Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Improving The Students Critical Reading Comprehension Through DRTA (Directed Reading Thinking Activity) Method
Improving The Students Critical Reading Comprehension Through DRTA (Directed Reading Thinking Activity) Method
Improving The Students Critical Reading Comprehension Through DRTA (Directed Reading Thinking Activity) Method
SKRIPSI
By
SUCI ARIANTIKA E TANJUNG
NPM.1402050346
This research answer these main question (1) Is there any significan improving on
Thinking Activity) Method? (2) How the improvement occurs after using Directed
class XI SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan ?. Twenty five students’ of the eleventh
grade students’ of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan 2018 were instructed through
planning, action, observation and reflection. From the result, the researcher found
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Reforhand praise and thanks we say present of almighty god to all his
blessing of grant from above and blessing to us all. Especially in enjoying Islam
and believe in experiencing this worlds life. Utterance Sholawat and greeting to
his messanger our prophet Muhammadiyah the blessing of the lord be upon him.
Method”. This study is written to fulfill one requirement to obtain the sarjana
It was not easy for the researcher in finishing this study. There were many
difficulties and problem faced by her, phsycally and mentally. Without helping
the following people, it might be impossible for her to finish it. Therefore, she
would like to thanks very much, especially to her dearest and lovely great parents,
and also to my younger siblings Abdul Azis Tanjung, Abdul Gani Tanjung
and Putri Anggraini Tanjung for their million grateful words never be enough
to endless love, care, attention, pray, encourangement and hearth they have given.
The researcher also would like to express her gratitude and appreciation to:
2. Elfrianto Nasution, S.Pd,. M.Pd The Dekan of FKIP UMSU who had
secretary.
valuable suggestion, critics and never stop giving ideas in writing this
research.
6. Kasni, M.Pd The Head Master of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan who has
7. Her special boyfriend Heri Prasetia Budi thank you very much for helping
8. Her best friend in Kelapa Hijau Outbound, Brother Isyaf, Itong, Dani and
Sist Ayu thank you very much for all support until now, always give me
9. Her best friends in life Tri Mulyani and Risma Yunita big thanks my girls
10. Her special friends in PPL Kharisma Khairia, Citra Pakar Ningsih, Gita
The last, this study is far from being perfect, but it is expected that this
study will be useful not only for the writer, but also the readers. For these reasons,
constructive thoughts, full suggestions, and critics are welcome to make this study
better.
Finally, may Allah Subhaanahu Wa Ta’ala receives all their work and
kindnesses. Aamiinn.
The Researcher
ABSTRACT ............................................................................................... i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ....................................................................... ii
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
1. Reading ........................................................................................... 5
v
2.1 Definition of Reading Comprehension ....................................... 11
D. Hypothesis ............................................................................................ 25
vi
B. The Quantitative ................................................................................... 37
1. Cycle I ............................................................................................. 38
2. Cycle II ............................................................................................ 44
C. Discussion ............................................................................................ 50
A. Conclusion ............................................................................................ 52
B. Suggestion ............................................................................................ 53
REFERENCES
APPENDICES
vii
LIST OF FIGURE
viii
LIST OF TABLE
Table 3.1 The List XI RPL 2 Class of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan .............. 27
ix
LIST OF APPENDICES
x
1
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
the students. Reading skill are necessary for students in acquiring knowledge and
new information. According Brown (2007) that reading is the most essential skill
a text. However, critical reading is something beyond that, for when students start
enlightened, but students read to react with the writer and show our standing by
accepting or rejecting his/her assertion and critical reading for Senior High School
students help to discover and understand the author’s arguments and helps to
In the fact, there are still many problems in the learning process of critical
in reading comprehension. Sometimes students are only required to read the text
in the heart, and then answer questions related to the content of the text. it is a
way that does not involve the process of thinking students so that students are not
involved in critical reading process, so the readers are practicing what the critical
The problems that found in SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan based on my
experience in teaching practice, the reality in the field, learning critical in reading
still read less especially in comprehending the text, most of the students did not
like and were not interested with English especially in reading, and the an
objective that high school English teachers should strive to achieve is to teach
their students to become critical readers: where researcher hopes the readers who
can infer, analyze, predict, synthesize, and use any other higher-order thinking
with different kinds and mediums of texts, but the teachers still use traditional
method in teaching reading. In the reality of this research are most of the students
think that reading is difficult because they were afraid making mistakes or
incorrect pronunciation when they were reading, make fun and not borred, and
teaching that uses all the students sense (Blachowich & Ogle, 2008). The DRTA
provides the teacher to guide students to think like good readers do anticipating,
predicting, and then confirming and modifying their ideas with the story as it
that using DRTA method is really effective in teaching analysis. In other case,
based on Richardson & Morgan’s (1997) researcher that have title Improving The
3
that the DRTA engages students in higher order thinking skill and that these skills
1. Many students still read less especially in critical comprehending the text
2. Most of the students did not like and were not interested with English
especially in reading
The scope of this research will be focused on teach reading skill. This
Method ?
Method
2. To find out how the improvment occured on the students’ critical reading
1. Theoretically
At theoritical, this proposal can help or add fluency for students’ in critical
the study will enrich the knowledge and skill in critical reading comprehension.
2. Practically
(DRTA) method.
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
A. Theoretical Framework
This study deals with theories that were support the concept. In this case,
theoretical framework is aim to give some clear concept apply in this research. It
was intended to define the boundary of this study. There were many points in this
1. Reading
English which consist of listening, speaking, reading and writing. From those four
basic skill, reading is considered as important skill. Students need good reading
skill for acquiring knowledge and learning new information. They have to practice
thinking process. The reader applies many strategies to reconstruct the meaning
that the author is assumed to have intended. The reader does this by comparing
information in the text to his or her background knowledge and prior experience.
rather than of decoding print to sound, a theoritical position that has become
5
According Nunan (1991:20), also said that Reading is a process of
decoding written symbol, working from smaller units (individual latters) to large
ones (words, clause, and sentences). Reading is a process to grasping the language
between the reader with the author, represented by his writings. In the interaction
by the researcher. Contact between the two characteristics that will give birth to
the readers understabding of the idea of the author. This mean that reading is not
merely express written language and follow the text line by line, but trying to get
the message, the mandate and the meaning conveyed by the authors through
purposes for comprehensive reading. All these purposes require necessary skills in
slower from of reading, which allows the reader to envision the scenery
reader.
concepts and the nature of the presented information. The reader skims
Brown (2001: 125) explain the type of reading. In this case reading,
variety of performance is derived more from the multiplicity of type of the text
that from the variety of overt types of performance, nevertheless. Several types of
1. Percetive
2. Selective
applied.
3. Interactive
psycholinguistic some, interest with the text. That is, reading is process of
recogciating meaning, the reader brings the text a set of schemats for
4. Extensive
21
the word, understanding arguments and working out for the egreement of
Harmer considers that students can get more benefit from reading if they
reading text, not just to the language. In this principle, the point is that
begin when they can get the hints of the text so they can predict what’s
undermine boring and inappropriate questions so the reading activity can be more
The five principles behind teaching reading process some important points
important to make the students engaged with and have abilities to respond to the
texts. The principles also highlight that predicting is crusial in reading since it is
related to the students active process of reading. In addition, choosing the good
tasks is one of the considerations to make the reading activity be more exciting
and challengging. By referring to those principles, the teacher and students can be
1. The teacher should not insist on speed of reading but on the accuracy
2. While teaching reading teacher should ask not more than one pupil to read
3. While teaching reading the teacher should be very carefyl in pointing out
of the pupil.
21
4. While reading teaching the teacher should first try to find out the causes of
5. While teaching reading the teacher should be aware of the right sitting or
2. Reading Comprehension
situation that we are in if we are not confused by it, whether we are reading the
text, reapiring an appliance, or trying to find our way through the traffic
downtown.
the interpreter and the message. The presumption here is that meaning resides in
the intentional problem-solving, thinking processes of the interpreter, that the
selective, anticipatory, and based on comprehension, all maters where the reader
process in which the reader contructs meaning using as the building materials the
information on the printed page and the knowledge stored in the reader’s head. It
Reading cover a lot of things. It does not simply know the meaning of
mention about the bottom-up and top-down process. Both of them are the
a. Bottom-up processing
21
itself. From among all the perceived data, the reader selects the signals that
b. Top-down processing
Top down is a process in ehich the readers draw their own intelligence and
c. Interactive reading
which are employed flexible and selectively in the course of reading. Reading
strategies are often divided into three stages; before reading, during reading, and
after reading. To be able to read texts, students should have their strategies.
In addition to Duke and Person (2001:432) explain that there are some
c. Make predictions
n. Motivation/purpose/goals/engagement
decoding
p. Fluent reading
Analytical exposition text is one of some genres of texts that are learned in
(2001), the function of analytical exposition is to explain some aspect of the world
and bring the addressee to share the writer’s point of view. Moreover, Coffin
(2001) state that analytical exposition is the text which is used to put forward a
While., Mali-Jali (2007) says that the social function or the purpose of the
analytical exposition is to argue and give reasons for particular point of view of an
issue, from the ideas above, it clear that an analytical exposition not only a
common reading text but it also need the reader to analyze, interpretation the text
There are some opinion given by the expert about definition of analytical
analytical exposition as a text that elaborates the writer’s idea about the reader that
1) Purpose:
a) To persuade the reader or listener that there is something that,
b) To analyze a topic and to persuade the reader that this opinion is correct
2) Generic Structure:
opinioins that support the main idea of the author of the text. usually
text there are more than two arguments. The more arguments displayed,
the more it makes the reader believe that the topics discussed by the
3) Language Features:
4. Critical Thinking
Critical thinking checks the reading process, presumptions are created and
discarded and viewpoints orginated. Students must be aware that they have to
text an actor that uses various craft to coax them into its own viepoints. In tye
initial phases, students can be told to what pay attention. As students are not
expected to initially understand what to seek for, they need to be guided. In the
next steps, students can eb instructed to associate what questions to the how
questions. Critical thinking would help students of literature dicern that literary
significant cognitive skill that schools attempt to foster in students, there seems to
critical thinking (Halpern, 2001; Moseley et al. 2005). Critical thinking has been
regarded together with creative thinking as associated secondary ideas within the
taxonomy. One of the major differences within critical thinking is the differences
between dispositions and skills. They are of the opinion that dispositions are
that guides the students in making prediction about text and then read it to confirm
students are given a number of words from a text. working in groups, they have to
predict what kind of a text they are going to read or what story the text tells. They
then read the text to see if their orginal predictions were correct. We don’t have to
Based this nations upon the belief that reading is at thinking process
involving the reader in using his or her own experiences to reconstruct the
author’s ideas. This begins with the generation of hypotheses based upon the
information and the generation of further hypotheses during reading. Then, there
constuction terminates with the resolution of the reader’s doubts and desires.
are guided through the process of sampling text, making predictions based upon
schema and helps them to make sense of sentence. It calls into mind any
experiences and associated knowledge that a reader already has about the topic of
the text. Predicting prepares the reader for comprehension. Although an overall
specific portions of text and then to read the appropriate portions to confirm or
alter the predictions. Students reflect aloud on those predictions before going on
explained below:
5.1 Talk about the genre, name the author, show the cover picture and read
the title. Ask the children to predict what the story will be about. The
5.2 Teacher tells the children to read to the first stopping point.
5.3 Teacher reviews the predictions and asks which ones are coming true so
far. Teacher asks them to read aloud parts of the text that confirm or
5.4 Teacher asks the children to make more predictions, and presses for
5.5 After proceeding to the end, the teacher reviews the story and asks the
why using Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) method in reading class
such as: it encourages students to be active and thoughtful readers. The process of
predicting, reading and proving make the students are not passive in reading class.
They use their mind to be more aware about the topic given may be known yet by
the students. In addition, it activates students prior knowledge. It will appear prior
knowledge by predicting the topic and new information wiil add students
knowledge.
21
contructions of meaning. It’s mean that through students predictions in the text to
make their active in reading. Thus, Brunner (2011:56),said that method help
students read critically and reflect upon what they read. Besides, this method help
students determines a purpose for reading. Carefully examine the text, and remain
it is only useful if students have read or heard to text being used. Besides,
more than thirty) because the teacher could not control the students personally.
B. Related Studies
students and reported that teaching yhis activity is significant for enhancing
some researchers.
Reading Approach (DRA). The result of her analysis shows that the mean
Odwan is combined the DRTA with cooperative learning, there are some
points about the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) itself which
because during the activity students set purposes, make predictions, read
Even if it does not present about the Directed Reading Thinking Activity
(DRTA) only, the previous review of related studies stresses the importance of
using Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) which may help the teacher
C. Conceptual Framework
21
Reading is one of the language skill that students should be mastered and
from a text. Thus, teaching and learning of reading atthe school be carefully
students were found. The grade XI students at SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan,
detected from their difficulty in generating the main idea and identifying detail
information while both of those problem are included as the skills of reading.
Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) is one of the method in reading that has three
core steps of comprehenion cycle. They are sample the text, make prediction and
sample the text to comfirm or correct previous prediction. These three steps are
conducted as before, during and after reading steps so that they fulfill the proper
steps of reading comprehension. This guides students step by step in the reading
process.
Figure 2.1 The Conceptual Framework of Action Research
READING
XI-RPL 2 of SMK
D. Hypothesis
Based on the theoretical and conceptual framework above, there were two
hypothesis :
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research was conducted at SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan which was
located at Jalan Kolam no.3 Kenangan Baru, Kecamatan Percut Sei Tuan,
Kabupaten Deli Serdang Sumatera Utara. The reason for choosing this school
because the researcher will ever do field experience practice (PPL) in this school,
B. Subject of Research
The subject of the research was carried out to XI grade students of SMK
Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan, of the second semester in the academic year of
2017/2018. The researcher takes XI RPL 2 class as the subject of this research. It
is consist of twenty five students’. At this scholl, there are two classes, and the
research is as a teacher.
2
Table 3.1 the list XI RPL 2 Class of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan in the
NO NAMA JK
1. ARP Male
2. AWR Female
3. AWD Female
4. DS Female
5. DAS Female
6. DVT Female
7. FMA Male
8. FAS Male
9. HG Male
14. MI Male
15. MN Male
16. MY Male
17. M Female
18. P Female
3
19. PT Femlae
20. RC Male
21. RH Male
23. SN Female
C. Research Design
The class of this research will bedevided the Classroom Action Research
(CAR) procedure used in this research was Arikunto (2006: 16), informs that the
stages (and its repeating); there are four steps to do classroom action research.
They are planning, acting, observing, and reflecting. The researcher spent two
Figure 3.2
16)
Planning
Observation
Planning
Observation
1. planning
planning explains about WH question (what, why, when, where, who and
a. preparing materials, making lesson plan, and design the step in doing the
action.
c. Preparing teaching-aids
e. Preparing a test for pre-test and post-test (to know whether students’
2. Action
3) The researcher used some text in the pre-test and post-test in each
cycle.
problems.
8) The researcher reflected the learning activity with the observe in order
problems.
6
5) The researcher reflected the learning activity with the observe in order
3. Observation
investigated like the students feeling, thinking, and something they do in teaching
4. Reflecting
researcher was examining the result of the acting that has been conducted.
Through the reflection researcher was know the strength and weakness of
there is problem in the cycle I the researcher must solve the problem in the next
cycles.
In this researcher, instrument is the main important tool to collect the data.
observation, and camera. The interview guidlines were used in the beginning of
the research process, the end of the cycle, and the end of the research process.
7
These guidelines were used to guide the researcher to focus on the intended
research area as she conducted the interviews. The guidlines was possibly
developed as long as the interviews were still on the right path. The next
rundown of the classroom teaching and learning process. The las was camera, the
researcher used camera to take some picture of the process of teaching and
learning process. She also used it record the process of teaching and learning.
Techniques of collecting data which are used in this research are as follows:
1. Observation
learning activities. It is used to know the situation of the teaching learning process
before and after using DRTA to improve critical reading comprehension. In the
2. Interview
Interview was conducted to the teacher and the students because the
researcher want to find directly the teachers problems in teaching critical reading
and the interview was conducted in Bahasa Indonesia to make the interview
conducted in the end of each meaning to obtain the information about the students
8
response and impact of using DRTA method, and whole process of teaching and
learning practice.
3. Test
In this research will use test, the kind of the test is used in this research is
written tests were in the form of multiple choices and essay for each the pre-tesr
and pos-test. By used the written test the researcher more easy to measure the
students critical in reading comprehension score through DRTA method. The test
Technique data analysis that used in this research is quantitative and qualitative
approach. Quantitative analysis was getting from the result of studies after
analysis qualitative was getting the data from the result of observation and
getting by students. The writer uses three technique in analyzing the numerical
data as follows:
9
a) The writer seeks the average of students grammar score within pre-test
∑
=
N
Where:
M : Mean
To calculate the Mean, the whole scores will add and the sum will divide
by the total number of cases. This analysis purpose to find out how is the
data using the mean because it is already known the result of the research from
this way. It shows that there are differences between cycle I pretest-protest, and
b) The writer seeks the class percentage which pass the KKM score (75) by
р= × 100
Explanation :
∑ ² ∑
SD = − ²
After calculating the SD, the researcher will calculate t-test to know if
∑
t◦ =
√
Exolanation :
The data was getting from interview and the result of teachers activities
students responds toward the new method (affective) and students activity toward
learning a subject, their attention, their enthusiastic in learing, their response, their
The writer uses descriptive analysis to analyze this qualitative data, which
the teaching learning process, the field notes, also the interview before and after
The researcher made the schedule of the research as in the table below :
NO ACTIVITIES TIME
CHAPTER IV
There are two kinds of this research, qualitative and quantitative. The
qualitative data were taken from observation, interview, test, and documentation.
The quantitative data were taken from the mean of students score in taking test.
The total number of the students in that class was 25 students that consisted of 9
females and 16 males. This research was accomplished in two cycles. The
research was conducted in four meetings. There was pre-test before conducting
the cycle in the first meeting. The cycle I included the post-test I that was
conducted sfter the research taught the students in two meeting. The cycle II
included the post test II that was conducted after the researcher taught the students
in two meeting also. The steps performed by the researcher in each cycle were
based on the rule of Classroom Action Research. The each cycle consisted of four
B. The Quantitative
The quantitative data was taken from the result of the test, which were
carried out in two cycles. The test was given to the students in forms of pre-test.
Post-test of cycle I and cycle II. The result of the students’ score could be seen in
the following:
38
1. Cycle I
a. Planning
planning explains about WH question (what, why, when, where, who and how the
1) preparing materials, making lesson plan, and design the step in doing the
action.
3) Preparing teaching-aids
5) Preparing a test for pre-test and post-test (to know whether students’
b. Action
1. First Meeting
The writer did the research on Wednesday, February 8th 2018 at 12.30. It
introduced her self and writer explained the learning purpose in this class during 4
meeting. The class was started by greeting between the teacher and the students’.
The first meeting, DRTA method activity did not started in this meeting
because writer wanted to understand how students’ English reading skills. Before
began method DRTA. Researcher asked students’ “Do you know analytical
exposition text?. Students’ said “they are not know about analytical exposition
that researcher asked students’ to read the text. But, the students’ just silent and
embarrassed to read text. So, researchers choose 2 students to read the text. After
that students’ translate the text and the teacher help the students’.
After the translating the text, researcher divided into some group discussion.
Researcher gave random jumble sentences and arranged in whiteboard. After that,
pre-test then teacher closed the lesson. Researcher closed the lesson by saying
Hamdallah together.
2. Second meeting
Researcher entered to the class at 12.30 a.m. too, the researcher started the
teaching and learning process by greeting the students’, asking them to pray and
the previous lesson. After that, researcher gave material about analytical
exposition text. She discussed about strategy Directed Reading Thinking Activity
Now, without selected students, began to lift your hand to read. After that,
exercise with a classmate, to prediction the text to search good titles, the simple
40
present tense and generic stucture in the text. After that, the researcher discussed
After that, the researcher and students’ discussed the contents of the text and
translate the text. After finishing the translating of the text researcher asked
students’ say had no question. They did not have question, researcher gave a post-
test. They had not finish about 20 minutes. After finishing the test, researcher
closed the lesson and the researcher gave a conclusion of the lesson. She
explained how to predict the text gave tips to answer the question. Subsequently,
3. Observation
observed the students’ activity in this teaching learning process, but they saw that
students’ felt shy to answer prediction because she was afraid if the answer false.
So, researcher gave support to students’ in order to make them more confidents to
The time was conducted less effectively because the introduction and pre-
test wasted a long time. Where as second meeting students’ did post-test hurry
because the ceremony so the time was limited. The results of pre-test in cycle and
Table 4.1
Pre-test 1 Post-test 1
No Students’ Initial y-x D²
(x) (y)
1 ARP 60 80 20 400
2 AWR 40 60 20 400
3 AWD 70 80 10 100
4 DS 60 70 10 100
5 DAS 60 80 20 400
6 DVT 60 80 20 400
7 FMA 70 80 10 100
8 FAS 50 70 10 100
9 HG 40 60 10 100
10 LRM 60 70 10 100
11 MRK 70 80 10 100
12 MFR 80 90 10 100
13 MMQ 70 80 10 100
14 MI 70 80 10 100
15 MN 70 80 10 100
16 MY 80 80 0 0
17 M 50 60 10 100
18 P 50 70 20 400
19 PT 70 60 -10 100
20 RC 60 70 10 100
21 RH 80 90 10 100
22 RLR 60 70 10 100
23 SN 70 80 10 100
24 SAL 80 80 0 0
25 TAB 60 80 20 400
Jumlah 1.590 1.880 280 4.100
42
a) Mean of pre-test I
ﻃ
.
b) Mean of post-test I
ﻃ
.
From the calculation above, it can conclude that there were some
comparison between pre-test and post-test cycle I, the mean of pre-test was 63,3
ﻃ ﻃ
SD =
43
SD =
SD = Ẅ
SD = Ẅ
SD = 38,56
ﻃ
t◦ =
ﺾ
t◦ = Ẅ
ﺾ
Ẅ
t◦ = Ẅ
Ẅ
Ẅ
t◦ =
Ẅ
t◦ = Ẅ
The calculation which shows the class percentage of students’ who pass the
KKM was:
זּ %
זּ %
זּ %
44
It means there are 76% of students’ who pass the standardized score. It indicates
2. Reflecting
After analyzing the result of the action in this cycle I, the researcher
concluded that the students’ “reading comrehension was improved”. It was shown
1. Cycle II
a. Planning
planning explains about WH question (what, why, when, where, who and how the
1) preparing materials, making lesson plan, and design the step in doing the
action.
3) Preparing teaching-aids
5) Preparing a test for pre-test and post-test (to know whether students’
b. Action
entered to the class at 12.30. the researcher started the teaching and learning
45
process by gretting the students, asking them to pray and checking the students’
attendance list.
Then with the spirit, the students’ answered the greeting from the teacher.
There before doing pre-test, the teacher asked the students’ abaout explanation of
previous material and some students’ answered. Teacher stars to prepare pre-test
and dividing it. She gives 20 minutes for students’ to answer the question. After
finishing their pre-test, the teacher starts to explain example about prediction
picture and answer question with see picture. The researcher guide students’ to
predict the picture. After that write the prediction on the paper, students’ read the
text to confirm the prediction. After that researcher asked students’ to read the text
Now without being asked students’ want to read the text. MFR a students’
raised her hand and wants to read the text of each paragraph. Researcher showed
that their predictions were correct or not. Students’ began to dare to raise your
hands and want to read the text. after the researcher divided into some groups and
asked students’ to predict text. after being given 20 minutes, researcher predicted
After finishing the lesson today, researcher closed the lesson. The
entered to the class at 12.30. the researcher started the teaching and learning
46
process by greeting to the students’, asking them to pray and checking the
students’ attandance list. Researcher gives the text for students’, and students’
predict the text and transalet the meaning of the text. researcher given 20 minutes
to understand the text. after that researcher asked students’ to in front of the class
Researcher give opportunity to four students’ can stranslate the text and
brave forward to translate and predict the text would give reward. After finishing
researcher gave post-test and students did the post-test. After the finishing post-
c. Observation
In the cycle II, researchers got observation notes from the observer. By
observed the students’ activity in this teaching learning process, but they saw that
the students’ felt confident to answer the prediction because she felt comfort with
The time was conducted better than before, because students’ did pre-test
seriously. Where as second meeting students’ did post-test hurry because the
ceremony so the time was limited. The results of pre-test in cycle and test in cycle
II as follow :
47
Table 4.2
Pre-test II Post-test II
No Students’ Initial y-x D²
(x) (y)
1 ARP 70 90 20 400
2 AWR 70 80 10 100
3 AWD 80 90 10 100
4 DS 80 100 20 400
5 DAS 80 90 10 100
6 DVT 80 90 10 100
7 FMA 70 80 10 100
8 FAS 70 80 10 100
9 HG 70 80 10 100
10 LRM 70 90 20 400
11 MRK 70 90 20 400
12 MFR 80 100 20 400
13 MMQ 60 80 20 400
14 MI 70 80 10 100
15 MN 90 100 10 100
16 MY 80 90 10 100
17 M 70 80 10 100
18 P 70 80 10 100
19 PT 90 100 10 100
20 RC 70 80 10 100
21 RH 70 90 20 400
22 RLR 80 100 20 400
23 SN 80 90 10 100
24 SAL 70 90 20 400
25 TAB 80 100 20 400
Jumlah 1.860 2.240 350 5.100
48
a) Mean of pre-test II
ﻃ
.
b) Mean of post-test II
ﻃ
.
From the calculation above, it can conclude that there were some
comparison between pre-test and post-test cycle II, the mean of pre-test was 74,4
ﻃ ﻃ
SD =
49
ỳ
SD =
SD =
SD = ﺾ
SD = 8
ﻃ
t◦ =
ﺾ
t◦ =
ﺾ
t◦ =
Ẅ
t◦ =
Ẅ
t◦ = Ẅ
The calculation which shows the class percentage of students’ who pass the
KKM was:
זּ %
50
זּ %
P = 96%
The score percentage of students’ who pass the KKM was 96%. It means
that there were only 24 students’ who pass the KKM. However, 1 students’ could
not pass the KKM. It conclude that the improvement of students’ critical in
d. Reflection
After analyzing the result of the action in this cycle, the researcher seen that
students’ easy to understand the material, few them did the test well. They learned
to read seriously and carefully to find the answer of questions. The result of pre-
test and post-test in this cycle are higher than be first cycle.
C. Discussion
Based on the result of analysis in two cycles, the researcher would like
1. Mean
51
calculation Cycle II. It means that the application of DRTA method can improve
significantly, where both of post-test are higher than pre-test. The table above
display that the mean of cycle I improves; the mean of pre-test is 63,6 and the
mean of post-test is 75,2. In cycle II also show that post test is bigger than pre-
The result shows that then mean of the findings in cycle I and cycle II
were higher than the standardized score (KKM) in score 75. All students’ pass the
standardized score. The score of mean of post-test in cycle I and Cycle II were
75,2 and 89,6. The result in cycle I and cycle II were successful to achieve the
standardized score.
CHAPTER V
this chapter summarize the findings in the previous chapter. It presents the
A. Conclusion
Related to the findings of this research, it could be said that this research
was improved students’ critical reading comprehension. It can be seen from the
cycle I and cycle II. It was shown by pre-test and post-test. Beside that, the table
above display that the mean of cycle I improves; the mean of pre-test is 63,6 and
the mean of post-test is 75,2. In cycle II also show that post test is higher than pre-
In conclusion. Based on the result of the research and the data found, it can
(DRTA) method can acceptable with the XI grade students’ in SMK Negeri 1
52
B. Suggestion
After the knowing and finding of the research, researcher gives suggestion
as follow:
1. To Teacher
process. The teacher can use new material not only use book or internet
b. The teacher can use strategy DRTA method to get the interest of the
students, the reading is not boring so students’ can prediction text with
read English text. So students’ are interested in reading habit. They are
2. To Students’
a. The students’ must be active in learning process and should not be afraid
b. Students’ can use DRTA method to prediction the text, and the students
c. Students should read the material carefully, so they can understand the
content of text.
53
3. For other Researchers
use Directed Reading Thinking Activity as one the references in teaching reading.
54
REFERENCES
Richardson, J.S., and Morgan, R.F. (1997). Reading to Learn in the Content
Areas. Belmont, CA:Wadsworth Publishing Company.
Mahmoud. 1992. Research and Writing: A Complete Guide and Handbook. USA:
Betterway Publication.
Odwan, T.A. A. H. 2012. The Effect of the Directed Reading Thinking Activity
through Cooperative Learning on English Secondary Stage Students’
Reading Comprehension in Jordan. International Journal of Humanities
and Social Science, Vol.2, N0. 16.
Duke, Nell K., and P. David Pearson. How Can I Help Children Improve Their
Comprehension? Ann Arbor, Michigan: Center for the Improvement of
Early Reading Achievement (CIERA), Michigan StateUniversity, 2001.
Brown, H. Douglas.2000. Principle of Language Learning and Teaching.San
Fransisco:Logman.
Sethna, Melissa. (2012). Literary Skills and Strategies for Content Area Teachers.
Sudijono, Anas, 2008. Pengantar Statistis Pendidikan, Jakarta: PT. Raja Grafindo
Persada
Renn, C. (1999). The Effects of the Directed Reading Thinking Activity on second
grade Reading Comprehension. M.Ed. dissertation, Grand Valley State
University, Michigan, USA. Retrieved September 16, 2008, from
Dissertation & These: A&I database. (Publication No. AAT 1395108).
Coffin, Caroline.2001.Arguing about How the Worldis or How the World should
be:The Role of Argument in ELTS Test.Retrived on March
2013fromhttp://oro.open.ac.uk./378/EAP_respository.pdf
APPENDIX 1
LESSON PLAN
(Treatmeant)
Subject : English
I. Competence Standard
Analyze the social function, text structure, and linguistic elements of short
and simple biographical texts on famous characters, in accordance with the
context of their use.
III. Indicator
V. Learning Material
Analytical Text
VII.Learning Activity
1. Opening Activity
• Greeting
• Prayer
• Check students’ attendance list
2. Main Activity
• The teacher explain the strategies that will be use Using DRTA
(Directed Reading Thinking Activity) Method
• Teacher show the example of the analytical text
• Teacher explain the communicative social function, generic structure
and reiteration.
• Teacher assigns students’ to some group
• Teacher asks students in pairs to analyze some analytical texts with a
focus on social function, structure, and linguistic elements
• Students get feedback from teachers and friends about the results of
analysis submitted in group work.
• Teacher asks students to retell simple analytical texts about the
exemplary of famous personality by paying attention to social
function, structure and linguistic elements.
• Teacher ask students reading text and answer question based on
analytical text.
• Teacher correct the answer question true or false.
3. Close Activity
• Teacher asks student to make analysis text with critical thinking
• The teacher and students make a conclusion about analytical text in
the end of lesson.
• The teacher close the meeting with say hamdallah
VIII. Media, Tools and Learning Resources
1. Media
- Power point presentation
- Picture
2. Tools / Materials
- Loud speaker laptop
- Computer
3. Learning Resources
- Teacher’s voice
- English language book SMK class XI sem 2
XI. Learning Source
IX. Assesment
1. True Answer 5
2. Wrong Answer 0
• Every correct answer score = 5
• Amount of Maximal Score 5 × 20 = 100
• Maximal Score = 100
• Student mark = × 100%
Know by:
The Head Master of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Kasni, M.Pd
NIP. 19661009 198812 1 004
Appendix 2
Analytical Text 1
Today teens don’t know how to disconnect. Social media has allowed
them to take their life online from the time they wake up till they back to
sleep via their smart phone. One reason this “always connected” activity is
harmful is because of the alarming trend of cyberbullying. Bullying has now
moved from not only being in the school and on the bus, but online. What
does this mean? If a teen is getting bullied, they cannot get away from it! The
people bullying them simply continue their bullying via social media
A new study has found that teenagers who engage with social media
during the night could be damaging their sleep and increasing their risk of
anxiety and depression. Teenagers spoke about the pressure they felt to make
themselves available 24/7, and the resulting anxiety if they did not respond
immediately to texts or posts. Teens are so emotionally invested in social
media that a fifth of secondary school pupils will wake up at night and log on,
just to make sure they don’t miss out.
Another impact social media has had on teens is teens being more
comfortable online doing things that they should be more sensitive to doing.
A separate study by the National Citizen Service found that, rather than
talking to their parents, girls seek comfort on social media when they are
worried. The survey also suggests that girls are likely to experience stress
more often than boys – an average of twice a week.
7. Today teens don’t know how to disconnect. Social media has allowed them to
take their life online from the time they wake up till they back to sleep via
their smart phone.
The sentence above characterize as.... of the text.
a. Thesis
b. Arguments
c. Reiterartion
d. Topic sentences
e. Supporting details
a. Social media is becoming more than just a part of their world, it’s
becoming their world
b. Easy access to communication between people from various parts of the
world
c. Social media can socialize well through cyberspace, such as facebook,
twitter
d. Social media could become media for bullying, risk them of anxiety and
depression, and risk their real-life social interaction
e. can also be lazy to read books
a. Resolution
b. Reiteration
c. Conclusion
d. Recommendation
e. Twist
a. I and II
b. III and IV
c. IV
d. All paragraph
e. V
Analytical Text 3
The Importance of Reading
I personally think that reading is a very important activity in our life. Why
do I say so? Firstly, by reading we can get a lot of knowledge about many things
in the world such as Science, technology. Sports, arts, culture, etc written in either
books, magazine, newspaper, etc.
Another reason, reading can give us pleasure too. When we are tired, we
read books, newspaper or magazine on the entertainment coloumn such as
comedy, short story, quiz, etc. To make us relaxed.
The last, reading can also take us to other parts of the world.By reading a
book about Irian Jaya we may feel we’re really sitting in the jungles not at home
in our rooms.
From the facts above, it’s obvious that everyone needs to read to get
knowledge, information and also entertainment.Or in summary we can say
reading is truly important in our life.
Learning English through music and songs can be very enjoyable. You can
mix pleasure with learning when you listen to a song and exploit the song as a
means to your English progress. Some underlying reason can be drawn to support
the idea why we use songs in language learning.
Firstly, “the song stuck in my head” Phenomenon (the echoing in our
minds of the last song we heard after leaving a restaurant, shopping malls, etc) can
be both enjoyable and sometimes unnerving. This phenomenon also seems to
reinforce the idea that songs work on our short-and-long term memory.
Secondly, songs in general also use simple conversational language, with a
lot of repetition, which is just what many learners look for sample text. The fact
that they are effective makes them many times more motivating than other text.
Although usually simple, some songs can be quite complex syntactically, lexically
and poetically, and can be analyzed in the same way as any other literary sample.
Furthermore, song can be appropriated by listener for their own purpose.
Most pop songs and probably many other types don’t have precise people, place
or time reference.
In addition, songs are relaxing. They provide variety and fun, and
encourage harmony within oneself and within one group. Little wonder they are
important tools in sustaining culture, religion, patriotism and yeas, even
revolution.
Last but not least, there are many learning activities we can do with songs
such as studying grammar, practicing selective listening comprehension,
translating songs, learning vocabulary, spelling and culture.
From the elaboration above, it can be concluded that learning through music and
songs, learning English can be enjoyable and fun.
5. Based on the text, there are …… reason for using songs in learning language
a. 6
b. 4
c. 5
d. 3
e. 2
6. “They provide variety and fun, and encourage harmony within oneself and
within one group.”
The underlined word refers to ….
a. a)Groups b)Learners c)People d)Songs e)Activities
Analytical Text 4
Cars should be banned in the city. As we all know, cars create pollution,
and cause a lot of road deaths and other accidents.
Firstly, cars, as we all know contribute the most of pollution in the world.
Cars emit a deadly gas causes illnesses such as bronchitis, lung cancer, and trigger
of asthma. Some of these illness are so bad that people can die from them.
Secondly, the city is very busy. Pedestrians wander every where and cars
commonly hit pedestrians in the city, which causes them to die. Cars today are our
roads biggest killers.
Thirdly, cars are very noisy. If you live in the city, you may find it hard to
sleep at night, or concentrate in your homework, and especially talk to someone.
In conclusion, cars should be banned from the city for the reasons listed.
(RPP)
3.11 Menganalisis fungsi sosial, struktur teks, dan unsur kebahasaan dari
III. Indicator
1. Mengidentifikasi fungsi sosial, struktur teks dan tata bahasa dari teks
analisis tertulis
2. Temukan gagasan pokok, informasi terperinci dan informasi spesifik
dan fungsi sosial dari teks analytical yang dibaca.
3. Merumuskan dan mengembangkan pemikiran mereka terhadap materi.
IV. Tujuan Pembelajaran
1. Siswa dapat menemukan gagasan pokok, informasi terperinci dan
informasi tertentu serta fungsi sosial membaca/mendengarkan teks
analytical.
2. Merumuskan dan mengembangkan pemikiran mereka terhadap materi
secara kritis
V. Materi Pembelajaran 1
VII.Learning Activity
Meeting 1
X. Rubik Penilaian
1. True Answer 10
2. Wrong Answer 0
Know by:
The Head Master of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Kasni, M.Pd
NIP. 19661009 198812 1 004
RENCANA PELAKSANAAN PEMBELAJARAN
(RPP)
3.11 Menganalisis fungsi sosial, struktur teks, dan unsur kebahasaan dari
III. Indicator
1. Mengidentifikasi fungsi sosial, struktur teks dan tata bahasa dari teks
analisis tertulis
2. Temukan gagasan pokok, informasi terperinci dan informasi spesifik dan
fungsi sosial dari teks analytical yang dibaca.
3. Merumuskan dan mengembangkan pemikiran mereka terhadap materi.
IV. Tujuan Pembelajaran
V. Materi Pembelajaran 1
Example :
VII.Langkah-langkah Pembelajaran
Meeting 2
X. Rubik Penilaian
1. True Answer 10
2. Wrong Answer 0
Know by:
The Head Master of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Kasni, M.Pd
NIP. 19661009 198812 1 004
RENCANA PELAKSANAAN PEMBELAJARAN
(RPP)
3.11 Menganalisis fungsi sosial, struktur teks, dan unsur kebahasaan dari
III. Indicator
1. Mengidentifikasi fungsi sosial, struktur teks dan tata bahasa dari teks
analisis tertulis
2. Temukan gagasan pokok, informasi terperinci dan informasi spesifik dan
fungsi sosial dari teks analytical yang dibaca.
3. Merumuskan dan mengembangkan pemikiran mereka terhadap materi.
IV. Tujuan Pembelajaran
1. Siswa dapat menemukan gagasan pokok, informasi terperinci dan
informasi tertentu serta fungsi sosial membaca/mendengarkan teks
analytical.
2. Merumuskan dan mengembangkan pemikiran mereka terhadap materi
secara kritis
V. Materi Pembelajaran 1
I personally think that reading is a very important activity in our life. Why
do I say so? Firstly, by reading we can get a lot of knowledge about many things
in the world such as Science, technology. Sports, arts, culture, etc written in either
books, magazine, newspaper, etc.
Another reason, reading can give us pleasure too. When we are tired, we
read books, newspaper or magazine on the entertainment coloumn such as
comedy, short story, quiz, etc. To make us relaxed.
The last, reading can also take us to other parts of the world.By reading a
book about Irian Jaya we may feel we’re really sitting in the jungles not at home
in our rooms.
From the facts above, it’s obvious that everyone needs to read to get
knowledge, information and also entertainment.Or in summary we can say
reading is truly important in our life.
Meeting 3
Ø Konfirmasi
• Guru menanyakan kesulitan siswa
• Guru memberikan soal post-test
• Guru menjadi sumber dan fasilitator siswa
dalam memahami teks analytical exposition
c. Close activity 10 menit
• Menyimpulkan materi pembelajaran dan
penguatan materi
• Mengingatkan untuk selalu belajar
• Guru menutup pembelajaran dangan membaca
hamdallah dan salam.
X. Rubik Penilaian
1. True Answer 10
2. Wrong Answer 0
Know by:
The Head Master of SMK Negeri 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Kasni, M.Pd
NIP. 19661009 198812 1 004
Name :
Class :
Learning English through music and songs can be very enjoyable. You can mix
pleasure with learning when you listen to a song and exploit the song as a means to your
English progress. Some underlying reason can be drawn to support the idea why we use
songs in language learning.
Firstly, “the song stuck in my head” phenomenon ( the echoing in our minds of the last
song we heard after leaving a restaurant, shopping malls, etc) can be both enjoyable and
sometimes unnerving. This phenomenon also seems to reinforce the idea that songs work on
our short and long term memory.
secondly, songs in general also use simple conversational language, with a lot of
repetition,which is just what many learners look for sample text. the fact that they are
effective makes them many times more motivating than other text. although usually simple,
some songs can be quite complex syntactically, lexically and poetically, and can be analyzed
in the same way as any other literary sample.
furthermore, song can be appropriated by listener for their own purpose. Most pop
songs and probably many other type don’t have precise people, place or time reference.
in addition, song are relaxing. They provide variety and fun, and encourage harmony
within oneself and within one group. Little wonder they are important tools in sustaining
culture, religion, patriotism and yeas even revolution.
last but not least, there are many learning activities we can do it with songs such as
studying grammar, practicing selective listening comprehension, translating songs, learning
vocabulary, spelling and culture.
from the elaboration above, it can be concluded that learning through music and songs,
learning English can be enjoyable and fun.
5. Based on the text, there are …… reason for using songs in learning language
a. 6
b. 4
c. 5
d. 3
e. 2
6. “They provide variety and fun, and encourage harmony within oneself and within one
group.”
The underlined word refers to ….
a. Groups
b. Learners
c. People
d. Songs
e. Activities
Name :
Class :
Computer and internet are useful as well as powerful. Information about health and
safe usage of computer and Internet, especially for children, should be owned by each family.
Computer connected to internet is powerful way to socialize with others. It can be good but
also bad effect. Recently we hear a lot of children get the advantage of social networking
sites but we often see the news about the disadvantage of it for children. Healthy and safety
of computer and Internet usage should continue to be campaigned.
The role of parent in assisting and directing children in using computer is very
necessary. Installation of software monitor such as key logger which has function to watch
and note all activities relating to keyboard usage is helpful but not enough to protect children
from potential harms. Children tend to hide what they have done in front of the computer to
their parent. They see that all of they have done are their privacy and no one may know.
a. Healthy and safety of computer and Internet usage should continue to be campaigned.
b. As a means of entertainment for children, such as playing games.
c. Children wiil learn how children can socialize well through cyberspace, such as
facebook, twitter
d. With a child’s computer can operate a variety of word and figure programs
e. Children can also be lazy to read books
8. Healthy and safety usage of computer and Internet should continue to be campaigned.
The sentence above characterize as.... of the text.
a. Thesis
b. Arguments
c. Reiterartion
d. Topic sentences
e. Supporting details
9. Which paragraph is called arguments?
a. I and II
b. III
c. All paragraph
d. I and III
e. II
Social media Web sites, such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and many others have
become nearly inescapable facets of modern life, particularly for teenagers. Social media is
becoming more than just a part of their world, it’s becoming their world. Teens are spending
more and more time online, usually on a social media platform like Facebook or Twitter.
Most teens now have smart phones where they are on social media networks all throughout
the day. They are constantly texting, tweeting, and posting pictures via Snapchat and
Instagram. However, hyper-connected to social media could be bad for them.
Today teens don’t know how to disconnect. Social media has allowed them to take
their life online from the time they wake up till they back to sleep via their smart phone. One
reason this “always connected” activity is harmful is because of the alarming trend of
cyberbullying. Bullying has now moved from not only being in the school and on the bus, but
online. What does this mean? If a teen is getting bullied, they cannot get away from it! The
people bullying them simply continue their bullying via social media
A new study has found that teenagers who engage with social media during the night
could be damaging their sleep and increasing their risk of anxiety and depression. Teenagers
spoke about the pressure they felt to make themselves available 24/7, and the resulting
anxiety if they did not respond immediately to texts or posts. Teens are so emotionally
invested in social media that a fifth of secondary school pupils will wake up at night and log
on, just to make sure they don’t miss out.
Another impact social media has had on teens is teens being more comfortable online
doing things that they should be more sensitive to doing. A separate study by the National
Citizen Service found that, rather than talking to their parents, girls seek comfort on social
media when they are worried. The survey also suggests that girls are likely to experience
stress more often than boys – an average of twice a week.
Social media such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and many others are basically
created to connect everyone around the globe so they can interact and communicate each
other. However, too much exposure of social media can also be bad especially for teenagers.
As it mentioned above, social media could become media for bullying, risk them of anxiety
and depression, and risk their real-life social interaction. Therefore, social media are
dangerous for teenagers’ health both mentally and emotionally.
7. Today teens don’t know how to disconnect. Social media has allowed them to take their
life online from the time they wake up till they back to sleep via their smart phone.
The sentence above characterize as.... of the text.
a. Thesis
b. Arguments
c. Reiterartion
d. Topic sentences
e. Supporting details
a. Social media is becoming more than just a part of their world, it’s becoming their
world
b. Easy access to communication between people from various parts of the world
c. Social media can socialize well through cyberspace, such as facebook, twitter
d. Social media could become media for bullying, risk them of anxiety and depression,
and risk their real-life social interaction
e. can also be lazy to read books
a. Resolution
b. Reiteration
c. Conclusion
d. Recommendation
e. Twist
a. I and II
b. III and IV
c. IV
d. All paragraph
e. V
Name :
Class :
Cars should be banned in the city. As we all know, cars create pollution, and cause a
lot of road deaths and other accidents.
Firstly, cars, as we all know contribute the most of pollution in the world. Cars emit a
deadly gas causes illnesses such as bronchitis, lung cancer, and trigger of asthma. Some of
these illness are so bad that people can die from them.
Secondly, the city is very busy. Pedestrians wander every where and cars commonly
hit pedestrians in the city, which causes them to die. Cars today are our roads biggest killers.
Thirdly, cars are very noisy. If you live in the city, you may find it hard to sleep at
night, or concentrate in your homework, and especially talk to someone.
In conclusion, cars should be banned from the city for the reasons listed.
KEY
1. A
2. B
3. C
4. A
5. B
6. D
7. E
8. A
9. E
10. B
Attendance List of Cycle 1
EDUCATION:
1. Primary School at MI AL-JAMIATUL HUSNA Bakti Makmur Psr I finish
2008
2. Junior High School at MTs NURUL HASANAH Dusun Bakti Psr II finish
2011
3. Senior High School at SMA NEGERI 2 Bagan Sinembah finish 2014
4. Students of University Muhammadiyah Sumatera Utara Until Sarjana
Degree of English Department 2018