Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SHRM Individual Assignment
SHRM Individual Assignment
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
ASSIGNMENT 1:
Individual Research Paper
Topic:
THE IMPACT OF HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
PRACTICES ON JOB SATISFACTION IN HOTEL INDUSTRY
PREPARED BY:
PREPARED FOR:
DR. NORIZAN BINTI HJ AZIZAN
SUBMISSION DATE:
29th OCTOBER 2022
Contents
1.0
Introduction...............................................................................................................................1
1.1 Background of study………...………………..………………………………….…...2
1.2 Problem Statement…..………………………………………………………………..4
1.3 Research Objectives…………………………………………………………………..5
1.4 Research Questions………..………………………………………………………….5
1.5 Significant of The Study……………………………………………………………5-6
11
2.4 Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………...12
3.0 Methodology (Introduction)……………………………………………………………...12
3.1 Conceptual Framework………………………………………………………………
13
Summary……………………………………………………………………………..19
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Following Thailand and Singapore, Malaysia was listed as the third-most attractive
country in Southeast Asia for the hotel industry according to Knight Frank's
Malaysian Hotel Investment Intentions Survey. Due to the numerous requests for
services, benefits, and convenience from clients and visitors, it keeps changing.
Hotel industry, dominantly the service and facilities areas have been helping to
increase the gross domestic product (GDP) improvement, speculation, and work,
and also support the record business equality of percentages. The hotel industry
transportation, and beverages and food. The tourism industry in Malaysia has
recorded a positive on development of 4.8% increment for the January until May
In this chapter, the researcher incorporates the difficult assertion and current hole,
this theme, which is identified with human asset practices and job satisfaction. The
reason for this review study is to examine the effect of human asset the executive’s
zeroing in on job satisfaction, different human asset the board rehearses, hotel
connection between HRM practices and job satisfaction and theories has been
created.
1
1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
The idea of job satisfaction, besides incredibly late source, it is firmly connected to
efficiency, and ultimately its bottom line. In this industry, having patience, skilful and
of these capable workers is a need in this industry. The reason for this study was to
explore the internal factors influencing the job satisfaction of employees at hotel
industry in Malaysia.
Hotel industry has been facing a high turnover rate since those days and many
and the loyalty connection between the management and employees. A hotel
industry invests through thousands of moneys in training, recruiting and hiring new
employees and put in a lot of effort and money in retaining employees every year.
Thusly, enrolling new staff is a period consuming and extravagant practice that
In addition, Amin et al. (2017), has recommended that the management of the hotel
industry need to continually update their services because they face hardened rivalry
in the market from the local organizations as well as from the worldwide market also.
2
While focusing on profit and customers satisfaction, the management failed to
monitor employee’s idea towards their hotel. More often than not the hotel industry
will acknowledge after lose their workers. Instead of being late engaged, they should
identify the issue prior and address it quickly before they tumble to profound.
in traveller appearances yet neglected to meet the objective fixed by the Tourism
Ministry. The Ministry focused to invite 28.1 million visitors in the year 2019, while
the genuine appearances were just 26.1 million travellers. Despite the fact that the
nation couldn't arrive at their objective, yet it figured out how to break the descending
pattern it has been recording from 2017. 2014 actually holds the most elevated
number concerning the traveller passage with 27.44 million however figured out how
to create RM 72 billion. The complete traveller receipts for 2019 were RM 86.1 billion
which is RM 6.1 billion focused by the Ministry. The nation persistently zeroing in on
activities to build the absolute number of appearances from its key business sectors,
departures from China with optional air terminals in Penang, Kota Kinabalu, Kuching
and Johor Bahru. Additionally, with the achievement of the e-visa administration for
Chinese nationals which was dispatched in March 2016, which assisted with drawing
in more guests, Malaysia presented the equivalent for Indians in March 2017.
3
Malaysian Tourism Statistics from
2014 to 2019
27.44
26.76
25.72 25.95 25.83 26.1
In view of (Nor Zafir Md Salleh Abu et. Al) There are three significant difficulties for
HRM in Malaysian hotel industry, such as lack of workers (due of high turnover), lack
of motivation for the hotel staff, and lack of compensations/benefits for the staff
compare to their workload. The explanation of high turnover, a great deal of hotels
willing to give better salary and benefits compare with current hotel working spot.
Despite the fact that the employee work there for quite a long time yet at the same
time not bear to pay a good salary, it may push the employee to choose to out from
the current working place. Out of all the staffing issue, staff shortage was happened
the most. As per the front office managers, staff shortage at the front office are
brought about by the trouble of getting and retain the workers because of the low
pay/compensation and long working hours. Job motivations are a set mentality
towards work and occupation inspiration is needed by all staffs or employees and
place. Worker's motivations are the fundamental drive to hold the employees in the
hotel for quite a long time. Shockingly, still a lot of hotel industry struggling to draw
out the motivation from the workers. From the managers' viewpoint, the minimum
4
wages permitted by law execution has brought about chiefs receiving the best
improvement in worker efficiency and motivation. Conversely, the positive effect from
the managers' viewpoint is lower turnover aims and social equity for foreign laborers.
From the employees' point of view, there is a somewhat negative effect – the lowest
pay permitted by law strategy has resulted in a minimal increase in the salary.
• To determine the relationship between the employee’s job motivation with job
This research study would bring the answers for the following questions:
1. How effectively the human resource practices to retain their employees in hotel
2. What is the impact of lack of compensation/benefits for the staff compare to their
5
1.5 SIGNIFICANT OF THE STUDY
According to (Kysilka & Csaba, 2013), hotel industry consistently faces with the issue
of lack of staffs because of low job satisfaction among workers which prompts high
turnover. In the first place, we will examine about the general factors that face by the
hotel industry. Second, we will amend the variables influencing the factors of job
policy maker of this industry to narrow down the territory of focus and better craft
strategy tools to support job satisfaction among its employees. The high degree of
There are three main factors that facing by Malaysia hotel industry regularly such as
shortage of labour (due to high turnover), lack of motivation for the hotel staff, and
lack of benefits for the staff compare to their workload. By increasing job satisfaction
among employees, it can achieve their goal which later reduce the turnover rate and
retain the workers by tackling the issues. This will minimize the lack of staff issues to
run a smooth the business in a hotel. Besides that, organization performance will be
improved when employees are satisfied with their work and have been motivated to
Aside from that, this research additionally filling the gap of information about the
connection between job satisfaction and the mentioned factors in Malaysian hotel
industry setting. It is trust that this study will starts the interest of researchers to lead
6
1.6 SCOPE OF THE STUDY
The purpose of this study to investigate the level of job satisfaction among workers,
and the main factors affecting the level. Besides that, job satisfaction and its
for the hotel staff, and lack of benefits for the staff compare to workload among
employees in the hotel business will likewise being studied. This investigation will be
led in Malaysian hotel industry. The focused-on respondents of this exploration are
Accountant, room Service, general worker, food and beverages and security
services.
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 INTRODUCTION
In this chapter included with writing survey, pertinent hypothetical models, proposed
reasonable structure and speculations improvement. The point of the writing survey
is to distinguish optional information from journal and articles which identified in this
outline of how different creators in the connected investigation field assess factor of
7
2.1 LITERATURE REVIEW HRM PRACTICES AND JOB SATISFACTION
The human resources writing recommended that hotels hoping to lead their
competitors and become known for their quality assistance should be explicit in
staffing, give direction and training, offer fair pay, reasonable compensation/benefits,
Moreover, turnover can happen in two different ways which are voluntary and
involuntary. Voluntary turnover will happen when the employees purposefully choose
to leave the organization while involuntary turnover happen when the workers
unwillingly leave the organization however been forced by the management to leave
behaviour at workplace and that high capacity and undeniable high level of job
training will not bring the expected results if the individual is totally demotivated or
undermotivated at work." Employee motivation is not a new topic in HRM and it has
Motivational variables like recognition, achievement and personal and career growth
8
characteristically compensating factors are attractive to a worker and can lift their
a monetary reward, which given to workers to meeting their goals. This may include
like money grants, rewards, commission, gift vouchers, and more. Money is a
successful motivator for that can fulfil the workers and improving employee
programs and more. A benefits plan is intended to address a particular need and is
Based on Moncarz, Zhao and Kay (2008) concentrated what incentives and benefits
the hotel industry that most low maintenance workers do not get many, assuming
any, benefits, and incentives are very sparse (Cunningham and Mahoney, 2004).
Compensation is the second reason after salary employee decide to work there,
however if the hotel industry failed to give it the worker's idea may change to find any
Most of the hotel industry focused around profits and customers satisfaction which is
acceptable yet pushing with a great deal of duty without giving a fair compensation
9
2.2 PREVIOUS STUDY
2014; Yildirim, Gulmez, & Yildirim, 2016). Aminudin (2013) In specific, previously the
are less researches were carried out to investigate the relationship between turnover
working in hotel industry in Malaysia stated that not much academic research uses
Based on overall compilation of previous literature, this study identifies the factors
that affect the job satisfaction towards employees’ job satisfaction in hotel industry.
The study structured the factors that relate to employee’s satisfaction in hotel
motivation. Based on previous researches, (Bakotić and Babić, 2013; Malik, Danish
and Munir, 2012; O'Donnell and Mirtcheva Broderson, 2015); have conducted a
satisfaction. Earlier studies by Chen (2006), the loyalty of employee will be higher if
they have high job satisfaction, and they can be more optimistic with their work and
also the organization. Besides that, based on the previous researches less of people
that not much academic research uses hotel as the target of their study despite its
importance.
10
2.3 ISLAMIC PERSPECTIVE ON JOB SATISFACTION IN HOTEL INDUSTRY
Islam, which is 61.3 percent of the population hold by Islam. To give a good Islamic
establish Islamic working environment climate are to permit the employees to open
up about their belief through their dressing or give a Sharia consistence uniform
particularly for the female Muslim workers. Additionally, in hotel industry particularly
4 stars and 5 stars hotels serve non-Halal items to the customers such as alcohol,
pork and so on the hotel management should regard their obligations and should be
Last but not least, it is important for the organization to realize Muslim employees'
dietary restriction when they gave free food during any proper event to give an
(2012), permitting the workers to rehearse their religion will build their work execution
11
2.4 CONCLUSION
Through the study on this chapter, had chance to found that the independent
can earn back the employees’ loyalty and the employee will continue their assistance
to achieve the organization’s goal. Career development can retain the employee
will fascinate the employee to organizations for long term. On the other hand,
job motivation will lead the employee to put more commitment in their work and stay
in the organization for long term period. Thus, the extra examination will show the
possibilities whether or not the variables can predict the employee satisfaction on
METHODOLOGY
3.0 INTRODUCTION
This chapter reviews the technique use to analyse the relationship between
dependent variables and the independent variables, which is the effect of human
section shows how the studies is done as far as the conceptual framework, data
development, sampling design, data processing and data analysis. It also shows the
12
result interpreted by providing questionnaires that will provide to the targeted
The conceptual framework shows the relationship between the independent and
dependent variables
Lack of compensations/benefits
compared with workload
variable. The structure was outlined after estimated by the research question,
objective and review of literature. Henceforth, the structure focuses on the human
resource practices that could affect the job satisfaction in hotel industry in Malaysia.
HYPOTHESIS DEVELOPMENT
13
were proposed in this study. The following is the arrangement of speculations that
will be tried.
satisfaction
satisfaction
According to the (Zikmund et al., 2010), the main plan which portrays in research
design is requiring the procedures and methods for collecting and analysing the
needed information. It is a system that designs the activities for the research project
and control to find the best solution for this issue as well. Quantitative research
configuration identifies with the plan of a research project which utilizes quantitative
research methods. The plan varies depending on the method used, which could be
research has been utilized to lead this research study due to huge number of
respondents who have participated. This study evaluated, and hypotheses are
generated.
online reviews, video and phone meetings and results which are level headed and
14
fewer researchers will be seen during this progress advancement. The objective of
directing this quantitative research study is to decide the connection between about
the effect of HR practices influence job satisfaction in hotel industry with in broader
population which the exploration covered instead of qualitative method where a little
Therefore, benefit for this study has applied quantitative research as it utilizes
analyse based on the hypothesis, in this way, it very well may be successful
Descriptive research designs that will practice in this research. Descriptive research
being studied. It focuses on answering the how, what, when, and where questions If
a research problem, rather than the why. This is mostly on the grounds that it is
strategy that endeavours to gather quantifiable data for statistical analysis of the
Data collection is the information that gathered from the respondents or through any
other source that is available and applicable to the research topic that has directed
15
study. Inaccurate data collection can lead to inappropriate results of a study and
Primary data is the information that is gathered directly from the data source without
going through any current or existing sources. It is for the part gathered research
Primary data is often reliable, true, and objective in as much as collected with the
It is a method has been narrowing down the size before the information data
earlier to hotel workers in Kuala Lumpur. I hope by choosing the main city as a
16
Time wise and cost wise, for me to focus overall market all in all; consequently, the
worker who actually perform their job as a hotel employee will be the targeted
population. However, hotel employees are the main pole of this study. Based on
Statista, in 2018, there were 435 hotels in Malaysia's capital city of Kuala Lumpur.
According to the star online (26 Mar 2020) Kuala Lumpur, with a sampling size of
17,826 employees, thus the recommended sample size is around 20 employees with
wherein units of the model are chosen based on up close and personal judgment or
convenience. There are four sorts of probability assessing systems; one of them is
basic irregular testing and it will be the inspecting procedure in the assessment.
Every one of the questions in questionnaire are set in fundamental language so that
random sampling, can endeavouring to require the respondent that who will answer
the review for this exploration. For those focused on respondents, they can address
the requests quickly due to the setting of the request is clear, by then we prepared to
For this study, we would like to use Probability sampling method, which means that
every member of the population has a chance of being selected, for example in hotel
17
industry, employees working under few departments, so all of them are eligible to
produce results that are representative of the whole population, probability sampling.
Descriptive statistics
Descriptive statistics serve in simple way but critically important role in the research
to explain the data set for instance, consider a simple number used to summarize
how well the hotel industry is put effort to retain the employee for years. Unlike
inferential, descriptive statistics are not aiming to make implications about the entire
population but they’re just interested in the details of the particular example.
At the point when writing up on analysis chapter, descriptive statistics are the initial
set of details that will be covered, before moving to inferential statistics. However,
depending on research objectives and questions, they may be the only type of
statistics that will be used and whatever the case, they’re fundamental.
The techniques/methods
• Median – will use the middle point of arrangement of numbers (if the numbers
numbers listed. In other words, about the distance or average range from the
questions
18
Inferential statistics
According to the previous discussion, the descriptive statistics are about the details
about the population. All in all, inferential statistics means to make expectations
about what to discover in the full populace during the research. This could include
predictions about:
• Differences between groups – for instance, the contrasts between impact by the
3.6 SUMMARY
This chapter has described the methodological aspects of this study including the
variable, the sample of this study, and finally the data procedure and method of
analysing the data of this study. The questionnaire is distributed according to the
19
QUESTIONNAIRE
a. Male
b. Female
a. Below 18
b. 21-30
c. 31-40
d. Above 50
c. Housekeeping Dept
e. Others: ___________________________
20
4. How long have you worked for your hotel?
b. 1-5 years
c. 5-10 years
d. Above 10 years
5. Do you think your future career development prospects is positive in your
hotel?
6. Please indicate all the reasons why you might leave your job two years from
now?
a. Better pay
c. Better management
d. Better benefits
a. Yes.
21
8. There is a system of monthly or annually rewards or incentives in your hotel
a. Strongly agree
b. Agree
c. Neutral
d. Disagree
e. Strongly disagree
9. How would you rate each of the factors that motivate you to perform your
i. Wages/ Salary 1 2 3 4 5
v. Flexible hours 1 2 3 4 5
vii. Co-workers 1 2 3 4 5
22
ix. Training 1 2 3 4 5
x. Empowerment 1 2 3 4 5
a. Strongly agree
b. Agree
c. Neutral
d. Disagree
e. Strongly disagree
23
References
WeiBo, Z., Kaur, S., & Zhi, T. (2010). A critical review of employee turnover model
(1938-2009) and development in perspective of performance. African journal of
Business Management, 4(19), 4146-4158.
Kim, W. G., Leong, J. K., & Lee, Y. K. (2005). Effect of service orientation on job
satisfaction, organizational commitment, and intention of leaving in a casual dining
chain restaurant. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 24(2), 171-193
24
Bakotic, D., & Babic, T. (2013). Relationship between working conditions and job
satisfaction: The case of croatian shipbuilding company. International Journal of
Business and Social Science, 4(2)
Chan, K. L., Lee, C. F. Y., Lee, Y. C., Loh, C. Y., & Low, S. M. (2013). The impact of
human resource management practices on job satisfaction in hotel industry (Doctoral
dissertation, UTAR).
25