Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aakash Bhakta (A-1)
Aakash Bhakta (A-1)
Aakash Bhakta (A-1)
I (Aakash Bhakta) assure that all ethical standards have been followed during this
project and due permission was taken at each step. Permission was taken before the
conduct of the interview, before clicking the photograph and before recording the
interview. If the respondent did not give permission to record the interview recording
was not and the entire interview was conducted on pen paper mode. The respondent
was uprightly informed about the project.
2
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Table of Contents
___________________________________________________
3
COVID – 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
__________________________________________________________________
CE 4 & CE 5
4
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Chapter 1
Self-Introduction
My name is Aakash Bhakta, I completed my Class 10 board exams from Julien Day
School, Ganganagar, which is affiliated to ICSE, after which I completed my Class 12
board exams from Sudhir Memorial Institute, Madhyamgram, which is affiliated to
CBSE, the subjects I studied in 12th are English, Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry,
Biology and Physical Education and the medium of instruction was in English. I
graduated from University of Calcutta with specialization in Zoology and the medium
of instruction was in English. My father’s name is Anjan Bhakta and he works in
Geological Survey of India. We did not get affected by COVID led lockdown because
my father works for the Central Government, due to which he received his monthly
salary on time, even though offices were closed.
The area where I conducted the interview of the micro-entrepreneur is New
Barrackpore, which is a sub-urban area near Kolkata, West Bengal. The local language
is Bangla and since, I am a Bengali, I am very fluent in speaking Bangla, reading and
writing it.
1
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Chapter 2
Introduction of the Micro Entrepreneur
The name of the person on whom I am writing this case study is Subhasish Ganguly
and he is the owner of a small vegetable vendor, who goes around New Barrackpore
selling vegetables. He has been running this business since the lockdown happened,
before that he was a ‘Rickshaw-wala’ in New Barrackpore. He took up this job during
the COVID led lockdown because of financial issues. People were not coming out of
their houses during that time due to which his Rickshaw business was down. Therefore,
he was compelled to sell vegetables from door to door during the pandemic.
2
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Chapter 3
Lockdown and Impact on Supply Chain
Subhasish did face issues in the supply of raw materials. Trucks used to come from
Kolkata filled with vegetables, which were sold to these vegetable sellers, so that they
could subsequently sell them to us. Since, Subhasish was not in this business before the
pandemic, he had no idea whether the situation was same or different before the COVID
led lockdown. However, the challenge he faced was that since, he was new to this
business and the people who were already in this business before did not know him
properly, they refused to sell their vegetables to him initially and the little items he was
able to procure were either with very less shelf life or almost rotten. However, this did
change after the first COVID led nationwide lockdown. After he became familiar with
the new environment and the people surrounding him, he was able to procure better
items and good quality vegetables. After the economy reopened in June – July 2020 i.e.
after the first COVID led lockdown the input prices of these vegetables changed. The
prices decreased because some sellers had gone back to their previous business because
people were then being able to come out of their houses and naturally the demand for
high priced vegetables decreased, since people had the choice to buy from other
vegetable vendors at a much lower price if they so desired. But, unlike others, Subhasish
did not shift back to his old business, he stayed in this business because the buyers with
whom he interacted for these few months had become close to him, so they trusted
Subhasish that he will bring them the best quality vegetables at a reasonable price,
which he did. Therefore, he was able to maintain his sales continuously. Sometimes,
despite the demand, he was not not able to make enough sales as the raw materials did
not reach him on time. Also, he did pass the increase cost to the customer in the form
of increased end prices, whose proportion was more than 50%. The reason behind such
a strategy was to procure profit as much as possible since another lockdown was
inevitable in the future, as the COVID cases number were not falling. In the festive
season, as the cases started rising gradually, even though there was no lockdown, some
people started staying inside their homes, which increased his vegetable sales.
After the deadly second wave and the economy was partially locked down, but this time
the supply got disrupted badly because people in the supply chain of vegetables died,
trucks that brought the vegetables were stopped and naturally the prices of vegetables
increased drastically. This time, however, Subhasish put his son in the business as well
so that the total family income remained the same since his income was reduced
dramatically, as he was unable to procure vegetables like before because of the
increased price and disrupted supply. He was not at all in a better position which not
only reduced his income but also sacrificed his son’s education.
After the second wave of COVID led pandemic, the supply of vegetables slowly started
to get better, so much so, that compared to last year’s festive season, the situation was
much better this year. Last year, people were more afraid which is why many people in
the supply chain stopped working due to which the people who were still working had
3
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
to work harder that before. As a result, the prices of the vegetables increased and
became hard to procure by new comers like Subhasish. His strategy back then was to
gain from his sales as much as possible which he did by passing on the increase in cost
price to the end customer in the form of increased prices by more than 50%. The reason
behind this was to get back to his previous conditions so that his son could renew his
education. Now after the re-opening of the deadly second wave, and also massive
vaccination drive, the situation is better from last year. The procurement of raw
materials is now easier, the prices have also fallen by 10-20%. However, according to
Subhasish, we are far from returning back to pre-covid situations, which is why he is
afraid as he might lose customers in the future, if this continues for a longer period of
time.
For the future, Subhasish expects situation to get better since vaccinations are occurring
at a very high rate. Also, people have become more conscious now, they are wearing
masks and using sanitizers. Hence, Subhasish is really optimistic about the future.
During the 2 lockdowns, neither did he not receive any help from the government nor
was he aware of any government scheme that could have helped him. He did, however,
expect some form of help from the government. In the future, Subhasish expects the
Government to not held elections during such a viral pandemic and act accordingly.
4
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Chapter 4
5
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
only become normal but also improve because of the massive vaccination drive. He is
planning on buying some insurance policies next year if situations improve and his
income rises a little bit more as from next year he is planning to open a fish market
because in West Bengal that business fetches a lot of money irrespective of lockdown.
Again, in term of finances he did not receive any help from the government. During the
first lockdown, there was no help from the government. No one from the government
approached him during the 2 lockdowns. He was not aware of any government schemes
like easy loans at lower rate of interest, or longer payoff time. He did, however, expect
some form of help from the Government in terms of monetary support.
6
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Chapter 5
7
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
8
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Chapter 6
Conclusion
The case study revolves around a person who is not much educated and has been a
“Rickshaw-wala” since he was 22 years old. He had no idea about how a vegetable
selling business works but had to shift to that business due to some unforeseen
circumstances. Now, he had to learn about how a business works, the ins and outs of
certain situations in the business, how to formulate his own marketing strategy, how to
understand customers, how to supply the demand, what to do when he loses customers,
how to analyze consumer behaviour, how to establish yourself in a new environment,
how to procure vegetables when you are new in the business and so much more.
Subhasish had to go through a lot, from depriving his son from his education to planning
to shift from vegetable selling business to fish selling business. He realized that
economy is such a thing that is not constant, there are ups and downs. Mostly, during
the festive season the sales are up and the income he acquires from that is better off
when atleast 40% of it is in the bank.
The Government intervention was minimal. They did not provide any type of help to
these micro-entrepreneurs during the pandemic. During the first wave, they were
themselves confused as to what should be done during such a time of crisis. Other than
announcing a lockdown, they could not really do anything about it. In the second wave,
the Government was busy with the elections, campaigning and urging the people to join
their campaign. This put the general public at risk and was a disaster to the whole
scenario overall given the circumstances. As a result, the people’s trust over the
Government was somewhat shaken.
For the future, people are hoping for the things to turn out better than it is right now.
Even though the vaccination drive all over the country is taking place in a huge scale,
however, there is a possibility that a third wave might take place as several variants
have come up and the vaccines are not exactly providing long term immunity against
the virus. But people can understand this, they have become more health conscious than
before, everyone is wearing mask and sanitizing their hands in public places. Hence,
their facial expressions suggest that they are optimistic about the future. When I was
making this survey, the facial expression of Subhasish told me the same story when I
was asking him about the present conditions and what might happen in the future. All
his facial expressions told me that if a third wave comes, as he has now become
accustomed to this business, he will be better prepared than before.
The Government should come up with schemes that will help these micro-entrepreneurs
with their business, like providing them with a basic monetary help monthly. These
micro-entrepreneurs should also know how to save money, about 40% of their income
should stay in the bank and the rest should be used for expenses. Even if such a situation
arises where they are not making any income, then they should change their marketing
strategy according to the consumer behavior otherwise their sales would decrease and
sustaining the business might become a challenge for them which they won’t be able to
overcome, as they are not running huge businesses.
9
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Annexure 1
Worse
situation than
19 If no then why and if yes then how? first wave Disgust
Was the disruption you faced the same as the
previous lockdown as this time there was no
20 nationwide lockdown? No Fear
By putting
his son to
21 How did you manage this time? work Sad
Were you better positioned as you already had
experience from the last lockdown that was more
22 stringent? No Sad
How strong was the supply chain disruption this
time; was it the same, was it less than before or
23 was it more than before? More Sad
Did this lead to any impact on the input prices?
Did the input prices increase, decrease or remain
24 the same? Increase Sad
25 How has been the supply of raw materials? Poor Sad
Please compare the supply before the pandemic, It was poor
during the pandemic led lockdown and after the but it got
26 pandemic led lockdown? better Happy
Last year during the festival time (Dusherra –
Diwali) when the lockdown was partially lifted was
27 the supply still disrupted? No Happy
28 Did that result in increase in cost price? No Happy
To incur
profit as
much as
29 What was your strategy then? possible Happy
Did you pass on the increase in cost price to the
30 end customer in the form of increased prices? Yes Anxious
31 If yes then how much? >50% Anxious
32 The entire portion or only a part? A part Anxious
To get back
33 Please explain the reason behind your strategy? on his feet Happy
Now after the re-opening of the deadly second
wave, and also massive vaccination is the
34 situation better from last year? Yes Happy
35 Has the procurement of raw materials easier? Yes Happy
Are the prices of the raw still high or have they
fallen? If not, then why did you think that the
36 prices did not fall? Fallen Happy
If they have fallen, then how much have they By about
37 fallen? 50% Happy
Have they reached the pre-Covid level or is it still
38 higher than that? Higher Fear
Have you passed on the increase cost prices to the
customer? If yes then how much, the entire part
39 or only a proportion like less than 50% of the >50% Fear
11
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
12
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
13
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
Large scale
vaccination
drive &
If yes then why, if no then why and if don’t know consciousnes
47 then why? s of people Anxious
48 Has your financial behavior changed? Yes Happy
Have you started provisioning (like opening a bank
account and saving money, or buying some
insurance policy for the future etc.) for a situation
49 like this in future? Yes Happy
If no then why and if yes then why? Explain the To tackle
50 reason behind your strategy? future events Fear
Again, in term of finances too did you receive any
51 help from the government? No Disgust
During the first lockdown was there any help from
52 the government? No Disgust
Did anyone from the government approach you
53 during the 2 lockdowns? No Disgust
Were you aware of any government schemes like
easy loans at lower rate of interest, or longer
54 payoff time etc.? No Anxious
55 Did you expect anything from the government? Yes Sad
Is it the same, better off or worse off compared to
41 the last year? Better off Happy
Has, your finances improved to the pre-Covid
42 level? Yes Happy
Did the festive this year-round bring the same
level of hope and expectations like the pre-Covid
43 years? No Sad
Did your finances improve like all other festive
44 years? If no then what is the deficiency? Yes Happy
45 What are your expectations from the future? - -
Do you think that things will become normal from
46 here? Someday Anxious
Large scale
vaccination
drive &
If yes then why, if no then why and if don’t know consciousnes
47 then why? s of people Anxious
48 Has your financial behavior changed? Yes Happy
Have you started provisioning (like opening a bank
account and saving money, or buying some
insurance policy for the future etc.) for a situation
49 like this in future? Yes Happy
If no then why and if yes then why? Explain the To tackle
50 reason behind your strategy? future events Fear
Again, in term of finances too did you receive any
51 help from the government? No Disgust
During the first lockdown was there any help from
52 the government? No Disgust
15
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
17
COVID 19 and Subsequent Lockdown: Impact on Small and Micro Entrepreneurs
People are
visiting the
39 If no then why and if yes then how it is different? market more Sad
How has the changed customer behavior
impacted your sales, positively, negatively or it
40 has remained the same? Negatively Sad
If it has improved positively, then how have you
41 adjusted to the increase in demand? - -
How do you find the mood of the customer now?
42 Positive, negative or neutral? Positive Happy
Did based on their mood, did you have any add –
ons especially for the festivals like Rakhi,
43 Dusherra, Diwali etc.? - -
44 If yes then what? - -
45 What was the response? - -
For the
future,
consumer
behaviour to
improve and
a change in
What are your expectations for the future? Do marketing
you think a change in strategy especially in strategy is
46 marketing is needed? needed Anxious
47 Did you ever think of changing your profession? Yes Happy
-x-
18