1 REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

2 CITY OF ANTIPOLO
3 PROVINCE OF RIZAL
4
5 RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS DURING THE 156th REGULAR SESSION OF THE
6 SANGGUNIANG PANLUNGSOD OF THE CITY OF ANTIPOLO, HELD ON JUNE 29, 2022 @ 9:30
7 A.M. DURING ITS FACE-TO-FACE REGULAR SESSION HELD AT THE SESSION HALL, 8TH
8 FLOOR, CITY HALL ANNEX BUILDING ANTIPOLO, RIZAL.
9
10 PRESENT:
11
12 Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan City Vice-Mayor/Presiding Officer
13
14 FIRST DISTRICT
15
16 Hon. Enrico C. De Guzman, M.D.,FPOGS City Councilor
17 Hon. Susana G. Say City Councilor
18 Hon. Arnel M. Camacho City Councilor
19 Hon. Christian Jay C. Tapales City Councilor
20 Hon. Lemuel Marlowe G. Zapanta City Councilor
21 Hon. Agnes G. Oldan-Gratil City Councilor
22 Hon. Robert A. Altamirano Jr. City Councilor
23 Hon. Felipe C. Pimentel, Sr. AFP (Ret.) City Councilor
24
25 SECOND DISTRICT
26
27 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop, M.D, M.P.M City Councilor
28 Hon. Catalino M. Leyva City Councilor
29 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales City Councilor
30 Hon. Antonio O. Masangkay City Councilor
31 Hon. Edward R. O’Hara City Councilor
32 Hon. Nixon R. Aranas City Councilor
33 Hon. Alfred J. Zapanta City Councilor
34
35
36 EX-OFFICIO MEMBERS
37
38 Hon. Jonathan C. Salen President, Liga ng mga Barangay
39 Hon. Peter Arnold S. Papel, Jr. SK Federation President
40 ABSENT:
41
42 GUEST/S:
43
44 The 156th regular session was called to order by the Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G.
45 Gatlabayan.
46
47 The reflection was shared by Hon. Philip Conrad M . Acop.
48
49 Invictus
50
51 By William Ernest Henley
52
53 Out of the night that covers me,
54 Black as the pit from pole to pole,
55 I thank whatever gods may be
56 For my unconquerable soul.
57 In the fell clutch of circumstance
58 I have not winced nor cried aloud.
59 Under the bludgeonings of chance

1
 60 My head is bloody, but unbowed.
61 Beyond this place of wrath and tears
62 Looms but the Horror of the shade,
63 And yet the menace of the years
64 Finds and shall find me unafraid.
65 It matters not how strait the gate,
66 How charged with punishments the scroll,
67 I am the master of my fate,
68 I am the captain of my soul.
69
70 Hon. Philip Conrad Acop manifested: “By tomorrow, new leaders will rise up, some old souls
71 will step down. To the new leaders, I would like to challenge them that despite the hardships,
72 despite the trials, speculations, despite the doubts, just remain steadfast in your purpose,
73 to protect Antipolo and that of Antipoleños. To the old souls who are stepping down, I don’t
74 think I have to remind you but we will meet in time, know noble ways to attain that
75 objective, some through our love ones who have given the chance to lead, others find noble
76 ways to help Antipoleños again. This pandemic is not yet over and there will be various and
77 different pandemic that may come, it may not be the same but these pandemic will come. A
78 new President is set to take his oath tomorrow as well, we do not know what he brings, we
79 do not know what kind of governance he will be setting as an example to all of us, just know
80 that if it is unpopular but right, stay the course but if it is wrong and popular be the one to
81 fight. It might be difficult but still, it is the right thing to do. With that po, that is the challenge
82 I will provide, I challenge myself first. And hopefully, with the days and years to come, we will
83 find a better Antipolo and a better future for Antipoleños. Thank you.”
84
85 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “That is a challenge to the new
86 City Council and I believe that we have done that, we have performed our role, our job
87 effectively and efficiently. Although, there are some battlenecks or some weaknesses on our
88 part, but, still, we don’t have this kind of decision might it be unanimous or majority, still, you
89 are the captain of your soul and the master of your faith. If one of us believe on his side
90 positively although, not drawing to the unanimous decision of the rest, you are the master of
91 your faith even if you don’t approve to the majority or unanimous decision, although may
92 kanya-kanya tayong pag-iisip, mayroon din tayong faith sa sarili natin na kung ano man ang
93 ating naging decision specially in the approval of a resolution or an ordinance, we hold on our
94 belief that your approval has something to prove that your side either positive or negative can
95 be depended on. Thank you very much, Coun. Philip Acop.”
96
97 The invocation was led by Hon. Enrico C. De Guzman. The Singing of the Philippine National
98 Anthem was led by Hon. Susana G. Say. The Recital of the Councilor’s Creed was led by
99 Hon. Arnel M. Camacho.
100
101 Roll call. The Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod conducted the roll call and since he
102 counted sixteen (16) members of the august body, the Presiding Officer declared the
103 presence of a quorum.
104
105 E. READING AND APPROVAL OF THE RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS DURING THE 155 th
106 REGULAR SESSION OF THE SANGGUNIANG PANLUNGSOD HELD LAST JUNE 24, 2022 AS PER
107 SECTION 52 (e) OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE OF 1991.
108
109 The Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod manifested: “I would like to beg for your
110 indulgence, due to time constraint, my stenographic staff was not able to finish the Record of
111 the Proceedings.”
112
113 Hon. Enrico De Guzman manifested: “I move that the Minute of the previous session be
114 adopted pending review of the Members of the Council.”
115
116 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “There is a motion from our
117 Majority Floor Leader that the Minutes of the Procedings is pending review and to be

2
118 adopted and approved by the august body next regular session upon the presentation of the
119 Minutes of the 155th Regular Session of the Sangguniang Panlungsod held last June 24, 2022
120 and has been hosted by yours truly.”
121
122 F. SIGNING PERIOD
123
124 G. FIRST READING (READING AND REFERRAL OF PROPOSED MEASURES, ORDINANCES,
125 RESOLUTIONS, PETITIONS, LETTERS AND OTHER COMMUNICATIONS).
126
127 1. LETTER dated 16 June 2022 from the Office of the Mayor, CERTIFIED URGENT, RE: Request
128 for the enactment of an ordinance entitled, “An Ordinance Cancelling Franchises on the
129 Establishment and Operation of All Online Gaming and Betting Sites Including the
130 Operation of Off-Cockpit and Off-Track Betting Stations in the City of Antipolo, Providing
131 Penalties for Violation Thereof, and For Other Purposes.”
132
133 THE SAID MATTER WAS JOINTLY REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON RESOLUTIONS,
134 ORDINANCES AND LEGAL MATTERS, CHAIRED BY HON. IRVIN PAULO C. TAPALES, THE
135 LEAD COMMITTEE, THE COMMITTEE ON LOCAL FRANCHISING, CHAIRED BY HON.
136 LEMUEL MARLOWE G. ZAPANTA AND TO THE COMMITTEE ON GAMES AND
137 AMUSEMENT, CHAIRED BY HON. CHRISTIAN JAY C. TAPALES.
138
139 Hon. Enrico De Guzman moved for the suspension of the rules in the order of business,
140 duly seconded and approved by the members of the august body.
141
142 Hon. Enrico De Guzman moved that this matter be included under the Calendar of
143 Business, Business for the day (2nd) reading, for today’s regular session, duly seconded and
144 approved by the members of the august body.
145
146 2. Endorsement dated 27 June 2022 from the City Budget Office, RE: Six (6) Copies of the Re-
147 submitted FY 2022 Annual Budget (AB) Documents of the Sangguniang Kabataan (SK) of
148 Barangay San Luis Amounting to Eight Million Pesos Only (Php8,000,000.00) embodied
149 under SK Resolution No. 2021-26, which is under review by the members of the City of
150 Antipolo Finance Committee (CAFC).
151
152 THE SAID MATTER WAS JOINTLY REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET, FINANCE
153 AND APPROPRIATION, CHAIRED BY HON. IRVIN PAULO C. TAPALES, THE LEAD
154 COMMITTEE AND TO THE COMMITTEE ON YOUTH AND SPORTS DEVELOPMENT,
155 CHAIRED BY HON. PETER ARNOLD S. PAPEL, JR.
156
157 3. MEMORANDUM ORDER dated 27 June 2022 from the Office of the Mayor, RE: DILG
158 Memorandum dated 16 June 2022 and entitled, “Guidelines on the Accreditation of Civil
159 Society Organizations and Selection of Representatives to the Local Special Bodies.”
160
161 THE SAID MATTER WAS REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON ACCREDITATION, CHAIRED
162 BY HON. NIXON R. ARANAS.
163
164 4. LETTER dated 03 June 2022 from the Office of the Mayor, CERTIFIED URGENT, RE: Request
165 for the adoption of a resolution entitled, ”A Resolution Authorizing the Hon. Andrea B.
166 Ynares, City Mayor, to Enter Into and Sign, and Execute a Deed of Donation and
167 Acceptance Relative to the Donation of Composter and Shredder and Memorandum of
168 Agreement Between the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR)
169 through the Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) Represented by its Director, Engr.
170 William P. Cuñado and the City Government of Antipolo, Represented by Hon. Andrea B.
171 Ynares Relative to the Validity of the Deed of Donation and For Other Purposes.”
172
173 THE SAID MATTER WAS JOINTLY REFFERED TO THE COMMITTEE ON RESOLUTIONS,
174 ORDINANCES AND LEGAL MATTERS, CHAIRED BY HON. IRVIN PAULO C. TAPALES, THE
175 LEAD COMMITTEE, THE COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE, CHAIRED BY HON. PHILIP

3
176 CONRAD M. ACOP AND TO THE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND
177 NATURAL RESOURCES, CHAIRED BY HON. CATALINO M. LEYVA.
178
179 Hon. Enrico De Guzman moved that this matter be included under the Calendar of
180 Business, Business for the day (2nd) reading, for today’s regular session, duly seconded and
181 approved by the members of the august body.
182
183 5. Entry of Appearance of Atty. Harold Elmo O. Banzuela, Counsel for Respondent with
184 Motion For Extension of Time to File Counter Affidavit, RE: Complaint-Affidavit Filed by
185 BERNADETTE B. ALMOROS VS ROMULO B. BALOLOY, Kagawad, Brgy. San Luis for Sexual
186 Harassment.
187
188 THE SAID MATTER WAS REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON RESOLUTIONS, ORDINANCES
189 AND LEGAL MATTERS, CHAIRED BY HON. IRVIN PAULO C. TAPALES.
190
191 OTHER MATTER
192
193 6. Letter, dated June 28, 2022 from the Office of the City Mayor, CERTIFIED URGENT, RE:
194 Request for adoption of an Ordinance relative to the Reversion of Continuing
195 Appropriation under the General Fund- Infrastructure, Twenty Percent Development
196 Fund and Disaster Risk Reduction Management Fund, amounting to P174,842,776.91,
197 P80,116,633.82 and P49,844,767.20, respectively.”
198
199 H. COMMITTEE REPORT
200 None
201
202 I. CALENDAR OF BUSINESS
203 Unfinished Business:
204 2nd Reading
205
206 1. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2022-646, “An Ordinance Granting a Special Use Permit (SUP)
207 to Mr. Guil Carl Uy, VP of Operations, Sto. Niño De Cebu Resources and Development
208 Corp., to Operate, Manage and Maintain a Providence Memorial Park Antipolo with a Total
209 Area of Ninety-Four Thousand Seven Hundred Two Square Meters (94,702sqm) located at
210 Sitio Pandayan, Barangay Inarawan, City of Antipolo, Subject to Existing and Applicable
211 Laws and Conditions, and for Other Purposes.”
212
213 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “PAUi” C. Tapales
214 Sponsored by: Committee on Planning, Land Utilization, Housing and Settlement
215
216 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, with regard to these items: Proposed
217 Ordinance No. 2022-646 and Proposed Ordinance No. 2022-646, since we don’t have a
218 material time to discuss and finish these, I move for the deferment of these two items until
219 these are place on the new members of the committees concern.”
220
221 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Coun. Paui, have you
222 received the necessary documents including other requirements?”
223
224 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Yes, Madam and it is the same document that we
225 are going to transfer to the Office of the Vice Mayor thru the Secretariat.”
226
227 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “It has been deferred
228 already last regular session, for what reason you are deferring it again?”
229
230 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, as I said, we do not have a material time, I
231 concentrated on ones I wasn’t finish.”
232
233 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “What particular material?”

4
234 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, what I mean is I am concentrating on
235 several measures I wasn’t able to finish.”
236
237 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Are you referring to the
238 referral that has been discussed previously but not yet approve?”
239
240 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Yes, Madam. For example the Budget of Brgy.
241 Inarawan, maybe I can finish it today. I would rather spend my remaining hours discussing
242 the matter I haven’t finish.”
243
244 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Alright, accepted. You have
245 to coordinate with the Secretariat, to give the documents to the next Committee Chairman
246 of Committee on Budget, Finance and Appropriation.”
247
248 The Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod manifested: “Madam, I already post giving
249 due notice with the incumbent members of this august body regarding the respective
250 committees for transmittal of those pending legislative matters to my office, for
251 submission to the incoming Committee Chairman of the next Council.”
252
253 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Thank you, we believe that
254 everyone is aware that we are in the transition period and similarly, we have also the one
255 that you have deferred, the Proposed Ordinance No. 2022-647 and that refers to the
256 granting Special Use Permit (SUP) to Mr. Benjamin P. Salvador, for the Operation and
257 Management of a Slaughterhouse on a Property Embraced Under TCT Nos. R-39219,
258 175235, 175238, Containing an Aggregate Area of Seven Thousand One Hundred Thirty-
259 One Square Meters (7,131sqm) located at Marcos Highway, Barangay Cupang. Okay, you
260 are deferring the discussion of this aforementioned ordinance, for what reason?”
261
262 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, when we approve slaughterhouse, we
263 inspect them. The last termer, we don’t have time if we are going to inspect them, so on
264 and so forth. So, we would rather refer it the next officer. If we are going to concentrate
265 the effort of passing a Slaughterhouse , it will take a month or six weeks.”
266
267 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, in as much as the
268 Vice-Chairman of the Committee on PLUHS is around, all the documents will be accorded to
269 you and just be ready for the deliberation as soon as you are prepared.”
270
271 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, on my last term, we approved two
272 slaughterhouse, for each are we do ocular inspection.”
273
274 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, thank you.”
275
276 The said matter was deferred.
277
278 2. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2022-647, “An Ordinance Granting a Special Use Permit (SUP)
279 to Mr. Benjamin P. Salvador, for the Operation and Management of a Slaughterhouse on a
280 Property Embraced Under TCT Nos. R-39219, 175235, 175238, Containing an Aggregate
281 Area of Seven Thousand One Hundred Thirty-One Square Meters (7,131sqm) located at
282 Marcos Highway, Barangay Cupang.”
283
284 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “PAUi” C. Tapales
285 : Coun. Felipe C. Pimentel, Sr.
286 Sponsored by: Committee on Planning, Land Utilization, Housing and Settlement
287 Committee on Market and Slaughterhouse
288
289 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the deferment of the said measure.
290
291 The said matter was deferred.

5
292 3. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2022-094, “A Resolution Declaring Appropriation Ordinance
293 No. 2021-001 Entitled “An Ordinance Authorizing the Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 Annual Budget
294 of Barangay Inarawan in the Amount of Forty-Three Million Six Hundred Fifty-Four
295 Thousand Six Hundred Twenty-Eight Pesos (Php43,654,628.00) Covering the Various
296 Expenditures for the Operation of the Barangay Government and Appropriating the
297 Necessary Funds for the Purpose”, OPERATIVE.
298
299 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “Paui” C. Tapales
300 Sponsored by: Committee on Budget, Finance and Appropriations
301
302 The Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod manifested: “Madam, I have here with me
303 two resolutions adopted by the Sangguniang Barangay of Inarawan, Resolution No. 020-
304 2022, “A Resolution Ratifying the Approval for the Improvement of the Second Floor of the
305 Barangay Hall Comprising the Office of the Punong Barangay with Restroom, Sangguniang
306 Barangay Office with Restroom, Treasury Office, Admin Office, Secretariat Office with
307 Restroom and the Lobby”, and Resolution No. 021-2022, “A Resolution Approving the
308 Improvement of the Ground Floor of the Barangay Hall Comprising the Office of the
309 Reception Area, BPSO Office, BADAC Office, Lupon Office, VAWC Office, a Kitchen with a
310 Common Restroom and a Minor Improvement of Health Office. May I turnover this letter
311 to Coun. Paui for the sponsoring speech of Brgy. Inarawan Resolution.”
312
313 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, when we discussed the budget of Brgy.
314 Inarawan, there were two major items that were not tackled and answered at the same
315 time. This matter is the Budget of Brgy. Inarawan, when we check the budget, it was
316 approved but there was a typographical error, it was discussed, they cannot reduce the
317 budget. The second item that was discussed is the veracity of the renovation of the
318 barangay in time of pandemic. What they discussed is to pass a resolution in order for
319 them to continue the renovation of the barangay. Just for safety, we advise them to make
320 the necessary resolution instead of antidating the resolution, they made a ratificatory
321 resolution from the renovation. Even it is already on the budget that was budgeted that
322 they are going to renovate the barangay. During the time of pandemic, they also made a
323 resolution, Resolution No. 020-2022, “A Resolution Ratifying the Approval for the
324 Improvement of the Second Floor of the Barangay Hall Comprising the Office of the Punong
325 Barangay with Restroom, Sangguniang Barangay Office with Restroom, Treasury Office,
326 Admin Office, Secretariat Office with Restroom and the Lobby.” and the Resolution No. 021-
327 2022, “A Resolution Approving the Improvement of the Ground Floor of the Barangay Hall
328 Comprising the Office of the Reception Area, BPSO Office, BADAC Office, Lupon Office,
329 VAWC Office, a Kitchen with a Common Restroom and a Minor Improvement of Health
330 Office.” In this regard, I believe the Barangay. Inarawan was able to satisfy the worry of
331 Sanggunian.”
332
333 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, any comment?”
334
335 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, if I may add, I checked the records of
336 Brgy. Inarawan, as we know before they come up with the budget, the Barangay
337 Development Council had convened. So, they have the common residents of the Barangay
338 and the other several members of their barangay. So, the Barangay Development Council
339 was able to come up with the Annual Investment Program of the Barangay and they
340 intended the people of the Barangay Inarawan to add additional funds in order for them to
341 renovate their barangay. Since, the AIP was the basis of Barangay, they made sure that
342 they included it on the budget. And despite the fact that there was a Budget Ordinance of
343 Brgy. Inarawan, we required them to pass this resolution also for their protection.”
344
345 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, any comment? Yes,
346 Coun. Alfred?”
347
348 Hon. Alfred J. Zapanta manifested: “I just want to know if the resolution is unanimously
349 approve?”

6
350
351 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Yes, Madam.”
352
353 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Yes, I received also the two
354 resolution. Anymore? Yes, Coun. Nixon?”
355
356 Hon. Nixon R. Aranas manifested: “Not a query, Madam. Good for them to be able to
357 comply with the requirements. We know the fact that the resolution has an important
358 role when it comes to the requirements. So, actually I am the one who raised the issue, to
359 approve a resolution. I’m glad that they were able to comply. Wala na po akong masasabi,
360 that’s good kasi para naman po sa kanila ang ginagawa natin.”
361
362 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Area you satisfied now?”
363
364 Hon. Nixon R. Aranas manifested: “Yes, Madam. I am satisfied now.”
365
366 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Yes, Coun. Edward?”
367
368 Hon. Edward R. O’Hara manifested: “In terms of additional budget for the improvement of
369 the barangay, ano po yung final budget for the health programs po?”
370
371 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “The final budget for Health
372 is Php900,000.00 po, that is from Php500,000.00 po from last year. Brgy. Inarawan is the
373 one that has not any problem in terms of services of the hospital because the biggest
374 hospital is located in their barangay.”
375
376 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, all those very
377 important data in budget of Brgy. Inarawan in the Year 2021, the question and all the
378 typographical errors in the aspect of health has been corrected already. Second, the
379 barangay has stipulated two resolutions regarding the improvement of 1 st and 2nd floor of
380 the barangay. I believe all the questions laid on the floor have been answered and verified.
381 Coun. Paui, what is now your decision?”
382
383 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the approval of the said measure on 2 nd reading.
384
385 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
386 on 2nd reading.
387
388 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the approval of the said measure on 3rd and final
389 reading.
390
391 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
392 on 3rd and final reading.
393
394 UPON THE UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE MEMBERS PRESENT, PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO.
395 2022-094, WAS FINALLY APPROVED.
396
397 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “May I ask if you are really
398 for the calling of the Barangay Captain by the time their budget and appropriation be
399 discussed and deliberated. Would it be better to confirm to them prior to the discussion
400 of the barangay, so that we can thresh out possible questions to be asked. Kasi, the usual
401 way is pinatatawag namin sila para i-discuss, so that we will be able to save time.”
402
403 Hon. Enrico C. De Guzman manifested: “Madam, we can set a Committee Hearing inviting
404 all the personalities prior the deliberation of budget ordinance.”
405
406 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Exactly, that is what I am
407 referring too. Anymore suggestion?”

7
408
409 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “Good morning po. I sought the manifestion of the
410 Presiding Officer, I think the Sanggunian has knowledge in knowing about this budget
411 ordinance. Tama po kayo, kailangan nating lagyan ng tatak natin bilang Sangguniang
412 Panlungsod ng Antipolo yung mga bagay na inaaprubahan natin. Hindi tayo padalos-dalos
413 sa mga inaaprubahan natin. Dapat, gamitin po natin iyon bilang karagdagang haligi,
414 katibayan po sa ipinapasa natin. Hindi lang dapat tayo ay tumitingin don sa mga boards,
415 yung Financial Board o Zoning Board, yung ating ginawang basehan. Tama po kayo, tayo
416 ang mapapahiya, kung sakaling inaprubahan ng mga boards na ito, hindi na tayo nag banat
417 ng buto, sa bandang huli ive-veto. Para po sa akin, ang pag veto ay isang sampal sa
418 Sanggunian dahil ang sinasabi niya ay nag kulang tayo sa pag timbang sa mga aplikasyon na
419 nasa harapan natin. So, let it be a lesson to the next Sanggunian that much as the board
420 we created helps us, they are still humans, prone to mistakes, prone to temptations. Sana
421 po, we use it as a basis. I agree po with the Presiding Officer, we need to see the people,
422 their intentions might be good but we need to see most substance and process follows po.
423 I think, minsan kulang sa substance, kadalasan kulang sa proseso.”
424
425 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Thank you, Coun. Acop.
426 Yes, Coun. Camacho?”
427
428 Hon. Arnel M. Camacho manifested: “Marami pong advantages having face-to-face. I
429 remember being the Chairman on Committee on Public Utilities and Facilities which we
430 invited applicants. Ang dami pong natututunan ng Council for inviting them. Aside from
431 inviting them, we might as well invite those important applicants, especially the Barangay
432 Council. Lalong lalo na po sa incoming Councilors.”
433
434 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay. In order to help, first
435 we have to invite the applicant for Committee Hearing as what Coun. Enrico has suggested
436 especially the Lead Committee and discuss to among members, to talk it all about. Meron
437 tayong Conference Room dyan. Second, you have to see the documents, tingnan niyo na
438 muna ang documents. Anyway Joy, thank you very much for sending us the agenda and
439 some related information. Aside from inviting them, check the documents. If others are
440 given a chance on scrutinizing the documents, they have to be informed prior to the
441 deliberation because there might be possible questions to be asked during the
442 deliberation. Third, make sure that you invite them in our Session Hall. Is it clear my dear
443 colleagues? For the new set of Council, pagka ganyan pag-uusapan ninyo.”
444
445
446 Business For The Day
447 3RD Reading
448
449
450 2ND Reading
451 1. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2022-102, ”A Resolution Authorizing the Hon. Andrea B.
452 Ynares, City Mayor, to Enter Into and Sign, a Memorandum of Agreement with Audrey
453 Heights Phase 2B Relocation Homeowners Association, Inc., Relative to the Request of the
454 Latter to Make the City Government of Antipolo, through the Urban Settlement and
455 Development Office (USDO), as their Originating Institution in the Acquisition of a Parcel of
456 Land Situated at Sitio Banaba I, Barangay San Luis, City of Antipolo, Registered Under the
457 Name of Winning Homes Realty and Development Corporation, Covered and Embraced
458 Under Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) Nos. R-36724, R-36725, et.al. (37 Titles), Involving
459 an Aggregate Area of Three Thousand Six Hundred Twelve Square Meters (3,612sqm)
460 More or Less, Through the Community Mortgage Program (CMP) of the Social Housing
461 Finance Corporation (SHFC).
462
463 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “Paui” C. Tapales
464 Sponsored by: Committee on Resolutions, Ordinances and Legal Matters
465

8
466 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “Since 1992, the Congress enacted RA 7279 which is
467 the Act to provide for a Comprehensive and Continuing Urban Development and Housing
468 Program, Establish the Mechanism for its Implementation, and for Other Purposes. It was
469 declared Under Section 2, it shall be the policy of the State to undertake in cooperation
470 withn the private sector, a comprehensive and continuing Urban Development and Housing
471 Program, hereinafter referred to as the program. With this, we were able to have or
472 established the Social Housing Finance Corporation or the SHFC. It was created through
473 Executive Order No. 272 and it directs the transfer of the Community Mortgage Program,
474 Abot- Kaya Pabahay Fund Program, and other Social Housing Powers and Functions of
475 the National Home Mortgage Finance Corporation to the Social Housing Finance
476 Corporation. With this, the SHFC delegate the Urban Poor to at least to have a decent
477 housing for them. We have two parties here, the Audrey Heights , this party is the
478 Homeowners Association located at Phase 2B and the other party is the Winning Homes
479 Realty, the owner of the property. In here, these parties entered into a Memorandum of
480 Agreement wherein the owner is willing to sell to the association and the association is
481 willing to purchase the property in the amount of P26,343,230.00, and both parties agree
482 that the acquisition of the said property is through the Community Mortgage Program.
483 Since this is a CMP, the Local Government of Antipolo which will be represented by the
484 Local Chief Executive will be the originator. This is the reason why the Hon. Andrea B.
485 Ynares is seeking the indulgence of the august body to allow her to enter into and sign the
486 Memorandum of Agreement.”
487
488 Hon. Enrico De Guzman manifested: “I would like to ask the total number of the
489 occupants and the status of negotiation with the Winning Homes?”
490
491 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “How many lots are there in
492 the Audrey Heights?”
493
494 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “The number of beneficiaries are 55, all in all.”
495
496 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “Coun. Paui, the area is 3,612
497 sqm., how many are the members of the Audrey Heights Subdivision? This is a relocation
498 of Phase 2B.”
499
500 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “55 household, they will be sharing the property of
501 3,612 sqm. covered by 37 titles and.”
502
503 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “How many lots are to be
504 awarded to the members?”
505
506 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “At the moment, there are 37 titles, once the sale is
507 consumed, the Audrey Heights Subdivision will have its new title once it was awarded to
508 them.”
509
510 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “The number of household
511 members will still be pending, what is important here is the negotiation between the
512 Audrey Heights and the acceptance of the owner. With that agreement, they do request
513 the City Government of Antipolo as the Originator or Facilitator so that the Memorandum
514 of Agreement upon the approval and signing of the City Government of Antipolo through
515 our City Mayor can help maintain the request, so that this Memorandum of Agreement can
516 be done.”
517
518 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “The intention of the program is to assist the legally
519 organized association for them to have a decent home.”
520
521 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “Coun. Nixon, has the Audrey
522 Homeowners Association already requested for accreditation?”
523

9
524 Hon. Nixon Aranas manifested: “Wala pa po.”
525
526 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “What is important is to show
527 our Mayor, Andrea Ynares who always mention her objective of extending to the
528 community the Malasakit. And one way of showing malasakit is to provide houses specially
529 to those who have been relocated. With that, we will be helping our people.”
530
531 Hon. Edward O’Hara manifested: “The amount per square meter is P7,000 plus.”
532
533 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “I remember when we went
534 there during the Inauguration there were already prepared units for sale and this is also
535 another program of the owner to just have one association for a certain parcel of lot, para
536 sa kanila iyan. Ito ba ay lote lang o kasama ang bahay?”
537
538 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “Just the lot.”
539
540 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “The association is expected to
541 give down payment. “
542
543 Hon. Alfred Zapanta manifested: “What is the agreement between the beneficiaries and
544 the USDO?”
545
546 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “Other than the amount of the property and the area
547 that we mentioned, the payment and release of titles, it provides upon the submission of
548 all the documents for the CMP, the SHFC shall issue a Letter of Guarantee in favor of the
549 vendor in the amount equivalent to the take out proceeds of the guaranteed loan. And
550 upon the issuance of the Letter of Guarantee by the SHFC, the vendor shall execute an
551 Absolute Deed of Sale.”
552
553 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “There are many conditions
554 stated here;
555 1.) Payments for the said land coming from the loan applied by each member/beneficiary
556 from the SHFC.
557 2.) The vendee shall guarantee that all their members/beneficiaries shall comply with all
558 the financial obligations of the organization and the completion of all necessary
559 documents
560 3.) The vendor shall shoulder all expenses for the payment of Capital Gains Tax,
561 Documentary Stamp Tax on sale to the Bureau of Internal Revenues, Transfer Taxes
562 at the Assessor’s and Treasurer’s Office
563 4.) Real Property Tax and all expenses in the preparation and notarization of the Deed of
564 Absolute Sale and this agreement.
565
566 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “Mayroon na silang agreement
567 na naka prepare?”
568
569 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “Yes po Maám. Actually this is in a form of a contract
570 but the terms of payment is according to SHFC.”
571
572 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “Normally, ilang years to pay?
573 25 years? 30 years? With this MOA that was being sought by the association and the
574 owner, is already a manifestation of their interest as well as their objecting a property.”
575
576 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “This amount will be divided by the 55 household
577 unequally, it will depend on the lot area they have.”
578
579 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “The owner has the option to
580 buy one or two lots.
581

10
582 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales moved for the approval of the said measure on 2 nd reading.
583
584 here being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
585 on 2nd reading.
586
587 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales moved for the approval of the said measure on 3 rd and final
588 reading.
589
590 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
591 on 3rd and final reading.
592
593 UPON THE UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE MEMBERS PRESENT, PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO.
594 2022-102, WAS FINALLY APPROVED.
595
596 2. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2022-103, “A Resolution Declaring the 2022 Annual Budget
597 (AB) of the Sangguniang Kabataan (SK) of Barangay Mayamot Amounting to Seven Million
598 Six Hundred Forty-Eight Thousand One Hundred Six Pesos and 10/100 (Php7,648,106.10)
599 embodied under SK Resolution No. 20 Series of 2021.”, OPERATIVE.
600
601 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “Paui” C. Tapales
602 Sponsored by: Committee on Budget, Finance and Appropriations
603
604 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, since the Sanggunian has a policy, inviting
605 the personnel from the barangay, not only to scutinize their budget but to establish two
606 learning way process, from the barangay to Sanggunian. My deferment is not for the
607 purpose of postponing them but in order for me to transfer it to the next committee
608 Chairman.”
609
610 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “So, what is your plan?”
611
612 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the deferment of the said measure.
613
614 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Yes, Coun. Acop?”
615
616 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “With regards to the barangay budget ordinance
617 po, do we invite them?”
618
619 The Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod manifested: “There is no manifestation from
620 the Chairman po.”
621
622 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “So, we never extend an invitation
623
624 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Alright, as requested, we
625 will be inviting the barangay in conference prior its discussion so that we will be sorting
626 questions and answers, likewise we will be cleared if there are still pending prerequisites
627 on the submitted documents. And therefore, we can invite them to appear, it depends on
628 the Chairman.”
629
630 The said matter was deferred.
631
632 3. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2022-104, “A Resolution Declaring the FY 2022 Annual
633 Budget (AB) documents of Barangay Dela Paz Amounting to Ninety-Eight Million Six
634 Hundred Thirty-Four Thousand Six Hundred Sixty-Four Pesos Only (Php98,634,664.00)
635 embodied under Appropriation Ordinance No. 2021-01.”, OPERATIVE.
636
637 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “Paui” C. Tapales
638 Sponsored by: Committee on Resolutions, Ordinances and Legal Matters
639

11
640 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the deferment of the said measure.
641
642 The said matter was deferred.
643
644 4. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2022-651, ”An Ordinance Approving the Application for
645 Special Use Permit (SUP) Filed by Ms. Opalyn P. Torres, Operations Manager of Haven of
646 Angels Memorial Chapels and Crematorium Inc., for the Operation of Memorial Chapel
647 and Crematorium Embraced Under TCT Nos. R-78717, 163-2015002307, R-96766 and 163-
648 2014003391 with a Total Area of Nine Thousand Four Hundred Fifty-Two Square Meters
649 (9,452sqm) Located at Sumulong Highway, Barangay Sta. Cruz, Antipolo City.”
650
651 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “Paui” C. Tapales
652 Sponsored by: Committee on Resolutions, Ordinances and Legal Matters
653
654 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the deferment of the said measure.
655
656 The said matter was deferred.
657
658 5. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2022-105, ”A Resolution Authorizing the Hon. Andrea B.
659 Ynares, City Mayor, to Enter Into and Sign, a Memorandum of Agreement with SUNRISE
660 VALLEY HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION INC., Represented by its President, Malonie
661 Bayrante, Relative to the Request of the Latter to Make the City Government of Antipolo,
662 through the Urban Settlement and Development Office (USDO), as their Originating
663 Institution in the Acquisition of a Portion of a Parcel of Land Measuring Twenty Thousand
664 Square Meters (20,000sqm) More or Less Situated at Sitio Tanza II, Barangay San Jose, City
665 of Antipolo Covered and Embraced under TCT No. N-136899, with a Total Land Area of
666 Fifty-Two Thousand Four Hundred Sixty-Eight Square Meters More or Less (52,468sqm),
667 through the Community Mortgage Program (CMP) of the Social Housing Finance
668 Corporation (SHFC).”
669
670 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo “Paui” C. Tapales
671 Sponsored by: Committee on Resolutions, Ordinances and Legal Matters
672
673 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, the preliminaries we have earlier is the
674 same. The pertinent discussion what we discuss is, all in all, the property is amounting to
675 Php15,400,000.00 and the lot area is only a portion of 20,000 sqm. There are 280
676 beneficiaries, Madam. This is located at Sitio Tanza II po, when you enter to the Prayer
677 Mountain, there is a subdivision there. If there are no other question po, I move for its
678 approval under 2nd reading po.”
679
680 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, the discussion of this
681 measure is the same with the Audrey Heights Phase 2B Relocation Homeowners
682 Association, Inc., that you have approved under 2 nd, 3rd and final reading. How much is the
683 cost per square meter?”
684
685 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “Php770.00 per square meter po.”
686
687 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay. It depends on the
688 accessibility, owner and the development of the vicinity.”
689
690 Hon. Alfred J. Zapanta manifested: “Madam, is this part of the watershed protected area?”
691
692 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “No, Madam.”
693
694 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Have you verify the status
695 of the title?”
696
697 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Yes, Madam.”

12
698 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Talagang kanya?”
699
700 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Yes, Madam.”
701
702 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, there will be no
703 problem.”
704
705 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “Siguro po we have to contextualize on what we
706 have in Audrey Heights po, we have a situation wherein there are families existing with
707 their own. Basically, squatters po sila. It’s not their land but they built houses po. What we
708 are doing now is addressing the problem of the owner, may lupa siya pero hindi niya
709 magamit dahil may mga nakatira. Ina-address natin yung problema nung mga nakatira dun
710 na may bahay pero hindi naman kanila ang lupa. So, with what we approved earlier, the
711 Audrey Heights, we are actually addressing the problem, the land owner and the house
712 owner po.”
713
714 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “What is the situation of the
715 homeowners of Sunrise?”
716
717 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, they are accredited by the City
718 Government of Antipolo.”
719
720 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “In other words, this
721 resolution which seek the government to be the originator has approval of the owner to
722 sell the lot and their homeowners is accredited by the City Governement. Coun. Paui, what
723 is now your pleasure?”
724
725 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales moved for the approval of the said measure on 2 nd, 3rd and final
726 reading.
727
728 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
729 on 2nd, 3rd and final reading.
730
731 UPON THE UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE MEMBERS PRESENT, PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO.
732 2022-105, WAS FINALLY APPROVED.
733
734 6. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2022-652, An Ordinance Cancelling Franchises on the
735 Establishment and Operation of All Online Gaming and Betting Sites Including the
736 Operation of Off-Cockpit and Off-Track Betting Stations in the City of Antipolo, Providing
737 Penalties for Violation Thereof, and For Other Purposes.”
738
739 Hon. Cristian Jay C. Tapales manifested: “Good morning. Madam, kung mapapansin po
740 natin sa title, Cancelling Franchises on the Establishment and Operation of All Online
741 Gaming and Betting Sites. Maganda po and in respect din po para sa Vatican declaring
742 Antipolo Cathderal as the International Shrine sa Southeast Asia.”
743
744 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Any question? Yes, Coun.
745 Alfred?”
746
747 Hon. Alfred J. Zapanta manifested: “Thank you, Madam. For the longest time, si Coun.
748 Acop, Coun. Camacho and myself, hindi talaga kami pumipirma when it comes to E-games
749 and betting site. Ito po bang ordinance na ito also includes the E-Bingo?”
750
751 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “What do you think, Coun.
752 Acop?”
753
754 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “Madam, first, finally. Second, I fought to
755 gambling or E-Games in the City. We always wanted to be the Pilgrimage City and yet, we

13
756 allow it right at the doorstep of our Cathedral, yung E-Games po. Yung mismong dadaanan
757 ng prusisyon, ng mga umaakyat po ay talamak sa E-Games. It is contrary to what we want.
758 When Coun. Zapanta was the Chairman of the Committee, sinama niya po ako as member
759 kahit na alam niya na never akong pipirma sa Committee Report. With guidance po, I
760 make sure lang na it’s legally sound, ginawa ko po yung trabaho ko kahit alam niya na hindi
761 ako pipirma. Umabot po sa punto na pumayag na may kompromiso, sige may E-games
762 basta wala sa Poblacion, dahil nandoon nga po ang pinaka-puso ng Antipolo. After a year,
763 tinibag po yung ordinansa na yon at kinompromiso natin yung pinaka-diwa ng Antipolo.
764 Pinayagan na natin ulit sa Poblacion.”
765
766 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “What is the measure that
767 we used?”
768
769 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifested: “Pinayagan natin yung CONO na hinihingi ng
770 PAGCOR mula sa mga LGUs na pumapayag tayo maglagay ng E-Games. Basically, pagka
771 ginagawa po natin yung CONO. Pagka pumayag po tayo sa CONO, tayo ang pumapayag na
772 maging sugalan ang lugar natin, hindi po ang PAGCOR. Ang PAGCOR nagpapaalam lang,
773 tayo ang nagbibigay pahintulot para yung mga anak-anakan natin, yung mga constituents
774 natin pwedeng mag sugal sa loob ng Antipolo. Iyon po yung nilabanan natin. Bittersweet
775 po na mawawala yung mga online betting, salamat wala na, pero greater than na kailangan
776 pang magpasa ng Executive Order para tanggalin, samantalang tayo na nandito sa
777 Antipolo, ramdam natin ang sitwasyon ng Antipoleño ay hindi natin nakita yon. Ang
778 PAGCOR, ang habol lang ay profit, paano natin napapatunayan? Doon sa guidelines nila,
779 ang sabi bawal ang E-Games sa anumang malapit sa eskwelahan, hospital informal sector
780 o government property. Pero, ang kasunod noon, pagka nasa isang Arcade ay pwede. Ang
781 nakakatawa po don, nawawala lang yung linear distancing pagka nasa Arcade, pero pagka
782 magkatabi, hindi sila pwedeng magkasama, hindi pwedeng magkalapait. Ibig sabihin,
783 pinoprotektahan ng PAGCOR yung business pero hindi yung institusyon na mahalaga sa
784 atin, yung kalusugan, paaralan at edukasyon, hospital o government facilities. Merong mga
785 kasama natin, National o Local na nalululong sa sugal, at pagka ganon, ang isang tao ay
786 nawawala sa wisyo. I told SK Papel kanina, I heard a farmer says na hindi pa naaani yung
787 sinaka ko, naiutang ko na dahil sa sugal. Iyon po yung mga pinagmumulan ng sama ng loob
788 ko kung bakit hindi pwedeng may sugalan dito. Narinig ko na rin yung inuwi nung isang
789 kakilala ko na nagpapautang sa Casino, nasa likod ng kotse yung school bag ng anak niya,
790 hindi man lang naisip na maiuwi yon. I hope, there will be at least someone sa Council who
791 will champion this because nung dumating ang E-Sabong, 10-12 yrs old, basta merong G-
792 Cash ay pwedeng tumaya sa E-Sabong. Yun po yung sana mapigilan natin. I look forward
793 to somebody who will champion that, asahan ninyo po pagka narinig kong wala,
794 mangungulit po ako sa likod, kailangan kong panindigan yung adbokasiya kong ito. Salamat
795 po.”
796
797 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, thank you very much
798 for giving us a clear explanation. I know that you are not able to approve the request of
799 the Realty Corporation for the owner to continue his job when his establishment, a gaming
800 station, I remember we disapproved that. It was not approved to the extent that even the
801 owner beg Congressman and anyone of us to proceed to the approval of aforementioned
802 gaming or E-Bingo. Second, remember the one that headed and insisted by Coun. Jay
803 located at the New Market. Since nobody really like the idea of having an E-Bingo there,
804 the operation of E-Bingo did not succeed. So, hopefully our image as Pilgrimage City will
805 stay. It is good that there will be no more acceptance of any applicant, those who are
806 applying for E-games and Betting Stations.”
807
808 Hon. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales manifested: “I just want to post this question, Madam. E-Bingos
809 are not included because they are just there, face-to-face. I wonder if it is included.”
810
811 Hon. Alfred J. Zapanta manifested: “Iyon po yung tinatanong ko Madam , kung kasama po
812 yung E-Bingos.”
813

14
814 Hon. Christian Jay C. Tapales manifested: “Madam, dalawa po kasi yung Bingo, yung
815 traditional na face-to-face. Pero yung ika-cancel po natin na E-bingo ay yung nasa
816 machine.”
817
818 Hon. Arnel M. Camacho manifested: “Madam, sa tingin ko, as preserving the values as the
819 pilgrimage, lahat ng sugal, sa tingin ko kasama yun dahil nasa whereas.”
820
821 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Depende na siguro yon sa
822 LGU. Basta, yung lahat ng online games.”
823
824 Hon. Enrico C. De Guzman manifested: “Madam, sa Section 2. Any and all business permits
825 issued in favor of, or applied for by business establishments engaged in gaming and betting
826 establishments, activities or operations in the territorial jurisdiction of Antipolo City are
827 deemed revoked.”
828
829 Hon. Alfred J. Zapanta manifested: “Madam, sabi nga po ng isa nating kasama, pati Lotto.”
830
831 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Okay, this is the first step
832 that our National Government has issued online gaming and betting station using the
833 computer system. So, maybe we have to realize that all gambling will follow or any of us in
834 LGU can file a resolution in order that we can cancel also the traditional betting games. It’s
835 up to us to issue another resolution regarding gambling in Antipolo City, yung gambling
836 will include the traditional. What is now your pleasure, Coun. Jay?”
837
838 Hon. Chritian Jay C. Tapales moved for the approval of the said measure on 2 nd, 3rd and final
839 reading
840
841 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
842 on 2nd, 3rd and final reading.
843
844 UPON THE UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE MEMBERS PRESENT, PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO.
845 2022- 652, WAS FINALLY APPROVED.
846
847 7. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2022-107, A Resolution Authorizing the Hon. Andrea B.
848 Ynares, City Mayor, to Enter Into and Sign, and Execute a Deed of Donation and Acceptance
849 Relative to the Donation of Composter and Shredder and Memorandum of Agreement
850 Between the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) through the
851 Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) Represented by its Director, Engr. William P.
852 Cuñado and the City Government of Antipolo, Represented by Hon. Andrea B. Ynares
853 Relative to the Validity of the Deed of Donation and For Other Purposes.”
854
855 (Administration Measure)
856 Introduced by : Coun. Catalino M. Leyva
857 : Coun. Philip Conrad M. Acop
858 : Coun. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales
859 Sponsored by : Committee on Environmental Protection and Natural Resources
860 : Committee on Agriculture
861 : Committee on Resolutions, Ordinances and Legal Matters
862
863 Hon. Catalino Leyva manifested: “This is in connection with the Deed of Donation and
864 Memorandum of Agreement between the Department of Environment and Natural
865 Resources through the Environmental Management Bureau Represented by its Director,
866 Engr. William P. Cuñado and the City Government of Antipolo, Represented by Hon.
867 Andrea B. Ynares. The request for the adoption of a Sanggunian Panlungosd resolution
868 authorizing the Hon. City Mayor, Andrea B. Ynares to Enter Into and Sign, and Execute for
869 and in behalf of the City for the validity of the said Deed of Donation. I have here a copy of
870 the Deed of Donation but I don’t have a copy of the Memorandum of Agreement but I
871 pressume a MOA itself speaks well of the Local Government Unit is going to utilize those

15
872 equipments to be donated by the DENR pursuant to the Provision of RA 9003 otherwise
873 known as Ecological Waste Management Act of 2000. May I read the Deed of Donation.”
874
875 The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) through the
876 Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) with office address at DENR Compound,
877 Visayas Avenue, Diliman, Quezon City, represented by its Director, Engr. William P.
878 Cuñado, hereinafter referred to as the DONOR and The City Government of Antipolo with
879 office address Carigma Street, represented herein by the City Mayor, herein referred to as
880 the DONEE.
881
882 WITNESSETH:
883
884 That the DONOR hereby freely and voluntarily gives, conveys, and transfers by way of
885 donation unto the DONEE the following equipment to become effective upon signing of
886 this document:
887
888 a. One (1) unit of biodegradable waste shredder with a minimum capacity of 250
889 kilograms, powered by 12 HP diesel engine with electric and manual start,
890 composed of shredding chamber, shredder blades; and
891 b. One (1) unit of composter with a capacity of 1,000 kilograms per batch for every
892 24 hours’ operation powered by five (5) HP by Electric Motor, 220v, 60hz, single
893 phase with speed reducer 1:10 type 120
894
895 That the DONEE shall use the equipment in processing wastes generated within his
896 territorial jurisdiction and shall fulfill the roles and responsibilities stipulated in the
897 Memorandum of Agreement (MOA);
898
899 That the DONOR reserves the right to revoke this Deed of Donation and withdraw the
900 said equipment from the DONEE for failure to utilize them within three (3) months upon
901 receipt of the said equipment and/or failure to perform, with justifiable cause, the
902 responsibilities provided under Section 4, Article III of the MOA;
903
904 Hon. Catalino Leyva manifested: “Madam Presiding Officer, this is the highlight of
905 interpolation and this is self-explanatory. I believe that these equipments will be added at
906 the Materials Recovery Facility situated in Sitio Tanza. The Material Recovery Facility also
907 housed the Composting Facility. This representation is open for any query.”
908
909 The Prsiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan manifested: “The Deed of Doantion will
910 greatly improved the waste management system of our City which is located at Sitio Tanza.
911 And according to Cou. Loni, this will contain in the Material Recovery of the City. And of
912 course, the Deed of Donation is as good as the Memorandum of Agreement. That will
913 facilitate our system of shredding, all those biodegradable waste that will be converted to
914 organic fertilizer
915
916 Hon. Catalino Leyva manifested: “With the 900 thousand population of the City, we are
917 projecting 135 tons of biodegradable waste, this is very necessary.”
918
919 Hon. Catalino leyva moved for the approval of the said measure on 2 nd, 3rd and final
920 reading.
921
922 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
923 on 3rd and final reading.
924
925 UPON THE UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE MEMBERS PRESENT, PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO.
926 2022-107, WAS FINALLY APPROVED.
927
928 8. APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. 2022-03, ”An Ordinance Authorizing the Reversion of
929 the Continuing Appropriation Under the General Fund- Infrastructure in the Amount of

16
930 One Hundred Fifty Million, Six Hundred Eighty-Three Thousand One Hundred Eighty-Three
931 and 72/100 (P150,683,183.72) under the Twenty Percent (20%) Development Fund in the
932 Amount of Eighty Million One Hundred Sixteen Thousand Six Hundred Thirty-Three and
933 82/100 , and Disaster Risk Reduction Management Fund in the Amount of Forty Nine
934 Million Eight Hundred Forty-Four Thousand Seven Hundred Sixty-Seven and 20/100 to the
935 Unappropriated Surplus of the General Fund of the City Government of Antipolo, in
936 Compliance with Section 322 of the Local Government of 1992, and for Other Purposes.”
937
938 (Administration Measure)
939 Introduced by: Coun. Irvin Paulo C. Tapales
940 Sponsored by : Committee on Budget, Finance and Appropriation
941
942 Hon. Irvin Paulo Tapales manifested: “This is just a reversion of account. We are doing the
943 same because Article 418 of the Rules and Regulation Implementing the Local
944 Government Code of 1991 on Reversion of Unexpected Balances of Appropriations
945 Authorized in the Annual Appropriations Ordinance shall revert back to the
946 Unappropriated Surplus of the General Fund at the end of the Fiscal Year and shall not
947 thereafter be available for the expenditure except by subsequent enactment. With this,
948 we are just reverting the fund in the General Fund to be utilized sooner or later as long as
949 the proper resolution or ordinance will be passed. I move for the approval of the said
950 measure on 2nd, 3rd and final rading.
951
952 There being no objection, the said matter was unanimously approved by the august body
953 on 3rd and final reading.
954
955 UPON THE UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE MEMBERS PRESENT, PROPOSED APPROPRIATION
956 ORDINANCE NO. 2022-03, WAS FINALLY APPROVED.
957
958 J. PRIVILEGE HOUR:
959
960 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan availed the Privilege Hour.
961
962 I would like to manifest again that the 2021 Cities and Municipalities ceremony sponsored
963 by DTI and its management assisted by PSA for data purpose has announced that Antipolo
964 City Government led by our Chief Executive Officer, Hon. Andrea B. Ynares has received
965 award as 2nd Place for the Most Competitive Component City in the whole Philippines, in
966 terms of the structure, government efficiency, economic growth and resiliency. The
967 awarding has been done on the 3rd Floor of Provincial Capitol Building. The Department
968 Heads were there and I was invited also. The Cainta is the over-all winner on the first and
969 second class municipalities in the Province of Rizal. The third is Taytay, in terms of
970 economic growth, structure. San Mateo in terms of resiliency. So, it is still the Province of
971 Rizal, the number one for the Most Competitive Province in the Entire Nation, seven times
972 already. It will still give an inspiration for all the workers/employees in the Province of Rizal
973 to continue extra effort. We are part of its success as a contributor as legislation is
974 concerned. Thank you very much, Coun. Leyva as Chairman of the Committee on
975 Environmental Protection and Natural Resources and Committee on Public Works and
976 Highways. Coun. Acop as Chairman of the Committee on Agriculture and thank you also for
977 helping Antipolo in the case of Covid-19. Coun. De Guzman, as very cooperative and
978 efficient Majority Floor Leader and likewise, as Chairman of the Committee on Good
979 Government, Ethics and Public Accountability and at the same time, the Committee on
980 Health and Social Services. Coun. Paui as the Chairman of the Committee on Budget,
981 Finance and Appropriation, Committee on Planning, Land Utilization, Housing and
982 Settlement as well as the Committee on Resolutions, Ordinances and Legal Matters. Coun.
983 Susan, thank you very much for being the Chairman of Committee on Women and Family
984 Affairs as well as Committee on Cooperative and Livelihood. Coun. Arnel as Chairman of the
985 Committee on Peace & Order, Public Safety and Security. Coun. Jay as Chairman of the
986 Committee on Games and Amusement. Coun. Agnes as Chairman of the Committee on
987 Tourism, Culture, Arts and Indigenous People. Coun. Alfred, thank you very much for your

17
 988 cooperation and of course, your approval has been considered. Coun. Toni, we will be
989 missing your report in the History of Antipolo. Coun. Edward as Chairman of the
990 Committee on Ways and Means. Coun. Nixon, thank you for being the Chairman of the
991 Committee on Accreditation as well as Committee on Education. Coun. Altamirano, thank
992 you so much. Thank you so much for the cooperation, Coun. Lemuel. Coun. Pimentel for
993 being the Chairman of Committee on Market and Slaughterhouse. Of course, thank you to
994 our SK Federation President Peter Papel, you are very outstanding in reporting issues and
995 concerns of the barangay. Kap. Jojo, thank you for your contribution, for discussing the
996 issues of the barangay that needs to be clarify and for further discussion, you are standing
997 there for their behalf. Thank you for your cooperation especially during this pandemic, I
998 hope we will still be getting your presence until the next barangay election is already there
999 and has completed. Of course, to Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod, Mr. Alan
1000 Espinas to make the ordinances and resolutions presentable and likewise, guiding the SP-
1001 Secretariat staff so that they will be working as one, as a team work. So that, our
1002 resolutions and ordinances will be acceptable and will be appealing to the Provincial Board
1003 Member who are actually taking charge of validating and verifying our submitted
1004 resolutions and ordinances. Thank you, Secretariat.”
1005
1006 Hon. Philip Conrad M. Acop manifersed: “Good afternoon. In behalf of the members of the
1007 Council, thank you very much Madam for the guidance, for the words of wisdom and
1008 persistence when we improve ourselves in the midst in so far discussion po. Thank you for
1009 concerns even to the point of being at the dilemma po for you. We have seen and
1010 witnessed your sacrifices po, so that we can advance our needs po particularly personal po.
1011 Thank you, you have been a teacher and a mother to all of us. Hopefully, magaya nung
1012 mga bago nating myembro, be a teacher, be the guider, be strong in conditions and advice
1013 rin po, mas kailangan po natin yon. Maraming salamat po. I believe, most of my colleagues
1014 could be around to help them and available for any opinion. Again, thank you very much
1015 po.”
1016
1017 The Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina G. Gatlabayan manifested: “Thank you so much, Coun.
1018 Acop for your wisdom and wishes that we will be continuing hard work and excellent
1019 performances for the new members of the Concil. Thank you very much for the new
1020 members of the Sangguniang Panlungsod, I would like to recognize, Coun. Marife Pimentel,
1021 Coun. Jewel Anne Camacho, Coun. Eileen Zapanta, Coun. Robert Altamirano, Sr., and Coun.
1022 Jill Tapales. The last termer will assist you, you can make it, you can make things work.”
1023
1024 K. QUESTION HOUR:
1025
1026 L. ANNOUNCEMENT:
1027
1028 M. ADJOURNMENT:
1029
1030 Hon. Enrico C. De Guzman moved for the adjournment of the 156th regular session.
1031
1032 There being no further business matters to take up, and since there was no objection from the
1033 floor, the Presiding Officer, Hon. Josefina Gatlabayan declared the adjournment of the 156 th
1034 Regular Session at 1:20 P.M.
1035
1036 Transcribed by: Prepared by:
1037
1038
1039 AIDA L. OBCENA ALAN R. ESPINAS
1040 Administrative Assistant lll Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod I
1041 Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod
1042
1043
1044 SYRIL M. RADAM
1045 Administrative Aide l
1046 Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod
1047

18
1048 Attested by:
1049
1050
1051 ENRICO C. DE GUZMAN, M.D., FPOGS PHILIP CONRAD M. ACOP, M.D.,M.P.M
1052 City Councilor– 1st District City Councilor – 2nd District
1053
1054
1055
1056
1057 SUSANA G. SAY CATALINO M. LEYVA
1058 City Councilor – 1st District City Councilor – 2nd District
1059
1060
1061
1062
1063 ARNEL M. CAMACHO IRVIN PAULO C. TAPALES
1064 City Councilor – 1st District City Councilor – 2 nd District
1065
1066
1067
1068 AGNES G. OLDAN-GRATIL ANTONIO O. MASANGKAY
1069 City Councilor – 1st District - City Councilor – 2 nd District
1070
1071
1072
1073 CHRISTIAN JAY C. TAPALES EDWARD R. O’HARA
1074 City Councilor – 1st District City Councilor – 2 nd District
1075
1076
1077
1078 LEMUEL MARLOWE G. ZAPANTA NIXON R. ARANAS
1079 City Councilor – 1st District City Councilor - 2nd District
1080
1081
1082
1083 ROBERT A. ALTAMIRANO, JR. ALFRED J. ZAPANTA
1084 City Councilor – 1st District City Councilor-2nd District
1085
1086
1087
1088 FELIPE C. PIMENTEL, SR. AFP(Ret.)
1089 City Councilor – 1st District
1090
1091
1092
1093
1094 JONATHAN C. SALEN PETER ARNOLD S. PAPEL, JR.
1095 President, Liga ng mga Barangay SK Federation President
1096
1097
1098
1099
1100 Certified by:
1101
1102
1103 JOSEFINA G. GATLABAYAN
1104 City Vice-Mayor
1105
1106 D:\Aida Obcena\SP Secretariat\Record of Proceedings 2022/ROP of the 156th regular session – June 29, 2022.doc

19