Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Satterthwaite, J.C.
Satterthwaite, J.C.
By JOSEPH C. SATTERTHWAITE
Joseph C. Satterthwaite was appointed a Foreign Service officer in 1926 after receiving
A.B. and A.M. degrees from the University of Michigan. He was Secretary of Embassy
in Ankara, 1940-44. In 1945 he was assigned to the Near Eastern Division of the
State Department. In 1946 he was named Special Assistant to the Director for Near
Eastern and African Affairs, in 1947 the Deputy Director, and from July 1948 to July
1949 he was Director for Near Eastern and African Affairs. Subsequently he served
as Ambassador to Ceylon, Diplomatic Agent in Tangier for Morocco, Ambassador to
Burma, Director General of the Foreign Service, Assistant Secretary of State for African
Affairs, and Ambassador to South Africa. He retired from the Foreign Service at the
end of 1965. Since then he has been a consultant on foreign affairs.
74
75
to cope with the crisis. General The recommendations were ready the
Marshall returned to his office Monday next day and the President approved
morning, read the British notes and the the paper for action. The next step was
background papers that had been pre- consultation with Congress, and the
pared for him, and received Lord President set up a meeting for the
Inverchapel at 10:00 A.M. The Ambas- next day.
sador left knowing that the Secretary The President, Marshall, and Acheson
fully appreciated the seriousness of the met the next morning with congressional
notes he had handed him. The Secre- leaders, headed by Senator Arthur
tary next instructed Acheson to take Vandenberg of Michigan who was both
responsibility for action from there on, Acting-President of the Senate-there
as he had to leave for Moscow in a week being no vice-president-and Chairman
for the meeting of the Council of For- of the Senate Foreign Relations Com-
eign Ministers and would be fully occu- mittee. He, with the President and
pied with preparations for the meeting. Acheson, was to play a key role in the
Acheson asked Henderson to head a success of what came to be called the
team working to prepare the necessary Truman Doctrine.
recommendations for the President, with After opening remarks by the Presi-
Hickerson as his principal assistant. dent and Secretary Marshall, Acheson
They, of course, maintained liaison made a reasoned and impassioned pre-
with the officials of the Pentagon pre- sentation of the seriousness of the crisis
paring the military aspects of the action facing the United States. He, with the
required. full backing of the President and Mar-
After the Cabinet luncheon that Mon- shall, was obviously successful in per-
day morning, the President met with suading the congressional leaders present
General Marshall, Secretary of War to give their support to the proposed
Robert Patterson, Secretary of the program for aid to Greece and Turkey.
Navy James Forrestal, Admiral Forrest Particularly important, they persuaded
Sherman, and General Lauris Norstad. Senator Vandenberg, who promised his
All except the President and Marshall support.
met with Acheson, Henderson, and
Hickerson in the Under Secretary’s office POSTWAR THREATS TO TURKEY FROM
THE SOVIET UNION
afterwards. &dquo;We agreed,&dquo; Acheson
wrote in Present at the Creation, Because Greece was the danger spot,
most of the ensuing discussions and
that the President and his principal advisers statements before the congressional com-
seemed convinced that it was vital to the mittees were concerned largely with that
security of the US for Greece and Turkey country, but always with some mention
to be strengthened to preserve their na-
of the equal importance of aiding
tional independence, that only the US
could do this, that funds and the authority Turkey; so mention might be made at
of Congress were necessary, and that State this point of the threats and pressures
would prepare for concurrence by War and from the Soviet Union to which Turkey
Navy specific recommendations for the had been exposed following World
President. General Marshall approving, War II.
Henderson and his staff worked with me When the writer returned to the
1
preparing the recommendations. United States in July 1945 for the first
time in more than five years, he found
1. Dean Acheson, Present at the Creation:
there was a feeling among many of the
My Years in the State Department (New
York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1969), p. 218. friends he met while on home leave that
77
the Soviet Union, our ally during the &dquo;Turkey will not be able to maintain in-
war, could be expected to co-operate definitely a defensive posture against the
with the Western world in solving grave Soviet Union. The burden is too great
for the nation’s economy to carry much
postwar problems. Upon reporting for
duty in the Division of Near East- longer.&dquo;
ern Affairs in September, however, he Thus with its experience of continuing
at once learned how unrealistic that Soviet pressures and the difficulties of
feeling was. modernizing its large army, Turkey
Thus Turkey already knew from So- found itself more than ready to welcome
viet claims on the border regions of Kars the assistance which the Truman Doc-
and Ardahan, and from Soviet demands trine promised.
for a new regime governing the Straits
that would have given Russia virtual PRESIDENT TRUMAN’S MESSAGE TO
control of them, that the Soviets had no
intention of letting up on these pressures,
CONGRESS, MARCH 12, 1947
and that its only protection was to Following the President’s meetings
maintain its army of more than five hun- with congressional leaders, the State De-
dred thousand men that had been mobi- partment, under the guidance of Dean
lized since the early days of World War Acheson and Loy Henderson, mobilized
II. all resources in drafting the required
Turkey had firmly rejected all these legislation and in preparing the public
Soviet proposals. To the renewed So- for what of the most important
was one
viet proposal of July 1946 for sole con- foreign policy decisions in our history.
trol of the Straits by the Black Sea Joseph M. Jones, the Press Officer, was
Powers, a proposal also repeated to the assigned to make the first draft of a mes-
United States, Great Britain, and sage which the President proposed to
France, the Turkish government again deliver in person before a joint session
said no, this time with the full backing of Congress. Acheson himself carried
of those Powers. President Truman in out the initial briefing of the press.
his Memoirs said that the answer to the The Message to Congress was deliv-
Soviet Union made it clear that if the ered by the President in person on
Straits should become the object of Rus- March 12, 1947. So important was it,
sian aggression, &dquo;the resulting situation enunciating as it did what came to be
would constitute a threat to interna- known as the Truman Doctrine, that
tional security and would clearly be a some of the paragraphs of his relatively
matter for action on the part of the Se- short address need to be repeated here.
curity Council.&dquo; Then Truman added: First the President described the So-
viet pressures being applied to Greece
The Turkish Government, encouraged by and Turkey, Greece’s deplorable eco-
the American attitude, rejected the Soviet nomic situation, its state of exhaustion,
demands and showed admirable determina- and the dangers to the free world should
tion to resist if Russia should resort to it collapse. Then he added:
open violence. But Turkey’s army, though
sizable, was poorly equipped and would I believe it must be the policy of the
have been no match for the battle-tested US to support free peoples who are re-
divisions of the Kremlin. sisting attempted subjugation by armed
More serious still was the drain which minorities or by outside pressures.
this continuous exertion made on the na- I believe that we must assist free peoples
tion’s economy. Toward the close of 1946 to work out their own destinies in their
our Ambassador reported from Ankara: own ways.
78
I believe that our help should be pri- thorization to detail American civilian
marily economic and financial, which is and military personnel to Greece and
essential to economic stability and orderly
Turkey, and that the instruction and
political processes.... training of selected Greek and Turkish
In helping free and independent nations
to maintain their freedom, the US will be
personnel also be authorized.
Senator Vandenberg, speaking to re-
giving effect to the Charter of the UN....
Should we fail to aid Greece and Turkey porters on the afternoon of the Presi-
in this fateful hour, the effect will be far- dent’s address was quoted as saying:
reaching to the West as well as to the East.
We must take immediate and resolute The President’s message faces facts and
action.2 so must Congress. The independence of
Greece and Turkey must be preserved, not
The relatively short part of the Presi- only for their own sakes, but also in de-
dent’s message concerning Turkey said: fense of peace and security for all of us.
In such a critical moment the President’s
The future of Turkey as an independent hand must be upheld. Any other course
and economically sound state is clearly no would be dangerously misunderstood. But
less important to the freedom-loving peo- Congress must carefully determine the
ples of the world than the future of Greece. methods and explore the details in so
Turkey has been spared the disasters that momentous a departure from our previous
have beset Greece. And during the war policies.8
the US and Great Britain furnished Turkey
with material aid. Congressional hearings
Nevertheless, Turkey needs our support. The day after the President’s address
Since the war Turkey has sought addi-
tional financial assistance from Great to Congress, the Senate Foreign Rela-
Britain and the US for the purpose of tions Committee began hearings on the
effecting that modernization necessary for proposed legislation. The Senate ap-
the maintenance of its national integrity. proved the bill, with amendments agree-
That integrity is essential for the able to the administration, on April 22
preservation of order in the Middle East. by a vote of 67 to 23. The hearings
The British Government has informed before the House Foreign Affairs Com-
us that, owing to its own difficulties, it can
mittee began on March 20. The House
no longer extend financial or economic aid
to Turkey.
approved the bill on May 8 by a vote of
As in the case of Greece, if Turkey is
287 to 107.
to have the assistance it needs, the US
On May 22, 1947, President Truman
must supply it. We are the only country signed the bill, which became known as
able to provide that help.... Public Law 75. On signing it he issued
The free peoples of the world look to us a statement which said, in part:
for support in maintaining their freedom.
If we falter in our leadership we may This act authorizing US aid to Greece
endanger the peace of the world and we and Turkey, which I have just signed, is
shall surely endanger the welfare of this an important step in the building of peace.
nation. Its passage by overwhelming majorities in
both Houses of Congress is proof that the
President Truman asked Congress, in US earnestly desires peace and is willing
addition to the funds requested-$400 to make a vigorous effort to help create
million for the period ending June 30, the conditions of peace.
1948, for Greece and Turkey-for au- The conditions of peace include, among
2. Harry S Truman, Memoirs, vol. 2, Years 3. Quoted in Joseph Marion Jones, The
of Trial and Hope (Garden City, N.Y.: Fifteen Weeks (February 21-June 5, 1947)
Doubleday & Co., 1955), pp. 97-98. (New York: Viking Press, 1955), p. 174.
79
other things, the ability of nations to main- key’s military needs was organized by
tain order and independence, and to sup- the Pentagon in May..It completed its
port themselves economically. In extend- survey in July.
ing the aid requested by states members But before an aid mission could be
of the UN for the purpose of maintain-
sent to Turkey, it was necessary to ne-
ing these conditions, the US is helping to
further aims and purposes identical with gotiate an aid agreement under the terms
those of the UN. Our aim in this instance of PL 75. Although the Turks fully
is evidence not only that we pledge our welcomed the prospect of our aid, certain
support to the UN but that we act to stipulations of that law caused them
support it. some difficulty because of their bitter
memories of the history of the capitula-
The references to the United Nations
in this statement
tions in Turkey. Fortunately, our Am-
no doubt were inspired
bassador to Turkey, Edwin C. Wilson,
by the fact that the strongest opposi-
who carried on the negotiation with the
tion to the draft that developed in Con-
Turkish Foreign Minister, Hasan Saka,
gress was because it seemed to many was exceptionally able and experienced.
members to bypass the United Nations.
The Turks’ objection to use of the word
For this reason our representative to the
administrator was solved by naming the
United Nations, Ambassador Warren
Ambassador chief of the mission, with
Austin, was instructed to make a state- the heads of the army, air force, navy,
ment assuring that body that this was
and roads groups having the title of
not the intent of the bill. Then Sena-
tor Vandenberg gained support for the
director.
More difficult was agreeing on lan-
bill with his amendment, which was ac-
guage which would meet the require-
cepted, instructing the President to with- ment in PL 75 of open access to the
draw all aid if the Security Council or
work of the mission not only to U.S.
the General Assembly found that U.N.
action had made the aid undesirable. officials, but to the press as well. This
So, with the adoption of PL 75 on problem was solved in the agreement
May 22 by the President’s signature, the signed at Ankara on July 12, 1947, by
Truman Doctrine became the law of the using in Article III the following lan-
land. He explains it in his Memoirs guage :
thus:
The Government of Turkey and the
I wished to state, for all the world to Government of the US will cooperate in
know, what the position of the US was in assuring the peoples of the US and Turkey
the face of the new totalitarian challenge. full information concerning the assistance
This declaration of policy soon began to be furnished pursuant to this agreement. To
referred to as &dquo;The Truman Doctrine.&dquo; this end, in so far as may be consistent
This was, I believe, the turning point in with the security of the two countries:
America’s foreign policy, which now de- (1) Representatives of the press and radio
clared that wherever aggression, direct or of the US will be permitted to observe
indirect, threatened the peace, the security fully regarding the utilization of such
of the US was involved.4 assistance; and (2) the Government of
Turkey will give full and continuous pub-
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE TURKISH licity within Turkey as to the purpose,
AID PROGRAM source, character, scope, amounts and
Little time was lost in implementing progress of such assistance.5
PL 75. A preliminary survey of Tur-
5. U.S., Congress, Senate, A Decade of
4. Truman, Years of Trial and Hope, pp. American Foreign Policy, Sen. Doc. No. 123,
105-6. 81st Cong., 1st sess. (1949), pp. 1265-66.
80
Even before the agreement was signed, ment and training, we would make it
the State Department had taken two possible for the Turkish government to
administrative steps to give needed sup- devote its resources to the restoration of
port to PL 75. An Office for the Coordi- the national economy. Another urgent
nation of Aid to Greece and Turkey was need was the construction of all-weather
approved. George C. McGhee, who had roads which not only would serve to
been Special Assistant to the Under Sec- strengthen the military, but would also
retary for Economic Affairs, was ap- assist in reviving Turkish agriculture.
pointed the Coordinator. These points were forcefully brought
Loy Henderson, Director for Near out in the messages of the President to
Eastern and African Affairs, received ap- Congress supporting the annual bills
proval to add a Division of Greek, Turk- authorizing continued aid to Greece and
ish, and Iranian Affairs. John D. Jerne- Turkey, and by the personal appearance
gan, who had done much of the spade before the Senate Foreign Relations and
work during the early planning stage of the House Foreign Affairs Committees
the program under Henderson, was of Under Secretary Acheson (who was
named the first Chief of the Division. Acting-Secretary on a number of such
The Turkish Aid Program ran so occasions and then, from 1949 to 1953,
smoothly once it got started that most Secretary), our Ambassadors to Turkey,
of the problems could be worked out by and the Directors of the military aid
McGhee and Jernegan and their staffs. groups. The importance that both the
This was fortunate for both Henderson Democratic and Republican (after Jan-
and the writer, who succeeded him in uary 1953) administrations attached to
July 1948, because of the many pressing continued assistance to Greece and Tur-
problems facing us at the time, such as key for the entire period of this article
Palestine, the Arab-Israeli war, and the is attested by the high level at which
dispute over Kashmir. attention has been given to it. Their
Major General Horace McBride was statements may be found in The Public
appointed Director of the army group Papers of the President and in the pub-
and got his mission under way in Turkey lished Hearings of both Committees.
early in 1948. By the end of October From the beginning of the Truman
of that year the total military and ci- Doctrine there was a feeling on the part
vilian personnel serving under the Chief of our Defense officials that funds spent
of the Mission (the Ambassador) was to support the Turkish armed forces
374. This had increased to 1364 per- accomplished more than aid spent any-
sons by April 1, 1952. where else. One of the generals just
back from Turkey near the beginning of
The military assistance program the program told the writer, &dquo;A dollar
It was clear from the inception of the in Turkey is worth two spent on mili-
Truman Doctrine that our aid to Tur- tary support anywhere else.&dquo; Actual
key should be directed at modernizing experience gained in implementing our
and training the Turkish army. More aid program in Turkey proved this to
than five hundred thousand men had be an understatement.
been mobilized since early 1940 at great On July 23, 1951, Major General Wil-
cost to the Turkish economy. But by liam H. Arnold, Director of the Joint
1947 this large force was woefully in- American Military Mission for As-
adequate to cope with the Soviet army. sistance to Turkey, told the House Com-
By furnishing the badly needed equip- mittee that in four years the Mission had
81
ing leaders in President Truman, Secre- the Senate Foreign Relations Commit-
tary of State Marshall and Under Sec- tee and Republican leader of the Senate,
retary Acheson. Although Marshall had played a vital role in persuading his Re-
passed responsibility for handling this publican colleagues to support the pro-
grave problem to Acheson and did not gram for aid to Greece and Turkey on
take it back, he gave it his full support a nonpartisan basis. He also displayed
from Moscow. A weaker man might great qualities of leadership. Both the
have postponed action so displeasing to Democratic administration and the Re-
the Soviet Union until after the Council publican Congress under such effective
of Foreign Ministers being held in Mos- leadership accepted the seriousness of
cow had adjourned. Acheson was Act- the problem facing our country with the
ing Secretary during much of the period announced withdrawal of British aid to
February 21-May 22, 1947. Acheson Greece and Turkey, and worked together
in turn gave principal action responsibil- as a team to develop what came to be