Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development of Corn (Zea Mays L.) Stalk Geotextile Net For Soil Erosion Mitigation
Development of Corn (Zea Mays L.) Stalk Geotextile Net For Soil Erosion Mitigation
for dew, water, chemical (1 day after harvest and15 days after products has not received any significant consideration as
harvest), respectively, with the corresponding average extracting researches were mostly focused on the production and
duration of 70, 82, 89, and 94 minutes. Physical characterization of
utilization of synthetic geotextiles like polyolefin and
the developed corn stalk geotextile net resulted to average mass per
unit area of 806.25 g/m2 and 241% water absorbing capacity. The polyester. Natural geotextile is also known to have a short life
effect of corn stalk geotextile net in mitigating soil erosion was span, degrades easily [5], and has properties that limit its full
evaluated in a laboratory experiment for 30o and 60o inclinations with utilization.
three treatments: bare soil (A1), corn stalk geotextile net (A2) and In an age of growing environmental awareness,
combined cornstalk geotextile net and vegetation cover (A3). Results biodegradation of natural geotextile as a result of
revealed that treatment A2 and A3 significantly decreased sediment
microorganism’s activity is of great advantage. This advantage
yield and an increase in terms of soil loss reduction efficiency. The
cost of corn stalk geotextile net is Php 62.41 per square meter. leads to exploitation of different natural fiber resources which
can be used as geotextile for a specific soil erosion problem.
Keywords—Corn stalk, natural geotextile, retting, soil erosion. Expected degradation of these geotextiles eliminates the
doubling effect when combined with the vegetation. Natural
I. INTRODUCTION geotextile’s advantages are biodegradability, ability to protect
S OIL erosion is widely recognized as a major soil from splash erosion, capacity to absorb water, and aid for
environmental problem which threatens the most reduction to water loss through evaporation [5]. These are the
important and non-renewable reserve of human, the farmland. indications that natural geotextiles have an edge over synthetic
This problem is mainly initiated by the erosive forces like geotextile for slope stability application. In this premise,
farm tillage, wind and water resulting to removal of top soil. investigation of other potential natural fiber resources such as
Eroding of soil is dominantly triggered by intense rainfall and fiber from corn stalks can be done to reduce agro-wastes left
high velocity runoff to cultivated and steep areas. This on the field which can significantly reduce soil erosion when
condition causes great destruction not only to soil properly converted to geotextile net.
characteristics but also to its properties and fertility affecting A. Statement of the Problem
numerous numbers of individuals. Corn ranks second next to rice as the most important grain
In the Philippines, about 45% of the country’s arable land crop in the country. The volume of production of corn in the
suffers from moderate to severe soil erosion [1]. Reference [2] country for the year of 2014 has an output level of 7.75
cited that an estimate of 623 MT of soil is lost annually from million MT which is 5.1% above the 2013 output and is
28 million hectares of cultivated land in the country. Without expected to rise up to 2.56 million hectares in 2015.
immediate and appropriate protection, there will be severe soil The province of Pangasinan has a total land area of 536,818
loss that may lead to difficulty in establishing vegetation and hectares, which represents almost 50% of the total area of the
possibly increase in sediment input to nearby rivers [3]. entire Region 1 and constitutes to about 1.8% of the total land
Hydroseeding, on the other hand, is a technique used to area of the country. Report from [6] showed that Pangasinan
establish vegetation cover that can provide long-term has a total corn production of 289,607 MT for the cropping
protection against soil erosion. However, growth of vegetation year 2012-2013 with an average yield of 5.63 tons/ha within
is difficult during early stage since seeds or seedlings might be the harvest area of 51,430 ha.
washed away by the erosive forces of rainfall and runoff [4]. Since there is a massive production of this crop, there is
also a high biomass production. The common practice of
C. S. Decano, V. U. Malamug, M. E. Agulto and H. F. Gavino are with farmers is to leave the residues in the field and some are burnt
Department of Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering, College of
Engineering, Central Luzon State University, Nueva Ecija, Philippines (e- which causes pollution. Corn residues are also left by the
mail: datz.tina@yahoo.com). farmers on the ground immediately after harvesting to act as
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 10(10) 2016 618 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10005527
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Fashion and Textile Engineering
Vol:10, No:10, 2016
mu
mulch materiall in conserviing soil moiisture for thee next chem mical retting (15
( days afterr stalk harvest)), T3 – dew reetting
crropping seasonn. The probleem, however, is that corn stalks, andd T4– water retting. Manual stripping wass done to sepaarate
wiithout any prior physical alteration, m may damage small fibeers.
m
machineries duuring land preeparation. Alsso dried corn stalks Production of single spline rope from corrn stalk was m
P made
whhen used as mulch can bee easily blow wn by wind and a be posssible by usingg rope makingg machine. Coornstalk geoteextile
waashed away thhrough runofff. Lastly, hugee quantities oof corn net weaving prrocess follow ws the traditiional open-w weave
staalks left in thee field to decoompose may leead to emergeence of patttern. This wass done by inteerlacing the siingle-splined fiber
diseases among crops. ropees at right anngle with eacch other mannually. Mesh size
openning used 25 mm x 25 mm m (1 in. x 1 in..). The end paart of
B. Objectives
eachh interlockingg rope was tieed with a broown yarn to avoid
a
The general oobjective of thhe study was too develop cornn stalk diseengagement off each rope.
mitigation. Speecifically, the study
geeotextile net ffor erosion m
aimmed to: B
B. Vegetation C
Cover Preparaation
1. Determine the physical properties of the developedd corn T
The experimeent employedd hydroseedding to estabblish
stalk geotexxtile net; vegetation coverr. Hydroseeding mixture ingredients w were
2. Evaluate thhe effect of deeveloped corn stalk geotexttile net careefully weigheed and thenn were mixeed together iin a
and vegettation cover in sedimennt yield, seddiment container.
International Science Index, Fashion and Textile Engineering Vol:10, No:10, 2016 waset.org/Publication/10005527
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 10(10) 2016 619 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10005527
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Fashion and Textile Engineering
Vol:10, No:10, 2016
neet and A3 - 255 mm x 25 m mm (1 in. x 1 in.) mesh size corn 22. Sediment Yiield
staalk geotextile net combinedd with hydroseeeding TThis determinees the mass off the sedimentt over its plot area
The laboratorry experimentt was arrangeed in a Randoomized withh respect to time. This is the mass oof the oven-ddried
Coomplete Blockk Design (RCBD), with thrree replicationns. The sediiment collecteed over the area of the ssoil test box and
exxperiment was analyzed seeparately for the two anggles of duraation of simullation. It was estimated by using (2) citeed in
inclinations of test boxes (30o and 60o). Comparison aamong [8].
treeatment means was done byy using Duncaan’s Multiple Range
Teest (DMRT), aat a 5% level oof significancee. Preparation of the Sm
SY== (2)
exxperimental units
u under tthe bare soill, with corn stalk tAb
geeotextile net and combined corn stalk geotextile neet and
veegetation is shhown in Fig. 2. Rainfall simuulation lasted for 60 wheere SY is sedim ment yield (g//m2.hr), Sm is m
mass of oven-ddried
m
minutes where datad were takeen at 10-minutte interval. sediiment collecteed (g), Ab is arrea of soil testt box (m2) andd t is
duraation of rain siimulation (hr))
3. Soil Loss Reeduction Efficciency
T
This determinees how well a certain geoteextile controlss soil
erossion. Computaation was in acccordance to ((3), as given inn [9],
International Science Index, Fashion and Textile Engineering Vol:10, No:10, 2016 waset.org/Publication/10005527
[10]]:
SYb ‐SYg
SLRE== (3)
SYb
1. Physical Characterizatio
C on wheere GNC is coost of corn sttalk geotextilee net (Php), T TC is
The physical properties weere limited to:: mass/unit areea and costt of harvestingg, transportingg, loading andd unloading (P Php),
waater absorptioon (WA). Techhnical specificcation of cornn stalk Ss iss cost of stalkk separation (P
Php), Rc is cosst of retting (P
Php),
geeotextile net included num mber of twines crosswise and Sc is cost of fiiber strippingg (Php), RDc is cost of rope
lenngthwise, singgle and doublee spline rope ddiameters. prodduction (Php)) and Wc iss cost of weeaving corn stalk
Mass/unit area is an impoortant propertty that can ddirectly geotextile net (Phhp).
m
measure fabric ccost. It was deetermined by w weighing sampples in The main facttor that contriibuted to the initial cost off the
T
ann accurate digiital weighing sscale. developed cornsttalk geotextilee net is the duuration of maanual
Water absorpption was com mputed throughh (2) as cited in [7]. fibeer extraction wwhich may be reduced and ccompensated w when
Neet weight reefers to the weight of ggeotextile afteer the development proccesses are fullyy mechanizedd.
prrotruding fiberrs in the rope have been rem moved and the final
weeight refers too the weight off the net after soaking.
s IIII. RESULTS A
AND DISCUSSIO
ONS
WA
Af ‐WAi
A
A. Fiber Extracction
WA= (1) F
From the diffeerent retting m
methods used iin the experim ment,
W
WAf
was determinedd dew retting (T3) had the hhighest mean fiber
it w
whhere WA is wwater absorptioon (%), WAi iss net weight (g) and yielld of 45 g fromm 300 g of drried corn stalkks or about 15%% of
W
WAf is final weiight (g) its ddry weight andd average extraction duratioon of 70 minuttes.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 10(10) 2016 620 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10005527
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Fashion and Textile Engineering
Vol:10, No:10, 2016
TAB BLE II
SEEDIMENT YIELD MEANS AT 30O SLO OPE
S
SURFACE COVE ER
RAINFALL
DURATION Bare Geeotextile Combbined geotextile
soil net net and
a vegetation
10 100.00a 622.500ab 0.00b
Fig. 3 Corn stalk geotextile net
n a ab
20 134.37 6
65.62 0.00b
a ab
30 170.83 6
62.50 0.00b
The average mass per uniit area is 8066.25 g/m2. Maass per
International Science Index, Fashion and Textile Engineering Vol:10, No:10, 2016 waset.org/Publication/10005527
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 10(10) 2016 621 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10005527
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Fashion and Textile Engineering
Vol:10, No:10, 2016
TABLE V The corn stalk geotextile nets that were developed were
SOIL LOSS REDUCTION EFFICIENCY (%) MEANS AT 60O SLOPE
effective in mitigating soil erosion at 30o and 60o slope
SURFACE COVER
RAINFALL inclination under a laboratory condition. Soil loss reduction
DURATION With Combined Geotextile
geotextile net net and vegetation efficiency ranged from 29 - 66.99% for 30o slope and 72.67 -
10 57.68b 100a 78.19% for 60o slope.
20 72.67 b
100a The cost of developing corn stalk geotextile net was placed
30 71.79b 100a at Php 62.41 per m2. A higher initial cost of the developed
40 73.34b 100a corn stalk geotextile net than the commercially available
b
50 75.34 100a geotextile nets was attributed to the cost of fiber.
b
60 78.18 100a
In a row under each rainfall duration, means followed by a common letter V. RECOMMENDATIONS
are not significantly different at 5% level by DMRT.
Results revealed that the developed corn stalk geotextile net
D. Corn Stalk Geotextile Net Cost has the potential to be used for soil erosion control. Sediment
From the assumptions and calculations, an estimate of yield and soil loss efficiency were significantly reduced when
6,246.8 kg of stovers was produced per hectare of corn compared with plots without soil covering. Other
plantation. The amount of corn stalk per hectare reached up to recommendations derived from the results of the experiments
International Science Index, Fashion and Textile Engineering Vol:10, No:10, 2016 waset.org/Publication/10005527
3,173.5 kg and 1,808.61 kg for wet and dry basis, respectively. include:
From one (1) hectare of standing corn stover, 271.83 kg of Developing and designing of decorticating and rope-
stalk fiber could be obtained and converted into corn stalk making machines specifically for corn stalks to decrease
geotextile net. Similarly, in order to produce 1 m x 1 m size the labor requirement, cost of producing geotextile net
corn stalk geotextile net with mesh opening of 2.54 cm x 2.54 and fiber extraction duration.
cm, a total of 78 m double-spline ropes are needed with an Validating the results of the laboratory experiment
equivalent weight of 806.26 g of stalk fiber. through field testing.
Cost estimation for producing corn stalk geotextile net was
determined by taking into account the following various cost: ACKNOWLEDGMENT
1. cost of harvesting of standing stovers, transporting, The author wish to thank DOST-ERDT scholarship
loading and unloading;
program for the financial assistance given to the author in
2. cost of stalk separation; pursuing higher degree program. Acknowledgment is also
3. cost of retting;
given to UPMO- Flood Control Personels for the invaluable
4. cost of fiber stripping; information and time they accorded during the utilization of
5. cost of rope production; and,
the rainfall simulator.
6. cost of weaving the corn stalk geotextile net.
The estimated cost of developing geotextile net made from REFERENCES
corn stalk fiber was placed at Php 62.41. When compared with
[1] D. Pimentel and M. Burgess, “Soil Erosion Threatens Food Production.”
commercially available geotextile net for erosion mitigation 2013.
such as coco coir geotextile net, the cost of corn stalk net is [2] E. Sombrito. “Restoration of Soil Fertility and Sustenance in
higher by 4–52% depending on the diameter of the ropes used. Agricultural Productivity”. Philippine Nuclear Research Institute. 2004.
[3] R.P. Morgan, and R. J. Rickson, “Slope Stabilization and Erosion
The additional processes involved in developing corn stalk Control: A Bioengineering Approach”. E and FN Spoon, London,
geotextile net such as stalk separation and retting, accounted United Kingdom. 2003.
for the relatively higher cost of the processed geotextile net. [4] M.M. Cereno, FG. Tan, and F.A. Uy, “Combined Hydroseeding and
Coconet Reinforcement for Soil Erosion Control, Soil Erosion Studies,”
Dr. Danilo Godone (Ed.), ISBN: 978-953-307-710-9, InTech. 2011.
IV. CONCLUSION [5] M. Calkins, “Materials for Sustainable Sites: A Complete Guide to the
Evaluation, Selection, and Use of Sustainable Construction Materials,”
Based from the results, the following conclusions were John Wiley and Sons. 2008.
derived: [6] Department of Agriculture Regional Field Unit 01. Annual Report. 2013
Alteration of the physical structure of corn stalks should be [7] G.A. Rosario, “Cement-bonded Particleboard from Cotton Stalk,”
done first before it can be converted into geotextile product for Unpublished Masteral Thesis. College of Engineering, Central Luzon
State University, Science City of Munoz, Nueva Ecija. 1997.
soil erosion mitigation. The processes in corn stalk geotextile [8] A.C. Junio, et al, “Performance Investigation of Banana Net as Slope
net production involve retting, fiber extracting, rope making Protection Against Soil Erosion” Unpublished Undergraduate Thesis.
and net weaving. Department of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, Technological
University of the Philippines, Manila, Philippines. 2009.
Corn stalk geotextile net may be characterized in terms of [9] R. Bhattacharyya, K. Davies, M.A. Fullen, & C.A. Booth, C. A,
such physical properties as mass per unit area and water “Utilizing Palm-leaf Geotextile Mat to conserve Loamy Sand Soil in
absorbing capacity. Mass per unit area of the net (806.25 United Kingdom”. 2008.
[10] R. Bhattacharyya, K. Davies, M.A. Fullen, & C.A. Booth, C. A.
g/m2) was affected by the mass of single and double spline Utilization of Palm-mat Geotextiles to Conserve Agricultural Soils. 2009
ropes used in the production. Water absorbing capacity is [11] Commission Fund for Commodities (CFC), “A Report on the
about 241% of its initial weight. Comparative Advantages of Sisal, Coir and Jute Geotextile.” 2010.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 10(10) 2016 622 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10005527
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Fashion and Textile Engineering
Vol:10, No:10, 2016
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 10(10) 2016 623 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10005527