Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project 1 Investigative Field Essay Revised
Project 1 Investigative Field Essay Revised
Joseph Martinez
December 1, 2022
2
Eisenhower got his idea for a U.S. interstate system from his time overseas in Germany,
modeling our system after the Autobahn. He wanted a way to have cities be more interconnected
than ever. However, this came at a cost. Interstate highway construction resulted in the tearing
physical boundaries between White, well-off communities and mostly Black, typically poor
communities. In some cases, the highways even created “inner city ghettos” (Ware, 2021). The
interstate system was successful in solving the issues present in America’s past road systems,
namely dirt roads and long travel times. However, it created issues in minority communities that
have been harmed since the country’s inception. According to The Los Angeles Times (2021),
almost 1 million people were forced out of their homes, with 200,000 losing their homes in the
last three decades alone. Throughout the development of these interstate highway systems,
Figure 1
Miami, Florida
In the case of historic neighborhood Overtown in Miami, Florida, White residents had
planned for decades to remove Black residents to “expand Miami’s central business district”
(Archer, 2020). They even went so far as to construct a new town entirely: Liberty Square, now
known as Liberty City. When President Eisenhower signed the Federal-Aid Highway Act, White
business leaders saw their opportunity to strike. As shown in Figure 1, Interstate 95 (I-95) is one
of the longest and most important pieces of the interstate system, spanning from Miami all the
way to the tip of Maine. According to The Washington Post, the I-95 and I-395 interchange was
originally intended to “bypass Overtown and use a nearby rail corridor,” but it was routed
directly through the neighborhood, with no input from the residents (Blakemore, 2021). I-95’s
construction in Overtown tore down “eighty-seven acres of housing and commercial property”
(Archer, 2020). Overtown went from a community of 40,000 prior to I-95’s construction to a
4
mere 8,000 after it was built (Archer, 2020). Despite the displacement of roughly 30,000 people,
who were mostly Black, “very few housing units were built to replace demolished homes” and
by wealthy White residents in nearby areas. When the highway was completed, the displaced
residents were pushed to the edge of Miami, with a lot of them settling in Liberty Square, the
racially segregated neighborhood previously constructed for them. This mass influx of people
resulted in “aggressive overcrowding, further strained limited public services, and reinforced
racial segregation” (Archer, 2020). In addition to this, Black people were “regularly denied
access to well-paying jobs” (Archer, 2020). These people had to sell their homes so the
government could construct I-95, were pushed into dangerous, low-income areas, were robbed of
job offers, and forced into a cycle of poverty. Nowadays, people will make sure to say, “Steer
Furthermore, “the same people who devised and built the highway systems also defunded
existing infrastructure in the areas decimated by the highways” (Archer, 2020). Not only did the
government displace large groups of Black residents, they were forced into areas with
underfunded infrastructure. A lack of said infrastructure essentially isolated them in their own
communities. Without well-funded public transportation, these people often could not leave their
neighborhoods. Additionally, without well-funded utilities like water, these people were often
sick. And without well-funded healthcare in the area, these people often did not have adequate
access to care.
5
Figure 2
Figure 3
150,000 cars daily prior to the pandemic. Brian Pascus (2021), a writer for Crain’s New York
Business, a newspaper dedicated to business in the New York City area summarizes the words of
Eddie Bautista, executive director of The New York City Environmental Justice Alliance, whom
Construction of the highway involved messy choices that altered two communities.
Bautista pointed to the difference in how the BQE flows between Red Hook and
Brooklyn Heights. He noted that it bends through Red Hook, dividing the neighborhood
from Carroll Gardens and Cobble Hill, as it heads up toward Atlantic Avenue. But as it
approaches affluent Brooklyn Heights, "it loops," he said, away from the community and
The Brooklyn Queens Expressway was deliberately rerouted around Brooklyn Heights, a
wealthy and predominantly White community while cutting straight through neighborhoods like
Red Hook, which boasts the “largest public housing development in Brooklyn” (Pascus 2021).
The expressway serves as a wall to separate this neighborhood from the rest. Also, Red Hook is
located in what is referred to as a “mass transit desert,” meaning they do not have adequate
access to nearby subway lines (Pascus 2021). Segregation era tactics such as redlining have left
minority groups unable to escape the neighborhoods they were forced into, often near interstate
highways.
There have been recent calls to demolish the Brooklyn Queens Expressway and replace it
with a light rail system, effectively tearing down the dividing wall between these neighborhoods.
In some places, such as Rochester, New York, plans to tear down highways have been realized.
According to The New York Times (2022), a highway loop in Rochester which previously cut
7
through black communities has finally been torn down and affordable housing was built on the
The Cross Bronx Expressway. as shown in Figure 2, was constructed in the early 1960s.
The Cross Bronx Expressway was the first American highway to be built through a
dense, urban environment, cutting the Bronx in two and breaking up some of the most
residents and depressed property values in the South Bronx. The expressway routinely
ranks among the country’s most congested roads. Much of the traffic is long-haul
trucking that passes straight through the borough, leaving behind only pollution. The
surrounding neighborhoods have some of the highest rates of asthma in the city, linked to
Brian Pascus also interviewed Matt Carmody, vice president of traffic and transportation
engineering at consulting firm AKRF. He says, “They drew lines on a map and looked to make
lines go through communities that wouldn't protest highways and where land was cheapest”
(Pascus, 2021). The I-95 section of the Cross Bronx Expressway boasted an average of 175,000
cars a day, with a quarter of them being trucks (Pascus, 2021). The pollution from the trucks
alone contributes to health issues in minority communities in surrounding areas. Pascus (2021)
says two areas severed by the Cross Bronx Expressway, Pelham-Throgs Neck and Cotrona in the
South Bronx have asthma rates of 8.2% and 7.1%, respectively. He goes on to state that
neighborhoods like Riverdale and others in the North Bronx area, which are farther from the
heavy traffic, have asthma rates of 3.8% and 2.7%, respectively. With property levels being
depressed as a result of the construction, the only people willing to move into these
8
neighborhoods are low-income groups, most of whom are minorities. And now, they’re also
being affected by the pollution caused by the highways they live near.
Houston, Texas
Figure 4
I-10 (see figure 4) is a major interstate highway that cuts through the southern half of
Texas. I-10 begins in Jacksonville, Florida and ends in Los Angeles, California, spanning 2,460
miles. In Houston, the original construction of I-10 “removed tens of thousands of people” and
“wiped out black business districts” (Dillon & Poston, 2021). The construction of I-610 in the
1960s also resulted in “floodwaters from nearby areas pooling into Independence Heights,” a
minority community in Houston. Recently, there have been plans to expand the highways in
9
Houston in order to reduce highway congestion (Dillon & Poston, 2021). The New York Times
The expansion would demolish the Clayton Homes and displace many more residents
from the historic Black and Latino neighborhoods of Near Northside and Independence
Heights — all despite decades of evidence that widening highways does little to relieve
congestion. The Third Ward — the heart of the city’s Black community — remains
blocked off on all sides by highways. The planned expansion would literally widen this
divide.
Liam Dillon and Ben Poston, writers at The Los Angeles Times (2021) say the following about
the expansion:
Houston’s proposed expansion would cover about 450 acres through the center of the
city, adding new lanes and redoing interchanges across four interstates at a cost of $9
billion. Nearly half of the 1,000 families set to lose their homes now live in low-income
apartment buildings, including the Clayton Homes and Kelly Village public housing
complexes. The demolition toll also involves five churches, three homeless service
These communities will be torn down, people will be displaced, and if trends continue,
they will not be compensated for their losses. Minority communities in Houston were
demolished in the 1900s and continue to risk being demolished to this day due to the I-10
expansion, with the U.S. Department of Transportation investigating claims that the expansion is
discriminatory (Dillon & Poston, 2021). According to the Los Angeles Times (2021), Modesti
Cooper, who filed the report, has been harassed by the Texas Department of Transportation after
Birmingham, Alabama
Figure 5
comes from the east and cuts straight into the center of town. However, the highway, directly
southwest of the airport, “departs from its generally northeast to southwest trajectory to loop
north and bisect the predominantly Black portion of East Birmingham” (Connerly, 2002).
Charles Connerly, a professor at Florida State University, researched this loop. He says:
easy achievement as it required a sharp turn in the highway, thereby reducing the
11
interstate’s speed limit and increasing the danger of an accident as automobiles and large
commercial trucks, accustomed to traveling sixty or more miles per hour, had to slow to
The original plan for I-59 avoided the sharp loop, was approximately 1.25 miles shorter than the
current highway, and did not run through the Black neighborhoods of East Birmingham
(Connerly, 2002). It would appear that I-59 was deliberately routed through a minority
community at the expense of highway safety in order to protect the White community of
Woodlawn.
Similarly to the Woodlawn loop, I-59 continues to cut through a primarily Black
neighborhood, East Lake, “taking an upward bend,” instead of heading south toward Wahouma
Park, which separated the Black and White neighborhoods (Connerly, 2002). The original plan
for I-59 also did not include the highway cutting through East Lake. Therefore, again, I-59 was
deliberately routed through a minority community in order to keep it away from the White
To the west of Birmingham, affluent Black neighborhood Smithfield once was home to
the wealthier Black elite. Despite their wealth, I-59 was routed straight through the middle of this
neighborhood, showing that it was not class that dictated the highway’s path, but race. The
residents were displaced and forced to leave (Connerly, 2002). Middle class Black people had
trouble finding housing in Birmingham at the time, as “few areas in the city had been zoned for
blacks, particularly areas that were not located near industry and that were zoned for single-
Finally, In some neighborhoods, like College Hills and Fountain Heights, the Black
population had been increasing steadily in the 1950s and 1960s. With the removal of racial
12
zoning, White citizens got violent, sometimes even bombing Black families in their houses
(Connerly, 2002). Interstates 59 and 65 (see figure 1) were perfectly aligned with the racial
zoning boundaries put forth in the early 1900s (Connerly, 2002), effectively reinstating said
boundaries.
The United States interstate system has displaced minorities, harmed them economically,
and reinforced decade old racial boundaries. First, in Miami, thousands of citizens were
displaced and forced into low-income, run down neighborhoods such as Liberty Square. Second,
in New York, highways demolished Black communities and contributed to pollution. Third, in
Houston, expansions continue to affect and displace the same communities the original
constructions harmed. Last, in Birmingham, highways were deliberately routed around White
neighborhoods in favor of cutting through Black ones, and some even were constructed directly
along the boundaries of racial zones. Despite differences in location (North and South) the
pattern of minority communities being negatively affected by interstate highways persists. Even
when Black communities were just as wealthy and affluent as nearby White ones, the Black
whether the United States deliberately ordered the construction of these highways to destroy
minority communities.
My opinion
With the information presented in this paper, I have come to the conclusion that the
United States needs to fix the mistakes it made. I think a large reason as to why nothing is being
done about this issue is the lack of awareness. There are so many people who don’t know this
has been going on for decades, and some that do know completely disregard it. We should be
educating people on this issue as the first step in the right direction. Then, we should research
13
and contact the communities that have been harmed, and find ways to support them and
reimburse them for the trouble they have gone through. Once we have done these steps, we can
make bigger strides in fixing the problem, like attempting to pass legislation that would make
this practice illegal (because it still happens, like in Texas) and passing laws to protect the
communities that our country has hurt. We could even attempt to get funding to demolish and
rebuild highways—as has happened in some places—so our interstates don’t cut through
do better overall, but I am a strong believer in the idea that we need to pinpoint specific issues
before we tackle the overarching one. I think this is a good first step into making amends with
References
14
Archer. (2020). “White Men’s Roads Through Black Men’s Homes”: Advancing Racial
Blakemore, E. (2021, August 17). Interstate highways were touted as modern marvels.
Racial injustice was part of the plan. The Washington Post. Retrieved September 13,
were-touted-modern-marvels-racial-injustice-was-part-plan/.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X02238441
Dillon, L., & Poston, B. (2021, November 11). Freeways force out residents in
communities of color — again. Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 13, 2022, from
https://www.latimes.com/projects/us-freeway-highway-expansion-black-latino-
communities/.
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cross_Bronx_Expressway_Map.svg#/media/
File:Cross_Bronx_Expressway_Map.svg
GISGeography. (2022, June 2). Birmingham map, Alabama. GIS Geography. Retrieved
https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/interstate/finalmap.cfm
15
NBC New York. (2021, August 30). BQE construction begins Monday. NBC New York.
https://www.nbcnewyork.com/on-air/as-seen-on/bqe-construction-begins-monday/
3246575/
map.gif
Brian Pascus. (2021). How New York City’s legacy of racism lives on in community-disrupting
Susaneck, A. P. (2022, September 8). Mr. Biden, Tear Down This Highway. The New
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/08/opinion/urban-highways-
segregation.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare.
Leland Ware. (2021). Plessy’s Legacy: The Government’s Role in the Development and
Annotated Bibliography
Archer. (2020). “White Men’s Roads Through Black Men’s Homes”: Advancing Racial
This 70 page article is titled after a popular phrase that was used by civil rights activists to
protest the interstate system. It has a large abstract, which highlights that the interstate system
severed black communities, that it was used to further segregation, and it separated black and
white communities. These barriers that were erected still remain to this day. It continues to
explain that due to the need to rebuild or replace highways, the government has a chance to fix
its past mistakes, but people are wary that the government may just make them again. I will now
summarize the main sections I am going to use: the sections on Miami, Birmingham, Atlanta,
poverty, and psychological impact. This article goes significantly more in-depth regarding the
Miami/Overtown issue than the other sources I have. It begins by explaining that white business
leaders constructed Liberty Square as a new place for the Black people of Miami to live so they
could expand their businesses into Overtown. Then, when the Federal Highway Act was passed,
these white leaders used it as their opportunity to push out Black residents. Some 10,000
residents were displaced, pushed to the edge of Miami and most were never fairly compensated
for their loss, nor were many new housing units constructed for them. Overtown went from
40,000 residents to only 8,000 after I-95 was built. In Birmingham, AL, Black residents were not
displaced per se, but the interstate put up a divide between Black and White neighborhoods and
communities. As Black citizens moved into White neighborhoods, the state redirected I-59 and I-
65 to form a de facto racial zoning line. For instance, I-59 was constructed perfectly along the
line of an old racial zoning boundary. Similarly. I-65 followed old racial zoning boundaries as
well, this time dividing the neighborhood of Fountain Heights between Black and White. In
17
Atlanta, I-20 was built to be a wall between Black neighborhoods to the north and White
neighborhoods to the south. When Black residents tried to gain permission to build housing
south of I-20, they were denied. Black Americans were forced into segregated neighborhoods,
ghettos, and lived in overcrowded housing or were homeless as a result of the divide. Black
businesses were torn down to make way for the interstates as well, leaving residents without
income. These factors combined resulted in a cycle of poverty and segregation that permeates to
this day. Low income children are not able to escape poverty, nor are they ever given a chance
to. In Nashville, Black businesses, churches, and universities were either torn down or divided by
the “wall” that is I-40. In St. Paul, a neighborhood named Rondo was torn down to make room
for I-94. One resident said the residents of Rondo became castaways. The article goes on to
explain the psychological impact of segregation: how it results in a sense of otherness, how it
“assaults” dignity and self respect, and how it humiliates. I would use this article for its powerful
analysis of the issues at hand. Its extensive length ensures I would have an adequate amount of
information. This article is credible as it comes from an academic, peer-reviewed journal with
Blakemore, E. (2021, August 17). Interstate highways were touted as modern marvels.
Racial injustice was part of the plan. The Washington Post. Retrieved September 13,
were-touted-modern-marvels-racial-injustice-was-part-plan/.
The article begins by giving an example of Interstate 77, which, when constructed, cut straight
the idea and development of the system. Then, it references how the interchange between
18
Interstates 95 and 395 was originally supposed to bypass Overtown (a historically Black
neighborhood in Miami) but was instead redirected to go straight through, displacing over
10,000 residents. The article goes on to give several other examples, such as Logan Heights, a
Latino community in San Diego, being cut in half by I-5, Black Bottom, a majority Black
neighborhood in Detroit, was bulldozed to make room for I-375, and finally, in Alabama, the
state’s highway director (a KKK member), ignored unused land and chose a route that displaced
civil rights leaders. It goes on to mention protests by minority communities and toward the end
states that people of color who live near interstates are more likely to suffer from the effects of
air pollution (with higher chances to have illnesses like asthma). I will use this source to quote its
references to specific interstates, like the mention of the I-95/395 interchange destroying
Overtown. The source is credible because it comes from The Washington Post, a well-known
news source that was founded in 1877 and is based out of D.C. This source relates to my others
because it comments on the same topics brought up in the others, while also mentioning the
https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X02238441
The article begins by describing how the interstate system in Birmingham tried to follow the
boundaries set by the original racial zoning laws. Then, it goes on to explain how the
construction of said interstates displaced Black citizens and led to population loss. Then, it
concludes by referencing a time when a Black community stood up to the government and got
them to change the path of the highway so it would not destroy a majority Black neighborhood.
19
This source was hard to summarize well due to its use of maps and charts. However, these are
helpful for visualizing how the interstates affected the communities in Birmingham. I will use it
for its insight on Birmingham, specifically its points on individual neighborhoods. This source is
credible as it is an academic, peer-reviewed article. It was also written by an FSU professor, who
later received awards for a book about the same topic. It is similar to my other sources as it
discusses the issue at hand, but it is different as it only covers one city instead of multiple.
Dillon, L., & Poston, B. (2021, November 11). Freeways force out residents in
communities of color — again. Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 13, 2022, from
https://www.latimes.com/projects/us-freeway-highway-expansion-black-latino-
communities/.
The article begins by giving a real-world anecdote of a Black person by the name of Cooper,
who bought a home in Texas which is now set to be demolished to make room for the expansion
of I-10. It comments on the history of the interstate system and its effects on minority
communities in history but shifts its focus to emphasize how widenings, expansions, and other
construction of highways affect communities now. It gives recent examples of cities in which
interstate expansion negatively harmed minority communities. It states that its analysis is the
“first of its kind” to measure the effects over the last 30 years, and goes on to explain its research
and subsequent findings. It continues to give some recent good news, such as highways being
torn down, the pausing of new projects, and stopping lane expansions. Then, it takes a step back
to look at the history behind the issue. It mentions the same story in Miami as the Washington
Post source, examples in Los Angeles, and even gives helpful graphics to show the buildings that
were torn down in Tampa as a result of the construction of I-275. It ends by explaining that
although these people are compensated for the loss of their homes, their neighborhoods, their
20
culture, and their way of life are disrupted. I would use this source for its several specific
examples of minority neighborhoods that were affected by the construction of the interstate
system. I also like that it connects to modern expansions as well, so my research is not only
limited to the past. Like The Washington Post, this source is credible because of its long-standing
history (it was founded in 1881) and because it is widely known. An issue with credibility is the
claim that this analysis is the only of its kind, which suggests there may be no other sources to
back the article up, however, given the LA Times’ history and the obvious care put into the
research, I still view it as credible. This source relates to the others as it expands upon the
Brian Pascus. (2021). How New York City’s legacy of racism lives on in community-
The article begins by prefacing a new infrastructure bill that the Mayor-elect of New York City
plans on using to improve subway systems and highway systems. It then goes on to highlight two
instances of highways in New York that have racist pasts. It begins with the Cross Bronx
Expressway (mentioned in the New York Times article), explaining its history, what areas were
torn down, and how highway traffic contributes to pollution in the area which affects the
cuts through minority communities, but strangely loops around a majority White neighborhood,
Brooklyn Heights. One of these minority communities, a neighborhood by the name of Red
Hook, is home to the largest public housing development in Brooklyn, but is cut off from other
neighborhoods by the highway. I will use this source for its quotes and information about the
BQE, which has not been in any other sources thus far. This source seems less credible than the
others, as it comes from a site I have never heard of, and it is not peer-reviewed. However, the
21
information lines up with the information in other sources, and the quotes used are from highly
qualified professionals, like the Mayor, Eddie Bautista, who is the executive director of the New
York Environmental Justice Alliance, and Matt Carmody, vice president of traffic and
transportation engineering at consulting firm AKRF. This source is similar to the New York
Times article as it also highlights New York City, but it is different because it includes
Susaneck, A. P. (2022, September 8). Mr. Biden, Tear Down This Highway. The New
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/08/opinion/urban-highways-
segregation.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare.
This article begins by discussing the Houston interstate expansions and how it will affect
minority communities, even referencing the LA Times analysis in the source above this. It then
gives a graphic of the Cross Bronx Expressway, highlighting the areas that were demolished as
you scroll, while also providing statistics and information regarding the displacement of
minorities as a result of the expressway’s construction. It gives a powerful interactive graph that
shows the percentage of white vs. nonwhite people that were displaced as a result of the
interstate system. It explains that people were often not compensated for their loss, and
minorities were forced into moving into public housing, which creates a cycle of generational
poverty. It goes on to provide some examples of when roads were torn down, but circles back to
explain that U.S. legislation is trending toward highway expansion, with $273 billion likely
being used for expansion, and explains that by pushing an electric car narrative, the government
continues to repeat their mistakes. I would mainly use this source for its graphics and charts.
These are insanely helpful tools that provide an immense amount of statistics regarding
22
displacement (especially in the case of the chart). Like the Washington Post article and the LA
Times article, this one is also very credible. Despite being an opinion piece, it cites sources via
hyperlinks throughout the article and was published by a highly known and respected news
source, The New York Times, which was founded in 1851. This source is similar to the others but
mostly similar to the LA Times article and is different from any of them due to its use of
Leland Ware. (2021). Plessy’s Legacy: The Government’s Role in the Development and
This article analyzes the impact of Supreme Court case Plessy v. Ferguson on segregation
through multiple categories. There are sections on redlining, segregated schools, public housing,
and for the purposes of my paper, interstate highways. The interstate section gives background
history on the system’s development, defines an interstate, and continues to explain how these
highways affected minority communities through the use of a quote from a former U.S.
Department of Transportation secretary. I will use this source for its quote by the secretary, a
person who would be very knowledgeable about the subject. I will also use it for its examples of
neighborhoods torn down and its mention of inner-city ghettos. This source is credible because it
comes from an academic, peer-reviewed journal. It was found on the FSU Library database,
which I trust. It has an extensive bibliography, so I know its information was well researched.