Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Second Chance Love by M
Second Chance Love by M
Second Chance Love by M
M. Robinson
COPYRIGHT© 2022 Second Chance Love by M. Robinson
This book is a work of fiction. References to real people, events, establishments, organizations, or
locations are intended only to provide a sense of authenticity and are used fictitiously. All characters
are a figment of the author’s imagination, and all incidents and dialogue are drawn from the author’s
mind's eye and are not to be interpreted as real. Though several people, places, and events portrayed in
this book are correct, the story is fiction that the author has made up for entertainment purposes only.
To readers who love their heroes with a pierced cock…
Contents
Prologue
1. Evie
2. Evie
3. Evie
4. Evie
5. Evie
6. Evie
7. Caleb
8. Caleb
9. Evie
10. Evie
11. Caleb
12. Evie
13. Evie
14. Caleb
15. Evie
16. Evie
17. Caleb
18. Evie
19. Evie
20. Evie
21. Evie
22. Evie
23. Evie
24. Evie
25. Evie
26. Caleb
27. Evie
28. Caleb
29. Evie
30. Evie
31. Caleb
32. Caleb
33. Evie
34. Caleb
Epilogue
Acknowledgments
Meet M. Robinson
Connect With M
More Books by M. Robinson
Prologue
Evie
C ALEB
For the first time in over eight years, we were hooking up.
Chapter 2
Evie
T HE SUBTLE TOUCH OF HIS LIPS AGAINST MY SILK PANTIES HAD ME MELTING INTO
his embrace, making my body shudder and head spin.
Lightly, he bit my clit through my panties. “This what you want, Evie? My
mouth on you? Tell me … I want to hear you beg for my love.”
“Caleb, stop saying the word love.”
He roughly pulled my panties to the side to blow on my clit. “Then tell me
you don’t want this… Tell me you don’t think about me anymore… Tell me
you’ve never made yourself come to the memory of my tongue fucking your
cunt.”
“Holy shit, just stop talking.”
“I’ll stop when you tell me you still love me… Just say the words, and I’m
forever yours.”
I gripped onto his hair. “Caleb,” I panted, trying to form a coherent
sentence while he rubbed my clit with his hand.
“You don’t know me, and you never did.”
“Bullshit. I know what it feels like when you come.” He slid his fingers
back inside of me in a much more demanding way than before. “I know how
your face gets flushed. How your breathing elevates, and you moan the
sweetest fucking sound as you whimper my name. I know your pussy pulsates
so goddamn tight that it pushes my fingers out, just like it is right now.”
I bit my bottom lip and suppressed another moan, not wanting to give him
the satisfaction of how well he still knew my body.
“I know what you taste like, but most importantly, I know what it feels
like to be inside you.”
I gasped the second he sucked my clit into his mouth.
“And I’m not talking about your sweet cunt. I’m talking about your heart.
You’re going to let me back into your life, Evie. Because that’s what I want.
You and me. Then. Now. Always.”
There was no holding back—I was about to come.
“You want me, darlin’?”
Silence. Not one word from me.
“You’ve always been a stubborn little shit. It was one of my favorite
things about you. Nice to know you haven’t changed and my girl is still the
same.”
I snapped, “I’m not your girl.”
He chuckled before making love to me with his mouth. It didn’t take long
until I was crazy with desire for him. Right as I was about to come, he moved
his finger and lips away as he threatened, “Tell me or I’ll stop.”
“Oh, come on,” I griped in distress.
“I’ll give you what you need as soon as you give me what I want. Now tell
me.”
Without giving it another thought, I shoved him away and sternly stated,
“Not a chance in hell.”
I took a step, about to leave, but he used my momentum against me. He
gripped onto my wrist and spun me around until my face was against the wall
and the front of his body was along my back.
“You stubborn little shit,” he whispered in my ear from behind me. The
sound of his belt unbuckling was loud and sharp, echoing off the walls. His
zipper was next, and the removal of both felt like atomic bombs. My mind and
heart raged war with one another, knowing what would come next.
“Don’t worry, darlin’. I have no problem fucking it right out of you.”
I opened my mouth to reply at the same exact moment he thrusted deep
inside of me.
Immediately, I shook away the memory, fucking seething, “You didn’t
use a condom!”
He smiled, fully aware of what I just remembered.
“Evie, since when have we ever used condoms?”
Unable to resist, I pushed him. “That was before, asshole! Who the hell
knows how many women you’ve been—”
“There was Tessa, and then there was you.”
“You’ve been divorced for almost a year. You really think I believe you
haven’t had sex since your wife?”
He folded his arms over his chest. “Why would I lie? And it’s been more
than a year.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“It means last night was the first time I’ve had sex since my daughter,
Ariel, was conceived.”
“Ariel is five.”
He smirked, loving the fact that I knew how old his baby girl was.
“What are you going to tell me next, Caleb? Before Ariel you didn’t have
sex since your son, Ethan, was conceived two years prior?”
“I don’t have to. You just did.”
I rolled my eyes. “You must really think I’m stupid if you expect me to
believe you’ve only had sex with your wife twice.”
“She’s not my wife.”
“Whatever. Your ex-wife.”
“Darlin’, there’s a lot you don’t know.”
“I’m sure there is.” I nodded. “It’s what happens when you completely
cut someone out of your life.”
“I had no choice.”
“You always have a choice, Caleb. Just like you chose to marry Tessa,
and then you chose to have two kids with her. Now you’re choosing to lie to
me about how many times you’ve had sex with her. All your choices. Take
some accountability for once.”
“Alright, if you insist. The first choice I’ve made in a long time was to
divorce Tessa. The second was to bury my face in between your legs.
Satisfied? Or do you need my mouth on your pussy again? Trust me, darlin’.
I could eat you all day.”
“Stop,” I roared, becoming furious. “I don’t need to hear your lies
anymore. Last night was a mistake that was stirred solely by way too many
shots of tequila. I barely remember any of it, especially what you claim you
said to me.”
“You remember enough that if I touched your pussy right now it’d be
wet…” He paused for effect. “For me.”
“We’re done now.”
Instantly, I spun, but he gripped onto my arm and made me face him
again. His mouth was now inches away from mine.
“The fuck we are. If anything, this has only begun between us.”
“I have nothing else to say to you.”
“Well, I have plenty to say to you. Starting with, I never stopped lov—”
I shoved him as hard as I could, and he barely wavered, which only
infuriated me further.
“Fuck off, Caleb.”
“I’d much rather fuck you. Again. But I have no problem proving myself
to you this time around, so please let me. I want to make things right between
us.”
“I’m not the one who pushed you away.”
“I know, darlin’, but—”
“But nothing! Everything is still the same. Jax is still my brother. I’m still
his sister. He’s still your client and best friend. The only thing that’s changed
is the time I’ve wasted since you approached me last night.”
“Evie, let me worry about Jax.”
“Oh! Now you want to handle Jax? How convenient for you. What else
would you like, Caleb? My heart and soul?”
“Yes, but I’ll start with being your friend.”
“We were never friends.”
“You’re right. We were so much more than that.”
“That’s not how I remember it.”
“Then let me remind you of the man who saved you once.”
I yanked my arm away. “I don’t want to remember him. I spent years
trying to forget him.”
“Evie, just let me explain.”
“You’re a day late and a dollar short. I don’t care to hear your bullshit
anymore. I’m not that doe-eyed young girl who loved you. She’s gone,
Caleb, and she’s never coming back. Get used to it. Last night I was horny,
and you were available. End. Of. Story.”
With that, I turned around and rushed toward the bathroom, making sure I
locked it behind me, needing to keep him out. It was where he belonged.
I turned on the shower, trying to tune out the memories of last night. It
was nearly impossible. Especially when I took off my robe and looked in the
mirror.
The truth was staring me in the face. He wasn’t lying—there were marks
on my neck, my breasts, stomach and thighs.
Fucking bastard.
It didn’t take a genius to figure out he did it on purpose. He wanted to
mark me, claim me, make me remember the night we shared, and I hated him
more for it. The audacity of that man was inconceivable. He had some brass
balls, but he always had.
Deciding to shake off the anger, I stepped into the hot shower, wanting to
wash away any stench of him on my skin. When I made my way back into
the bedroom, he was nowhere to be found. Not that I expected him to be.
Once again, taking a deep, reassuring breath, I reached for my overnight
bag and grabbed the maxi dress I was going to wear today. Something else
fell onto the bed. Right there before my eyes was our past glaring at me with
a blaze of glory.
Damn you, Caleb. How did he still have this?
It was the first photo we’d ever taken together. The same night he saved
me, catapulting my mind back to another place and time.
When I fell for the man who’d only end up breaking me.
Chapter 3
Evie
C ALEB
C ALEB ’ S EYES FLUTTERED OPEN . I WAS STILL IN HIS ARMS , STARING UP AT HIM
with my chin on his chest.
“Mmm,” he groaned, stirring awake while our gazes connected. “Are you
watching me sleep?”
Even his raspy morning voice was sexy.
Smiling, I shrugged. “Maybe.”
“Are you plotting on how you intend to kill me?”
“I decided to let you live.”
“That’s nice of you.”
“I do what I can.”
He chuckled. “How are you feeling?”
“Much better. Whatever medication you gave me did the trick.”
“My friend called it in for you. My assistant brought it over shortly after.”
Sweeping a piece of hair out of my face, he asked, “What time is it?”
I loved the adoring expression on his face. No one had ever looked at me
the way he was. Despite not wanting to break our connection, I grabbed his
wrist and read his watch.
“It’s almost noon.”
“I don’t remember the last time I slept in this late.”
Bringing my attention back to him, I questioned, “Are you an early
riser?”
“Mmm hmm.”
“How early?”
“Usually by five A.M.”
“Five in the morning? That’s crazy! Who wakes up at five A.M.?”
“I get a workout in before I head to my office.”
“Are you trying to tell me you’re a workaholic?”
He smiled, rubbing my back. “That’s what happens when you own your
own agency.”
“That’s pretty admirable. You’re still so young.”
“I thought I was ancient?”
“You might still have a few good years left.”
“Do I get to spend them with you?”
“If you play your cards right.”
“Well, what do you know, I’m actually holding four of a kind.”
“I’ll see your four of a kind and raise you a royal flush.”
He smiled, big and wide. “My girl knows how to play poker.”
Again with my girl.
I didn’t call him out on it. Instead, I changed the subject. “Do you know
your body temperature runs hot?”
He arched an eyebrow. “What?”
“You’re very warm. Almost like a heated blanket.”
“Good to know.”
“No other girl has told you that before?”
“You’re the first girl I’ve ever woken up with.”
I eyed him skeptically. “Oh, come on. You expect me to believe that?”
“I told you. I’m a lot of things, but I’m not a liar.”
“So you’re telling me you’ve never had a woman spend the night?”
“Why is that so hard to believe?”
“Because you’re an almost twenty-six-year-old successful entrepreneur
who is easy on the eyes.”
“I said I’ve never woken up with a woman, not that I’ve never fucked
one.”
“Oh…” I nodded. “I get it. You’re that guy.”
“Care to elaborate?”
“You know, the one who never settles down. Sleeps around. My guess is
that you have deep rooted issues.”
“And what issues would those be, Dr. Monroe?”
“Smart ass.” I grinned. “It’s actually a textbook case. Who was she?”
He arched an eyebrow again, looking at me confused.
“Who was the woman who broke your heart?”
He laughed, big and throaty. “Never had my heart broken, darlin’.”
“Really?”
He shook his head. “I’ve never been in a relationship.”
“What?!” I sat up, staring deep into his eyes. “You’ve never had a
girlfriend?”
“That shocks you?”
“Of course! That’s insane.”
“How about you?”
“I don’t really swing that way, but I have kissed a girl.”
Now that got his attention. He crossed his arms behind his head which
only accentuated his defined, muscular arms. Doing all sorts of things to my
core.
Grinning like a fool, he demanded, “Tell me more.”
“You’re such a guy.” I blushed. “Does this mean you’re not mad at me
anymore?”
“I’m livid.”
“What if I told you her lips were soft and she tasted like Juicy Fruit
bubble gum.”
“I’m listening.”
I rolled my eyes, smirking. “It was a high school party. We were playing
truth or dare in the woods.”
“I’m enjoying this mental picture. Did she make you wet?”
“Caleb! I was fifteen. I didn’t know what wet was.”
“And who was the boy who showed you what wet was, Evie?”
“Considering I’ve only had one boyfriend. His name was Kyle, and I
don’t think he knew what wet was either.”
He laughed, enjoying my response. “That’s what happens when you fuck
with a boy, darlin’.”
“Oh yeah? Are you up for the challenge, old man?”
“Trust me, Evie. If I had my hands on you, you’d know what wet was.”
My thighs clenched.
“Does that mean you’ve only been with one boy?”
I nodded. “We were together on and off all through high school, but it
wasn’t meant to be.”
“Did he make you come?”
“Caleb!”
“That’s a no.”
“Oh my God, you’re horrible.”
“Did you love him?”
I wanted to make him sweat a little, so I stated, “This is some deep
conversation before breakfast, and I’m starving.”
“How about you let me feed you?”
“That would be great, but I need to take a shower first.”
“My bathroom is behind you, and there’s fresh towels under the sink.”
“Ummm.” I looked down at myself. “I don’t have any clothes—”
“My assistant took care of that for you. They’re on the couch over there.”
I turned around, following his stare. There on the couch were several
pieces of clothing, from a dress, to jeans, to a couple t-shirts. There was even
undergarments, while sandals and sneakers were on the floor below them.
“Looks like your assistant bought me a whole new wardrobe.”
“I didn’t know what you’d like.”
“I can pay you bac—”
“Evie.”
His sharp tone shifted my gaze back to him.
“When someone buys you gifts, you simply thank them.”
“Thank you, Caleb. That was very thoughtful of you.”
I never expected him to add, “Do you need my help in the shower?”
Backing away, I slowly stood up off the bed. “I think I can handle it on
my own.”
“If you change your mind, you know where I’ll be. Or you can help me
with my shower. You know”—he showed me his hands—“I’m injured and
all.”
“Do you need me to wash your back?”
“Is that before or after you wash my cock?”
My mouth dropped open, and he stood, striding toward me. Each step was
sexier than the last. It was the first time I noticed what he was wearing—
sweatpants. My eyes shifted to the bulge swinging between his legs.
Holy shit!
He instantly noticed where my stare went. “Like what you see, darlin’?”
I swallowed hard, trying to play it off like I wasn’t impressed by what he
was packing.
Once he was standing in front of me, he whispered in my ear, “Go take a
shower before I eat you for breakfast instead.”
With that, he left his room, and I stayed there frozen.
Excited for the day ahead.
C ALEB
She didn’t take long time to shower and get ready which I appreciated.
There wasn’t much she needed to do to make herself more breathtaking than
she already was. When she walked out into the kitchen, she was wearing a
light pink summer dress that was tight on her breasts and loose toward her
luscious ass. The white sneakers made her look fucking adorable.
She held onto the sides of her dress, giving me a little twirl, then throwing
my question back at me, “Like what you see?”
“It’s shorter than I would have liked, but you’re going out with me, so I’ll
allow it.”
“You’ll allow it? Umm … excuse me, old man. Last time I checked, only
I control what I wear.”
“That was before you met me.”
“Hmm…” She put her finger up to her mouth in a contemplating gesture.
“I’m going to let that red flag slide, but only because you saved me last
night.”
In three long strides I was in her face. “Being protective is not a red flag,
Evie. Last night proves that you need someone protecting you.”
She snapped, “Last night was a careless mistake that won’t happen again.
I can take care of myself, Caleb. I’ve been doing it for a very long time.”
“Did I hit a nerve?”
“I don’t like being told what I can and can’t do. I’m not a little girl.”
“No, but you are very young, darlin’. Men can smell it on you.”
“Oh really? And what smell is that?”
Without thinking twice about it, I grabbed the back of her thighs and
lifted her, setting her on the kitchen island then stood between her legs. My
hands stayed on her skin, rubbing her soft flesh with my thumbs. Her mouth
parted, realizing our sudden change in position.
Leaning forward, I rubbed my lips along the column of her throat and
inhaled her sweet scent.
“You smell good enough to eat.”
Her pulse heightened against my lips.
“Would you like that, Evie? My mouth on you?”
“Your mouth is on me.”
“It’s not your neck I want to kiss.”
She sucked in a breath.
“But first…” I pecked my way up to her ear, loving the effect I was
having on her. “I’m going to feed you.” Pulling away, I lifted her off the
counter and took her hand in mine.
“Hey! I was enjoying that!”
I smiled, speaking with conviction, “Trust me, sweetheart. I’ve only just
begun.”
Chapter 7
Caleb
S HE WAS FIDGETING .
Nervous.
I wanted to ease her anxiousness for what was to come.
“Stay still. Stop moving.”
Her dress hiked up her toned thighs, and my hands glided up her legs.
They were as soft as they were inviting.
I was fucking done for.
Pressing soft kisses up her neck, I confessed, “You have me questioning
everything about myself, Evie.”
She sucked in a breath, realizing the sudden change in my demeanor.
“All I know is that I want you. For the first time in my life, I’m struggling
with the reality that maybe you were made for me, darlin’,” I huskily
groaned, hanging on by a very thin thread.
My hands moved at a gentle, torturous speed, up to where I really yearned
to touch her. Evie’s dress rode up her thighs, exposing the pink lace panties I
bought her.
“Do you have any idea what you’re doing to me?”
She peeked up at me through her lashes, simply moaning, “Show me.”
“This isn’t why I brought you here. Tell me you know that.”
“I do. I want you too.”
I reached up, stroking the side of her cheek. Her face leaned into my
embrace. Shifting my hand to the back of her neck, I tugged her closer to my
mouth. Her lips found mine, and what started off as a peck turned into
something else entirely. Taking on a life of its own. I opened my mouth and
sought out her tongue. This was our first kiss, and it was fucking explosive.
We explored each other’s mouths. Our tongues twisted as we tasted one
another. It felt amazing.
She felt amazing.
But like everything with Evie, it quickly moved on its own accord. I
gripped onto the sides of her face, kissing her more aggressively than before.
All the buildup of the day was just fucking foreplay. It was better than I
imagined, having her at my mercy.
My fingers moved down her chest in an agonizing motion. She held her
breath as I cupped her breasts, softly kneading them while still devouring her
mouth. Nothing could have prepared me for this moment.
Her moaning.
Panting.
The way she rocked her hips on my hard cock.
Our legs entwined, rubbing together and moving all around my desk. I
kissed along her jawline, her neck, deliberately making my way back up to
her lips. I no longer had any control over my movements.
“Fuck … Evie,” I rumbled into her mouth. “We need to stop.”
“I don’t want to stop.”
I pressed my hand over her throat, holding her down against my desk to
stare intently into her eyes.
“There’s only so much restraint I have left for you. If we don’t stop now,
I’m going to show you what it’s like to be with a real man.”
Her eyes widened. “Yes…”
My restraint snapped.
Loud and clear.
My eyes glazed over like a possessed man as my jaw clenched with my
thumb gliding over her mouth.
“I don’t want anything in between us. I want to feel every inch of your
pussy coming down my cock. I’m clean, darlin’. I get tested regularly. Now
tell me you’re on the pill.”
“I am.”
I growled, tearing at her dress.
“Hey! That’s my dress!”
“Don’t worry, sweetheart. I’ll buy you a new one.” With that, I ripped it
off.
Until all she was left in was her panties and bra.
“Christ, you’re fucking gorgeous.”
Unable to hold back, I stripped her naked, leaving her bare beneath me.
Taking a moment, I completely took her in. From her luscious breasts, to her
tiny waist, to her captivating fucking hips and legs until my greedy regard
found her pussy.
“Evie, do you have any idea what I’m about to do to you?”
Her eyes lit up, big and bold, luring me in even further.
“Spread your legs for me, darlin’, I want to show you what wet feels
like.”
Not waiting for her to answer, I got down on my knees and gripped onto
her thighs, tugging her ass to the edge of my desk with my face now inches
away from her cunt.
“Darlin’ you have the prettiest fucking pussy.”
I had no intention of stopping there. I’d only just begun.
“Your scent is fucking addicting. You know that, Evie?”
Her breathing hitched, waiting for my next move.
Her legs trembled.
Her body shook.
Her hips swayed, baiting me to continue.
“How should I make you wet first? Should it be with my fingers? My
mouth? Tell me how I should make you come?”
“Anyway you want me to…”
She moaned as I slid two fingers inside of her warm, welcoming pussy.
“I’m going to make you come down my hand by finger fucking you right
… here.” I pushed on her g-spot, not letting up. Her head fell back, and her
legs tightened around my face.
“Caleb … please…”
“Begging me isn’t going to give you mercy. If anything, it only triggers
me to do the opposite. Now the question is, should I make you come or make
you squirt. All I have to do is push back further and hit … right … here…”
“Oh God! Don’t stop… Please … right there … don’t stop…”
“You feel that, Evie? Now that’s me finger-fucking your g-spot, and it’s
what’s going to make you squirt for me.” Moving my fingers back and forth,
getting right up in there.
Faster.
Harder.
I gave her everything I had.
With the palm of my other hand, I stimulated her clit from side to side,
never letting up on my assault inside of her.
“Fuck my face my, Evie. Yeah ... just like that… There’s no one here,
darlin’. I want to hear you scream my name.”
It didn’t take long for her to do exactly that, screaming, “Caleb!” in pure
abandon. Coming so fucking hard, she almost pushed my fingers out.
I allowed her to ride the wave of ecstasy before huskily groaning, “Now
we can get to my favorite part.”
“What?”
Our eyes connected.
What started off as tender became rough and demanding.
“I’m going to fuck you with my tongue.”
I stuck it into her pussy as far as it would go. Still playing with her
swollen, sensitive nub, manipulating it with the palm of my hand until she
came in the back of my throat.
“Caleb, Caleb, Caleb…”
The salty sweetness of her come was delicious.
My dick throbbed to the point of pain, so I unzipped my slacks and pulled
out my cock. I instantly stroked it up and down as she watched through a
hooded gaze, while I ate her out. There on my desk, overlooking downtown.
I’d never brought a woman back to my office, and yet I couldn’t wait to do
this with her again.
She went crazy with desire, coming so goddamn hard again. Her juices
dripped down my face and throat, and I loved every second of it. She even
drenched the top of my button-down shirt. Locking my other arm around her
thighs, I held her down.
She was squirming, begging for mercy. Her breathing was heavy and
deep, and her skin was bright pink and shimmered with a light film of sweat.
She shined bright with the afterglow of her orgasms.
I’d never tire of watching her come undone.
She was fucking breathtaking.
Letting her rest for a couple seconds, I wiped my mouth with the back of
my hand and licked the rest of her come from my lips, savoring it in my
mouth for as long as I could. Placing her legs on my shoulders, I stood in
front of her.
In one swift movement, I thrust deep inside of her. She jolted forward,
feeling the impact of my cock.
“You feel huge, Caleb.”
“Words every man loves to hear, darlin’.”
To prove my point, I pulled out and slammed back into her which caused
her body to inch higher on my desk.
The feel of her cunt.
The taste of her come.
The smell of her arousal.
I. Was. Fucked.
My mind was reeling with so many conflicting emotions, I couldn’t keep
up with them. There was so much I wanted to say, but I barely understood
what was wreaking havoc on my mind. I wanted to remember her just this
way. Her long hair spread all over her face. The way her cheeks were slightly
flushed and how the blush crept down her neck. How her lips were swollen
from my touch, and her serene eyes glazed over.
So beautiful.
So captivating.
Everything I didn’t know I could have until this moment.
I loved seeing every emotion I felt through her gaze as I thrust in and out
of her pussy. Her green eyes watched me passionately as I took what I
needed.
What she was giving me.
“Caleb, I never thought it could feel this way. What are you doing to
me?”
“I’m the man who’s given you your first orgasm, and I’m not stopping
anytime soon. Now I want you to come on my cock.”
Her body shuddered. Her pussy fit me like a glove.
Tight.
Wet.
Warm.
I could have come right then and there, but I wanted to feel more of her.
Gripping onto her waist, I slammed in and out of her, getting as far as I could
inside of her.
Wanting to make us one person.
“Yeah, darlin’, just like that. Come down my balls.”
She let go, almost taking me with her. It was only then I let go of her legs
to lean forward and kiss her. Hugging around her neck, I brought her lips
closer to me. Our mouths fused together, unable to get enough of one
another. It seemed like hours had passed and the whole world was left behind
us.
“Caleb…” she moaned, her pussy pulsating around my shaft, clamping
down hard.
I thrust in and out a few more times, and it felt so fucking good, until I
couldn’t hold back any longer. I came deep inside her.
Knowing all along…
I was falling for her.
E VIE
I spent the night at his house again. Waking up in his arms was becoming
my new favorite thing.
“Mmm…” I groaned, feeling sore everywhere, but in the most amazing
way.
Caleb stirred awake at the same time I did, both of us looking at the clock
on his nightstand. It was noon.
“Crap!” I jolted awake. “How do we keep sleeping in this late?”
“I wouldn’t call what we did sleeping.”
I smiled. “Yeah, you’re insatiable.”
“And you’re fucking addicting.”
I smiled bigger. “I have to go.”
“Oh, I see. I make you come all night, and now you’re leaving me?”
I giggled, loving his smart-ass personality. “I have to meet my brother.”
“Lucky for you, I have somewhere I have to be too, or else I’d hold you
captive in my bed.”
“You can hold me captive tonight if you want?”
He didn’t waver in replying, “It’s a date.”
“A date, huh?”
I squealed as he picked me up and threw me over his shoulder.
“You can leave after we take a shower.”
“I’m going to be late!”
Smacking my ass, he argued, “Blame it on my insatiable need for your
addicting pussy.”
I was indeed late, arriving at Jax’s house an hour after I was supposed to
be there. I had to stop at my apartment and grab a couple of things I wanted
to show him. Caleb let me leave with his hoodie, and I didn’t take it off. I
wanted the scent of him on me for the rest of the day.
Using the key Jax gave me, I walked into his new place. This was his
second home, and he spent most of his time living in Miami, where he played
for the Miami Sharks. He wanted to make sure I still had access to his condo
in case I needed to stay there for whatever reason. He actually wanted me to
move in there, but it was too far away from campus, and I wanted my own
space.
Closing the door behind me, I shouted, “Jax! I’m so sorry I’m late! I lost
track of time!”
He hollered, “I’m in the kitchen!”
I made my way over there, quickly realizing he wasn’t alone.
“Oh, crap. Am I interrupting you?”
“Not at all. This is actually why I wanted you to come over.”
What happened next could only be described as an out of body
experience. His guest turned around, stopping me dead in my tracks.
“Evie, I’d like you to meet my agent.”
My stomach dropped to the ground when he announced…
C ALEB
“Oh, so now you know me? That’s convenient for you. Should we call
Jax back into the room, so he knows his best friend just fucked his baby sister
like what? Two, three hours ago? And now he’s trying to fuck her over?”
I wanted to tear my hair out. I couldn’t believe this was even happening.
Out of all the women in the world, she ends up being my best friend’s little
sister.
Fuck me.
“Evie ... you need to stop acting like a child.”
“Well then, you need to stop acting like you don’t know me. What the
hell was that? Are you really going to keep this charade up?”
“Sweetheart, we barely know each other. It was one day.”
She jerked back. The hurt was evident all over her face.
What could I do?
Either way, I was fucked.
“So everything you said last night was bullshit? What was that? Just a
game to get me into bed?”
“You know that’s not true.”
“I don’t know shit. All I know is I showed up to my brother’s house, and
the man who told me that I make him question everything is pretending like
he doesn’t know me.”
“I promised you nothing.”
“Are you for real?”
“If I had known Jax was your brother, Evie, last night wouldn’t have
happened.”
“What about the night before? You would have just let Ryan throw me in
his car?”
My expression immediately turned heated.
“Oh, so you do care. Good to know I didn’t just imagine it.”
“You need to calm down.”
“And you need to stop telling me what to do. Despite what my brother
thinks, I don’t answer to you.”
“You’re going to find out really fucking quick that you actually do.”
She ignored my warning. “So what? Yesterday didn’t happen? I’m
supposed to pretend like your dick wasn’t in my mouth? How about
everything you said to me? Am I supposed to forget that too?”
“Last night was between two consensual adults. Whatever I said was in
the heat of the moment. Now knowing who you are, there’s no way in hell
I’m ever going there with you again.”
I had to draw the line. It was pointless to lead her on in anyway other than
me looking out for her. I wouldn’t lose control with her again, and she
needed to understand that. The man she met was long gone. The only thing
that was left of him was my guilty conscience.
Shoving away the memories of her, I admitted, “I don’t want to hurt you,
but your brother means more to me than you.”
She grimaced, making me feel like an even bigger piece of shit.
“I’m such an idiot. I should have known better than to trust you. Men are
all the same. Thanks for reminding me of that.”
“Darlin’—”
“No! You don’t get to call me that. I don’t ever want to see you again.”
“You don’t have a choice. I already promised your brother, so, darlin’,
get used to my presence in your life because I’m not going anywhere.”
“We’ll see about that.” Slowly, she stepped back. “Tell Jax I had a
migraine and had to leave, but the truth is, I can’t look at you anymore. You
might be able to pretend like you didn’t feel everything I did yesterday, but
I’m not as great of a liar as you are.”
There was nothing I could say that could change the outcome of this day.
This was just how things between us needed to stay. If she wanted to hate me,
that was her problem. I made a promise to my best friend that I would be
there for her regardless.
Adding the final nail to my coffin, I demanded, “I want my hoodie before
you go,” referring to the one she was wearing.
Shaking her head in disbelief at my cold demeanor, she pulled it off and
threw it at me, and I caught it midair. Right when she opened the door to
leave, I couldn’t help myself in stressing…
“You’re my responsibility now.”
E VIE
Before he could speak a word, I shoved the document against his chest,
catching him off guard. He clutched the paperwork before it fluttered to the
ground.
“Here’s our contract. If you agree to all of my terms, you’re looking at
your new nanny.”
He didn’t bat an eye as he flung the document back at me. “I’m not
signing this.”
“What?” I scoffed. He was already testing my patience, and it was only
nine in the morning. “You didn’t even look at it.”
“I don’t have to look it over to know it’s full of terms and conditions I
refuse to follow.”
“Well then, I’m not going.”
“Darlin’, even if I signed your bullshit agreement, I’m not going to obey
it. We both know I don’t answer to anyone.”
“Especially me, right?”
“Did I say a word?”
“You didn’t have to. It was implied. But I’m not surprised in the least. It
won’t be the first time you’ve broken a promise to me.”
“The only thing I’ve ever broken is your heart.”
“Don’t give yourself that much credit, Caleb. Actually, I’m grateful we
never worked out.”
“Is that right?”
“Absolutely. I don’t have to answer to you. I didn’t then, and I don’t
now.”
“Then why are you standing at my door with your suitcase?”
“You’ve given me no choice. Again, you’ve forced your hand in my life.
Except this time it’s through my business. I’ve worked too damn hard to have
the best agency around, and I won’t let you take that away from me. So here I
am. You need a nanny. I have rules. Take it or leave it.”
He cocked his head to the side. “Since when have we ever followed the
rules, Evie?”
“That was before. I won’t fall for your antics this time. I don’t even drink
tequila anymore, so don’t think you’ll be able to get into my pants through
margaritas.”
“You make it sound like I took advantage of you, sweetheart, which
couldn’t be further from the truth. I gave you what you wanted, or better yet,
what you were begging me for.”
“I’m not here to talk about that mistake. In fact, I don’t want to discuss
anything that isn’t about Ethan and Ariel, as you’ll see on page three of my
contract. We’re not friends, Caleb. I have no interest of going down that road
with you.”
“Going down or on?”
“Per condition twelve on page four of our agreement, you’re not allowed
to talk to me like that anymore.”
“I haven’t signed a thing. I can speak to you any damn way I please.”
“Fine.” I narrowed my eyes at him. “Good luck on your trip with your
kids. Talk never.”
With that, I spun around to leave, but he caught my wrist, stopping me.
A spark of electricity sizzling through my skin was not what I expected.
Even after all these years, the lies, the pain, the memories of what could have
been, I thought I’d put it all behind me.
However, it was still alive and thriving. Our connection wasn’t something
I could ever ignore. Trust me, I’d spent years trying. My body’s reaction to
him was another emotion I wasn’t prepared for.
Instead of succumbing to him, I yanked my arm back and snapped,
“Don’t touch me.”
The bastard actually had the brass balls to grin, knowing exactly why I
was warning him. I don’t know how long we stood there, a power struggle
raging between us. Until out of nowhere, his baby girl wrapped her arm
around his leg.
This was the first time I’d seen her in person. After he married Tessa,
Caleb completely shut me out of his life in every way, shape, or form. I’d
only run into him randomly a couple times throughout the years. I’d seen
pictures of them at Jax’s house and in the press. Caleb was the best sports
agent in the industry, and reporters loved his rugged, handsome face. He was
getting better looking with age.
Bastard.
He was a private person. I’d never read or seen an interview with him.
Very rarely had I seen photos of his kids on gossip sites or magazines while
they were out in public. I had seen a few pictures of him and Tessa over the
years, but they weren’t intimate shots.
No one knew about my history with Caleb. It was always something I had
to go through alone, making me hate him even more for putting me through
the wringer with his over possessive bullshit. The number of dates this man
ruined for me while I was in college would blow anyone’s mind. Not to
mention, all the parties he would miraculously show up to. It was ridiculous.
I was young.
Naïve.
Fucking stupid.
Thinking he was doing it because he was in love with me when in reality
who the hell knows. Having his daughter look up at me with such a guarded
expression hurt my heart for her. This wasn’t about Caleb and me—this was
about his kids.
Jax unknowingly kept me in the loop over the years. He didn’t hide his
distaste for Caleb’s wife and his concern for their kids. Jax was their
godfather, and he loved them like they were his own. He often stated that
Tessa wasn’t fit to be called, “Mom,” saying Caleb was raising them on his
own, and all she did was spend his hard-earned money.
He felt bad for Ethan and Ariel. Now seeing Ariel for myself, I couldn’t
help but love her immediately, which only added to my confused emotions on
where I stood with Caleb.
C ALEB
If I was going to go down memory lane, then I was taking her with me.
Chapter 13
Evie
C ALEB
I wanted to do.
Chapter 14
Caleb
E VIE
A WEEK HAD GONE BY SINCE C ALEB WAS HOME AT A DECENT TIME . W E TOOK
two steps forward, only to take three steps back. I’d barely spoken to him
since the night he came home early, and it didn’t look like anything had
changed after our discussion.
Taking a deep, sturdy breath, I cleaned up the kitchen. I was getting ready
to tuck the kids into bed for their seven-thirty bedtime when Ariel walked
into the room.
“Miss Evie,” she expressed in the cutest tone.
“Sweetie, how many times have I told you to call me Evie?”
She shrugged in response, looking at me all shy. “When is Daddy coming
home?”
“I don’t know, honey. Do you need something?”
She shrugged again.
“Are you okay?”
The expression on her face told me she wasn’t. I picked her up off the
ground and sat her on the island in front of me.
Placing my hands on the side of her tiny body, I asked, “What’s wrong?”
“Is Daddy going to leave like Mommy did?”
I jerked back, never expecting her to question that. Thinking quick on my
feet, I affirmed, “I know your parents’ divorce is hard to understand, but your
daddy is never going to leave you.”
“That’s not what Ethan said.”
I cocked my head to the side. “What did he tell you?”
“That you were our new mommy now.”
Oh. My. God.
“Ariel, I could never replace your mommy. I’m just here to take care of
you, baby.”
“But that’s what Mommies do.”
I understood where she was coming from. Her concerns were valid.
“Yes, mommies do take care of their kids, but sometimes they need
nannies to help.”
“So you’re going to leave us too?”
This kid was breaking my heart into a million pieces.
“Sweetie, I promise I’ll always be in your life.”
“With my daddy?”
“No, honey, not with your daddy.”
“You don’t love him?”
I opened my mouth to respond, but quickly shut it.
How do I answer that?
“Your daddy is my boss.”
“But Daddy told me you’re the love of his life, like Prince Eric is with
The Little Mermaid.”
My eyes widened. “When did he say that to you?”
She scratched her little head. “I don’t remember.”
“Ariel, are you sure he said that to you?”
“Yes. I’m sure.”
“Was Ethan there as well?”
She shook her head. “I don’t know.”
Was this why Ethan thought I was his new mom?
“Your daddy and I have a very complicated relationship.”
“Daddy says he rescued you from a bad guy.”
“What else did he tell you?”
“That Uncle Jax is your brother, like Ethan is mine.”
“Okay, anything else?”
“Hmm…” She thought about it for a second. “That you’re beautiful and
have a big heart. And that you would take care of us, so he didn’t have to
worry because Grammy and Grampy can’t help him right now.”
I’d never met his parents before. Caleb didn’t talk about his family often.
From my impression, I didn’t think they were close. At least not back then.
To unexpectedly find out they were helping him raise his kids was eye-
opening to hear.
How much did I not know about him?
“Was that all he told you?”
“No, he said you would love us too.”
I smiled. “Of course I do.”
“Does my mommy love us too?”
“Of course she does, sweetie.”
“How do you know?”
This was the longest conversation we’d ever had together. I wasn’t
surprised Ariel’s vocabulary was prolific for a five-year-old. Everyone
treated her and Ethan like adults.
“Because that’s what mommies do.”
“Do you have kids?”
“No.”
“How come?”
“I’ve never met the right person to have them with.”
“What about my daddy?”
For some reason, my eyes flew to the camera in the room.
Did Caleb put her up to this?
Staring straight into the camera, I repeated, “Honey, like I said, your
daddy is just my boss.” Shifting my gaze back to Ariel, I reiterated, “But it
has nothing to do with my love for you and Ethan. Or your mommy’s love
for you two.”
“Okay, Miss Evie.” She giggled, “I mean, Evie.”
I beamed, finally feeling like I was getting somewhere with her.
“Can I have a hug?”
She nodded, throwing her arms around my neck before I could pull her
into my chest.
“How about I read you a bedtime story?”
“Can you read Peppa Pig?” she questioned, looking at my face. “She’s
my favorite.”
“Peppa Pig is my favorite too.”
I helped her off the counter as the doorbell rang.
“I’ll get it!” Ethan exclaimed, rushing down the stairs.
“Ethan, wait for me!” I hurried after him at the exact moment he opened
the door, revealing a man I’d never seen before.
“Uncle Joseph!” Ethan greeted, catching me by surprise.
Who’s Uncle Joseph?
Ariel hid behind my legs, seeking comfort from me for the first time.
“Hey there, princess. Don’t I get a hug?”
Ariel peered up at me, waiting for my approval. I nodded, giving her my
okay. After she timidly hugged him, she wrapped her arms around my legs
again, and I rubbed her head in a reassuring gesture.
“Hi, I’m Joseph.” He extended his hand. “Caleb’s brother.”
“Oh!” I replied, caught off guard. I shook his hand. “Hello, I’m Evie, the
kids’ nanny.”
“Nice to meet you, Evie.”
“Likewise.”
There must have been something in the Hawkins’ genes. Joseph was as
handsome as his brother. They both had dark hair, hazel eyes, and a killer
smile.
“Come in.”
“Is Caleb around?”
“No. He’s at work.” I shut the door behind him. “Does he know you’re
here to see him?”
“Not exactly.” He grabbed the back of his head. “I’ve learned over the
years it’s just better if I surprise him.”
I nodded, unsure of what he meant by that.
“I don’t know what time he’ll be home, but you’re more than welcome to
wait for him in the living room.”
“That’d be great, thanks.”
I let the kids catch up with their uncle for a little bit before putting them
to bed. By the time I returned downstairs, it was after nine at night. Joseph
was where I’d left him, sitting on the couch with Caleb nowhere to be found.
He was gazing at his phone while the television was on.
“I wish I could tell you Caleb will be home soon, but I honestly have no
idea what time he’ll be back.”
“It’s Caleb, so it’ll probably be late. Don’t feel pressured to keep me
company, though. I can wait for him alone.”
“Well.” I smiled. “I haven’t had much adult conversation this last month,
so if you don’t mind, I can wait with you.”
He gestured to the seat beside him. “By all means, Evie. I’d love your
company.”
I smiled again, sitting down. Wanting to break the ice between us, I
asked, “Do you live in Texas too?”
He looked at me funny. “I see my brother hasn’t mentioned me to you.
Good to know things haven’t changed with him.”
“Caleb’s never been one to share much about his family, or his personal
life for that matter.”
“It sounds like you’re speaking from experience?”
“You could say that.”
“Are you and him…”
“Oh, no.” I shook my head. “We’ve never been together like that. I’m just
here to help him with the kids while they’re in Spain.” Intentionally, I
changed the subject. “Do you talk to Caleb a lot?”
He chuckled. “Does Caleb talk to anyone often?”
“Good point.” I wanted to be hospitable. “Would you like anything to
drink or eat? We have plenty of leftovers from dinner tonight.”
“A nanny who cooks too? Caleb lucked out with you.”
“Hardly.” I stood, making my way into the kitchen. “Would you like a
glass of wine? We have that too.”
“A woman after my own heart.”
“I have to admit,” I laughed, “this adult conversation might be the
highlight of my day. Did you want me to warm you up some food too?”
“A beautiful woman waiting on me, I’d be an idiot to say no.”
We locked eyes.
“I see the Hawkins charm runs deep in your family.”
For the rest of the evening, we sat on the couch, drinking and eating,
talking about nothing in particular.
Except, I was not expecting him to ask…
C ALEB
I unlocked the front door and stopped dead in my tracks when I heard
Evie giggling like a fucking school girl. Instantly, I recognized that laugh.
Although, I hadn’t heard it since Jax’s vow renewal.
Who’s making her giggle like that?
As soon as I walked into the living room, I jerked back from the scene
unfolding in front of my seething glare.
In seconds, I was fuming. Seeing nothing but fucking red.
Bright. Fucking. Red.
There was Joseph.
My brother.
Shirtless.
Evie … in his arms.
They were laughing.
Happy.
Enjoying each other’s company.
“What the fuck?” I roared with my fists clenching at the sides.
They both jumped, peering over at me.
“Hey,” Evie greeted with glossy eyes and flushed cheeks, holding up
what I assumed was Joseph’s shirt. “I need to wash this. I mean…” She
shook her head, stumbling over her words. “I spilled my drink on his shirt,
and I was going to throw it in the washer before the stain set in.”
I didn’t pay her any mind. It was my brother who had my full attention.
Zeroing in on Joseph, I suspiciously eyed him up and down.
“What the fuck are you doing here?”
He scoffed out, “Nice to see you too, Caleb.”
“Whoa!” Evie exclaimed, bringing our attention back to her. “Why are
you being an asshole to him?”
I stepped toward her, but she stepped back and fell into the couch.
“Evie...” Joseph coaxed, leaning forward. He grabbed onto her arm and
wrapped it around his neck to help her up. “Let’s get you to bed.”
I was over to them in three strides, tugging her out of his arms. With one
deadly stare, he backed away from me with his hands out in front of him in a
surrendering gesture, understanding my not-so-subtle warning.
Evie swayed against my chest, and before she could argue, I cradled her
body into my arms and carried her out of the room. I desperately needed to
get away from my brother to calm the fuck down.
Despite hating the circumstances of why I was carrying her up the stairs, I
loved the feel of her against my torso. I tried to keep my focus on that instead
of the rage coursing through my veins and eating me alive.
Fucking Joseph.
I couldn’t believe he had the balls to show up here.
To hang out with Evie as if it were their first fucking date.
To see my kids.
To step into my home.
To hit on my fucking nanny.
Thinking about all the reasons why I wanted to knock him the fuck out
wasn’t helping me cool down.
It wasn’t until Evie announced, “I can walk you know,” that my anger
shifted to her.
“That’s an interesting perception. Seeing as you could barely stand
seconds ago, darlin’.”
“Stop calling me that.”
“You don’t want me to call you what I’m thinking.”
“Whatever you’re thinking, it’s false.”
“That’s good, considering I want to beat the fuck out of my brother for
even touching you.”
“I fell into his arms.”
“Even worse.”
“It’s not what you think.”
“It never is with you, is it?”
“You’re overreacting like always.”
“And you’re a pain in my ass like always.”
“I just want the record to show that I don’t feel well, and it’s the only
reason I’m letting you carry me to my room.”
“Who said I’m taking you to your room?”
“Caleb…”
“The way I see it you have two options, sweetheart. One, you can sleep in
my bed. Or two, you can sleep on the couch in my room. Either way, you’re
drunk, and I’m keeping an eye on you.”
“I’m not drunk.”
“Tell that to your feet when you stand.”
“Wh—”
To prove my point, I abruptly set her down, and she instantly stumbled
over her feet, which only pissed me off further. Instead of continuing this
bullshit conversation about what happened tonight, I threw her over my
shoulder.
“Hey!” she huffed out. “I liked it better the other way you were carrying
me!”
Once I stepped into my bedroom, I didn’t think twice about it. I spanked
her ass.
Hard.
“Caleb, what the fu—”
“Actions have consequences, Evie.”
“Caleb, if you don’t—”
I laid her down roughly on my bed and hovered above her small frame.
“If I don’t what, darlin’?”
She gasped.
The smell of merlot assaulted my senses, reminding me why I was pissed
off to begin with.
“You can’t do this.”
Narrowing my eyes at her, I challenged, “Then try to stop me, Evie.”
“I can’t believe you’re manhandling me again. You know how much I
hate it when you act like this.”
“I know how much you love pretending that you hate it.”
She rolled her eyes. “You don’t know anything. Especially when it comes
to me.”
“I know if I reached into your panties you’d be wet. Especially when it
comes to me.”
“Thanks for reminding me that all I ever was to you was a meaningless
fuck.”
“Your pussy was the last thing I wanted, but it was always the first thing
you threw at me.”
“You asshole!”
I growled, gripping onto her neck. “It was never about fucking you, Evie.
It was always about loving you.”
Her eyes widened while her body melted into the mattress. Her skin
flushed a deeper shade of red with each second that passed between us. I
could see it in her heady gaze—she wanted me to kiss her. Evie could never
hide her feelings from me. It didn’t matter how hard she tried. I could always
see right through her, making our connection that much stronger.
When she licked her lips, I knew she was baiting me, and because I
couldn’t resist, I inched closer to her mouth.
Almost touching her lips with mine, I rasped, “I can still taste you in my
mouth.”
She swallowed hard, and I felt it against my fingers around her throat.
“If all you ever were to me was just a meaningless fuck, then I’d fuck you
right now, and you’d let me.”
I pushed off the mattress and left her there, craving my touch, fully aware
I was right. I had to walk back into the living room to get my head straight. If
I didn’t, I’d fuck her right then and there just to remind her who she belonged
to.
Joseph was cleaning up their mess and paused when he saw me standing
there. I tried to keep a calm composure, but my temper wouldn’t allow it.
Stepping into his face, I spewed, “What the fuck are you still doing
here?”
He didn’t back down, not that I expected him to.
“What is your problem? I haven’t seen you in over a year. I can’t visit my
brother, niece, and nephew?”
“Who the hell do you think you’re talking to, Joseph? This is what you
do. You show up out of nowhere, always causing a disaster that you leave me
to clean up. When are you going to grow up and be a man, huh? What do you
need this time? More money? Who do you owe now?”
“Actually…” He cunningly grinned. “Since you’re still never around and
drowning yourself in work, I thought I’d fuck your lonely nanny—”
My fist connected with his jaw. His body whooshed back and stumbled
into the fireplace behind him where he caught himself.
“That’s your one warning, Joseph. Stay the fuck away from Evie and my
kids.”
Raising an eyebrow, he rubbed his jawline as he backed away from me.
“You always did have a temper, big brother.”
“Get the fuck out of my house!”
He smiled and chuckled. “Fine, but this isn’t over.”
“Nothing ever is with you.”
I watched him leave and locked the door behind him. I couldn’t stop
thinking about what I walked in on. I swear Joseph’s timing was always
impeccable, making his presence known when I least expected it. He was still
a fucking mess. I could see it in his eyes. It wouldn’t be the last time his
gambling addiction got him into trouble. I was exhausted from having to bail
him out.
For years my parents and I tried to help him, save him from himself, but it
didn’t matter what we did for him. It was never enough. He had an addicting
personality, and everything he did was to the extreme. Even as a child, he
was pure chaos running around our home.
Who knows what kind of problems he had now…
The only time he reappeared in my life was when he needed something.
He made the worst decisions. Since he was a kid, there was no controlling his
poor choices. Most of the time, they were complete and utter bullshit.
Getting suspended from school.
Dropping out of college.
Losing money left and right.
The list of his mistakes was endless.
I was fighting a battle I couldn’t win with him.
And now I was in a war with a woman I couldn’t live without. All I knew
was I couldn’t lose her again. I wouldn’t survive it. I barely did the first time.
To catch her in my brother’s arms, regardless of the reason, turned my
world upside down. Our relationship was frustrating, having no clue where
the fuck I stood with her.
One minute I felt like we were making progress, going in the right
direction, and the next I didn’t recognize the woman standing in front of me.
For the last eight years, I thought about her every day. Whether it was for a
few seconds or couple hours, I never stopped thinking about her.
I opened the cabinet in my bathroom and grabbed some pain reliever for
Evie before making my way back into my bedroom. She was passed out on
my pillow on my side of the bed. Her hair cascaded around her face,
reminding me of all the times I watched her sleep while she was in my arms.
I didn’t want to wake her, but if I didn’t then she’d wake up with a hell of a
hangover.
“Darlin’, you need to take this.”
She half-opened her glossy eyes, nodding at me.
After she swallowed the pills, I laid her back down. She was already
asleep when I began sliding off her jeans. I left her in her shirt and panties.
She rolled onto her stomach, groaning, “Caleb,” into my pillow.
I sat in the armchair by my bed, rubbing my temples in an effort to calm
the migraine that was looming.
“Mmm … Caleb…” she moaned, making me wonder what she was
dreaming about.
There was so much I wanted to say, so much I needed to tell her, but I
didn’t know where to start. I didn’t want to scare her away. She was finally
back in my life, and I was determined to keep her there. My brother showing
up out of nowhere was unexpected. It seemed like it was one thing after
another.
I still had hours of work ahead of me and decided to bring it into my
bedroom so I could watch over Evie as she slept. Although, I left before she
woke up the next morning. It was better that way. I didn’t sleep, and I was
fucking exhausted, running myself ragged.
Evie was right. I was missing so much time with my kids. They were
growing up so fast. Before I knew it, they’d be driving, in college, getting
married, beginning their own lives. I had to try to be present for them and
their futures.
I just hoped…
E VIE
C ALEB
A FTER OUR KISS , HE ABRUPTLY LEFT , AND I DIDN ’ T FEEL THE NEED TO
follow him. The sound of the suite door slamming shut was enough for me to
know a part of me still lingered on his mouth. Thinking about his lips on
mine, I rode the high that was Caleb Hawkins and walked into his room,
making myself at home on his bed.
I was going to wait for him, and what better way than in his space. He
wouldn’t be able to run away from me this time. I wouldn’t allow it. I’d get
to the bottom of his feelings for me if it was the last thing I did.
Laying on his bed, I stared at the ceiling. I incessantly rubbed my fingers
over my swollen lips, tasting him all over again. Although he wasn’t there
with me, I still felt him in every bone of my body.
I’d be lying if I said I hadn’t thought about him in ways I shouldn’t for
the last year, but I couldn’t help it. Every time he made his presence known
in my life, the little voice in the back of my head kept telling me there was
more to it than him just keeping his promise to Jax.
I wanted to hate him, truly I did.
But can you hate and love someone at the same time?
I laid there for hours until I looked over at the clock on the nightstand
which read two in the morning. Who knew where the hell Caleb went and
when he’d be back. At some point, I must have fallen asleep. The sound of
his footsteps descending down the hall woke me up. I instinctively rolled
over and put my back toward the door to pretend like I was sleeping.
He shuffled around his room, opening and closing drawers before making
his way into the en-suite bathroom where he turned on the shower. The
bathroom door opened minutes later, and out walked Caleb filling the space
with steam and his fresh masculine scent. Despite him taking a shower, the
pungent smell of whiskey assaulted my senses as I waited for his next move.
If he was surprised I was passed out in his bed, he didn’t show it. Nothing
happened for what felt like forever, but I swear I could feel his conflicting
emotions rolling off him in waves.
Especially when I felt the bed dip behind me.
My heart pounded out of my chest, faster and harder with each second
that passed. There was so much I wanted to say, but I couldn’t form the
words. Too many thoughts and emotions were overwhelming my mind at a
rapid pace.
Neither one of us said a word until finally, I felt his arm wrap around my
waist and pull me toward him. I swallowed hard. Conflicted was an
understatement of what I was feeling from what was unexpectedly
happening.
I didn’t know what to anticipate by coming into his room and falling
asleep in his bed. I guess I was running on pure adrenaline at that point, not
thinking about the consequences of my actions in that moment.
The instant I felt his hand slowly glide down my stomach, I didn’t move
an inch, wanting to see where he was going with this. Little by little, his
fingers slid closer to where I craved them the most.
Would he?
Lightly, he skimmed his fingers across the seam of my panties. The
summer dress I was wearing made it easy for him to do so. I could feel his
intoxicated breaths on the back of my neck, and I shut my eyes, anxious and
excited all at the same time.
At first, he went back and forth over the elastic as if he was fighting the
urge to do what we both obliviously desired. He softly caressed my lower
abdomen with his knuckles, leaving goosebumps in their wake. He slipped
his fingers into my panties, and I sucked in another breath.
His hand moved slowly until it was on my pussy. With each elevated
breath that escaped my lips, he moved them faster. Again, I didn’t say a
word, too afraid he would stop if I did. His fingers spread me open to rub my
clit, making me moan in encouragement.
Which was enough to trigger the response I wanted out of him. I knew he
could feel my wetness, urging him to keep going. He slid his fingers over my
nub in a side to side motion before trailing circles and causing me to see stars
fairly quickly. There were still no words from either of us, just heavy
breathing and moans.
I swayed my hips to match his skilled movements as he curved his fingers
inside of me, angling them directly toward my g-spot. He released a growl
from deep within his chest, vibrating against my core while working me over
with his fingers. I could only imagine what his cock felt like, but I didn’t
have to for very long.
It was rock hard against my ass.
Caleb fucked me faster with his fingers, determined to set me over the
edge. I rode his hand harder and harder. I wanted to hear him say my name,
but I didn’t want to push his limits. I was aware he was breaking every rule
he’d set and followed for the last year when it came to me and his role in my
life. I focused on what I could control in this moment because I knew he’d
lost his.
My head spun.
My body quivered.
My pussy pulsated.
I gasped, sucking in air, climaxing so hard…
I saw galaxies.
C ALEB
C ALEB
The day flew by, and before I knew it, Evie was dragging me into a
piercing shop at one in the morning.
“Come on, old man! A deal is a deal!”
I groaned, feeling the pain I was about to endure. On our way back to the
hotel from the Super Bowl party, she saw the shop on the corner of the street,
demanding we pull over immediately.
She spent most of the night by Jax’s side, being the only family who
attended his game tonight. We barely said more than a couple words to one
another the entire day. It was chaotic, exactly as I expected it to be. Being
yanked in every direction for Jax kept her at arm’s length from me for most
of the day.
After seeing the look in her eyes during the game and the party, I knew
what she was envisioning.
A family.
The one she never had before.
The pride and admiration that was radiating off of her wasn’t something I
could overlook. She genuinely loved him in every sense of the word. Only
confirming what I already knew—I couldn’t come between them.
Even if I wanted to.
It was the cold, hard reality I needed to witness in order to return to our
dynamic in the way it had been for over a year. I’d be hurting her way more
than I was if I took Jax away from her too. He’d flip the fuck out if he knew
we’d been lying to him for this long. There was no way I could tell him the
truth.
And what truth would that be anyway?
Half the time I had no idea where I stood with her or what personality I’d
get when I’d show up in her life. We’d been alone several times, but last
night was the first time that I’d lost all of my control with her. The instant I
saw her in my shirt this morning, I’d be lying if I said my cock didn’t get
hard. She looked breathtaking. I couldn’t help but remember what laid
beneath my shirt.
It didn’t help that every time I was around Evie with a crowd of people,
she was always the center of attention in any room without even trying.
Men’s eyes were on her all night, from Jax’s teammates to random people,
and I desperately tried to keep my temper in check.
My jealousy was a traitorous emotion I didn’t want to feel. It took
everything inside me not to claim her right then and there. In front of her
brother…
My client and best friend.
There was no controlling the internal battle that surfaced in my core—it
was a wave of sensation I refused to feel. There was something about kissing
her, touching her, making her come that drove me insane all day.
When she suddenly caught my stare from across the room at the party,
she knew what I was going through. I kept my distance, watching her from
afar like I didn’t just finger fuck her the night before.
I didn’t look away, wanting her to know I was conflicted and torn. I
should have known better than to put my hands on her again, fully aware I
wouldn’t want to stop if I did.
She was the first to break our connection, gazing at the ground instead of
my eyes. If she adverted her gaze for my benefit or hers, I had no idea, but I
didn’t give it too much thought either.
I couldn’t.
The minute I began contemplating if I was doing the right thing would be
the moment I’d give up everything for her. I shoved it away, out of respect
for her brother and our friendship. It was easier to pretend she was just his
little sister and I was looking out for her because of my promise to him.
She was right.
I did want her.
I wanted her more than I’d ever wanted anyone in all my life.
Bringing my attention back to her, she asked, “Aren’t you excited? I
mean, Jax did win the Super Bowl.”
“I had no doubt he’d win.”
Evie was on a mission as I followed close behind her up to the
receptionist.
She greeted, “Hi,” enjoying my agony way too fucking much. “We’re
here to get his dick pierced.”
I let her handle all the logistics, along for the ride that was my cock about
to get pierced. Once I was sitting in the chair in a private room with both
women staring at me, it was game fucking over.
My dick lost.
The only thing I could do was pray this wouldn’t hurt like a
motherfucker.
“Is this your first piercing?” the woman named Leeann asked.
“First and last.”
“Never say never, Caleb. This could be the start to your addiction for new
piercings.”
“She’s right,” Leeann agreed. “Piercings and tattoos are addicting. Are
you sure you want to go through with it? Jacob’s Ladder is a pretty intense
piercing for your first body jewelry. The recovery time is long as well.”
“Recovery time?” I scoffed out.
“Yeah.” She nodded. “You can’t have sex for six months.”
My glare locked with Evie’s.
It was only then I understood her true intentions. She blazingly smiled,
knowing I’d caught on to her spitefulness.
The little shit even winked at me.
“Bodily fluids could cause infection until the piercings are completely
healed. Like I said, this is an intense piercing. You sure you want to go
through with it?”
“Of course he’s sure,” Evie confirmed, grabbing the clipboard out of her
hands for me to sign the disclaimer.
“Anything else I need to know before I sign this?”
“Nope. After you sign, you’ll get your dick hard, and then I’ll—”
“Dick hard?” Evie interrupted, arching an eyebrow. “Wait? What?”
“The skin has to be stretched in order to do the piercings correctly. I can
leave you two alone.”
“No need,” Evie informed. “I’m not his girlfriend.”
“Oh…” Leeann smirked. “Well in that case, I can help you.”
“Umm…” Evie peered back and forth between us. “Isn’t that a little
unprofessional?”
“It’s only unprofessional if he doesn’t want me to.”
I signed the waiver and grinned as I leaned back in my seat. I purposely
wanted to piss Evie off. I unzipped my slacks next and replied, “By all
means, I’d appreciate any assistance.”
Leeann licked her lips, leaning forward before Evie stopped her with her
hand on Leeann’s forehead.
“You can leave now.”
“I thought you said he wasn’t your boyfriend?”
Cocking my head to the side, it was my turn to wink at Evie while she
glared back at me.
With one foot in front of the other, Evie abruptly walked to the door and
opened it.
“Forget what I said. I’ll let you know when you can come back in.”
I chuckled, unable to resist. I was amused by her sudden change of mind
when it came to my cock and who was actually touching it.
Leeann closed the door, and Evie walked toward me, each stride more
determined than the last.
I stopped her dead in her tracks when I stated, “The only touching you’re
going to do, darlin’, is on yourself.”
Her eyes widened.
“Spread your legs for me, sweetheart. Let me see your perfect pink
pussy.”
Conflicted, she questioned, “Why can’t I touch you?”
“Because I’ll end up fucking you.”
“Why is that so bad?”
“Because if I break that last rule, Evie, once my cock is inside of you, I
won’t be able to stop myself from fucking you whenever I want.”
“Again, why is that so bad?”
“I told you I’d do whatever you wanted if you stayed this weekend. I’m a
man of my word. Now shut the fuck up, pull your panties to the side, and
spread your legs for me, darlin’.”
“You know this bossin—”
I pulled out my cock, rendering her speechless.
“Time is money, Evie, and you’re wasting mine. Now spread your
fucking legs.”
She swallowed hard, sitting in the chair Leeann was just in before sliding
her panties to the side.
“Is this what you want?”
I growled, “More than you’ll ever know.”
Her concentrated stare zeroed in on my dick as I stroked it up and down.
“I want to watch you fuck yourself.”
“How did I get dragged into this?”
“The second you kicked her out of the room, you brought it on yourself.”
Up and down, I fisted my cock. Never letting up until she began playing
with her clit.
“That’s right, Evie. Just like that.”
Watching her wasn’t a sight I was expecting. This wasn’t ideal by any
means, but at least I wasn’t touching her again.
I could basically taste her on my tongue.
Feel her against my fingers.
Coming down my dick...
Long and hard.
Giving me exactly what I hungered for.
It didn’t take long for my cock to get hard. I didn’t stop her, longing to
keep the Evie show running right in front of me for as long as I could. She
was the vision of flawlessness. Everything about her was exquisite.
However, this was the last time I’d let anything like this happen between
us, so I took advantage of it.
Thoroughly mindful…
I. Was. Fucked.
“You see, Evie Monroe. When you love someone, truly fucking love
someone, you put their needs ahead of yours. Even if it means, breaking their
heart in the process.”
Chapter 22
Evie
D ID HE SAY HE LOVED ME ?
The question troubled my mind the entire time I was packing the kids’
suitcases and then mine.
The captain announced, “Sir, welcome aboard Living the Dream,”
bringing my focus back to the present. “We’re so excited to have your family
onboard for the next couple of days.”
“Oh,” I breathed out, caught off guard. “I’m just the nanny.”
I could feel Caleb’s anger burning a hole in my side.
“Evie.” Ariel tugged my shirt.
“Yes, honey?”
“You’re my best friend too.”
I smiled at her before locking eyes with Caleb. He was staring at us with
affection, but there was also something I couldn’t quite place.
Quickly shaking off the sentiment, I responded to Ariel. “Baby girl,
you’re my best friend too.”
For the next hour, the captain and his crew showed us around their
massive yacht. From the seven staterooms to the fully stocked kitchen, where
the chef would cook for us at any time of the day, to the living room, dining
area, the crew’s quarters, then down to the top deck of the yacht which had
the most amazing view of the ocean. There was a landing pad for a helicopter
to arrive if needed and two jet skis for us to play on.
I’d never seen anything like this luxury home on the water. I couldn’t
imagine what this was setting Caleb back. He even brought his assistant,
Jennifer, to help with Ethan and Ariel. I’d met her the morning I rang their
doorbell, letting him know I was his new nanny for their trip to Spain. The
kids liked her, and it was all that mattered to me.
While they were unpacking with Jennifer, Caleb barged into my
stateroom, making himself at home on my bed. He leaned against the
headboard, smiling at me.
“Don’t you know how to knock? I could have been changing.”
He grinned, looking at me with a predatory regard.
“You being naked isn’t anything I haven’t seen before.”
“That was different, and you know it. I have a boyfriend who wouldn’t
appreciate your—”
“My what, Evie? Love for you?”
“Why do you keep throwing out that word?”
“What word would that be?”
“Don’t be a smart ass. You know exactly what I’m talking about.”
“You used to love my smart ass personality. I thought I’d bring that back
for you too.”
“I don’t need you to bring anything back for me, Caleb. In fact, I love
feeling like I don’t know you. It makes it easier to hate you.”
“Whatever you have to tell yourself, sweetheart.”
I rolled my eyes. “What do you want?”
“Can’t I enjoy a casual conversation with my nanny?”
“I’m not your nanny. I’m your kids’ nanny.”
“What if I need you to tuck me in at night too?”
“That would make it hard, seeing as you’re never home.”
“Home?” He grinned again.
“You know what I mean.”
“Do you?”
“Stop it.”
“Stop what?”
“The flirting.”
“Is that what I’m doing?”
“Caleb, I mean it. My boyfriend—”
“Is a fucking idiot for letting you come live with me.”
“I’m not living with you. Besides, he doesn’t control my life unlike some
men I know. We actually have a healthy relationship. One that’s built on trust
and respect.”
“Your make-believe boyfriend sounds like a pussy.”
My mouth dropped open. “He’s a nice guy!”
“I’m a nice guy.”
“I hardly define you as a nice guy.”
“Is that right?”
“You scared away every date I had in college.”
“That’s what nice guys do.”
“Okay, what about knocking up my roommate? Is that what nice guys do
too?”
“Considering I came to your apartment that night to tell you how much I
loved you—”
“What?”
“You heard me.”
“You came to my apartment to tell me you loved me, but ended up
getting my roommate pregnant? How did that happen, Caleb? Did you fall
and your dick just happened to slip into her—”
“She was in your bed. I thought she was you.”
My heart began pounding against my chest. “In my bed? What was she
doing in my bed?”
“Tell me, Evie.” He folded his arms over his chest. “Did you ever inform
Tessa of who my family was?”
“I … I … I don’t remember, but why does it matter if I did?”
“Because she—”
“Evie!” Ariel shouted down the hallway, running into my room with
Ethan behind her. “I don’t want to do piano today. Can we go to the island
instead?” She halted her steps when she realized her father was on my bed.
“Daddy, what are you doing in here?” She giggled in the cutest sound.
My head was once again full of questions I couldn’t ask him with his
children around.
Because she what?
Resisting the urge to ask, I answered Ariel. “He’s in here so I can help
him plan all the fun things we have in store for you two.”
“Fun things?” Ethan questioned, looking at him. “You’re not going to
work?”
“Not this time, bud.”
“You mean you’re going to stay here with us?”
I could hear the hesitation in his voice, making me sad for all of them.
“There’s nowhere else I’d rather be.”
To my surprise, Ethan glanced over at me with the same expression that
was on his sister’s face. Both of them stared at me like lost puppies, waiting
for my reaction.
Or maybe it was my approval?
I smiled, nodding in reassurance.
“Baby girl.” Caleb smiled at her. “I think going to the island is the best
idea.”
“Really, Daddy?” She beamed.
“Of course, and you have me all to yourself.”
“Ethan! Did you hear what Daddy said?”
“You swear, Dad?”
“I promise.” He nodded. “This trip is the first of many to come.”
Shifting his gaze to meet my eyes, he added, “As a family.”
Rendering me speechless.
C ALEB
“D ARLIN ’…”
“Hmm,” I mumbled, stirring awake beneath my tangled white sheets as I
faintly felt someone’s lips laying soft kisses down the side of my neck.
“Wake up, birthday girl…”
My eyes fluttered, trying to wake up, but my body wouldn’t allow it, and
sleep won out. I was tired from spending so much time in the hot sun, falling
asleep fast and hard as soon as my head hit the pillow.
Dreaming only about Caleb.
Even in my deep slumber, I could still smell his intoxicating scent.
I could feel his soft lips trailing along my skin, making his way down my
stomach.
“Should I keep going?”
“Mmm hmm,” I hummed. Kiss by kiss, he pecked every inch of my
heated skin until he reached the edge of my panties, making my body shudder
at the heady feel of his mouth so close to my core.
I fisted my sheets.
Wanting.
Needing.
His tongue on my pussy.
When I felt his fingers tug the waist of my panties, my breathing hitched
and my eyes snapped open, big and wide. Coming face to face with the last
person I expected to see, hovering above me.
Caleb.
There was no way I was still dreaming, but if this happened to be a dream
within a dream, then I didn’t want to wake up. In that moment, the world
stopped spinning, stopped moving, and time just stood still for us.
“What are you doing?”
“I think that’s pretty obvious.” He grinned. “You said I could keep
going.”
“I was sleeping.”
“I was trying to give you your birthday present.”
With everything that was going on, my birthday had slipped my mind.
“Should I keep going?”
I shook my head.
“Are you sure, birthday girl? There’s nothing else I’d rather do than make
you come in my mouth.”
I was so disoriented.
“Your pussy wants me to keep going.”
“Yeah, well, it’s always wanted bad things for me.”
“I’ll make you feel really fucking good.”
“Where are the kids?”
“I love that you always think about them, Evie.”
“If they barge in here like their daddy—”
“I could get used to you calling me that.”
I rolled my eyes. “Can you please back up?”
“What? You used to love my face in your pussy.”
“Caleb, I mean it. If the kids—”
“They’re with Jennifer on the island.”
“Island? What time is it?”
“Almost noon.”
“What?” I exclaimed, caught off guard.
“It’s your birthday. I wanted you to sleep in.”
I grabbed my head. “My mind is spinning.”
“Let me take care of you then.”
“You’re the cause.”
He smiled.
“That’s not a good thing.”
“I could think of worst things.”
“Yes, because you’ve done them.”
“I’ve done some pretty great things too.”
“I don’t remember it that way.”
“As much as I’d love to continue where my mouth was headed, you need
to get dressed.”
“You sure are using that word a lot this week.”
He smiled. “I’m making up for lost time.” With that, he pushed off the
bed, ordering, “Get dressed. We’re leaving in twenty minutes.”
“Leaving? Where are we going?”
With an even bigger smile on his face, he informed, “To make up for
your last birthday that I ruined.”
C ALEB
By the time I walked back into her stateroom, she was sitting on the bed
wearing a light pink dress, deep in thought.
Slowly, I crossed my arms over my chest and leaned against the doorway,
wanting to remember her in this moment.
Her hair was pulled away of her face.
Her lips were still swollen from sleep.
Her dress clung to her skin, accentuating her curvy figure.
There was no taking my eyes off her. I couldn’t, and I didn’t fucking
want to. She was breathtakingly beautiful sitting there.
She looked like a dream.
My dream.
She didn’t turn toward me or acknowledge I was there, lost in her own
little world. A world I desperately wanted to be a part of again.
I gazed at the side of her gorgeous face, willing her to say something, but
her eyes remained front and center toward the middle of the room while mine
remained on her. The breeze blowing through the thin white curtains did little
to cool the surge of heat I felt for her.
I could see it in her eyes.
The doubt.
The insecurity.
The pain I’d caused.
My truths were weighing heavily on her mind.
I had no idea where we went from here. Evie was always my biggest
weakness and my greatest strength.
Unable to help myself, I walked into her room and caressed the side of
her face. To my surprise, she leaned into my embrace with her eyes closed,
melting into my touch.
“Caleb…”
The smell and feel of her was all around me, making me burn with desire
to claim every last fucking inch of her heart, body, and soul.
I wanted to capture this moment and hold onto it for as long as I could. I
wanted to remember her just like this.
For me.
Mine.
“What are you doing to me, Caleb?”
“I need you to give me a chance.”
She opened her eyes, staring straight into mine.
“A chance for what?”
“To show you the man you once loved.”
“And what if I can’t?”
“I need you to try. Please. Do it for my kids.”
She pulled away from my touch. “That’s not fair.”
“They deserve to have you in their lives.”
“They do—”
“Permanently.”
She gasped as my thumb pulled on her bottom lip.
“I’ve never been happier than when I’m with you. Even when you hated
having me around, they were still the best moments in my life. You made me
laugh, smile, feel like I was living again. You make me want to be a better
father for my children and a better man … for you.”
“Caleb—”
“You know that, don’t you? The affect you’ve always had on me? From
your eyes, to your words, to the way you are with my kids. You’re my
family, Evie. You’ve always been my family. You fill this void I didn’t know
I had in my life until I met you. There’s no coming back from you, Evie. I’ve
tried.”
I was a man of a few words. Yet there I was, laying it all out for her.
Word by word.
Sentence by sentence.
Making my thoughts and emotions known for the first time.
“I plan to have you all to myself today. Just you and me. Now tell me you
want that too…”
“Do people always do what you want?”
“Yes, you should try it sometime.”
She smiled, and it lit up her entire face.
“I can’t think when you’re this close to me.”
“Then I’ll make sure to stay close to you all day.”
She backed away, reaching for her purse. “Okay, Mr. Hawkins, let’s see
this amazing day you have planned for my birthday.”
In two strides, I grabbed her hand and led her off the yacht where there
was another boat waiting for us. The day started with sightseeing and
exploring the town where Evie was amazed by all the small shops. She tried
to buy a couple of things for herself, Ethan and Ariel, but I paid for them
instead.
For the first time since she came back into my life, she finally allowed
herself to enjoy my company.
We laughed.
Joked.
Talked about nothing and everything.
Except for what I really wanted her to know which would come later
tonight.
The day couldn’t have been better. I loved every second with her,
remembering how truly easy it was for us to hang out. Our banter flowed
loosely, effortlessly like always. The day quickly turned to night, and I had
the crew cook up a spread for her birthday.
I made her close her eyes before she saw what I prepared for her. We
were on the top deck of the boat that picked up us to take us to town. I
wanted complete privacy, knowing we wouldn’t get that with my kids
around. If these last couple of days proved anything to me, it was how much
they were glued to her side.
I couldn’t blame them. Evie was even easier to love.
“Caleb, this is stunning.”
They decorated the table with LED candles and an assortment of pink
roses, her favorite. A bottle of champagne chilled in the metal bucket.
“I can’t believe you did this.”
The stars sparkled in the night sky with the full moon looming over the
horizon. There was this energy between us that flowed into the air. This
magnetic pull that never went away. If anything, it only intensified as the
years evolved.
Evie always controlled my thoughts.
My actions.
My choices.
Consuming every last part of me since the first time I set eyes on her.
“Come here.” I motioned with my finger.
She cunningly smirked, as I pulled her toward me instead, making her
straddle my lap. She didn’t say a word, but she didn’t have to.
Her eyes spoke for themselves.
“I’d do anything for you. Look up, darlin’. Look at all the stars.”
She glanced up for a second before she questioned in a conceding tone,
“Why are you doing this to me, Caleb? Is this just another scheme to get your
way?”
“You know that’s not true.”
“Which part? The one where you pretended you didn’t know me after the
day we had shared? Or how you not only ruined my social life, but also my
dating life all through college?” Her voice remained sturdy and strong,
though the tormented expression on her face gave away her anguish. “Or how
about all the years you pushed me away before you knocked up my
roommate and then married her?”
I didn’t respond, listening intently to the allegations I knew she still had
to spew.
“Do you know I’ve hated my birthday until today?”
“At least I did something right.”
“Why would you do that to me, Caleb? How could you hurt me like that
when you’d already hurt me enough?”
I winced. Her admitting that was worse than already knowing it.
“You want me to forgive you, but it’s so hard to do that. You pushed me
away, completely dropped out of my life. Why? I deserve to know the truth. I
knew there was something more to you and Tessa. It was written all over
your face when you came to my apartment the next morning. You wouldn’t
tell me then, but you have to tell me—”
“If I didn’t marry her…” I paused for a moment, catching my bearings.
This would be the first time I’d ever confessed this to anyone. I didn’t
think I’d get a second chance to make things right, and I wasn’t going to
waste another minute without her by my side.
Looking deep into her glossy gaze, I finally told her the truth…
Whole again.
Chapter 26
Caleb
E VIE
T HIS WASN ’ T HOW I IMAGINED THE TRUTH WOULD FINALLY COME OUT .
Never in my wildest dreams did I think a fucking tabloid magazine would
spill a twisted version of our love story. I had no choice but to explain and try
to reason with Jax, knowing in the end I might lose my best friend to the
woman I couldn’t continue to live without.
At least, I was somewhat in control of the situation. Based off the article,
he had every right to be furious with me, but I was ready to fight for Evie.
Even if it meant losing him in the process.
No matter what, Evie was mine. If I had to prove it to her in a hundred
different ways, I would. In the meantime, man to man, her brother and I
would deck it out. The time had come for the truth to prevail.
Regardless of the consequences.
“What?” Jax harshly questioned.
“You heard me. I already asked her to marry me.”
His eyes widened while Evie listened intently to what I was saying. “A
couple weeks before her twenty-second birthday, I was going to give it all up
for her, but I started questioning if it was right or wrong. I found myself at
the bottom of a bottle of Jack and ended up at her apartment. Tessa was in her
bed, and one thing led to another. However, I don’t remember a damn second
of it. A month and a half later, Tessa showed up at my condo to tell me she
was pregnant.” I paused to let my words sink in.
“And the only reason I married her was to keep my relationship with Evie
from you. Tessa found out about Evie and me. She knew you were her
brother, and she was going to tell you if I didn’t make her my wife. You’ve
said it yourself several times, Jax. I was just trying to do the right thing by
her. Except, it wasn’t the right thing for my child, but it was the right thing
for Evie not to lose you to me.”
He stood there, contemplating what I had said before he asked, “How did
she know about Evie and me?”
“I have no fucking idea.”
“Don’t try me, Caleb! Not right now!”
“Or what?” I countered, cocking my head to the side. “You’re going to
punch me again? It’s not going to change our past. It doesn’t matter how
many times you hit me. It won’t change anything! I’m done pretending like
she isn’t my whole fucking world!”
He shoved me, and since I was expecting it, I didn’t budge, which further
triggered the fury in his blood.
“How could you lie to me? I trusted you with everything! Including my
baby sister!”
“Jax, enough!” Evie ordered, stepping in front of me. “I’m not a baby!
I’ve never been a baby! I didn’t need Caleb’s protection then, and I don’t
need it now! You need to back up and just stop. I’m not a child. I can make
my own decisions. I understand you thought you were doing what’s best for
me, but for one second, you never considered what I thought was best for me.
You blame our father for not protecting me. Well, I blame you for
overprotecting me. This could have been avoided. All these years of pain and
lies, if you’d just let go of the image of me that you had in your mind.”
“What do you want from me, Evie? I didn’t have a family until I met you.
You loved me unconditionally right from the start. You fought our own father
so I could be in your life. What did you expect me to do? Huh? Just forget the
fact you didn’t have anyone else but me?”
“No.” She shook her head. “Of course not. I appreciate everything you’ve
ever done for me. I don’t know where I would be if it wasn’t for you. I love
you, Jax, but I can’t take this anymore. If I want to be with Caleb, then it’s
my choice. Solely my decision. Not yours or anyone else’s for that matter. I
don’t tell you how to live your life, and it’s not fair you won’t grant me the
same respect. What have I ever done for you not to trust me?”
“I trust you, Evie.”
“You have a shitty way of showing it.”
“You think this is the best way for me to find out? Through fucking
extortion?” He grabbed the folder out of my hands. “I’m fresh out of one
scandal, and now I have to deal with this? When you could have just fucking
told me the truth?”
Caleb chimed in, “And what would you have done, Jax? What would you
have said if I told you I was in love with her back then?”
“Fuck!” He tugged his hair away from his face as if he wanted to tear it
out. “I don’t know! All I know is right now I want to fucking kill you!”
“You would have wanted to kill me back then too.”
“Not as much as I want to kill you right now!”
“Jax, please,” Evie pleaded. “You need to calm down. This isn’t helping
anyone. You’re only making things worse.”
“I’m making things worse?” he mocked. “I’ve seen pictures of my best
friend’s dick inside of you like you’re a fucking whore—”
“Caleb, no!”
My fist flashed past Evie’s face to crush against her brother’s jaw.
“Oh my God! Can we please stop hitting each other for one fucking
second?!”
“Don’t you ever call her a whore!”
She gripped onto my arm. “Stop it! You’re as bad as he is!”
“I can’t stop thinking about how many times you were alone with her! I
was supposed to protect her, but all I did was hand her right to you! Do you
have any idea how sick that makes me?”
“You know that’s not true.”
“Caleb, I don’t know shit. I don’t know you at all.”
“Fuck, Jax! What do you want from me? I’m telling you the truth! You
want to hate me? Fine. Be fucking livid with me! But don’t take your anger
out on Evie. She loves you. You’re the only family she has. She doesn’t
deserve that. She’s done nothing wrong. I hate that this is happening. I hate
that I can’t do anything about it. But please, don’t blame her for this.”
“I don’t know how to get past this.” He shook his head, disappointed.
“How did I not know what was going on between you two? I love Evie more
than anything in this world, and I couldn’t see it? How many times were we
all together and still I was so fucking blind?”
“I … don’t…” I sighed, not knowing what to say.
“I can’t look at you right now. I can’t even look at my own sister. Do you
know how hard that is for me? You two are the most important people in my
life, and I can’t stand to face either of you. All I see is your lies.”
“I’m sorry, Jax. I don’t know what else I can say to make this right.”
“Sophie knows, doesn’t she?”
“Don’t drag her into this, Jax.”
He faintly nodded. “Shit…” was all he managed to say. “I’ll tell you this
right now. In front of both of you. You hurt her, Caleb. I’ll beat you within an
inch of your life. You hear me? I’ll end you.”
“I swear on my life. I’ll die before I ever hurt her again.” My eyes
connected with Evie’s. “I love you.”
“I don’t agree with this,” Jax added, backing away. “There’s no point in
pretending like I do. Who’s to say that won’t change, but for right now, I still
want to fucking kill you.”
I nodded, fully aware…
He meant it.
E VIE
I believed him.
Chapter 29
Evie
W E WERE ON OUR WAY TO C ALEB ’ S PARENTS ’ HOUSE , AND I MADE HIM STOP
at the flower shop to buy his mother a mixture of pink roses, my favorite.
“Stop fidgeting.”
“I can’t help it. I’m freaking out.”
Despite his mother wanting to send the chauffeur to pick us up from the
private hangar, Caleb had an SUV waiting for us. He was adamant about
having his own vehicle which didn’t surprise me. He was a control freak like
that.
Ethan and Ariel were on their iPads. They were watching a movie with
their headphones on, so we could speak naturally.
“What if they don’t like me?”
“I like you.” He winked at me. “A lot.”
“Caleb.” I playfully slapped his chest. “I’m serious. I’ve never met
someone’s parents before.”
“Is that right?”
“Yes. My dates never got that far. You would know, you ruined most of
them.”
He smiled proudly. “They’re going to love you, darlin’.”
“Do they know about me?”
“They do.”
“Okay … and?”
“And what?”
“Oh, come on! I’m dying here. Don’t make me beg.”
He whispered, “But you know how much I love it when you’re on your
knees for me.”
My eyes shifted to the kids. They weren’t paying us any mind.
Giving into his demands, I mockingly pleaded, “Please, oh please, Mr.
Hawkins. Tell me what your parents know about me?”
He laughed, throwing his head back.
“Did it work?”
“It’d be better if you were actually on your knees, but I’ll take the bait.”
I bit my lip, anxiously waiting for his response.
“They know everything.”
My eyes widened. “You’re joking.”
“Why would I joke about that?”
“So they know like everything, everything? Like our history too?”
“Cliff notes version.”
“When did you tell them?”
“When you started working for me.”
I gasped. “Caleb!”
“What?” He chuckled. “My mother is extremely overprotective.
Especially when it comes to her only grandchildren. I had to ease her mind by
telling her you’ve come on my coc—”
“Oh my God. You better be joking.”
He reached for my hand, kissing it. “I am. Relax. She knows how much
you mean to me and my kids. They wouldn’t stop talking about you when
they last spoke on the phone. Trust me, you’ve won them over already, and
they haven’t even met you yet.”
“This isn’t making me feel any better.”
“You can sit on my face. That usually works for you.”
I rolled my eyes, nodding to the kids in the back.
“We can sneak into my bedroom.”
“Eww! Where you’ve taken all your high school hookups? No thank
you.”
“Sweetheart, I never fucked anyone in my bed.”
I smirked.
“I always fucked them in theirs.”
“Caleb!”
My shouting caught Ethan and Ariel’s attention. For the rest of the ride,
we interacted with them until Caleb drove through these huge golden gates
that entered an enormous estate.
Their property was massive. I thought my brother had a compound, but it
didn’t compare to Caleb’s parents’ estate.
“Wow.”
“Yeah, try growing up in this place.”
As soon as Caleb parked, Ethan and Ariel booked it out of the SUV,
running toward the front door while I stayed glued to the seat.
“Come on, darlin’, let’s go.”
“Do I look okay?” I pulled down the visor, looking in the mirror.
“You look gorgeous. Now get your ass out of the car before I do it for
you.”
He stepped out, and I followed his lead, unconsciously grabbing his hand.
“I have one more question.”
“Mmm hmm.”
“Do they know the truth about you and Tessa?”
“They fucking hate Tessa. They’ve always hated Tessa. My mother spent
months trying to convince me not to marry her.”
“Okay.” I inhaled a deep breath. “I feel much better now.”
My heart was pounding out of my chest as we walked inside. Their home
was like a museum with columns, portraits, and antiques in every corner. I
couldn’t believe he grew up in this extravagance and decadence. I was
mesmerized, trying to focus on one thing at a time, but there was too much to
see.
“This is crazy,” I muttered under my breath.
“Tell me about it. This estate has been in my family for generations.”
“I can see that. The painting by the door? Is that a real Picasso?”
“Everything you see is real.”
“That painting alone is worth a fortune. There’s being rich, and then
there’s wealthy. Your family is beyond both.”
“Don’t let it intimidate you.”
“How can I not?”
“Caleb!” His mom calling for him interrupted us. “Honey, we’re in the
kitchen with the kids!”
I inhaled another deep, solid breath, making our way into the room.
“Caleb.” His mom rushed over to him, instantly pulling him into her
arms.
They embraced for a couple of seconds before our eyes connected.
“Hi.” I extended my hand to her. “I’m Evie, so nice to finally meet you.”
“I know who you are. Welcome to our home,” she greeted, pulling me
into a snug hug.
I was a little caught off guard. However, I quickly hugged her back. The
rest of the day was easy, although I didn’t think it would be. Caleb’s father
was just as kind as his mother was. I enjoyed being around them. It was
effortless, like my connection with their son.
They caught me up on his life, telling me all about him when he was
young. She even brought out photo albums, and we spent hours going
through each one. The kids loved seeing their dad as a child.
One thing was for sure, though, Caleb was his mother’s everything. It was
blatantly obvious how much she cared for him. It was amazing to witness the
love they all had for each other. I didn’t have this growing up, and I was
beyond grateful to see it for the first time in my life. Don’t get me wrong,
Jax’s family was loving too, but this was different.
Familiar yet new.
After Caleb left to put the kids to bed, I walked outside, needing a minute
to take in the day we’d just shared with his family. I didn’t realize how much
being around him and his loved ones would affect me.
Until I heard a voice ask from behind me, “You love him, don’t you?”
I immediately turned, finding his mother standing there.
“I’ve always loved him.”
“I can tell.” She smiled. “My son is an amazing man.”
“He is. He’s an amazing father too. Ethan and Ariel worship the ground
he walks on. You did a great job raising him.”
“Thank you. He was the easy child. Joseph was the opposite. They were
both raised with the same morals too. Just proves it doesn’t matter how you
raise your children. In the end, all you can do is hope and pray they’ll find the
right path in life.”
“That must be hard, worrying about Joseph.”
“I worry about Caleb too. He’s had to play both roles as a parent. We’ve
tried to help him as much as we could, but his brother has a way of pulling us
back into his world.”
“Is Joseph alright?”
“We think so. It’s hard to tell with him sometimes.”
“Is he attending the party?”
“Who knows with him. Have you met him yet?”
“Briefly. He was charming,” I nervously breathed out. “He stopped by
unexpectedly while we were in Spain.”
“How did Caleb take it?”
“Umm … they don’t seem to have the best relationship.”
“Through the years, Joseph has done a lot of damage, and Caleb has been
there for him several times. I don’t blame Caleb for being distant with his
brother. Although, I do wish they’d have a better relationship, but I’m
hopeful that one day it will happen.”
Unsure of what to reply, I simply smiled in reassurance.
Changing the subject, she questioned, “How is Jax these days?”
“He’s good.”
“He’s such a wonderful man and can throw a football like no one can.”
“That’s why they call him the greatest of all time.”
“I’m glad you three were able to work everything out.”
“Caleb told you about that, huh?”
She chuckled. “I’m a prying mother.”
“I understand. My brother is like that with me. He spent years having
Caleb look out for me when I didn’t really need it.”
“It’s his job to protect you.”
“Yeah, and Jax takes—”
“I’m not talking about Jax.”
“Oh … well, in that case, I honestly don’t know which one is worse if
we’re comparing my brother and your son.”
“I can only imagine. Caleb has always been the protector of our family.
Even as a child, he didn’t have very many friends. He always wanted to make
sure he could trust them before they came into our home.”
“I can totally see that. He’s a very private person.”
“He’s always been that way. I don’t want to bring up a sore subject,
but…”
I knew our conversation would eventually lead to the kids’ mother, but it
didn’t stop the uncertainty I felt when she asked, “Have you seen Tessa
lately?”
Chapter 30
Evie
“I HAVEN ’ T .”
“Of course not. She won an obscene amount of money in the divorce
settlement. It’s all she ever wanted anyway.”
“Yeah, so I’ve been told.”
“Evie.” She sympathetically nodded. “I’m sorry for what Caleb must
have put you through. He made a mistake, and it cost him years of his life.
Tessa is a horrible woman, let alone mother. My grandchildren deserve
better. They always have. I can’t tell you how happy I am that they have you
now. Like I said, I worried about them constantly, and over the last two
months, I’ve started worrying about them less and less. Today only proves
how much of an effect you’ve had on their lives. Including my son’s.”
“They’ve all had the same effect on me, Mrs. Hawkins.”
“Please, call me Gale.” She spoke so soft and eloquently. “We all have
choices in life, Evie. Whether they’re good or bad, they’re ours to make. My
son has always wanted to do the right thing. He loves you, and I can see you
love him too, but I can also see something else in your eyes. You’re scared,
and I don’t blame you. Love can be a scary thing sometimes.”
“Did he tell you he asked me to marry him?”
She nodded again.
“I want to say yes. Truly, I do. I guess I don’t really know what’s holding
me up. My brother knows about us now. He was the main reason we couldn’t
be together in the first place. Now that he knows about us, I feel like there’s
still another shoe waiting to drop.”
“Tomorrow you’ll meet the whole family, and maybe it will help ease
your apprehension about the future.”
“You might be right,” I agreed, feeling better than I did. “Thanks for
taking the time to talk to me.”
“Honey, that’s what family does.” She hugged and kissed me goodnight,
excusing herself to go up to bed.
Caleb’s room was on the far end of the estate, and before I knew what I
was doing, I knocked on his door.
He answered shirtless and devastatingly handsome. My heart literally
skipped a beat, as I jumped into his arms. There was no uncertainty of his
behalf.
He welcomed me into his arms, wrapping one behind my back and the
other behind my head, murmuring, “You alright?”
I tucked my face into the nook of his neck.
His kindness.
His patience.
His gentleness.
His love.
It was perfect.
He was perfect.
C ALEB
I picked her up, then kicked the door shut before I carried her over to my
bed and laid her on the mattress. Softly, I kissed all over her face, longing to
take away all the pain I’d caused her.
My regret would be my biggest hardship to overcome.
Evie gazed deep into my eyes, trying to understand our connection, our
love, the fact that we couldn’t stay away from one another for very long.
Even when we had to.
“Make love to me,” she coaxed, just loud enough for me to hear. “Please
make love to me. Touch me like you’re never going to let me go. Make me
yours.”
I didn’t have to be told twice.
My lips moved to hers, and I gently kissed her, my tongue seeking out
hers.
“You’re so beautiful, Evie. Do you have any idea how beautiful you are
and how much you mean to me?”
She lovingly smiled as I unbuttoned her blouse, discarding it onto the
floor. Her skirt, bra, and panties quickly followed until she was completely
naked for me.
So vulnerable.
So exposed.
Everything I ever wanted.
Her breathing became erratic, and I had barely touched her. I wanted to
take my time to love her like she deserved, to show her what she did to my
heart and what I did to hers.
I grabbed the back of her neck, claiming her mouth once again. My hands
roamed her silky skin in a slow, torturous melody. I was torn with craving to
feel her and wanting to see her come undone, knowing her mind mimicked
mine by the expression on her face.
For the first time, her emotions poured out of her, wreaking havoc all
around us. Her delicate fingers caressed the sides of my face, and I knew she
was telling me she loved me without having to say it. The words were written
clearly across her face.
My fingers lightly touched her nipples, making them hard within seconds.
I leaned forward, breathing on them, and took one into my mouth while my
hand caressed the other.
Evie grabbed the back of my neck, pulling me closer before bringing my
mouth back to hers. I pecked her at first, teasing her lips with the tip of my
tongue and then all along the outline of her pouty pink mouth.
My fingers ran against her cheek and down her body, finding her perfect
pussy that was already wet for me. I tried to move my mouth, wanting to taste
her, but she wouldn’t let me.
“Caleb…” She shuddered.
My fingers moved faster around her clit as her breathing became heavy.
Both our mouths were open from her looming orgasm that was rising higher
and higher with each rub of my fingers.
“Yes… yes…” she panted as she came apart, dripping down my hand.
My body laid on top of hers, caging her in with my arms and legs. Evie
loved it rough, but in that moment, she wanted me to go nice and slow for
her, and I happily obliged.
Gently, I thrust into her tight, wet pussy, worshipping her with my cock. I
affectionately kissed all around her face, jawline, and neck, thrusting in and
out of her at a slow and soft pace.
I could sense her love and adoration for me. It was spilling out of her,
engulfing me like the waves of the ocean. I lapped at her breasts, leaving tiny
marks where I sucked.
I groaned, “Does that feel good?” kissing my way back up to her mouth.
“Yes … harder,” she breathed out.
She hugged me close to her body to put more of my weight on her. She
wanted to feel surrounded by me and what I was giving her.
The pleasure.
Adoration.
Devotion.
Love…
Her eyes stayed open the entire time, and I pressed my forehead against
hers. Our mouths were still parted, simply breathing in each other’s air as we
panted profusely. The skin-on-skin sensations while my cock hit her g-spot
was all-consuming. I swear you could hear the pounding of our hearts
echoing off the walls.
I could feel her begin to unravel, and I was right there with her. Pulling
her knee up to meet my hip, I thrust in harder and more demanding. Rotating
her hips, she met each and every one of my thrusts. Her pussy pulsating made
my dick throb.
“Come with me, Caleb,” she moaned into my mouth.
“Fuck… I love you…”
It was all she needed to hear to climax all around my cock, taking me
right along with her. We shook, trembling with our release while I never
stopped kissing her. It didn’t take long for me to get hard again. I made love
to her into the morning hours.
“Everything.”
Chapter 32
Caleb
O UR STARES LOCKED .
“I need you to know that no one has to find out what I’m about to tell
you.”
“Joseph, what’s going on? What kind of trouble are you in now?”
“I’m not the one who’s in trouble.” He opened his suit jacket, grabbing
what looked like a photo. “This time it’s you.”
Before I could reply, he handed the photo to me. Almost instantly I tried
controlling my temper. However, I failed miserably as I stared at a photo of
him kissing the woman I least expected.
Tessa.
“When was this taken?”
Feeling the shift in my demeanor, he coaxed, “Caleb, what I’m about to
divulge will make you hate me, but I need you to know I was beyond fucked
up back then. Drinking, drugs, gambling. You name it, and I was doing it.
I…” He shook his head, stumbling over his words. “If I could change what I
did, I would.”
“Enough with the pep talk.” I glared at him, holding up the picture.
“When the fuck was this taken?”
“A year before she got pregnant.”
My heart began beating at a rapid pace, a mile a minute with each word
that drew me closer to what he had to confess.
“After Grandfather didn’t even consider me for the business, I was lost,
blaming all my fuck ups on you. You were always the good son. All my life
I’ve felt as if I’m walking through your shadow. Nothing I did was ever good
enough, compared to what you could accomplish.”
My hand fisted at my side while anger coursed through my veins. The
audacity of this piece of shit to blame me for his insecurities.
“I owed a lot of people money, and I didn’t know what else to do but con
you.”
I jerked back. “Con me?”
“Yeah. We came up with a plan.”
“A plan for what?”
He rubbed the back of his neck, anxiety radiating off of him.
“To take your money.”
Our chests heaved in sync with one another, our heated emotions running
wild. I could feel his remorse surrounding every last part of me. Just like a
ticking time bomb, I waited for it to explode in my face.
“How did you know Tessa?”
“We randomly met at a bar one night. I thought I loved her.”
“So what? That makes it okay?”
“No. I’m sorry, Caleb. I wasn’t thinking. I would never—”
“I don’t want to hear your pathetic excuses! Now fucking tell me what
else you need to say!”
He hesitated for a moment. “The plan was to get you to marry her, but we
didn’t know how until she ran into you and Evie at a pool party. For years she
thought something was going on between you two, but as you know, Evie
was your best kept secret. One night when she was in the shower, Tessa
snuck into her bedroom and looked at her phone. After months of trying to
figure out her password, she finally nailed it. It was your birthday.”
The realization hit me like a ton of fucking bricks. “That’s how she knew
Jax was Evie’s brother.”
He nodded. “She found their text messages when she was looking for
yours. I followed you around for weeks, trying to figure out how we could
get you to marry her. We needed more ammunition other than blackmailing
you with Jax, in case it wasn’t enough to convince you to marry her. It was
the only way, Caleb.”
“What was?”
“You’ve always done the right thing. It’s who you are. It’s how you’re
made.”
I was aware of where he was going with this. “You knew I’d marry her if
she was carrying my baby.”
“Yeah.”
I tugged my hair away from my face, wanting to tear it the fuck out. “So
you waited until I was shitfaced to make your plan go into effect. That’s why
Tessa was in Evie’s bed that night.”
He nodded again. “Except we couldn’t risk her not getting pregnant.”
I grimaced, hanging on by a thread. “No … please don’t tell me…”
I thought I could handle anything the world threw at me. Especially when
it came to my brother. However, nothing could have prepared me for what
happened next.
Not his lies.
Not his truths.
Not. One. Damn. Thing.
The atomic bomb didn’t just explode in my face. It erupted throughout
my entire body, leaving very little in its place as he declared, “Ethan’s my
son.”
BOOM.
It was loud.
Tragic.
Triggering me to see nothing but fucking red.
Bright. Bold. Red.
I reacted.
Forcefully gripping onto his collared shirt, I slammed his back against the
cement wall behind him, ready to fucking kill him.
He loudly gasped, sucking in the air I was taking from him.
“He’s not your son! He will never be your son!”
“I know he’s yours, Caleb. I swear to you.” He shook uncontrollably in
my grasp. “I don’t want them, I swear … but I had to tell you. These lies are
eating me alive!”
I stumbled back, letting him go with tears in my eyes.
“Them?”
“I’m sorry, Caleb. I’m so fucking sorry, but…”
“No…” I begged for I don’t know what. “Please … don’t…”
Another bomb detonated through my soul as he confessed, “Ariel is mine
too.”
I fell to my knees. My legs couldn’t hold me up anymore.
This was what dying felt like.
Eliciting feelings I never thought possible, emotions no one should ever
have to experience. I felt every loss of breath as if he jammed a knife into my
heart. Agony clutched my heart and wouldn’t let go.
“Your prenup stated the more kids you had, the more money she’d get if
you divorced. We knew you’d eventually file, so we made Ethan to get you
to marry her, but we made Ariel to get more money out of you. We just had
to wait for the perfect timing to get you to think you’d slept with her.”
I whispered, “We never had sex.”
“No, we just made you believe you did. We rigged the paternity tests to
prove you were the father of both of them.”
All the air from my lungs vanished.
I couldn’t breathe…
I couldn’t fucking breathe.
Not for a second.
A minute.
A lifetime.
My heart shattered into a million pieces.
It was raw.
Excruciating.
Downright torture.
I was suffocating in his lies and now I was drowning in his truths.
Without thinking twice about it, I charged at him, ramming my shoulder
into his stomach. My brazen glare never wavered from the man who’d just
ruined my life and everything I believed in.
My chest heaved.
My nostrils flared.
I looked like a rabid fucking dog.
His body tumbled to the ground from the impact of my vigorous attack.
Not letting up, I punched him in the face over and over again.
I hit him until my knuckles bled.
Until my fists were numb.
Until my body couldn’t feel anything at all.
“Caleb! Caleb!” I faintly heard some yell, “Stop! You’re going to kill
him!”
I didn’t.
Using all my strength, I brutally assaulted him as bile rose in the back of
my throat with each gasp for my next breath. Chaos blasted all around us.
The pain.
The torment.
Blow after blow after blow.
I didn’t stop.
I couldn’t.
Once I heard Evie shout, “Caleb, please stop!”
Her voice had the power to halt my attack. I stopped, taking in Joseph for
the first time since I began beating the shit out of him.
“You’re dead to me! Do you understand me?! You’re fucking dead to
me!”
I leaned back, sitting on the balls of my feet.
Joseph groaned, rolling onto his stomach and coughing up blood.
The sound of footsteps brought my attention to her. As if things couldn’t
get any worse, my eyes connected with the woman hauling ass next to Evie.
Seconds.
Hours.
Days could have flown by.
Time seemed to stand still for me while Evie skidded across the floor,
suddenly in front of me. Though my stare was still locked on the woman who
ruined my life.
Tessa.
E VIE
I ASKED C ALEB ’ S MOM IF THEY COULD STAY WITH THE KIDS , TELLING THEM
that Caleb felt sick and we were heading back to their home.
Caleb was quiet the whole drive, quickly stepping out of the car as soon
as I parked in their circular driveway. There was so much I wanted to ask
him, but I knew it wasn’t the right time.
I left him to himself until he was ready to talk. He sat on the lounger on
the balcony of his room for a few hours, until I finally walked out there to
check on him.
“Are you coming to bed?”
He shook his head.
“Come on, Caleb. You can’t stay out here all night.”
Our eyes connected before he finally agreed. I grabbed his hand and led
him inside.
When we passed his bed, he questioned, “Where are you going?”
“You’re covered in Joseph’s blood. We need to shower.”
“Evie—”
“Shhh, let me take care of you.”
He reluctantly sighed and followed me into the bathroom.
I turned on the shower, and within seconds the glass fogged up from the
steam of the hot water. Clutching his hand tighter, I spun to face him.
His eyes never lied to me. They were currently filled with nothing but
devastation. There was no indecision on my part as I began unbuttoning his
shirt. One-by-one, my fingers moved down his torso before carefully pulling
it down his arms.
I reached for his belt next, and I buttoned his slacks, stripping them off as
well. He stepped out of them, never breaking our intense connection. In one
quick move, I pulled off my dress, bra, and panties. Stepping into the shower,
I brought him with me.
He closed the doors as I approached him with caution, terrified he’d push
me away, but not caring if he did.
I needed to look at him.
Hold him.
Show him how much I truly loved him.
Delicately, I washed away the blood from his body before I kissed the
cuts on his knuckles. I’d never seen him appear as vulnerable as he did in that
moment, worrying me a little.
He shuddered when I touched him, but I didn’t stop. I wanted to get rid of
all the hurt and pain he was feeling. The hot water cascaded above our heads,
washing away the night of pure devastation.
I watched him, silently praying that what I’d express next would be
enough to soothe him.
Wholeheartedly, I rasped, “I love you, Caleb. I never stopped loving you.
From the second I first saw you, I was yours. I’ve always been yours. Mind.
Body. Soul. I belong to you.”
For a moment, he was captivated by my words.
Leaning forward, he kissed my lips then whispered, “I never slept with
Tessa.” Gripping the sides of his face, he added, “I was just a game.”
This was what I’d been waiting for this whole time. I just knew it in my
heart which was pounding against my chest.
Harder.
Faster.
I lost myself in his eyes.
“I don’t understand.”
“They conned me,” he stated, looking deep into my gaze. “All they
wanted was my money. I spent years away from you for nothing.”
I blew out a long breath, feeling emotions I couldn’t begin to understand.
“Joseph is my kids’ biological father,” he revealed, and all the blood
drained from my face.
“Oh my God.”
In an instant, all the layers of our regrets.
Mistakes.
Lies.
Secrets.
Everything that kept us apart was stripped away, and all that was left was
us.
I finally felt what I’d been waiting for.
Peace.
We gazed into each other’s eyes as he claimed my mouth the way I so
desperately wanted him to. My breathing labored, waiting for the words that
never came, so I said them instead.
“I’ll marry you, Caleb.”
Breathing life back into him again.
C ALEB
“Say it again.”
“I’ll marry you, Caleb. Today, tomorrow, whenever you want. I want to
be your wife and the mother to your kids. I’m so sorry this happened to you,
but it doesn’t matter who biologically created Ethan and Ariel—they’re
yours. Ours.”
She had the power to bring me to my knees. She always did. I could feel
her chest rising and falling against my torso. Her hard nipples firmly pressed
against my skin.
“Caleb,” she coaxed, strangled and frantic.
I kissed her until her body yielded to me.
Until she was no longer concerned and shaky, but soft and supple in my
arms.
Until every one of her muscles pulsated with anticipation.
With need.
With want.
With the desire for me to own every last inch of her.
That was my undoing.
She was my undoing.
There was no need for conversation. I just wanted to feel her, dropping to
my knees. Dying to taste heaven.
Forcefully yet gently, I sucked her sensitive clit into my mouth until she
was completely at my mercy. She responded to every sensation my tongue
inflicted while I inhaled her addicting scent of arousal mixed with the sweet
smell of her pussy.
“Caleb…” she purred my name, fisting my hair and using it as leverage to
stay upright.
I made love to her with my mouth.
Licking.
Sucking.
Devouring.
I worked her clit from side to side and up and down as she rocked her
hips in a back and forth motion against my lips and tongue. She was going to
rip out my hair. Making my cock throb so fucking hard, I started to fuck my
fist.
I watched her unravel from the inside out, her juices dripping out of her
core. Possessing every last fiber of her being, I made her come again and
again.
Her body shook so violently from the pressure and pleasure, screaming
out, “Caleb!”
I stood, wrapping her legs around my waist before I turned off the shower
and carried her back to my bed. I laid her down and hovered above her,
placing my muscular frame on top of hers.
“Do you have any idea how much I love you?”
“I do. I love you so much too.”
Through hooded eyes, she gave me what I craved.
“Good girl.”
Needing to bury myself inside her, I longed to feel her tight pussy
clenching around me. She didn’t have to wait long. I positioned my dick at
her opening and slowly thrust my way in. Deliberately taking my time, I
wanted to cherish this moment. My head was spinning, and I wanted to forget
this night ever happened.
I kissed all over her face.
Her neck.
Her breasts.
Back to her lips again.
Until I couldn’t take it anymore.
I had to look at her.
I had to watch her.
I had to make sweet love to her.
“How do you feel so fucking perfect? You’re mine. All mine.”
“I’m yours,” she breathlessly moaned.
Every moan that escaped her lips.
Every thrust of my dick against her g-spot.
Every grip of her pussy.
Stirred in my heart and soul.
I rested my forehead against hers, staring into her glossy, hazed eyes. Our
hearts pounded, our skin still wet from the shower, and our lungs completely
out of breath.
Vanished in our abandonment.
In our own world.
In our own love.
“Give me a baby,” I growled.
All I could hear was her desire encouraging me to go faster, harder.
“Yeah, Evie. Take my cock. Just like that.”
Grasping the back of her neck, I wanted to bring her closer to my face.
Our mouths found each other, no longer having any control over our actions.
“Give me a baby,” I repeated, fueling my need to thrust my come deep
inside of her.
Her pussy throbbed around my cock, pulsating long and hard.
“Give me a baby.” I couldn’t stop saying it, like it would magically
happen if I repeated it enough.
She came with such a force, taking me over the edge with her. I released
my seed as far back into her cunt as I could, both of us trying to catch our
breath.
Until she smiled. “Caleb.”
“Yeah, darlin’?”
“I’ve been trying to find the right time to tell you.”
My eyebrows pinched together. This night went from my worst nightmare
to my best dream.
When she announced…
“I’m pregnant.”
Chapter 34
Caleb
E VIE
“Hey! I didn’t hear you come in, Caleb. You need to go get ready. People
will be here soon.”
The playroom suddenly felt stifling.
“What’s going on? Why are you all looking at me like that?”
Ethan and Ariel peered at each other with smiles on their adorable faces.
“What are you gu—”
“We love that you’re our new mommy!” Ariel exclaimed.
And my heart just exploded.
They ran to me and jumped into my arms.
“Daddy says I can be the flower girl and Ethan is the ring bearer!”
Tears formed in my eyes.
“Now that the king and queen are getting married, we still need a baby,”
Ariel added, hugging me as tight as she could.
My gaze connected with Caleb’s, and he nodded, silently giving me his
approval to tell them. I crouched to their level so I could look into their eyes.
“What if I told you there’s already a baby in my belly?”
“We’re going to be a family!” Ethan shouted as they tackled me to the
floor, falling into a fit of laughter with Ariel.
Caleb didn’t waver, sitting next to us. “Get her,” he playfully demanded.
“Yes, let’s get her good, Daddy.”
“On the count of three, okay?”
“Caleb…” I warned.
They both nodded, counting, “One...”
“Ariel,” I coaxed.
“Two…” they added in unison.
“This isn’t fair.”
“Three!” they yelled together.
I instantly got up to take off running, but Caleb wrapped his arm around
my waist before I took a step, flinging me up in the air.
“Caleb!” I giggled, loving this game even though I liked to pretend I
didn’t.
He placed me down on the ground, straddling my legs. The kids attacked
me, tickling me everywhere as I thrashed around, screaming and laughing all
at once.
“This isn’t fair! It’s three against one!”
Caleb held my arms above my head, tickling my neck and face with his
beard.
“Oh my God! Stop!” I thrashed around, moving my face from side to side
until they jumped on Caleb’s back, tickling him now.
He placed the diamond on my finger, confirming, “It’s where it belongs
now.”
I smiled at him while the kids were no match for his strength. He threw
both of them over his shoulders and walked out of the room. It was the cutest
sight to see.
For the first time in my life, I had everything I wanted and didn’t think I
could have.
After Caleb’s parents picked up the kids, he walked up behind me in the
bedroom.
“I want you to wear something for me.”
“Oh yeah? What’s that?”
Pulling something out of his pocket, he showed me.
“What is this?”
“Vibrating panties.”
“Umm, excuse me? What?”
“It gets better.”
He revealed a controller next. “Now I get to control your orgasms for the
rest of the night.”
“You’ve got to be joking.”
With a wicked grin on his face, he grabbed the edge of my panties and
slid the silk down my legs. He pulled the vibrating panties on and then stood
back behind me.
“Did I ever tell you,” he whispered in my ear, “payback’s a bitch?”
My mouth dropped open. “There’s no way you’re still holding that over
my head.”
“I got my cock pierced for you, you little minx. I couldn’t have sex for six
months.”
“Oh, trust me, I remember. You barely lasted five minutes the first—”
He turned on the toy, and I fell back against his chest, immediately
panting.
“What was that, darlin’? I didn’t what?”
“You’re … oh God … cheating.”
“Am I now?”
He turned up the pulsation, making my legs shake from the intense
vibration on my clit.
“I’m … going … to … come…”
And just like that, the bastard stopped it, moving away from me.
“Oh, you have to be kidding me!”
He eyed me up and down with a predatory regard.
C ALEB
Tucking my dick back into my pants, I grinned and winked at Evie as I
backed away.
“You’re shameless, Mr. Hawkins.”
“And you love it, Mrs. Hawkins.”
We had a private ceremony with immediate family only on the island we
were on for a week. I refused to fly back to the States with Evie not being my
wife. We’d waited long enough.
Our new home was filled with the most important people in ours lives.
Jax and I were on better terms. He was slowly accepting my love for his
sister.
“Evie,” Sophie announced while we were standing outside, watching the
kids play. “You are the cutest pregnant woman.”
“I certainly don’t feel that way.”
I tugged her toward me, hugging her tiny frame into my chest to look
down at her. “Have I told you how beautiful you look with my baby inside of
you?”
“Once or twice, but you’re going to be thirty-eight soon, old man.”
I teasingly spanked her.
“Hey!” Jax chimed in. “Watch where your hands are. What do you think
you’re touching there?”
“What’s mine,” I replied not taking my eyes off Evie.
“You’re lucky I don’t kick your ass again.”
“I don’t remember it happening the first time.”
“Alright,” Evie scolded. “Let’s remember that we like each other, okay?”
She nodded to the delivery man, pulling up to our mailbox. “Make yourself
useful and get our mail.”
I murmured into her ear, “I’ll remember that later when you’re begging
for my cock.”
Things couldn’t be any more perfect even if I tried. For the first time in
my life, I finally had everything I’d ever wanted. There was no looking back,
just forward.
I grabbed the mail from the mailbox, gesturing hello to the postman. I
was skimming through the mail as I made my way back to Evie when the
bright manilla envelope caught my attention. The return address was what
really had my notice.
“What’s wrong?” Evie asked as I opened the envelope.
I never thought I’d see the day.
“Caleb, you’re scaring me.”
Looking up at her, I was shocked as shit. Completely rendered speechless
for a minute.
“It’s a wedding invitation.”
“Who’s getting married?”
With wide eyes, I divulged…
The end.
https://geni.us/SecondChanceRival
Acknowledgments
Executive assistants & all around the reason I can write: Silla Webb &
Heather Moss
Editor: Silla Webb
Cover Designer: Lori Jackson
Paperback, Ebook Formatter: Silla Webb
Publicist: Danielle Sanchez
Agent: Stephanie DeLamater Phillips
My VIPS/Readers
M. Robinson is the Wall Street Journal and USA Today Bestselling author of
more than thirty novels in Contemporary Romance and Romantic Suspense.
Crowned the “Queen of Angst” by her loyal readers, you’ll feel the cut of her
pen slicing through your heart as your soul bleeds upon the words of her
stories with each turn of the page.
Most notably known for the Good Ol’ Boys, M’s newest venture has
graced her with the #1 Bestseller on Apple Books with Second Chance
Contract. The Second Chance Men are powerful, intelligent and will sweep
you off your feet and leave you weak in the knees–every woman’s wildest
dreams.
M. lives the boat life along the Gulf Coast of Florida with her two
puppies and real life book boyfriend, the inspiration for all her filthy talking
alphas, Bossman.
When she isn’t in the cave writing her next epic love story, you can
usually spot her mad-dashing through Target or in the drive-thru of
Starbucks, refueling. Yes, she’s a self-proclaimed shopaholic, but only if
she’s spending Bossman’s money.
You can follow M, Ted, Marley, and Bossman on Facebook, Instagram,
and her absolute favorite social platform-TikTok.
Connect With M
ANGSTY ROM-COM
The Kiss
The Fling
MC ROMANCE
Road to Nowhere
Ends Here
BUNDLES
Road to Nowhere/Ends Here
Jameson Brothers
Sinner/Saint Duet
Pierced Hearts Duet
Love Hurts Duet
Life of Debauchery Duet
Los Diablos
Sinacore Crime Family Collection
EROTIC ROMANCE
VIP
The Madam
MVP
Two Sides
Tempting Bad