Poe’s implication that the fate of the narrator is somehow linked to
that of a beautiful young woman places this tale among an important
group of “portraits” —writings about doomed beauty and untimely
translation. in an early, quasi-autobiographical poem Poe wrote, “I
could not love except where Death / Was mingling his with Beauty's
breath” (CW, 1:157). In one sense this declaration expresses an
entirely conventional Romantic attitude; Mario Praz notes: “To such
an extent were Beauty and Death looked upon as sisters by the
Romantics that they became fused into a sort of two-faced herm,
filled with corruption and melancholy and fatal in its beauty—a
beauty of which the more bitter the taste, the more abundant the
enjoyment.”3 But as with premature burial, Poe's insistent figuring of
the death of beauty—and the beauty of death—obliges us to look
more closely at implicit metaphorical attributes. The poet endeav-
ored in “The Philosophy of Composition” to rationalize his obsession
with dying young women, calling the theme “the most poetical topic
in the world,” as if that assertion explained the brooding evocation of
the “lost Lenore” and all of the other doomed ladies in his writing.
Poe's biography yields plentiful sources for his preoccupation with
cadaverous women and mournful men, and in chapter 4 I discuss the
pattern of loss which informs his correspondence. Here | want to
situate the death-of-a-beautiful-woman motif in relation to conven-
tions of popular literature and to the anthropology of death in the
nineteenth century. As noted earlier, Ariés typifies Poe's epoch as
“the Age of the Beautiful Death,” a period in which dying became a
fetishized spectacle, an elaborately prepared departure; in which the
deathbed became a site of beatific intimacy; and in which the corpse
became an object of idolatry and commemoration. Barton Levi St.
Armand comments on the extensions of this practice: “The loved
dead themselves became keepsakes, as advances in embalming and
the invention of waterproof tombs and airtight burial cases actually
allowed sentimentalists to treat the corpse as a metaphorical gem,
treasure, or idol it so often is in the lofty lamentations of mortuary
verse."+ As the dead body became an icon, the proliferation of
mourning art in nineteenth-century America—with its iconography
of urns, plinths, mourners, and weeping willows—helped to feed a
melancholy preoccupation with death. This impulse found its con-
summation inthe death of young women, especially unmarried wom-
en, whose departures from this life seemed to epitomize the beauty of
innocent faith,Poe’s response to the cult of mourning and the Beautiful Death
defies easy summary. His poetic treatment of dying women indicates
that, to a certain extent, he shared the pervasive sentimental view
that death intensified female beauty and even brought about a pu-
tification of loveliness. Thus for example in “Lenore” he idealized
the departed one:
The sweet Lenore hath gone before, with Hope that flew beside,
Leaving thee wild for the dear child that should have been thy
bride—
For her, the fair and debonair, that now so lowly lies,
The life upon her yellow hair, but not within her eyes—
‘The life still there upon her hair, the death upon her eyes.
(CW, 1:337]
This lyric captures the subtle eroticism of a beauty heightened by
the implication that Lenore takes to the grave the charms which she
had not yet yielded to her “wild” lover, Guy de Vere. But Poe's
emphasis (in I. 12) on the death of “innocence” is also consistent
with gift-book evocations of the saintly departure. More frequently
in his verses, the beauty of the beloved is an obsessive memory; his
speakers recall “the rare and radiant maiden whom the angels name
Lenore” (in “The Raven”) or “the bright eyes/Of the beautiful
Annabel Lee.” Poe could argue (in “The Philosophy of Composi-
tion”) that the death of a beautiful woman offered the most poetical
subject imaginable because that motif conjoined the essential ele-
ments of desire: irresistible loveliness and the impossibility of its
preservation or recovery. The ephemerality of such beauty ac-
counted for its force: unlike the timeless beauty of the work of art
(the oval portrait), the loveliness of Poe’s women is doubly evanes-cent, being both an aspect of youth (which is lost daily) and a
symptom of illness (which must end in death). This aesthetic no
doubt developed in part from the much-noted irony that consump-
tion—the all-too-common destroyer in the nineteenth century—
actually did enhance physical beauty at an intermediate stage by
inducing a feverish glow. In Poe's tales, which deal more directly
with the process of dying, fated women seem invariably to grow more
beautiful as they approach their last hour. Poe implies that through
this insidious transformation, temporal loveliness approaches the
perfection of eternal beauty, and theoretically at least the corpse of
the dead woman briefly incarnates an ideality. But because death also.
entails physiological decay, the beauty of the just-departed contains
an element of terror, since the passage of time implies a subsequent
and inevitable mutation to loathsomeness. Death discloses its cruel
paradoxicality, being both the source of ideal beauty and its destroy-
er. Poe could accept the perverse fact that death intensified beauty—
he had seen it often enough—but he also saw through the illusion
fostered by sentimentalism.