Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 87

1

ABSTRACT

Name of Researchers:
Biscarra, Rachelle S.
Delin, Maria Theresa M.
Gayla, Gie Anne S.
Grospe, Mary Lhea T.
Pedrozo, Jericho

Name and Address of Institution: University of Eastern Pangasinan


McArthur Highway, Brgy.
Canarvacanan, Binalonan,
Pangasinan

Course: Bachelor of Science in Business


Administration major in Financial
Management

Semester and School Year: Second Semester S.Y. 2021-2022

Adviser: John Christopher Garces, MBA

Title of Research Study: Relevance of Service Quality and


Physical Environment on Customer
Satisfaction among Beauty Salon in
Binalonan, Pangasinan

Key Terms: Satisfaction, Business, Beauty Salon


Establishment, Business Customer
Service, Tangibility
2

ABSTRACT

This study focuses on the Relevance of Service Quality and Physical Environment

on Customer Satisfaction among Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan. This study

aimed to determine if the service quality provided by the beauty salon has relevance to

the customer satisfaction among the salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan. The findings of this

study will be essential and beneficial for salons in gaining a broader understanding in

providing a standard of service that could have an impact positively or negatively on the

customer satisfaction with their business. Additionally , the study will be helpful to the

business owners as well as serve as a guide to help them gain information that could also

enhance and eventually improve and ultimately gain profitability as it may lead to higher

customer satisfaction. Nevertheless, to the future researchers as the findings of the study

will serve as their basis and reference for further studies.

The majority of the customers in acquiring the services that the salon offers are in

the age ranges 18-21 years old, most of them are female and some are few male, In

addition beauty salon is an establishment that offers a variety of cosmetic

treatments and cosmetic services for men and women. Beauty salons may offer a

variety of services that may affect the customer satisfaction in terms of age and

gender. The majority female has a percentage of 78% or 78 out of 100 and for the

male customer respondents with a total of 22 or 22%. This implies that most

female are more frequent to go to salon to avail a business.

As in the result of study of Sulaiman et. al (2020) shows that 55% of their
3

respondents are female. And it was concluded that women belonging to different

age groups vary with respect to their perceptions regarding visit to beauty parlor.

Very young and young women feel that it is necessary to visit parlors whereas

elderly women feel that it is not necessary. Very young women do not give

importance to professional salons whereas middle age and elderly women prefer

services from professional salons. With respect to demographics, it was seen that

as qualification increases, the necessity for ambience factor also increases.

“Looking good and feeling confident‟ is of utmost priority to consumers in

general and women in particular.

The majority of the customers in acquiring the services that the salon offers

are in the age ranges 18-21 years old, most of them are female and some are few

male, In addition beauty salon is an establishment that offers a variety of cosmetic

treatments and cosmetic services for men and women. Beauty salons may offer a

variety of services that may affect the customer satisfaction in terms of age and

gender. The majority female has a percentage of 78% or 78 out of 100 and for the

male customer respondents with a total of 22 or 22%. This implies that most

female are more frequent to go to salon to avail a business.

As in the result of study of Sulaiman et. al (2020) shows that 55% of their

respondents are female. And it was concluded that women belonging to different

age groups vary with respect to their perceptions regarding visit to beauty parlor.

Very young and young women feel that it is necessary to visit parlors whereas
4

elderly women feel that it is not necessary. Very young women do not give

importance to professional salons whereas middle age and elderly women prefer

services from professional salons. With respect to demographics, it was seen that

as qualification increases, the necessity for ambience factor also increases.

“Looking good and feeling confident‟ is of utmost priority to consumers in

general and women in particular.

Based on the findings and conclusions, the researchers recommended that the salon

manager should focus with enhancing the skills of the employees by training, leading

them by examples, seminars regarding career development, for them to show what their

skills can do to achieve the customer satisfaction. They must also have an enough space

for upcoming customers such as waiting lines and have enough space for parking lots.
5

Chapter I

THE PROBLEM AND IT’S BACKGROUND

Background of the Study

Most people have various morning rituals for personal grooming. It includes

taking a daily shower, shaving, and getting a haircut once a month. A beauty salon is a

place where men and women can go to get services to improve their physical appearance.

It provides numerous services, including manicures, pedicures, foot care and spa,

haircuts, and hair treatments. However, due to a lack of knowledge from their target

customers, it's not like every beauty salon can readily raise profit.

Many can affect the customer’s satisfaction; it is not only about the product or

service a company may give to its customer. Since this is the key factor and best way to

increase the competitiveness of beauty facilities, their challenge is to find ways to

improve service quality. institute. Customer satisfaction is also constantly a top priority

for survival and growth in order to meet the needs of present consumers and attract fresh

ones. Since then, it has become necessary for the aesthetic facility, in addition to

enhancing service quality, to continually grasp consumer trends and customer

preferences.

In the post pandemic world, the parameters for customer satisfaction

have changed considerably (Monmousseau et al., 2020; Srivastava and Kumar,

2021; Wu et al., 2021). Pandemic has made personal interaction more

challenging (Brown, 2020). To be less vulnerable to becoming severely ill with

the virus, customers prefer touchless digital mediums of communications. For

example, Mason et al. (2021) concluded that pandemic has altered customers’


6

needs, shopping and purchasing behaviors, and post purchase satisfaction levels.

In connection to this the most vital aspect of a business is good service and

customers satisfaction. Giving excellent customer service is becoming increasingly vital

as time passes in every organization.

With the study of Sulaiman et al entitled “Customer Satisfaction and Service

Quality of SPA in Penang”, stated that meeting the customers’ expectations is one

requirement the customer seek when availing the service at the spa industry. However,

lack of skill of the staff and discomfort ambience can lead to the unsatisfied towards the

service quality and decrease the level of customer satisfaction in the spa. The finding of

their study shows that there is no relationship between service quality and ambience or

the physical appearance of the store towards customer satisfaction in the spa.

Along with customer satisfaction plays a pivotal role in success of every business

whether it is meant for a product or a service. Customers satisfaction is at the heart of

marketing. Ninety-nine percent of dissatisfied customers will never buy another product

or service from the organization, understanding customer satisfaction is an effective

approach to reduce disgruntled customers while improving profits. The more reliable the

service provided by the business entity the greater the level of customer satisfaction.

Customer satisfaction is a critical aspect of a company's product since it determines the

level of profitability between the company's product and the beliefs of its customers. (Ali

et al 2021)

Nowadays, customer satisfaction is a very significant factor in determining how

well a company's product meets customer expectations. Customers will not care about

products if a corporation does not care about their satisfaction.


7

As in the study of Panicker (2017) entitled “A Study on the Service Quality

Attributes of Parlor Service Employees and Their Contribution to Customer Satisfaction

in the Beauty Care Service Industry”, stated that customer satisfaction at the beauty

parlor can be largely attributed to the skill sets and unique capabilities possessed by the

parlor service employee.

To meet the economy's expanding demand, businesses must deliver high-quality

services, as well as consumers satisfaction. In marketing, the word "customer

satisfaction" is commonly employed. It's a metric for how well a company's new products

and services meet or exceed customer expectations.

As cited in the study of Suria Sulaiman et. al (2020) that according to

Parasuraman et al. Customers who purchase goods and services from the spa business

commonly want such products or services to fulfill to their expectations so they can be

satisfied. A lack of expertise on the part of the employees and an uncomfortable

ambience might make customers dissatisfied with the quality of the services they receive

at the spa. The tangible, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy are all

correlated to service staff.

Along with Commence (2020) “What Factors Influence Customer Satisfaction?”

that three major factors that affect modern customer satisfaction are customer

understanding, service, and technology. Loyal customers want to be assured that they are

buying from an organization that truly cares about their best interests. Customers prefer

companies that offer multiple choices, remember their preferences, and personalize the

buying experience. And true customer satisfaction takes more than just attentive

employees. Excellent customer service is also ensuring that the needs of consumers are
8

met. Most consumers require convenient, intuitive customer service that delivers exactly

what they want in a timely manner. And lastly in order to satisfy consumers with

technology, the company channels should be widely accessible, easy to navigate and load

pages quickly.

Moreover Panicker and Muhammad (2017) supported the idea that

beauticians/hairdresser at the parlor has great contribution in gathering satisfaction of

customers. Also, a great service quality results in excellent customer satisfaction which in

return, the loyalty of the customers. Most of women are very accurate regarding the

behavior of the employees serving them. Once satisfied with one particular employee,

they would prefer the same employee in receiving the service once visited the salon

again. Through the study, findings concluded that service quality provided by the

employees and customer satisfaction associated with great performance has a strong

relationship.

According to the study of Gong and Yi (2018) entitled “The Effect of Service

Quality on Customer Satisfaction, Loyalty, and Happiness in Five Asian Countries”, the

findings show that overall service quality has a positive influence on customer

satisfaction, which in turns leads to customer loyalty and customer happiness and that the

general pattern of structural paths is valid in the five countries. Also, the result of this

study reveals four key findings. First, customer well-being or happiness was driven by

service quality. Second, customer loyalty was driven by service quality across the five

Asian countries, demonstrating that the economic values of service quality could be

applied to Asian countries just as they are in North American and European countries.

Third, customer satisfaction was driven by service quality. Fourth, customer income
9

increased the effect of service quality on customer happiness via customer satisfaction in

China, Hong Kong, and South Korea.

Also in the study of Sureka et al (2017) entitled “Customer Satisfaction and

Service Quality Towards Natural Parlor, Chennai” stated the role of satisfaction on

repurchase and defining the intervention between customer satisfaction and repurchase

intention and loyalty. It is quite clear that in this service role of satisfaction on repurchase

and defining the intervention between custom satisfaction and repurchase intention and

loyalty. It is quite clear that in this service that overall satisfaction is an important factor

in retaining customers. For developing customer retention strategies, effort should be put

on satisfying the customers to achieve the highest level of repurchase intention and

subsequent retention.

R. Jayasathya and P. Priya on 2019 conducted “A Study on Customer Preference

towards Natural Unisex Salon and Spa” in that they said considerable difference between

the service preference of the beauty salon in terms of reliability, responsiveness,

empathy, assurance and tangible dimension of service quality. It is emphasized that

service industry should work to prevent and minimize the gaps in service quality by

improving the customer preference with service offerings.

Also, customer satisfaction is a metric that encourages a greater focus on the

customer's outcome while also encouraging improvements in the company's work

methods and processes.

And according to Seth et al defined service quality as the ability for service

providers to match expected service with perceived service to achieve customer

satisfaction. Service quality was evaluated utilizing the SERVQUAL model proposed by
10

Parasuraman et al.

Moreover Aleksandar et al, service is known as tangible because it cannot be

touched or seen it can only be experienced or feel. The most significant component of

maintaining service quality is that it helps mold the product according to the services and

the needs of the clients. Customers satisfaction is based on the service quality the

business may provide to its customer; on how will they serve.

In addition to this, according to Parisa and Ayesha (2018), customers evaluate the

setting of the parlor, therapy services, information-dissemination system, and cost while

selecting a specific parlor. They also consider the service provider's behavior and

knowledge. According to the study's findings, the environment, the executive's behavior,

the complaint-handling system, and trustworthiness were all factors that customers of

high-end parlors found to be immensely satisfying. The common service-quality factors

that contributed to customer satisfaction could be divided into four major categories:

support & facility factor, employee performance factor, customer relationship factor, and

communication factor. The factors considered things like the environment, the materials,

the accurate service, the prompt service, the handling of concerns, the knowledge of the

service provider and executive, the behavior of the service provider and executive, the

credibility of the provider, the accessibility, the safety, the accessibility, the

advertisement, the information provided by the service provider, the understanding of the

need of the client, and the working.

In connection to this, according to the study of Gonzaga (2021) entitled “Service

Quality and Customer Satisfaction among Beauty Salons”, the study was conducted to

determine the significant influence of service quality on customer satisfaction among


11

beauty salons in a certain municipality of Davao del Norte, Philippines. Further, only

tangibles domains significantly influences customer satisfaction while the rest did not.

Thus service quality is recommended to be enhanced to achieve a high level of customer

satisfaction.

And in the study of Mangarin (2021) it was to determine the significant influence of

service quality on customer satisfaction among beauty salons in a certain municipality in

Mindanao. According to the result, service quality was in high level which while

customer satisfaction was in moderate level.

As well as with the study of Asis et al entitled “Service Quality Assessment of

Beauty Salons in Batong Malake, Los Banos Using Importance Performance Analysis” ,

the study evaluates the service quality provided by beauty salons at Batong Malake, Los

Banos, Laguna using Importance Performance Analysis (IPA). It was determined that

availability of service information, promptness of service, availability of internet

connection and parking space must be improved.

Also that business who are able to give excellent customer service have the best

chance of continuing to be frequented by their customers. Because service quality is a

crucial factor in motivating customers to behave favorably, such as promoting the

company's products to others. It can be interpreted that the Service quality of a business

will have a positive impact on customers satisfaction and loyalty. ( NiLuhDesiyanti et al

2018)

As a person's reaction to a product or service's perceived performance in

proportion to their expectations will determine whether they feel satisfied, which can be

either happy or disappointed. Customers assume which offer will be more valuable.
12

Within the boundaries of search expenses, limited knowledge, mobility, and income,

customers are valued as much as possible. They develop as an expectation and value and

follow through on it. Whether or whether the offer meets the value exception has an

impact on both customer satisfaction and the likelihood of a repeat purchase. Anything

that may be sold to a market to fulfill a need or desire qualifies as a product.

And because of the pandemic COVID-19 is having a seismic effect not only in the

food industry but on businesses around the world. Some research studies show this

pandemic affect the customers satisfaction in times of pandemic since the limited number

of customers within the business premises, some businesses are even forced to shut down

and following the protocols for them to function while in the midst of pandemic.

In the study of Rabo and Ang (2018) entitled “Determinants of Customer

Satisfaction in a Philippine Retail Chain”, states that satisfied customers would likely

repurchase and influence customer loyalty, thus understanding customer satisfaction can

provide organizations with information to streamline their operations. Determinants of

customer satisfaction can be classified into three main factors, namely, quality and

quantity of goods and services offered, customer experience, and value for money.

Additionally, according to the study of Farooqui and Alwi (2019), Social cues,

design cues, and ambient cues are the three types of environmental influences. The

complete view and ambience of the restaurant is an ambient cue, the decorations and

interior decoration are a design cue, and the customers in the restaurant are a social cue. It

also stated there that the physical environment produces an image in the mind of the

consumer that influences their behavior toward the restaurant; it also includes furniture,

scent, music, and lighting, all of which contribute to the creation of an outshine
13

environment.

Furthermore, in the study of Altejar et.al (2019) entitled “Study of Effects of

Customer Service Quality and Product Quality on Customer Satisfaction and Customer

Loyalty” the researchers address the effects of customer service quality and product

quality on customer satisfaction and customer loyalty, and the relationship between these

four variables in the context of food-chain industry. Customer loyalty is the key part

behind a business’ success as it also extends the market esteem. On the other hand, its

product quality and customer service quality are important points in meeting the

customer’s satisfaction. Results of the study show that product and customer service

quality only has a small effect on customer satisfaction; and customer satisfaction does

not guarantee the loyalty of the customer.

In accordance with the study of Aguilar (2022), entitled “Experiential Marketing

on Revisiting Intention of Beauty Salons”, the purpose of the study is to determine the

significant association of experiential marketing dimensions on customer revisit intention

in Beauty Salons, examine the experiential marketing dimensions in terms of sense,

relate, feel, think and act. Also, determine the frequency of visits and the type of services

availed by the respondents. And based on the result of the study, the overall experience of

a customer response in revisit intention in terms of sense, relate, feel, think, and act does

have a significant importance to create perceptions of places and to establish brand

reputation in beauty salons.

Also with the beauty service business it is one of the many business that play an

important role in economic and social development. A product is anything that can be

made available to the public for use, consumption, or attention acquisition that satisfies a
14

desire or need. It encompasses tangible things like services, individuals, locations,

organizations, and concepts.

Based from the study of Ferrer et al (2021) entitled “A Feasibility Study on

Establishing Barbers on the Wheels; a Mobile barbershop for Men” the study was

conducted in Dagupan, Pangasinan and aims to monitor the current status of the

movement the supply and demand for the hair and grooming service industry is greatly

affected. It also aims to bridge the gap of having a proper hair grooming for the clients

despite the occurrence of the COVID 19.

As well as that a beauty salon is an establishment that provides services for hair,

nails and skin. These services are offered to both men and women. For hair services,

these includes hair cutting, styling, treatment, dyeing etc. Manicures and pedicures are

offered for the nails. Often, these salons provide other services such as facials, makeups

and makeover.

Physical beauty is an advantage as being beautiful gives a person much more

confidence. Even it has been shown that being attractive can give a person up to 10 folds

increases in getting marry.

This study aims to determine if the service quality provided by the beauty salon

has relevance to the customer satisfaction among the salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan. The

findings of this study will be essential and beneficial for salons in gaining a broader

understanding in providing a standard of service that could have an impact positively or

negatively on the customer satisfaction with their business. Additionally, the study will

be helpful to the business owners as well as serve as a guide to help them gain

information that could also enhance and eventually improve and ultimately gain
15

profitability as it may lead to higher customer satisfaction. Nevertheless, to the future

researchers as the findings of the study will serve as their basis and reference for further

studies.

Theoretical Framework

According to Maslow's theory, the physical setting is perceived as most important

when it is least satisfactory, that is, when it threatens or fails to meet basic needs.

Otherwise, the physical environment psychologically recedes into the background. The

theory has great practical appeal but rather limited empirical support.

Customer Satisfaction (CS hereafter) is considering as a crucial factor of which can

affect the firm sales (Thi & Nguyen, 2020). Currently, the beauty service industry has

subdivided and specialized into hair, makeup, nail care, and skin care (Yoo & Park, 2020)

SERVQUAL Model developed by Parasuman and Berry, is a method to capture and

measure the service quality experienced by a customer. It is a multi-dimensional designed

to capture consumer expectations and perceptions of a service along five dimensions that

are believed to represent service quality, these five dimensions are tangibility,

responsiveness, empathy, assurance and reliability.

Beauty management is an outward expression method to give confidence in

interpersonal relations and to deliver good impression (Jung & Moon, 2018).

Beauty service contains mental stability effect for successful decrepitude and confidence

improvement instead of changing external management, pursuing beauty trend Simply

(Jung & Moon, 2018).

It is worth paying attention to the research results that the personality characteristics

of organizational members can have a significant effect on service orientation, job


16

satisfaction, and job turnover in order to maintain a higher customer service level and

stable human power (Park et al., 2019).

Since human history started, the beauty desire had become the basic instinct and raw

thing of humanity and it had built in various aspects through the age (Jung & Moon,

2018).

The beauty service at the hair salon is to provide hairstyle related services such as

shampoo, cut, perm, color, scalp and hair care to customers who want to increase their

emotional satisfaction and self-esteem by satisfying their aesthetic needs. In terms of

dealing with part of the body, face-to-face is essential, and because the time for contact

and interaction with customers is longer than that of other service industries, quality

control of the human service provided is important. In addition, since the non-technical

services of hair salon human resources affect the customer’s feelings toward the

company, the attitude, appearance, and communication ability of the service provider also

play a large part in the competitiveness of the company (Moon et al., 2019).

Conceptual Framework

In this research, the researcher presents the conceptual framework of the study

using the input, process-output (IPO) model as the study’s working paradigm.

The conceptual framework which includes the paradigm of the study and is

presented using the Input-Process-Output (IPO) model. The input consists of the profile

of the respondents which includes the age and gender. Also, the relevance of service

quality in terms of Tangibility, Responsiveness, Empathy, Assurance and Reliability in

which the researchers want to determine if service quality have significant effect on

customers satisfaction, also regarding how customer achieve customers satisfaction in


17

terms service quality. On the other side, the process being used is through survey,

questionnaire, tabulation, and computation data analysis and interpretation of the result

Figure 1 shows how the researchers studied, surveyed and solved their research

study.

INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT

1. What is the profile of respondents


in terms of:

a. age; and
b. gender?

2.What are the services provided in


the salon that the customer acquired
in determining their level of
satisfaction?

3. What is the relevance of Service THE RESEARCHERS USE


Quality in terms of:
TO COLLECT DATA
a. tangibility
What is the relevance of
THROUGH SURVEY
b. responsiveness
service quality to
QUESTIONNAIRE.
c. empathy
TABULATION AND customer satisfaction
d. assurance

e. reliability? COMPUTATION DATA among beauty salon in

4. Is there a significant relationship ANALYSIS AND Binalonan, Pangasinan.


between the profile of respondents
and the service quality to customer INTERPRETATION
satisfaction among beauty salon in
Binalonan, Pangasinan. RESULT

5. What strategic plan can be propose


to improve the operations of beauty
parlor business in Binalonan,
Pangasinan?

FEEDBACK
18

Figure 1. Paradigm of the Study.

Statement of the Problem

This Research study is all about “Relevance of Service Quality to Customer

Satisfaction Among Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan” in which the researchers

seek to answer the following questions:

1. What is the profile of respondents in terms of:

a. age; and

b. gender

2. What are the services provided by the salon that customers acquire in determining

their level of satisfaction?

3. What is the relevance of service quality in terms of:

a. tangibility;

b. responsiveness;

c. empathy;

d. assurance; and

e. reliability?

4. Is there a significant relationship between the profile of the respondents and the

service quality to customer satisfaction among the beauty salon in Binalonan,

Pangasinan?
19

5. What strategic plan can be proposed to improve the operations of beauty salon

business in Binalonan, Pangasinan?

Null Hypothesis - is there no significant relationship between the profile of respondents

and service quality to customer satisfaction among beauty salons in Binalonan,

Pangasinan.

Assumption of the Study

1. The age of the respondents, who are customers of beauty salon business in Binalonan,

Pangasinan is up to 18 years and up. Male and female are very much welcome to try and

experience this kind of servce.

2. The researcher assumes that service quality such as; tangibility, responsiveness,

empathy, assurance and reliability greatly influence customer satisfaction when availing

the business service.

3. The researchers also assumes that business owners and employees encounter

challenges when it comes to satisfy their customer in terms of the service they provide of

the said business.

Significance of the Study

This study will be beneficial to the following:

The Researchers - the study will benefit the researcher as they gain new knowledge

about this study.

Selected Customer Respondents – will have their privilege to provide them information

about what to expect in their service and to rate the job performance of the staff and

crews. They can also give their suggestions on how it can be improved.
20

Management – can use the provided findings strategies and understandable knowledge

to improve and develop their business as well as the satisfaction level from customer.

Staff and Employees – will be beneficial for them to know if they were able to do their

job and providing the best service experience to customer.

The Future Researchers – This study will be beneficial for the future researchers to use

it as a basis for their research.

Community - This study will be beneficial to the community for the business to know

what to consider when they want their customer to feel satisfied with the service or

product they are offering to the public.

Definition of Terms

The following are the term that the researchers used in this study, here they are defined as

follows:

Customer satisfaction – defines a customer as a business's most significant stakeholder

who pays cash in return for a product offering delivered to a person by the organization

with the goal of meeting a need and eventually maximizing satisfaction of the same.

Service Quality-defines service quality as a thorough evaluation or view on the entire

excellence of services delivered to a variety of stakeholders, including the organization's

consumers.

Tangibility- This means characteristic is connected to the attractiveness of a service

firm's facilities, equipment, and materials, as well as the look of service staff.

Responsiveness- This indicates that service business staffs are willing to assist

consumers and reply to their demands, as well as tell customers when service will be

supplied and then offer quick service.


21

Empathy-It means that the firm understands its customers' concerns and acts in their best

interests, as well as providing them with specific personal attention and working hours

that are convenient for them.

Assurance – It means the skill of the employee to produce trust and credibility in minds

of the consumer. It requires proper knowledge and dedication.

Reliability – It means the ability of the firm to perform the service effectively and

accurately. It measures whether the firm lived up to its promises or not.

Chapter II

DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY

This chapter will cover the research methodologies used in the development of

this study. This includes the research design, study subjects, and sampling scheme, as

well as data gathering instruments, data collection, and statistical treatment.

Research Design and Methodology

The descriptive method will be use by the researcher in this study using a

questionnaire checklist as the main instrument to gather the needed data. The purpose of

descriptive research is to become more familiar with phenomena, to gain new insight, and

affect relationships among variables. Quantitative methods emphasize objective

measurements and statistical, mathematical, or numerical analysis of data collected

through polls, questionnaires, and surveys, or by manipulating pre-existing statistical data

using computational techniques.

This method will be used to describe the personal profile such as age and sex of the

respondents. Also, the service offered, and the dimension of customer satisfaction in
22

terms of tangibility, responsiveness, empathy, assurance, and reliability.

Population and Locale of the Study

The respondents of the study are a total of 100 customers of beauty salon within the

public market of municipality of Binalonan, Pangasinan. The researcher will use the

purposive sampling to get the total size of the sample respondents.

Purposive sampling (also known as controlled by the researcher, selective, or

subjective sampling) is a type of non-probability sampling in which researchers choose

people from in general to participate in their surveys based on their own opinion. H Ames

(2019)

Data Gathering Instrument

The researchers will prepare a checklist-questionnaire validated by their external

and internal validators. And a letter of request to conduct the study will be prepare.

The researcher will conduct the study in Binalonan public market and will humbly

ask for the permission of the business owner and along with the customers of the said

business as their respondents to answer the said questionnaire. The tool that will be use in

gathering the need data is in the form of a questionnaire. When data gathering

instruments are approved and substantiated, surveys will be serve by handing out the

questionnaire to the chosen number of respondents to make results significantly reliable.


23

Part I of the questionnaire will focus on the profile of the respondents which include their

age and gender. Part II of the questionnaire intends to gather information about the

services availed by the customers in the salon and Part III of the questionnaire concern

with the information of the service quality in terms of; a) Tangibility, b) Responsiveness,

c)Empathy, d.) Assurance, e.) Reliability. These will be given one set of four checkboxes

and will rank as follows: 4 – Highly Satisfied 3 – Satisfied 2 – Unsatisfied 1 – Strongly

Unsatisfied.

Data Gathering Procedure

After the tools in gathering the data were finalized and checked, the researchers will

seek the permission and approval of the Dean, Dr. Mona Liza D. Abanes and research

adviser Mr. John Christopher V. Garces to conduct the study to the chosen beauty salons.

The researchers personally floated the questionnaire and administered the test to the

respondents and asked for their cooperation to accomplish the desired completion of the

study. The content of the questionnaire is explained properly and that the respondents

must need to answer with full honesty. As for the questionnaires’ retrieval, the

researchers personally collected them from the respondents.

Treatment of Data

The data were collected and tabulated to determine on how to interpret and

analyze the study. To answer the problem 1 in the statement of the problem in which it is

the personal profile of the respondents in terms of age and gender. Question number 2 is

the services availed by the customer. Another is the relevance of service quality in terms

of tangibility, responsiveness, empathy, assurance, and reliability among the customers


24

who is chosen by the researchers as a respondent at Binalonan, Pangasinan in which

frequency counts, percentages and average weighted means are shown below.

For problem number one and two, the personal profile of the respondents and

what service they avail at the salon, frequency and percentage was used. The formula is

shown below.

P = f/n x 100

Where: P= percentage equivalent

F= frequency

N= total number of respondents

To answer the third problem about what is the relevance of service quality in

terms of tangibility, responsiveness, empathy, assurance, and reliability, it was

tabulated using a mean scale with the corresponding average weighted mean (WM)

Weighted average is a calculation that considers the varying degrees of

importance or frequency of the numbers in a data set. A weighted average can be

much more reliable than a basic average, which assigns the same weight to all integers

in a data collection. Each value in the data set is multiplied by a predefined weight first

before final computation is completed in generating a weighted average.

(ArhileshGanti, 2021)

Descriptive equivalent (DE) shown below:

AWM= (∑fixi)
25

Where: AWM = average weighted mean

F = frequency

X = rating value of each category

N = total number of respondents

The following scale was used to interpret the obtained weighted mean:

Likert Scale:

Point of Value Mean Scale Descriptive Scale Description

4 3.50 - 4.49 Very Satisfied This mean that the

quality of

service provided by the salon

is outstanding.

3 2.50 - 3.49 Satisfied This mean that the quality of

service provided by the salon

is satisfactory

2 1.50 - 2.49 Unsatisfied This mean that the quality of

service provided by the salon

is poor.

1 1.00 - 1.49 Strongly Unsatisfied This mean that the quality of

service provided by the salon

is very poor.
26

To answer problem number 4 on the significant relationship between the profile

of respondents and the relevance of service quality to customer satisfaction among beauty

salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan, the following formula was utilized:

Pearson-r Correlation was used to determine the significant relationship between the

service quality in terms of Tangibility, Responsiveness, Empathy, Assurance and

Reliability to customer satisfaction. It is a measure of the strength of a linear association

between two variables and is denoted by r.

Where: r = Pearson Coefficient

n = number of the pairs of the stock

∑ xy = sum of products of the paired stocks


∑ x = sum of the x scores
∑ y = sum of the y scores
∑ x 2 = sum of the squared x scores
∑ y2 = sum of the squared y scores
Also Chi Square Test of Independence was used to test the statistical significance

of the cross-tabulation table for age group and dimension of customer satisfaction. It is

used for categorical variables like the age since it is in bracket. It is to test whether the

two variables are related to each other


27

For Chi-Square ∑ ¿¿ ¿
Where, 0 = Observed frequency

E = Expected frequency

Σ = Summation

X 2 = Chi Square value

Chapter III

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

In this chapter present the results and interpretation based on the data gathered

from the customers of salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan. The data gathered is presented in

table form. And the findings are interpreted in this chapter to know the relevance of

service quality to customer satisfaction in terms of, tangibility, responsiveness, empathy,

assurance and reliability.

Table 1 shows the data gathered from the personal profile of the customers from

the salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan, which includes age and gender as well as the

corresponding frequency count and percentage of the variables. The data gathered were

presented below for a better understanding.

Personal Profile of Respondents in terms of Age and Gender

Table 1 presents the personal profile of respondents in terms of their age and

gender in the salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan in which in terms of age most of the

respondents ranges 19 to 21 years old in which if we will look for its percentage it is 38%
28

While the lowest will be the 38 and above which has a percentage of 5%, another is the

Gender in which the female has a percentage of 78% compare to male that has a

percentage of 22%

Table 1

Personal Profile of Respondents in terms of Age and Gender:

n=100
VARIABLES INDICATORS FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE%
AGE 18 – 21 38 38
22 – 25 37 37
26 – 29 13 13
30 – 33 4 4
34 – 37 3 3
38 AND ABOVE 5 5
GENDER
MALE 22 22
FEMALE 78 78
Age. The table shows that ages 18 – 21 has the highest frequency of 38 or with a

percentage of 38%. And for ages 34 - 37 has the lowest frequency of 3 and a percentage

of 3%. The result of the study of Sultana and Islam (2017) shows that in the age of 15 –

24 are the has the most frequency, as age of a customer plays an important role in

determining expectation and perception of customers regarding various aspects of service

quality offered by the employees.

Dr. Farzana and R. Banu Priya (2017) concluded that the perception of below 25

years and 26 – 36 years old of people are opinion that there is necessity of beauty salon,
29

and they want to pamper themselves. At below 25 years of age group of people have

started using beauty services for personal hygiene. In an age where looking and feeling

beautiful is given prime importance, beauty service industry is growing steadily, although

at a slow stride.

The results implies that those from 18 – 21 years of age are the most customers of

salon.

Sex. The table also shows that most of the customer are female with a percentage

of 78% or 78 out of 100 and for the male customer respondents with a total of 22 or 22%.

This implies that most female are more frequent to go to salon to avail a business.

As in the result of study of Sulaiman et. al (2020) shows that 55% of their

respondents are female. And it was concluded that women belonging to different age

groups vary with respect to their perceptions regarding visit to beauty parlor. Very young

and young women feel that it is necessary to visit parlors whereas elderly women feel

that it is not necessary. Very young women do not give importance to professional salons

whereas middle age and elderly women prefer services from professional salons. With

respect to demographics, it was seen that as qualification increases, the necessity for

ambience factor also increases. “Looking good and feeling confident‟ is of utmost

priority to consumers in general and women in particular

Table 2

Services availed by the customer at the salon

n=244

VARIABLES INDICATORS FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE %


Service/s availed
by the customer
at the salon
Blow Dry 11 11
30

Brazilian Keratin 8 8
Brazilian Blow Out 3 3
Color Highlights 14 14
Hair Cellophane 5 5
Hair Color 57 57
Hair Cut 60 60
Hair Curl/Perming 2 2
Hair Extension 0 0
Hair Keratin Treatment 8 8
Hair Spa 2 2
Highlights 6 6
Hot Oil Treatment 4 4
Rebond 11 11
Rebond with Treatment 11 11
Gel Manicure 4 4
Manicure 15 15
Pedicure 13 13
Foot Spa 5 5
Eyebrow Threading 1 1
Eyelash Extension 4 4
Table 2 shows the gathered information about the services that the customer

availed at the salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan. Based from the table above hair cut has

highest frequency of 60 with a percentage of. And for the Eyebrow Threading 1 out of

the 100 respondents acquired this kind of service at the salon.

Haircuts for men, women, and kids should be the salon's most primary service.

Although some salons have areas of specialization, it is anticipated that the beauticians

can trim all kinds of hair. Another common service that is included in the price of the

haircut is drying and styling the client's hair before they leave the salon. To be able to

provide each client with a haircut and style, all beauticians must have knowledge of

various hair types.

One of the most desirable treatments at a hair salon is hair coloring. Most

individuals visit salons to have their hair professionally colored because home hair

coloring can go wrong in so many ways and box colors are bad for hair. Customers who

visit the salon typically believe they can acquire the exact shade they desire because

professional beauticians may mix colors to achieve the desired look. All-over color,
31

touch-ups, grey cover, highlights, lowlights, and other hair coloring techniques are all

possible. The expectations of beauticians change along with changing and evolving hair

coloring trends. (The Collegian, 2020)

The result implies that hair cut is the most common service customers avail and

least for the Eyebrow Threading.

Table 3

Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction in terms of Tangibility

n=100

A. Tangibility Weighted Descriptive


Mean Equivalent
1.) I am satisfied with the physical facilities and the 3.15 S
visual appeal of the salon.
2.) I am satisfied because the salon employees are 3.40 S
well dressed and neat
3.) I am satisfied because the place is very accessible 3.12 S
and have enough parking space for the customers.
4.) I am satisfied because the salon uses modern
equipment in providing services. 3.29 S
5.) I am satisfied with the arrangement of facilities
because it is well-ordered. 3.27 S
OVERALL WEIGHTED MEAN 3.26 S
Legend: AWM = Average Weighted Mean; DE = Descriptive Equivalent; 3.50 – 4.00
(Highly Satisfied); 2.50 – 3.49 (Satisfied); 2.49 – 1.50 (Unsatisfied) 1.00 – 1.49
(Strongly Unsatisfied)
The table above illustrates the mean that the researchers gathered using the

questionnaire responses from a total of 100 respondents. It has an overall weighted mean

of 3.30, in which customers are satisfied with the physical appearance of the facility as

well as the appearance of the personnel at the salon. In the statement “I am satisfied
32

because the salon employees are well-dressed/neat.” perceived a highest average with

3.46 with a descriptive equivalent of “Satisfied” and the statement, “I am satisfied

because the place is very accessible and have enough parking space for the customers.”

which has the least overall weighted mean of 3.17 and a descriptive equivalent of

“Satisfied”.

Compared to intangible advertising or good work, the precise cost of delivering a

tangible product to the customer can be defined and measured with more accuracy.

Tangibility has been linked to higher customer satisfaction, emotional attachment,

generosity, and willingness to pay, according to earlier study. As tangibility significantly

affects the customer's perception of service quality, it can therefore be used to determine

customer satisfaction. (Stushek, 2018)

This implies that when it comes to the physical appearance of the employees of

the salon the customer are satisfied with it and focus on how they can provide enough

space for parking for the upcoming customers, All of the things mention above are the

things that can affect their satisfaction. Parking convenience is one of the factors that

influence customer retention and repeat purchases in one business therefore those things

should focus by the business itself for them to achieve the satisfaction that they needed.

Table 4

Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction in terms of Responsiveness

n=100

B. Responsiveness AWM DE
1.) I am satisfied because the personnel are polite and friendly. 3.31 S
2.) I am satisfied because the salon have enough space for 3.31 S
incoming customers.
3.) I am satisfied because the personnel inform how many 3.14 S
33

minutes it may take the service I avail to be done. 3.37 S


4.) I am satisfied because personnel are approachable when you
need assistance. 3.20 S
5.) I am satisfied because of the positive response of personnel
when you ask for knowledge or information in acquiring
their service.
OVERALL WEIGHTED MEAN 3.28 S
Legend: AWM = Average Weighted Mean; DE = Descriptive Equivalent; 3.50 – 4.00
(Highly Satisfied); 2.50 – 3.49 (Satisfied); 2.49 – 1.50 (Unsatisfied) 1.00 – 1.49
(Strongly Unsatisfied)

The overall average weighted mean for Relevance of Service Quality to Customer

Satisfaction in terms of Responsiveness is 3.28, in which most of the customers at the

salon are satisfied that they experience the willingness of the salon to help the customers

by providing them prompt service. It is clearly seen in the statement “I am satisfied

because personnel are appreciable when you need assistance” perceives the highest

weighted mean of 3.37 with the descriptive equivalent of “satisfied” and the statement “I

am satisfied because the personnel inform how many minutes it may take the service I

avail to be done” which obtained the least average weighted mean of 3.15 as “satisfied”.

Uyoga, 2018 stated in their study that customers showed more satisfaction when

staff members responded more promptly to service performance.

That employees' readiness and willingness to assist customers by performing

prompt service represents what is meant by "responsiveness."

As cited in the study of Spyridoula Vryoni et al., (2017), spa customers were

asked about the extent to which SERVQUAL variables influence their satisfaction.

Results showed that, among the five SERVQUAL instrument factors, responsiveness

(willingness to help the customer) had the highest correlation with spa customers'

satisfaction and explained almost 22.15% of the variance.

This implies that when it comes to informing the customers the salon should
34

clearly inform the customer on how many minutes it may take in acquiring the service to

finish for the salon to keep their customer satisfied on the service quality that they offer.

And that customers are satisfied because the salon has willingness to help customer by

providing prompt service.

Table 5

Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction in terms of Empathy

n=100

C. Empathy AWM DE
1.) I am satisfied because they have convenient business 3.30 S
hours.
2.) I am satisfied because the personnel are attentive to the 3.26 S
needs of the customers.
3.) I am satisfied because the personnel respond to 3.24 S
customer’s concern.
4.) I am satisfied because they have individual attention to 3.27 S
customer.
5.) I am satisfied because personnel ask for customer’s 3.30 S
feedback to know if they are satisfied.
OVERALL WEIGHTED MEAN 3.32 S
Legend: AWM = Average Weighted Mean; DE = Descriptive Equivalent; 3.50 – 4.00
(Highly Satisfied); 2.50 – 3.49 (Satisfied); 2.49 – 1.50 (Unsatisfied) 1.00 – 1.49
(Strongly Unsatisfied).

In table 5 shows the result for relevance of service quality to customer satisfaction

in terms of empathy with an overall weighted mean of 3.32 and a descriptive equivalent

of “Satisfied”. It shows that the statement “I am satisfied because personnel ask for

customer’s feedback to know if they are satisfied.” with an average weighted mean of
35

3.36 and descriptive equivalent of “Satisfied” and statement “I am satisfied because the

personnel respond to customer’s concern.” which obtained the least average weighted

mean of 3.28 with a descriptive equivalent of “Satisfied”.

In accordance with the study of Sultana (2017), findings revealed that customers

are least satisfied with the empathy which includes special care and attention to

customers every time. So, empathy dimensions in beauty parlors in Chittagong needs to

emphasize more to enhance the satisfaction level of their customers.

This implies that the business is concern with the feedback of their customer if

they are satisfied with the service provided and must focus more on responding to the

concern of their customers. And customers are satisfied because the salon employee gives

proper attention and care to their customers.

Table 6

Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction in terms of Assurance

n=100

D. Assurance AWM DE
1.) I am satisfied because the employees can provide all 3.24 S
required information about the service I avail.
2.) I am satisfied because the salon employees are 3.26 S
consistently courteous.
3.) I am satisfied because the salon transaction are safe and 3.27 S
accurate.
4.) I am satisfied with the professionalism of the employee. 3.30 S
5.) I am satisfied because the employees delivered the 3.21 S
service in efficient way.
OVERALL WEIGHTED MEAN 3.22 S
Legend: AWM = Average Weighted Mean; DE = Descriptive Equivalent; 3.50 – 4.00
(Highly Satisfied); 2.50 – 3.49 (Satisfied); 2.49 – 1.50 (Unsatisfied) 1.00 – 1.49
(Strongly Unsatisfied).
In table 6, shows the result for relevance of service quality to customer

satisfaction in terms of assurance with an overall weighted mean of 3.30 and a descriptive
36

equivalent of “Satisfied”. It shows that the statement “I am satisfied because the salon

transaction are safe and accurate.” and statement “I am satisfied with the professionalism

of the employee.” has the same average weighted mean of 3.35 and descriptive

equivalent of “Satisfied” and statement “I am satisfied because the employees can

provide all required information about the service I avail.” which obtained the least

average weighted mean of 3.25 with a descriptive equivalent of “Satisfied”.

As cited in the study of Spyridoula Vryoni et al., (2017), assurance is related to

knowledge and courtesy of employees and their ability to convey trust and confidence.

Their study findings shows that assurance contributed to spa customers satisfaction at the

percentage of 6.01%.

This implies that the business provides accurate service to their customer and that

they do their service in professional way to satisfy their customer they also need to

provide their customer information about the service the customer availed at the salon.

Therefor, customers are satisfied because the salon employees are knowledgeable about

the service they availed and is trustworthy.

Table 7

Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction in terms of Reliability

n=100

E. Reliability AWM DE
1.) I am satisfied because the services realized as promised 3.21 S
and accurate.
2.) I am satisfied because the employees of salon provides 3.28 S
the services at the time it promises to do so.
3.) I am satisfied when employee keeps accurate records 3.14 S
(reservations, guest records, bills, orders, etc.)
4.) I am satisfied whenever the employees provide the 3.23 S
service as I avail without any wrongs.
3.23 S
37

5.) I am satisfied when the advertising and promotional


messages of the salon reflect reality.
OVERALL WEIGHTED MEAN 3.23 S
Legend: AWM = Average Weighted Mean; DE = Descriptive Equivalent; 3.50 – 4.00
(Highly Satisfied); 2.50 – 3.49 (Satisfied); 2.49 – 1.50 (Unsatisfied) 1.00 – 1.49
(Strongly Unsatisfied).

Shown in the table is the mean that we gather from 100 respondents who

answered our questionnaire. The table has a 3.27 overall weighted mean, in which most

of the customer at the salon “agree” that the salon estimate the likelihood that service will

sustain performance standard over a given length of time. The statement “I am satisfied

because the employee of salon provides the service at the time it promises to do so.” Had

the highest average weighted mean of 3.32 which is equivalent to “agree” with the

statement “I am satisfied when employee keeps accurate records(reservation, guest

records, bills, orders, etc.” had the lowest average weighted mean of 3.21, which also

equivalent to “agree” This suggest that salons must focus mainly on the services

especially the records or transactions between customer and the employee.

Returning to the definition of reliability, "the ability to perform the promised

service dependably and accurately," we can look at the characteristics that were used in

place of reliability in the different service sectors, such as "time conscious staff" at Ume

University, "accurate service" at Forex Bank, and "less queue" at ICA. This might be the

only explanation for why dependability in this study's design was not substantially

connected to neither client happiness nor service quality for ICA. (Parasuraman et al.,

2022).

Therefore, customers are satisfied that the salon estimates the likelihood that

services will sustain performance standards over a given length of time.

Table 8
38

Variables Compared Pearson Chi Significant value Descriptive


Square Equivalent
Correlation
Tangibility and Age 22.576 .012* S
Responsiveness and 10.268 .147 NS
Age
Empathy and Age 12.154 .667 NS
Assurance and Age 15.743 .399 NS
Reliability and Age 10.777 .768 NS
Significant Relationship between the Profile of the Respondents in Terms of Age

and Dimension of Service Quality.

n=100

Legend: S = Significant; NS = Not Significant

Based from the finding, where the p-value (.012) and basing to our table of value

it is equivalent of very weak correlation but appears in the same row in the “Asymptotic

Significance (2-sided)” column. The result is significant because the value is equal to or

less than the designated alpha level (0.05). In this case, the p-value is smaller than the

standard alpha value, so therefore reject the null hypothesis that asserts the two variables

are independent of each other. To put it simply, the result is significant – the data

suggests that the variables Tangibility and Age are associated with each other. In here we

failed to reject the null hypothesis.

Correlation between the variable Responsiveness and Age of the respondents,

Empathy and Age, Assurance and Age, and Reliability and Age shows that it is not

significant to each other as its p value is higher than the set alpha level. Therefore, the

null hypothesis is accepted.

In connection with the study of Gonzaga (2021) there findings also revealed that

only tangibles indicator significantly influences (p-value 0.05) to customer satisfaction.


39

The rest of the indicators of quality service, to wit, reliability, responsiveness, assurance,

and empathy have no significant influence (p-value>0.05) to quality service.

Findings revealed that after using the Chi Square test to know the significant

relationship between variables, only Tangibility and Age is highly significant and

Responsiveness and Age; Empathy and Age; Assurance and Age; and Reliability and

Age does not show any relationship or no correlation at all..

Table 9

Relationship Between Respondents Profile in terms of Gender and the

Dimensions of Service Quality

Correlations
Gend Tangibil Responsiv Empat Assura Reliabil
er ity eness hy nce ity
Pearson
1 .209* .292** .145 .155 .185
Correlation
Gender Sig. (2-
.037 .003 .149 .123 .065
tailed)
N 100 100 100 100 100 100
Pearson
.209* 1 .703** .746** .689** .684**
Correlation
Tangibility Sig. (2-
.037 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
N 100 100 100 100 100 100
Pearson
.292** .703** 1 .775** .753** .770**
Correlation
Responsiven
Sig. (2-
ess .003 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
N 100 100 100 100 100 100
40

Pearson
.145 .746** .775** 1 .853** .843**
Correlation
Empathy Sig. (2-
.149 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
N 100 100 100 100 100 100
Pearson
.155 .689** .753** .853** 1 .803**
Correlation
Assurance Sig. (2-
.123 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
N 100 100 100 100 100 100
Pearson
.185 .684** .770** .843** .803** 1
Correlation
Reliability Sig. (2-
.065 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
N 100 100 100 100 100 100
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
As shown in the table above, Gender and Tangibility variable with a correlation of

.209* a very weak correlation according to Rule of Correlation, and a sig. (2 tailed)

of .037 and since it is Significant at the level 0.05 level (2 tailed). Correlation of

Tangibility and Gender is 0.209, based on n=100 P<0.05. Hence the variables are

significant at the level 0.05 level (2 tailed). In conclusion even if the correlation shows a

very weak correlation but the p value is inside the 0.05 alpha level, there is a significant

relationship between the Gender and Tangibility variable.

Based on the table above, it shows the correlation is .292 which according to the

rule of correlation is very weak. And it is outside the alpha level which is 0.01. It can be

concluded that between the Gender and Responsiveness variable there is no significant

relationship. Same also with Gender and Empathy variable with a correlation of .145 a

very weak correlation, and a sig. (2 tailed) of .149 and since it is Significant at the level

0.05 level (2 tailed). Correlation of Empathy and Gender is .149, based on n=100 P<0.05.
41

Hence the variables are not significant at the level 0.05 level (2 tailed). In conclusion

even if the correlation shows a very weak correlation and there is no significant

relationship between the Gender and Empathy variable. Lastly with Gender and

Reliability that also shows no significant relationship between the two variables.

Each gender, male and female, may observe the environment and processes differently

and accordingly, show their judgements and satisfaction in dissimilar ways. In line with the

study of Agbor (2017) prove that while females’ satisfaction level is higher if they perceived a

pleasurable level of value expressive attributes, that of male customers is higher if they

perceived a pleasurable level of functional attributes. 

The table also shows the relationship between the 5 variables among the

Tangibility, Responsiveness, Empathy, Assurance and Reliability, there is a high to very

high correlation between them. There is also significant relationship between them since

the p = 000 < 0.01. Correlation is significant among them.

Table 10

Proposed Action Plan to improve the operations of beauty salon business in

Binalonan, Pangasinan

Areas of Objectives Strategy Outcome Persons

Concern Involved

Tangibility Physical The salon must In that way Salon

appearance, also use up to they can attract Management

equipment as date more

well as the equipment. customers


42

appearance of when they

the personnel invest also for

of the salon. their

equipment.

Face their
They can gain
customer with
more
a pleasing
satisfaction and
personality.
loyalty from

their

customers.

Responsiveness Salon Only provide The business Salon

employees has service that can will gain the Management

the willingness meet the trust and

to help expectations of loyalty of the

customers by the customers. customers if

providing the

prompt service Provide a management

feedback box knows how to

wherein salon communicate

management and provide

can ask service based


43

question, or the on what the

customer can business has to

leave their offer.

feedback about

the service they

availed.

Empathy The salon Responding to In this they Salon

employees the concern will know if Management

shows proper and needs of they show

attention and customers. enough

care to their Provide a concern and

customers. feedback box attention to

for their their customer

customer. to satisfy them

more.

Assurance The salon Knowing from Helps prevent Salon

employees are the basic type from doing the Management

knowledgeable of service. same mistakes

about the again when

service they are Guarantee to interacting

providing to customer that with the

their customers they will have customers.

and is or receive the


44

trustworthy best, expected

and desirable

experience

when

purchasing or

availing the

service from

the salon.

Reliability The salon Provide service They can meet Salon

estimates the as accurate as the expectation Management

likelihood that possible. of their

services will customers.

sustain

performance

standards over

a given length

of time.

Chapter 4

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

This chapter presents the conclusion drawn and the recommendation advanced as

the results regarding the Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction Among

Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan.


45

CONCLUSION

The following are the conclusions made by the researchers based on the foregoing

findings of the study.

1. Majority of the customers in acquiring the services that the salon offers are in the

age ranges 18-21 years old, most of them are female and some are few males, In

addition beauty salon is an establishment that offers a variety of cosmetic

treatments and cosmetic services for men and women. Beauty salons may offer a

variety of services that may affect the customer satisfaction in terms of age and

gender.

2. Majority of the customers acquired services such as Hair color, Haircut, Blow

dry, Rebond, Rebond with Treatment, Pedicure and Lastly Manicure. Salon

nowadays not just accepting women in acquiring services that are offered in salon

Men can also acquire those services offered by the salon in which salons are

designed with comfort and relaxation in mind, offer a mini retreat away from

work, kids, and errands. If it's not time to get your hair trimmed or colored, a

soothing facial or massage is always a wonderful choice that’s why men and

women acquired those services.

3. In terms of services that may affect their customer satisfaction such as in

tangibility which customers agreed that they are satisfied because the salon

employees are well-dressed/neat in which they are satisfied with it.

Regarding in responsiveness customers agreed that they are satisfied because

personnel are approachable when you need assistance in which it has a biggest
46

factor affecting their satisfaction in acquiring the services offered by the salon.

In terms of empathy, customers agreed that it satisfied them when personnel ask

for customer’s feedback to know if they are satisfied, and they are being satisfied

when the salon have convenient business hours in which we all know that

empathy is when the salon employee gives proper attention and care to their

customers which leads to customer satisfaction in acquiring their services.

Regarding assurance in which assurance is when the salon employees are

knowledgeable about the service they availed and is trustworthy customers agreed

that they are satisfied with the professionalism of the employee in which to

conclude it is relevance to customers for them to be satisfied.

In terms of reliability, in which if the salon estimates the likelihood that services

will sustain performance standards over a given length of time it is relevance to

customers for them to be satisfied in which customers agreed that they are

satisfied when the employee of salon provides the services at the time it promises

to do so.

4. Those dimensions of service quality are needed by the salon for them to achieve

the customer satisfaction to customer that they offer services in Binalonan,

Pangasinan

5. In testing if there is a significant relationship between the profile of the

respondent and the service quality in terms of Tangibility, Responsiveness,

Empathy, Assurance and Reliability, the findings revealed that there is no

significant relationship between the Gender and Responsiveness, Gender and


47

Empathy, Gender and Assurance, Gender and Reliability, only Gender and

Tangibility has the significant relationship. Also in Age and Tangibility, it also

shows a positive correlation between the two and the rest shows no correlation.

Bibliography

A. Book

Sundstorm, E. (n.d.). Work places the psychology of the physical environment in


office and factories . Google Books. Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://books.google.com.ph/books?
hl=en&lr=&id=mzI7AAAAIAAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR9&dq=theory%2Bof
%2Bphysical
%2Benvironment&ots=8soA9Zy9hl&sig=LLuCJosnXZP70l74qiSf3c44Tzk&redir
_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

B. Journal

NGUYEN, T. T. N. (n.d.). Gender differences in determinants of customer


satisfaction in Beauty and cosmetic e-commerce. The Journal of Asian Finance,
Economics and Business. Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://koreascience.kr/article/JAKO202029062616712.page

I-Ming Wang,Chich-Jen Shieh. (n.d.). The relationship between service quality and
customer satisfaction: The ... The relationship between service quality and
customer satisfaction: the example of CJCU library. Retrieved October 27, 2022,
from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237561091_The_relationship_between_s
ervice_quality_and_customer_satisfaction_the_example_of_CJCU_library
48

Approved), J. ijmr.net.in(U. G. C. (2018, February 26). A study on customer


satisfaction towards the services of Green Trends in Trichy marketing. Journal of
Management and Science. Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.academia.edu/36026850/A_STUDY_ON_CUSTOMER_SATISFACT
ION_TOWARDS_THE_SERVICES_OF_GREEN_TRENDS_IN_TRICHY_MAR
KETING?
fbclid=IwAR3a8T1bbKjpHrQJc64Afqi5VbZ0UJlmrKophxBJF09l_4oObSgNugL_
AGU

C. Electronic References

Syeda Shaharbanu Shahbazi. (n.d.). Identifying the decision criterion for choosing
beauty parlor and salon ... Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259181028_Identifying_the_Decision_
Criterion_for_Choosing_Beauty_Parlor_and_Salon_A_Marketing_Communicatio
n_Perspective

Islam, T., & Sultana, S. (2018, March 29). Measuring customer satisfaction
through SERVQUAL model: A study on beauty parlors in Chittagong.
Academia.edu. Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.academia.edu/36283081/Measuring_Customer_Satisfaction_through
_SERVQUAL_Model_A_Study_on_Beauty_Parlors_in_Chittagong

Islam, T., & Sultana, S. (2018, March 29). Measuring customer satisfaction
through SERVQUAL model: A study on beauty parlors in Chittagong.
Academia.edu. Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.academia.edu/36283081/Measuring_Customer_Satisfaction_through
_SERVQUAL_Model_A_Study_on_Beauty_Parlors_in_Chittagong

JENET MANYI AGBOR. (n.d.). The Relationship between Customer Satisfaction


and Service Quality: a study of three Service sectors in Umeå. Simple search.
Retrieved October 27, 2022, from https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/search.jsf

Spyridoula Vryoni,Panteleimon Bakirtzoglou,Panagiotis Ioannou. (n.d.). Vryoni,


S. et al.: Customers' satisfaction and service quality of spa ... CUSTOMERS'
SATISFACTION AND SERVICE QUALITY OF SPA CENTERS IN GREECE.
Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Panteleimon-Bakirtzoglou/publication/
322232333_CUSTOMERS
%27_SATISFACTION_AND_SERVICE_QUALITY_OF_SPA_CENTERS_IN_
GREECE/links/5a4cfb5caca2729b7c8b0f26/CUSTOMERS-SATISFACTION-
49

AND-SERVICE-QUALITY-OF-SPA-CENTERS-IN-GREECE.pdf?
origin=publication_detail

Yuksel, A. (n.d.). consumer satisfaction theories: A critical review - researchgate.


Consumer Satisfaction Theories: A Critical Review. Retrieved October 27, 2022,
from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258224400_Consumer_Satisfaction_Theo
ries_A_Critical_Review

Ehigie C. Johnson ,Jesse S. Karlay. (n.d.). Impact of service quality on customer


satisfaction - diva-portal.org. Impact of Service Quality on customer Satisfaction.
Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1246475/FULLTEXT01.pdf

Download 40 million pdfs for free. Academia.edu - Share research. (n.d.). Retrieved
October 27, 2022, from https://www.academia.edu/?
fbclid=IwAR1GdriEm6aEAFgaZLUaHWFlNuWTwcYtl0qIRNtaNrW4wm1-
CGNMI5oVxhY

AI-Powered Research Tool. Semantic Scholar. (n.d.). Retrieved October 27, 2022,
from https://www.semanticscholar.org/?
fbclid=IwAR2zfMjQ9L1KeTgI6oOAglROGBFA5wDDqrFwv-
Gdn_Uv4_RUCC2IlNjCbbo

Juniele Deloria,Lyndell Altejar,Camille Dizon. (n.d.). Study of the Effects of


Customer Service Quality and Product Quality on Customer Satisfaction and
Customer Loyalty. Polytechnic University of the Philippines College of Business
Administration-Major in Marketing Managemen. Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/336839312_Study_of_the_Effects_of_Cu
stomer_Service_Quality_and_Product_Quality_on_Customer_Satisfaction_and_Cu
stomer_Loyalty

Find and share research. ResearchGate. (n.d.). Retrieved October 27, 2022, from
https://www.researchgate.net/?
fbclid=IwAR1GdriEm6aEAFgaZLUaHWFlNuWTwcYtl0qIRNtaNrW4wm1-
CGNMI5oVxhY
50

APPENDIX A
LETTER TO THE PROGRAM HEAD
November 3, 2022
MRS. MONA LIZA DC. ABANES, Ph.D.
Program Head, College of Business Administration
University of Eastern Pangasinan
Binalonan, Pangasinan

Dear Ma’am;
Greetings! We, the undersigned are Bachelor of Science in Business
Administration major in Marketing Management students of our University, presently
conducting a study entitled “RELEVANCE OF SERVICE QUALITY TO
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AMONG BEAUTY SALON IN BINALONAN,
PANGASINAN” As part of the requirements of the program.
51

In this regard, the undersigned request the approval of your good office to conduct
the data gathering and collection.
Thank you very much for your favorable approval and endorsement of this
request.

Respectfully yours,
Gayla, Gie Anne S. Delin, Maria Theresa M. Pedrozo, Jericho D.
Biscarra, Rachelle S. Grospe, Mary Lhea T.

Noted by:

JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA


Research Adviser

Approved:

MONA LIZA DC. ABANES, Ph.D.

APPENDIX B
LETTER TO THE RESPONDENTS
52

APPENDIX C
53

SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
“Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction Among Beauty Salon in
Binalonan, Pangasinan”
Part I.
Direction: Check (✓) the following that correspond your answer on the space provided.

Age: ( ) 18 – 21 years old ( ) 30 – 33 years old


( ) 22 – 25 years old ( ) 34 – 37 years old
( ) 26 – 29 years old ( ) 38 and above

Gender: ( ) Male ( ) Female

Part II.
Check (✓) the following service/s that you avail at the salon:
( ) Blow Dry ( ) Gel Manicure ( ) Pedicure ( ) Eyebrow Threading
( ) Brazilian Keratin ( ) Manicure ( ) Foot Spa ( ) Eyelash Extension
( ) Brazilian Blow Out ( ) Others
( ) Color Highlights
( ) Hair Cellophane
( ) Hair Color
( ) Hair Cut
( ) Hair Curl/Perming
( ) Hair Extension
( ) Hair Keratin Treatment
( ) Hair Spa
( ) Highlights
( ) Hot Oil Treatment
( ) Rebond
( ) Rebond with Treatment

Part III.
54

4 – Highly Satisfied 3 – Satisfied 2 – Unsatisfied 1 – Strongly Unsatisfied


1 2 3 4
A. Tangibility
1.) I am satisfied with the physical
facilities and the visual appeal of the
salon.
2.) I am satisfied because the salon
employees are well-dressed/neat
3.) I am satisfied because the place is
very accessible and have enough
parking space for the customers.
4.) I am satisfied because the salon
uses modern equipment in providing
services.
5.) I am satisfied with the
arrangement of facilities because it is
well-ordered.
B. Responsiveness
1.) I am satisfied because the
personnel are polite and friendly.
2.) I am satisfied because the salon
have enough space for incoming
customers.
3.) I am satisfied because the
personnel inform how many minutes
it may take the service I avail to be
done.
4.) I am satisfied because personnel
are approachable when you need
assistance.
5.) I am satisfied because of the
positive response of personnel when
you ask for knowledge or information
in acquiring their service.
C. Empathy
1.) I am satisfied because they have
convenient business hours.
2.) I am satisfied because the
personnel are attentive to the needs of
55

the customers.
3.) I am satisfied because the
personnel respond to customer’s
concern.
4.) I am satisfied because they have
individual attention to customer.
5.) I am satisfied because personnel
ask for customer’s feedback to know
if they are satisfied.
D. Assurance
1.) I am satisfied because the
employees can provide all required
information about the service I avail.
2.) I am satisfied because the salon
employees are consistently courteous.
3.) I am satisfied because the salon
transaction are safe and accurate.
4.) I am satisfied with the
professionalism of the employee.
5.) I am satisfied because the
employees delivered the service in
efficient way.
E. Reliability
1.) I am satisfied because the services
realized as promised and accurate.
2.) I am satisfied because the
employees of salon provides the
services at the time it promises to do
so.
3.) I am satisfied when employee
keeps accurate records (reservations,
guest records, bills, orders, etc.).
4.) I am satisfied whenever the
employees provide the service as I
avail without any wrongs.
5. I am satisfied when the advertising
and promotional messages of the
salon reflect reality.
DOCUMENTATION
56

FLOATING OF QUESTIONNAIRE

This photo was taken when the researchers

personally floated the questionnaire to the

salons in Binalonan Public Market and

asked permission to the salon

owners/employees to conduct the said

study.

APPENDIX D

VALIDITY TOOL
Directions: Please read each statement in the valuation sheet and relate each statement

using the rating scale below by making a check (/) mark on the appropriate column of the

evaluation sheet.
57

Point Value Descriptive Valid Extent of Descriptive


5 Highly Valid (HV) At least 100% of the items are
appropriate and relevant.
4 Valid (V) At least 80% of the items are
appropriate and relevant.
3 Moderately Valid (MV) At least 60% of the items are
appropriate and relevant.
2 Fairly Valid (FV) At least 40% of the items are
appropriate and relevant.
1 Not Valid (NV) At least 40% of the items are
appropriate and relevant.

Indicators of Validity 5 4 3 2 1
1. Every item is stated clearly.
2. Every item is sufficiently comprehensive.
3. Every item corresponds to the subject matter.
4. Every item shows reasonable range of variation.
5. Every item is consistently to reality.
6. Every item is precise and exact.
7. Every item is correct and accurate.
8. Every item can be applied specifically for the
topic.
9. Every item responds to the objectives of the
study.
10. Every item is written the ability level of the
respondents.

_____________________________
Signature over Printed Name of the Evaluator

Statement about the Mean Description


items in questionnaire Experts Rating
A B C D E TOTAL
1. Every item is stated 4 4 5 3 5 4.2
clearly. (Valid)
2. Every item is 5 4 5 3 5 4.4
sufficiently (Valid)
58

comprehensive.
3. Every item 5 5 5 3 5 4.6
corresponds to the (Highly Valid)
subject matter.
4. Every item shows 5 5 5 3 5 4.6
reasonable range of (Highly Valid)
variation.
5. Every item is 5 5 5 3 5 4.6
consistently to (Highly Valid)
reality.
6. Every item is 5 4 5 3 5 4.4
precise and exact. (Valid)
7. Every item is 4 5 5 3 5 4.4
correct and (Valid)
accurate.
8. Every item can be 5 5 5 3 5 4.6
applied specifically (Highly Valid)
for the topic.
9. Every item 5 5 5 3 5 4.6
responds to the (Highly Valid)
objectives of the
study.
10. Every item is 5 5 5 3 5 4.6
written the ability (Highly Valid)
level of the
respondents.
Total Mean 4.8 4.7 5 3 5 4.5
(Highly Valid)

Point of Value Mean Scale DescriptiveRating

5 4.50 - 5.00 Highly Valid (HV)


4 3.50 - 4.49 Valid (V)
3 2.50 - 3.49 Moderately Valid (MV)
2 1.50 - 2.49 Fairly Valid (FV)
1 1.00 - 1.49 Not Valid (NV)
59
60

APPENDIX E
61

OTHER APPROVAL SHEETS

RESEARCH PANEL ACCEPTANCE FORM

RESEARCH PANEL ACCEPTANCE FORM

Date: November 3,2022


Academic Year: 2022 – 2023
Semester: First Semester

This is to attest that I, DR. GLENDA B. GANZON, have agreed and accepted to
be the Research Panel Member of the following students/faculty:

GAYLA, GIE ANNE S.


BISCARRA, RACHELLE S.
DELIN, MARIA THERESA M.
GROSPE, MARY LHEA T.
PEDROZO, JERICHO D.

with the research/thesis title “Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction


among Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan” Furthermore, I agree to set the
schedule for consultation; and to be readily available and present during the scheduled
defense to help the researcher/s and to ensure the success of the study.

Conformed:
DR. GLENDA GANZON,
Signature over printed name

Noted: Noted:
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA DR. MONA LIZA D. ABANES,
Ph.D.
Signature over printed name Signature over printed name
Program Research Coordinator Program Head
62

RESEARCH PANEL ACCEPTANCE FORM

Date: November 3,2022


Academic Year: 2022 – 2023
Semester: First Semester

This is to attest that I, MR. JOSHUA T. ANDRADA, MBA , have agreed and
accepted to be the Research Panel Member of the following students/faculty:

GAYLA, GIE ANNE S.


BISCARRA, RACHELLE S.
DELIN, MARIA THERESA M.
GROSPE, MARY LHEA T.
PEDROZO, JERICHO D.

with the research/thesis title Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction


among Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan Furthermore, I agree to set the
schedule for consultation; and to be readily available and present during the scheduled
defense to help the researcher/s and to ensure the success of the study.

Conformed:
MR. JOSHUA T. ANDRADA, MBA
Signature over printed name

Noted: Noted:
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA DR. MONA LIZA D. ABANES,
Ph.D.
Signature over printed name Signature over printed name
Program Research Coordinator Program Head
63

RESEARCH PANEL ACCEPTANCE FORM

Date: November 3,2022


Academic Year: 2022 – 2023
Semester: First Semester

This is to attest that I, DR. MONA LIZA D. ABANES, have agreed and accepted
to be the Research Panel Member of the following students/faculty:

GAYLA, GIE ANNE S.


BISCARRA, RACHELLE S.
DELIN, MARIA THERESA M.
GROSPE, MARY LHEA T.
PEDROZO, JERICHO D.

with the research/thesis title Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction


among Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan Furthermore, I agree to set the
schedule for consultation; and to be readily available and present during the scheduled
defense to help the researcher/s and to ensure the success of the study.

Conformed:
DR. MONA LIZA D. ABANES
Signature over printed name

Noted: Noted:
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA DR. MONA LIZA D. ABANES,
Ph.D.
Signature over printed name Signature over printed name
Program Research Coordinator Program Head
64

RESEARCH ADVISER AND ADVISEE


MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT

KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS:

This agreement is made and entered into this 26 th day of August 2022, in
Binalonan, Pangasinan by and between:
The Mr. John Christopher V. Garces, from the College of Business Administration,
hereinafter referred as “Adviser”
- and -
The Student Researcher/s Gayla, Gie Anne, Biscarra, Rachelle, Delin, Maria Theresa,
Grospe, Mary Lhea and Pedrozo, Jericho. from the College of Business
Administration in University of Eastern Pangasinan.

hereinafter referred as “Advisee/s”

WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS the Adviser is preferably a full-time faculty/employee of the
University of Eastern Pangasinan, with Master’s degree of Thesis track or with research
experience (evidenced by research outcomes or publications) in lieu of a thesis, and an
expert in the field of study conducted by her/his Advisees;
WHEREAS advisee/s is/are students enrolled in research subject as a
requirement of the degree Bachelor of Science in Business Administration Major in
Marketing Management who seeks advice and guidance in the conduct of a Research
Project.
NOW, THEREFORE, the two parties hereby agree to enter into this Agreement
under the following terms and conditions:
Adviser shall:
1. Assist the students in the selection of research topics/titles.
2. Help the students in the proper conduct (through regular and close monitoring) of
research work according to the set timetable to ensure integrity and high-quality output.
3. Review/check submitted proposals, questionnaires, and other chapters/aspects of the
research paper.
65

4. Provide not only technical expertise but moral guidance as well to students while the
latter are working on their research project.
5. Conduct mock defense prior to the oral defense, when necessary.
6. Monitor participation or involvement of group members by accomplishing the
consultation matrix form.
7. Attend the defense of their advisee/s as observer.
8. Submits signed and book bounded final manuscript to the department
9. Attend orientation set by the UEP Research Office.
Advisee/s shall:
1. Follow the work schedule stipulated in the planned of activities agreed with the
adviser.
2. Include adviser as co-author of the research paper.
3. Follow stringent quality assurance measures such as professional editing, plagiarism,
grammar and readability tests, reference and intercontinental literature sources checking.
4. Pay defense fee of P500.00 per researcher/defense prior to scheduled defense.

The parties further agree that any financial benefit arising from the study such as
grants and awards shall go to the advisee and co-author/s while benefit from publication
shall go to the rank and promotion of the adviser.
The parties further agree that any Copyright of the output of this collaboration
shall belong to the advisee/s, co-author and University of Eastern Pangasinan; and subject
to terms and agreements for publication and utilization of any external parties.

In WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto set their hands on the date and
place above-written.
ADVISEE/S
GAYLA, GIE ANNE S.
BISCARRA, RACHELLE S.
DELIN, MARIA THERESA M.
GROSPE, MARY LHEA T.
PEDROZO, JERICHO D.
66

ADVISER
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES

Witnesses:
DR. MONA LIZA DC. ABANES
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES
MR. JOSHUA ANDRADA
MS. JEAN DELA CRUZ
MS. AIDA GANITUAN

Research Teacher
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES
Program Research Coordinator

DR. MONA LIZA DC. ABANES


Program Head
67

RESEARCH ADVISER ACCEPTANCE FORM

Date: August 30, 2022


Academic Year: 2022-2023
Semester: First Semester

This is to attest that I, JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA, have agreed


and accepted to be the Research Adviser of the following students/faculty:

GAYLA, GIE ANNE S.


BISCARRA, RACHELLE S.
DELIN, MARIA THERESA M.
GROSPE, MARY LHEA T.
PEDROZO, JERICHO D.

with the research/thesis title Relevance of Service Quality to Customer Satisfaction


among Beauty Salon in Binalonan, Pangasinan Furthermore, I agree to set the
schedule for follow up, advising and consultation; and to be readily available and present
during the scheduled defense to help the researcher/s and to ensure the success of the
study.

Conformed:
JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA,
Signature over printed name

Noted: Noted:
JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA DR. MONA LIZA D. ABANES
Signature over printed name Signature over printed name
Program Research Coordinator Program Head
68

LETTER TO THE ADVISER

November 3, 2022
MR. JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES, DBA
Instructor, College of Business Administration
University of Eastern Pangasinan

Sir.

We, the third year Bachelor of Science in Business Administration major in Marketing

Management students of University of Eastern Pangasinan are currently working on a

research entitled “RELEVANCE OF SERVICE QUALITY TO CUSTOMER

SATISFACTION AMONG BEAUTY SALON IN BINALONAN, PANGASINAN”

In this regard, we would like to request your professional assistance to be our adviser.

Your favorable action on the above request will truly help us in the completion of our

research work.

Thank you very much and we highly appreciate your time and effort.

Respectfully yours,

Gayla, Gie Anne S. Delin, Maria Theresa M. Pedrozo, Jericho D.

Biscarra, Rachelle S. Grospe, Mary Lhea T.

Noted:

MONA LIZA DELA CRUZ, ABANES, Ph. D.

Dean, college of Business Administration

Approved:

JOHN CHRISTOPHER V. GARCES


69

EXTERNAL VALIDATORS

This photo screenshot of conversation of some of the researchers who approached

online the external validators for the research study for the validation of the statement of

the problem and questionnaire and to answer the evaluation sheet.


70

RESEARCH ETHICS REVIEW APPLICATION

RESEARCH TITLE
Relevance of Service Quality to Customer
Satisfaction Among Beauty Salon in Binalonan,
Pangasinan.

NAME/S OF
RESEARCHER/S AND Lead Researcher: Gayla, Gie Anne S.
EMAIL giesurnipgayla@gmail.com

Co-researchers
1. Biscarra, Rachelle V.
Rachelleviscarra21@gmail.com

2. Delin, Maria Theresa


delinmariatheresa@gmail.com

3. Grospe, Mary Lhea


Mleduc2001@gmail.com

4. Pedrozo, Jericho
pedrozojericho@gmail.com

DEPARTMENT/COLLEGE College of Business Administration

PLANNED START OF
RESEARCH (DATE) August 15,2022
SEMESTER AND First Semester of Academic Year 2022 – 2023
ACADEMIC YEAR
PLANNED END OF
RESEARCH (DATE) December 9, 2022
SEMESTER AND First Semester of Academic Year 2022 – 2023
ACADEMIC YEAR
SOURC E OF FUND
(if applicable)

Has your study been reviewed by other Ethics Review Board?


___ yes (state the status, where and when was it reviewed)
______________________________________________
✓ no
71
72
73
74

RESEARCH ETHICS CHECKLIST

RESEARCHER/S’ DETAILS
RESEARCH TITLE Relevance of Service Quality to Customer
Satisfaction Among Beauty Salons in Binalonan,
Pangasinan.
NAME/S OF
RESEARCHER/S AND Lead Researcher: Gayla, Gie Anne S.
EMAIL giesurnipgayla@gmail.com

Co-researchers
1. Biscarra, Rachelle S.
Rachelleviscarra21@gmail.com

2. Delin, Maria Theresa M.


delinmariatheresa@gmail.com

3. Grospe, Mary Lhea T.


Mleduc2001@gmail.com

4. Pedrozo, Jericho D.
pedrozojericho@gmail.com

DEPARTMENT/COLLEGE College of Business Adminitration


SEMESTER AND First Semester
ACADEMIC YEAR A.Y. 2022 – 2023

Does your study involve human participants?


✓ yes ___no

* If your answer is “yes”, proceed complying the checklist below

Check the appropriate answer for each question:


SOURCE OF DATA
1. How will the data be gathered? (check all that applied?
_____ personal interview _____ telephone interview
_____ internet survey _____ telephone survey
_____ observation _____ focus group
_____ self-administered questionnaire _____ others (specify)
✓ researcher - administered
questionnaire ________________________________

Pre- existing data from human participants


(answer the questions below if you check this item)

Where the data of the study be sourced?


75

Is the data publicly available? yes (indicate where the data set is
available)

____ no (indicate/attach the approval authority


for access)

Was the original data set originally collected yes ( attach the Consent Form used in the
for the present study’s purpose? original study)

____ no ( attach the Information Collection


Statement)

Does the original data set contain sensitive ____ yes (describe the type of sensitive data to
data? be used in the present research)

no

Does the original data set have personal ____ yes


identifiers? ____ direct (personal details)
____ indirect (used code)

no

Will new data be collected and analyzed yes


along with data from the existing data set?
____ no

* Answer the questions below if new data will be collected


SAMPLING DETAILS
Number of respondents 100 respondents

Location of the respondents Binalonan Public Market Poblacion Binalonan,


Pangasinan
Duration of data collection First Semester of the A.Y. 2022 – 2023

Who will collect the data? Researchers

Locale of the study Fifty customers of salons in Binalonan Public


Market
Employed technique to ensure voluntary Request letter for the salon shop owner to conduct
consent from participants? the floating of questionnaires to the customer.
Informed consent answered and signed by the
respondents
76

DATA RETENTION
How long will the data of participant with Three (3) years.
identifiers be kept after the publication?

How long will the anonymized data be Three (3) years.


kept after the publication ?

PROCEDURE FOR INFORMED CONSENT


How will informed consent be recorded? (check all that applies)

✓ Written Consent
____ Audio-recorded Consent
____ Online/Email recorded Consent
____ Others (specify)
__________________________

STUDY THAT NEEDS FULL REVIEW


YES NO
1. Will the study involve recruitment of staff/employees of UEP or other ✓
agency?
2. Does the study involve participants age 18 and below who are unable to ✓
give informed consent?
3. Does the research involve potentially vulnerable groups: children, those ✓
with cognitive impairment, or those in unequal relationships?
4. Will there be a possibility that the research can induce physical harm to ✓
the subject?
5. Will there be a possibility that the research can induce psychological ✓
harm to the subject?
6. Will the participants be informed that they will be observed? ✓
7. Will there be a possibility that the research can induce emotional ✓
discomfort to the subject?
8. Will the study require the cooperation of a gatekeeper or another person ✓
in authority for initial access to the groups or individuals to be recruited?
(eg students at school, members of self- help group, residents of nursing
home?)
9. Will it be necessary for participants to take part in the study without ✓
77

their knowledge and consent at the time? (eg covert observation of people
in non- public places)
10. Will the study involve discussion of sensitive topics? (eg sexual ✓
activity, drug use, politics)
11. Are drugs, placebos or other substances (eg food substances, vitamins) ✓
to be administered to the study participants, or will the study involve
invasive, intrusive or potentially harmful procedures of any kind?
12. Will tissue samples (including blood) be obtained from participants? ✓
13. Will genetic samples be extracted from the obtained biological ✓
samples?
14. Is pain or more than mild discomfort likely to result from the study? ✓
15. Could the study induce psychological stress, discomfort, anxiety or ✓
cause harm or negative consequences beyond the risks encountered in
normal life?
16. Will the study involve prolonged or repetitive testing? ✓
17. Will the research involve administrative or secure data that requires ✓
permission from the appropriate authorities before use?
18. Is there a possibility that the safety of the researcher may be in ✓
question? (eg in international research: locally employed research
assistants)
19. Does the research involve members of the public in a research capacity ✓
(participant research)?
20. Does the research involves government officials? ✓
21. Does the research involves top management of an institution, ✓
organization or company?
22. Will the research take place outside the Philippines? ✓
23. Will the research involve respondents to the internet or other ✓
visual/vocal methods where respondents may be identified?
78
79

RESEARCH ETHICS CLEARANCE


80

APPENDIX F

RESULT BUDGETARY EXPENSES

Amount

Pre Oral Defense Fee 150

Pre Oral Panel Fee 350

Final Defense Fee 300

Final Panel Fee 700

TOTAL P 1500

Printing/ Hardbound 2,000

Transportation/ Travel 500

TOTAL P 2,500
81

PRE ORAL PANEL FEE RECEIPT

Photo proof of payment/receipt for panel fee for pre- oral defense.

APPENDIX G

RESEARCHERS RESUME

CURRICULUM VITAE

A. Personal Data

Name: Gie Anne S. Gayla

Age: 21

Date of Birth: September 21, 2001


82

Place of Birth: Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

Address: #32 San Felipe Central Binalonan, Pangasinan

Religion: Christian

Contact Number: 09456049728

Email Address: giesurnipgayla@gmail.com

Name of Father: Ferdinand T. Gayla

Name of Mother: Anna Liza S. Gayla

B. Educational Background

Primary: Binalonan North Central School SPED Center


Binalonan, Pangasinan
2008– 2014

Secondary:
Junior High School Juan G. Macaraeg National High School
Binalonan, Pangasinan
2014-2018

Senior High School ABE International College of Business and


Accountancy
E.A. Cabrera Bldg., Mc Arthur Hi-way, San Vicente,
Urdaneta City, Pangasinan
2018-2020

Tertiary: University of Eastern Pangasinan


Mc Arthur Highway, Canarvacanan 
Binalonan, Pangasinan
2020 – 2024

Course: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration


Major in Marketing Management
83

CURRICULUM VITAE

A. Personal Data

Name: Rachelle S. Biscarra

Age: 22

Date of Birth: October 10, 2000

Place of Birth: Pozorrubio, Pangasinan

Address: Malokiat, Pozorrubio,Pangasinan


84

Religion: Christian

Contact Number: 09128790062

Email Address: rachelleviscarra21@gmail.com

Name of Father: Rodulfo Biscarra

Name of Mother: Elorde Biscarra

B. Educational Background

Primary: Malokiat Elementary School


Malokiat Pozzorubio Pangasinan
2007-2013

Secondary:
Junior High School Don Benito Agro-Industrial High School
Don Benito Pozzorubio Pangasinan
2013 – 2017

Senior High School Don Benito Agro-Industrial High School


Don Benito Pozzorubio Pangasinan
2017 – 2019

Tertiary: University of Eastern Pangasinan


Mc Arthur Highway, Canarvacanan 
Binalonan, Pangasinan
2020 – 2024

Course: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration


Major in Marketing Management
CURRICULUM VITAE

A. Personal Data

Name: Maria Theresa M. Delin

Age: 26

Date of Birth: January 14, 1996

Place of Birth: Pao Manaoag Pangasinan

Address: 164 Pao Manaoag, Pangasinan


85

Religion: Roman Catholic

Contact Number: 09279103856

Email Address: theresadelin@yahoo.com

Name of Father: Delfin C. Delin

Name of Mother: Maricel M. Delin

B. Educational Background

Primary: Pao Elementary School


Pao Manaoag Pangasinan
2007-2008
Secondary:
Junior High School: Manaoag National High School
Manaoag Panagasinan
2002 – 2008

Vocational: Bright International School


Computer Hardware Servicing NCII
2014 – 2015

Tertiary: University of Eastern Pangasinan


Binalonan, Pangasinan
2019 – 2024

Course: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration


Major in Marketing Management

CURRICULUM VITAE

A. Personal Data

Name: Mary Lhea T. Grospe

Age: 21

Date of Birth: September 08, 2001

Place of Birth: Sta.Maria Norte Binalonan Pangasinan

Address: Sta. Maria Norte Binalonan, Pangasinan


86

Religion: Roman Catholic

Contact Number: 09076213006

Email Address: mleduc2001@gmail.com

Name of Father: Pablo D. Grospe

Name of Mother: Angielyn T. Grospe

B. Educational Background

Primary: Sta. Maria Elemtary School


Binalonan, Pangasinan
2008– 2014
Secondary:
Junior High School Sta. Maria National High Schoo
Binalonan, Pangasinan
2014-2018

Senior High School MATH Excellence Academy of Binalonan Inc.


Mc. Arthur Highway, Canarvacanan
Binalonan,Pangasinan
2018-2020

Tertiary: University of Eastern Pangasinan


Mc Arthur Highway, Canarvacanan 
Binalonan, Pangasinan
2020 – Present

Course: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration


Major in Marketing Management
CURRICULUM VITAE

A. Personal Data

Name: Jericho D. Pedrozo

Age: 20

Date of Birth: January 19,2002

Place of Birth: Bobonan West, Pozzorubio, Pangasinan

Address: Bobonan West, Pozzorubio, Pangasinan


87

Religion: Iglesia Ni Cristo

Contact Number: 09128186318

Email Address: pedrozojericho@gmail.com

Name of Father: Orlando V. Pedrozo

Name of Mother: Maggie D. Pedrozo

B. Educational Background

Primary: Bobonan Central School


Bobonan, Pozzorubio, Pangasinan
2008 – 2014
Secondary:
Junior High School Bobonan National High School
Bobonan, Pozzorubio, Pangasinan
2014 – 2018

Senior High School University of Luzon


Pozzorubio, Pangasinan
2018 – 2020

Tertiary: University of Eastern Pangasinan


Mc Arthur Highway, Canarvacanan 
Binalonan, Pangasinan
2020 – 2024

Course: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration


Major in Marketing Management

You might also like