Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 1049@iet-Rpg 2018 6106
10 1049@iet-Rpg 2018 6106
Research Article
Abstract: In order to maximise the power from a harvester including a great number of piezoelectric transducers (PZTs), the
outputs of these transducers should be connected in a suitable way. Since each PZT can be thought of as a non-ideal source, it
is also clear that direct serial connection or parallel connection of these PZTs will not be a very good strategy. In this study, a
new circuit topology is proposed for the electric connection between PZTs in a harvester including a great number of PZTs. This
proposed circuit topology at the same time presents an efficient rectification and regulation strategy for each PZT used. The
process of rectification takes place with minimum voltage loss due to the structure of the proposed circuit topology. In addition,
the output of the proposed circuit topology can be used directly to charge an energy storage unit in addition to being connected
to the input of any interface circuit. An experimental setup was designed to compare the performance of circuit topology
proposed in this study in the form of connection used commonly in the literature. With this experimental setup used, various
connection forms and the proposed circuit topology were compared under the same conditions.
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2019, Vol. 13 Iss. 12, pp. 2105-2110 2105
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019
directions in a piezoelectric ceramic element, a specific coordinate
system is used. Three axes are defined, termed 1, 2, and 3,
analogous to X, Y, and Z of the classical three-dimensional
orthogonal set of axes. Thus, (1) can be rewritten based on the
direction of the effect. The directions that can be used are given in
Fig. 2.
Another parameter for piezoelectric energy harvesting is the
working mode. These modes are expressed as dij. The suffix
denotes the direction of polarisation and direction of induced
stress, respectively. The most common modes considered are d31
and d33. This study is based on d33 mode. Since piezoelectric
materials are fragile materials, except for some special
Fig. 2 Directions that are used in piezoelectric calculations
applications, they are not suitable for 2, 4 and 6 directions sensor
and transducer applications. The reason why 31 and 33 directions
were used results from the structural characteristics of piezoelectric
materials.
An important parameter described for piezoelectric energy
harvesting systems is coupling coefficient k2. This parameter can
be expressed mathematically as follows:
Fig. 3 General equivalent circuit of a piezoelectric energy harvester supplied electrical energy
k2 = (2)
stored mechanical energy
Fig. 4 Standard energy harvesting circuit 2.1 Circuit topologies for optimisation of piezoelectric energy
harvesting
from wind energy. Piezoelectric materials shaped as an elastic Efficient transfer of the electrical power obtained from a
string were used in this generator [10]. These generators were piezoelectric energy harvester depends on the performance of the
tested for 2–17 m/s wind speed interval and the greatest output interface circuit between the source and the load. The standard
voltage was found as 34 V. When 15 kW load was connected, 1.73 circuit used for piezoelectric materials is shown in Fig. 4 [15].
mW energy was found to be generated for 17 m/s wind speed. However, the efficiency of the standard energy harvesting
However, the interest in the use of PZTs for W–kW energy circuit is low due to the voltage drop of the diodes and the load
generation has been on the increase recently. Viet et al. designed a mismatch seen at the output of the transducer [16]. For a more
generator that could generate energy from ocean tide and wind efficient energy harvesting, the standard energy harvesting circuit
flow and work on the basis of piezoelectric energy conversion [11]. should be improved. The first improvement that can be done is
According to simulation results, this generator has a capacity to reducing the forward voltage drop. To do this, passive diodes can
generate 5 kW energy for ocean tide of 1.75 m/s speed. It can be be replaced with Schottky diodes. Schottky diodes show lower
predicted that with developing technology and with the voltage drop when compared with passive diodes. However, their
development of PZTs with higher power generation potential and implementation is expensive, due to extra fabrication steps as they
efficient circuit topologies, there will be a very big increase in kW are not available in standard complementary metal oxide
and greater scale energy generation studies. semiconductor (CMOS) processes [17]. Another alternative
solution to this problem is using CMOS rectifier designs. There are
2 Fundamentals of piezoelectric energy different rectifier circuit topologies proposed to increase energy
harvesting harvesting yield in the literature [18–20]. Conventional active
rectifiers that decrease voltage drop and increase system efficiency
According to IEEE standards, piezoelectric constitutive equations are usually powered from the output. This causes the emergence of
for linear piezoelectricity are as given below [12] another problem. A major drawback of the conventional active
rectifiers is that these rectifiers consume energy from the output
T = cE S − e E , storage capacitor even when the system is not harvesting any
(1) energy. In addition, the energy that a PZT will generate will be
D = e S + εS E ,
quite low alone. It will be necessary to use a great number of PZTs
in a piezoelectric energy harvester to generate high levels of energy
where [T], [S], [E], and [D] are, respectively, the stress vector, the that can be used. In this case, electrical connection between these
strain vector, the electric field vector, and the electrical induction convertors will have to be made in a way that will increase the
vector. On the other hand, [cE], [e] and [ɛS] are the physical output power. Circuit topologies proposed in the literature do not
properties of piezoelectric material and they are, respectively, the recommend a method for the electrical connection between more
elastic stiffness matrix determined at a constant electric field, the than one PZT. It is also not possible to operate each piezoelectric
piezoelectric stress matrix and the permittivity matrix at a constant element at its own resonance frequency in systems including more
strain. than one piezoelectric element. This means that there will be phase
The type of stress applied on a piezoelectric material being differences between the current and voltages these elements will
compressive or tensile stress does not have an effect on the generate. For this reason, it is clear that it will not be a good
magnitude of the output voltage produced. The type of stress method to connect more than one piezoelectric element directly or
applied being compressive or tensile stress is associated with the as series or parallel. The circuit topology proposed in this study
direction of output voltage [13]. Since the thickness of material presents a useful way to connect more than one PZT to each other
used in commercial PZTs is between 10 and 150 μm, PZTs are not to increase output power with the least loss possible. In addition,
suitable for use under biaxial stress. the output of the proposed circuit topology can also be connected
Owing to the anisotropic nature of piezoelectric materials, their to any interface circuit as input. Fig. 5 shows the most commonly
physical characteristics differ based on direction. To identify
2106 IET Renew. Power Gener., 2019, Vol. 13 Iss. 12, pp. 2105-2110
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019
used rectifier circuit topologies used with piezoelectric energy
harvesters [18].
All of the piezoelectric energy harvesters include one rectifier.
This rectified voltage is used to charge an energy storage unit.
There has to be impedance matching between piezoelectric energy
harvester and output load as required by the maximum power
transfer law to transfer the power from PZTs efficiently to load. In
some circuit topologies used for this matching, a DC–DC converter
is connected between the rectifier output and the load [21].
However, circuit topologies, which use a non-linear switching
process in which the output voltage of piezoelectric element is
increased artificially to increase power flow, are also used
commonly in the literature. For all of the circuit topologies used for
energy harvesting, the number of elements used poses a problem in
general because as the number of elements increases, voltage drops
on these elements and the energy spent by these elements will
cause the total efficiency to decrease. For this reason, in systems, Fig. 5 Full-wave rectifier topologies
which include more than one piezoelectric element, using separate (a) Passive diode rectifier, (b) Diode-tied metal oxide semiconductor field effect
energy harvesting circuit topologies for each piezoelectric element transistor rectifier, (c) Gate cross-coupled N-type metal oxide semiconductor rectifier,
is a very big disadvantage in terms of both system efficiency and (d) Cross-coupled rectifier, (e) Active rectifier with cross-coupled P-type metal oxide
cost. Thus, for high output power, piezoelectric elements as many semiconductor switches
as possible should be brought together with a suitable
electromechanical coupling coefficient and electrical connection.
System output that consists of piezoelectric elements brought
together like this can be connected to the input of a suitable
harvesting circuit.
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2019, Vol. 13 Iss. 12, pp. 2105-2110 2107
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019
Fig. 8 Sample circuit given for the analysis of the proposed topology
Fig. 12 Printed circuit board of the proposed circuit topology fabricated
for four PZTs
3.1 Experiments compare the circuit topology presented in this study with standard
connections used.
A vibration machine was designed and fabricated to assess the
The purpose of the experiments conducted is not to obtain an
performance of the proposed circuit topology. The purpose of this
output power as high as possible from the PZTs used. In
machine is not to obtain maximum output power from PZTs, but to
experiments conducted for different operating frequencies, it was
compare the proposed circuit topology with other connection types
found that output voltages of PZTs caused the same rates of
under the same conditions. For this reason, the fabricated vibration
increase and decrease independently in connection types. For this
machine has a very simple structure. This vibration machine, which
reason, in order to be able to show the results in a more
has a vibration motor to vibrate a 10 × 10 mm and 3 mm thick
comprehensible way, the same operating frequency was used for all
plaque including four diaphragm type PZTs with a diameter of 3
experiments. This operating frequency was determined as 200 Hz.
cm, four screws and four springs covered outside these screws is
In addition, since the main purpose was to compare the connection
shown in Fig. 11.
types used and the proposed circuit topologies for the same
The vibration frequency of the system can be increased and
conditions, standard energy harvesting circuit given in Fig. 4 was
decreased with the supply voltage of the DC motor used. The
used in all experiments. In the first experiment, the output of
motor used is a DC motor with permanent magnet and it has an
serially connected four PZTs was used to charge 100 μF output
operating voltage of 2–12 V. 15 g weight was installed on the
capacitor through a bridge rectifier. The serial connection type used
motor shaft for vibration. Rotation speed for 12 V operating
is shown in Fig. 14.
voltage is 12,500 rpm.
The voltage that occurred on output capacitor in the case of
The outputs of the PZTs in the system given in Fig. 11 were
serial connection of PZTs is given in Fig. 15.
transferred outside the system with the help of cables for required
The maximum value of the voltage stored on output capacitor
external connections and the external connections were built
when PZTs were serially connected was 8.2 V in the 38th second.
outside the vibration machine. The printed circuit board of the
In the second experiment conducted, PZTs were parallel connected
proposed circuit topology is seen in Fig. 12.
as seen in Fig. 16.
BAT85 Schottky diodes were used to rectify the voltages
Fig. 17 shows the voltage on the output capacitor when PZTs
generated by PZTs. The reason for this is the fact that the forward
were parallelly connected.
voltage drops on these diodes are much smaller than standard
diodes. The experimental setup given in Fig. 13 was used to
2108 IET Renew. Power Gener., 2019, Vol. 13 Iss. 12, pp. 2105-2110
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019
Fig. 14 Serial connection of PZTs
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2019, Vol. 13 Iss. 12, pp. 2105-2110 2109
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019
obtained from the proposed circuit topology. Two different cases 5 References
should be mentioned here. As is known, charging time of a
[1] Dineva, P.S., Gross, D., Müller, R., et al.: ‘Dynamic fracture of piezoelectric
capacitor is dependent on ‘τ’ time constant. This time constant materials’, Solid mechanics and its applications, vol. 212 (Springer
changes depending on the load voltage and capacitor value. As the International Publishing, Switzerland, 2014), doi:
value of the capacitor used increases, so will the value of this time 10.1007/978-3-319-03961-9_2
constant. For this reason, maximum output voltage in the proposed [2] Gautschi, G., Sensorics, P.: ‘Force strain pressure acceleration and acoustic
emission sensors materials and amplifiers’ (Springer Science & Business
circuit topology depends on this circuit's equivalent capacitor value Media, Zurich, Switzerland, 2013), ISNB 9783662047323
and the internal voltage of the circuit. While a capacitor of 100 μF [3] Roundy, S., Wright, P.K., Rabaey, J.: ‘A study of low level vibrations as a
is used in all experiments as an output capacitor, since the power source for wireless sensor nodes’, Comput. Commun., 2003, 26, (11),
equivalent of the internal capacitors in the proposed circuit pp. 1131–1144
[4] Jeon, Y.B., Sood, R., Jeong, J.-H., et al.: ‘MEMS power generator with
topology will be parallelly connected to the output capacitor, an transverse mode thin film PZT’, Sens. Actuators A, 2005, 122, (1), pp. 16–22,
equivalent capacitor value for the proposed circuit topology will ISSN 0924-4247
always be higher than 100 μF. This, in turn, means that the time [5] Renaud, M., Karakaya, K., Sterken, T., et al.: ‘Fabrication, modelling and
output capacitor reaches the maximum output voltage will increase. characterization of MEMS piezoelectric vibration harvesters’, Sens. Actuators
A, Phys., 2008, 145–146, pp. 380–386
However, since the current from the circuit will flow over [6] Dai, X., Wen, Y., Li, P., et al.: ‘Modeling, characterization and fabrication of
transducers in the case of transducers being serially connected, it vibration energy harvester using terfenol-D/PZT/terfenol-D composite
will come across high impedance and more losses will occur in the transducer’, Sens. Actuators A, Phys., 2009, 156, (2), pp. 350–358
output voltage. This is the reason why the highest output voltage [7] Chen, G., Meng, Q., Fu, H., et al.: ‘Development and experiments of a micro
piezoelectric vibration energy storage device’, Mech. Syst. Signal Process.,
will be reached in the proposed circuit topology. 2013, 40, (1), pp. 377–384
[8] Akkaya Oy, S., Özdemir, A.E.: ‘Piezoelectric based low power wind
generator design and testing’, Arab. J. Sci. Eng., 2018, 43, (6), pp. 2759–2767
4 Conclusions [9] Zhang, J., Fang, Z., Shu, C., et al.: ‘A rotational piezoelectric energy
This study introduces a circuit topology both to rectify PZT outputs harvester for efficient wind energy harvesting’, Sens. Actuators A, Phys.,
2017, 262, pp. 123–129
with the least loss and to connect these outputs effectively. The [10] Zhao, J., Yang, J., Lin, Z., et al.: ‘An arc-shaped piezoelectric generator for
proposed circuit topology is a useful method for all applications multi-directional wind energy harvesting’, Sens. Actuators A, Phys., 2015,
that include more than one PZT. In addition, the proposed circuit 236, pp. 173–179
topology prevents PZTs to drain current through each other. This [11] Viet, N.V., Al-Qutayri, M., Liew, K.M., et al.: ‘An octo-generator for energy
harvesting based on the piezoelectric effect’, Appl. Ocean Res., 2017, 64, pp.
way, it is also prevented for a part of the generated energy to be 128–134
spent on PZTs. The experiments conducted and standard [12] IEEE Standard on Piezoelectricity, ANSI/IEEE Std 176-1987, 1988
connection types and the proposed circuit topology were compared [13] Moheimani, S.O.R., Fleming, A.J.: ‘Piezoelectric transducers for vibration
and found that the proposed topology increased the output voltage control and damping’ (Springer-Verlag, London, 2006)
[14] Li, Y.: ‘Simple techniques for piezoelectric energy harvesting optimization’,
between 40 and 80% when compared with other methods. In the Electronics. INSA de Lyon, 2014. English. NNT: 2014ISAL0077
experiments conducted, while the maximum voltage value of 8.2 [15] Lefeuvre, E., Badel, A., Richard, C., et al.: ‘A comparison between several
was reached in the 38th second for serial connection, the voltage vibration-powered piezoelectric generators for standalone systems’, Sens.
value on output capacitor was measured as 10.1 V in the proposed Actuators A, Phys., 2006, 126, (2), pp. 405–416
[16] Ramadass, Y., Chandrakasan, A.: ‘An efficient piezoelectric energy
circuit topology within the same period of time. Similarly, while harvesting interface circuit using a bias-flip rectifier and share inductor’,
the voltage value of the output capacitor was 2.2 V in the 14th IEEE J. Solid-State Circuit, 2010, 45, (1), pp. 189–204
second for parallel connection, this value was measured as 4.8 V [17] Hashemi, S., Sawan, M., Savaria, Y.: ‘A novel low-drop CMOS active
for the proposed circuit topology. Lastly, while the maximum value rectifier for RF-powered devices: experimental results’, Microelectron. J.,
2009, 40, (11), pp. 1547–1554
of the voltage of the output capacitor was 4.6 V in the 36th second [18] Szarka, G.D., Stark, B.H., Burrow, S.G.: ‘Review of power conditioning for
for serial–serial–parallel connection, this value was measured as kinetic energy harvesting systems’, IEEE Trans. Power Electron., 2012, 27,
9.9 V for the proposed circuit topology within the same period of (2), pp. 803–815, doi: 10.1109/TPEL.2011.2161675
time. In short, it was found that the speed of increase of the voltage [19] Sauer, C., Stanacevic, M., Cauwenberghs, G., et al.: ‘Power harvesting and
telemetry in CMOS for implant devices’, IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I, 2005,
of the output capacitor was found to be greater than all other 52, (12), pp. 2605–2613
methods with the proposed circuit topology in all of the [20] Peters, C., Kessling, O., Henrici, F., et al.: ‘CMOS integrated highly efficient
experiments conducted. Another important point of the result is full wave rectifier’. 2007 IEEE Int. Symp. on Circuits and Systems, New
that the proposed topology was not influenced by the operating Orleans, LA, 2007, pp. 2415–2418, doi: 10.1109/ISCAS.2007.377947
[21] Guyomar, D., Badel, A., Lefeuvre, E., et al.: ‘Toward energy harvesting using
frequency and phases of PZTs. If PZTs in any piezoelectric energy active materials and conversion improvement by nonlinear processing’, IEEE
harvester are working in different frequency and/or phases, there Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Control, 2005, 52, (4), pp. 584–595, doi:
may occur great decline in the output voltage of the system. In 10.1109/TUFFC.2005.1428041
order to prevent this, each PZT should be rectified with a bridge [22] Du, S., Jia, Y., Zhao, C., et al.: ‘A passive design scheme to increase the
rectified power of piezoelectric energy harvesters’, IEEE Trans. Ind.
rectifier and in this case, a great part of the voltage generated by Electron., 2018, 65, (9), pp. 7095–7105
PZTs will be spent through diodes within bridge rectifiers. [23] Wang, W., Yang, T., Chen, X., et al.: ‘Vibration energy harvesting using a
However, the proposed circuit topology is immune to the operating piezoelectric circular diaphragm array’, IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr.
frequency and phases of PZTs in the energy harvester. However, Freq. Control, 2012, 59, (9), pp. 2022–2026
[24] Du, S., Jia, Y., Seshia, A.A.: ‘An efficient inductorless dynamically
the proposed circuit topology can be used not only for PZTs but configured interface circuit for piezoelectric vibration energy harvesting’,
also to connect transducer outputs of many different types in many IEEE Trans. Power Electron., 2017, 32, (5), pp. 3595–3609, doi: 10.1109/
different systems. TPEL.2018.2873079
[25] Lu, Q., Liu, L., Scarpa, F., et al.: ‘A novel composite multi-layer piezoelectric
energy harvester’, Compos. Struct., 2018, 201, pp. 121–130
[26] Jasim, A., Yesner, G., Wang, H., et al.: ‘Laboratory testing and numerical
simulation of piezoelectric energy harvester for roadway applications’, Appl.
Energy, 2018, 224, pp. 438–447
[27] https://www.multisim.com/content/LEDTBBtD6uwxqiuSDTN6gE/
dogrultucu/open/, accessed 7 November 2018
2110 IET Renew. Power Gener., 2019, Vol. 13 Iss. 12, pp. 2105-2110
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2019