UNIVERSITY OF SANTO TOMAS

THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES

DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH

POSITION PAPER RUBRIC (15%)

5 4 3 2 1

CRITERIA Exemplary Accomplished Satisfactory Developing Limited Rating

Focus/ Thesis Developed a Developed a Developed Thesis A clear

Statement strong thesis strong thesis a thesis Statement position is
and included and included statement needs to be not present
it in the it in the and developed throughout
appropriate appropriate included it further or is the paper.
place in the place in the in the paper. not included
paper. The paper. Most Some of the in the paper.
thesis was the of the information The thesis is
focal point of information supported not fully
the paper and supported the the thesis supported in
was both thesis statement. the paper.
strongly and statement.
thoroughly
supported
throughout
the paper.

Content Position is Position is Position is Reasons are Reasons are

supported supported supported weak and/or not
with well- with a with a repetitive. developed or
 UNIVERSITY OF SANTO TOMAS
THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES

developed
DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH minimum of minimum of They need are repetitive.
and thought- three distinct three to be Ideas can be
out reasons reasons. distinct developed difficult to
(minimum of Reasons are reasons. and understand.
three). developed, Reasons are explained
Reasons but more developed, further.
show strong analysis and but are
analysis and conclusions more
conclusions are needed. general and
based on the need to be
information. developed
further.

Support for Position is Position is Position Paper lacks Little to no

position supported in supported needs to be valid and support from
depth with a with a variety supported accurate researched
variety of of sources. with more information. information
sources. Valid and valid and Some of the is present in
Substantial, accurate accurate information the paper.
valid and information information. is not
accurate has been used Some of the relevant and
information throughout information does not
in the form of the paper. may not be support the
expert Most of the relevant position.
opinion, information and/or does
statistics, is relevant not support
 UNIVERSITY OF SANTO TOMAS
THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES

research
DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH and supports the thesis.
studies, etc. the writer’s
has been used ideas. A mix
throughout of general
the paper. and specific
Information information
is relevant is used.
and supports
the writer’s
ideas.

Every Every There are a Not all the

paragraph paragraph few parts of the
Organization makes one makes one paragraphs paper are Paper lacks
distinct and distinct and that are effectively organization.
coherent coherent effectively integrated.
point, point and, for integrated
expressed in the most part, and there In a number
a clear topic the parts of are a few of
sentence; the each coherent paragraphs,
parts of each paragraph points there is not
paragraph connect a distinct or
connect logically and coherent
logically and effectively. point
persuasively,
and internal
transitions
UNIVERSITY OF SANTO TOMAS
THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES

areENGLISH
DEPARTMENT OF smooth.

Ties together Paper flows Sometimes Paper does Does not tie
information with only ties together not flow - together
Style from all some information disjointedne information.
sources. disjointednes from all ss is Paper does
Paper flows s. sources. apparent. not flow and
from one Author's Author's appears to be
issue to the Author's writing does writing does created from
next without writing demonstrate not disparate
the need for demonstrates an demonstrate issues.
headings. a very good understandi an Headings are
Author's understandin ng of the understandi necessary to
writing g of the relationship ng of the link concepts.
demonstrates relationship among relationship Writing does
a thorough among material among not
understandin material obtained material demonstrate
g of the obtained from all obtained understandin
relationship from all sources. from all g any
among sources. sources. relationships.
material
obtained
from all
sources.

Entire paper Cites most Cites data Cites some Does not
Source follows APA data obtained obtained data cite sources.
Citation 7th edition from other from other obtained
style sources. Fails to
sources. from other
guidelines follow APA
UNIVERSITY OF SANTO TOMAS
THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES

with
DEPARTMENT OF proper
ENGLISH APA citation Most sources. 7th edition
use of style is used elements style
parenthetical in either text of APA 7th guidelines.
citations & or edition Citation
reference bibliography style style is
page. section. guidelines inconsistent
are or incorrect
followed.

TOTAL /35