Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Teaching With Strengths in Trauma-Affected Students
Teaching With Strengths in Trauma-Affected Students
Teaching With Strengths in Trauma-Affected Students
T
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
he National Child Traumatic Stress promote both healing and growth in their cluding problems with self-regulation, ag-
Network in the United States reports classrooms. This article presents scientific gression, attention, dissociation, and physi-
that up to 40% of students have ex- and practice-based evidence to support our cal and motor problems. As part of the
perienced, or been witness to, traumatic claim. We present education interventions PTSD response, the child’s acute alarm re-
stressors in their short lifetimes. These in- aimed to build positive emotions, character action when perceiving external threat trig-
clude home destabilization, violence, ne- strengths, resilient mindsets, and gratitude, gers the body’s stress response systems.
glect, sexual abuse, substance abuse, death, and show how these can be embedded in the When this system is repeatedly triggered it
and other adverse childhood experiences. daily routines of classroom learning to assist damages key neurological and psychologi-
The effects of trauma on a child severely struggling students. cal systems in the long term.
compound the ability to self-regulate and As a consequence of the neurological and
sustain healthy relationships. In the class- psychological damage resulting from
room, the effects of trauma may manifest as Trauma and Students trauma, trauma has been shown to lead to
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, con- Trauma has been described as an over- disadvantages in a child’s educational jour-
duct disorder, oppositional defiance disor- whelming experience that can forever alter ney. Robert F. Anda and colleagues con-
der, reactive attachment, disinhibited social one’s belief that the world is good and safe. ducted a large epidemiological study of
engagement, and/or acute stress disorders. A simple trauma can be defined as a short- adults who reported adverse childhood ex-
In this article, we contend that the class- occurrence or one-time event that threatens periences in their youth. The study was
room can be positioned as a powerful place of bodily injury or serious harm (e.g., accidents funded by the Centers for Disease Control
intervention for posttraumatic healing both in or natural disasters), which can be accom- and Prevention, and the sample was sourced
the context of special education and in main- panied by a social innovations response such in a large HMO. The study found that indi-
stream classrooms that contain trauma- as coordinated support from civic organiza- viduals who experienced childhood abuse
affected students. The current landscape of tions. Complex trauma, sometimes referred were more likely to have been suspended or
trauma-informed practice for primary and to as relationship trauma, describes trau- expelled, failed a grade, have lower aca-
secondary classrooms has focused on teach- matic exposure that can be longer in dura- demic achievement assessments, be at sig-
ing practices that seek to repair emotional tion and involve multiple incidents, ongoing nificant risk for language delays, and be
dysregulation and fix broken attachment. In personal threat, violence, and violation. Ex- assigned to special education. Given these
working for more than a decade with main- amples include child abuse, neglect, bully- alarming rates of school struggle and failure,
stream and specialist schools, we have dis- ing, and sexual or domestic violence. In teachers must have the strategies and sup-
covered that positive psychology has a role simple trauma, the victim often receives lit- port needed to meet the complex needs that
to play in contributing to trauma-informed tle blame. For complex traumas, however, students bring to the classroom.
learning. We argue that combining trauma- the social innovations response may be mor-
informed approaches with positive psychol- ally ambiguous or cloaked in shame. In
ogy will empower and enable teachers to these cases, the child does not receive the
The Need for a
same kind of immediate care response given
Trauma-Informed
following simple trauma and is often impli-
Teaching Approach
cated or blamed for the trauma. It is important for children who experi-
Tom Brunzell, Lea Waters, and Helen Stokes, The American Psychiatric Association ence trauma to receive therapy by qualified
Melbourne Graduate School of Education, Uni- advises that directly experiencing a trauma, psychologists, psychiatrists, and/or social
versity of Melbourne.
witnessing a traumatic stressor, learning workers. However, many students and their
Correspondence concerning this article should
be addressed to Tom Brunzell, Melbourne Grad-
about trauma events, or exposure to adverse families lack access, motivation, and ability
uate School of Education, University of Mel- details can lead to enduring, debilitating to successfully participate in therapy and
bourne, 100 Leicester Street, Parkville Victoria conditions such as posttraumatic stress dis- follow treatment plans. For most students,
3010, Australia. E-mail: tbrunzell@student.unimelb order (PTSD). Childhood PTSD can have attending school is the most regular and
.edu.au significant effects on child development, in- predictable routine in their young lives. For
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry © 2015 American Orthopsychiatric Association
2015, Vol. 85, No. 1, 3–9 http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/ort0000048
social innovations
senior secondary students, access and adher- classroom learning depends on a well- opportunities to healthily modulate their ac-
ence to treatment may be lacking, but those organized and regulated brain— or at the tive heart rate and resting heart rate while
same young people will choose to attend very least, moments of regulatory align- simultaneously creating group cohesion and
school in an attempt to meet their needs for ment allowing students to access neural readiness for learning.
social belongingness and opportunities to resources to meet developmentally appro- For older students, rhythmic, patterned,
and regulatory activities can take the form of
mindful breathing, visualizations, yoga or
tai-chi adaptations, drumming, or music-
We believe that schools can be healing based activities. If possible, “brain-breaks”
institutions—in addition to academic institutions— for older students can involve short exercise
bursts on stationary equipment (e.g., tread-
for the 40% of the student population who are mill, bike, or elliptical machine), a walk
adversely affected by trauma around the sport oval, sport drills, or adap-
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
4
social innovations
arousal. Students must have multiple oppor- the Sanville Institute and psychologist Allan motivations and can engage in defensive
tunities throughout the day to build emo- Schore has described attachment in psychobi- reactions that reject and hurt the teachers
tional regulatory capacities to notice, under- ological models as a regulation process. This who attempt to show warm care toward
stand, and communicate their feelings to form of regulation, which begins in the them. They reject first to avoid the pain of
others. Teachers can design and incorporate mother– child dyad—as in the case of healthy being rejected (a pain they may have expe-
rienced many times over in their lives).
One example of such resistance is that of
a teacher struggling with an adolescent male
Attachment principles can guide teachers when student who had a background of suspension
nurturing relational strengths in students through and prior school disengagement. The
teacher had set up a classroom environment
classroom-based relationships of unconditional positive regard; yet, the
student’s first response to teacher correction
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
curricular opportunities such as analyzing development—initiates an attunement and this comment: “You are trading on your
texts through an emotion lens, drama-based regulatory process for the body’s stress re- good looks to get into our heads. You don’t
activities where students act out and de- sponses and relational hardiness. The presence care about us.” This teacher was initially
escalate emotions, or collaboratively problem or absence of nurturing interactions form fu- challenged and bewildered by the student’s
solve using student examples. For instance, ture templates for self-protection in the face of outburst, and it caused him to question if it
adversity, threats, or danger. In trauma- was indeed true. After consultation with his
one teacher we have coached has a favorite
affected families, these templates are inconsis- supervisor, this teacher reconnected to the
literacy activity where the students take differ-
tent and maladaptive because of unpredictable principle of unconditional positive regard,
ent highlighter colors to the text and code the
or erratic responses to stressor scenarios when developed a plan for modeling a moment of
text for emotion states and emotion shifts of
children cannot comfort or soothe themselves. mindful breathing, and committed to a con-
characters, paying special attention to when sistent de-escalation strategy to address
the character’s stress response escalates and Defensive behaviors such as aggression, with-
drawal, dissociation, and bullying can serve as these outbursts in a calm, regulatory man-
de-escalates accordingly. ner: “I see that you’re frustrated, and I’m
protective strategies for children as a conse-
quence of abuse or neglect. here to ensure your growth as a student.
Attachment principles can guide teachers Let’s give you two choices which will allow
when nurturing relational strengths in students you to accomplish today’s learning
through classroom-based relationships. Teach- aims. . . .” As part of this plan, an important
step in restoring the relationship became
Repairing Regulatory Abilities ers must establish strong relational founda-
consistent follow-up between teacher and
tions in the classroom to ground the students in
student to explain the effects of these sorts
safety and belonging. In a meta-analysis of the
of comments once both parties were in a
effects of teacher–student relationships, Jef-
• Aligning the body through sensory inte- calm state for successful reflection.
frey Cornelius-White of Missouri State Uni-
gration strategies (e.g., drumming, mu- Trauma-informed teachers must de-
versity found that strong classroom relation-
sic, circle games). velop a strong resolve to understand their
ships are built on teacher empathy, warmth,
• Weaving rhythm and repetition across own stress responses within the pressured
genuineness, nondirectivity, and the encour-
the school day, particularly during tran- context of the classroom. As models of
agement of critical thinking. He noted that
sition times. adulthood, teachers hold a position of
teachers do well when they approach student
• Introducing mindfulness strategies or sometimes-unacknowledged power. A re-
relationships as attempts to build reciprocal
mindful “brain breaks” throughout the
and secure attachments. Thus, we have
school day.
adapted Carl Rogers’ popularization of Stan-
• Staying consistent with classroom rou-
ley Standal’s concept of unconditional posi- Strengthening Relational and
tines which practice self-regulation.
tive regard for the classroom. A position of
unconditional positive regard encourages a
Attachment Styles
teacher to value a student regardless of his or
her behaviors, affect, or presentation. Carl
Disordered Attachment and Rogers refers to this as a warm caring for the • Building strong classroom relation-
Building Strong Relational child, which is neither possessive nor demand- ships through multiple, consistent,
Capacities ing of personal gratification for the adult. and daily relational interactions.
Such a task can be difficult with trauma- • Teaching emotional intelligence com-
The second emergent focus of trauma- affected students, given that these students petencies to understand self and others.
informed education that came through our re- struggle with backgrounds of broken family • Incorporating play and fun into class-
view of the literature concerns the healing of attachments and often have the inability to room learning as a way to shift affect
disordered attachment styles. The foundational create or sustain strong and lasting relation- and prepare for learning.
theorizing of John Bowlby, Judith Schore of ships. They may be suspicious of teachers’
5
social innovations
lationally based classroom is predicated psychological strengths, and heal their psy- positively related to a range of wellbeing
on the belief that struggling students will chological problems. outcomes including hope, optimism, resil-
put forth their best efforts for teachers Our argument to incorporate positive edu- ience, mindfulness, and other character
they like, respect, and believe will be pres- cation into trauma-affected teaching is sup- strengths. We contend that when teachers
ent for them at times when they are not at ported by sociologist Corey Keyes, who posits focus on repairing regulatory competencies
and maladaptive attachment styles together
with a positive education approach, the re-
sulting pedagogy is a full-bodied approach
Positive education offers an important perspective to where teachers can envision their classroom
trauma-informed models of classroom learning as a therapeutic milieu addressing the effects
of adverse childhood experiences and struc-
because it creates more pathways for teachers to turing trajectory-shifting learning to enable
address differentiated social and emotional skills posttraumatic growth, psychological wellbe-
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
students.
Psychologist Kate Hefferon incorporates
positive psychology in her research on trau-
their best. Teachers must continually work a two-factor theory of mental health. This the- ma’s effects on the body in participants who
to employ attachment-based principles to ory argues that building mental health requires have shown posttraumatic healing and
present consistent, proactive, and welcom- more than repairing illness. One does not learn growth. Similar to our work, Hefferon’s re-
ing invitations to remain in teacher– about one’s strengths by studying one’s weak- search advocates a mind-body approach ad-
student relational mirroring and modeling nesses, and it has been theorized that mental dressing the factors that promote posttrau-
to create safe opportunities for learning. health and mental illness are not opposite ends matic growth by increasing psychological
of the same continuum. Trauma-affected stu- resources through strengthening both social
dents need ever-present opportunities to build support and new strengths-based competen-
upon their strengths. Scholarship, especially in cies. We believe this same approach will
But Is It Enough? the field of positive psychology, continues to assist struggling students.
show that those who report struggles with
From a review of the literature on
mental illness and trauma also show posttrau-
trauma-informed teaching and learning Positive Education
matic growth and positive accommodation.
classroom models, two clear areas of in- Interventions in
We advocate a model of education that ac-
tervention are strongly positioned as im- a Trauma-Informed Classroom
knowledges the importance of increasing psy-
portant opportunities to intervene when
chological growth in the trauma-affected Our goal is to give trauma-affected stu-
supporting trauma-affected students—reg-
classroom through proven positive psychol- dents many more opportunities to build psy-
ulation and relationship. However, over
ogy interventions that increase wellbeing in chological resources through the inclusion
the last decade of working with main-
students. of positive education. We have suggested
stream and specialist schools to embed a
wellbeing approach using interventions, that building upon one’s strengths is both
we believe that positive psychology also theoretically and pragmatically different
has a role to play in contributing to
Positive Psychology and than addressing that which requires healing
trauma-informed learning. We argue that
Positive Education: Feeling (e.g., disrupted regulation and broken at-
combining trauma-informed approaches
Well and Doing Well tachment patterns). Many of the intervention
with positive psychology will empower Positive psychology is the empirical par- strategies in positive psychology require a
and enable teachers to promote both heal- adigm that studies wellbeing, human strong sense of cortical mediation incorpo-
ing and growth in their classrooms. strengths, and optimal functioning in indi- rating language, cognition, and social skills.
We know that teachers are assisted in viduals, groups, and organizations. Positive As such we argue for a sequential approach
conceptualizing their practice through a education is the application of positive psy- to the use of positive education in trauma-
healing lens by having the strategies re- chology in a school setting and positions affected classrooms.
quired to build regulatory processes and re- wellbeing learning to be of equal importance Here, we detail four specific interventions
lational strength. If trauma-affected students to academic learning. Positive education of- with examples of how positive education
do not increase their abilities in these two fers an important perspective to trauma- interventions have been successfully used
areas, they will not be nurturing their own informed models of classroom learning be- with trauma-affected classrooms in both
developmental stamina and persistence to cause it creates more pathways for teachers mainstream and specialist schools.
take on greater challenges in the future. We to address differentiated social and emo-
also want teachers to widen their under- tional skills development. Lea Waters, Chair
Positive Emotion as a
standings of wellbeing and strengths-based and Director of the Center for Positive Psy-
Priming Activity
approaches in the classroom because we be- chology at the University of Melbourne, re-
lieve that all students must be given oppor- viewed the field of positive education and Barbara Fredrickson from the University of
tunities to identify, practice, and grow their found that positive education activities are North Carolina has put forward the broaden-
6
social innovations
and-build theory of positive emotion, which short activities that grab students’ attention
explains that positive emotions broaden one’s at the beginning of the lesson. Often these Questions for Self-Assessment
thought-action repertoire and build social re- hooks are designed to intrigue and connect
sources. Among a number of effects in the preexisting student knowledge to the aims or
broaden hypothesis, positive emotions objectives of the current day’s lesson. This
1. What are the critical developmental
pathways that are thwarted by trauma
and how do the resulting maladaptive
Teaching character strengths in schools has been conditions affect learning?
shown to increase school performance, achievement, 2. Describe the two intervention areas
included in models for trauma-
and wellbeing; and to be an effective tool in affected classrooms.
planning higher education and career pathways 3. What are the arguments given by the
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
7
social innovations
8
social innovations
calm and focus through manualized resil- connection to others, and a recognition that Holocaust. In both cases, teachers were able to
iency programs (such as the Penn Resiliency even in dark times, people can benefit from invite individuals to their classrooms who
Program, University of Pennsylvania or practicing gratitude. could give first-hand accounts and stories of
MindUp, Scholastic). We have found that A useful definition of gratitude is being their survival to share with the students. What
once teachers learn these strategies and can aware and appreciating good things, particu- began as a desire to have dynamic, interactive
integrate them into their own lives, they are larly another’s actions, and experiencing the history lessons on trauma and resiliency be-
able to weave these resilient mindset inter- kindness of others. For trauma-affected stu- came unforgettable lessons in gratitude as
ventions into the life of the school day. dents, conversations around gratitude must the students recognized and created gestures
To incorporate resilience lessons into a lead to opportunities to “action gratitude.” of gratitude for the visiting guests. In both
busy school schedule, many classrooms be- Time and time again, we have found that stu- classrooms, the students invited the visitors
gin the day in a morning meeting or a morn- dents surprise themselves with positive action back to their classrooms. On the return vis-
ing classroom circle, where teachers intro- when given the time and encouragement to its, the students initiated and prepared
duce and then regularly review resiliency design their own gratitude initiatives. Grati- shared-meals, gestures of appreciation, and
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
vocabulary. A favorite strategy is to listen to tude also helps students to notice and capital- moderated the conversations themselves.
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
radio hits and have students identify the ize “small moments of good” that occur during These classroom moments are rich examples
resilient and nonresilient self-talk. It is a their day at school, such as laughing with a of education toward strengths and growth,
pretty easy task for students to determine if friend, having a heater in the classroom, or which occurred in rhythmic and regulated
the pop singer is catastrophizing their cur- lunch provided each day. These small mo- environments anchored in relationships of
rent state in a love song. If the classroom has ments can build a positive bank account that safety and belonging.
established a strong sense of peer trust and accrues emotional, cognitive, and social re-
safety, students bring up personal problems sources based on Fredrickson’s broaden-and-
or situations for seeking peer advice, and build theory. Conclusion
collaborative problem solving can occur In the positive psychology literature, grati- Trauma-informed models of teaching and
through a resilient mindset lens. tude activities have been shown to yield en- learning have been employed to connect and
Similarly, another popular activity is ask- during wellbeing effects through daily actions engage students in the classroom. By focusing
ing students to bring in Internet links of their such as keeping a gratitude journal, acknowl- on the two broad domains of improving self-
favorite sport clips or defining sporting mo- edging three good things, recalling what is regulation and building relational capacities,
ments. Teachers ask students to imagine working well, and making “gratitude visits” to trauma-informed teaching assists struggling
what parts of the brain might be firing at show appreciation to another. students to strengthen their capacity to learn.
those particular moments and what the re- In one school working with prior-identified With proper supports, students can develop the
silient or nonresilient self-talk may have trauma-affected students, a group of students stamina through self-regulation within a rela-
been for that athlete. Students can be very mutually decided to make the principal their tional context to find levels of safety and be-
insightful when placing themselves in “gratitude target” to thank her for extraordi- longing in the classroom that are necessary to
such positions, and these activities give nary efforts to include them in the life of the take learning risks. We believe that trauma-
teachers valuable opportunities to suggest school. Without the principal’s knowledge, the informed models of teaching and learning can
and insert resilient thinking cues into stu- students dedicated a week of doing small, se- be enhanced by embedding positive education
dent responses. cret favors for the principal, such as leaving into the classroom. We have introduced this
notes at her office and figuring out ways to third focus to trauma-informed teaching and
recognize her publicly. At the end of the week, suggest that teachers can increase psycholog-
Gratitude
all was revealed to the principal, and one ical resources such as positive emotion, char-
Teaching gratitude in trauma-affected young person exclaimed in the debrief: “I acter strengths, resiliency, and gratitude. By
classrooms has become a hallmark of our ef- knew that I was doing things for her so she adding positive education techniques to
forts to integrate positive education with would feel good, but I’m surprised about how trauma-informed teaching approaches, teach-
trauma-informed practice. At times, some of great I felt doing it.” These efforts are a pow- ers provide the 40% of students who are
the most well-meaning teachers that we have erful reminder that gratitude affects both the trauma-affected with the opportunity for both
worked with initially struggle with teaching giver and receiver, and gratitude can be an healing areas of deficit and growing areas of
gratitude. Teachers have told us that students effective way for trauma-affected students to strength. Our experience over the past decade
who have experienced traumatic stressors may build strong, empathetic relationships through with this approach has given us, the teachers,
find lessons on gratitude to be inappropriate action. and their students great cause for hope—a
given the trauma they have experienced. We Teacher educator Kerry Howell has sug- quintessential positive psychology emotion.
understand this concern and refer to psychol- gested that effective curriculum connections
ogist Robert Emmons, whose research in grat- can come through gratitude. Two classroom Keywords: classroom; pedagogy; positive
itude emphasizes an embodied sense of grati- examples involve teaching students units education; trauma; wellbeing; healing;
tude through action, lived experience, and about the Rwandan genocide and the Jewish growth