Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C19 WSEAS2007 562 079 ArchGreenDesSust
C19 WSEAS2007 562 079 ArchGreenDesSust
net/publication/326773991
CITATION READS
1 6,854
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Stamatiou E, Lacroix R: "Erosion and immersion of coasts due to climate changes –forecasts and policies of the CELRL in France", In 4MMCZ: 589-599, (Sep 2008) View
project
All content following this page was uploaded by Richard E Lacroix on 02 August 2018.
Abstract: - This paper discusses the concept of “Sustainable Architecture” and of “Green Design”. It makes a
special reference to heating, ventilating and cooling systems efficiency, to sustainable building materials and
recycling and to waste management. Reference is made to improved energy efficient building designs with
examples of the passive solar building design with the three approaches of direct, indirect and isolated solar
gains and to active solar building design. A comparison of solar technologies is attempted with a discussion of
the passive house concepts and practices and how that technology compares with the Active solar technology,
with reference to details from Ireland’s Glengarriff Active Solar House project.
1 Introduction
Architecture to be consistent with sustainability
applies techniques of sustainable design to
architecture [12]. From the root words sus– (under)
+ tenere (to hold); to keep in existence; to maintain
or prolong [1]. Sustainable architecture and green
architecture for that matter is framed by the larger
discussion of sustainability and the pressing
economic and political issues of our world [2]. In
Figure 1: K2 sustainable apartments in Windsor,
the broad context, sustainable architecture, seeks to
Victoria, Australia by Hansen Yuncken (2006)
minimize the negative environmental impact of
features passive solar design, recycled and
buildings by enhancing efficiency and moderation in
sustainable materials, photovoltaic cells, wastewater
the use of materials, energy, and development space
treatment, rainwater collection and solar hot water.
[3]. Sustainability in architecture is related to the
Source: Hansen Yuncken (2006)
concept of "green architecture" or “green building”
[4]. The two terms, however are often used
interchangeably to relate to any building designed
2.1 Heating, Ventilation and Cooling System
with environmental goals in mind [5], often
regardless of how they actually function in regard to Efficiency
such goals[6]. The most important and cost effective element of an
efficient heating, ventilating, and air conditioning
(HVAC) system is a well insulated building. A more
efficient building requires less heat generating or
2 Architecture & Sustainable Energy dissipating power, but may require more ventilation
Energy efficiency over the entire Life cycle of a capacity to expel polluted indoor air (Figure 2).
building is the most important single goal of
sustainable architecture [7]. Architects use many
different techniques to reduce the energy needs of
buildings and increase their ability to capture [8] or
generate [9] their own energy (Figure 1).
IASME / WSEAS Inernational.Conference Agios Nikolaos, Crete Island, Greece, July 24-26,
2007, WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on Energy, Environment, Ecosystems And Sustainable
Development (EEESD'07), paper 562-079
architecture can lead the way for the greater retro-fit old structures to serve new needs in order to
community. avoid unnecessary development [19].
Architectural design can play a large part in
influencing the ways that social groups interact. 2.5 Waste management
Communist Russia's Constructivist Social Sustainable architecture focuses on the on-site use
condensers are a good example of this, buildings of waste, incorporating things such as grey water
which were designed with the specific intention of systems for use on garden beds, and composting
controlling or directing the flow of everyday life to toilets to reduce sewage [20]. These methods, when
"create socially equitable spaces". combined with on-site food waste composting and
Art can be a powerfully positive social force. It can off-site recycling, can reduce a house's waste to a
help to reduce stress in many situations, lowering small amount of packaging waste [21].
the risk of stress-related health problems, both
physical and mental. Art can also be a way of
individual expression, which can add to the 3 Improved Energy Efficient Building
community as a whole. Hundertwasser's buildings
in Austria are an inspiring example of art giving Designs
back to the community. Active solar devices such as photovoltaic solar
panels help to provide sustainable electricity for any
use. Roofs are often angled toward the sun to allow
2.3 Building placement photovoltaic panels to collect at maximum
One central and often ignored aspect of sustainable
efficiency, and some buildings even move
architecture is building placement [16]. Although
throughout the day to follow the sun. The Samundra
many environmentalists envision the ideal home or
Institute of Maritime Studies (SIMS)at Lonavala,
office structure as an isolated place in the middle of
near Pune India, has the longest photovoltaic wall in
the woods this kind of placement is often
the world, at over ninety meters long [22].
detrimental to the environment. First such structures
Undersized wind turbines (normal turbines are often
often serve as the unknowing frontlines of suburban
over 250 feet) are becoming increasingly practical
sprawl. Second isolated structures usually increase
for individual consumers and builders. Active solar
the energy consumption required for transportation
water heating systems have long provided heating-
and lead to unnecessary auto emissions. Ideally
specific energy in a sustainable manner.
most building should avoid suburban sprawl in
Occasionally houses that use a combination of these
favor of the kind of light urban development
methods achieve the lofty goal of "zero energy" and
articulated by the New Urbanist movement. Careful
can even begin generating excess energy for use in
mixed use zoning can make commercial, residential,
other structures[23].
and light industrial areas more accessible for those
traveling by foot, bicycle, or public transit, as
proposed in the Principles of Intelligent Urbanism. 3.1 Passive solar building design
Passive solar building design involves the modeling,
selection and use of appropriate passive solar
2.4 Sustainable Building Materials & technologies to maintain the building environment
Recycling at a desired temperature range (usually based
Some examples of sustainable building materials around human thermal comfort) throughout the
include recycled denim or blown-in fiber glass sun's daily and annual cycles. As a result it generally
insulation, sustainably harvested wood, bamboo, minimizes the use of active solar, renewable energy
which is one of the strongest and fastest growing and especially fossil fuel technologies [24].
woody plants, and non-toxic low-VOC glues and Passive solar building design is only one part of
paints [18]. thermally efficient building design, which in turn is
Some sustainable architecture incorporates recycled only one part of sustainable design, although the
or second hand materials. The reduction in use of terms are often used erroneously as synonyms
new materials creates a corresponding reduction in (passive solar design does not relate to factors such
embodied energy (energy used in the production of as ventilation, evaporative cooling, or life cycle
materials). Often sustainable architects attempt to analysis unless these operate solely by the sun).
IASME / WSEAS Inernational.Conference Agios Nikolaos, Crete Island, Greece, July 24-26,
2007, WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on Energy, Environment, Ecosystems And Sustainable
Development (EEESD'07), paper 562-079
Figure 3: Elements of passive solar design, shown 3.1.3 Isolated solar gain
in a direct gain application Isolated gain, involves passively capturing solar
heat and then moving it passively into or out of the
The use of sun-facing windows and a high-mass building using a liquid (for example using a
floor is a short-cycle example of this. John Hait's thermosiphon solar space heating system) or air
"Passive Annual Heat Storage" (PAHS) method is (perhaps using a solar chimney), either directly or
an example of an annualized solar approach using a thermal store.
primarily using this path. Sun-spaces, greenhouses, and "solar closets" are
Direct solar gain systems suffer because historically alternative ways of capturing isolated heat gain
there were no reasonably priced transparent from which warmed air can be taken. In practice it
thermally insulating materials with R-values has been found that some owners use these
comparable to standard wall insulation. This is now structures as living spaces, heating them with
changing in Europe [14], [15], where super conventional fuels and therefore significantly
insulated windows have been developed and are increasing, rather than reducing, the environmental
widely used to help meet the German Passive House impact of the building.
standard. Don Stephens' "Annualized Geo-Solar" (AGS)
In the northern hemisphere, a design that uses too heating is an annualized example of this option,
much south-facing glass can result in excessive which offers the advantages of preventing over-
heating and an uncomfortably bright living space at heating when living spaces are already deemed
certain times of the year. Conversely, in the southern warm enough, and of extending time-delays until
hemisphere the same is true for north-facing glass. such heat will be desired.
utilization systems that do not use external energy, with electricity to power a heat pump of less than
like a solar chimney, are classified as passive solar 9kWh/m2/a [25].
technologies [24].
Solar hot water systems, except those based on the 4.1 The Passive House Concept & Practice
thermosiphon, use pumps or fans to circulate water, The term Passive house (Passivhaus in German)
an anti-freeze mixture, or air through solar
[17] refers to the rigorous, voluntary, Passivhaus
collectors, and are therefore classified under active
standard for energy use in buildings. It results in
solar technology. The solar collectors can be non
ultra-low energy buildings that require little energy
concentrating or 'flat-plate', or of various
for space heating. A similar standard, MINERGIE-
concentrating designs. Most solar-thermal collectors
P®, is used in Switzerland. The first Passivhaus
have fixed mounting, but can have a higher
buildings were built in Darmstadt, Germany, in
performance if they track the path of the sun
1990, and occupied the following year. In
through the sky. Solar trackers, used to orient
September 1996 the Passivhaus-Institut was
photovoltaic arrays, may be driven by either passive
founded in Darmstadt to promote and control the
or active technology. Because passive solar systems
standard. Since then more than 6,000 Passivhaus
require no additional energy to operate and therefore
buildings have been constructed in Europe, most of
have zero operating costs, emit no greenhouse
them in Germany (Figures 6, 7, 8) and Austria, with
gasses in operation, and can have low maintenance
others in various countries world-wide.
costs, passive solar technologies should be given
full consideration.
show the way ahead. This information is taken from controls of a modern car; something that we take for
Ernst Posthuma of Solarcon which sheds light on a granted today. The house was monitored throughout
demonstration project in west Cork in Ireland that the entire year of 2005, and data of more then 50
combines passive and active solar gains to sensors was collected at five-minute intervals [25].
remarkable effect (Figures 10, 11, 12) [25].
and pump activity of less then 9 kWh per square [5] Jancovici Jean-Marc, L’Avenir climatique,
meter per year in the form of electricity. All other éditions Seuil, France, 2002 (in French)
energy for heating is extracted from the [6] Jolliver Marcel, (Scientific Editor), Sustainable
environment, leaving us with a bill of € 270.00 for development from utopia to the concept? New
heating and hot water for the entire year [25]. paths for research, Collection Environment,
Without Sunspace: Heating load = 9,564 kWh Elsevier, 2001
Area = 170 m² Heating load/m² = 56.3 kWh/m² [7] Jouzel Jean & Debroise Anne, Le climat: jeu
With Sunspace fitted: Heating load = 6,088 kWh dangereux, éditions Dunod, Quai des sciences
Area = 200 m² Heating load/m² = 30.44 kWh/m² collection, 2004 (in French)
Saving on the heating load per m² = 45.9 % [8] Lévêque Christian & Mounolou Jean-Claude,
This shows that the ‘passive house’ is one possible Biodiversité, Masson Sciences, éditions Dunod,
solution to solving energy problems and the ‘active France, 2001 (in French)
solar house’ may be another, equally sustainable [9] Lévêque Christian & Van der Leeuw Sander,
approach. (Scientific Editors) Which Natures do we want?
For a socio-ecological approach to the field of
the environment, Elsevier, Paris, France, 2003
6 Conclusion [10] Marechal Jean-Paul & Quenault Beatrice,
The concept of “Sustainable Architecture” and of (Scientific Editors) le développement durable:
“Green Design” with its demonstrated results from Une perspectives pour le XXIème siècle, éditions
around the world, will remain practical for many presses universitaires de Rennes, France, 2005
years to come. Through improvements made the (in French)
last five years to insulation of new building [11] Martin Jean-Yves, (Scientific Editor)
materials and to heating, ventilating and cooling Développement durable? Doctrines, pratiques,
systems efficiency, new and older homes can évaluations, éditions de l’IRD, France, 2002 (in
become more sustainable and energy efficient. As French)
new passive solar building designs have shown with [12] McNeill J.R., An environmental history of the
their uses of the three approaches of direct, indirect twentieth-century world. Something new under
and isolated solar gains and to active solar building the sun, W.W.Norton & Company, New York,
design the prospects are encouraging for sustainable USA, 2000
living. The passive house is a representative solution [13] Smouts Marie-Claude, Le développement
to solving energy problems while the active solar durable: les termes du débat, éditions Armand
house as Ireland’s Glengarriff Active Solar House Colin Compact, France, 2005 (in French)
project offers equally effective results as a [14] European Commission Portal on sustainable
sustainable approach. development, (2007)
http://ec.europa.eu/sustainable/welcome/index_e
References: n.htm
[1] Bourg Dominique, Le Développement durable [15] French Ministry of Sustainable Development
a-t’il un avenir?, Le Pommier, France, 2002 (in (Ministère de l’écologie et du développement
French) durable) (2007) http://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/
[2] Brunel Sylvie, Le Développement durable, Que [16] Hopkins R, A Natural Way of Building,
sais-je? PUF Editions, France, 2004 (in French) Transition Culture, Retrieved 2007-04-13
[3] Ducroux Anne Marie (Scientific Editor), Les http://transitionculture.org/articles/a-natural-
nouveaux utopistes du développement durable, way-of-building-2002/
Collections Mutations No. 216, Editions [17] Imes John, Grün auf Deutsch, at HOME in the
Autrement, France, 2002 (in French) Capital Region, pp 35 -36] Retrieved 2007-04-
[4] Erkman Suren, Vers une écologie industrielle, 13 http://www.wi-ei.org/germanymission.pdf
Comment mettre en pratique le développement [18] USGBC Document Excel file Retrieved 2007-
durable dans une société hyper-industrielle, 04-13
Editions Charles Léopold Meyer, Paris, France, https://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?
1998 (in French) DocumentID=1096
IASME / WSEAS Inernational.Conference Agios Nikolaos, Crete Island, Greece, July 24-26,
2007, WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on Energy, Environment, Ecosystems And Sustainable
Development (EEESD'07), paper 562-079