Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Adepic Acid
Adepic Acid
SUMMARY
CONTENTS
1 Introduction 238
1 INTRODUCTION
This series of papers examines the current status of adipic acid (AAD) pro-
duction. The present paper contains general technical information on the pro-
duction processes of AA0 (and of the related cyclohexanol-cyclohexanone/olone
mixtures), the relevant patents, the industrial use and the market prospects of
adipic acid. In the three following papers (refs. 1 - 3) the chemistry of the
nitric acid oxidation of cyclohexanol to adipic acid is further examined and
significant technological improvements are indicated for both batch and con-
tinuous processing.
Both single- and two-step oxidation processes have been described for the
production of AAD from cyclohexane (Fig. 1). The first one-step production pro-
cess was described by Loder (ref. 4). Du Pant's original development of a com-
mercial AAD process dates from 1937. The basis for the traditional, industri-
ally applied, two-step procedure (air oxidation of cyclohexane to olone
followed by oxidation of the intermediates with HN03 to AAD) was laid some time
during World War II (refs. 5, 6).
This process was developed around 1940. At first, it led to rather low
yields but it has recently been studied and improved by Asahi Chemical Industry
(refs. 8, 9) and Gulf (ref. 10). According to the present scheme, cyclohexane
is oxidized with air or oxygen in the liquid phase, using acetic acid as a
solvent and a cobalt salt as an oxidation catalyst. The typical reaction con-
ditions given in the literature are temperatures of 70 - 100 OC and residence
times of 2 - 6 h; the values usually given for the selectivity towards AAD
range between 70 and 75 % at a degree of conversion of between 50 and 75 %.
239
TABLE 1
Direct oxidation of cyclohexane to adipic acid
Under mild conditions, air oxidation tends to stop at cyclohexanol and cyclo-
hexanone. More drastic conditions, however, lead to complete combustion of the
hydrocarbon. This is why intermediate conditions have to be chosen and ade-
quately controlled (ref. 11). It is also rather difficult to obtain a selec-
tivity similar to that of the traditional process with this route (in spite of
what is claimed in the literature) and further research in this direction has
apparently been discontinued. On the other hand, it cannot be denied that this
procedure would lead to considerable savings, provided that an acceptable
selectivity is achieved, because an entire step could then be eliminated from
the overall production process of adipic acid.
According to Suresh et al. (ref. 12), the oxidation of cyclohexane is an
autocatalytic reaction of the first order as regards the concentration of total
products in the conversion range of 1 - 10 %. The kinetic features of the oxida-
tion catalysed by cobalt naphthenate resemble those of the uncatalysed reac-
tion. In spite of the abundant patent literature, the published information is
limited (refs. 8, 9, 13 - 17). Articles have been published on the influence of
240
mass transfer on the processes (refs. 12, 18 - 20). In addition, the literature
includes reports on the overall oxidation of cyclohexane to AAD and information
on the liquid-phase oxidation on a pilot-plant scale of cyclohexane to AAD
using a mixture of cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone (refs. 21, 22). The latter,
relatively slow, reaction is probably the rate-determining step in the overall
oxidation of cyclohexane to adipic acid.
cA~oOOH 6o_,65 oc / ,/ ‘y
“-‘O
Co. Cr. V. Cu, flu, MO COOH
L COOH
OH
H2
CAT
e-
0
Fig. 1. Adipic acid production processes
The starting products are efther cyclohexane or phenol, of which the former
is preferred in view of the lower costs involved.
Phenol may be substituted for cyclohexane for various reasons, for example
the availability of starting materials, plant size, investment costs, etc.
(refs. 23 - 25). Phenol can be hydrogenated to form either prevalently cyclo-
hexanol or cyclohexanone, dependent on the type of catalyst used (nickel,
241
copper or chromium oxide) and on the operating conditions. For the production
of AAD the alcohol is preferred, while cyclohexanone is usually used for the
preparation of caprolactam. More than 99 % of the phenol can be converted into
cyclohexanol with a selectivity of 97 - 99 %. Small amounts of byproducts are
removed by distillation.
2.2.2 Oxidation
__----- of cxclohexane to cyclohexanol-cyclohexanone
-----_------- --------- (olone)
8
x
a
0
244
Table 2 (contd.)
a The calculated yield does not include unconverted cyclohexanol
b The examples show the effect of the purification of the substrate on the
[poor) purity of the fine1 MD product
The pressure is controlled so as to keep the mixture boiling
The temperature Is controlled by means of a cooltng circuit
Parameter k varies between 20 and 40
Countercurrent flows of nitric mother liquor and air
Production of AAD and oxime
Use of V5* as en oxidizing agent; FIN03 reoxidizes V4* to V5+
Use of nitro-derivatives as solvents
High temperature. Reduction of nitrogen to below a valancy of 2 must be
avoided in order to save HNU3.
k Removal of nitrogen-containing organic impurities et 90 - 110 *C.
Excess urea is removed with the aid of HNO2.
The use of O2 leads to a 30 % saving in HNU3 consumption (from 1.227 to
0.869 kg of HN03/kg of AAD; N2 = 24 %, N20 = 72 %, No = 4 %).
Consumption of O2 instead of HN03. Recycling of Off-gas.
Formation of edipomononitrolic acid (AMA) and dione.
Variations in the HN03 concentration and HN03/cyclohexanol rat.10 affect
the yields of AMNA end dione; higher concentrations lead to higher
AMNA yields.
Recovery of NOx (10% of the off-gas mixture).
Removal of nitrous gases from the mother liquor with the aid of a coun-
tercurrent flow of air. 15 % N02, 22 % N20, 63 % 02.
3 % increase obtained by recycling the catalyst.
Nitrogen-containing impurities amount to 0.02 - 0.2 %; recycle of NO2;
low reaction temperatures allowed.
s The amount of by-products formed increases with the contact time.
t Reduced pressure permits operation at high temperatures and the recovery
of the heat of reaction through evaporation.
” Nitrogen-containing products ere recovered as hydroxylamine end
nitrosylchloride.
” Production of MO from cyclohexanone vie the intermediate formation of
s-caprolactone.
w Oione formation is favoured.
x Simulation on a laboratory scale.
3 INUUSTRIALPRODUCTION
OF AOIPIC ACIO
Practically the entire world output of adipic acid (of Du Pont, Monsanto,
Rh6ne Poulenc, ICI, BASF, UCB and others) is produced via the liquid-phase oxi-
dation of cyclohexane by air to a mixture of cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone,
which is further oxidized to adipic acid with the aid of nitric acid (Table 2).
Only in a few cases is cyclohexanol or cyclohexanone obtained through catalytic
hydrogenation of phenol.
Typical reaction conditions are: a HN03 concentration of 50 - 60 %; reaction
temperatures of 60 - 80 OC; a pressure of 1 - 3 atm.; and the use of copper and
vanadium as catalysts, in concentrations of 0.1 - 0.5 % and 0.05 - 0.6 %,
respectively (Table 3).
TABLE 3
Consumption (kg/kg)
Patentee Temp. b HND3 Catalyst “*3/ Feed HNoJ/ alone/ Refe-
(“C) (wt %I V (wt %) Cu (wt %) olona type* AAD AAD rence
a Patent literature
b Atmospheric pressure, unless otherwise indicated
c 2 ata.
d 0.1 - 1 atm.
e 01, cyclohexanol; one, cyclohexanone
f Laboratory experiments carried out in industrial operating conditions.
TABLE 4
Process for the production of adipic acid. Main characteristics.
P,ocII
P.wnm, uon@aiin Rhbrn-PwJ*m n&SF D" PO"vuO~ulm
241
c) the best yields (particularly those of Chemische Werke Hills and of Rhdne
Poulenc) were obtained by oxidizing cyclohexanol at low temperatures.
Since the reaction is very exothermal, an AAD plant based on the nitric acid
oxidation of olone must be equipped with an efficient heat-exchanging system
and must be capable of processing solutions with high HN03/olone ratios in a
manner enabling efficient thermal control (ref. 23).
Adipic acid is usually recovered from the oxidation solution via crystalli-
zation at 30 - 70 OC and the mother liquors are recycled after having been con-
centrated at reduced pressure (Table 4). A fraction is drained to avoid accumu-
lation of glutaric and succinic acid. Various methods have been investigated
for the recovery of the adipic acid, HN03 and the catalysts from this drained
mixture. The only disadvantage of this excellent process, which leads to a high
yield of product of high purity, is the substantial nitric acid consumption.
The HN03 consumption is discussed further in refs. 2 and 3.
4 ALTERNATIVE PROCESSES
In the past, much research has been done on alternative starting materials,
but so far no other procedure has been applied on a commercial scale. Numerous
alternative processes have been suggested (for a survey see Vesel'chakova et
al. (ref. 34) and Leitner (ref. 35)), for example:
d) ozonisation of cyclohexene;
h) carbonylation of butanediol;
After the direct oxidation of cyclohexane with air and the oxidation of the
olone mixture with air the most interesting alternative procedures are hydra-
tion followed by oxidation of cyclohexene and carbonylation of butadiene.
Two BASF patents, issued in 1978 (refs. 36, 37), open new perspectives for a
potentially very interesting way of producing adipic acid. In this process
butadiene is reacted with carbon monoxide and methanol in two separate reac-
tors. In the first reactor methyl-3-pentenoate is formed at a pressure of 600
atm. and a temperature of 120 'C, in the presence of cobalt and tertiary amine
(pyridine, picoline, quinoline, etc.) catalysts:
CH3
98 % <l%
In the second reactor the pentenoate is once again reacted with CO and metha-
nol, at 30 atm. and a temperature of 185 "C, to form dimethyladipate (75 %),
dimethyl and methyl glutarate and dimethyl ethyl succinate. The costs envisaged
for a plant producing 100 ktpa according to the BASF process are slightly lower
than those required for the construction of a new plant operated on the basis
of the traditional process, i.e. the two-step oxidation of cyclohexane (ref.
38).
The costs involved in producing adipic acid from butadiene are the same as
or less than those of the process starting from cyclohexane even though the new
process uses a more expensive starting material and requires more sophisticated
equipment in the first step. A particular disadvantage of the traditional pro-
cess is the necessity of recovering the nitrogen oxides.
5 MARKET PROSPECTS
In January 1986 the world output of adipic acid amounted to 1597 ktpa, of
which 42 % was produced in the USA and 37 % in Western Europe (ref. 24). Since
76 % of the U.S. output (1986) is used for nylon 6.6 fibres, the manufacturers
of synthetic fibres are usually also the main producers of adipic acid (ref.
23). Tables 5, 6 and 7 show the major producers in the USA, in Western Europe
and in Japan, and some investment projects. Nylon 6.6, produced from adipic
acid and hexamethylene diamine (HMDA), and nylon 6, manufactured from caprolac-
249
TABLE 5
Total 968c
a Ref. 24
b As of Jan. 1, 1986
c Scheduled for 1993
TABLE 6
1
wstendeb 27 cyclohexane
France 12
RhBnePoulenc, Chalampg 230 cyclohexane
3
si Chimica, Novara 50 (phenol)
13
migshafen 2ooc cyclohexane
Bayed, Leverkusen 40 cyclohexane
Great Britain 16
I 9 Wiltond- cyclohexane
W. Europe (total)
TABLE 7
Toray Industries d
Mitsubishi Petrochemical - e
tam, together account for the greater part of the world market of synthetic
fibres. In the USA, nylon 6.6 is used twice as much as nylon 6. In England and
France too the use of nylon 6.6 predominates, whereas in Japan, Brazil, Italy
and other European countries nylon 6 has the largest market share (ref. 23).
One of the factors which has had a great influence on the European adipic
acid market over the past years is the decline in the use of AA0 as an inter-
mediate in the production of HHDA (refs. 23, 24). Until the 196Os, practically
all of the diamine used for the production of nylon 6.6 was obtained by con-
verting AA0 and ammonia into adiponitrile, which was then hydrogenated to form
HMDA. But Llu Pant's processes based on furfural (1948) and, later, butadiene
and Monsanto's commercial electrochemical process for the hydrodimerization of
acrylonitrile provided alternatives for AA0 in the production of HMOA (ref.
25). When the production of adiponitrile from butadiene was started in 1977 at
ChalampB, France (in a 104-ktpa plant jointly operated by Ou Pont and RhBne-
Poulenc) and the Monsanto~ontefibre joint venture started to produce adipo-
nitrile from acrylonitrile at Seal Sands (England) in 1978, a large stock of
alternative starting material for the production of HMOA was formed in Europe,
251
6.1 Polyamides
6.2 Polyesters
AAD is not only used to manufacture polyamide but also plasticizers (3 %),
polyurethanes (5 %) and a variety of other industrial products (2 %) (Table 8).
About 90 % of the esters is marketed as plasticizers for PVC, natural and
synthetic adhesives, polystyrene and cellulose derivatives, the other 10 %
being used for synthetic ester lubricants (hydraulic liquids). Of course, this
262
TABLE 8
a Ref. 24
b In most cases the AAD production is for captive use, U.S. merchant market
is negligible.
c Estimate
d Fibers and resins
253
Adipic acid is one of the many food additives approved by the Food and Drug
Administration as 'generally recognized as safe'. As such, it may be used as a
substitute for the more common food acidulants citric and tartaric acid (ref.
43). Adipic acid is now used in gelatine-based desserts, powdered concentrates
for fruit-flavoured beverages, bottled beverages, non-standardized jams and
jellies, sweets, precooked food, canned vegetables and flavourings.
As the greatest part of the adipic acid output is used for applications out-
side the food-processing industry, little attention has so far been paid to the
production of adipic acid of the high purity required by food processors. Also
Du Pont's projected 'Adi-Pure' high purity adipic acid plant in Singapore is
expected to serve mainly the region's automotive, electronics, appliance and
electrical industries.
REFERENCES
A.K. Suresh, T. Sridhar and O.E. Potter, AIChE J. 34, 55, 69, 81 (1988).
if V.V. Lipes, L.K. Kazentseva, N.A. Gol'tyaeva and Mz. Furman, Int. Chem.
Eng. 5, 355 (1965).
14 I.V. Berezin, E.T. Denisov and N.M. Emanuel, 'The Oxidation of Cyclohexa-
ne', Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1966.
15 P.W. Sherwood, Petr. Proc. (5), 74 (1956).
16 S.B. Chandalia, 'Oxidation of Hydrocarbons', Sevak Publications, Bombay,
1977.
17 V.D. Luedeke, in 'Encyclopedia of Chemical Processing and Design' (J.J.
McKetta, ed.), M. Dekker, New York, 1977, Vol. 2, p. 128.
18 A.K. Suresh, T. Sridhar and O.E. Potter, Chem. Eng. Sci. 41, 741 (1986).
254