1. What are the ethical issues relevant to this case?
The ethical issues of this case are Harassment and Discrimination.
Harassment - Suggestive comments, inappropriate touch, and unwanted sexual
advances faced by Ms. Diana Janzen and Ms. Tracy Johnson from Cook Tommy Gammas involve both Mental and Physical Harassment
Discrimination – Threatening behavior, continual criticizing, and refusal to
cooperate in fulfilling mutual responsibilities in the Operation of the restaurant by Mr. Grammas clearly show that he discriminated against Ms. Janzen for her repeated objection to his sexual advancements and harassment towards her. The Manager of the restaurant also discriminates against Ms. Janzen by not addressing the Harassment complaint and by firing Ms. Tracey Johnson for speaking up about her harassment issues by Mr. Gammas. This incident shows the lethargic and discriminating behavior of The Manager and Mr. Gammas towards Ms. Janzen and Ms. Tracey Johnson due to their gender.
2. What, ethically speaking, should employers and employees be
aware of in cases of sexual harassment? Employer
The Employer should create a Speaking up culture inside the Organization
Based on the size of the Organization, the steps in preventing sexual harassment may differ, but ultimately, the Victim should have the confidence to speak up, and when the Victim raises a complaint, proper countermeasure has to be taken by the Organization The Employer has to make sure the Victim is not getting hurt in any other way because of raising a complaint/ speaking-up Periodic reviews with the Employees about Workplace harassment need to be conducted and implement preventive measures to minimize the risk of sexual harassment Also, the Employer has to ensure the complaint from the Victim is right and he/she is not raising a complaint based on personal disputes or experiences. Promptly responding to the complaints raised by the Employee. Create a workplace where sexual harassment and discrimination are not tolerated
Employee
The Employee should speak up/raise a complaint in the case of
encountering any form of Harassment/Discrimination. Formally reporting the issue with the relevant Supervisor/ member of the Organization. Supporting the colleague who is suffering from harassment and not isolating him/her for raising a complaint and creating a friendly environment for him/her Be sensitive to colleagues who may offend by the verbal and non- behavioral attitudes of others. Speak up even on the subtle forms of harassment. Confront the Harasser immediately. If there is no change in behavior, raise this as a complaint to the Supervisor.
3. In your opinion, were Ms. Janzen and Ms. Johnson being
discriminated against?
In my opinion, Ms. Janzen and Ms. Johnson are discriminated against by
their gender and position in the restaurant. From the Case Study, I understand Working level of Ms. Janzen, and Ms. Johnson is not superior to that of Mr. Gamma and The Manager. Because of this, Ms. Janzen and Ms. Johnson are judged as powerless to position, and being a woman makes them vulnerable and easy targets for discrimination.