Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Canoira 2007
Canoira 2007
Canoira 2007
www.fuelfirst.com
Received 13 July 2006; received in revised form 26 October 2006; accepted 31 October 2006
Available online 27 November 2006
Abstract
Biodiesel has been produced by transesterification of waste frying oil with methanol catalysed by sodium methoxide. The unsaturated
fatty acid methyl esters of the biodiesel produced have been nitrated by two alternative nitration methods, showing an incorporation of
nitrogen between 3.43 and 5.10 wt.%, in the chemical form of nitro, nitrate and acetoxy functional groups. A detailed gas chromatog-
raphy–mass spectrometry analysis has been carried out on the nitrated biodiesel samples in order to identify the nitration products of this
complex mixture. The nitrated biodiesel has been added to a base diesel fuel in a 1000 mg L1 concentration resulting in an increase of
the cetane number of the fuel by more than five points, from 54.7 to 60.5.
2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0016-2361/$ - see front matter 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2006.10.022
966 L. Canoira et al. / Fuel 86 (2007) 965–971
Table 3 Table 4
Elemental composition of biodiesel and nitrated biodiesel Properties of the biodiesel of waste oil
Waste oils Biodiesel Nitration products of biodiesel Analysis Biodiesel Max Min Units Standard
70% HNO3 Fuming HNO3 Free glycerol 0.03 0.02 – % mass EN 14105
Monoglycerides 1.29 0.80 – % mass EN 14105
%C %H %C %H %N %C %H %N
Diglycerides 0.17 0.20 – % mass EN 14105
Waste oil 1 78.63 12.18 60.82 9.39 5.10 69.76 11.18 3.82 Triglycerides <0.05 0.20 – % mass EN 14105
(batch 1) Total glycerol 0.36 0.25 – % mass EN 14105
Waste oil 1 78.63 12.18 62.28 9.71 4.89 68.92 10.90 3.43 Water and <0.05 0.05 – % vol ASTM D 1796
(batch 2) sediments
Waste oil 2 78.06 12.10 60.31 9.18 4.48 ND ND ND Density at 15 C 880 900 860 kg m3 ASTM D 4052
Methyl oleate 76.98 12.27 62.54 9.77 4.88 67.66 11.00 3.69 Sulfated ash <0.005 0.02 – % mass ASTM D 482
ND indicates that composition was not determined. content
Copper strip 1a Class 1 Class ASTM D 130
corrosion
Total 24.0 – – mg kg1 EN 12662
where m is the mass and Mw the mean molecular weight. The contamination
conversion was always very high, ranging from 93% to 98%. Flash point 141.9 – 120 C ASTM D 92
Cloud point 5 – – C ASTM D 2500
The elemental composition of biodiesel samples was
Cold filter 5.0 – – C EN 116
determined in a LECO CHN-600 elemental analyser, and plugging point
it is summarized in Table 3. Kinematic viscosity 5.44 5.00 3.50 mm2 s1 ASTM D 445
at 40 C
2.4. Determination of the physicochemical properties of the Higher calorific 40.79 – – kJ g1 ASTM D240
value
biodiesel
Cetane number 57.9 – 51 – ASTM D 613
2.5.1. Reactor 2.5.3. General procedure with fuming nitric acid [7]
The experiments of nitration of biodiesel were carried In the 1 L three-necked cylindrical glass tank reactor,
out in a 1 L three-necked cylindrical glass tank reactor, fuming nitric acid (19.0 g, 0.303 mol, 12.5 ml) was added
equipped with glass jacket with a bottom inlet and an drop wise very carefully over glacial acetic acid (451.2 g,
upper outlet for circulation of the refrigerated water. The 7.5 mol, 430 mL) at room temperature. Later biodiesel of
reactor has a stirrer powered by a Heidolph RZR 2050 waste frying oil (70 g, 0.258 mol, 79.5 mL) and solid
motor drive, a type K thermocouple, a double jacket water sodium nitrite (35.6 g, 0.515 mol) were added simulta-
condenser and a 500 mL liquids addition funnel. The solid neously at room temperature. When the addition has fin-
sodium nitrite in the nitration (b) procedure was added by ished (3–4 h), the reaction mixture was poured over cool
means of a solids microdosifier device model GMD-60/2 water and extracted with diethyl ether. The ethereal phase
from Gericke. was washed with 10 wt.% sodium bicarbonate several times
and later with water (until neutral pH in the washing
2.5.2. General procedure with acetyl nitrate [6] waters), dried over anhydrous sodium sulfate and concen-
The preparation of acetyl nitrate was carried out as fol- trated under vacuum. The resulting nitration product of
lows: in the 1 L three-necked cylindrical glass tank reactor, biodiesel was quantitatively recovered as a clear, orange
cooled at 15 C with the refrigeration water, 70 wt.% nitric yellow liquid that darkened with the time, although a single
acid (149.5 g, 2.37 mol, 105.6 mL) was added dropwise to pass through a chromatographic column charged with a
acetic anhydride (378 g, 3.70 mol, 350 mL) with stirring. small amount of silicagel restored its original appearance.
The reaction temperature was controlled between 20 and
25 C by the slow addition of the nitric acid. Biodiesel of 2.6. Analysis of the nitration products of biodiesel
used frying oil (70.0 g, 0.258 mol, 79.5 mL) was added to
the acetyl nitrate solution previously prepared, and the reac- 2.6.1. Elemental analysis
tion mixture was stirred at 25 C for 1 h. Afterwards, the The elemental composition of the nitration products of
reaction mixture was poured over ice-water (1.5 L), and biodiesel samples was determined in a LECO CHN-600
extracted with diethyl ether. The ethereal extract was elemental analyser, and it is summarized in Table 3.
968 L. Canoira et al. / Fuel 86 (2007) 965–971
Table 5
Transmittance (%) of the biodiesel samples nitrated with acetyl nitrate Table 8
(70 wt.% HNO3 + acetic anhydride) in the characteristic frequencies GC–MS analysis of biodiesel of waste frying oil nitrated with fuming nitric
Biodiesel Frequency (cm1) acid
Waste oil 71 20.4 49.4 29.6 37.2 12.98 1.1 341 74 Methyl-9-nitrooleate 9; Methyl-
1a 10-nitrooleate 10
Waste oil 73 26.0 47.8 31.7 44.5 22.55 11.8 270 74 Methyl palmitate
1b 25.67 50.9 296 74 Methyl oleate
Waste oil 70 24.7 45.3 32.0 42.4 25.85 6.1 298 74 Methyl stearate
2 28.70 0.9 326 74 Methyl arachnate
Methyl 70 39.1 66.9 47.4 56.7 29.03 0.7 327 55 9-Nitrooleic acid 11, 10-nitrooleic
oleate acid 12
31.51 8.9 387 55 10-Acetoxy-9-nitrostearic acid 7,
a
Batch 1. 9-acetoxy-10-nitrostearic acid 8
b
Batch 2.
c
Assymetric NO2 stretching.
d
Symmetric NO2 stretching.
and increased at a rate of 6 C/min to 300 C where it
was kept for 10 min. Helium was used as the carrier gas
Table 6 at a constant column head pressure of 4.0 psi. Sample of
Transmittance (%) of the biodiesel samples nitrated with fuming nitric acid biodiesel nitrated after each one of the two experimental
in the characteristic frequencies procedures described above were analysed by GC–MS,
Biodiesel Frequency (cm1) and the results are summarized in Tables 7 and 8.
3400 1735–50 1625–60 1545–56 1355–90
(OH) (C@O) (ONO2) (NO2)c (NO2)d 2.7. Cetane number and total acid number (TAN)
Waste oil 79.0 23.9 68.9 41.2 45.0
1a The cetane number was calculated from the time in ms
Waste oil 76.0 25.1 69.0 37.6 48.0
needed for the rise of the pressure by 2 mbar in the fuel
1b
Methyl 74.0 23.2 69.0 35.6 40.9 ignition chamber after the ASTM D 613 standard. The
oleate equipment used was from Fuel Tech. Co. and for the cool-
a
Batch 1. ing circulation was used the Circulating System 253 from
b
Batch 2. the Precision Co. The fossil diesel was mixed with the
c
Assymetric NO2 stretching. nitrated biodiesel homogenising the solutions with strong
stirring, preparing blends containing 1000 mg L1 of
d
Symmetric NO2 stretching.
L. Canoira et al. / Fuel 86 (2007) 965–971 969
80 80
60 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200
time (min) time (min)
used oil 1-1 used oil 1-2 used oil 3-1 used oil 3-2
30.80 min correspond to isomeric nitrates of linoleic acid esters have been identified, two isomers of nitro oleate
(M+ 341) in a very significant amount (14.0%), and another (methyl 9-nitrooleate 9 and methyl 10-nitrooleate 10,
group of signals between 33.04 and 33.38 min have been RT = 12.98 min, in minor amounts 1.1%). The remaining
identified as isomers of nitrate nitroso linoleic acid (M+ nitrated products have suffered hydrolysis in the strong
370) in a great amount (11.3%). Finally, an important peak acidic reaction medium, and they appear as nitrated fatty
(7.0%) appearing at 33.53 min has been identified as a mix- acids: 9-nitrooleic acid 11 and 10-nitrooleic acid 12
ture of nitroso nitrate derivatives of linolenic acid (M+ (RT = 29.03 min, 0.7%) and 9-acetoxy-10-nitrostearic 8
368). This hydrolysis process is very clear in the mass spec- acid and 10-acetoxy-9-nitro stearic acid 7 (RT = 31.51 min,
tra since the methyl esters suffer a retro Diels–Alder reac- 8.9%). As it has been pointed out above, all nitrated methyl
tion giving m/z 74 ðC3 H6 Oþ2 Þ as their base peak or a very esters have base peak m/z 74 whereas nitrated fatty acids
intense peak, whereas the base peak of the nitrated fatty have base peak at m/z 55.
acids is always m/z 55 (C4 Hþ7 , olefinic fragment). From these detailed GC–MS analyses, two different
In the biodiesel sample nitrated with fuming nitric acid nitration schemes of the FAME composing the biodiesel
(Fig. 3), besides the saturated methyl esters that results could be drawn, illustrated for methyl oleate (Fig. 4). It
unaffected by the nitration (methyl palmitate 11.8%, should be highlighted at this point that fuming nitric acid
methyl stearate 6.1% and methyl arachnate 0.9%) and the nitrates into the double bond [7], but acetyl nitrate nitrates
unreacted methyl oleate 50.9%, only two nitrated methyl into the allylic positions of the double bond [6].
TIC:BIO-1.D
Abundance
25.67
1.3e+08
1.2e+08
1.1e+08
1e+08
9e+07
8e+07
22.55
7e+07 25.85
6e+07 31.51
5e+07
4e+07
3e+07
2e+07 12.98 28.70
1e+07
0
Time--> 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00 45.00
Fig. 4. Nitration products of methyl oleate with acetyl nitrate (70 wt.% nitric acid + acetic anhydride) (top) and with fuming nitric acid (bottom).
The hydrolysis of the FAME to free fatty acids as a con- of Molecular Stratigraphy of the School of Mines for the
sequence of the strong acid medium that implies the nitra- GC–MS analyses.
tion is worrying since the total acid number (TAN) of the
fuels with the nitrated biodiesel added could increase, leav- Supplementary data
ing them out of specifications. For this reason, the TAN of
the blends of base diesel and nitrated biodiesel (Table 9) Supplementary data associated with this article can be
have been measured, and it does not affect the quality of found, in the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2006.10.
the blends that show lower TAN values than the base 022.
diesel.
The cetane number of the samples of fossil diesel treated References
with these new additives was increased by more than five
points (from 54.7 to 60.1), which is a very good preliminary [1] European Committee for Standarisation (DIN). Automotive fuels.
result on the performance of this nitrated biodiesel. In this Fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) for diesel engines. Requirements and
test methods. European Standard EN 14214; 2003.
case, there was no appreciable difference between the bio- [2] Meher LC, Vidya Sagar D, Naik SN. Technical aspects of biodiesel
diesel nitrated by the two methods exposed in this paper. production by transesterification: a review. Renew Sust Energy Rev
In conclusion, this paper proposes a new and feasible 2006;10:248–68.
method to incorporate small amounts of renewable addi- [3] Fangrui Ma, Hanna MA. Biodiesel production: a review. Bioresource
Technol 1999;70(1):1–15.
tives as improvers of the cetane number of fossil diesel to
[4] Alcantara R, Amores J, Canoira L, Fidalgo E, Franco MJ, Navarro A.
comply, at least in part, with the European directive on Catalytic production of biodiesel from soy-bean oil, used frying oil and
biofuels. tallow. Biomass Bioenergy 2000;18:515–27.
[5] Alcantara R, Canoira L, Garcia-Martinez MJ, Carrasco J. Biodiesel
from jojoba oil–wax: transesterification with methanol and properties
Acknowledgements as a fuel. Biomass Bioenergy 2006;30:76–81.
[6] Malins DC, Houle CR. Nitration of methyl oleate with acetyl nitrate: a
synthesis of methyl aminostearate. J Am Oil Chem Assoc 1963:43–5.
We are greatly indebted to the Laboratory of Petroleum [7] Gupta A, Ahmad F, Siddiqui MS. Nitration of olefinic and acetylenic
Products of the Gomez-Pardo Foundation for the physico- fatty acid esters. Ind J Chem 1987;26B:870–2.
chemical analyses of biodiesel, and also to the Laboratory [8] Kemp W. Practical organic chemistry. London: Mc Graw-Hill; 1967.