Bsn3a Group 2 Speaker Notes

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

Mind by Mary Belenky, Blythe

GENDER STUDIES McVicker Clinchy, Nancy Rule


OUTLINE: Goldberger, and Jill Mattuck Tarule
● CHAPTER 4: Women’s Ways of
published in 1986
Knowing
○ Women and the Metaphor for - It will also discuss the
Silence implications of the identified
○ Differences in Ways of ways of knowing in relation to
Knowing: Women and
Connectedness
the greater societal context
○ Exclusion Of Women In - Western male reasoning uses
Disciplines? images that are related to
● CHAPTER 11: The Western Women’s visuals, seeing, or illumination
Movement
○ Where does Liberation Begin? to represent knowledge.
○ What is Feminism? - Light as a representation of
○ The First wave of Feminism: knowledge stems from Plato
Women and Civil Rights
and his Allegory of the Cave
○ The Second Wave of Feminism
and Women's Liberation - He likened an
○ The Third Wave of Feminism enlightened individual
○ Summing up the Western to a person who
Feminist Movement
leaves the cave and is
suddenly exposed to
CHAPTER 4 the light of the sun,
which can be seen to
WOMEN AND THE METAPHOR FOR represent knowledge.
SILENCE While the common
metaphor for
- Femininity and masculinity are not knowledge is light,
inherent but learned this image is not
- Culture plays a large part in representative of how
determining what are considered other people,
masculine or feminine traits specifically women,
- Likewise, individuals in particular view knowledge.
cultures are taught to conform to - A study on women by
these standards institutions of learning
- A woman's way of understanding the showed that listening is more
world is affected by socialization. representative of their
Women may address problems knowledge than seeing. The
differently or be less inclined towards stark difference between
certain disciplines. women and men's ways of
- They may also be excluded knowing are illustrated in the
from certain schools of work by Belenky et al.
thought because of traits - Women associate silence with
associated with their gender. knowledge as they
- Based on Women's Ways of Knowing: themselves are often left
The Development of Self, Voice, and unheard and silent. In the
study, silence and voice were covertly, their own beliefs about
dominant themes for gender.
women—a person who had A concrete example of this is that:
knowledge and authority was - The role of universal caregiving in all
supposed to be listened to, societies was given to women.
but women who spoke out Because of this, girls learned to be
were silenced women by copying their mothers, and
boys learned to be men through a
DIFFERENCES IN WAYS OF KNOWING: disassociation with their mother's
WOMEN AND CONNECTEDNESS role.
- Because young girls had their mothers
- Women and men have different ways as role models, they learned through
of knowing, judgments, forms of association and connectedness.
human development, values, and Women then learned through
visions of humanity and existence. empathy. Men learned through the
This book assumes that the main separation of the self from the other.
difference between men and women These themes of connectedness and
comes from upbringing and gender separation will be used to describe
socialization. women's ways of knowing.
Wherein upbringing is defined as:
- helping someone grow up to be an HOW WOMEN KNOW
accepted member of the - According to Belenky and colleagues,
community women use the following
perspectives to see the world and to
Wherein gender socialization is defined as:
understand knowledge and truth
- Gender socialization is the process of 1. Silence
learning the social expectations and 2. Received knowledge: listening
attitudes associated with one's sex. to the voices of others
- These terms come into play as 3. Subjective knowledge: the
gender-specific social and behavioral inner voice
norms are mostly embedded in family 4. Subjective knowledge: the
structure and upbringing.As children quest for self
move through childhood and into 5. Procedural knowledge: voice
adolescence, they are exposed to of reason
many factors which influence their 6. Procedural knowledge:
attitudes and behaviors regarding separate and connected
gender roles. These attitudes and knowing
behaviors are generally learned first 7. Constructed knowledge:
in the home and are then reinforced integrating the voices
by the child's peers, school - These perspectives comprise of five
experience, and television viewing. categories (silence, knowledge,
However, the strongest influence on subjective knowledge, procedural
gender role development seems to knowledge, and constructed
occur within the family setting, with knowledge) which describe the
parents passing on, both overtly and general ways women learn about
their world and come to conclusions death, and sometimes a literal one.
about truth. For instance, If no one listens when
you say your ex-husband is trying to
WOMEN AND SILENCE kill you, or abuse you, this often leads
- Silence as knowing indicates an to perpetuation to Violence against
absence of thought or reflection. women, rooted in silence where it is
- As Rebecca Solnit, a writer stated against our voices and our stories.
that, Silence and powerlessness go
hand in hand. RECEIVED KNOWLEDGE: LISTENING TO THE
- Women who live in silence are often VOICES OF OTHERS
disconnected from their families and - Received knowledge is developed by
communities due to their situation, absorbing knowledge. Silence is still
the geographical separation of the valued in this way of knowing as the
families from the greater community, receiver must be silent to receive the
and suffocation, all of which bring knowledge transmitted. However, the
about lack of space for constructive silence is not always internal. Women
thought. These women usually come who learn through receiving
from families that are abusive or knowledge listen to friends and
violent. authorities, and understand what is
- Their knowledge comes from being said enough for them to repeat
authorities and focuses on their need the words. These women see words
to survive. as imperative to learning.
- Women who learn through silence - Women characterizing this position
lack the ability to understand abstract lacked confidence in their own ability
thought. They do not enjoy a space to speak and generally defined
for introspection given their themselves externally, usually in
environment while growing up, or a relation to social norms, gender roles
greater awareness of their own and expectations of others, i.e.,
mental capacity. cultural ideals of women as set forth
- Here, there is absence of by external authorities.
Reflective thought, which is - Belenky et al. (1986) places a woman
characterized by ideas that are at the receiving knowledge level if she
developed from back-and-forth is listening but does not have the
communication between two people, confidence to voice her opinion. As
which is stunted. Therefore, there is the receiver she will listen and pass
no dialogue with the self. knowledge onto others, shaping her
- In this case, thoughts to match those in authority.
- Women who do not have a voice end When asked about herself, the
up having no internal voice as well, no receiver of knowledge will reply with
self-perception, and lack an identity what other individuals have stated,
separate from what is dictated to unable to voice her feelings. Abuse is
them. still prevalent in the life of a woman
- Silence is what allows people to suffer receiving knowledge.
without recourse. Imagine Being - Women who learn in this manner are
unable to tell your story is a living able to do the right thing by following
the rules of authority figures. woman's previous (often abusive)
However, those under the line of environment, a new quest for self is
received knowledge value authority done in relation to her new
and cannot comprehend paradoxes. If community. New connections are
two of her authority figures have formed, and the woman is able to find
contradicting information, the woman herself.
will not be able to distinguish which is - As Such significant events become
correct. She will use arbitrary means an eye opener, this encourages a
to decide on who is telling the truth. woman to go from a receiver of
SUBJECTIVE KNOWLEDGE: THE INNER VOICE knowledge to progress to the level
AND THE QUEST FOR SELF
of subjectivity. The woman begins
- Women who learn through subjective
to accept that she has a voice, an
knowledge learn to trust what is
inner source of strength lying
called their "inner voice and infallible
gut." Women who utilize this form of within herself, and an opinion that
knowledge are often those who have is due to past experiences. She
awakened to the previous abuses recognizes that she does not have
they have suffered, or have broken to agree with the authority but is
off with the authority figures they still cautious about voicing
have held dear. They also realize that opinions. Truth is experienced
following rules will not make them within oneself but not acted upon
happy. Hence, they move from for fear of jeopardizing the
passivity to action.
associations one has with others at
- Subjective knowers depend on their
the same level.
selves and their experience to attain
To continue, Miss carpio will be further
truth. Logic, rhetoric, and theory are
elaborating the different types.
viewed with suspicion for these tools
PROCEDURAL KNOWLEDGE: VOICE OF
are associated with forms of
REASON AND SEPARATE AND CONNECTED
knowledge that these women are not
KNOWING
familiar with, or are used to discredit
- Procedural knowers learn through
or debase them. Women who fall
processes. Often, the women utilizing
under this category of learners use
this method have learned well from
their intuition to decipher truth from
formal systems of knowledge, enough
fiction. Basically, they believe their
to excel. However, they have views
intuition is the only thing they can
that differ from what they are taught.
trust.
They then use the tools they acquired
- Women with subjective knowledge
from these formal systems to defend
often experience a break, a
their own worldview. Rather than
separation of self from their previous
moving on from subjective
communities that may have been
knowledge, they learn to defend their
harmful to them. In severing
beliefs and rationalize their thoughts.
connections, these women learn to
Women with this form of knowledge
depend on themselves and find
learn the language of the experts and
themselves as their own authority.
apply this to their own views. Those
Because of this break from the
who use procedural knowledge learning to play the system, women
usually focus more on the method must learn to value their own
and less on the problem. Since the methods of knowing and their own
method centers on the debate and constructed knowledge.
winning, it may not allow women the - To do this, the constructed knowledge
space to voice out their own concerns must turn inward instead of outward,
and bring their needs to light. with the idea that "knowledge is
- Procedural knowers believe that each constructed, and the knower is an
person views the world differently intimate part of the known."
and is entitled to his or her own - Women must learn to listen to
opinion. They pay attention to how themselves in a world where the
different people form their views of dominant voice is male, and when it
the world. The question "Where are stifles their own. By continuing to
they coming from?" is pivotal for listen to themselves, voicing what is
them left unsaid, and learning to read
- Understanding then comes as a vital through the different interactions
aspect of knowing. The importance around them, women may validate
women give to connections is and continue their own self-
reflected in how they come to learn knowledge.
about things. Understanding involves - The connectedness that women value
acquainting oneself with the object to must not be discounted. The notion of
be known, and forming a connection "real talk"—the sharing of ideas
with it. To understand, as women say, through open and honest
there must be a form of acceptance, discussion—should be valued. This is
which is achieved by questioning the optimum setting for the co-
what the object is trying to show in creation of knowledge. By valuing
relation to one's self. Through this themselves and seeing themselves as
process, procedural knowledge and an indispensable part of knowledge-
connected knowers learn through creation, women may become
acquiring the knowledge of others. empowered, working towards an
The ideas of connection and improvement in their lives as well as
understanding show an important in the lives of others.
difference in how men and women
view morality. Men tend to separate MEANING OF DIFFERENCES IN KNOWING
themselves and become impartial - The first wave of the Western
when it comes to giving justice. Women's Movement often equated
Women often see themselves as women's liberation with reason; its
connected to other people, are more main aim was to achieve equality with
empathetic, and create morality men. This goal was to be realized
based on care for others. through the inclusion of women in all
aspects of society, meaning that all
CONSTRUCTED KNOWLEDGE: INTEGRATING the rights afforded to men must be
THE VOICES afforded to women. Observably, true
- Women need the ability to reflect on inclusion through equal access does
and accept themselves. Instead of not immediately mean equal
opportunities. To have equal rights as thought to be abnormal. Women
men is not the same as having actual were also missing from research
equality since the structure of the studies on human behavior.
world is based on male ways of - Hence, it can be assumed that there is
knowing. The education system is an a gap in previous theorists' knowledge
example of this inequality. It was on the human condition.
founded on the interests of the
dominant group, specifically men. CHAPTER 11
- Education was modeled after what
they needed to know and how they WHERE DOES LIBERATION BEGIN?
were socialized to learn. Women's
schools were then modeled after - When speaking of women's history,
these systems, ignoring the specific the Western women's movement may
ways that women were taught to come to mind. Why?
experience the world. - So, the western women movement
is also called the women’s liberation
EXCLUSION OF WOMEN IN DISCIPLINES? movement it is a diverse social
movement, which is largely based in
- Knowledge, specifically in the the United States that in the 1960’s
sciences, are said to be gender and 1970’s sought equal rights and
neutral. However, many feminists opportunities and greater personal
argue that this is not the case. Male freedom for women. This is actually
bias is present in different disciplines, what they call the second wave of
from the topics one chooses to study, feminism.
the kinds of research questions one - The first wave happened on the 19th
develops, to the observable data that and early 20th century which largely
is deemed "relevant. focuses on women’s legal rights,
- Carol Gilligan in her book A Different especially the right to vote which us
Voice highlights male bias in women has already the privileged
psychology. She notes that different now.
psychologists often highlight women's - While the second wave of feminism
failure to fit into existing models of which is the what we call the
human growth. All women were ‘Women’s liberation movement’
thought to have these problems and touches every area of women’s
these delays. Yet, this conception of experience that includes politics
human beings showed that something because women aren’t allowed to be
was lacking in the analysis of women part of the politics before, work
- Specifically, men were often used as wherein women aren’t allowed to or
the template for studies on human there are only specific types of work
beings. The male as a dominant women can do and apply, the family
model made men and men's behavior since before the father is the head
the basis of assessing human and the mother has no voice or right
development. Because women did to make family decisions, and
not conform to this behavior or sexuality where women cannot
pattern of development, they were express themselves in different areas
like the way they dress women rights for all as defined by thinkers
cannot wear pants or shorts and such as Kant and Mill.
expressing oneself is forbidden. - The evolution of Western women's
- Organized activism by and on behalf movement in recent history can be
of women continued through the summarized into three waves
third and fourth waves of feminism
from the mid-1990s and early 2010s. WESTERN WOMEN'S MOVEMENT: A BRIEF
HISTORY
- This movement exposed the - The first wave of feminism involves
structural inequality faced by the
women in particular eras. call for women's equal rights,
- More importantly, this focusing on the woman's right to
movement identified women vote.
as an oppressed group. - It is largely rooted in the
- The sectoral situationer on women liberal political thought which
shows that the power imbalance of prioritized the power of
gender roles is mostly limiting. reason and the mind.
- Much of these students' - The next wave is known as radical
understanding of gender justice is feminism, a post-World War II era of
influenced by social media posts and feminism when women were already
popular culture. recognized as having distinct
- Without knowing the biological needs from men,
historicity of an issue, one will such as for reproductive health, and
not understand its root and needs that arose from their being
cannot address it in a holistic socialized as women.
manner - The last wave of feminism is rooted in
the recognition of various theories
WHAT IS FEMINISM? and various modes of being. To
- Feminism is a way of looking at the be truly free from patriarchy, the
world through a woman's recognition of intersectionality
perspective. considers women's struggle from
- The patriarchal nature of society has different parts of the globe—such
driven feminism to concern itself with as that of the Black or Latin women—
issues in relation to women to be distinct struggles that are
oppression, with an end goal of different from women's struggles in
liberating women the Western world.
through gender equality
- Feminism is a concept popularized by THE FIRST WAVE OF FEMINISM:
Western societies, with many feminist WOMEN AND CIVIL RIGHTS
issues articulated by THEORETICAL ROOTS OF THE FIRST WAVE OF
Westerneducated women and even FEMINISM—LIBERAL FEMINISM
men. It is deeply rooted in the - Characterized by the women's
Western concept of liberal struggle for equality
democracy and philosophy of equal - Latter part of the 18th century until
the first half of the 20th century
- The development of liberal political - Considered the mother of Western
thought by philosophers like Kant, and Anglo—Saxon feminism,
- Mill, and Rousseau underscoring the Wollstonecraft
equal rights of all men inspired advocated for the uplifting of
women to craft their own philosophy women's rights through the valuation
of equality of their work within the family. Her
with men work highlights the need for women's
- Start of the documented feminist education, and that women are not
movement during the French merely objects to be married off but
Revolution in the late 1700s. are also educators and caregivers of
- The French Revolution was a their children.
movement that overthrew - While these documents show an
the Bourbon monarchy, a insight as to why the rights of women
powerful family that ruled were denied under existing laws,
France for over a century and Friedrich Engels, a collaborator of Karl
controlled most of French Marx in writing the communist
resources. manifesto,
- While there was no woman- provided a plausible reason why
specific issue addressed women were oppressed. Given the
during this movement, it Marxist focus on material conditions
inspired the seminal text for and the accumulation and production
the Western women's of resources as key movers of
movement: the Citoyennes societies, Engels saw the relation
Républicaines, between women and goods as the
Révolutionnaires root to women's subjugation.
(Revolutionary Republican - Engels' text, The Origin of the Family,
Women Citizens). Private Property, and the State,
- The Citoyennes Républicaines, published in 1884, describes marriage
Révolutionnaires demanded that as a process of gaining control of
women be granted the right to vote women.
and hold civilian and military positions - Monogamy was a creation necessary
like men. However, the (male) to pass on wealth to one's offspring.
revolutionaries ignored these
- It is evident in the Declaration of the WOMEN AND THE ANTI-SLAVERY
Rights of Man and the Citizen of 1789 MOVEMENT
which only focused on men and men's - During the 1840 World Anti-Slavery
rights. Convention in London, women
- Olympia de Gouges was a French delegates were even made to listen to
feminist, writer, and political activist proceedings behind curtains.
who believed strongly in justice and - Two prominent figures of the
equality for all. American women's movement who
- She responded to the National attended the convention—Lucretia
Assembly's Declaration by publishing Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton—
in 1791 her own Declaration of the were moved by this insulting
Rights of Woman and of the Female experience.
Citizen.
- The manifesto of de Gouges inspired WOMEN AND THE RIGHT TO VOTE
what can be considered the keystone - Women fought for equal access to
text of liberal feminist thought, A various opportunities as formalized in
Vindication of the Rights of Women in the Declaration of Sentiments that
1792 by Mary Wollstonecraft.
emerged from the Seneca Falls mechanical work, a traditional male
Convention—the first women's rights job, in a bid to invite women to work
convention—in New York City in in factories as most men were
1848. Stanton enumerated in this
assembled for war.
Declaration various women's issues
that eventually led to what would be - Betty Friedan's The Feminine
known as the suffrage movement. Mystique describes the growing
- The first-wavers not only called for discontent of white and middle-class
the right to vote but also the right to housewives during the postWorld
smoke, the right to wear pants, and War II period. Her idea of the
the right to promiscuity like men. "problem with no name" united
housemakers across America
THE SECOND WAVE OF FEMINISM
regarding the growing helplessness
AND WOMEN'S LIBERATION
that
- Women in the Western world
women felt due to their lack of power
eventually earned the right to vote
as they remained trapped in the
- A new struggle arose, one that
domestic sphere
involved marginalized sectors such as
- Simone de Beauvoir, a French
black women, lesbians and
feminist best known for her work, The
homosexuals, women in developing
Second Sex, explored how women
countries, and other marginalized
were not seen as equal by men and
women.
that the very realization of women's
- More concerned with the idea of
existence as persons was structured
womanhood and the issue that came
to be inferior
with the social construction of a
- Shulamith Firestone and Kate Millett
woman’s role and identity
showed how this construction was an
- One work that awoke numerous
outcome of the economy, the culture,
women across America was Betty
and society at large
Friedan's book, The Feminine
- Firestone, in her text The Dialectic of
Mystique, published in 1963.
Sex, called for a feminist revolution
- Also founded on such works as
that could help liberate women from
Simone de Beauvoir's The Second Sex,
the inequality brought about by their
Kate Millett's Sexual Politics, and
biology, specifically those concerning
Shulamith Firestone's The Dialectic of
conception, childbirth, and child-
Sex.
rearing.
- These books, published
between 1949 and the 1970s,
THEORETICAL ROOTS IN THE SECOND WAVE
marked the spirit and
OF FEMINISM—SOCIALIST FEMINISM
ideology of the second wave
- Socialist feminism was developed
of feminism because they
after Marxist feminism to address
articulated the heart of a new
gaps found in Marxist theories.
struggle
- Unlike Marxist feminists, socialist
- The American propaganda "Rosie the
feminists believe that women are
Riveter became an icon of women. It
oppressed in all aspects of their lives,
shows a poster image of a woman
not only in the economic aspect
doing
- Socialist feminism draws a different field. This move was based on the need
meaning from the Marxist idea of to counter years of what many
human productivity: one's productive consider the preferential option for
the male gender in productive work.
activity is based on the sexual division
of labor which is determined by OTHER FEMINISMS DURING THE SECOND
society and human nature. WAVE
- The civil rights movement in the U.S. - Working class women and Third World
inspired another form of feminism women believed that their issues were
that is grounded on structural also determined by the upper classes
change. This feminist perspective— - Third World women found many First
World women to be condescending
known as radical feminism—sought
and aggressive with their agenda in
to ensure that women's differences important international conferences
from men were recognized and
celebrated. THE THIRD WAVE OF FEMINISM
- Radical feminism came about as a - The rise of communism
reaction to the lack of attention given and the new global order along with
to sex and sexuality in the women's biomedical and technological
struggle advances shaped the issues of this
era.
PATRIARCHY AS THE ROOT OF INEQUALITY? - The feminist movement shifted focus
- The subjugation of women worked in
to include the needs of women from
favor of society inasmuch as it ensured
developing countries in light of the
that the working force (men) and
future laborers (children) were cared effect of globalization and neoliberal
for at home. economic policies.
- De la Cruz notes that, "Generations of - This new wave of feminism was
second-wave feminist scholarship deemed more inclusive, as voices
have made gender oppression from post-colony and post-socialist
impossible to ignore.
countries were involved in the
- Key issues for radical feminists include
the reproductive rights of a woman or movement.
a woman's freedom to choose for her - Third-wave feminists were motivated
own body. by the need to develop a feminist
- Specifically, women fought for the theory and politics that honor
right to use birth control methods, get contradictory experiences and
sterilized, or even get abortions. deconstruct categorical thinking.
- What characterizes this feminism
THE CALL FOR AFFIRMATIVE ACTION
- The second wave of the women's is its "local, national, and
movement focused on redefining the transnational activism in areas such
meaning of woman in society by as violence against women,
restoring the struggle for genuine trafficking, body surgery, self-
gender equality. mutilation, and the overall
- Inequality was addressed during this
'pornofication' of the media," issues
time through various efforts, one of
that affect different women from
which was affirmative action.
- Affirmative action meant a deliberate various countries.
preferential option for women in order - The idea of postfeminism manifested
to have equal opportunity in a certain during the third wave of feminism, in
which the second wave was assessed the performance of traits that are
for purporting a universal feminism gendered.
that created one truth for all women,
with one answer for all issues and SUMMING UP THE WESTERN FEMINIST
directing the movement's concerns to MOVEMENT
target one dominant group—the
white and Western feminists. - Despite this rich diversity, it all shows
According to the book by Leslie that one thing has been the priority of
Heywood and Jennifer Drake, Third the movement: uplifting women such
Wave Agenda, postfeminism sought that they can fully participate in
to critique previous feminisms with society as equals with others, and
regard to what work had yet to be removing structural barriers that
done. prevent them from doing so
- Womanhood as an identity was one
major movement that was References:
scrutinized. Chegg. (n.d.)
- This movement that questioned, https://www.chegg.com/homework-
renamed, and reclaimed the concept help/definitions/gender-socialization-
of womanhood was called 49#:~:text=Gender%20Socialization.%20Gend
postmodern feminism er%20socialization%20is%20the%20process%
- The theme of "gender as a social 20of,in%20different%20ways%3A%20they%2
construct" was prevalent during this 0learn%20different%20social%20roles
time due to the pivotal text Gender
Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion Witt, S. D. (1997). Parental influence on
of Identity by Judith Butler published children's socialization to gender roles.
in 1990. PubMed.
- The challenge for feminists in this https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9179321/
period was to be conscious of how
one could express his or her gender Silence and powerlessness go hand in hand –
identity in a manner that truly women’s voices must be heard. (2017). The
represented him or her. Guardian.
- Identity politics was a driving force https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre
for discussion. e/2017/mar/08/silence-powerlessness-
- A notable woman during the third womens-voices-rebecca-solnit
wave of feminism is Judith Butler. She
is an American philosopher and Women’s ways of knowing: The development
academic whose book Gender of self, voice, and mind. (n.d.).
Trouble: Feminism and the https://mason.gmu.edu/~pbailey2/portfolio/
Subversion of Identity, brought docs/educ800waysofknowing/paperonwome
to light the fluid nature of gender. nswok.htm
- One of the many key words that
explain Judith Butler's philosophy is Postfeminism | CanLit Guides. (n.d.). CanLit.
performance. Gender is performed, Retrieved 9 April 2022 from
and one's identity is shaped through https://canlitguides.ca/canlit-guides-editorial-
team/postfeminism-and-conservative-
feminism/postfeminism/#:%7E:text=Postfemi
nism%20is%20a%20term%20used,expansions
%20of%20the%20movement%20obsolete.

You might also like