Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S0003267021000313 Main
1 s2.0 S0003267021000313 Main
h i g h l i g h t s g r a p h i c a l a b s t r a c t
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Hydrogen sulfide (H2S), as a hazardous gas, is often found around dump areas. Long term exposure can
Received 11 September 2020 cause harm to health, it is highly necessary to develop some simple and sensitive methods for on-site H2S
Received in revised form detection. Herein, a convenient photothermal assay has been designed for the quantitation of H2S using a
31 December 2020
handheld thermometer as readout. Au@Ag nanocubes (Au@Ag NCs), a core-shell nanocomposite with
Accepted 6 January 2021
Available online 12 January 2021
strong light absorption at ~450 nm, was chosen as a novel photothermal agent in this study. Under the
laser irradiation at 450 nm, the Au@Ag NCs show a strong photothermal effect, and a significant tem-
perature enhancement can be measured by the thermometer easily. The presence of H2S can lead to the
Keywords:
Au@Ag nanocubes
deposition of sulfur onto Au@Ag NCs, altering the localized surface plasmon resonance absorption, size,
Hydrogen sulfide surface composition, and morphology of Au@Ag NCs and hence leading to the reduction of photothermal
Photothermal effect effect. The change of the temperature has a linear relationship with the H2S concentration in the range of
Temperature 0.5e80.0 mM with a detection limit of 0.35 mM. By combining with simple sample purification proced-
Thermometer ures, the developed method has been applied to detect H2S in garbage odor gas with satisfactory results.
© 2021 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
* Corresponding author.
** Corresponding author. MOE Key Laboratory for Analytical Science of Food Safety and Biology, Fujian Provincial Key Laboratory of Analysis and Detection Technology for
Food Safety, College of Chemistry, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou, 350116, China.
*** Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: luofang@fzu.edu.cn, zylin@fzu.edu.cn (F. Luo), lcuiying007@163.com (C. Lin).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aca.2021.338211
0003-2670/© 2021 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Y. Tao, Y. Lin, F. Luo et al. Analytica Chimica Acta 1149 (2021) 338211
1. Introduction portable digital thermometer (CIE 305 P). The hand-held laser
(450 nm, 1 W) was purchased from OXLasers Electronics Co., Ltd.
Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is one of the highly toxic environmental (Shanghai, China).
pollutants [1e3]. Excessive H2S in the environment can cause the
paralysis of the human respiratory system, the impairment of brain
function, the loss of the sense of balance, even sudden death.
Consequently, the development of simple and sensitive technology 2.3. Synthesis of AuNPs and Au@Ag NCs
for H2S detection is of paramount importance. Commercial lead
acetate paper is widely used for the detection of H2S, however, it is The synthesis of Au@Ag NCs was based on early literature with a
limited by the low sensitivity and the potential environmental slight modification because of the difference in the reagents and
damage caused by the lead [4,5]. Fluorescence, electrochemistry, materials [18]. The slight modification refers to that the AuNPs for
chromatography, and electrochemiluminescence technologies have the preparation of Au@Ag NCs are synthesized in a different
been applied for H2S detection [6e10]. Although these methods are method. In this study, AuNPs were prepared according to the pre-
sensitive and reliable, the bulk instruments and the experienced vious work [19,20]. In brief, the HAuCl4 solution (100 mL, 0.25 mM)
operator are usually required, which limits the use in the resource- was heated to 120 C for 30 min under continuous stirring. Then
poor areas. sodium citrate solution (10 mL, 1%) was added and heated at 120 C
Colorimetric method is one of the most used strategies for on- for 20 min. Before being used, the prepared AuNPs were centri-
site detection, which has been designed to detect H2S frequently fuged and washed three times with CTAC (20 mM). To synthesize
[11,12]. Au@Ag nanoparticles, with tunable optical properties that the Au@Ag NCs, the above prepared AuNPs (3.0 mL) was mixed
can be affected by the size, component, and surface coating, have with CTAC (7.0 mL, 20 mM), then AA (3.0 mL, 100 mM) was intro-
been widely used in the development of colorimetric methods for duced. The solution was reacted at 60 C for 20 min under stirring.
H2S detection owing to the reaction between Ag and sulfur in the Subsequently, AgNO3 (0.6 mL, 10 mM) was introduced to the
presence of oxygen [13e15]. For example, an analytical approach mixture and held at 60 C for another 3 h. Then the mixed solution
was developed for H2S, which was based on H2S-induced shifting of was naturally cooled to room temperature. After centrifugation
localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) absorption peak of (5000 rpm, 10 min) and washed three times, the Au@Ag NCs were
Au@Ag nanorods [16]. A rapid color analysis was reported for the collected for future study. Before use, the prepared Au@Ag NCs
reliable detection of H2S using the Au@Ag nanosphere as a probe (3.0 mL) was mixed with 1% (v/v) Tween-80 (30 mL).
[17]. However, these methods only can achieve the qualitative or
semi-quantitative detection of H2S. The quantitative detection of
H2S still relies on large instruments, which is high-cost and non- 2.4. Photothermal assay for H2S
portable (as shown in Table S1). Many efforts are still needed for
the development of new quantitative detection strategies for H2S A simple process was applied for the photothermal assay of H2S
with easily available readout. using a split tube and a polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) membrane.
In this study, a photothermal detection system has been The tube was split into two parts, and the top half part was com-
developed to detect H2S using a simple thermometer as readout. bined with the PTFE membrane. Au@Ag NCs solution was dropped
The reaction between Au@Ag NCs and H2S leads to the change in on the PTFE membrane, only allowing gas to pass through and
LSPR absorption and light-to-heat transition efficiency of Au@Ag insulate the water. H2S standard solution with different concen-
NCs. An obvious temperature variation of the Au@Ag NCs can be tration was freshly prepared using Na2S as the source. Na2S solution
measured with the addition of H2S, providing a novel and simple was added to the bottom of the tube, followed by the addition of
quantitative method for H2S using a thermometer as readout. H2SO4 (10 mL, 0.5 mM, pH 3.0) to generate H2S. Then the split tube
Moreover, this photothermal assay is expanded for the detection of was integrated and sealed immediately. H2S was evaporated from
H2S around dumps with the assistance of simple purification acid solution and trapped in the Au@Ag NCs solution on the PTFE
procedures. membrane [12]. Subsequently, Au@Ag NCs solution that was reac-
ted with H2S on the PTFE membrane was transferred into the
2. Experimental section photothermal assay device. The total volume was set as 200 mL in
each assay to avoid the influence of different volumes on the
2.1. Materials and chemicals photothermal measurement. With the irradiation of the laser, the
temperature change of the system was measured by a handheld
The chloroauric acid tetrahydrate (HAuCl4$4H2O), cetyl- thermometer.
trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), cetyltrimethylammonium
chloride (CTAC) were purchased from Sinopharm Chemical Reagent
(Shanghai, China). Sodium borohydride (NaBH4) and sodium sul-
fide nonahydrate were acquired from Aladdin (Shanghai, China). 2.5. Collection and purification of samples
Ascorbic acid (AA) was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Shanghai,
China). All other reagents were of analytical reagent grade. Gas samples were collected from the garbage station at Fuzhou
University (Fuzhou, China). The collection procedures were the
2.2. Instruments same as those in the reported work [21,22]. Briefly, the gas was
extracted using an air pump (2 L min 1) for 10 min. By this means,
The UVevisible absorption spectrum was obtained by a micro- the H2S gas could react with NaOH to form Na2S. The solution was
plate spectrophotometer (Multiskan GO, Thermo Scientific, USA). transferred into the bottom of a split tube with a PTFE membrane.
The transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were acquired Other procedures were the same as those mentioned above. Then,
on a Tecnai G2 F20 STWIN microscope. High angle annular dark the concentration of H2S measured by our method was compared
field-scanning transmission electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM) with that obtained by a commercial H2S kit. The commercial H2S kit
images and elemental mapping images were obtained from the FEI was obtained from Hangzhou Lohand Biological Co. Ltd (Hangzhou,
Talos F200S microscope. The temperatures were measured by a China), and the batch number is 8307230.
2
Y. Tao, Y. Lin, F. Luo et al. Analytica Chimica Acta 1149 (2021) 338211
3.1. Principle of the photothermal assay system Previous literature has demonstrated that the photothermal
effect of nanoparticles is strongly dependent on the plasmon
Scheme 1 shows the principle of the designed photothermal resonance wavelength, particle volume, shell coating, and assembly
assay system for H2S and the photograph of the photothermal assay [28]. In this study, the detection mechanism is based on the
device. Under the laser irradiation at 450 nm, the Au@Ag NCs show different photothermal effect of Au@Ag NCs before and after reac-
a great photothermal effect, transferring the light energy to heat tion with H2S. Au@Ag NCs showed strong light absorption at
energy efficiently and hence resulting in the sharp temperature 450 nm, leading to a high light-to-heat conversion efficiency under
increase that can be measured by a hand-held thermometer easily. the laser irradiation at 450 nm. However, after reaction with H2S,
In the presence of H2S, Ag can bind to S2, leading to the formation the LSPR absorption at 450 nm was weakened, subsequently
of Ag2S (Ksp ¼ 6.3 1050). The reaction equation is as follows resulting in a decrease of photothermal effect of Au@Ag NCs. The
(4Ag þ 2 S2 þ O2 þ 2H2O / 2 Ag2S þ 4OH). The generated Ag2S changes in the photothermal effect were reflected by the different
changes the surface composition of Au@Ag NCs, inducing a temperature changes under the laser irradiation. As the change of
decrease of the LSPR absorption peak of nanoparticles at 450 nm. As temperature could be decreased by the addition of H2S to the sys-
the photothermal effect of nanoparticles is governed by the light tem, a photothermal assay for H2S was developed by correlating the
absorption, the addition of H2S weakens the photothermal effect of H2S concentration with temperature changes. Simple control as-
Au@Ag NCs under the laser at 450 nm, leading to a decrease in says were performed to test the feasibility of the designed
temperature enhancement. The degree of the decrease strongly nanoparticles-based photothermal assay for H2S detection. The
relies on the concentration of the added H2S. Thus, the quantifi- UVevis spectrum was obtained to characterize the Au@Ag NCs
cation of H2S can be converted to a measurement of temperature, before and after mixing with H2S (Fig. 1A). The synthesized Au@Ag
and a convenient photothermal assay system can be established for NCs showed a strong absorption peak at 450 nm (curve a). How-
H2S using a common thermometer as readout. ever, after reaction with H2S, the absorption value of the mixed
As shown in Figure S1, TEM was used for the characterization of solution at around 450 nm decreased (curve b). Besides, the ab-
the morphology and structure of the Au@Ag NCs before and after sorption peak was slightly red shift. The decrease and red-shift of
the reaction with H2S. Moreover, to confirm the composition the absorption peak at around 450 nm may probably because of the
changing of the Au@Ag NCs after the addition of H2S, HAADF-STEM formation of Ag2S on the surface of Au@Ag NCs, as the LSPR ab-
and elemental mapping were employed to analyze the distribution sorption peak of nanoparticles is governed by the size, morphology,
of elements. Those result implied that the addition of H2S leads to and composition of nanoparticles [29e31]. Then the difference of
the deposition of sulfur onto Au@Ag NCs and changes the the photothermal effect of the nanoparticles was tested. As pre-
morphology and structure of Au@Ag NCs [23e27]. In addition, the sented in Fig. 1B, an obvious temperature enhancement was
effect of the non-specific aggregation on the photothermal effect of observed in Au@Ag NCs solution under the laser irradiation (curve
Au@Ag NCs was tested. As shown in Figure S2, the addition of a). But after reaction with H2S, the temperature enhancement
Tween-80 can avoid the change of photothermal effect of Au@Ag decreased greatly (curve b). The results imply that the addition of
NCs caused by non-specific aggregation. Meanwhile, the presence H2S can effectively alter the photothermal effect of Au@Ag NCs,
of Tween-80 did not affect the change of photothermal effect of which can be applied in the photothermal assay of H2S. Moreover,
Au@Ag NCs caused by the addition of H2S. the long-term stability of Au@Ag NCs was tested during the irra-
diation with laser and the addition of H2S. As shown in Figure S3,
under the irradiation with laser, the temperature of Au@Ag NCs
Scheme 1. (A) Schematic mechanism of the nanoparticles-based photothermal detection system for H2S. (B) Photograph of the photothermal assay system.
3
Y. Tao, Y. Lin, F. Luo et al. Analytica Chimica Acta 1149 (2021) 338211
Fig. 1. (A) UVevis absorption spectra of Au@Ag NCs before and after the addition of H2S. (B)Temperature comparison between Au@Ag NCs before and after addition of H2S during
the irradiation for 5 min. (C) The optimization of the dosage of the volume of Au@Ag NCs.
increased at the first 4 min and then reached a plateau. When the NCs has week absorption at 450 nm. As shown in Fig. 2A, owing to
irradiation was prolonged, no significant temperature decrease was the strong light-to-heat energy conversion of the Au@Ag NCs under
observed from 4 to 10 min, suggesting that Au@Ag NCs have suf- the irradiation with a 450 nm laser, the temperature of Au@Ag NCs
ficient stability in the photothermal assay (curve a). Similarly, the changed from 25 C to 55 C when the H2S was not added (0 mM).
long-term stability of Au@Ag NCs upon the addition of H2S was The temperature of the system decreased with the growing con-
tested. The addition of H2S did weak the photothermal effect of centrations of H2S. There was a linear relationship between the DT
Au@Ag NCs; however, under the relatively long-term irradiation, no and the logarithm of H2S concentration in the range of 0.5e80 mM
temperature decrease was observed in time intervals of 4e10 min, (Fig. 2B). The corresponding linear regression equation was
suggesting that Au@Ag NCs have sufficient stability in photo- DT ¼ 6.032 lg CH2S þ 4.52 (R2 ¼ 0.998) and the limit of detection
thermal assay (curve b). (LOD) was 0.35 mM (S/N ¼ 3). LOD was calculated based on the
traditional and typical approach reported in the previous reference.
3.3. Optimization of experimental conditions [32] The detail can be found in Supporting Information. Without
the use of bulk instruments, the sensitivity of this designed method
To obtain the best analytical performance, experimental con- for H2S is comparable to that in previous reported literature
ditions were optimized. In the above assay (Fig. 1B), the tempera- [11,33e35]. The target-induced nanoparticles color change was
ture of the system reached a plateau after the 4 min of laser usually used to design the colorimetric analysis method. However,
irradiation. Hence, the temperature value recorded at 4 min was as obtained in the inset of Fig. 2B, the color change induced by the
used for the next study. The dosage of Au@Ag NCs was optimized H2S was not obvious when the concentration of H2S was too close
because it may affect the temperature change range of the system (e.g. 2.0 and 5.0 mM), whereas the DT measured by the hand-held
and the sensitivity of detection. As shown in Fig. 1C, the change of thermometer had obvious difference, which enables the accurate
temperature enhancement (DT, defined as the difference of the quantitation of the target. Besides, compared with the common
temperature change before and after the addition of H2S) was colorimetric method for H2S, the consumption of nanoparticles in
utilized to study the effect of the various dosages of Au@Ag NCs. this work is much smaller because of the strong photothermal ef-
The total volume under the irradiation was fixed as 200 mL, and the fect of Au@Ag NCs.
concentration of H2S was set as 40 mM. The value of DT was low The selectivity of this photothermal system for H2S detection
when the dosage of Au@Ag NCs was less than 5 mL, which is was evaluated by using common ions (F, Cl, Br, HCO2 2
3 , CO3 ,
2 þ þ 2þ 2þ
probably because the low dosage of Au@Ag NCs only can absorb SO4 , NH4 , K , Ca , Mg ) and common substances in garbage
small amount of light energy, resulting in insignificant temperature odor gas (CH3SH, H2O2, SO2) as interferences [36]. The concentra-
changes even when H2S was not added. However, when the dosage tion of interferences was 0.15 mM, which is 10 times higher than
of Au@Ag NCs was higher than 5 mL, the DT decreased with the that of H2S. As shown in Fig. 3, the addition of H2S resulted in an
increased dosage. This is probably because the excessive use of obvious temperature change, while the introduction of other sub-
Au@Ag NCs causes strong light-to-heat conversion, and the influ- stances led to insignificant temperature changes. In addition, the
ence of the H2S on the light-to-heat conversion of Au@Ag NCs is highest tolerate concentrations of these interferences were deter-
weakened. Hence the dosage of Au@Ag NCs is a key factor for the mined, in which the relative error in measurement of H2S con-
sensitive detection of H2S. The maximum DT was obtained when centration was lower than 5.0%. The highest tolerate concentration
the dosage was 5 mL, hence 5 mL of Au@Ag NCs was used for the for F, Cl, Br, HCO2 2 2 þ þ 2þ 2þ
3 , CO3 , SO4 , NH4 , K , Ca , Mg , and H2O2
following study. was 0.1 M. This is probably because a simple sample purification
procedure is initially used to avoid the interference of other com-
3.4. Performance of the developed photothermal assay system pounds. The samples containing interference are firstly dissolved in
NaOH solution, and H2SO4 is subsequently added to release H2S. In
The analytical performance of this photothermal detection this process, most interferents are dissolved in NaOH, absorbed by
system was tested under the optimized experimental conditions. H2SO4, or converted into other substances. Only H2S can be released
The temperature changes in our assay were obtained from the and reacted with photothermal agents. The highest tolerate con-
light-to-heat energy conversion. The principle of this study lies in centrations for CH3SH andSO2 was 0.2 mM and 0.4 mM, respec-
that the Au@Ag NCs have different photothermal effects before and tively. This phenomenon is probably because the solubility of sulfur
after the reaction with H2S. The Au@Ag NCs can effectively absorb dioxide (11.3 g/mL) and methyl mercaptan (2.33 g/mL) is larger
laser at 450 nm; however, after the reaction with H2S, the Au@Ag than that of H2S (0.385 g/mL) at room temperature. Thus, the H2S is
4
Y. Tao, Y. Lin, F. Luo et al. Analytica Chimica Acta 1149 (2021) 338211
Fig. 2. (A) Temperature comparison of Au@Ag NCs with different H2S concentrations during the irradiation for 5 min (from the curve a to g, the concentration of H2S is 0, 0.5, 2, 5,
15, 40, 80 mM). (B) Calibration curve for quantification of the H2S concentration. Insets are the photographs of the samples.
was tested. The samples were collected and purified with simple
procedures mentioned in section 2.5. As shown in Table 1, the H2S
concentration value measured by the photothermal detection sys-
tem was consistent with that measured by the commercial H2S kit.
Moreover, in the recovery assay, the recovery rates were varied in
95.0e101.0% and the relative standard deviations (RSDs) were
lower than 5.0%. Besides, the proposed method was compared with
gas chromatography for the real gas sample detection as shown in
Table S2. The results indicated that these two methods are in
agreement with each other.
4. Conclusion
Table 1
Determination of H2S in the garbage odor gas samples (n ¼ 3).
Sample Found in the concentrated solution Corresponding concentration in gas samplesa Detected by a commercial kit Added Total found Recovery RSD
(mM) (ppb) (mM) (mM) (mM) (%) [%]
5
Y. Tao, Y. Lin, F. Luo et al. Analytica Chimica Acta 1149 (2021) 338211