Fbess - 25

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

ID 395

Contribution of Architecture on Juvenile Rehabilitation Process in Sri


Lanka
HMYM Abeywardhane# and DWK Gayantha

Faculty of Built Environment & Spatial Sciences, General Sir John Kotelawala Defence University, Sri Lanka
#yohanabeywardane@gmail.com

Abstract— The process of reintegrating Keywords: juveniles, rehabilitation, architectural


juveniles to society from juvenile rehabilitation attributes
facilities is as important as the process of
I. INTRODUCTION
rehabilitation. If the rehabilitation process is not
conducted properly it would rather be difficult to A. Healing Process and built environment
control the reconvicted/recidivism rates. Hence, Human beings have an inner connection with the
the rehabilitation methods must adhere to environment by physical, mental, emotional and
certain attributes relating to the rehabilitation spiritual means. This connection with our
process, one key aspect being the built environment is the key in keeping a balance
environment of the rehabilitation facilities. within ourselves. Healing does not limit to
Humans by nature have an undeniable psychology or medicine. By the definition itself,
connection with their environment through healing is the process of re-establishing harmony
physical, mental, emotional and spiritual means. within the organism. In our built environment we
This connection helps to keep a balance within often interact with the buildings without even
ourselves. Most of the time, unlike adults, realizing the great influence such built
juveniles commit crimes or become victims environments and surroundings hold. This great
without their own will. It is of paramount power holds influence in our lives for good or
importance that this is understood and they are bad, happy or sad, stressed or relaxed in every
attended with the required special attention in physical, emotional and spiritual way. This
the rehabilitation process. At the stage of natural state, when in check or harmonies allows
admission to the rehabilitation facilities, these our body to be in both mentally and physically
youngsters are more likely to be in a very weak healthy state. Architecture has various
state of mind, with the need of protection, self- definitions from different points of view. It
value, freedom, and to obtain the sense of always deals with the built environment and can
belongingness in the society as they are be described it as an art of composing meaningful
reintroduced. This requires improvement of spaces.
interpersonal and intrapersonal skills before
leaving the correctional facility to avoid B. Juvenile rehabilitation
reconviction/recidivism. The rehabilitation The term juvenile in common dialect could be
process influenced by architectural attributes defined as a child or a young person who is in age
was followed in this research would be to below 18. It can also be defined as a child or an
understand by location and site planning, spatial adolescent between childhood and
organization, provision amenities, supervision man/womanhood. (Niriella) According to the
and security and visual character. In the Sri world health organization definition of the
Lankan context, it shows that most of the rehabilitation refers to “the combined and
juveniles from facilities that have considered coordinated use of medical, social, educational
these architectural attributes show comfort and vocational measures for training the
when reintegrating with the society as adults individual to a highest level of functional ability”.
whereas others from contradicting facilities In Sri Lanka, there is a number of juveniles who
show difficulties when reintegrating with the are although under the guardianship and the
society as adults. custody of parents but were neglected, involving

232
in antisocial behaviour or becoming a prey for functioning under the Ministry of Women and
crimes which the relevant authorities should pay Child Affairs since 2015. There are appointed
their serious attention. It should be noted that the commissioners in all 9 provinces covering the
juvenile generation is a vital social entity who entire island.
will eventually grow up to take over the
According to them, they have classified children’s
responsibility of the future of any country.
homes as below,
Therefore, it is very important to build a good
physical and psychological condition within Voluntary Homes
them. And their education, vocation and the Remand homes
future programmes need to be ensured.
Therefore, through the authorities, these Certified schools
children are admitted into juvenile rehabilitation Detention homes
facilities for rehabilitation.
State Receiving homes
C. Legislation and Procedures
Approved schools
Since 1939 Sri Lanka had has separate legislation
governing the administration of juvenile justice. And there are some international organizations
Children and Young Person’s Ordinance (CYPO) which are also providing care, protection and
1939 was introduced for children age under 16. shelter for these children. After the court
Children who are in conflict with law and procedures, the department of probation and
children in need protection deals with following childcare services admit juveniles into these
ordinance. In present situation there are several facilities. One of these organizations is,
legislative enactments which currently deal with SOS Children’s Villages
the law relating to juveniles.
II. OBJECTIVES
The Children and Young Persons Ordinance
To identify the relation between rehabilitation
(CYPO) No. 48 of 1939
and reintegration process and built environment
Youthful Offenders (Training Schools) Ordinance
To identify the architectural attributes which
No.28 of 1939
effect on rehabilitation and reintegration process
Probation of Offenders Ordinance No. 42 of 1944 of juveniles
Penal Code Act No. 2 of 1882 To study the architectural character in juvenile
Code of Criminal Procedure Act No. 15 of 1979 rehabilitation facilities in Sri Lanka

Prison Ordinance No. 16 of 1877 (also contain To identify the architectural contribution on
some special legal provisions applicable to rehabilitation and reintegration process of
juvenile offenders) juveniles

However, CYPO is out of date and fails to fulfil the III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
standards of CRC (United Nations Convention on This research follows both qualitative and
the Rights of the Child 1989); therefore, there is quantitative methods. The qualitative part will
a growing need of reformation of the system. The follow a literature survey done on the principles
National Child Protection Authority has taken a of environmental psychology and the child
leadership role in the process of reviewing and psychological theories related to the built
revising the legislation. (UNICEF, 2006) environment that will enable a view on legal
D. Juvenile Rehabilitation Facilities in Sri Lanka background of the juvenile delinquency and
existing correctional methods and correctional
The department of Probation and Childcare institutes whilst also identifying the correct
Services is providing care, protection and shelter architectural attributes which are already
for orphaned, abandoned, destitute and abused applied in local and foreign examples. And the
children in Children homes in the entire country. quantitative part is obtained via questionnaires.
The administration of these services has been The questionnaire will be based on the theories

233
from the literature survey, analysing the social v. Scale and shape of the
and psychological behaviour of the inmates. spaces related to the
Onsite interviews will also be conducted with the functions
children and respective guardians of the
vi. Sports and
children. After choosing case studies, the
recreational facilities
correctional institutes will be inspected via visual
Provision of
and photographic survey. The exterior facades, vii. Skill acquisition
amenities
special progression and other main architectural facilities
aspects such as conditions of natural light and
viii. Religious facilities
ventilations, colours, textures will mainly be
examined in the onsite survey. The measured ix. Visibility of the
Supervision corridors, pathways
plans and sections will also be taken into account.
and Security
Afterwards there will be a comparison between x. Number of blind spots
the correct architectural attributions and current
attributes in case studies. And finally provide a xi. Architectural
design solution with suitable examples for the Visual language
correctional institutes. character xii. Colours, Textures and
IV. DATA ANALYSIS Materials

The scheme of analysis for this study focusses on


attributes which effect on rehabilitation process To check the perspective of the child about the
and the rehabilitation and reintegration of the built environment of the facility, the list of
juveniles. There are main two parts in the statements was listed related to the literature
analysis to understand the following aspects; review.
Architectural attributes in the facility List of statements
Perception of the primary user on the facility The facility is isolated from the community and
A list of architectural parameters synthesised promotes the image of punishment
from the literature review will be used to The landscaping of the facility is pleasing and
understand the architectural attributes in the encourage outdoor activities
facilities and a list of statements are synthesized
to perceive the perception of the primary user on The layout of facilities and circulation system
the facility. Following figure below presents the encourage active participation
parameters synthesized from the literature Adequate sports and recreational facilities are
review on the architectural attributes, which will provided to prevent idleness and antisocial
be studied under the case studies through a behaviour
visual survey.
The presence of common facilities encourages
healthy social interaction
Table 9. Architectural Attributes I feel normal being watched at the facility
i. Respond to the micro The visual characteristic of the building is
Location and context pleasing and inspiring
Site plan ii. Respond to the macro The interior colours of the buildings are pleasing
context
The design promotes the image of incarceration,
iii. Identification of beggary and contribute to depression
functions
Special
Organization iv. Physical, visual
V. CASE STUDIES
connection with the
outdoor A. SOS Children’s Village - Piliyandala

234
In December 1981 SOS children’s Village in
Piliyandala was established as the first ever SOS
village in Sri Lanka. It was established with 16
family houses in the village. First, a group of
mothers were trained by local NGO named
Saravodaya and then moved to the village with
the children as family units. Up to now the village
has been accommodating three generations of
families and at present it accommodates 135
children in 16 families as fourth generation. In
the past 35 years the facility has successfully
integrated more than 307 children into society.

Figure 27. Courtyard arrangement between


house units – SOS Children’s Village –
Piliyandala [Drawing] (Source –By Author)

B. SOS Youth Facility for Boys – Piliyandala

This facility is a non-government juvenile


rehabilitation facility and also a part of a SOS
village. This was the first facility built for the SOS
youth in Sri Lanka and could accommodate up to
40 youth who are yet in high school. The Youth
Facility is situated on the far end of the 15 acres
that is the campus for the Children’s Village and

Figure 26. Plan of House – SOS Children’s


Village- Piliyandala [Drawing](Source –By
Author)

1.Front Porch 2.Living Area


3.Dining Ares 4.Kitchen
5.Mother’s bedroom6.Children’s
Bedrooms (nos. 03)
7.Washroom 8. Backyard

Figure 3. Section & Plan of children’s Accommodation


Area - SOS Youth Facility for Boys – Piliyandala
[Drawing] (Source – By Author)

235
all other projects at Piliyandala. The building was 3. Dining areas 4. Library
designed by Archit. C. Anjalenden and it was
5. Kitchen 6. Storages
established in 1989. The facility is a part of SOS
village and after the age of fourteen the boys are
moved to this facility from the SOS children’s D. Case Study: 04 – Voluntary Home
village.
This facility is a non-government juvenile
7. Classroom 9. Common Area rehabilitation facility and also funded by a
13. Bedrooms 14. Washroom foreigner, the facility has been registered under
the department of probation and childcare
17. Open to sky
services. Therefore, the children in the facility
courtyard
and the administrative functions are monitored
by the probation officers. This facility was
established in 1999. The building was initially a
C. Certified School – Hikkaduwa
residential unit which was later converted into a
The certified school at the Hikkaduwa was rehabilitation facility. With time they have added
established in 1952 as the first Sri Lankan child new parts for the building following necessary
rehabilitation facility later converted into the requirement. The facility accommodates 22 girls
first certified school in the country. Initially the aged between 10 to 18 years.
facility was named as “Lake School” referring to
its context. The land of the facility is surrounded
by a lagoon. The vision of the facility is to bring
the children who were offended to the correct
path, under orders directed from the jurisdiction.
The mission of the facility is to rehabilitate and
reintegrate the boys who are admitted from the
jurisdiction at age between 12 to 16, and boys
who need special protection. At the present
facility, 55 boys are accommodated. The area of
the land is 14 acres and the facility

Figure 5. Voluntary Home Plan [Drawing] (Source –


By Author)
1. Veranda 2. Office room
3. Living 4. Bedroom
5. Kitchen 6. Storages
7. Study area 8. Utility
9. Dining area 10. Store
11. Kitchen 12. Working Space
13. Guard room 14. Toilets
/Bathing

VI. RESULTS

Figure 4. Plan of Manor – Certified School at Table 10. Summary of Survey Results
Hikkaduwa [Drawing] (Source – By Author)
Location and Site Planning
1. Administration 2. Lecture Hall
Integrate into community

236
Deinstitutionalized and homely built Playgroun Playgroun Playgrou Play
environment ds and ds and nd has area
play areas indoor provided has
SOS SOS Certified Voluntar
were games provid
Village Youth school y home
provided were ed
facility
provided
Integrated Integra Isolated Less
Skill Skill Skill Skill
with the ted from the integrate
acquisitio acquisitio acquisiti acquisi
communit with communi d with the
n facilities n facilities on tion
y the ty communi
were were facilities facilitie
commu ty
provided provided were s were
nity
provided provid
Deinstituti Enviro Environ Environm ed
onalized nment ment ent
Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Religio
and appeal appeals appeals
shrine has shrine has shrine us
homely s normal less
provided provided has facility
built homely and homely
provided has not
environme institutio
but not in provid
nt nal
use ed
Spatial Organization
Allow for surveillance
Supervision and Security
Functional clusters or linear sequence
Avoid blind spots
SOS SOS Certified Voluntar
Promote freedom and unobtrusive
Village Youth school y home
supervision
facility
SOS SOS Certified Volunt
Central Aids Separate Aids
Village Youth school ary
courtyard supervi surveilla supervisi
facility home
plan which sion nce on and
aids and required surveillan Openness Openness Abundan Avoid
supervisio surveill for ce, need and and t blind
n and ance different to courtyards courtyard buildings spots,
surveillanc buildings improve avoid s avoid , attics, but
e ment blind spots blind spot forest need to
areas improv
Arranged Linear No No
provide e
around the sequen identifica identifica
blind
main ce tion of tion of
spots
space functiona functions
l clusters Promote Promote Promote Demot
freedom freedom freedom e
Provision of Amenities
and and and freedo
Sports and recreational facilities unobtrusiv unobtrusi unobtrus m by
e ve ive the
Skill acquisition facilities
supervisio supervisio supervisi rampar
Religious facilities n n on t
SOS SOS Certified Volunt Visual Character
Village Youth school ary
Inspiring and foster self esteem
facility home

237
Familiar, homelike environment Statement The visual characteristic of the
07 building is pleasing and
Eliminate image of incarceration/ punishment
inspiring
or beggary
Statement The interior colours of the
SOS SOS Certified Volunt
08 buildings are pleasing
Village Youth school ary
facility home Statement The design promotes the image
09 of incarceration, beggary and
Inspiring Inspiring uninspiri uninsp
contribute to depression.
and foster and foster ng and iring
self self foster
esteem esteem humble
Table 12. Summary of interview results
homelike homelike Prison Institut
SOS SOS Certifi Volunt
environme environm environ ional
villag youth ed ary
nt ent ment enviro
e Number
school home
nment
Number of Number Number
Eliminate Eliminate Image of Image of Participa of of
image of image of incarcera of Particip nts 40 Participa Participa
incarcerati incarcerat tion/ beggar ants 50 nts 50 nts 22

on/ ion/ punishm y Statem None None 48 15


punishme punishme ent or ent 01
(0%) (0%) (96%) (68.2%
nt or nt or beggary
)
beggary beggary
Statem 40 35 12 10
ent 02
(80%) (87.5% (24%) (45.4%
) )
Summary of Interview results
Statem 45 38 8 9
Table 11. List of Statements ent 03
(90%) (95%) (16%) (40.9%
Statement The facility is isolated from the )
01 community and promotes the
Statem 50 40 44 17
image of punishment
ent 04
(100 (100% (80%) (77.27
Statement The landscaping of the facility is
%) ) %)
02 pleasing and encourage
outdoor activities Statem 48 35 20 12
ent 05
Statement The layout of facilities and (96%) (87.5% (40%) (54.5%
03 circulation system encourage ) )
active participation
Statem 3 2 50 16
Statement Adequate sports and ent 06
(6%) (5%) (100% (72.7%
04 recreational facilities are
) )
provided to prevent idleness
and antisocial behaviour Statem 47 38 14 14
ent 07
Statement The presence of common (94%) (95%) (28%) (63.6%
05 facilities encourages healthy )
social interaction
Statem 48 38 11 16
Statement I feel normal being watched at ent 08
(96%) (95%) (22%) (72.7%
06 the facility )

238
Statem None 01 49 20 architectural attributes that has affected in the
ent 09 rehabilitation process much more positively than
(0%) (2.5%) (98%) (90.9%
the others; certified school and voluntary home.
)
According to the interview results juveniles at
the SOS facilities have good impression and
better psychological state comparing to the
VII. CONCLUSION
certified school and voluntary home. SOS
Unlike adults, when a child is admitted into a facilities show that the architectural attributes
rehabilitation facility there is a high chance of helped to improve and enhance the rehabilitating
that child being a victim of depravation and and reintegration process through both visual
derogation. Due to that, the juvenile may have survey and interviews. The facility has been
adoptive problems to strange place. Therefore, it designed specifically for the main user. And the
is a necessity to launch gradual and juveniles who are released as adults to the
methodological adaptation methods with society have a good image among the society and
adaptation systems. Through research, they are properly integrating. According to the
psychologists and environment behaviour SOS facility records, these children have good
studies have recognized the role of the built achievements in both education and
environment in behaviour control. The studies extracurricular activities. Most of them are
prove that the built environment can support or having good marriages and the proper higher
inhibit human behaviour change. It also affects education. When considering certified school at
cognitive behaviours of an individual, and an Hikkaduwa, the architectural character of the
understanding about this relationship can help to main building appears unnecessarily powerful
determine and predict the activity and behaviour and intimidates the juveniles in the facility. And
of its users. Positive behavioural interventions the character of the accommodation buildings
help to prevent juveniles from engaging in brings sense of punishment or imprisonment to
negative behaviours by changing the the juveniles. The hierarchy of the spaces, the
environment in which the behaviours occur. identification and response to the main user is
Interventions also help juveniles to develop very poor. Many juveniles who are reintroduced
social skills and individual behavioural skills to the society have not had a good image in the
which they need to succeed in an inclusive society and they tend to reoffend in the future.
environment. The built environment includes the
Character of the voluntary home also brings the
infrastructural elements, utilities, and all other
sense of incarceration and the juveniles at the
structures created by humans. Therefore, it is the
facility are much introverted and their
integrated built context in which individuals live,
relationship with the society is poor. This shows
and it affects the attitude and behaviour of people
that the perception of such facilities varies from
in many ways, and built environment has a
one juvenile to another or among groups of
significant influence on the development of
juveniles, and the design of such facilities must
individuals and their activities and social
take these peculiarities into consideration.
interactions.
According to the United Nations, one of the
ways of reducing juvenile delinquency is by REFERENCES
altering the physical features of the environment
through architectural and landscape planning
and providing opportunities to engage young A.Kearney, C., 2005. Social Anxiety and Social
people’s interest. Phobia in Youth. Las Veges, Nevada: Springer.

By following the case studies of SOS facilities Anon., 2015. Imagine a New Potential for Juvenile
initially designed by architects and the buildings Justice Facilities, Miami: The American Institute
of both certified school and voluntary home of Architects.
converted as juvenile facilities. According to the
results, SOS facilities have achieved much

239
Anon., 2017. Annual Statistical Report 2013-2016, ROBERT B. BECHTEL and ARZA CHURCHMAN,
s.l.: Department of Probation and Child Care 2002. Handbook of Environmental Psychology.
Services. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Anon., n.d. s.l.:s.n. Rodriguez-Vargas, L. C., 1988. Rehabilitation
Centre for Juveniles Chihuahua Chih Mexico,
Auwalu, F. K., n.d. Built Environment for
Lubbock, Texas: College of Architecture, Texas
Rehabilitation: Case Studies of Selected Juvenile
Tech University.
Rehabilitation Centres in Nigeria. Zaria,
Department of Architecture, Ahmadu Bello Steg, L., 2019. Environmental. Second edition ed.
University. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Eddie Edgerton, Ombretta Romice, Christopher Turner, K. A., n.d. Treatment of Juvenile
Spencer, 2007. Environmental Psychology. Delinquents.
Newcastle: CAMBRIDGE SCHOLARS
UNICEF, 2006. JUVENILE JUSTICE IN SOUTH ASIA:
PUBLISHING.
Improving Protection for Children in Conflict with
Jain, A. k., 1995. Penology and Victimology. s.l.:s.n. the Law, Kathmandu: s.n.
Ledford, D. L., n.d. ‘Psychology of Space’: The Vidanapathirana, M., 2018. Correction methods
Psycho-Spatial Architecture of Paul Rudolph. available for the convicts in Sri Lanka compared
2014: s.n. with American methods of correction. Medico-
Legal Journal of Sri Lanka
Niriella, J., n.d. Rehabilitation and Re-integration
of Juvenile Offenders in Sri Lanka.

240

You might also like