Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Notes Theories Crime Causation
Notes Theories Crime Causation
• EARLY SCHOOL OR
THEORIES OF CRIMINOLOGY
A. PRE-CLASSICAL/DEMONOLOGICAL/
SUPERNATURAL THEORY
- Crime is a result of demonic possession or the evil abuse of freewill.
- result of Black Magic (by Witch Craft).
- result of Dark Prince or Satan.
- criminal viewed as a sinner possessed by demons or worldly/Natural force.
• HEDONISM PRINCIPLE
B. CLASSICAL THEORY
- Principle of “FREE WILL” / “ ABSOLUTE FREE WILL”
- Considered as “Age of Reason/Enlightenment”
- criminal should be responsible for his act.
PRINCIPAL ADVOCATE
• Cesare Beccaria( 1738- 1794),
• Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832)
Jeremy Bentham, Beccaria’s counterpart in Britain, borrowed from Beccaria the notion that laws should
provide the greatest happiness shared by greatest number.
Bentham has been called an advocate of Utilitarian Hedonism or Felicific Calculus or Penal Pharmacy.
DETERRENCE - is the core principle of classical school and rational choice theories which states that crime
can be controlled through the use of punishments that combine the proper degrees of certainty, severity and
clarity.
• SPECIFIC DETERRENCE THEORY – explains that preventing or discouraging the criminals to
commit another crime.
• GENERAL DETERRENCE THEORY – refers to provide fear to the potential criminal or public
deterrence from committing a crime.
HIGHLIGHTS OF CESARE BECCARIA’S IDEAS REGARDING CRIMES AND THE CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SYSTEM
❖ “In forming a human society, men and women sacrifice a portion of their liberty so as to enjoy peace
and security.”
❖ “Punishments that go beyond the need of preserving the public safety are in their nature unjust.”
❖ “Criminal laws must be clear and certain. Judges must make uniform judgments in similar crimes.”
❖ “The law must specify the degree of evidence that will justify the detention of an accused offender prior
to his trial.”
❖ “Accusations must be public. False accusations should be severely punished.”
❖ “To torture accused offenders to obtain a confession is inadmissible.”
❖ “Capital punishment is inefficacious and its place should be substituted life imprisonment.”
❖ “It is better to prevent crimes than to punish them. That is the chief purpose of all good legislation.”
❖ “The promptitude of punishment is one of the most effective curbs on crime.”
❖ “The aim of punishment can only be to prevent the criminal from committing new crimes against his
countrymen, and to keep others from doing likewise. Punishments, therefore, and the method of
inflicting them, should be chosen in due proportion to the crime, so as to make the most lasting
impression on the minds of men…”
“PUNISHMENT MUST FIT THE CRIME NOT THE CRIMINAL “
C. NEO-CLASSICAL THEORY
- Modification, opposition, contradiction of the Principle of Free Will
- Free Will Is Not Absolute
- consideration of Certain Factors
Exemption: CHILD, LUNATICS, INSANE, PHYSICALLY HANDICAPPED(Mitigated)
• NEO-CLASSICAL SCHOOL
- HEADED BY: GABRIEL TARDE – made a modification on fitness of punishment to crime.
- all perpetrators should not be treated in the same fashion.
The other two important figures in the Italian or Continental Positivists School of Criminology were
Lombroso’s students,
Enrico Ferri(1856-1929) and
Rafaele Garofalo (1852-1934).
CESARE LOMBROSO(1835-1909)
-Father of Criminology
-Criminal Anthropologist
-L’uomo Delinquente (The Criminal Man) Author.
-Theory of Atavism (ATAVISTIC STIGMATA)
Atavism- recurrence in an organism of a trait or character typical of an ancestral form and usually due to
genetic combination.
-derived from the Latin “atavus.”
-An atavus is a great-great-great-grandfather or, more generally, an ancestor.
-Atavistic Stigmata/atavistic Anomaly/Lombrosian stigmata
Criminals are throwback to the earlier stage of evolutionary process
• BIOLOGICAL DETERMINISM
- This explanation for the existence of criminal traits associates an individual’s evil disposition to physical
disfigurement or impairment.
HENRY H GODDARD
Martin Kallikak, a militiaman during the American Revolutionary war. Kallikak fathered a child out of
wedlock feebleminded, or deviant.
• The offspring of his marriage to a respectable woman were, on the other hand, all of the highest moral
standards.
• Goddard took these findings as proof positive of the real cause of crime-feeblemindedness or low
morality.
• GODDARD- coined the KALLIKAK means: KALLOS – good, KAKOS – bad.
“MORON” “FEEBLEMINDED”
• 2 WIVES OF MARTIN KALLIKAK
1. FEEBLE MINDED – LOW IQ
2. QUACKER – GOOD FAMILY/RELEGIOUS FAMILY
PSYCHOLOGICAL DETERMINISM
➢ This explains the psychological determinants which define behavior of a person. This idea has long
been hatched by thinkers who were consumed by the belief that it is the psychological equivalents that
prod the person to act the way he does.
- this theory focuses on the psychological aspects of crime, including the association between
- intelligence,
- personality,
- learning and
- criminal behavior.
• Psychodynamic/Psychoanalytic Theory
the development of the unconscious personality early in childhood influences behavior for the rest of person’s
life. Criminals have weak egos and damaged personalities. It is caused by intrapsychic processes experienced
by an individual consist of unconscious conflicts, defenses, tendencies, anger and sexuality.
ID – “PLEAUSRE PRINCIPLE”
--instinctive, natural or animalistic self.
--It is totally selfish and seeks to maximize pleasure
--the primitive part of the individual’s mental make-up present at birth
LIBIDO-Expressions of these pleasure principle
• Eros--their life or love instinct
• Thanatos-- as well as the death instinct (Thanatos).
Alfred Adler- The source of personality disorder and for us, criminality was a fear of inferiority and a
compensatory drive for power and superiority over his victim to compensate his own inferiority.
• INFERIORITY COMPLEX
“a basic feeling of inadequacy and insecurity, deriving from actual or imagined physical or psychological
deficiency.”
"Napoleon Complex" is a theorized inferiority complex normally attributed to people of short stature. It is
characterized by overly-aggressive or domineering social behavior, such as lying about earnings, and carries the
implication that such behavior is compensatory for the subject's physical or social shortcomings.
INFERIOR GIRL
• BY: FREUD
- when girls realize they have no penis, they sense that they are being punished because boys have
something important, they have been denied which result in inferiority complex.
MARXIST-FEMINIST THEORY
• When women do engage in crime, their criminal activity tends to be a response to their subordinate and
powerless position in patriarchal capitalist society..
IDENTITY CRISIS
- a period of uncertainty and confusion in which a person's sense of identity becomes insecure, typically
due to a change in their expected aims or role in society.
Erik Erikson- Criminality may be the result of an inadequate development of a sense of identity or the result
of inadequate development of sense of inferiority or inadequacy.
- sense of identity means being able to see yourself as the same person in the past, present, and future.
Behavioral
• People commit crime when they model their behavior after others they see being rewarded for the same
acts.
• Behavior is reinforced by rewards and extinguished by punishment.
BEHAVIORAL THEORY
- Criminal behavior is learned response that has been strengthened because of the reinforcements it
produces.
-
Abraham Maslow and Seymour Halleck
Fundamentally psychoanalytic.
- Called humanistic needs because they assume that human beings basically good even though sometimes they
are influenced by society to act badly.
• He suggested that human needs from a hierarchy from the most basic biological requirements to the
needs for self-actualization the highest of all needs.
• Hierarchy of Needs that Motivate Human Beings:
1. Physiological- (food, water, and procreational sex)
2. Safety- (security, stability, freedom from fear or anxiety)
3. Belongingness and love (friendship, love, affection, acceptance)
4. Cognitive-(learning & exploration)
5. Esteem-( self esteem and esteem of others)
6. Aesthetic-(beauty and order)
7. Self-actualization-(total satisfaction, capable of all)
COGNITIVE
• individual reasoning processes influence behavior.
• Reasoning is influenced by the way people perceive their environment and by their moral and
intellectual development.
• Cognitive is defined as an ability to process information.
• Cognition has to do with one's ability to learn information quickly, memorize, and understand
information they receive.
Cognitive theories of crime explain criminal behavior as a defect in
• moral thinking,
• thought processes, and
• mental development.
LEVEL OF IQ
1. Profound- I.Q. is under 20.
2. Severe- I.Q. is between 20 and 35
3. Moderate- I.Q. is 36 to 51
4. Mild- I.Q. is 56 to 67
5. Borderline Retardation- I.Q. is 68 to 83
3. COMPULSIVE NEUROSIS
– this is the uncontrollable or irresistible impulse to do something.
--Their maybe an active desire to resist the irrational behavior but prevented by the unconscious motives to act
out his difficulty and or to suffer miserably in his fear.
4. PSYCHOPHATIC PERSONALITY
– this is the most important cause of criminality among youthful offenders and habitual criminals.
It is characterized by infantile level of response, lack of conscience, deficient feeling of affection to others and
aggression to environment and other people.
5. Antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) is a condition characterized by a lack of empathy and regard for
other people.
People who have antisocial personality disorder have little or no regard for right or wrong.
They antagonize and often act insensitively or in an unfeeling manner.
Individuals with this disorder may lie, engage in aggressive or violent behavior, and participate in criminal
activity.
=Sociopath – educated person
=Psychopath – uneducated person
6. EPILEPSY – this is a condition characterized by convulsive seizures and a tendency to mental deterioration.
The seizure maybe extreme loss of consciousness. During the attack the person become muscularly rigid,
respiration ceases, froth on the mouth and tongue maybe bitter.
TYPES OF EPILEPSY:
a. GRAND MAL – there is a complete loss of conscience and general contraction of the muscles.
b. PETIT MAL – mild or complete loss of consciousness and contraction of muscles.
c. JACKSONIAN TYPE – localized contraction of muscles with or without loss of consciousness.
Karl Marx
- economic substructure determines the nature of all other institutions and social relationships in society.
- emergence of capitalism produces economic inequality in which the proletariats (workers) are
exploited by the bourgeoisie (owners or capitalist class).
- This exploitation creates poverty and also is the root of the existence of other social problems.
SOCIOLOGICAL DETERMINISM
• Sociological factors refers to things, places and people with whom we come in contact with and which
play a part in determining our actions and conduct. These causes may bring about the development of
criminal behavior
• ENRICO FERRI
- a member of the Italian parliament .
- he believed that criminals could not be held morally responsible because they did not choose to commit
crimes but was driven to commit them by conditions of their lives.
• SOCIAL NORMS
- Also called rules of conduct
- shared standard of behavior which in turn require certain expectations of behavior in a given situation.
• SOCIALIZATION
- Refers to the learning process by which a person learns and internalizes the ways of society so that he can
function and become an active part of society.
• CULTURE
- refers to the system of values and meanings shared by a group of individuals.
- refers to the way of life, modes of thinking, acting and feeling .
EMILE DURKHEIM
- one of the founding scholars of sociology
- published a book, “Division of Social Labor”, which became a landmark work on the organization of
societies.
“ANOMIE THEORY”
- normlessness, the breakdown of social order as a result of loss of standards and values.
• according to him:
• Crime is as normal a part of society as birth and death
• Crime is part of human nature because it has existed during periods of both poverty and
prosperity
• As long as human differences exists, which is one of the fundamental conditions of society, it is
but natural and expected that it will result to criminality
CHICAGO SCHOOL
- refers to an iconoclastic group of sociologists from the University of Chicago whose work would influence the
development of a new science to the discipline of sociology in the early 20th century.
Robert Ezra Park Ernest W. Burges Louis Wirth George Herbert Mead, Walter C. Reckless,
Edwin Sutherland,
TRADITIONAL CHICAGO SCHOOL OF CRIMINOLOGY
• It is identified with neighborhood studies of crime and delinquency that focus particularly on the spatial
pattern.
• It develop the Social Disorganization Theory – it link crime rates to neighborhood ecological
characteristics.
2. Strain Theory
• Robert Merton
- Crime is a function of the conflict between the goals people have and the means they can use to legally
obtain them.
- Deviance occur when society does not give all its members equal ability to achieve socially acceptable
goals
ECOLOGICAL THEORY
Social forces operating in urban areas create criminal interactions; some neighborhoods become natural areas
for crimes.
--also referred to as the Statistical Geographic, or Cartographic.
• This school was called Statistical because it was the first to attempt to apply official data and statistic to
the issue of explaining criminality.
• The labels geographical and cartographic have been assigned due to the fact that writers in this group
tended to rely upon maps and aerial data in their investigations.
• CLASSIFICATION OF CRIMINOLOGY
1. SOCIOLOGICAL CRIMINOLOGY
- Study of crime focused on the group of people and the society as a whole.
- Examination of the relationship of demographic and group variables to crime.
- SUCH AS: Socioeconomic Status, interpersonal relationships, age, race, gender and cultural groups of
people.
2. PSYCHOLOGICAL CRIMINOLOGY
• The science of behavior and mental processes of the criminal.
• Focused on the individual criminal behavior:
• How it is acquired, evoked, maintained and modified..
- Environmental and personality influence with mental processes.
3. PSYCHIATRIC CRIMINOLOGY
- Study of crime through forensic psychiatry, criminal behavior in terms of motives and drives.
“PSYCHOANALYTICAL THEORY” By: Sigmund Freud (Traditional View)
- explains that criminals are acting out of uncontrollable animalistic, unconscious, or biological urges.
(Modern View).
4. CRITICAL CRIMINOLOGY – analysis on crime and nature of social injustice and inequalities.
– provide alternative approach to understand crime and control.
- focuses on challenging traditional understandings and uncovering false belief about crime and criminal
justice.
SUCH AS: Marxism, feminism, Political Economy Theory and Critical Theory.
5. APPLIED CRIMINOLOGYY – focuses more on the processes seen in the justice system.
– applied form or approach with the “real world problems” of crime and criminal justice.
8. CONVICT CRIMINOLOGY – study is more on the efforts to reform jails, prisons, and other
correctional facilities.
10. BIOSOCIAL CRIMINOLOGY – an interdisciplinary field that aims to explain crime and antisocial
behavior by exploring biocultural factors.
12. RADICAL CRIMINOLOGY – conflict ideology which bases its perspective on crime and law in the
belief that capitalist societies define crimes and use their power to enact law that will control the
working class and repress threats to the power of the ruling class.
FEMINIST MOVEMENT
• Refers to series of social movements and political campaigns for radical and liberal forms on women
issues created by inequality between men and women.
• EX. Women’s Liberation Movement
• Black Feminism
• The Feminist Sex War
• Riot Girlss
• Suffrage Movement