Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Macy's Case - Ocred
Macy's Case - Ocred
Macy's Case - Ocred
—2018 357
CV S
www.macys.com, M
As of March 2018, Macy’s, Inc. operates 690 department stores in 45 states, Washington DC,
and outside the United States in Columbia, Guam, Puerto Rico, China, United Arab Emirates,
and Kuwait with third party license agreements. Headquartered in Cincinnati, Ohio, the compa
ny’s brands include Macy’s, Bloomingdale’s, Backstage, The Outlet, Last Act, and Bluemercury.
Most stores are located in urban or suburban areas and include a mix of apparel, accessories,
cosmetics, home furnishings, and various other consumer goods. Macy’s reported revenues in
excess of $25 billion in year ending January 2017 deriving from 382 company-owned stores,with
the rest being leased.
Approximately 710 stores are department stores operating under the names Macy’s and
Bloomingdale’s, and the remainder are specialty stores that include Bloomindale’s The Outlet,
Bluemercury, Macy’s Backstage, and Last Act. Macy’s divested 66 stores in year ending January
2017 and 43 year end January 2016, with plans to continue reducing total store numbers by about
30 as leases expire.
Macy’s employs 148,300 full-time and part-time employees with 10 percent represented by
unions. Closing more and more stores every year, Macy’s is struggling financially and needs a
clear strategic plan. During the month of December 2017, Macy’s spent $32 million on television
advertising, compared to J.C. Penney, who spent $27 million that month.
Copyright by Fred David Books LLC; written by Forest R. David.
History
Macy’s was founded by Rowland Hussey Macy 150 years ago. He chose the red star logo based
on a tattoo on his forearm which was inspired by the North Star Polaris that often guided him as
a sailor. After several failed attempts in retail, R. H. Macy started Macy’s in 1858 as a dry goods
store in New York City with first-day sales grossing $11.06, but first-full-year sales of $85,000.
Macy was a pioneer in many facets of business, promoting the first woman to an executive posi
tion in retail and the first to charge all customers the same price for an item. That original Macy’s
store at 1.1 million square feet has been at the same location since 1902 and has been the same
size since 1924.
Macy’s went public in 1922 and began expanding across the United States shortly after. The
firm is famously known for its Thanksgiving Day Parade, which began as a Christmas Parade in
1920 by immigrant workers thankful for their new American nationality. In 1929. Macy’s was
acquired by Federated Department Stores and remained in operation under that name until 2007
when Federated changed its corporate name to Macy’s, Inc. The company’s revenues and profits
have declined every year since 2015.
Vision/Mission
Macy’s provides a quite lengthy vision statement on their website, but no mission statement. At
the corporate website, simply click on About Us then click on Corporate Vision. Unhappy with
the vision and lack of mission, someone once proposed a mission statement for Macy’s as follows:
At Macy’s, we aspire to provide our worldwide shoppers an experience that gives them the
confidence to be the best version of themselves. Whether utilizing the unsurpassed exper
tise of our employees in store, or shopping on-line, we want to provide our customers with
open and honest communication while they shop for clothing and accessories that makes
them life-long members of our family.
358 STRATEGIC-MANAGEMENT CASE ANALYSIS
Internal Issues
Organizational Structure
Exhibit 1 provides Macy’s organizational structure. Currently, 7 of the top 19 executives are
female. Mr. Macy would likely take great pride in this; he hired the first women executives in
U.S. retail history in the 1920s.
Sustainability
Macy’s is committed to sustainability and has detailed commentary on its website on various
sustainable measures it has taken such as the firm adding 1.8 million LED lights through its
properties, saving 26 million kilowatt-hours of power. Macy’s was ranked in 2016 as the fourth
largest American enterprise for installed solar capacity; the company sells most of the solar
power it generates to others. Macy’s has been a member of the Dow Jones Sustainability Index
since 2005.
Current Strategies
Macy’s fiscal 2017 revenues and profits were down 4.8 and 42.9 percent, respectively, and
the company closed about 7 percent of its stores. The corporation blames shifts in con
sumer shopping habits and has designed several new strategies moving forward, but most
center around what Macy’s, Inc. refers to as the North Star Strategy, with the name being
an acknowledgement to their founder. There are five key points to the North Star Strategy,
and while all are vague as reported on the Annual Report, they are worth mentioning (para
phrased): 1) Increased marketing research to improve Macy’s loyalty programs and pricing
strategies, 2) Increased focus on private label brands only found at Macy’s stores as well
as catering increasingly to Macy’s Backstage and Last Act customers, 3) Further develop
ing of the mobile app and focus on better trained sales associates in what Macy refers to
as Omnichannel, simply meaning customers can shop in more ways than traditional stores,
4) Increased focus on cost reduction, reinvestment, and extra care in the real estate decisions,
5) Exploring unmet customer needs and exploring acquisitions through increased marketing
research.
Macy’s is adding Macy’s Backstage stores in existing Macy’s stores. The firm’s Last Act
program is aimed to move clearance merchandise at Macy’s stores more effectively. The com
pany is using a retrenchment strategy by recently closing 100 Macy’s stores, with plans to close
another 30 stores by year end 2018. Macy’s, Inc. is adding Bloomingdale’s and Bluemercury
stores as well as adding Bluemercury boutiques inside existing Macy’s stores. The company cur
rently has about 20 Bluemercury locations inside Macy’s stores.
CASE 1 • MACY'S, INC.—2018 359
Macy’s has a partnership with Brookfield Asset Management to help determine effective
ways of increasing value in Macy’s, Inc.’s real estate investments. Through January 2019, Brook
field is formulating strategies for each of Macy’s Inc.’s real estate assets.
Macy’s continues to expand its Macy’s Backstage stores, which are around 30,000 square
feet each and offer discounted products, after first opening six such stores in New York in
2015. Current focus is on adding Backstage stores inside existing Macy’s stores as a means
of attracting cost conscious customers into Macy’s stores. The company desires to expand
further into China and currently has a joint venture with Fung Retailing Limited holding a
35 percent stake and Macy’s holding the remaining 65 percent ownership stake in Macy’s
China Limited. All business to date is through ecommerce on Alibaba Group’s Tmall Global
website.
Suppliers
Macy’s purchases its products from many different suppliers with no single supplier accounting
for more than 5 percent of the firm’s net purchases and no formal long-term commitments with
any of the suppliers. Macy’s considers its relationships with suppliers to be good. The majority of
Macy’s products are produced outside the United States, primarily from Asia.
Finance
Macy’s continues to struggle financially as indicated by declining revenues in Exhibit 2,
and all the red downward pointing arrows in the balance sheets provided in Exhibit 3. Even
as its finances worsened, the firm repurchased nearly 8 million shares of stock in 2016 and
increased its dividend to $1.51 per share, possibly as a measure to keep shareholders from
selling the stock. This marked the sixth dividend increase in the last 5 years. From 2015 to
the end of 2017, Macy’s stock dropped 75 percent in value from over $70 to $18 per share,
yet dividend payouts in 2017 resulted in a reduction of retained earnings; the firm paid out
approximately $850 million in dividends to only $611 million in net income in 2017.
Assets
Cash and Short Term Investments $1,297 $1,455 4 12%
Accounts Receivable 522 363 -30%
Segment Data
Exhibit 4 reveals that Macy’s is fairly well positioned across the United States, but in reality the
firm is primarily focused on the east and west coasts. Like many department stores and retailers,
women account for the bulk of the business and Macy’s, Inc. is no exception with over 60 percent
of revenues derived from products exclusively for women. Department stores generally do not
cater to men much.
Exhibit 5 gives the number of Macy’s, Inc. stores by brand. Note the steady decline in the
flagship Macy’s department stores. Exhibit 6 gives a percentage breakdown of Macy’s, Inc. sales
by product category; note that women products comprise 61 percent of total sales.
As of January 2018, Macy’s, Inc. had 852 stores with nearly 400 owned and the oth
ers, leased. Among the 852 stores, 258 were located in the Northeast USA, while 188 were
located in the South, 144 in the North Central, and 131 in both the Northwest and Southwest.
Exhibit 5 reveals that the majority of stores are of Macy’s brand with Bluemercury store
numbers accounting for the second most, followed by Bloomingdale’s. Bluemercury stores
are significantly smaller than Bloomindales in square feet. The firm does not report revenues
nor profits across segments, but it can be inferred from company actions that Bluemercury is
more efficient at least in generating profits as the firm is expanding this segment while closing
CASE 1 • MACY'S, INC.—2018 361
EXHIBIT 4 The Number of Macy's Inc. Stores Across the United States
E Women’s Accessories.
Intimate Apparel, Shoes,
Cosmetics and Fragrances
E Women’s Apparel
■ Men’s and Children’s
E Home/Miscellaneous
underperforming Macy’s branded stores. Bluemercury is an upscale spa focusing on offering spa
services as well as haircuts, makeup, and other beauty products. Ulta Beauty is a much larger
competitor with a similar profile and target customer as Bluemercury. Macy’s, Inc. hopes cus
tomers utilizing Bluemercury will shop in Macy’s department stores as they make their way for
spa services at Bluemercury.
Competitors
Competition in the department store business is extremely competitive with many options for
customers ranging from online to traditional stores. Stores specialize in home goods, apparel,
general merchandise, and many other areas from discount stores to higher end stores. Even
stores like Walmart and Target have entire sections devoted to department store offerings in
cluding clothing, home goods, jewelry, and more. Customers have never had as many choices
as before. The entire department store industry is valued at over $150 billion with profits in
362 STRATEGIC-MANAGEMENT CASE ANALYSIS
excess of $4 billion. However annual growth has declined around 5 percent a year for the last
several years and is expected to continue to decline around 3 percent annually through 2023.
Such numbers for example would place department stores in the bottom half of a BCG Matrix
either as cash cows or dogs depending on their relative position to the top revenue-generating
firm in the industry.
Online department stores offering similar products simply do not incur the overhead cost
of traditional stores like Macy’s that incur really high rent, tax, utilities, and labor expenses
in areas such as New York City. Moving forward in the industry, it is vital for stores such as
Macy’s to differentiate themselves from rivals and online options—probably by providing su
perior in-store service. To date, Macy’s strategy (at least publicly stated on the Annual Report)
is providing omnichannel offerings and superior service. This type of vague strategy will like
ly not be good enough to compete with online providers offering similar quality products to
Macy’s, Inc.
Being forced to enter pricing wars with online providers is a huge threat facing all brick
and mortar providers, and one they are likely unable to win. Simply offering online products
themselves is a viable strategy although it is likely unwise to undercut in-store prices; customers
can simply shop in the store and then order online. This phenomenon is called show rooming. All
specialty stores that sell similar products as department stores, such as shoe stores and athletic
apparel stores, can be considered rivals to Macy’s, Inc. A financial comparison with two rival
companies is provided in Exhibit 7.
as wedding and home furnishings departments. Nordstrom operates in the US, Puerto Rico, and
Canada.
The firm operates over 120 department stores and 226 off-price with Nordstrom Rack stores
employing 78,000. The firm is currently testing smaller stores with an increased focus on luxury
goods that focus on customers who are less price conscious as a means of differentiating itself in
the market, or at least as a means of focusing on a more profitable customer segment. The first
Nordstrom Rack store in Canada opened in 2018 in Toronto.
Online
Consumers are increasingly shopping online for clothing through auctions and online-only
stores. Traditional retailers such as Nordstrom have virtually all responded with their own online
websites, yet often at the same high prices found in their stores. Brick-and-mortar stores still hold
the distinct advantage of customers being able to hold, feel, and try on items before purchasing,
as well as talk to knowledgeable salespeople at higher quality stores.
According to some analysts, the 15 most popular “online only” clothing stores that compete
with Macy’s, Inc. by offering clothing, mainly for women, are listed below:
1. Boohoo—a UK-based company; dresses start at $6; free shipping on orders over 60
2. Cotton On—an Australian retailer; dresses start at $10; free shipping on orders of over $55+
3. One Loved Babe—an online boutique for women; dresses start at $20; free shipping
4. Yes Style—a Hong Kong-based store; dresses start at $3.95, free shipping on orders over $35
5. Amazon.com—Prime members get free shipping and returns
6. Missguided—a UK-based firm; dresses start at $6; shipping free is $5 on all orders
7. ASOS—very fast and reliable; dresses start at $12.50; free shipping on orders over $40
8. Adore Me—specializes in lingerie in straight and plus sizes; free shipping
9. Saved by the Dress—Miami-based; dresses start at $25; free shipping on orders over $60
10. Dog Dog—dresses start at $17.95; free shipping on all orders
11. Lulu’s—dresses start at $14; free shipping on orders over $50
12. Dress Up—boutiques; dresses start at $16; free shipping on orders over $50
13. Thred Up—a resale store carrying all brands like new; free shipping on orders over $79
14. Blame Betty—offers vintage or retro clothing; dresses start at $27.60; shipping costs vary
15. 6pm—carries many brands such as Columbia, Under Armour, Prana; for men and women
External Issues
Economic Conditions
Department stores are heavily dependent on the state of the economy and customers’ disposable
income. The economic outlook for the United States is excellent through 2020. Customers are
increasingly purchasing online and this means of purchasing is expected to exceed 10 percent
annually through 2023. Despite lower profit margins, department stores are expected to increase
marketing efforts to attract customers into the stores.
Many customers of Macy’s are increasingly shopping online for the price range of products
Macy’s provides. Department stores have unknowingly “trained customers to wait for sales or
364 STRATEGIC-MANAGEMENT CASE ANALYSIS
look for deals as consumers are increasingly price conscious.” Firms are offering deals in low-
traffic times and even offering unannounced deals on select items.
Expenses
Although not likely to lead to a competitive advantage, controlling costs remains a significant
concern for department stores moving forward simply to avoid going bankrupt. Purchases ac
count for over 50 percent of industry revenue alone and Macy’s cost of goods sold is about 60
percent. Firms should explore joint ventures or strategic alliances with providers to help reduce
costs, if at all possible. Backward integration is an option as well, but most department stores
simply offer too many different products to make this a viable strategy. Labor continues to be a
relatively high expense totaling around 14 percent of revenues, but most workers are hourly and
not paid significantly. On January 1, 2018, however, 18 states increased their minimum wages
rates, even though the federal minimum wage rate remains unchanged.
Firms must decide moving forward if they wish to increase their labor to provide customers
increased customer service with experienced knowledgeable sales people in each section of the
store. Rent and utilities maybe surprisingly account for around 8 percent of revenues, but the
price is still significant when attempting to compete with online providers who have considerably
lower bills in this category. Marketing, contrary to what many believe is a relatively low expense,
accounts for only 1 percent of revenues. However, this number may increase as firms look to
increase their marketing efforts to help attract customers to the store.
Future
Like many department stores. Macy’s is struggling to compete with online shopping and more
niche retail stores that focus tremendously on customer service or a small subset of high-end
customers. Because of this, Macy’s is moving their popular Bluemercury stores inside Macy’s
department stores to attract new customers, the company's promotions and other tactics hope to
draw new customers into the stores.
As Macy’s sales have declined in recent years, management has shifted attention to monetiz
ing some of the company's highly valuable real estate, knowing that real estate sales often lead
to significant one-time gains on an income statement. Macy’s may be the biggest beneficiary in
the retail sector from the new, lower U.S. corporate tax law because with the sale of high-dollar
properties, Macy’s can pay down debt, continue paying its really high dividend (currently one of
the highest dividend yields as of mid-2018) and possibly in late 2018 or 2019 start buying back
stock again. In 2016-2017, the company was focused on paying down debt rather than trying to
buy back stock. Macy’s has actually started to sell excess real estate, and some of the properties
are in valuable locations.
Some Macy’s stores, while profitable, are not making enough money to pay for the oppor
tunity cost of what the real estate would be worth if it were to be sold. For example, Macy’s has
numerous downtown stores in really hot real estate markets like New York, San Francisco, and
Chicago. Every time Macy’s sells one of these "50-year-old" stores however, it has to pay a pretty
big tax bill because of that asset sale gain. But with lower corporate taxes, there is more incen
tive to sell. To manage this selling of real estate, Macy’s has formed a strategic partnership with
Brookfield Asset Management, a private equity and real estate management firm that’s looking
into several dozen Macy’s store sites and ways to either redevelop the store or do additional real
estate development on, for example, the parking lots or similar ideas of that nature.
Macy’s wants to monetize the upper floors of its humongous stores, partly because the com
pany’s real estate is worth more than the entire company’s valuation right now. Being able to sell
off some of that real estate can bring in needed cash, pay down debt, pay dividends to sharehold
ers, and be transformative for Macy’s viability.
Fiscal 2018-2019
In early 2019, Macy’s closed its Redmond Town Center main store in Redmond. Washington,
bringing the total to 83 of the approximately 100 store closures announced in August 2016. Over
the last three fiscal years, Macy's, Inc. has completed transactions totaling approximately $1.3
billion in cash proceeds. Heading into fiscal 2018, Macy’s, Inc. continues to evaluate its real
estate portfolio to identify opportunities where the redevelopment value of its real estate exceeds
CASE 1 • MACY'S, INC—2018 365
that ol non-strategic operating locations. For example, in February 2018, Macy’s signed an agree
ment to sell floors 8 through 14 of its State Street store in Chicago to a private real estate fund
sponsored by Brookfield Asset Management. Brookfield intends to convert these largely unused
floors into dynamic, creative office space. As part of this transaction, Macy’s, Inc. will receive
a total of $30 million ($27 million of consideration and a $3 million contribution for certain
improvements), as well as upside participation in the ultimate value creation associated with the
conversion of the upper floors to office space. This transaction will enable the company to make
Macy's on State Street a more vibrant shopping destination. The company anticipates closing this
transaction in the first half of fiscal 2018.
Macy’s, Inc. expects to open two additional Bloomingdale’s stores in San Jose, California,
and Norwalk, Connecticut, in fiscal 2019. Both Macy’s off-price brand of stores, Macy’s Back-
stage, and its clearance strategy, Last Act, are growing. As of February 3, 2018, the company has
a total of 52 Macy’s Backstage locations (7 freestanding and 45 inside Macy’s stores). Addition
ally, Macy’s Inc. is growing its luxury beauty products and spa retailer, Bluemercury, by opening
additional freestanding Bluemercury stores and adding Bluemercury products and boutiques to
Macy’s stores. As of February 3, 2018, Macy’s, Inc. operated 157 Bluemercury locations (137
freestanding and 20 inside Macy’s stores).
Moving forward, Macy’s, Inc. needs a detailed strategic plan; they must decide what position
they wish to take in the industry. Currently, offering moderately priced items in the traditional
department store format has not been effective relative to discount department stores, specialty
stores, or pure online shopping.