UEME4423 Manufacturing Technology II (May 2022 Trimester)

ASSIGNMENT RUBRIC (Individual Report)

No Low Fair Good Excellent
Criteria Marks 0 1 2 3 4 Max Marks Student
Mark (b) Mark
Weight axb
(a)
1. Overview/ background 2 No provided Overview/backgroun A simple and clear Detailed, clearly Product 8
details of product d is provided which is overview / written and structured overview/background
hard to understand or background of product of exemplary
lacking important product overview/background structure with clear
details coverage of all
relevant aspects

2. Justification of problem 3 Problem Poor justification of Problem statement Problem statement is Problem statement is 12
statement statement is not problem statement is correctly justified, explicitly justified, very clearly justified,
justified well formulated described and analyzed in depth,
analyzed covering
dependencies and
inter-relationships
with other problems

3. Definition of objectives 2 Objectives are not Unclear or vague Objectives are well Objectives are clearly Objectives are 8
provided objectives are defined formulated and obviously and
provided obviously derived unquestionably
from the justified derived from the
problem statement justified problem
statement, are
explicitly and clearly
defined

4. Evaluation and design 2 No evaluation and Little evaluation and Acceptable Sufficient evaluation Excellent evaluation 8
drawing design rendering design drawings evaluation and and design drawing and attractive 2D and
simple design 3D design drawing
drawings

5. Evaluation of material 3 No detailed Little detailed Acceptable Sufficient detailed Excellent detailed 12
selection, requirement evaluation on evaluation on evaluation on evaluation on material evaluation on
and choice material selection, material selection, material selection, selection, material selection,
requirement and requirement and requirement and requirement and requirement and
choice choice choice choice choice
6. Evaluation of 3 No detailed Little detailed Acceptable detailed Sufficient detailed Excellent detailed 12
manufacturing process, evaluation on evaluation on evaluation on evaluation on evaluation on
requirement and choice manufacturing manufacturing manufacturing manufacturing manufacturing
process, process, requirement process, process, requirement process, requirement
requirement and and choice requirement and and choice and choice
choice choice

7. Cost analysis 2 No cost analysis Poor cost analysis, Acceptable details Sufficient details on Excellent details on 8
unrealistic costing of cost analysis cost analysis cost analysis
with realistic
costing

8. Evaluation of market 1 No evaluation of Poor evaluation of Acceptable detailed Sufficient detailed Excellent detailed 4
potential market potential market potential evaluation of evaluation of market evaluation of market
market potential potential potential

9. Evaluation of impacts 2 No evaluation of Poor evaluation of Acceptable detailed Sufficient detailed Excellent detailed 8
to public health, safety impacts to public impacts to public evaluation of evaluation of impacts evaluation of impacts
and environment health, safety health, safety impacts to public to public health, to public health,
and environment and environment health, safety safety safety
and environment and environment and environment

10. Demonstration of 2 No demonstration Minimum details of Acceptable details Sufficient and clear Excellent and clear 8
problem solution and of problem problem solution and of problem solution details of problem details of problem
conclusion solution and conclusion and conclusion solution and solution and
conclusion conclusion conclusion

11. Quality: Report format, 1 No format, layout Format, layout and Format, layout and Good format, layout Excellent format, 4
layout & flow and flow flow out of order flow are acceptable and flow, all sections layout and flow, all
in order in order, interesting to sections in order,
read, well structured good graphics and
diagram to support
reader’s
understanding,
interesting to read
and visually pleasant,
excellent structure
12 Language: Grammar & 1 Numerous Many obvious Some grammatical A very few No grammatical or 4
Style grammatical or grammatical or or spelling errors grammatical or spelling errors
spelling errors are spelling errors are can be found which spelling errors can be
present which present which does not found which does not
cause most negatively affect significantly affect significantly affect the
part(s) of the understandability of the report’s quality report’s quality
report to be the report
incomprehensible

13. Reference & citation 1 No reference and Minimum reference Acceptable Good relevant, Excellent relevant, 4
citation with questionable relevant, reliable reliable reference and reliable reference and
quality or relevance; reference and citation. All citation citation. All citations
minimum citation & citation. Most of the are shown according are shown according
with numerous citation are correct, to the guidelines with to the guidelines, with
citation errors with a couple of very minor no errors.
minor errors inaccuracies.

Total Points 25 Final Mark 100

(Final Mark / 20%)