Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sudan 201710 JICA
Sudan 201710 JICA
Port Sudan
Legend
Northern Red Sea
Boundary
※ :Disputed Boundary
State Boundary
Capital City
River Nile
Main City
River Kassala
North Darfur Khartoum Kassala
North Kordofan
West Gezira
Darfur
El Fasher
Geneina Gedaref
El Obeid
Umm Ruwaba Situation of the Gash River,
Sennar Kassala, Aug. 2016
West Kordofan White Nile
Niyala
Central
®
Darfur East Darfur South Kordofan
Muglad Blue Nile
South Darfur Kadugli
1
although data on rainfall and discharge in the Nile cases without any sufficient analysis of need,
River have been collected and accumulated for priority and fairness, meaning that unnecessary
more than 100 years, these data cannot be directly facilities have been constructed while others are
utilized due to delays in converting them into a being poorly operated and maintained.
digital database. As water quality monitoring has In terms of the rural water supply, operating and
only been done in emergencies. Moreover, water maintaining the facilities constructed by the
levels and discharge in wadis (dry riverbed that government will be transferred to water users’
contains water only during times of heavy rain) had organizations, however, the technical transfer and
been monitored before decentralization, but it is not support will be insufficient, resulting in limited
currently being performed. operation and maintenance activities by water users.
From the above, historical and locational data
Current Legal Issues
management and monitoring system formulations
The Water Resources Act and the National Council
are insufficient, which in turn increases the need to
for Water Resources have been established and the
implement a water balance evaluation based on the
basic principles and the roles are clarified. However,
scientific evidence.
those are not functioning sufficiently because the
Issues of Coordination by Various Stakeholders detailed regulations and rules and so on for
and Active Participation
implementation are not formulated.
The decentralization policy has encouraged them to
Local Society and Cultural Background
implement water resources development on their
own terms, albeit without sufficient coordination There are over 300 tribes in Sudan and their
with neighboring states. As a result, a number of traditional administration system coexists alongside
water-use-related problems have occurred, such as the governmental system. This traditional system,
water conflicts between water users of upstream and which has a big influence over conflict resolutions
downstream of water resources, conflicts between between tribes, cannot be ignored when consulting
farmers and nomads, and unplanned water with nomads and farmers. For nomads in particular,
resources development. Enhancing the problem- the traditional system should be respected, as
solving capacity of the federal government and the nomads (who make up about 10% of the population)
negotiation and coordination capacity of state move around Sudan, such that it is difficult to place
2
to continue the IWRM activity and expand the pilot
2. Approach for problem-solving
activities to the other areas led by Sudanese C/P
Project objectives and outputs organizations even after the project completion.
This project aims to enhance the C/Ps’ capability of Therefore, the Japanese Experts supported for
the IWRM and to accomplish the project objectives implementation of the project activities by the C/Ps
and outputs considering the above issues. and capacity building was conducted through on-
Table 1 Project objectives and outputs the-job training.
To make recommendations for a
practical strategy, institutional and 10 full-time C/Ps committed to the project activities
Objectiv
organizational framework; to improve
es of the in the first phase. Moreover, the colleagues of the
the policies, strategies and plans for
project
IWRM; and to contribute to the full-time C/Ps were involved in the project activities
improvement of related projects
Output 1 Water balance analysis and supported for data organizing and water
Analyses of issues on water resources resources potential calculation.
Output 2
management
Implementation of IWRM in specific
Output 3
regions (pilot activities)
Recommendations for a strategy, legal
Output 4 framework and implementation
arrangements
C/P Sustainable
Supporting
Team
Figure 2 Flowchart of the project
Support by
Participatory activity by the C/P and participation of JICA Team Time 3 years
Water volume
3
1. Water resources potential
Working Item
Identification of issues on water resources
(WRP) Working Item with
consensus building management (Output2)
(Output-1)
Water balance analysis Three element Output 2 is identification of issues on water
To be evaluated by balance of three elements 1 to 3 will be
analyzed at
Understanding of methodology and model the same time resources management. Workflow of the output 2 is
Collection of necessary data
Discussion (PCM) in small seminar
as shown in Figure 8.
Water shortage will be analyzed Training in the
when?/where?/how serious? (Output-2) Identification of issues
Third Country(1 time)
on WR management
2. Capacity of facilities for water 3. Water demand With Discussion
resources development and supply (existing and future ) (PCM)and
(existing and planned) Data collection Small seminar…
Living Average Daily Business and Commercial Industrial Average Average Daily Amount Training in a Third Country
Amount of Water Average Daili Amount of Water Daily Amount of Water of Water for Others
Evapotrans
piration
Crops
Coefficient
Preparatory Water for
Underground seepage loss
Average Daily
Water Consumption
Rate of Leakage
(Leakage Amount)
Training in third country is a part of capacity
Water
Consumption
Effective
Rainfall
development and 3 trainings will be conducted
Net Water
Requirement
Irrigation Efficiency
Surface Water Source (waterway loss),
Groundwater Source
through the project. This training is one of the main
Gross Water
Requirement
Current and Planed
Cropping Pattern
objectives to establish independence and strengthen
Unit Water Duty
Agricultural
Land Area sustainability on the Sudanese side. By upgrading
Average Daily Water Other Water
Water Demand for Water Demand for Supply Demand
Irrigation Water Livestock and Aquaculture (Living, Commercial and Industry) (Hydroelectric power, etc.) knowledge and awareness of C/Ps on the IWRM,
: Necessary Data Water Demand
this training shall contribute to the ongoing
Figure 7 Flowchart of water demand calculation
implementation of IWRM activities after project
4
completion and practical implementation in pilot Atbara River and the outside of Sudan.
activity areas. In addition, taking into account
meteorological and hydrological conditions, such as
Northern Red Sea
South Darfur
East
Darfur
South
Kordofan Blue Nile 30.01 – 100.00
More than 100.00
terms of similarities, such as language, religion, Figure 10 Calculation result of surface water
resources potential
culture and appropriate engineering technology, it is
possible to carry out efficient training.
Table 2 Tentative training program Northern Red Sea
Morocco: Khartoum
Kassala Legend
Until about 20 years ago, there were North Kordofan
Training center Gezira
Water Demand (MCM/y)
many water-related issues. However, 0 - 400
and treatment West
400 - 800
they were overcome by infrastructure Darfur
Gedaref
800 - 1,600
facilities in White Sennar
developments and challenges relating Central
West Nile 1,600 - 2,400
to the self-help efforts for human South East Kordofan Blue Nile More than 4,000
Water user Darfur Darfur
resource development. States
association, etc. River
Khartoum
Kassala Legend
North Kordofan
Ratio:
of facilities for water resources development. Gezira
Water Demand/Water Resource
West
Gedaref 0
Darfur
As a result of the surface water resources potential, West
White Sennar
Nile
- 0.5%
0.5 - 1%
Central Kordofan 1 - 10%
Darfur South 10 - 50%
total annual discharge of surface water in the entire South Darfur
East
Darfur
Kordofan Blue Nile 50 -99.9%
More than 100%
States
Sudan was estimated as 4.05 BCM/year, which is River
exclusive of the water from the Nile Rivers, the Figure 12 Result of water balance analysis
(Projection for 2035)
5
Bad water quality is caused by contamination of
hafir water by animals, river water pollution by
discharge of untreated industrial wastewater and
Northern Red Sea
West Gedaref
900 - 1,200
1,200 - 1,500 Social, institutional and organizational problems
Darfur 1,500 - 1,800
White Sennar 1,800 - 2,100
Central
Nile
2,100 - 2,400 include famers-nomads conflicts, upstream-
Darfur South 2,400 - 2,700
6
regions of water issues of Sudan. These areas are This will accurate a depletion of Bara aquifer.
proposed as target regions of the Pilot Activities Content of Pilot Activity :
Outline of the Pilot Activities are proposed as Groundwater development potential of Al Sidir well
shown below. filed will be analyzed to propose safe groundwater
Kassala city area yield. The plan for optimal operation will be
Water Issue : formulated for the south water sources to
Groundwater which is recharged by Gash River is compensate groundwater sources of Al Sidir well
extracted for city water supply and horticultural use field. Moreover, the current groundwater use of
in Kassala city area. Huge amount of groundwater Bara aquifer will be surveyed,and discussion will
is pumped up from Kassala aquifer for the be held among various stakeholders to implement
horticultural activity which is causing continues aquifer management.
draw-down of groundwater level. There is high risk Training in a Third Country
of drying up of large number of wells in the near Training in a third country was held in Morocco in
future if the current extraction is continued. May 2017. Trainees were the project manager,
Content of Pilot Activity : director and the full-time C/Ps and in total 13 people.
Groundwater recharge of Kassala aquifer will be
evaluated, and safe groundwater development
potential will be proposed by local organizations in
charge of water management. Lowering of
groundwater level will be predicted under the
assumption that the current water extraction is
continued, and safe groundwater extraction rate will
be proposed in order to prevent depletion of Kassala
aquifer. Countermeasures to stop over-pumping will
be discussed among stakeholders for Site visit and group discussion about the
comparison of IWRM in the training in Morocco
implementation.
“Institut International de l’Eau et de
El Obeid city and Bara groundwater basin
l’Assainissement under l’Office National de
Water Issue :
l’Electricité et de l’Eau Potable (ONEE-IEA)” and
Water supply of El-Obeid city has two water
“Agence du Bassin Hydraulique de Souss Massa et
sources; groundwater sources (Al Sidir well field)
Draa (ABHSMD)” led the two weeks training and
in the north and surface water sources (Bagara dam)
the trainees learned the good practice of the
in the south. There is large question in sustainability
practical IWRM and its effects of implementation.
of El Sidir well field because there is no
Moreover, the trainees discussed and made some
groundwater monitoring in spite of the prediction
action plans to reflect the good practices and the
that groundwater level will continuously decline in
lessons learned through the training in Sudan.
Al Sidir well field. Al Sidir well field is located in
“Clear social and institutional frameworks,
Bara aquifer area. Groundwater level of Bara
strategies and plans”, “Scientific data for planning,
aquifer has been declined by groundwater
involvement of stakeholders and operation (it needs
development of agricultural use without control.
7
presenting the advantages of implementation of the presentation skill of C/Ps.
Water potential calculation (especially,
IWRM, such as saving water and energy and cost surface water) and water balance
analysis were shared and conducted by
reduction)”, “Financial and operational support by Involvement
all the full-time C/Ps as an on-the-job
of C/Ps in the
training. The whole Sudan was divided
the stakeholders, such as the Water User analysis and
into approximately 180 sub-basins and
calculations
Association, and capacity development and public C/Ps learned the very practical way of
water balance evaluation, which have a
awareness for the stakeholders to enable it” and so scientific basis.
Other C/P’s organization and C/Ps
on are the detailed examples of actions to be taken. other than the full-time C/Ps supported
Involvement
the project activities, such as data
It requires taking actions by the C/Ps in line with the of other C/P’s
organizing of wadi discharge,
organization
action plans through this project or after the project calculating of surface water resources
and C/Ps other
potential, and demonstrating of
than the full-
completion. ArcSWAT. The project team
time C/Ps
Social and Institutional
Important things encouraged the involvement of other
Strategies and plans and flowchart for
frameworks (with Stakeholders)
the
C/Ps.
implementation of Full-time C/Ps were enables to conduct
IWRM learned
Scientific Data for Planning, Involvement from the case a round of the IWRM spiral & process,
Scientific of Stakeholders and Operation study in Morocco especially “Recognizing &
Research
Technical
Capacity Practicing a identifying”, “Conceptualizing”, in the
With Clear strategy, plan and role Development round of the very practical way as an on-the-job
Involvement of Stakeholders
Financial & Operational support IWRM spiral training as above mentioned. Since
(Fderal, States, Community, WUAs, PS, Donor and etc)
Public
Awareness & process C/Ps had little practical experience of
Law, Legislation
and Regulation Technical & the IWRM, it will contribute to the
Operation & Maintenance Management
Modern (Fderal, States, Community, WUAs, and etc) sustainable process and activity by the
Technology Evaluation
C/P-led in the future.
Social and Institutional Frameworks + Strategy & Plan Project leaflet was made as a publicity
ISSUES
Social and Institutional
LEARNING IN MOROCCO
The water use institutions work on basin
ACTION PLAN
The role of federal, states, organization
material (both English and Arabic
frameworks level with : should be clear
Organization review to - Clear Responsibility, Good Coordination, Formation of WUA (water supply, irrigation), versions) as shown in Figure 16. It
develop technical expertise Engagement, Transparency and capacitate and support them to take
for river basin management
and planning
Association are very active
Advanced technology in basin management
their role in manging and using the water
efficiently
Publication contributed to a deepening of
and multi disciplinary expertise Awareness campaigns to stakeholders for
the participatory work understanding on “participatory
Institutional reform
Establishment of IWRM unit for better water
management
activity by C/P and participation of all
Strategies and plans
No integration between units
Clear strategies and plans at different levels
most of the time being implemented
Review and update the existing strategies
and plans and insure their implementation.
the stakeholders”.
in the planning process Updating plans periodically Gather all the cross sectoral in preparing
Coordination among Systematic approach and co-ordination of water strategy
stakeholders agencies in planning and implementation
There is a strong coordination and
Strengthen coordination among
stakeholders (DWSU-SWCs-community
As for the lessons learned on the project
collaboration between relevant departments associations etc. as well as between line
ministries.)
4. Efforts and lessons learned on the As the evaluation result, some of the activities were
project implementation substantively implemented by the Japanese Experts
Efforts on the project implementation is as shown in depending on the fields and the opportunity to take
Table 3. part in by the C/Ps was limited. This lesson shall be
Table 3 Efforts on the project implementation reflect in the second phase of the project.
Efforts Result / Impact
Each full-time C/P facilitated the
workshops of problem analysis and Implementation period
Facilitation at
organized the results of consultation in
the workshops Whole length: From August 2016 to August 2019
line with the Japanese Expert’s
of problem
guidance. C/Ps understood one of the 1st phase: From August 2016 to October 2017
analysis by the
process of the IWRM spiral & process,
C/Ps
“Recognizing & identifying” in a 2nd phase: From November 2017 to August 2019
practical way.
C/Ps made presentations on the
progress of the activities timely at the
Weekly weekly regular meeting. Minutes of
regular meeting were made by C/Ps by rotation
meeting as well. It contributed to information
sharing among the Japanese Experts
and the C/Ps and enhanced the
8
Reference
Nile Basin Initiative Secretariat (2012): “State of the River Nile Basin 2012”
UNESCO (2009): “IWRM guidelines at river basin level”
K. Okamoto, T. Iguchi, N. Takahashi, K. Iwanami and T. Ushio (2005): “The global satellite mapping of
precipitation (GSMaP) project, 25th IGARSS Proceedings, pp. 3414-3416”
* GSMaP_NRT is used as a part of the rainfall data (daily). “Global Rainfall Map in Near-Real-Time (GSMaP_NRT) by
JAXA Global Rainfall Watch” was produced and distributed by the Earth Observation Research Center, Japan Aerospace
Exploration Agency.
9
Poor quality Constraint in
of life economic growth
Climate Unauthorized Priorities in Inadequate coordination Reduced carrying High variable Poor condition of Inadequate Inadequate Lack of Lack of utilizing
Inadequate supply Lack of Improper
change extraction of allocating water not for trans-boundary rivers capacity of canals flow water supply capacities water leveling modern
of water resource electricity distribution
water matching demands and aquifers network points technology
of water
along (compacting soil
points along
Inadequate Deterioration & Inadequate Irrigation water stock etc.)
Inadequate Old Difficulty in stock routes
enforcement Sedimentation mismanagement routes
malfunctioning weeds control maintenance network expanding
& lack of laws Limited supply Limited of facilities
and regulations of water by dams supply of (pumps) urban water
& hafirs groundwater Irrigation & drainage Lack of spare supply
law not executed parts system
Inadequate
sometimes
maintenance
Improper Poor condition and Poor Excessive Inadequate
Sedimentation development of Financial Rapid &
inadequacy of
10
operation condition of discharge of
groundwater deficits uncontrolled
dams & hafirs wells groundwater
resources expansion of
cities
Social Limitation in Inadequate Inappropriate Inadequate & Dependence on Emphasis on Inadequate Inadequate & High cost Inadequate
constraints budget maintenance & design inappropriate traditional development rather enforcement inappropriate of High costs
revenue
(opposition rehabilitation planning process irrigation method than on of regulations planning developing
by people) management to control process GW
Inefficient GW use Flat rate water
utilization of Planning not Low priority Lack of tariff system
Lack of data Non-utilization of
budget based on on planning technology research outputs
basin unit
Devolution and Increasing Water quality not
Duplication of Limited access to
institutional demand for water matching the standard
functions between Duplication Low priority water facilities
Inadequate Lack of unified instability in the
DIU and other
Lack of spare
parts Inadequate Lack of
utilization of inspection
laboratories
Inadequate
capacities