Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wellbeing Special Report 2022 Final
Wellbeing Special Report 2022 Final
Introduction..................................................................................................3
I
have been wanting to write about tired juggling multiple balls in the air.
teaching for some time now. Concerns about Sometimes teaching gets tired because we’ve
burnout are what’s motivating me. Teachers done what we’re doing a hundred times before.
can reach a place where teaching does nothing Many of us teach the same courses year after
for them or their students. They don’t just wake year. If they are those bedrock, foundational
up one morning and find themselves burned out; courses, the content typically doesn’t change all
they’ve moved there gradually, and it’s a journey that much. We march through the material along
that often starts with tired teaching. well-worn paths. We know the way; we’ve seen
There’s nothing on the all the sights before. Every
subject in my big file of student is a unique individual,
articles and resources. I can’t We can start by facing the but collectively they’re all
remember having read about
reality of tired teaching, no novices who ask the same
it, and I’m not sure how questions we’ve heard before,
much we even talk about longer pretending everything who get stuck in the same
it. We do talk about being will be OK if we just get to places, and who repeatedly
tired. Teaching is relentless. make the same poor decisions
bed earlier.
It happens every day, several about learning.
times a week—or potentially In the beginning, tired
24/7 if it’s online. And it’s demanding. There’s teaching comes and goes. We may feel ourselves
so much more than the actual teaching. There’s falling into a rut, but it’s usually temporary and
considerable planning involved before each class. we’re soon back on track. But later, the tiredness
Plus, we need to spend time with students—those returns. At some point, a kind of paralyzing
who want to talk, those needing help, and inertia can settle over us. We no longer have the
those with questions or, sometimes, complaints. energy or motivation to change the syllabus, alter
There are assignments to grade and feedback to course readings, or update the assignments or
provide—all carrying the expectation of a quick activities. Add new content? No way, the course
turnaround. With multiple courses to teach, we is already too full with essential material. Offer
do get tired, but I think we regularly confuse online quizzes? Who has time to figure how that
physical fatigue with the more serious emotional works? Besides, the students will cheat.
tiredness that comes from a heavy workload of That’s why and how tired teaching happens.
always being there, always giving, and always The more important question is: What can we do
I
t’s the end of the semester! The shiny back- our course content to embed digital collaboration
to-school dust has settled and for the most and authentic conversations. We’ve been tasked
part, everyone is completing their daily COVID with checking on the mental health of our
checks, wearing colorful masks, and trying to be students—from seniors who are losing out on
more aware of their surroundings. The gears of practicum experiences and questioning what their
college seem to be moving forward and learning post-graduation plans will be to first-year students
hasn’t fallen off the wheels. But, if you pause and who are struggling more than normal to adjust to
listen to the rumblings, there college life to commuters with
is a different message being hectic schedules and nowhere
shared.
Educators routinely rise to set-up on campus.
Professors are burning out. to the occasion, adapting Teaching isn’t our only
Anxiety levels are at elevated and excelling in high stress responsibility. All the while,
levels, even among those professors are dealing with
who aren’t typically anxious.
situations. research and service duties.
Planning more than a week Our research agendas have
out seems a risky undertaking. A disproportionate been adjusted to include COVID-related topics
amount of time is spent searching for the best because publications have pivoted their focus.
ways to engage students in Zoom sessions while Journal articles that were previously accepted
also engaging in face-to-face sessions. We are pre-COVID have been put on the back burner.
forced to balance flexibility and understanding In order to keep up with research demands for
while maintaining high academic standards. We tenure/promotion, we need to pivot as well. Many
have to seek ways to foster student conversation of us have had to step up to teach more courses
both virtually and in person. This is difficult because university budgets are suffering. We join
amongst the unusually quiet students; even the committee meetings via Zoom after a solid day of
students who were chatty in previous semesters teaching classes that are larger than they’ve been
are more reserved now. We have restructured in the past. It’s not just work that is stressing us
R
esilience is about growing both personally fertile void (McDargh, 2014). This is a threshold
and professionally when we face difficult to something new, a growth opportunity. It can
situations. It is about coming out the other happen after a major event, when you may
side as a stronger or more prepared person rather feel you don’t know what to do next. In this
than bouncing back to the status quo. We know time, hold onto this “space” and listen: Seek
that our brains are highly adaptive: we can create support from your pit crew (crew of support and
new patterns of thinking and acting, yet we need nurturing) to aid you in decision-making and to
to purposefully practice to make those patterns provide encouragement. Complete a resiliency
stick. The brain has neuroplasticity and can inventory to self-assess where you are right
rewire itself with consistent practice, persistence, now, at this point in time. It might benefit you
and training—even when we face life’s most diffi- to routinely check your resiliency gauge—just as
cult challenges. you perform regular maintenance on your car.
It can help to think of taking care of ourselves Consider investing about 10 minutes to complete
as akin to the routine maintenance that supports a an inventory and perhaps sharing it with an
car’s longevity, high performance, and efficiency. accountability partner, coach, or trusted colleague
As regards our mental and physical wellbeing, we for additional value.
sometimes forget to watch for the signs to slow Here are some links to get you started:
down, to get “into the shop.” In this analogy, • How Resilient Are You? (A quiz)
we share some guidance toward wellbeing and • Your Personal Resiliency Quotient (RQ)
well-thinking to promote resilience in your Assessment
“dream car.”
Maintenance plan
Checking under the hood In addition to checking your resiliency gauge, it
Take the opportunity to self-assess and “check is important to have a maintenance plan for the
under the hood” to gauge your resiliency. In other components of developing your resiliency
life, you may reach a time in life known as the wellbeing. Just as a car needs four wheels to
This article first appeared in The Best of the 2019 Leadership in Higher Education Conference
I
n the early days of the pandemic, we all did and make up missed assignments and exams.
what we had to in order to flatten the curve, As many universities face budget cuts because
and that meant quickly switching to online of lost revenues and declining enrollments, the
instruction. As the pandemic raged, teachers only thing that is persistently climbing is faculty
everywhere were bombarded with information: workload.
strategies for moving in-person classes to online As well-meaning administrators recognized that
platform, tricks to make online classes more faculty were feeling isolated and overwhelmed,
engaging, and a plethora we received an onslaught
of tips on how to support of articles, trainings, and
stressed students (Izenberg, As educators, we are deeply webinars on work-life
2020; Gewin, 2020; An-
invested in student success and balance and self-care. But,
derson 2020; Field 2020). these trainings, webinars,
Everyone had ideas about frequently go the extra mile to and self-care procedures all
how to teach during a public ensure it. However, this effort took time, a commodity that
health crisis.
can be physically and mentally instructors have precious
Since the start of the little of in these uncertain
pandemic, faculty have draining. times. As educators, we
experienced an exponen- are deeply invested in
tially increased emotional load. Not only were student success and frequently go the extra
we charged with delivering engaging online mile to ensure it. However, this effort can be
instructions after a crash course in technology, physically and mentally draining. If you find
but we also saw students face more stress than you are getting snippy in communications with
ever before while also dealing with other issues, students and your excitement about education
like trying to care for sick family members. is giving way to irritation, then you are probably
Throughout this, we all tried to be flexible and getting burned out. It is okay to acknowledge it.
show compassion, which often meant extra work You are a human being, and you are sensitive to
for us in order to help students who were sick prolonged extreme stress just like anyone else.
or in quarantine keep up with class material We wouldn’t trust an airplane to a sleep-deprived
I
’ve had the pleasure of working with hundreds excuses why that is the case. I don’t have time.
of higher education administrators and leaders I don’t like to exercise. I don’t like to sweat. It is
over the past 20 years or so. The health habits too hot outside. It is too cold outside. I don’t like
of those administrators in many ways mimic those going outside. My tummy hurts. My shoes are
of the general population. Some routinely wake up worn out. I don’t have the energy. I’m too old. We
at 4:30 a.m. and go for a five-mile run, are very will always, without much effort, be able to come
conscious of what they eat, and get eight hours of up with an excuse not to be active.
sleep every night. Others attempt to fit some physi- Instead of telling people how much physical
cal activity into their routines, try but don’t always activity they should get every day or every week,
succeed at eating healthy foods, and sometimes I generally encourage people to strive to incorpo-
get as much sleep as they should. And some are rate some movement and activity into their daily
completely sedentary, eat far too many fatty and routine. This could include doing yardwork,
processed foods, and don’t prioritize quality sleep. shoveling snow, walking your dog, playing a sport
Most of the articles I write are about online with your child, going on a leisurely bike ride
education, as I’ve served as the director of online with your partner or spouse, walking to work,
education at the University of Wisconsin-La playing a round of golf, hiking at a state park,
Crosse for the past 11 years. However, before going to a Zumba class, etc. The options abound!
that I was a faculty member in a Department Find something you really like to do and do it
of Exercise and Sports Science where I taught a at a time that is convenient for you. Exercise with
variety of courses related to health and wellness. a friend, child, sibling, coworker, or significant
So, I welcome opportunities to write about other to help keep you accountable. Add your
health-related topics and encourage people to daily dose of physical activity directly in your
think about improving their health, whenever I calendar and guard that time like it is your most
can. Here’s my advice to you. important engagement of the day. Consider
incorporating walking meetings into your daily or
Move a little more weekly routine at work. I started utilizing walking
Roughly 80 percent of Americans don’t get meetings about 10 years ago, and I love them!
enough physical activity. People offer a myriad of
C
ollege student mental health is currently Creating a supportive learning
receiving a great deal of attention. Over environment
the last few years, the frequency and se- The climate of a course can influence learning
verity of mental health issues reported on college experiences and outcomes. Consequently, the
campuses has dramatically increased. In a recent instructor should create an environment that is
survey, 64 percent of respondents identified men- conducive for learning —a space where students
tal health–related issues as a reason for no longer feel safe and supported and are encouraged to
attending college. Students reported stress and discuss issues and ask questions.
anxiety as the top two factors affecting individual Adopting a student-centered teaching
student academic performance (American College philosophy is essential for creating an environ-
Health Association, 2017). ment that promotes student learning and
Universities are grappling with how to address wellbeing. This means creating experiences for
this serious health concern. What is needed is a active engagement, whereby student needs,
comprehensive strategy that calls on all members curiosities, and interests guide instruction. The
of the university community to commit to a instructor becomes a facilitator, cocreating the
shared vision—one that supports student learning learning experience with students, who share the
and wellbeing. This leads to the question I’m responsibility for learning.
interested in exploring: Are there practices that Supportive learning environments foster
teachers can implement in their courses that positive faculty-student and student-student
support this vision? Although many instructors relationships. In teaching first-year students,
may feel that it is not their responsibility and that I have realized how important it is for college
they do not have the training to serve as de facto students to discover that there are individuals at
counselors, there are teaching strategies, most not the school who care about their lives and their
difficult to implement, that can support student futures, teachers who care about their students’
learning and wellbeing. academic success and their personal wellbeing.
Faculty can convey this concern in many
A
mong teachers’ biggest worries about platforms such as Twitter and Instagram.
trying to incorporate humor into their I use memes in my courses. In fact, here’s one
classes are that no one understands their I use in the extra credit section on my syllabus
humor, that they might offend someone, and that (Figure 1).
they’re just not funny. As someone with a clear The Willy Wonka/Gene Wilder meme, which
bias in favor of humor is fairly popular and
notwithstanding, I say long-lived as far as
balderdash. Incorporating modern day memes go,
humor into your class is taken from a scene in
can be low-risk and en- the movie Charlie and
joyable and avoid all the the Chocolate Factory (dir.
above worries. It can also Mel Stuart, 1971). The
help you to enjoy class written content around
time more as well. And the image may change
the best part is, you’ll depending on context,
be able to use a mode of but the picture stays the
communication that is same, and that’s what
one of the most-traded you’re tapping into
forms of social media for Figure 1. Willy Wonka/Gene Wilder when you use memes.
anyone who is a millenni- extra credit meme The picture’s meaning
al or younger: the meme. is assumed by most
The term meme was first coined by Richard who read it. The text merely contextualizes it: in
Dawkins (1976/2006) to point out a “unit of my case, to my views on extra credit. That’s the
cultural transmission” (p. 192). Much like a beauty of memes. That’s what you can tap into
gene that gets transferred from one person to as a teacher. There is one thing to note about the
an offspring, a meme was a sort of culturally text to follow. When anyone analyses humor, it
held idea or text, such as a rhyme or a prayer, often loses its humorous punch. As E. B. White’s
that one member of the culture transmitted to paraphrased idea of humor analysis wryly notes,
another. Memes now are much more viral, and in “Analyzing humor is a bit like dissecting a frog:
popular culture usage has come to focus on viral You learn how it works but you end up with a
images or texts easily distributed on social media dead frog.” (For a fascinating look at the evolution
If you want to be a bit more creative in your classroom fee more like a comedy club than a
use of memes and not simply mine the various place of learning. Find a few memes you deem
sites or use your students, try making your own. funny and use them here and there. If you use
Here’s one I made for a presentation to faculty on your students’, cite them—and make the citation
why we should use humor in the classroom. The itself a little humorous (e.g., “ J. Smith, Intro
picture format is another famous one that most to Philosophy, spring 2018”). Modeling the use
students will know (Figure 5). of citation when using students’ memes has
If you’re interested in making your own memes, the added benefit of showing that you value
here are a few websites that will help you: Know student work and give credit to your students for
Your Meme, Imgflip’s Meme Generator, and their work—all in the best spirit of an academic
Cheezburger’s Meme Base. The process is pretty researcher who is still learning.
straightforward. Choose a picture, add some text, One final consideration: when you invite
and right-click to save. Distribute, then impress students to laugh and share humor, you not
your students with your savvy. only improve student engagement but also stay
So why incorporate memes? There are a reciprocally engaged as a teacher. As teachers we
number of reasons. Memes rely heavily on are focused on student success, and rightly so.
humor, and humor is well understood to help But we should remember that sharing pleasant
us tolerate stress better, improve memorability, experiences with our classes engages us as
and make us more engaged with those around teachers for the better as well. Students respond
us (Bennett & Lengacher, 2006; Berk et al. 2001; to engaged instructors. If you’re engaged, if they
Shazia A. Ahmed, PhD, is a clinical professor of Post-Baccalaureate and Transfer students. She
biology at Texas Woman’s University and Senior actively serves on leadership committees for
Fellow of Higher Education Academy (HEA). NAGC and TAGT.
Michael K. Cundall, Jr., PhD, is an associate Juliet V. Spencer, PhD, is a professor of biology
professor of philosophy at North Carolina at Texas Woman’s University and also serves as
Agricultural and Technical State University. He’s the Chair of the Biology Department.
been researching humor for nearly 20 years and Susan M. Stein, DHEd, is a professor emerita at
has his own company, Mirth Management. As Pacific University’s School of Pharmacy and
an organizational humorist he helps organi- the owner of Sue Stein Consulting. Prior to
zations learn how to use humor to increase consulting, she served as associate dean for the
engagement. Find him on the web at www. College of Health Professions and dean of the
mirthmanagment.co. School of Pharmacy at Pacific University.
Michele C. Everett, PhD, was recently a lecturer Brian Udermann, PhD, is director of online
of interdisciplinary studies at Coastal Carolina education and professor of exercise and sports
University. Her responsibilities included science for University of Wisconsin-La Crosse.
teaching and coordinating the first-year He is a member of the Academic Leader
experience and peer mentor programs. Her advisory board.
research focuses on teaching and learning
Jenny A. Van Amburgh, PharmD, is a clinical
in higher education, with specific interest in
professor and assistant dean for academic
strategies for student engagement, wellbeing,
affairs in the School of Pharmacy at the Bouvé
and interdisciplinary ways of knowing.
College of Health Sciences at Northeastern
Seena Haines, PharmD, is a professor and chair University. Additionally, she serves as the
of the Department of Pharmacy Practice at the director of the postgraduate teaching and
University of Mississippi School of Pharmacy. learning certificate program.
Previously, she served as associate dean for
Maryellen Weimer, PhD, is a professor emerita
faculty at Palm Beach Atlantic University. With
of teaching and learning at Penn State Berks.
Stuart Haines, she is the creator and instructor
She has served as editor of The Teaching
for the Magna Publications Course Wellbeing
Professor since the newsletter began in 1987.
Elixir.
A distinguished scholar and author, Weimer’s
Nicole Hesson, EdD, is an assistant professor Learner-Centered Teaching: Five Key Changes to
of education at York College of Pennsylvania. Practice, 2nd ed. (Jossey-Bass, 2013) remains
She has been a teacher since 2004. She teaches one of the most influential books for educators
undergraduate education courses, and is the looking to adopt a learner-centered approach
program coordinator for the Secondary, Middle in their classrooms. Weimer won Penn State’s
Level, and K-12 programs. Milton S. Eisenhower award for distinguished
Katie D. Lewis, EdD, is an associate professor teaching in 2005. She has consulted with more
at York College of Pennsylvania, formerly of than 600 colleges and universities on instruc-
Texas A&M International University. She teaches tional issues and regularly keynotes national
undergraduate education courses, and is the meetings and regional conferences.
program coordinator for Secondary Education,
www.magnapubs.com