11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted?

Explained With Judgments

Subscribe Premium LOGIN

TOP STORIES NEWS UPDATES COLUMNS INTERVIEWS ENVIRONMENT RTI

KNOW THE LAW VIDEOS SPONSORED ROUND UPS PODCAST LAW EXAMS

JOB UPDATES BOOK REVIEWS EVENTS CORNER LAW FIRMS SC JUDGMENTS लाइव लॉ हिंदी LAW SCHOOLS IBC TAX A

 Search... 

Home / Know the Law / When Can A Citizen's...

KNOW THE LAW

When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel

Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With
Judgments
Sofi Ahsan 19 Oct 2022 2:55 PM

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 1/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

Source: Sana Irshad Mattoo/Instagram 

The Pulitzer-winning photojournalist Sana Irshad Mattoo on Tuesday said she

was again stopped from travelling to New York. She was on her way to the

US to receive the international award when she was stopped by the

immigration authorities at New Delhi's Indira Gandhi International Airport. In

a tweet, she said she was holding a valid US visa and travel ticket.

The 28-year-old was also stopped from travelling to the US in July. Since

2019, the right to travel abroad of a number of Kashmiri journalists including

Aakash Hassan, Gowhar Geelani has been restricted by the government. In

March this year, journalist Rana Ayyub was also stopped by the immigration

authorities and prevented from boarding a flight to London. Chair of Board at

Amnesty International India, Aakar Patel too was stopped from leaving India

at Bangalore airport in April.

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 2/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

Also Read - Explained | UAPA Prosecution Sanction, Process and

Interpretations

While Ayyub and Patel's right to travel was restricted purportedly in

connection with the pending cases against them and they subsequently got

relief from the courts in Delhi, it is not clear whether Mattoo has any pending

FIR against her.

Live Law explains the guidelines which govern the issuance of Look Out

Circulars, that are employed to prevent a person from travelling abroad, and

decisions of various courts in this regard.

Also Read - Explained| Kerala Human Sacrifice : Which States Have Laws

Against Superstitions & Black Magic?

Article 21

The right to travel is a part of personal liberty under Article 21 of the

constitution. The Supreme Court in April 2019 said, "The right to travel

abroad is an important basic human right for it nourishes independent and

self-determining creative character of the individual, not only by extending his

freedoms of action, but also by extending the scope of his experience."

However, as is well settled, even fundamental rights can be restricted

"according to the procedure established by law".

Also Read - Explained | Nayanthara-Vignesh Shivan Controversy: What

Does Surrogacy (Regulation) Act Say?

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 3/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

The Passport Act and Lookout Circulars (LOCs)

The 1967 Act provides for issuance of passports and travel documents.

Under Section 10A of the Act, the passport or travel documents can be

suspended in certain cases by the central government "in the interests of the

sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of India, friendly relations of

India with any foreign country, or in the interests of the general public". The

departure of a person can be prevented by an imigration authority on

receiving intimation from the designated authority or central government.

Also Read - Delayed Institution Of Police Report Does Not Threaten

Assumption Of Cognizance U/S 468 CrPC: Punjab & Haryana High Court

The Centre in 1979 issued guidelines for issuance of look out circulars in

respect of the arrival and departure of people whose travel the investigating

agencies want restricted or banned. The guidelines were amended in 2010 in

pursuance of Delhi High Court's judgements in Vikram Sharma vs Union of

India and Sumer Singh Salkan versus Asstt. Director & Ors. While there have

been many modifications in the guidelines since then, they were reviewed

last in February 2021 by the Ministry of Home Affairs.

An LOC against a person is opened by the Bureau Of Immigration (BoI) after

receiving a request from the competent authority, who are senior officers in

the central government or law enforcement agencies. A district magistrate or

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 4/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

a superintendent of the police can also get an LOC issued. The criminal

courts can also order issuance of LOC. The legal liability of the action taken

by immigration authorities in pursuance of the LOC rests with the originating

agency, as per the guidelines.

"Recourse to LOC is to be taken in cognizable offences under IPC or

other penal laws. The details … in the enclosed Proforma regarding

'reason for opening LOC' must invariably be provided without which the

subject of an LOC will not be arrested/detained".

The guidelines make it clear that in cases where there is no cognizable

offence under IPC and other penal laws, the LOC subject cannot be detained

or arrested or prevented from leaving the country. In such cases, the

originating agency can only request that they be informed about the arrival or

departure of the subject.

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 5/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

However, the guidelines also state that LOCs can be issued and departure

can be declined even in such cases which may not be covered under the

guidelines, if departure of such person is considered "detrimental to the

sovereignty or security or integrity of India or that the same is detrimental to

the bilateral relations with any country or to the strategic and/or economic

interests of India or if such person is allowed to leave, he may potentially

indulge in an act of terrorism, or offences against the State and/or that such

departure ought not be permitted in the larger public interest at any given

point of time."

Free shipping on all orders

GIVA Jewellery

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 6/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

Till subsistence of the LOC, the immigration authorities are bound to stop the

persons against whom it has been issued. "The LOC opened shall remain in

force until and unless a deletion request is received by BoI from the

Originator Itself," as per the guidelines.

The Originator is required keep reviewing the LoCs on quarterly and annual

basis and thereafter immediately submit any proposal for deletion to the BoI.

Courts on LOCs

In its decision on a petition challenging the LOC issued against a person

whose family members are accused in a case being probed by the Central

Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement Directorate, the Delhi High Court on

July 4 said, "unless a citizen is suspected to be involved in the commission or

facing investigation or trial on the accusation of offences which are

cognizable under the Indian Penal Code or other Statutes, the citizen can

neither be detained, arrested or prevented from leaving the country and the

originating agency can only seek intimation of his arrival and/or departure."

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 7/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

Justice Mukta Gupta in the order observed that when it comes to 'LOC of

intimation', the authorities at the airport or any other port of departure or

arrival "cannot restrain or detain the person on the pretext that intimation of

his arrival or departure is required to be given to the originating agency which

would indirectly serve as a detentive/ preventive LOC."

The court made the observations after interpreting the guidelines or Office

Memorandum dated 27th October, 2010 of the MHA. However, the OM issued

in February 2021 makes it clear that departure of a person from India can be

declined in exceptional cases, even in absence of FIR.

Punjab and Haryana High Court on April 5 said the guidelines do not provide

for supply of the LOC to the person against whom it has been issued. The

non-supply of reasons for issuing LOC , and absence of a post decisional

hearing to the subject of the LOC, is not just, fair and reasonable procedure,

said the court, while holding it to be violative of Article 21 of the Constitution

of India.

"It may be that before issuing the LOC the respondent [authorities] may not

wish to issue a prior notice to the subject of the LOC like the petitioner

because there is every possibility that, after receiving such notice, the subject

may clandestinely leave the country," said the court.

However, it further said: "But we see no impediment to give a post decisional

opportunity to the petitioner by supplying to the subject of LOC, the copy of

the LOC, and the reasons for issuing it so that the subject of the LOC can

take legal recourse to challenge it."

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 8/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

The Karnataka High Court in a judgement passed on August 24 said the

statutory sanction for issuance of LOC can be traced to Section 10A and 10B

of the Passports Act. The object for issuance of LOC is to ensure that the

subject of LOC becomes available for interrogation, trial or any inquiry, it said.

The court rejected a contention that a notice ought to be issued to the

subject of the LOC prior to issuance of LOC. However, it added: "At the time

when he is stopped and handed over to the originator, he is, in the considered

view of this Court, entitled to know why his travel is being stopped with a

copy of the LOC handed over to his hands".

On January 12, Justice Rekha Palli of Delhi High Court rejected the Centre's

argument that a writ court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India

should not review the decision to issue LOC. "In fact, in case it is found that

the decision of the authorities is without application of mind to the relevant

factors, the Court can, and in fact, should come to the rescue of the

individual," said the court

The court also said, "the issuance of a LOC is an extremely severe step and

when purportedly issued in exceptional circumstances, on the ground of the

departure of the person being 'detrimental to the economic interests of India',

the authorities must tread with caution. Once this Clause itself is meant to be

used in exceptional circumstances, it cannot be permitted to be used in such

a mechanical manner, as in the present case".

Relying on Delhi High Court's 2010 decision in Sumer Singh Salkan versus

Asstt. Director & Ors, the Karnataka High Court on August 29 in 2019, said:
"recourse to lookout notice can be taken by the investigating agency in

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 9/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

cognizable offences under IPC or the other penal laws, where the accused

was deliberately evading arrest or not appearing in the trial court despite

NBWs and other coercive measures and there was likelihood of the accused

leaving the country to evade trial/ investigation."

Quashing the LOC against journalist Rana Ayyub, the Delhi High Court on

April 4 said, "The impugned LOC is accordingly liable to be set aside as being

devoid of merits as well as for infringing the human right of the Petitioner to

travel abroad and to exercise her freedom of speech and expression".

In Aakar Patel's case where the LOC was issued by CBI, the Special Judge

(PC Act) on April 16 said, "In the scheme of CBI Crime Manual, provision and

procedure for LOC is introduced to deal with absconders. It is with respect to

the absconding accused that when suspicion arises that the absconding

accused may flee from the country, LOC can be issued to thwart any such

attempt. So a wanted accused, absconding to join investigation is the pre-

condition for issuance of LOC during investigation."

The court in that order also said that investigation has been complete in the

case against him and the matter is at the stage of consideration of the

charge-sheet by the trial court for cognizance. "Once the matter is in the

Court, circumstances warranting opening of LOC will arise only when the

respondent accused does not appear in the Trial Court despite NBWs and

other coercive measures," said the Special Judge.

The trial court order has been challenged by the CBI before Delhi High Court.

Issuing notice on CBI's plea, the high court on May 13 said the trial court

observations will not come in the way of implementation of the guidelines

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 10/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

issued by MHA last year. CBI in its petition has called the issuance of LOC a

"lesser form of coercive measure" to ensure that an accused is available to

the face the process of law. The agency has also argued that it draws the

power to issue an LOC from the CBI manual.

Agreeing with an argument that the Office Memorandum on LOCs cannot be

described as "law", Justice Rajiv Shakdher in 2015 said, "This submission, I

must confess, has much merit in view of the decisions of the Supreme Court

both in Maneka Gandhi case as well as in the case of A.K. Gopalan. Both

judgements take the view that "law" referred to in Article 21, would mean

"enacted law"."

TAGS RIGHT TO TRAVEL ABROAD LOOK OUT CIRCULARS INTERPRETATION

FOREIGNERS REGISTRATION OFFICE IMMIGRATION DELHI HIGH COURT

PUNJAB AND HARYANA COURT KARNATAKA HIGH COURT HIGH COURT

SUPREME COURT

Subscribe to LiveLaw, enjoy Ad free version and other unlimited features,

just INR 899 Click here to Subscribe. All payment options available.

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 11/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

loading....

SIMILAR + VIEW MORE

POSTS

Explained | UAPA Explained| Kerala Human Explained | Nayanthara-

Prosecution Sanction, Sacrifice : Which States Vignesh Shivan
Process and Have Laws Against Controversy: What Does
Interpretations Superstitions & Black Surrogacy (Regulation)
Magic? Act Say?
16 Oct 2022 7:12 AM 12 Oct 2022 6:45 PM 11 Oct 2022 4:16 PM

Foreign Direct
Delayed Institution Of Investment In
Police Report Does Not India: Law And
S. 313 CrPC - All Adverse
Threaten Assumption Of Procedure
Evidences Should Be Put As
Cognizance U/S 468 Questions; Avoid Bundling
CrPC: Punjab & Haryana Circumstances Together With
High Court Only Single Opportunity To

29 Aug 2022

Explain : Supreme Court
1 Sept 2022 8:27 AM 8:42 AM 4 Aug 2022 4:53 PM

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 12/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

Difference Between "Per

Different Courts Can Retweeting, Sharing
Incurium" & "Sub
Different Orders On Use Or Forwarding Offensive
Silentio" -Explainer
Of Nets In "Mosquito Posts Attract Criminal
Prone" Taloja Prison Liability? Explainer
9 July 2022 12:47 PM 6 July 2022 10:10 AM 3 July 2022 8:21 AM

What Is A "Floor Test"? Roe v. Wade Overruled : Explainer : How The

Explained With What Does Indian Law President Of India Is
Important Supreme Say On Abortion? Elected?
Court Judgments
29 June 2022 7:46 AM 25 June 2022 10:44 AM 21 June 2022 5:07 PM

JUST ENTER YOUR EMAIL FOR THE

LIVELAW DAILY NEWS BRIEFING BY
EMAIL ALL THE DAY"S HEADLINES AND
HIGHLIGHTS FROM LIVELAW, DIRECT
TO YOU EVERY MORNING

NEWSLETTERS
DIRECTLY IN YOUR MAILBOX

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 13/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

Enter Your Email

Submit

+ MORE
LAW FIRMS

The Seat Or The Assets – Where Do You Enforce The Award?

+ MORE
LATEST NEWS

1 J&K&L High Court Refuses To Quash FIR Against Kashmir Walla Editors

2 Union Law Minister Kiren Rijiju Criticises Lawyers' Protests; Says Not
Good To Question Every Collegium Decision Which Has Govt Support

3 Alleged Remarks Against UP CM | Allahabad HC Refuses To Quash FIR

Against Samajwadi Party Leader Anurag Bhadouria

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 14/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

4 Bombay HC Seeks State's Response On PIL Seeking Mandatory Charging

Infrastructure For Electric Vehicles in Housing Societies

5 Kerala HC Deprecates Invocation Of Writ Jurisdiction Alleging 'Breach Of

Duty' By Police To Register Complaint When The Dispute Is Civil In Nature

6 FIR Registered In 1990 ; Trial Not Complete Even After Three Decades : SC
Directs Kolkata Court To Complete Trial Within 6 Months

7 Madras High Court Restrains Over 12K Websites From Illegally

Broadcasting FIFA World Cup 2022

8 Former CJI U U Lalit To Join NUJS Kolkata As Visting Professor

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 15/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

लाइव लॉ हिंदी + MORE

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 16/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

पूर्व मुख्य न्यायाधीश यू यू ललित NUJS कोलकाता के विजिटिंग प्रोफे सर के तौर पर ज्वाइन करें गे

' निजी मेडिकल कॉलेजों का छात्रों से बॉन्ड मांगना परे शान करने वाला' : सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने छात्र को
पांच लाख रुपये लौटाने के निर्देश की पुष्टि की

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 17/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने गौतम नवलखा की हाउस अरे स्ट की अनुमति देने वाले आदेश को वापस लेने से
इनकार किया, NIA को 24 घंटे में इसे निष्पादित करने का निर्देश दिया

जस्टिस एमआर शाह की खंडपीठ के समक्ष छत्तीसगढ़ एनएएन घोटाला मामले की लिस्टिंग से
विवाद खड़ा हुआ

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 18/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

'इसमें कोर्ट का कोई दखल नहीं'- सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने दो बच्चों के मानदंड और देश भर में जनसंख्या
नियंत्रण नीति को लागू करने की मांग वाली याचिका पर सुनवाई से इनकार किया

+ MORE
INTERNATIONAL

1 Banning Conditional Sentences For Certain Offences Is Constitutional:

Canada Supreme Court Holds In 5:4 Majority

2 Canada Supreme Court Says Mandatory And Lifetime Registration On Sex

Offender Registry Unconstitutional

3 Indian-American Attorney Arun Subramanian Nominated As US District

Judge In New York By President Joe Biden

4 Ketanji Brown Jackson Sworn In As US Supreme Court Justice- First Black

Woman In Court's History

ENVIRONMENT + MORE

1 Supreme Court Dismisses Plea Against ₹64 Lakh Penalty On Municipal

Body For Dumping Solid Waste In Wular Lake

2 NGT Should Test Bonafides & Credentials Of Applicants Before Passing

Orders Having Far Reaching Effect: Supreme Court

3 'Lack Of Good Governance': NGT Slaps ₹35 Cr Penalty On J&K Admin For
Doodh Ganga Pollution

4 Grant Of Ex Post Facto Environmental Clearance Permissible In

Exceptional Circumstances : Surpeme Court

JOB UPDATES

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 19/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

1. Chief Manager (Administration) & Secretary Vacancy At Jawaharlal Nehru Port

Authority

2. Business Analyst Vacancy At Centre For Management Development, Kerala

3. Assistant General Manager (Law) Vacancy At NMDC Limited

4. Legal Associate Vacancy At Meharia And Company (MCO Legals) [Apply Now]

5. Legal Officer Vacancy At National Institute Of Rural Development And Panchayati

Raj

+ VIEW MORE

TOP STORIES KNOW THE LAW

NEWS UPDATE LAW FIRMS

COLUMNS JOB UPDATES

INTERVIEWS BOOK REVIEWS

INTERNATIONAL EVENTS CORNER

RTI UPDATES COVER STORY

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 20/21
11/19/22, 5:35 PM When Can A Citizen's Right To Travel Abroad Be Restricted? Explained With Judgments

EDITOR'S PICK PLACEMENTS

LAW SCHOOL CORNER SCHOLARSHIPS

ARTICLES SEMINARS

CALL FOR PAPERS ENVIRONMENT

COMPETITIONS BOOK REVIEWS

INTERNSHIPS

2022 © All Rights Reserved @LiveLaw

Powered By Hocalwire

Who We Are Careers Advertise With Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms And Conditions



X
Live Law subscriptions starting ₹ 899 +GST

Subscribe to Live Law now and get unlimited access.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Already have an account? Sign In

https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/explained-right-to-travel-vs-look-out-circulars-212072 21/21