Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kahn's Light: The Measurable and The Unmeasurable of The Bangladesh National Assembly Building
Kahn's Light: The Measurable and The Unmeasurable of The Bangladesh National Assembly Building
ScienceDirect
RESEARCH ARTICLE
a
Bauhaus University Weimar, Weimar, 99423, Germany
b
Sapienza Università di Roma, Piazza Borghese, 9, Roma RM, 00186, Italy
Received 24 June 2021; received in revised form 20 September 2021; accepted 27 September 2021
KEYWORDS Abstract To incline and unfold the constituent elements of Louis I. Kahn’s architecture and
Louis Kahn; philosophy, a precise attention must lie on the fundamental objectives that he vigorously pur-
Light; sued and mastered, especially in his latest works. This work focuses attention on Louis Kahn’s
Architecture; idiosyncratic approach to light manipulation which he used to shape his architecture. That’s
Dhakka due to the constant coherence of his approach even today. As we are merged in the plurality
of fonts that haul our discipline, we constantly question the real sense of architecture and
what makes it intelligible. Kahn’s method drew conclusions and seeked for this sense through
precise fonts: lessons from the past, current modernist flow, and the context. He combined
and transformed these inspirations distinctively through his own sensitivity to achieve that
spiritual value and its own true sense that architecture should retain in its form. Thus, it is
considered of utmost interest to rethink his approach and particularly to reflect today on
the pertinence of his main architectural parameter: Light.
ª 2021 Higher Education Press Limited Company. Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf
of KeAi Communications Co. Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foar.2021.09.005
2095-2635/ª 2021 Higher Education Press Limited Company. Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co. Ltd.
This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
90
Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (2022) 89e102
91
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
Fig. 5 Caracalla Baths (212-216 AD). Source: Wikimedia Fig. 7 Artificial Lake of National Assembly Building. Source:
Commons. Wikimedia Commons.
92
Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (2022) 89e102
Fig. 8 (a) Main Floor Plan. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection,
University of Pensylvania). (b) Main Floor Plan. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I.
Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (c) The process of generating forms. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s
original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (d) Floor Plan e level 0. Source: Drawn in CAD by
authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (e) Floor Plan e level 1.
Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (f)
Floor Plan e level 2. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, Uni-
versity of Pensylvania). (g) Floor Plan e level 3. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I.
Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (h) Floor Plan e level 4. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original
drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (i) Floor Plan e level 5. Source: Drawn in CAD by authors,
based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (j) Section ‘A-A’. Source: Drawn in
CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania). (k) Elevation.
Source: Drawn in CAD by authors, based on Kahn’s original drawings (Source:Louis I. Kahn Collection, University of Pensylvania).
93
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
Fig. 8 (continued).
Some Bengali Buddhist monasteries, such as Mahas- minimalism, modularity and adaptability which are essen-
tangarh (3rd century B.C.), Paharpur (8th century A.D.), tially modern concepts. In addition, Kahn drew attention to
and Maynamoti (8e12th century), are also compared to this project based on his acquaintance with Bengali culture,
the assembly building in terms of the geometric and reflected Bengali religious diversity when designing the
arrangement (Choudhury, 2015), emphasized on the project and crossed the country, making sure he was
monumentality of these Buddhist architectures and their immersed in the Bengali building and cultural traditions
significant influence on Kahn’s design philosophy of the (Wiseman 2007). It also evokes various architectural styles,
assembly building. Significantly, the central cruciform such as Mughal building structures, the Roman Renaissance,
shape of the Paharpur monastery dictates Kahn’s inten- and appears to have converged as a palimpsest in one single
tion of visualizing the monumentality of Bengali archi- architectural event rather than as a synthesis (Ashraf,
tecture (Fig. 6). 1994).
As it was stressed, Bangladesh National Assembly is Building discerns silently in its brick basement sur-
embodied by Bengali vernacular style and according to rounded by artificial lake sealing a new origin, in a meta-
Rashid and Ara (2015) this type of style provokes physical sense and condensed in its being (Fig. 7).
94
Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (2022) 89e102
Fig. 8 (continued).
“This is architecture which restores something to those The physical configuration of voids is determined by
who have no heritage, who find in it an image their dignity, traversed axes, pierced inner walls, and volume juxtapo-
and who-for lack of anything better-see in it vision of a sition, allowing of volumes allow the space to fluctuate
different life”(Kahn, as cited in Diba, 1990, p. 11) while yet being but still to be contained in particular spaces
of the building just in order to find the moment of stasis to
Evidently, Kahn interprets the government, the mosque
assert its own character.
and the court in one universal social law circumscribed and
This occurs in the volumes allocated in four primary
blended in one building empathetically and poetically. As
orthogonal axes which end in subspaces with central orga-
Kahn stated “Architecture is the thoughtful making of
nization as well. The secondary radial axes that start from
spaces”, the visible solids are indeed the voids inside the
the main center are aligned with the rectangular volumes
building that generate a layering of spaces dissolved in
(Fig. 8aek).
sequential intervals through a dynamic interplay of light
The perimetric volumes that enclose the space in be-
and shadows. Despite the classical echoes, the spatial
tween assume their individuality through form and vertical
conception assumes a modernist twist.
95
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
Fig. 8 (continued).
layers, which are punctured with pure shapes, and so, to Universally, Kahn’s philosophy included these spatial
maintain the visual tension between the entire composition configurations using different external lines, geometrical
whole. This space in between is a ‘street’ that assumes the shapes and the game of light and shadow on the exterior,
communal sense in the universal order. so that he can represent Bangladeshi culture and heri-
Thus, the phenomenal transparency in Kahn’s space is tage. A similar layout and view are also present in Kahn’s
evident but of course not completely entirely in modernist other project in the library complex of Phillips Exeter
terms as it does not have the degree of anonymity as a Academy (Fig. 9). According to (Deijkers et al., 2014), the
characteristic of modernity, and stands between outer and book zone of the library building is similar to the street of
inner space, which are formally defined or concluded. As a the Assembly Building. Kahn used similar geometric
consequence of this concept, we witness a stratification of shapes for the academy’s library complex. The offices of
space that stands between dynamic and static equilibrium, the outer layer are also consistent with the student
and between modern and classical conception. reading zone of the library complex. Therefore, the
96
Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (2022) 89e102
Fig. 8 (continued).
learning of Phillips Exeter Academy Library in the USA “Of course there are some spaces which should be
(1965e1971) was one of the significant contributors of flexible, but there are also some which should be
Kahn’s project for the National Assembly Building completely inflexible. They should be just sheer
(1963e1974). Moreover, using space (street) to make inspiration. just the place to be, the place which does
room where people can interact with each other also not change, except for the people who go in and out.”
expresses Kahn’s inspiration from the courtyard of Salk (Kahn, as cited in Johnson, 1975, p. 27, p. 27)
Institute for Biological Studies. A similar concept is pre-
sent on the upper floors of the National Assembly Build-
ing, where people can communicate with each other 5. Sculpting (through) the silence and light
(Fig. 10). Kahn’s architectural order is abstract even
though he explicitly approached every parameter of his Evidently, the work of Louis Kahn relies on the strength of
architecture in an empathic way. oppositions. His dichotomous architecture reaches the
97
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
Fig. 8 (continued).
Fig. 9 Phillips Exeter Academy Library. Source: Wikimedia Fig. 10 Salk Institute for Biological Studies. Source: Flicker.
Commons. Creative Commons.
98
Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (2022) 89e102
defined space as an unprecedented scene and as a mani- between, generates different scenarios of light and
festation never to be repeated. shadow. As is to say, the light in the afternoon would cast
the polished punctured wall of ambulatory and the form of
“So light, this great maker of presence can never
projected light and shadow would reach its sublime unifi-
be.brought forth by the single moment in light which
cation on the building structures (Fig. 11a and b).
the electric bulb has. And natural light has all the
The intention is that none of the spaces can exist
moods of the time of the day, the seasons of the year,
without natural light; even a crack of natural light is enough
(which) year for year and day for day are different from
to name a space and feel the presence. “I said that all
the day preceding.” (Kahn, as cited in Johnson, 1975, p.
material in nature, the mountains and the streams and the
18, p. 18)
air and we, are made of Light which has been spent, and
The quality of light is defined from layered spatial this crumpled mass called material casts a shadow, and the
configuration and material of construction that acquires it. shadow belongs to Light. So Light is really the source of
Due to the geometrical juxtaposition of forms, the space in being” (Kahn, as cited in Lobell, 1985, p. 22)
“A plan of a building should be read like a harmony of
spaces in light. Even a space intended to be dark should
have just enough light from some mysterious opening to
tell us how dark it really is. Each space must be defined
by its structure and the character of its natural light.”
(Kahn as cited in Pietrogrande et al., 2015, p. 82)
The light that penetrates the spaces of Dhaka buildings
are of different kinds. From morning to sunset; direct cast
or indirectly through intermediate layers of spaces, and
that is consequently of different intensities. “Every space
must have natural light, because it is impossible to read
the configurations of a space or shape by having only one or
two ways of lighting it. Natural light enters the space
released by the choice of construction.” e (Kahn, “Law and
Rule in Architecture” lecture, 1961)
The platform of the Assembly building and the passages
of access draw different scenarios of mass and void. Be-
sides, the analogy to Roman ruins of Caracalla Baths is
explicit in the choice of constructive elements at this level
99
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
Fig. 13 (a) Offices. Source: Wikimedia Commons. (b) Light openingss. Source: mosqpedia.org.
100
Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (2022) 89e102
glassless openings of different shapes: triangles, semi- the void ring filled with different spatial and lightning se-
circles, rectangles and vertical and horizontal splits. This quences directly and indirectly, from the ceiling or from the
layer between the inner spaces of offices and outer infinite detachments of juxtaposed volumes. The natural light was
space controls the intensity of light that enters and the permeated into atmospheric layers of dense characters
projection of shadows. Besides, it allows natural ventilation belonging to different functions and yet reaching that
(Fig. 13a and b). These spaces are placed in radial axis and communal sense.
modulated in such a way so that they are not to be inter- The spaces are illuminated through the ribbed ceiling, the
sected, but linked through bridges in order to allow light to vertical fissures and the highest opening is above the entrance
enter the space in between or the most communal area. to the mosque. Is like an invitation to enlightenment (Fig. 16).
Moreover, the glassless openings from the outer skin are The center or the Assembly with its octagonal shape recalls a
always aligned to the communication area and stairs to point of stasis, a center. The light reaches its monumental
elevate the experience of vertical movement. presence in the chamber through the openings from the ceiling
with tent-like semi-circular openings. The light rhythmically
“A stair isn’t something you get out of catalogue but a
scans the space and certain projected intervals as the sun
very important event in building” (Kahn, as cited in
moves during the day. The infinity that enters the room,
Johnson, 1975, p. 18, p. 18)
transcends its mere function and instructs the dignity of
The entry hall on the north and the mosque on the south communal-social order (Fig. 17a and b).
are likewise appended of the outer ring. The last has Apparently, the quality and intensity of natural light to
defeated the orthogonal axis in a certain angle and is some extent is controlled through employed material-
hinged through the circle to the rest. The rectangular vol- concrete, which allows sharp reflection and homogenous
umes with cylindrical corners that serve as lightning wells dispersion depending on how it is molded by structure.
are pierced with circular glazed openings in upper and While in the level of passages to the platform, local bricks
lower corners and receive light through cylinders (Fig. 14). tend to absorb it more than reflected. And this level acts as
The intensity of light that enters the room is strong a base but still maintains its earthy ruin-like sense,
particularly in the zenith position of the sun. Thus, the opposed/amplified by water. Lastly, this convocation of
brightness again is controlled through semi-circular ele- concrete, brick and water in one unified ‘compound’
ments where the light first casts and then to be distributed assembled through light incites a definition of new “genius
through the hall. Here the lightning and spatial qualities are loci” for Bengali culture.
consecrated (Fig. 15a and b)
The second layer or the space in between (outer layer
and the central assembly) often considered as a street, is
101
B. Lutolli and K. Jashanica
6. Conclusion References
This paper attempted to bring into the light a new concept Ashraf, K.K., 1994. National Capital of Bangladesh, Dhaka, 1962-83.
of understanding of Kahn’s work. This understanding aimed Global Architecture. Edita Tokyo.
to be found from Kahn’s own words about the light. Light, Brownlee, D., Long, D.G., 1991. In the Realm of Architecture. The
as a major dominating parameter of Kahn’s architecture is Museum of Contemporary Art, Los Angeles.
Ching, F., Jarzombek, M., Prakash, V., 2017. A Global History of
obtained in between poetry and practical components of
Architecture, Second. Wiley & Sons, New Jersey.
his building design. Kahn’s approach to architecture in Choisy, A., 1899. Hisotrie de Architecture. Gauthier-Villars.
general, and in Dhaka in particular, reveals that light and Choudhury, B.I., 2015. The Genesis of Jatio Sangsad Bhaban at
shadow, as two important parameters to his architecture, Sher-E- Bangla Nagar. Dhaka. https://core.ac.uk/download/
are treated as building materials. Ultimately, Kahn’s work pdf/41240768.pdf.
stands on the threshold as regards to his careful reference Curtis, W., 1982. Modern Architecture since 1900. Phaidon Press
to the past and future without falling into something uto- Limited.
pian and neither eclectic. Undoubtedly, Dhaka stands as a Deijkers, M., Herwijnen, M. van, Prudon, G., 2014. Louis I. Kahn &
magnum opus of his idea of architecture and an exemplary His Inspiration.
manifestation of the twentieth century and a historical Diba, D., 1990. Return to Dacca, , Nr. 26711. L architecture
daujourdhui.
landscape of Bangladesh with one of the most famous
Johnson, E.N., 1975. Light Is the Theme. Louis I. Kahn and the
Kahn’s designs, Dhaka National Assembly Building. But Kimbell Art Museum. Kimbell Art Foundation, Texas.
above all, an opus to the prevalence of light as an element Kahn, N.P., 1963. Cited in the Development of Dacca “Remarks”
which is universal and still unique for the context and can Quoted in in the Realm of Architecture.
be articulated accurately to originate the architecture of Kahn, 2003. Film: My Architect. November 12, 2003. Producers:
the place. This research also welcomes future researchers Nathaniel Kahn, Susan Rose Behr.
to come across in-depth architectural reviews about Kahn’s Lobell, J., 1985. Between Silence and Light. Shambhala Publica-
philosophy that still reaches ‘unmeasurable’ in the current tions INC.
study. Such investigations may include new influential Pietrogrande, E., Rabacchin, A., Dalla, C., Alessandro, Lu, J., 2015.
variable architectural dictionaries. Notes on the architecture of Louis I. Kahn. DBS.
Rashid, M., Ara, D.R., 2015. Modernity in tradition: reflections on
building design and technology in the Asian vernacular. Front.
Declaration of competing interest Archit. Res. 4 (1), 46e55.
Scully, V., 1993. Louis I. Kahn and the Ruins of Rome. Engineering &
The authors declare that they have no known competing Science/Winter 1993. MoMA, Museum of Modern Art.
financial interests or personal relationships that could have Wiseman, C., 2007. Louis I. Kahn: beyond Time and Style. W. W.
Norton & Company, London.
appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
102