strong brand advertising’s campaigns, its vibrant red coverage can be
recognised by about 95% of the World’s population. Visual aspects are very significant in
terms of recognition and trust by their customers. This aspect can be one of the main
advantages for Costa Coffee. The Coca-Cola logo represents the company's identity, but it's
more than just the design, writing, and colors. The package design, particularly the bottle
shape, contributed significantly to the brand's success. On a worldwide scale, the shape of the
bottle became as recognized as the symbol without any marks.
Regardless of how well-known the Coca-Cola brand is now, the company has faced various
hurdles over its 130-year existence. In the 1980s, when cherry and diet coke were launched,
the company struggled with brand recognition. The cause for this was an inconsistency in the
new product packaging's usage of the brand's colors and emblem.
If we move to the main Coca-Cola’s competitor, which is PepsiCo and look at its mission and
vision statements, we can compare them.
Mission statement: “Create more smiles with every sip and every bite”
9
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Vision statement: “Be the global leader in convenient foods and beverages by winning with
purpose”
Having looked through both brand’s statements, it is clear that “Coca-Cola” is more focused
on beverages and does not expand its brand into food, evidence of this can also be seen in
their vision statement. While “PepsiCo” mentions not only drinks but also food as well.
3. BCG Matrix
Generally, having gone through the value of market shares and growth rates of some
companies, it helps us to find out a better picture of which companies are doing better in
which spheres. Here is a more precise analysis of this data.
On the chart below, we can see that Coca-Cola is performing better than their competitors,
especially holding more than half of the market. However, it still cannot go unnoticed that
Coca-Cola has negative Sales Growth value dragging the demand out from all such kinds of
drinks. Summarising these facts Coca-Cola is put in the “Cash Cow” category.
10
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Now, moving to the “water” companies, all companies have more or less high Market Share
and that's why they are appointed to the “Cash Cow” category. Coca-Cola’s company Dasani
is an average competitor among all others companies not showing really good results but still
staying in a good position.
Talking about sports drinks, Coca-Cola has a complete disadvantage against its competitor
PepsiCo. Having 18.44% of market share against 81.56% and a great decline in sales,
Coca-Cola is allocated to “Dog”.
Moving to the flavoured soft drink category, it is significant to point out that Cola has 20%
more of Market Share, but it has 4 times less Sales Growth value at the same time compared
to PepsiCo. Consequently, PepsiCo’s company SevenUP is put as a “Star” even if Cola has
quite good numbers.
11
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Fruit Drinks is potentially a very beneficial industry for Coca-Cola. It has one “Star” holding
more than half of the market and having a good sales growth value. Besides, Cola has a
Minute Maid with a higher Sales Growth rate and relatively lower Market Share. It is
assigned to “Question Mark” and should be more invested in to become more beneficial.
In the last category-Smoothies-Coca-Cola is an unparalleled market leader with its brand
Innocent. Having the highest Market Share and a sales growth rate, it is assigned to “Star”
without any doubt.
To sum up, Coca Cola has 2 spheres where it has an absolute advantage over its competitors.
Moreover, Cola has less number of “Cash Cows”,
that means that company has less amount of assets to
invest, this might sound risky for a new brands, on
the other hand Cola has only one “Dog”(Powder
ADE), which will not put a lot of financial pressure
12
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
on the company. Looking at the data below, Coca-Cola seems to be not really reliable in
terms of stability based on its WACC and Cost of Equity and leads to allocation of profits to
its shareholders losing the potential of future investments. The low number of EVA can be
also a good evidence of it, as it shows the true economic profit of the company.
4. PESTLE
In this part, Pestle analysis is going to be applied in order to determine the company's strategy
in the long term. The analysis is going to be done upon 5 main commodities: Arabica and
Robusta beans, sugar, tea, cocoa, and dairy milk fluid.
Coffee Robusta.
3
https://www.gcrmag.com/a-better-future-for-vietnam/
13
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Economical:
Аgriculture, fоrestry, and fisheriеs together made up 14% of Vietnam's gross domestic output
in 2021. This sector's GDР share increased for the first time in recent years in 2020. Despite
this, the agriculture sector accоunts for only 15% of total GDP. About half of the total coffee
trees planted in Vietnam are between the ages of 10 and 15, which prоduces the maximum
yiеld. Vietnamese coffee production will rely heavily on these trees in the future years. Other
coffee trees are over 30 percent between 15 and 20 years old, and about 20% are above 20
years old, implying that productivity cannot be guaranteed.
Basically, Vietnam's economy has been reasonably steady in recent years, with a GDP growth
rate of about 6.5-7%, a production growth rate of 5%, a stable currency rate, and healthy
inflation of around 3%.
Social:
The population of Vietnam is about 97 million people and the median age is 32.5 years old.4
Besides, the average working age of people in Vietnam varies from 25-54 years old.This
suggests that Vietnam will not experience a population catastrophe (such as an ageing
population) in the near future, and the workforce will stay strong and stable. Despite the fact
that Vietnam has experienced significant economic success in recent years, there is growing
criticism over income inequality.
4
https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/vietnam-population/
5
https://international.thenewslens.com/article/64591
14
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Legal:
Considering the fact that Vietnam is a low-secure country with a high risk of crime and a big
level of poverty, it has some patterns to worry about, such as child traffic, gender inequality,
law protection of workers, etc.
Cocoa.
Ivory Coast is a large producer of cocoa beans worldwide, hence it will be assessed next.
Political:
Ivory Coast is a federal republic. The political system is one of authoritarianism. The
President of the Republic is the Head of State, who is chosen for a seven-year term by
universal direct vote. The President wields extraordinary power and effectively controls all
other authorities.
Côte d'Ivoire's political system is exceedingly unstable. The first military coup since
independence occurred in 1999. In 2002, the country was split between the rebel-held north
and the government-controlled south by a civil war. Despite the fact that a power-sharing deal
was signed in 2007, the 2010 presidential election resulted in more violence.
Economical:
Prior to the pandemic's worldwide shock, Côte d'Ivoire had one of the most resilient
economies in Africa and the globe, growing at an annual average rate of 8% since 2012 and
accounting for about 17% of its total GDP. The worldwide health situation, on the other hand,
had a negative impact on Ivorian consumers and enterprises, slowing growth to 1.8 percent in
2020. In 2021, the country's economic recovery is predicted to be fueled by strong domestic
demand and stable exports.
Despite the fact that exports reached 95% in 2015, they dropped to 70% immediately after
due to Ebola fears in 2014 and the country's political upheaval in 2012.
Social:
Cote d'Ivoire's labor force has been fluctuating with a favourable trend of roughly 8-9 million
individuals. The age structure reveals a noteworthy preponderance of young people, which is
one of the reasons of child labor, which is one of the country's most important challenges.
15
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Indeed, “15 percent of Ivorian children are exploited”6. The emergence of a substantial black
market, where farmers escape the minimum prices set by the Farmgate Prices, harming the
domestic economy, is the second most serious concern.
Legal:
The key problem remains enacting a reform program that promotes the private sector in order
to create better employment, enhance the business climate, give access to funding for SMEs
and VSEs, expand agricultural capacity, and develop human capital, among other things.
Tea.
The biggest world producer of tea is Kenya, that's why this country is going to be examined.
Political:
Kenya is a presidential republic, with a big level of poverty and corruption, pretty similar to
the Ivory Coast. Talking about the tea industry, there are some key organisations controlling
and managing it. For instance, the Tea Directorate, which is responsible for regulating tea
factories, conducting tea research through its technical section, and registering producers and
purchasers, among other things. Another key body in the tea industry of Kenya is the
Research foundation of Kenya, whose mission is to “carry out research on the control of
pests and diseases, improvement of planting material, husbandry, yields and quality.”7
6
https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ilab/resources/reports/child-labor/cote-divoire
7
http://www.kenyarep-jp.com/business/tea_e.html
16
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Economical:
Kenya's economy grew at an annual rate of 4.7 percent from 2015 to 2019, dramatically
lowering poverty (which decreased to an estimated 34.4 percent at the $1.9/day limit in
2019). Kenya is producing about 450 thousand tones of tea and exports more than 90% of the
total output. The COVID-19 shock impacted the economy hard in 2020, hurting international
commerce and transportation, as well as tourist and urban services activities. Fortunately, the
agriculture sector, which is a cornerstone of the economy, has held up well, contributing to a
GDP drop of only 0.3 percent. The economy rebounded well in 2021, while certain
industries, such as tourism, remained under stress. GDP growth is expected to reach 5.0
percent in 2022, and the poverty rate has begun to drop again after climbing during the
epidemic.
Social:
According to the Wordometr8, the population of Kenya is nearly 56 million people and the
median age is 20 years. Kenyans have a life expectancy of 54 years. Adults (those over the
age of 15) have an 87 percent literacy rate. Access to sanitation facilities is available to 27%
of the urban population. In comparison to other African countries, Kenya has a lower infant
mortality rate. Kenya's population is growing at a pace of 2% per year. Kenya's population is
growing, with around 42 percent of the population aged 0-14 years and 54.5 percent aged
15-64 years.
Technological:
The use of technology is very poor due to the low income and wealth of the population. The
production of tea is mainly divided between small farmers and governmental organisations.
The first ones do not have money to buy new technologies and for both parties it is more
convenient to use human labour rather than expensive technologies with no educated workers
to use them.
Environmental:
Kenya is suffering from global warming and temperature rising.This is because of climate
change bringing about a temperature increase of over 2°, which will result in heavier
rainfalls, which will present a particular adversity for the Rift Valley region. Furthermore, the
8
https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/kenya-population/
17
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
calamity will largely damage the tea taste and quality - up to diminishing its contribution to
health. In order to deal with the threat, the country should dedicate a lot of its effort to
encouraging sustainable production, as well as R&D within the industry in search for possible
solutions to this problem.
Legal:
Despite the existence of national institutions aimed at supporting the industry, such as the
Kenya Tea Board or the Tea Act of Kenya, which regulate the industry and are responsible
for ensuring quality prоduction, the country's government still fails to devote enough
attention to small-scale producers in one of its most important export industries.
Political:
Germany is one of the world's most stable and industrialized countries.
In Germany, milk production is not a vital economic industry. Despite this, it receives
government assistance in the form of farmer subsidies to encourage the growth of milk
production in the country. Germany is a democratic country with a well-developed legal and
social infrastructure. The country's basic legislation is the Constitution, which establishes the
basis and framework of the country's legal and political institutions, as well as outlining the
fundamental rights of German citizens, which cannot be infringed by any governmental entity
or individual.
Economical:
Germany is a leading country in many economic sectors. It has a high economically active
portion of the populatiоn, about 44 million people. Export-oriented industries play a critical
role in the country’s еconomic model. The automobile business continues to be the most
profitable, with revenues of 436 billiоn еuros in 2019. It is a significant cщntribution to
development and success as an innovator. Because it has tight ties with enterprises in the
chemical, elеctrical еngineering, steel, metal, and tеxtile industries, vehicle manufacture also
provides revenues for other industries. Cоmpanies in other industries, such as the healthcare
business (372 billion euros in 2019) or the electrical engineering and electrical industry,
create substantial turnovers as well (191 billion euros in 2019).
18
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Environmaental:
The most critical problem is the experience and concentration of European citizens on the
problems of nature conservation and environmental conservation. In this regard, there are
concerns that dairy milk production harms the environment and requires a lot of water.
Legal:
The primary challenge for a commodity business in a developed country is legislation and
strict quality control, which also applies to the production of milk. While the business is
already suffering from climate-related concerns, weather cоnditions vоlatility, and low
market prices, complying with quality requirements costs German milk producers a lot of
money.
19
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Economical:
Generally, Brazil produces around 30% of total coffee global output. “Brazil produced 68
million bags (60 kg/bag) of green coffee in 2020, a record amount.”9
Regarding sugar, “Brazil is the world’s top producer and exporter of sugarcane. It supplies
50% of the world’s sugar, producing 654.8m tonnes of sugarcane, 41.25m tonnes of
processed sugar, and 29.7bn liters of ethanol annually. But the proportion of Brazilian land
that is dedicated to sugarcane production is just 1% (8.66m ha) of the country’s total land
area.”10
Social:
Brazil's employment is shrinking somewhat, hovering around 105 million people. The
population is similar in age to that of Vietnam, indicating that there will be no significant
negative influence on the workforce in the near future. Life expectancy is roughly 74 years,
which is not very high. However, severe unemployment and poverty are major issues in the
country. Numerous investigations by international human rights advocates are also pressing
the authorities on the problem of slavery in the coffee sector. On the one hand, it allows Costa
to purchase goods at lower costs, and purchasing more of them increases employment in the
nation.
Technological:
Brazil is a more or less decent user of technologies, especially in the agricultural sector.
Brazil is noted for pioneering several technical advancements in agriculture. Brazil went
above and above in bringing about effective upmarket technology in order to enhance the
manufacturing processes for both coffee and sugar. Both commodities profit from enormous
endowments devoted to their R&D departments, and Brazil is, as a result, a global leader in
both thanks to its current advances.
Environmental:
Due to global warming and droughts during the last few years, Brazilian farms are
experiencing some difficulties with their crops, “the coffee plants are experiencing the
9
https://gro-intelligence.com/insights/brazil-2021-coffee-production-seen-plunging
10
https://brazilianfarmers.com/sugarcane/
20
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
predicted degradation–the plants are yellow and damaged, and the beans are ruined. The
problem here was a lack of rainfall mixed with higher than normal temperatures.”11
Agricultural diseases, temperatures, insects, and water quality that Brazilian farmers rely on
are all influenced by global hardship, posing a serious danger to the country's capacity to
meet ever-increasing global demand.
Legal:
Brazil is facing nearly the same problems as all other low-income countries. The main
problem is the children workforce and low level of law enforcement. In order to stabilise this
situation, the level of security and law-abiding should be increased.
5.SWOT
In this part SWOT analysis is going to be applied in order to understand what influence
Coca-Cola has on Costa and whether it is profitable for Costa or not.
Strengths:
-Dominant in the beverages industry. Coca-Cola is the biggest company dealing with
non-alcoholic beverages, it sells about 3.2% of the total beverages servings worldwide(60
billion). Besides, the company is included in top-50 companies by market capitalization, the
estimated value is 231 billion dollars.
-High level of Diferestion. As it has already been mentioned, Coca-Cola has a fairly wide
range of drinks from sports to iced tea(Fuze Tea).
-Famous brand name. Brand name awareness of Cola is one of the key aspects. “If you
displayed the Coca-Cola logo to 7.1 billion people, they would know it. That's 94 percent of
the world's population, which is incredible given that only half of the world acknowledges the
cross as a Christian symbol”12.
-Huge operating profit margin, compared to its competitors. For instance, Coca-Cola has
around 23.5%, when its main rival PepsiCo has 14%.
11
https://www.panoramas.pitt.edu/economy-and-development/coffee-versus-climate-coffee-production-b
razil#:~:text=Brazilian%20coffee%20producers%20are%20already,and%20the%20beans%20are%20
ruined
12
https://brandmarketingblog.com/articles/branding-definitions/what-is-brand-awareness/
21
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
-The largest advertising budget. Except for 2020, when Coca-Cola spent just approximately
2.8 billion dollars on advertising, the company has spent an average of 4 billion dollars per
year on global advertising during the prior seven years. Over a quarter of the total
expenditure is spent in the United States.13
Weaknesses:
-Sustainability issues. Coca-Cola is the world's top plastic trash generator, according to the
Complaint, producing 2.9 million tons of plastic garbage per year. It consumes around
200,000 plastic bottles each minute, accounting for nearly one-fifth of the world's PET bottle
production. This plastic is also made with fossil fuels, which results in large CO2 emissions.14
-Strong reliance on soft drinks generated the main revenues for the company. About 70
percent of the profits of the stake comes from the sale of drinks. This entails a rather large
dependence on this particular market.15
-Unhealthy drinks. Since Coca-Cola is based on the production of mainly drinks containing
a large amount of sugar and various flavors, the brand is perceived and criticized for their
effect on health.
-Strong competition with PepsiCo, which shows better results in some indries, noticed in
Part 3.
-Lawsuits. Several cases resulted from unethical corporate tactics, such as a complaint
alleging fraud in recycling procedures or patent infringement through the use of a
customisation dispenser. Although the company's lawyers were able to avoid a lawsuit, such
charges put employees' loyalty and confidence in jeopardy.16
Opportunities:
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/feb/27/california-plastic-pollution-lawsuit-coke-pepsi
17
https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/industry-reports/ready-to-drink-rtd-coffee-market-100285
22
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
-Establishing or acquiring an alcoholic brand. Coca-Cola now lacks a strong brand that
produces alcohol, which might be a promising growth for the corporation.
-Coca-Cola has a large network of firms throughout the world as a result of previous
collaborations and acquisitions, which opens up a lot of options for the company in terms of
distribution and cooperation, as well as cost savings in the supply chain.
-Introduce new products in the health segments, it can play into Cola’s hands in terms of
targeting those who are focused on healthy lifestyle
Threats:
-Extension of “soda tax” in some cities in the US. For the first time in 2015, the soda tax
was introduced at Berkeley as demand for carbonated drinks fell by 23 percent, but at the
same time, water consumption rose by 60 percent. As a result, in 2018, several more cities
approved a similar tax.18
-Improper attention given to the new Costa brand as a result of failed attempts to join the
coffee industry in the US.
-Environmental potential threats. Reduced production of commodities that the hot drinks
sector relies on, such as coffee beans, cocoa, and tea, as a danger to Costa Coffee and
Coca-Cola, all caused by environmental adversity, lack of sustainability in the major
exporting countries, and the pressing issue of climate change and water usage.
-Coca-Cola's reluctance to expand new markets and James Quincey's position on James
Quincy's aversion to more bоld differentiation as well as the lack of a forward-looking vision
-Increased competition and Costa’s awareness in the US. Growing beverages industries,
such as RTD coffee drinks are facing a huge amount of new entrants, especially in the US. It
can prevent Coca-Cola from decent results on a new market.
Recommendations:
Coca-Cola is still the largest soft beverages drink company in the world. It is strongly
recommended to try to diversify and enter new markets, especially specialised in healthy
drinks and RTD healthy beverages. Moreover, it would be more beneficial for Cola to focus
and invest in recyclable and sustainability friendly products to show its attention to the world
environmental impact as well.
18
https://www.thebalance.com/state-taxes-4073925
23
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Costa will now be evaluated using the McKinsey Matrix. It is a brand marketing and product
management method that aids a corporation in deciding which items to produce and
determine the market attractiveness. The McKinsey model is a 9-cell matrix used to
compare the strategic business lines of a corporation.
In the simulation, the 60 important indicators were rated from 0 to 2, with 0 being assigned to
indicators that have no influence and 1 and 2 being assigned to criteria that have an impact on
the outcome, with 1 indicating a static criterion and 2 representing a variable criterion. The
indicators were divided into ten categories. All results are shown below:
24
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
25
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
26
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Conclusion:
As we can investigate the most attractive products on the market, Coffee shops lead in the
category of out-of-home, whereas the winner in the in-home category is coffee pods &
campsuls. Therefore, Costa Coffee should allocate their resources and invest in coffee shop
and coffee pods & capsules.
27
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
the higher pricing. Companies can gain a competitive edge by following a specialized
marketing strategy, a broad focus approach (targeting certain market segments), or an
industry-wide strategy (by offering products to maximum market segments). The usual
strategic alternatives available
differ according to the nature and
scope of competitive advantage.
28
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Conclusion.
Based on the assumptions shown above, Costa Coffee can expand its customer base
in New York City by highlighting distinctive product features and employing focus
and differentiation as a main approach. Costa Coffee's strategy aims to stand out
by embracing innovation and addressing the rising health concerns of its customers.
Coca-Cola should increase its product line in order to separate itself from competitors
and broaden the scope of market possibilities after examining altering customer tastes,
rather than investing in diversification.
8. Focus Group
The main goal of the focus group is to get opinions about the subject of research and to
identify the behavioral motives of people. Therefore, after analyzing the quotes and placing
the most significant factors, the result obtained turned out to be the following: Analyzing the
most significant factors, we can come to the conclusion that the most logical and rather
correct way is to focus on Adventurous and Cosmopolitans and the cost of focus group
appeared to be 2.555$.
These two focus groups are extremely demanding, as they enjoy the entire process of coffee
consumption as well as the cafe's atmosphere. That is to say, a high-quality coffee is
insufficiently gratifying. Costa should also offer a memorable and distinct flavor,
environment, and branding. In other words, these people focus on “gourmet” products
sacrificing any amount of money to achieve the needed amount of satisfaction.
29
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Making a perfect espresso shot for these 2 segments, it was essential to pay attention to their
tastes and preferences. For instance, we should focus on sweet and fruity aromas and avoid
making coffee with sour or watery qualities. The recipe for 2 target markets(Adventurous &
Cosmopolitans) is shown below:
Having done all the assumptions, we end up with the nearly highest COGS for Costa among
the competitors and the highest score at the same time.
30
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
9.Price Survey
The psychographic sample frame was chosen at this point. This is due to two factors. First,
Adventurers and Cosmopolitans are more focused on their lifestyle, tastes and preferences
rather than economical concerns and money. Second, regarding the previous stage, one of the
most influential factors was psychographical. It is preferable to study on the same segments
in order to integrate our analysis of the previous stage and current step.This is why the
psychographic sample frame was chosen over the socio-demographic sampling frame.
The initial confidence interval was set at 99.8%, which resulted in a p-value of less than
0.0001, indicating the survey's dependability and high quality. However, it will come at a
high cost of $8.755, and will become a burden for the SH results.
Then we move to the final adjusted results to be more confident in the selection of potential
target markets.
31
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
The psychological price survey suggests that there are big differences in price elasticity of
demand among different segments. The survey results show that the price attracting the most
buyers (64%) is the highest price of $5.99. This shows that our differentiation strategy picked
before would be perfectly working for the main target market-Adventurous, who is ready to
accept any price in order to increase their utility and satisfaction.
10. Positioning
Certain indicators for Costa Coffee will be determined in this part using the Perceptual
mapping simulator in order to bring about the positioning matching to the suggested
approach. As a result, if we want to focus on these two groups, we must first study and
analyse what these individuals enjoy and prefer. A deep research of these people's tastes and
opinions will help us more clearly identify items that meet their needs.
In general, adventurous individuals are those that are motivated by hedonism, which is
defined as a lifestyle that is centred on pleasure and enjoyment. In fact, they are willing to
pay whatever it takes to receive joy, as we saw in part 9 of the psychological pricing chart.
Generally, prices are more or less irrelevant for them compared to the quality of the product
and its uniqueness and unforgettable experience.
Besides, Costa's position should be consistent with a number of United Nations Sustainable
Development Goals. The Goal 3 is to promote the health and well-being of your clients. Goal
32
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
8: implementing more organic ingredients compared to industry average. Aim towards Goal
12 for responsible consumption and production since the firm sells ethically sourced or Fair
Trade merchandise. Goal 13: for climate action aiming to minimise greenhouse gas
emissions. By limiting plastic and non-recyclable items, it moves towards goals 14 and 15.
Finally, having applied all approaches mentioned above and taken into account all aspects,
we found costa in the bottom left corner of the Perceptual Map targeting the Adventurous
and Cosmopolitans.
33
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
34
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
This data will be used in the future steps, such as pricing of beverages and designing the
production level.
This section will examine design thinking as a progressive approach to business behaviour
that Costa Coffee should adopt. Yet, design thinking enables for a wider range of independent
personalities to be taken into account since it allows for a more customized and, as a result,
better experience, which leads to greater connection.
Costa Coffee is a narrative about progressive, responsible individuals who are industrious and
health-conscious. Costa's coffee is coated with their progressive and responsible thinking,
35
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
36
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Physical:
Upscale
Extravagant
Delicate
Fancy
Sense of excitement
Relationship:
Exclusivity
Individualization
Trustworthy
Target Customer:
Customers that have a high-end consumption habit
Сonnoisseurs of quality and delicious coffee
Customers wishing to be contributed to SDG
Searchers of new unforgettable experience
37
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Hedonists
Personality:
Gourmet
Exclusive
High class
Differentiating
Eco-friendly
Benefits:
Delighted
Relaxed
High status
Consuming the best
Socially and environmentally responsible
Culture:
Italian
British
Superior
Urban
Fair
Opening hours:
We chose to look at our opponents' work schedules to establish working hours. So our plan
was to locate our niche and pick something in between a lengthy work week, like Mcafee
38
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
(126 hours per week), and a short work week, like Peet's Coffee & Tea (83 hours per week),
which we can also rely on, since this chain is quite young and has a small number of cafes.
Another aim was to demonstrate our superiority over our biggest competition, Starbucks,
whose main target audience is Cosmopolitans as well.
39
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
40
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
41
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
In this part packagings and flaware will be discussed in order to find the best alternative to
our targeting segments. Packaging is designed to fulfil the demands of customers as well as
market segmentation and targeting. When the case study addresses UN Sustainable
Development Goal 3, it shows that it safeguards the health and well-being of the clients. As a
result, it is critical to choose packaging alternatives that correlate to the usage of recyclable
42
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
materials and cause the least amount of environmental impact. Besides, we chose three main
sises of our mugs: Small(236 ml), Medium(472 ml) and Large(590 ml).
When choosing suitable products, it is worth noting that the cheapest of them are made of
plastic. But since we cannot save money on the preferences of our customers and neglect
SDG(12-15), we are forced to use alternative substitutes such as wooden straws or edible
cups.
The biggest disadvantage of these products is their high cost. Therefore, from the entire list,
we had to abandon, for example, edible straws and replace them with wooden ones.
Nevertheless, many of our rivals have lower expenses than we do. However, because of our
devotion to environmental protection, we anticipate a great demand for our products.
This section delves deeper into Costa's capital expenditures as a result of the equipment it
acquires. Decisions will be made on the basis of costs and strategy. It's important to
43
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
remember that Costa is working hard to contribute to the SDGs. Costa will determine which
assets to purchase at this time by setting clear priorities. Once it refers to resources that are
directly linked to our company's basic value, the first aim is to select qualitative and
environmental friendly asset, in terms of electricity and water usage, at the same time.
Moreover, Costa's differentiating approach, selecting the greatest quality is crucial to offering
excellent customer service and provide clients with high-quality gourmet products.
Consequently, all choices made accordingly to the preferences and tastes of our target
audience are shown in the table below:
44
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
45
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
46
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
47
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
The potential Costa's keywords will include "top coffee shop in New York," "new coffee
shop in NY," and "growing coffee shop in New York," among others. Other prospective
adventurers and cosmopolitans will use keywords like "opening coffee shop in NY," "fair
trade coffee in NY," and "organic coffee in NY."
Finally, we got almost 3 thousand dollars per day as a cost of Google AdWords Campaign.
48
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
To be able to determine which social media platform is better to invest in, we firstly need to
find out which of them gives the most interactions and the most usable among other
competitors. “Twitter was the QSRs' preferred advertising platform. Nearly 40% of all ad
impressions came from Twitter, followed by YouTube (33%), Facebook (15%) and Instagram
(13%).”19 Moreover, Costa's penetration rates on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram,
YouTube, and Pinterest
should be higher than
its nearest competitors
by size, Caffe Nero
and Seattle's Best
Coffee, in order to
overcome them. To
enhance the success of
our social media
marketing, we should
concentrate on
Instagram, YouTube,
and Twitter. Because
our new businesses
service the New York
market solely, Costa does not need to invest as much in extending penetration as Dunkin and
Starbucks do. It's preferable to keep your penetration rate below such big chains, which have
so many properties and cafes all over the US.. However, because controlling the market on
19
https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/marketing/which-chains-spend-most-social-media-ads
49
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
In addition, Costa's aggressive positioning in New York City is unsuitable. Because, as it has
already been said before, adventurers and cosmopolitans seek a unique, “gourmet” and
unparalleled product and customer experience. An aggressive marketing strategy is highly
questioned and risky to use focusing on cosmopolitans and adventurers. Costa should
emphasize the distinctiveness of its goods and atmosphere, as the film will only be seen by a
small number of people.
50
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
The pricing for all goods in Costa's beverage line will be set in this part based on costs,
consumer perception, and the desired market strategy.
All our current spends are shown in the table.
Value-added consumers feel that higher-priced items are of higher quality and hence worth
the money, as it has already been mentioned they are ready to pay in order to achieve
satisfaction and meet their needs no matter what price it costs. Than create this perception in
the minds of consumers, the company must focus its advertising on how its features and
advantages are superior to those of its rivals.
Considering that our prices are going to be high, we decided, the report attempts to establish
prices approximately 30-40% above unit costs. As it has already been said before in the price
survey, the best utility is achieved at a higher price, consequently we decided to set an
optimal price-$5.79. Using cost-based pricing, we came up with our final results, shown
below:
51
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Summarizing, breakeven points (days) are projected to be 279, 268, and 248 days in the low,
medium, and high scenarios, respectively. We do believe that these results are quite optimistic
since we will be able to recoup all of our capital in less than one year, operating on a new
market.
52
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
determine how many clients buy food, regardless of whether they sit down. We input the
amount of hedonists into the simulator based on the time of day, sit-down and take-away
options, acquired in the previous steps.
The waste percentage for purchased items was chosen at a rate of 2.5 percent on average.
This figure was set to accommodate any potential operational mishaps.
The weighted average was used to alter the value of MUB/MUF of our target audience in all
hypotheses. From part 9, we see that weekly MU is 1.52, which means that the value of
coffee is above the value of food for 1.52 times. Considering that Starbucks prices coffee is
1.7 times higher than food, we could go further up for beverages for our microsegments.
Besides, the average markup for food is 30% and the average price is 2.89$. Below, there are
some final statements about the potential food sales. All numbers from parts 21 and 22 will
be used further.
53
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
54
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
55
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
56
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
Generally, Costa is going to spend around 10% of its EBIT on all charities organisations,
which we do believe would be more than enough to satisfy and cover all our potential
customers’ wants. In case of final success, Costa absolutely ought to increase its donations to
specific charities programs.
57
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
58
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
To sum up the case study, the analysis determined that Costa will perform a fine job in New
York City.
Firstly, we can look at the net profits in the income statement, shown below, which makes
the idea of implementing Costa very promising.
59
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
that is computed by dividing net income by shareholders' equity. Consequently, Costa would
be able to produce a profit that was greater than the cost of capital put in the firm.
Bibliography:
UN SDG:
-https://www.pepsico.com/sustainability-report/goals-and-progress#
-https://www.coca-cola.eu/news/supporting-communities/meeting-the-sdgs--the-greatest-glob
al-change-happens-together
-https://sdgs.un.org
-https://stories.starbucks.com/stories/2017/a-commitment-to-coffee-1-billion-new-coffee-tree
s/
-https://stories.starbucks.com/press/2016/100k-opportunities-initiative-exceeds-hiring-goal/
-https://www.coca-colacompany.com/news/how-coca-cola-is-driving-social-environmental-pr
iorities-and-sustainable-goals-during-covid-19-pandemic
- https://www.costa.co.uk/behind-the-beans/coffee/responsible-sourcing
PESTLE:
-https://www.gcrmag.com/a-better-future-for-vietnam/
60
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
-https://www.statista.com/statistics/1027971/vietnam-gdp-contribution-of-agriculture-forestry
-and-fishing-sector/
-https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/vietnam-population/
-https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/cotedivoire/overview#1
-https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ilab/resources/reports/child-labor/cote-divoire
-http://www.kenyarep-jp.com/business/tea_e.html
-https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/kenya/overview#1
-https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/kenya-population/
-https://www.make-it-in-germany.com/en/living-in-germany/discover-germany/economy
-https://gro-intelligence.com/insights/brazil-2021-coffee-production-seen-plunging
-https://www.britannica.com/place/Brazil/The-economy
-https://www.panoramas.pitt.edu/economy-and-development/coffee-versus-climate-coffee-pr
oduction-brazil#:~:text=Brazilian%20coffee%20producers%20are%20already,and%20the%2
0beans%20are%20ruined
SWOT:
-https://brandmarketingblog.com/articles/branding-definitions/what-is-brand-awareness/
-https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KO/cocacola/profit-margins#:~:text=Profit%20m
argin%20can%20be%20defined,31%2C%202021%20is%2025.28%25.&text=The%20
-https://www.statista.com/statistics/286526/coca-cola-advertising-spending-worldwide/
-https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/feb/27/california-plastic-pollution-lawsuit-c
oke-pepsi
-https://www.natlawreview.com/article/coca-cola-sued-deceptive-sustainability-claims
-https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/industry-reports/ready-to-drink-rtd-coffee-market-
100285
-https://www.thebalance.com/state-taxes-4073925
-https://www.statista.com/statistics/269221/operating-profit-margin-of-pepsico-worldwide/#:
~:text=PepsiCo%27s%20operating%20profit%20margin%20amounted%20to%2014.3%20pe
rcent%20in%202020
-https://investors.coca-colacompany.com
61
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
-https://backlinko.com/social-media-users#social-media-in-the-us-by-numbers
-https://www.gwi.com/reports
-https://www.statista.com/statistics/266466/net-revenue-of-the-starbucks-corporation-worldw
ide/#:~:text=Starbucks'%20net%20revenue%20reached%2024.61,previous%20year's%20tota
l%20of%2019.61.
-https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/marketing/which-chains-spend-most-social-media
-ads
Other resources:
-https://medium.com/@jkysharma/pixar-a-journey-in-design-thinking-e78de88b5975
-https://chools.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/The-Fearless-Organization_-Creating-Psychol
ogical-Safety-in-the-Workplace-for-Learning-Innovation-and-Growth.pdf
-https://www.comunicaffe.com/costa-coffee-is-uks-second-fastest-growing-brand-in-the-2019
/#:~:text=Success%20stories%3A%20Costa%20among%20the%20fastest%20risers&text=50
%20after%20increasing%20its%20value,for%20social%20and%20environmental%20sustain
ability.
-https://www.quirks.com/articles/strategies-for-marketing-to-cosmopolitan-consumers
-from https://www.quirks.com/articles/strategies-for-marketing-to-cosmopolitan-consumers
-https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/081415/comparing-cocacola-and-pepsis-busi
ness-models.asp
-https://1000logos.net/costa-coffee-logo/
-https://www.strategy-business.com/blog/Diversify-or-Focus-The-Best-Strategies-Do-Both#:
~:text=When%20you%20define%20focus%20in,you'll%20diversify%20for%20it.
-https://www.%20businessinsider.in/Coca-Costa-says-millennials-are-%20decimating-sales-o
f-Diet-Coke-and-now-its-going-to-%20war/articleshow/62953387.cms
-https://www.forbes.com/sites/larryhusten/2014/04/27/what-role-should-coca-Costa-play-in-o
besity-research/#bf5573da51b4
-https://www.paperdue.com/essay/strategic-management-at-coca-cola-and-pepsi-2150858
-https://simplymeasured.com/blog/lessons-from-coca-colas-social-media-strategy-cohesive-c
ampaigns-and-creative-content/#sm.00048ofq1dcnd3l10ba19umrctpea
62
Sviatoslav Kolykhaiev
63