November 14, 2022 Monday HON. JOE AMIL M. SALINO Regional Director Regional Office No. IV-B MIMAROPA Department of Environment and Natural Resources & Environmental Management Bureau Bay 1515, L+S Bldg., Roxas Boulevard, Ermita, Manila RE: Violation of Section 4 of Presidential Decree No. 1585 Dear RD Salino, May I respectfully appeal the imposition of your good office of the fine of FIFTY THOUSAND (Php50,000.00) PESOS pursuant to Section 09 of Presidential Decree No. 1585, which is the maximum fine imposed under the said law. The truth of the matter is I am yet to operate the NORBEL LUMBER TRADING, as supported and shown by the CERTIFICATE from Barangay Mapaya, San Jose, Occidental Mindoro attached herein as ANNEX “A” and the fact that | am yet to use the Official Receipt which Thad only received from the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) on July 2022, photographs of which are attached herein as ANNEX “B” to “B- a”, The location where I intend to operate the NORBEL LUMBER TRADING is also the site or place of manufacturing of my footwear products, which made through recovered/recycled materials. This may have led to an error in the evaluation of your good office. Your consideration of the above claims shall be highly appreciated. Very truly yours, woul CUETO ATIENZARepublic of the Philippines Province of Occidental Mindoro MUNICIPALITY OF SAN JOSE BARANGAY MAPAYA Barangay Hotline Nos.0926-631 -8737 OFFICE OF THE PUNONG BARANGAY =] OPERATION OF BUSINESS TO WHO! IT MAY CONCERN: THIS IS TO CERTIFY that NORBEL LUMBER Comeninaee TRADING owned by Mr. Norbel C. Atienza located at a National Highway, Iocandia, Barangay Mapaya, San Jose, BULY P. PADILLA Occidental Mindoro. aniang Barangay Comm. on Pesce and Orde, Human Rghs and ie THIS CERTIFIES FURTHER observed that there has been no operation stated on this business entity as NORBEL LUMBER TRADING and the office considered this business totally NO OPERATION up to this moment and securing any permit and clearances in this barangay. THIS CERTIFICATION is issued upon the request of the aforementioned owner/operators for whatever legal i] purpose it may serve him/her best. DONE AND ISSUED this 4" day of November, 2022 at Barangay Mapaya, San Jose, Occidental Mindoro.| RANVEL PRINTING PRESS i 30 Bonifacio St., San Jose, Occ Mind CP # SMART: 0910-243-4622 GLOBE: 0935~ Emall; ranvelprint mail.com | FACEBOOK: Ranvel Printing Press serene KawanlAan NGRENTAS REVENUE REGION NO. 09A - CAT REVENUE DISTRICT OFFICE WO, jor 418-4 INDORO-ROMBLON) ll ITE-BATANGAS-MI fe NPE, ‘OCCIDENTAL MINDORO 03%, _ OcN: 037AU20220000001156 q Date of ATP: May 25, 2022 Expiry Date: May 24, 2027 TAXPAYER DETAILS & BRANCH CODE“B2" ‘na press ‘Wi so, Occ. MEO 1p FOR CLAIM OF INPUT TAXES” MAY 24, 20.