Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chemical Peeling: How, When, Why?: I. Ghersetich A, P. Teofoll, M. Gantcheva B, M. Ribuffo, P. Puddu '
Chemical Peeling: How, When, Why?: I. Ghersetich A, P. Teofoll, M. Gantcheva B, M. Ribuffo, P. Puddu '
Abstract
General description Chemical peeling is a procedure frequently used to treat unaesthetic cutaneous
alterations such as photoageing, actinic keratosis, chloasma,senile lentigo, and post-acneicscarsas well those of
a non-strictly aesthetic nature such as seborrhoeic keratosis and flat warts. Several chemical agents are used
depending on the depth of peeling to be obtained. The most commonly used agents are: alpha-hydroxy-acids,
resorcinol, Jessner’ssolution, and trichloroacetic acid. In the present study the characteristicsof the individual
substances,technical procedure, and applications are taken into consideration. Finally, the main risks and
side-effects,depending on the depth of peeling, are considered.
Learning objective The reader will have learned what a chemical peeling is, what chemical agents are
available, and how to perform chemical peeling in the office. The mechanism of action of different chemical
agents, expectations from this procedure, potential risks and complications are also reviewed with insight into
criteria for selecting patients.
0926-9959/97/$17.00 Copyright 0 1997 Published by Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
PII SO926-9959(96)00107-9
2 I. Ghersetich et al. /J. Eur. Acad. Dermutol. Venereal. 8 (1997) I-l 1
mediators of inflammation may induce new colla- which act at more superficial levels, the alpha-hy-
gen synthesis and extracellular matrix deposition droxy-acids seemto act at the lowest stratumcomeum
in the dermis. [3-61.
The alpha-hydroxy-acids are used in dermatology
to treat numerous clinical conditions, such as cuta-
2. Classification of chemical peeling agents neous xerosis, ichthyosis, seborrhoeic keratosis, ac-
tinic keratosis, warts, and acne [3]. The excellent
Chemical peeling is generally classified according results achieved with alpha-hydroxy-acids imply that
to the depth obtained by exfoliation [l], which is their mechanism of action goes beyond mere cohe-
usually related to the chemical agent used, its con- sion reduction of the keratinized cells, and they
centration, and the duration of application. presumably play a fundamental role in the healing
Table 1 shows the most used classification of processand preventing cutaneousageing.
main chemical peeling agents [2]. It is obvious that Recent studies have demonstratedincreased epi-
the deeperthe wound, the better the results obtained, dermal thickness and a greater amount of hyaluronic
but with a higher risk of side-effectsand the need for acids in the dermis following treatment with alpha-
increasedprecautions to be taken. hydroxy-acids [7-91.
A clinical (histological and ultrastructural) pilot
study on the effects of alpha-hydroxy-acids on pho-
3. Alpha-hydroxy-acid peel toageing has documented an increase of epidermal
and dermal thickness, increasesin mucopolysaccha-
The alpha-hydroxy-acids (AHAs) are a group of ride acids and collagen density, and an improvement
organic acids of vegetable derivation representedby in the quality of elastic fibres after 6-months of
glycolic acid (which is surely the most common) application with a lotion containing a mixture of
citric acid, lactic acid, malic acid, and pyruvic acid. 25% alpha-hydrox-acids [lo].
Different from other substanceswith a keratolytic An in vivo preliminary study by our group showed
effect, such as salicylic acid, urea, and lithium salts an increase in epidermal Langerhans cells in 3 pa-
tients who underwent 1 month treatment with gly-
colic acid (peeling with 70% concentration weekly,
Table 1 and done at home, daily therapy with a 10% concen-
Classification of chemical peeling agents tration lotion) (Fig. 1) [11,12].
Very superficial (stratum granulosum) Interestingly, all these effects occurred without
30-50% glycolic acid (or other alpha-hydroxy-acids any real inflammatory effects. This supports the
with comparableeffect) hypothesis that the mechanism of action of the al-
Jessner’ssolution (l-3 coats)
Resorcinol at low concentration(20-30%), pha-hydroxy-acids and their related substancesis a
apphed only for a few minutes specific direct effect on the skin which goes beyond
the irritating effect.
Superficial (down to the papillary derma)
Glycolic acid (50-70%)
Jessner’ssolution (4-10 coats)
Resorcinol(40-50%, applied for 60 min) 4. Glycolic acid peel
TCA (10% to 30%)
Medium depth (down to the superficial reticular derma) 4.1. General characteristics of glycolic acid
Glycolic acid 70% (application varying from 3 to 30 min)
TCA (35-70%) Formula 70% glycolic acid solution (Glypure-
Combined peeling (TCA 35% + CO,, DuPont). The solutions are formulated with water, or
Jessner’ssolution+ TCA 35%,
glycolic acid 70% + TCA 35%) combinations of water, alcohol and propylene glycol.
Stability Non-sensible to light. Very stable (more
Deep (down to the to the medium reticular dermis) than 2 years). Easy evaporation (the bottle must be
Baker and Gordon’s phenol formula
kept well closed).
I. Ghersetich et al. /J. Eur. Acad. Dermatol. Venereol. 8 (1997) 1-11
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 1. Increased CDla+ cells in the epidermis after glycolic acid tre:atment.
Physical characteristics Clear and transparentso- ception of effervescencedue to the releaseof carbo-
lution; may be produced in gel by the addition of a nium dioxide acid that terminates only at the end of
gelling agent (the gel may appearyellow-coloured or neutralization.
turbid).
4.4. Post-peel care
4.2. Skin preparation for peeling
Following peeling, it is recommended that no
Before using any exfoliating agent for chemical cream containing alpha-hydroxy-acids be used for 2
peeling, a 2-week preparation is necessaryinvolving or 3 days. If the patient does not show any sign of
application of cream containing retinoic acid and/or irritation, erythema or abrasion, no specific post-peel
alpha-hydroxy-acids associated with a cutaneous care is necessary.
bleaching agent, depending on the type of skin and Two or 3 days application of topical non-
the specific problem of the patient. halogenated steroids should be prescribed for sub-
jects presenting significant erythema [13]. In the
4.3. Degreasing event of an overpeel phenomenon with abrasions,
application of an antibiotic cream for at least 1 week
Degreasing is effected with alcohol or acetone is necessary.
and allows a deeperand more homogeneouspenetra-
tion of the exfoliating agent.
5. Resorcinol peel
4.4. Application Resorcinol (m-dihydroxybenzene), structurally
and chemically related to phenol, soluble in water,
The application of the acid may be performed alcohol, and ether, acts as a potent reducing agent. In
with a special brush, a Q-tip or a gauze. Once the fact, it is able to break the weak bonds of the keratin
acid has been applied to the whole area to be treated, to the hydrogen [14]. In some casescontact allergy
it is necessaryto wait for the patient’s reaction to see has been observed 1151.This substance is used in
if there is erythema or “frosting”. The latter may creamy formulations at concentrations ranging from
occur with glycolic acid peel as a spotted-like pattern 10 to 30% basedon Unna’s 18th century formulation
indicating epidermolysis which consists of detach- later modified by Letessier [ 161.
ment of the epidermis from the papillary dermis [13]. Currently the formula most used is:
Generally, glycolic acid peeling is done to obtain
slight exfoliation without side-effects to make the Resorcinol 40 g
skin smoother. Therefore, the acid must be immedi- Zinc oxide 10 g
ately neutralized if frosting occurs [ 131.The duration Benzoated sugna 28 g
of application is extremely variable from patient to Kaolin 2g
patient and is unpredictable. It is advisable to ob-
serve the patient carefully during application and to Normally this cream is applied with a spatula on the
establish the duration of application according to area to be treated and left there for 60- 120 min.
personal experience. Following this application the patient shows a
reaction similar to a first-degree bum with further
4.5. Neutralization exfoliation which generally continues for 1 week to
10 days. The post-peel care foresees the use of
It is extremely important to neutralize the acid in antibiotic creams and corticosteroids for about 1
order to avoid the “overpeel” phenomenon due to week and l-month complete protection against UV
too deep penetration [ 131. radiation. This type of peeling is quite easy to man-
The neutralizing process is achieved with any age and has a low risk of side-effects,mainly tempo-
alkaline solution; generally a solution of sodium rary hyperpigmentation. Resorcinol peel is especially
bicarbonate (815%) is used, which allows the per- recommendedin patients with acne, including come-
I. Ghersetich et al. /J. Eur. Acad. Dermatol. Venereol. 8 (1997) I-l 1 5
donic acne, with good success in the clearing of 7. Trichloroacetic acid (TCA) peel
pigmented lesions and very superficial scars.
The most efficient peeling method for wrinkles
and scars is definitely the TCA peel. It can be
applied at different concentrations and therefore can
6. Jessner’s solution peel be used to cause peeling at different depths. In all
casesthe peeling is easy to control and predictable,
In addition to the creamy formulation of resorci- although the risk of scarring seems to be more
no1there is also a liquid formulation called “Jessner’s frequent only for concentrations over 40%.
solution” [ 171. Histological and ultrastructural studies have
Formulation of Jessner’s solution demonstrated that TCA peeling is able to reduce
Salicylic acid 14 g some typical aspects of photoageing (Fig. 3) by
Resorcinol 14 g inducing renovation of epidermal polarity, reduction
Lactic acid (85%) 14 g of epidermal intracytoplasmic bodies, increase in
Ethanol up to 1OOml fibroblasts, increasein collagen type I deposit, reduc-
Stability Light- and air-sensible; must be stored in tion of elastic fibres [ 191.Generally, these effects are
a dark-coloured container. Can be kept for up to 2 visible 1 month after peeling [20].
years. The indications for TCA peeling are above all
Physical characteristics Slightly amber-coloured photoageing.with sun elastosis, slight wrinkles, and
clear solution, which becomes darker with age and actinic keratosis. Deep and perioral wrinkles respond
exposure to light. only moderately to this treatment. Other indications
Jessner’s solution peel rarely causes “overpeel” include pigmentary changes (lentigo simplex,
and therefore the risk of complications is very low melasma or post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation).
[18]. The main disadvantagesare related to the great Although precautions must be taken, the results are
variability of manufacturing since the formula con- variable and the possibility of worsening has to be
tains 3 active substances,to possible intense exfolia- considered. TCA peeling, at concentrations ranging
tion which is sometimesburdensomefor the patient, from 35 to 50% [21], gives excellent results in
and to an intense burning sensation,generally greater post-acneic scars, especially in cases of moderate
than with glycolic acid [ 181. scarring (Fig. 2). In the literature, there are reports
The application technique is similar to that of that also acne rosacea, seborrhoeic dermatitis and
glycolic acid, but the effect on the skin is different. dilated pores can be treated with TCA, but in our
During the first phaseerythema will appearfollowed experience the results are not satisfactory.
by a dust-like white “powder” all over the skin
which, however, is not comparableto “frosting” but 7.1. TCA peeling technique
is only due to precipitation onto the skin of the
chemical compounds in the solution. This “whiten- 7.1.1. General characteristics of trichloroacetic acid
ing” is easily removed with water or simply by Formula Crystal trichloroacetic acid at 20-50%,
rubbing with a finger. in water solution.
During the following days exfoliation occurs, sim- Stability Not light-sensible. No refrigeration nec-
ilar to that produced with the creamy resorcinol peel, essary. Stable for at least 23 weeks.
and lasts for 8-10 days; post-peel care is similar to Physical characteristics Clear and transparent.
that used with the creamy formulation. Jessner’s Without precipitates.
solution is best for dyschromic changes and all the
other indications referring to alpha-hydroxy-acids. 7.1.2. Preparation of the skin for peeling
Although Jessner’s solution peel has the advantage Skin priming is particularly important in TCA
of producing more uniform peeling, it is less ac- peeling. Priming is necessaryto allow more uniform
cepted by patients because it induces more evident penetration of the exfoliating agent, to reduce the
exfoliation [ 181. re-epithelization phase, to minimize the risk of post-
1. Ghersetich et al. /J. Eur. Acad. Dennatol. Venereal. 8 (1997) l-l 1
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 3. Lentigo senilis in a photo-aged skin.
area to be treated, allowing the substanceto pene- radiation for 4-5 months. For 2 or 3 weeks after
trate for a few seconds,and then a second applica- exfoliation the skin may maintain a pinkish colour;
tion is made, followed by another one until frosting in such casesa light corticosteroid or a cream con-
appears (whitening due to the coagulation of the taining zinc oxide may hasten the return of normal
protein in the epidermis), indicating that the acid has skin colouring.
penetrateddown to the papillary dermis (Fig. 4) [23].
At this point the process is stopped by sprinkling
water at room temperature on the treated area. It is 8. Phenol peel
not necessaryto neutralize TCA and its dilution is
sufficient to limit and terminate the effect [23]. The phenol peel, using the Baker-Gordon for-
The following aspects must be considered when mula, is the deepest peeling method; the peeling
performing a TCA peel. agent penetrates down through the reticular derma
1. Peeling is painful; generally the discomfort lasts [24,25]. Since the chemical agent may be absorbed
only until dilution of the acid. Treatment takes and could cause cardiac, hepatic or renal toxicity as
about lo-15 min and is well tolerated by most well as other local and systemic side-effects,peeling
patients. If necessary,in some particularly sensi- must be performed only in an operating theatre with
tive patients EMLA pre-anaesthesiacan be done. the assistanceof an anaesthetistto monitor eventual
However, one must consider that local anaesthet- cardiac arrhythmia [26].
its cause vasoconstriction, thus increasing the
depth of peeling. ‘Therefore,when anaesthesiais
required, one should consider using a lower TCA
concentration. In any case, for particularly sensi- 9. Complications of chemical peeling
tive patients a sedative or a systematically admin-
istered analgesic is recommended. Obviously, the deeper the peeling, the greater the
2. Several TCA coats obtain an increasein the depth possibility of complications. The most frequent com-
of peeling; therefore, if higher concentrations plications are:
(50%) are used, only 1 or 2 coats are advisable.
3. When the patient requires treatment of a limited 9.1. Pigmentary modifcations
area, we recommend performing light peeling all
over the face in order to avoid dyschromia. It is possible to see a difference in colour with
evident boundary lines between the exfoliated and
7.1.5. Post-peeling care the non-treated area. Generally, this inconvenience is
The immediate postoperative treatment foresees temporary, and within l-2 months uniform colour-
the use of an antibiotic, sometimesassociatedwith a ing will be observed.
hydrogel dressing. Patients should be warned to ex- The most feared complication following chemical
pect various modifications, in particular: peeling is hyperpigmentation [27]. Quite often this is
1. itching sensations, due to even minimal sun exposure, although some-
2. marked hyperpigmentation possibly associated times it may depend on other factors. In the latter
with oedema,and that case there is a major risk in dark-skinned people
3. exfoliation is never the sameall over the face but [28]. According to Fitzpatrick, peeling is imprudent
generally starts at the periorbital and perioral in any seasonand in any subject with phototype V.
(more movable) area and ends at the forehead. It Hyperpigmentation can be treated with any bleach-
is important in this phase not to remove the skin ing agent with generally good results; sometimesit
to avoid post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. disappears spontaneously after some months. It is
Generally, in the days following treatment it is more difficult to treat hypopigmentation due to de-
sufficient to avoid the use of soapsand detergents,to struction of melanocytes[29]; this may be permanent
apply an antibiotic cream twice a day and to use total and can occur with potent peeling with a 50% TCA
sun block. The patient is recommendedto avoid UV or phenol.
8 1. Ghersetich et al./ J. Eur. Acad. Dermatol. Venereol. 8 (1997) l-11
9.2. Infections chemical peeling [33]. The major risks are in patients
subjectedto deeperpeeling (which may occur due to
Infection associated with peeling is rare. Nor- the performance of superficial peels), in subjects
mally, the frequency of this type of complication with keloids or hypertrophic scars, in patients who
increases with the depth of peeling and is more have undergone recent Accutane therapy, and in
pronounced when crusting occurs [30]. The most patients with infections or allergic post-peeling reac-
common pathogensare Streptococcusand Staphylo- tions [32].
coccus; infection due to Pseudomonasis much rarer. Different scarring reactions may result: flat, hy-
An herpes simplex infection may be reactivated by popigmented, depressed atrophic areas, and thick-
peeling at any depth [31]. A suitable local and/or ened, elevated areas and keloids. Scar treatment
systemic antibiotic therapy should be administered differs according to the type of scar and may require
quickly to treat bacterial infection. the use of intralesional steroids, silastic plasters,
laser therapy, and cryotherapy, including excision
9.3. Acne-like eruptions and revision of the scar.
medium depth chemical facial peels on dermal collagen in skin: a variation of superficial chemosurgery. J Dermatology
patients with actinically damaged skin. J Am Acad Dermatol Surg Oncol 1986;12:1268-1275.
1995;32:472-478. [28] Pierce HE, Brown LA. Laminar dermal reticulotomy and
[20] Roenigk RK, Brodland DG. A primer of facial chemical peel. chemical face peeling in the Black patient. J. Dermatol Surg
Dermatol Clin 1993;11:349-359. Oncol 1986;12:69-73.
[21] Resnik SS. Chemical peeling with trichloroacetic. In: Roenigk [29] Brody HJ. Complications of chemical peeling. J Dermatol
RK, Roenigk HH, eds. Dermatologic surgery: principles and Surg Oncol 1989;15:1010-1019.
practice. New York Marcel Dekker Inc., 1989;979. [30] Collins PS. The chemical peel. Clin Dermatol 1987;5:57-74.
[22] Resnik SS. Chemical peeling with trichloroacetic acid. J [31] Rapaport MJ, Kamar F. Exacerbation of facial herpes simlex
Dermatol Surg Oncol 1966;10:549-550. after phenolic face peels. J Dermatol Surg Oncol
[23] MG. Trichloroacetic acid peels. In: Manual of chemical 1984;10:57-58.
peels. Philadelphia: JB Lippincott Company, 1995;110-126. [32] Rubin MG. Complications. In: Manual of chemical peels.
[24] Baker TJ, Gordon HL. The ablation of rhytids by chemical Philadelphia: JB Lippincott Company, 1995;130- 153.
means in a preliminary report. J Fla Med Assoc 1961;48:45 1. [33] Litton C, Trinidad G. Complications of chemical face peeling
[25] Mackee GM, Karp FL. The treatment of post-acne scars with as evaluated by a questionnaire. Plast Reconstr Surg
phenol. Br J Dermatol 1952;64:456-459. 1981;67:738-744.
[26] Ashen S. Unoccluded Baker/Gordon chemical peel: review [34] Bridenstine JB, Dolezal JF. Standardizing chemical peel
and update. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 1989;15:998-1008. solution formulations to avoid mishaps. J Dermatol Surg
[27] Brody HJ, Haley CW. Medium depth chemical peeling of the Oncol 1994,20:813-816.